Document zdqXdok6DeemZpLvjn1qnLeBm
AR226- [047 3PaMgeColmofpa1n2y1
FINAL REPORT
Epidemiology, 220-3W-05 Medical Department 3M Company
St. Paul, MN 55144
Date: October 11,2001
Title: A Cross-sectional Analysis of Serum Perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS) and Perfluorooctanoate (PFOA) in Relation to Clinical Chemistry, Thyroid Hormone, Hematology and Urinalysis Results from Male and Female Employee Participants of the 2000 Antwerp and Decatur Fluorochemical Medical Surveillance Program
Study StantDate: March 1, 2000
Protocol Number (not applicable) IRB Approval
Exempt Expedited X
IRB Approval Date: (not applicable as these data are from a medical surveillance program)
Principal Investigator
Co-investigators:
Study Director:
Geary W. Olsen, D.V.M,, PhD.'
Michele M. Burlew, M.S."
JeanM. Burris, RN, MP.H.'
Jeffrey H. Mandel, M.D., MPH.
Jeffrey H. Mandel, M.D., MP.H.!
1. 3M Medical Department, 220-3W-05, St. Paul, MN 55144-1000
=
E on
=3 3=2z
x O3538 3
00 GEA NO CB!
P3uMaCso2omrpiazn]y
ABSTRACT
`The 3M fluorochemical medical surveillance program is conducted on a routine
periodic basis at the company's Antwerp (Belgium) and Decatur (Alabama)
fluorochemical manufacturing plants. In the most recent occurrence in 2000, there were
255 Antwerp employees (206 male and 49 female) and 263 Decatur employees (215 `male, 48 female) who participated in the program. This represents approximately 75 percent and SO percent of the eligible employees at these two locations, respectively. Seventy three percent of the participating Antwerp male employees and 75 percent of the Decatur employees were engaged in production activities. Only 12 percent of the participating Antwerp female employees were engaged in production activities compared 10 63 percent of the Decatur female employees.
Employees' sera were quantitatively analyzed for PFOS
(perfluorooctanesulfonate), PFOA (perfluorooctanoate), PFHS
(perfluorohexanesulfonate), PFOSAA (N-ethyl perfluorooctanesulfonamidoacetate), M570 (N-methyl perfluorooctanesulfonamidoacetate), PFOSA
(perfluorooctanesulfonateamide) and M556 (perfluorooctanesulfonamidoacetate) using
high-pressure liquid chromatography/electrospray tandem mass spectrometry
(HPLC/ESMSMS) and evaluated versus an extracted curve from a human serum matrix.
A total organic fluorine index (TOF) was also determined by calculating the percent of each specific fluorochemical's molecular weight that was attributed to organic fluorine
and multiplied by the ppm measured for each fluorochemical and then summed across all
seven fluorochemicals.
000003
P3aMgeCo3m0pfa2n1y Mean serum PFOS levels for Antwerp production and non-production male workers were 1.16 and 0.42 ppm, respectively. Among Decatur production and nonproduction male workers, their mean serum PFOS levels were 1.63 and 0.73 ppm, respectively. Mean serum PFOA levels for Antwerp male production and non-production workers were 1.28 and 0.34 ppm, respectively. Among Decatur male production and non-production workers, their mean serum PFOA levels were 2.34 and 0.59 ppm, respectively. The mean PFOS and PFOA levels for the Antwerp female employees (primarily nonproduction) were 0.13 ppm and 0.07 ppm, respectively. The mean PFOS and PFOA levels for Decatur female production and nonproduction employees were 0.93 and 1.23 ppm, respectively. Separate reports have been written which analyzed the employees' serum levels in relation to their job and building location work assignments as obtained from a self-reported work history questionnaire. A standard set of hematological and clinical chemistry tests were analyzed. These included the following hematological fests: hematoei (percent), hemoglobin (gil, red
blood cells (RBC. 1000/mm"), white blood cells (WBC, 1000/ mm") and platelet count
(1000/ mm'; and the following clinical chemistry tests: alkaline phosphatase (TU/L), `gamma glutamy transferase (GGT, IU/L), aspartate aminotransferase (AST, IU/L), alanine aminotransferase (ALT, IU/L), total and direct bilirubin (mg/d), blood urea nitrogen (BUN, mg/dl), serum creatinine (mg/dl), blood glucose (mg/dl), cholesterol (mg/d). high density cholesterol (HDL. mg/dl) and triglycerides (mg/dl). Urinalyses were only assessed for Decatur employees via the standard urine microstick analysis, which tested for urine glucose, albumin and red blood cells. Six thyroid hormones were also assayed: thyroid simlatng hormone (TSH: uIUmD: serum thyroxine (T4 kit 6
P3aMgeCodmofpa1n2y1
free thyroxine (free T4; ng/dL); serum triiodothyronine (T3; pg/mL); thyroid hormone
binding ratio (THBR, %, previously referred to as T3 Uptake) and free thyroxine index
(FTI).
Statistical analyses were conducted on the entire surveillance population as well
as subgroups by gender, production worker (yes/no) and location. Univariate analyses
categorized mean levels by serum PFOS quartile distributions. Multivariable regression
was used to analyze the clinical chemistry and thyroid hormones as dependent variables
in relation to the independent effects of PFOS, PFOA or TOF adjusted for several
demographic variables (age, body mass index, number of alcoholic drinks per day,
cigarettes smoked per day and years worked).
`There was a modest positive association between PFOS or PFOA with cholesterol
as well as a stronger positive association between PFOA and triglycerides. These
associations are inconsistent with the known toxicological evidence that has shown the
hypolipidemic (not hyperlipidemic) effect of PFOS (in rats and primates) and PFOA (in
ats but no effect in primates) at dosages that produced serum PFOS or PFOA levels
higher than those measured in this population. Therefore, it is unlikely the observed
positive associations between PFOS or PFOA and lipidsarecausal. Because of the
potential confounding positive association with serum triglycerides, this variable was
added to the hepatic clinical chemistry models as an independent variable. In these
`models, no significant associations were observed with PFOS, PFOA or TOF in relation
to alkaline phosphatase, GGT, AST, ALTortotal bilirubin. Although T3 was positively
associated with PFOA, no other thyroid hormones were associated with PFOS, PFOA or
`TOF: thus there is unlikely a causal explanation (e.g.. hypothyroidism or
000005
3PaMgeCSoompfa1n2y1 hyperthyroidism) for this positive T3 association with PFOA. Hematological and urinalysis results were unremarkable.
In summary, the findings from the 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance program continue to suggest that Antwerp and Decatur fluorochemical production and `non-production employeesdo not have significant changes in serum cholesterol, lipoproteins or hepatic enzymes that are consistent with toxicological findings in laboratory animals. Limitations of the study include its cross-sectional design, the voluntary participation rates and the lower levels of serum PFOS and PFOA measured among these employees compared with those suspected to cause effects in laboratory. animals. A longitudinal analysis is reported separately for the fluorochemical medical surveillance Antwerp and Decatur program data from 1994 through 2000.
000006
INTRODUCTION
3M Company Page bof 121
`The 3M fluorochemical medical surveillance