M0 ~t t I August 13# l$Sk Fwow HstallneBjr Dtrisina Aim Imvdb Uboxetorias Ataritmb Onsgamr of Anarloa P. 0* Box 778# Bov Kensington, Dost Mr.

NO. 99-5894-K JOHNNY FRANKLIN GIFFORD, et al., Plaintiffs, v.

1625{$Urt.NVVr wathmgtorr, DC 2000b 202-872-1060 ^OrganizationResources CounsdoFS^Inc.

PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT `CURRENT REPORT 471 required by the Act to be disclosed, records tailing within the caiegoreis covered by several exemptions including (2) may be made available to the extent, but only to the extent, that the appropriate Departmental official deter mines that such disclosure will further the public interest and will not impede the discharge of any of the Depart ment's functions. 70.23 deals specifically with exerr lion (2).

PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT * INTERNAL CORRESPOND 1 r;^&usiNE$i CONElDtHtlAL J UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION technical ze^e^ P O BOX SjF.1 SOUTH Ci-APl.BSTON.

INTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION ts PC- BO* >iA = lF ETC" B.

Harrison.

To: From: Cc: Bcc: Received Date: Subject: Methvin, Stacy P SCC-DCA <Stacy.Methvin@shell.com>; Carrier, Toniqua L SCC-DFS/137 doniqua.carrier@shell.com>; Simpson, Edward J SCC-DCAl2 <Edward.Simpson@shell.com> Clegg, Patsy M SCC-DCS/22 <lO=SHELLlOU=MSXSCC/CN=RECIPIENTS/CN=PH197432> 2006-11-2912:50:00 GMT RE: RESPONSE REQUESTED: Shanghai Health Study 2007 Invoice My records show the following: It 2005 invoice for 400K that was not paid until 2006.

To: 'Fitzsimmons, Mark' <MFitzsimmons@steptoe.com> From: Clegg, Patsy M SCC-DCS/22 </O=SHE LUOU=MSXSCC/CN=RE CI PI ENTS/CN=PH197432> Cc: Bcc: Received Date: 2007-03-2020:47:29 GMT Subject: RE: Shanghai Health Study - Meeting at API on March 29 YES.

To: 'trisha.m.perkins@exxonmobil.com' <trisha.m.perkins@exxonmobil.com> From: Clegg, Patsy M SCC-OCS/22 </O=SHE LUOU=MSXSCC/CN=RE CI PI ENTS/CN=PH197432> Cc: Bcc: Received Date: 2007-04-2621 :04:27 GMT Subject: RE: SHS - New contract terms - suggested changes to draft Will do; nobody needs extra email.

BHRC-TC, -OC...

From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Attach: George Woodall <Woodallg@api.org> Tuesday, August 14, 2001 7:58 PM (GMT) 'GuilanJi@sohu.com' Patrick Beatty (E-mail) <pwbe@chevron.com>; Shan Tsai (E-mail) <sptsai@shellus.com> Invitation to Participate in a Benzene Health Research Project SRP Overview .doc Dr.

To: From: Cc: Bcc: Received Date: Subject: Clegg, Patsy M SCC-DCS/22 <patsy.clegg@shell.com> Fu Hua <hfu@shmu.edu.cn> Tsai, Shan P SHLOIL-SHS <Shan.Tsai@shell.com> 2007-01-04 15:31 :32 GMT an issue related to Dr.

Shanghai Health Study Patsy Clegg Oversight Committee Chair 1220 L Street, NW Washington, D.

To: BenzConsort-OC@listserve.api.org <BenzConsort-OC@listserve.api.org>; BenzConsort-TC@listserve.api.org <BenzConsort-TC@listserve.api.org>; BHRC Communications Committee <benzconsort-cc@ listserve. api. org> From: Russell White <whiter@api.org> Cc: Bcc: Received Date: 2006-09-1520:15:12 GMT Subject: Shanghai Health Study Monthly Update (It's still September!)