Document zdqxnLKKjEX6yVpvRZeXyOQ7

APPENDIX I filtfll ALTERNATIVE MATERIALS INSTITUTE AMERICAN SUPPLIERS OF NON-ASBESTOS PRODUCTS December 17, 1986 NOTE The attached list of questions and products was prepared by 1CF, the contractor doing EPA's economic analysis related to the asbestos rulemaking. AMI is providing this list as a service to its members, but in doing so, AMI does not suggest that all of the information requested should be shared among the members of the Institute. Some of ICF`s questions relate to product prices, costs, market shares and the like. Although the information is needed by EPA, such data should not be shared among the members for antitrust reasons. We are currently developing mechanisms by which members may provide this information to EPA without sharing it with one another. AMI018LQP UCC 000285 605 Fourteenth Street. NW. Suite 900. Washington. DC 20005 Telephone 202 737-1419 , . .g (e ll a questions asked fo r drum brake lin in g s . ehicles answer v e -road pleas ff , o s) and three severe braking c a te g o rie s ra ilro a d cars, For the four prim ary uses o f brake blocksi trucks and uck r ) t ts g <eg. je and m inin *C000V Wl UE Q 3 (0 zo tpt: u* ot<0ou oz 44 40 1 V a u rH a h a mj m a 44 ? w 0. o H M o 3 Jf e 3 4> 0 P- o 0* Q H c o E rH o 44 0 CB Ku c a n> H o ?3 u O U TJ 44 40 U a u ^4 S o oc Vi a a c D -ri A* C >y 44 CP 3 0 c44 O' f-i H u o 44 C 44 o o0 *4 a. E f* u U 3 40 V a 40 a u <v' tt rH 44 c<n >. u O' o 7 9 % rH o E tt 44 44 tt 44 <0 cM o -h 0 h 44 O o 40 , o **H rH ^ * o 44 O U to -rH U 3 E c-H w a a M *o 44 e ax 44 w- u o c* a o 40 C 44 e o tt U E 40 uU eoe cO D 4 > O rH 9 <0 o o - *4 44 44 CP c 44 rH 3 CP rH w 3 0 < 44 s 44 o 0 H 3 14 3 44 1 44 u * o O 1 U 3 O 44 44 0 44 3 3 -pH 44 44 a 44 rH rH e U H aE *V a *u 44 B *r4 fi o 44 o tt tt U T3 44 rH tt T3 C tt a -* >. 4i C 3 44 C tt 3 tt 4> o oo 44 tt 44 fi o rH H tt W tu M 44 44 fl 44 44 <u o ao ^H a o -H 44 o o V o 40 44 3H *5 O -rH U U *4 o u c U O o U *n o c -rH u C a U . U 44 tt co 3 a <o S * o u -0 ca *4 H c s 44 01 o 44 o -H %5 w >. o EH o a 4-i tt O ftH 3 4 44 9 H n H 44 tt o ue *n & o H 44 r 44 0 <w 0 44 p S Qt rH 44 rH > 44 o 44 44 u H li E 44 Hu 4* p tt rH a 5 c c c o a 44 -rH 44 0oo ii 44 *5 O o u E tt H tt E a 0 4J O rH 44 14 44 rH 44 o 44 44 -n a U >t a rH 3 44 rH tt a rH 0* Ca tt 3 c o cnU E 44 W O U O o 44 > U> c CO E 44 o 9 H rH H 14 Vi o 3 E 44 c 44 44 rH o 44 U 44 44 44 > tt 44 *n U -H W tt * U o rH tt tt 3 44 E 3 3 o fi 44 % rH O X 3o 144 W3 li 44 . w rH v O U* rH O 0 U a M wyS -- >' -- -t -- Aft 3 n C M c e w. o' o - 5 6 tn h H JffHi C Of C, 0 " ~ rH u u > ao 2 3 rH CO u O- ^ V Ku 44 0 O 5 At H . ID rl tt AJ O > E O WT H 44 o o z X. U N c Ka 44 O *. < fi T o a c to Vi -* 1 ^ *o rH _ H -rH o rH w H * H b O' * ttvj e-- rH 01 44 *Uo O o Ofi '.*'.-. *K> " 1 44 -o c c rH 0 rH BC c o rH rH ttH "O rH 3 -H -rH 3 0V VI e X a rH & < rH 3 w H rH rH C QX . uC ^ J >. O e i c c 01 * uu rH c Q9 0o o Vi < H rH to < Cm o u CQ a U j (V CQ -H Z iU HU \ t ra f ing c g a ir log Sem l-m etallica NAO (non-asbestos o rg a n ic) com bination o f K evlarR, fib e rg la ss, and/or m ineral fib e r Brake blocks cn 0c1 f H o 44 D O O 4t0t 0 C <z a 0* o to p oa 44 ttot CO o 9 c to < w eu3 D O % < UCC 000286 la anyone producing or im porting aabestoa rollboard? tt Xl 1 tt Xi 1 VO a3 >, cC i ,, 4= o tEt <0 42 u3 H CO 3 tt xl Ea E 42 9 V4 9 u -4 tt *D 3 E 3 U O v "H Xo> 3 tttt a a tt H 41 c w Ett 44 E -4 *0 <o xi c cr a oV| ci O H H vO4 XV H4-4 V cr tt *--f u 42 >, <0 V vi o, ov k# O H4 tot 0* 41 tt t-f v 42 41 4uo4 ao u O X tt XI a * M u tt O O tt J C tt 44 a tt ^3 tt XI m 44 xi tt o tt u Xf i> u a c 0r4 $ H D Hc tt tt E uEM tt a tt *0 tt o H Xl VI b tt <} Xl Xl tt U tt 3w cr ^4 V x: XI <0u c tt tt 0 U 0 tt O U2 9 4= <n tt >> E tt O tt C V2 a tt *0 b tt >u1 Xl c tt tt tt C J3 >* &c 3 C* Ou XI H 0 O tt Vt -( u tt 0 a Oe XI >H tt Xl 0 tt O tt tt VI a O tt > Xi tt xi 0 O tt tt vt a 04 tt o o iH tt i-4 *o >0 xi *o 41 O a 4U E > *< tt <c Xl Q v tt xi 43 O V o tt 4? XQ Xi o >, c o> tt c tt c 4: o H xi **K XI tt utt c "r*t Co* *o v o XJ Xl tt tt wc tt. <w ctt O O tt xl X9I H XJ tt X tt 0 47 B 4> O u tt >* tt o> M C O) * c c tt c 43 tt o XI C C -rf tt c tt Xi *-1 *rl btt tHt c w4 tt tt i0tt-tt(* tt a U JJ D tt HC XI tt -uj: b X> tt oC o tttt XI x3> HC C 4: u 3 43 > tt tt tt w tt > tt C tt O O' c M c C 0 tt M C tt O 4J -H tt XI JC tt XI 43 xl C 6 0b a <> xi tv XJ tt XI tt 3 Oe XI V 3 H O 'g Vt tt E H *5 xi C tt Su -H tt H XI tttt tt xi a 3 xl tt wO xl e XttJ 4xtjt; j0C0 xtti O 3 XJ w 3 S3 a w a S tt tu 43 O* xi XI 3 tt tt rX wxti O xi x0l % sXt>tI t3t Jtt0tSttt 0 2 XI u9 90 O 9 au tt cu 0Vt X tt CL Xi Xi 3 tt tt xl H <rl O XI xtti JC 2 xi tt 42 3 a tttt 2<t5t HE e C/2 r-t C &5 H O 3 v< cn b. -4 v u CK C 40 -< 1 >e 5 tt vt K Vi \ oc gc- fHol -4oWJ faaf*l C iH tt X) v. Vi bB2 4 O^h 2 --M VI -- CS- 4u0 C w ac > -4 -w $ $e *: v. VI O 0<0MTJ\ S C *D O HW O 6 --' C *-< tt 42 v* b b 2 2 < z ^ W %d XI tt CtEOt w# F lb e rfra x Paper {550 & 570) Kaowool Rollboard Ceramic paper R o llb o a rd a c o tttt tt4 aE 2 9tt b xl Q ft. tt H eH O w4 XOi 3 3 3tt tt H E > O UCC 000287 E tt 3 w tot 10 a tt 0 c <a 40 4-1 Vi 0 42 44 --4 -e O' tt tt > 4^ 0 0-- tt tot 0 tt 4t5t > b tt x<t3t 0 QUESTIONS o Xi CO 2 to Mu 0 10 u a ti 0 Li a U o s *cn <0 U t> 4> lu O S' e 4J D L lu O X 4-4 o f-f -C w Sc E 4) cu o JC o XJ 40 xi u Xi -4 0 mu L U o MU MU m p4 m 4-1 0 r-t Vt 0 <-* u 3 *w SJ8 MU V xi r-4 Xi MU 3 MU M * 4> 10 U Xi 0 Xi Xi E0 a o Mi -*4 X5 V -( <0 Xi 40 Xi 40 O u 0 n 0 C X5 JC A H we cDt fW *o 1e w a x to o Xi MU xi 4J l 3 3 M i) C Xi -H H X> X *i Xi (0 Xi Q X X 3 W X 3 a3 lu XV <c3 <3 jC xl XI H 41 u u o MU O -*4 c 41 41 U 0> u Xo a xi xi 4) ^ U MU Ea *D 40 0 *-< Xl O' cO U 41 VVc ni fl O * w U 4 ae 1 41 0E xi u * >. XI .-4 3a u xi - xl f-i *1 to O' axe X3 300 -U L Q 0 r4 MU to o X> to 41 X <0 IQ oc> M XI lu O a E u w 0 Oc' M o 3 *8 w a c o >c1 r41 V H 41 M MU to o xi 09 $ X 09 . 4Q H > C > o> e U xl u a E 4 tu 0 ? **4 o 3 o 5 u Ou 0 0^ c Ox >, c *- 0 o 5 to 1-1 M MU -4 OS H lu 0 > E0 tc ? o ^4 c o H u oa MU X 3 0M X V 0 MU V o 0 0X MU rt H *-t c U 3 MU fi X9 0 MX 03 3 X lu X 0 3 o XWc xi i O -*4 lu E x> <0 e 14 X *4 0 ri D lu 0-1 a 0 XI 0o X> o 0a a 3 XI 0 C Xci c X r-< xJ 0 u 3 X> 3 H fw a ~ x> u >, -- U <Q 3 -U XI 0 o ^4 3 JC 3 4J HX u 3U u0 XI X 3 a lu X cXJ n A L lu -+t CL x: > $ XI 0 0x o o D Q 3 r-l H 0X un aE .0 MU o 3W Ea 0 lu 0 x: XI o 0 xi > c 0 X30 L 5 S #H < I o --1 aC c lu X Q c Xi JO lu M lu a 0o *o X xi ao 3o -U 0 0 ^4 X 4 e xi X o 0 Vi Xi o xi Xi a V 0- wX x 0 xi *to-l a cm Cl 00 u 0 X a < X oa u4 MU w o U MU XI xi Xi i* X} M -0-1 E oa tu o o ^ 3 0 5 0 * L o o lu r*t XI X XI a oW' --i ^Xi c 2 lu 0 -rC VI < E O' -. *3 <3 LU 22 r-i O ^ wE CL O Xi EH x> H O tu Mu Mu H C 0* O' L -C u C Xi id5| --U lu ^U z D fc* c lu xi 4J MU H >t a MU H a u O i. 0 wC Xi O' E --4 lu H tv o to tt a -ICS lDG H C X OX lu 2 0a fU o xi uc 3 *< 3 O a tv O Q OS w as (X X 0 2 w4 H lu Xi X^ a o Xi c 3 MU o Vi O O' lu 5 r-< *u 0 C- to E Cu tv lu IU X) XI *u -H MU MU OS Vi <o4 r-< > tu It O ,,n o cH 0 xi x: U *o c 0 u 3 E Xi x> 3 Xi XO 3 lu u o 14 00 b Ui O H iH a >, Vi O iJ 0 O a t< vj x: >m a a 0a a: vi \ O' o\ O' -* e o lu E Q j5 J X Li VI E (Q u 0 Vi lx U O < SUBSTITUTES KNOWN BY ICF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS OJ lu o lu C 0 rU 25 0-4 HU -rU ^4 E tv Xi Xi H H Cl Cl O' 2C --4 lu MU 0 Qo aQ *-4 Ou, Lt O 0 H MU o xi 0 JS to J r-i h| c> ---U1 xi| -04 > UCC 000288 lu C ^p4 a rJ --u -rU z a (4 1 xi C at-4 tn -4 0U x> X xi O xi XI < 1 CM \ X m rH tt x 3X C O 0 44 to O' X o X JQ XB 4J to O 4 a 4-1 tt O > P O *< x oC rH u CL X IQ o 4 o 4) u H ti rH X o 0 40 > X o 4) u u rH w -H tt -H 4) E > 44 rH CL XX X 3 -*4 a 0w X H H X Li 14 V *-H 44 0.* m u tt x Ea Z *8 X X X o u U 4 O JC mO 3 aX \ -a JO *2 X x> rH o rr O %4 c \ u H o 3 a <o o >1 X C 0 00O5 4) *n X X H tt H X o O' -rl U X 3 X ?c X c o -r4 u 4> * X o X J ac *o -n a o \ --1 4) 4) >1 x X 3 r4 a x u X -- X 0X Z X c^- X u 3 *o O CL *h C- ' O X u n O 44 il -H X 9 H X u 41 E X ttX JC X x ~4 jC X U aX *X c u P 2 3 X <0 E O X 3 X -4 O s 44 44 c % j5 K , CW *o -4 to rH -4 c a -i 01 A> 0 41 Ai w 0 CL o M\ aI 9 * u tr -* CM a 4 3 Xi -4 a < o o L 1 a 3 tt u c 44 rH X o 44 Q 1 x; H U E 0 ft *o <r w 14 a a **H O Ai CM 0 a X p 4J L Ai C a a c 'Tl c P c 0} a o 3 *4 oC 0 u 3 0O x: c X a Ec \ *o c *o 4i *4 Ai 0 x: < A* c 4J u * *0 u -C 0 c 4i (V w Ai x> 3 to A> M JC Ai Ai Li 0 > u 44 H JC 3 H <V CL 14 a L X rM 14 4J E Ai o -C u tu 44 Oc 44 *4 > 4J W o 6Lt o LI w AJ 0*> E * a >1 -r4 M-l A> H a 14 L o Ai ^4 a ?2 Ll U U rH ti a Li 4J ft Xo u t> m ~4 W E ' 3 X a tt p u O' > a 3 44 A4 O' ^ x: L CM u a <0 c* U 9 41 (4 Ai Ai a Ai W **H c & w 6 r4 x: u E E Ai C w AJ u E 14 c 1 JC CL O # u3W A> O y H W X 14 a * o X . lO a 0O n a i Z E ^5 c L c a P 4i 4 C a E a* x M aE uwu U --4 *0 > 0c0 X *o X w a# c Ko a t4t t> c XI z*a> a c * aU Q c - 4P JC. c o -o CM xl 1u 0u u -4 9 u CM CM 41 4J 4J rH r-4 *1 H I 3 e e H S A* %O 4 u 3 o Ai 3 *o Ai H 14 Ai a i A 0c u 3 AJ c ao u U Ai 14 *o 3 QPL w O' o C- U 44 4i acX D Ai Ai JC P L| 0*ri E L Ai ac 0a E O' p H H O n O' u -H 44 U Jj > *o *o 3 ^ Li LI 14 14 *4 ua *rj <4 41 a m U c n X 1 2 0 0 0X uO V4 a Q a L o 4 Q> X ax V 14 o c o o * o 4J Ai r4 E p Ecm o a m X* o *o x EH H CM H BH r-1 Ai -t a9 1 3 a *i O ** 4 3 JC. -r4 3 Ai O 3 H O aJC ^ SE H A> o St Ai o A> O LI .c O' r #* * <* *4 tf o tn n CM 5 o. >i X A> 0X 0 tn 44 * UC 00 00 < CM f^ c r* X X H fO rH CM tt >1 tt XH X X Li ow 0c p p 0c Co o u 8 M tt tt o u rH u o r4 X U4 X c O o ^H > a 3 o LI a 05 QUESTIONS SUBSTITUTES KNOWN BY ICF CO a Mr X X M rH W O 0 N cP C <D 0 o c 0 o V - C o E H - o W o *8 M c N p e C (4 X rH o u X >1 crH 44 X X tt L a rH u P r< ~ 0 > 3 Li a a Oa a -w-i v oCO QD U to < UCC 000289 ASBESTOS PRODUCTS 1 What percentage o f the ro o f c o a tin g s o r cement market is asbestos-free? Are th e re o th e r s u b s titu te s being used? (A 2 o M E* to w 5 o u % a o 9 >O c. u O uu ou C --4 4J C E U O >< 4 > Du O u U4 C HU 4a a0 0 * 4J 4 u HC U O' -H 0 41 o VH O U4 0 O3 a fv ^4 4l 3 41 *1 0 JC u4 +> C p4 0 4* 0 4 3 a *o H 3N *0 0 fb * 4> C 0 *4 4> o c 0 *H U0 0> 4i 44 n 3 o *n 04 O' O 4l 3 au -H S JJ 0 si o 4l <0 c jC 3 a o 41 0 0 3 O u a b *0 3 u O O <0 0 4J 4 *4 c E 4i E0 3 4 4o SI Si M 3 M -4 Si 3 Xs 0 O 2O o -< 3 0 41 u *4 41 > 4) 0 41 3 e4 CD 0 c 41 41 C o 0 ^4 0 o -~4 41 4 -4 o 41 s0 O' o c H O Cl 0 Ou \ <3 41 0 It .-4 *o a H Ou < 0 44 r-4 41 fw O 0 41 3 41 -*4 3 144 41 41 o3 41 0 U 41 w u3 03 O 4> O kl 4l (M 0 u0 4> 00 0 U 0 a0 o 0 3 41 u O 0 0> 0 4l E c 41 O 3 0 44 41 H 41 44 r* c O' CD C 3 O a -e4 E 0 O MO 41 44 u 0 c 0 O^ 0 o #-( 41 E 4 44 W 41 U 0 o 0 0 U 44 H O M 0 41 41 *4 44 u 0O o 41 0 r-< O Oo 3 T-l C *8 0 O 1-4 4> 3 \ n JC 0 0 44 < Ou C o E CL u a4i a h0 aE 0 44 41 3 O 00 o 0 4l O 4J H <-4 c 41 41 44 <r4 0 41 41 41 41 -4 a - E a o 3 H U h *H 41 0 U > 0 0 0 U H rt V0 4 0 jj 0 41 0 41 Si 44 c o 0 4l r-l 4J 0 si a 0 o O A 0 a 0M O *<4 u 41 < 3 0X u U S -w Ou oM 41 c o >* E a u0 o z0 X 44 *o Qc Z CL PC u Cb 41 ou 0o CO u tt 44 *o c -0o p * 0 4 r*4 41 EN 3 H u 41 * CO 6 a uO' 0 *4 0 V *4 Cc *4 0 0 E > 0 3 00 D a4 >H 0H CO Gu a<oo 41 M 4 U K o 41 <w 4-4 H X 0 c T? w 0 Eu. *wo k Q e< o u b A0 o 4 4 o 0 41 b a o 41 0 41 o 0 c o > 41 o <-4 A Z 0 O 0 41 Q E 41 *4 O c >, 0 u 41 o -- A o c 0 c o o b E O' A r-4 UC 0 c o 41 .M.X M. H Eu 4 44 H H0 *W 4l >c C0 0 CO z` % X *4 Cb u b 41 H 31 < a 0E t4 O * ua w 0 3 0 41 a E3 3 0 V0 aX o CO *u0 0 o 0 z X o ** o <0 O Ul c nH u 0 o a o b 4 >t t3 *o H u H X bOb o o b 41 41 o Ho * 0 CO 0 a *c 4 b c c U U4 0 41 >* b o 41 0 0 H 0 o c 0 0 O -< M o *4 41 0 0 *4 a a 44 4J H 0c >1 o 41 0 b L 0 0 Ok U C uO 0 4 >4 41 D 0 % v oc b oK o b 44 O *-< ~4 0 41 0 -K o H 0 0 t4 4-4 u u O' > u 3 b H 0 tc >4 b a 0O o h b0 0 4 H O 4* 0 41 bC O' H > b V 41 0 0 C *H c b TJ >a 41 41 0 O H 0 a a ab L0 0 CO 4> A 4J A w Z 3 c 0 E e A C *3 **4 0H o 0o 0 uu N 44 -4 -4 o X O wo h E0 E 0 Xz w 4 O XA a u C4 a A 4 U 3 i U C c E V 05 o a ommo UCC 000290 mo 41 o eOs 4J O' C ellulose Fibers polyethylene Pibere Clay, Talc Roof Coatings t Cements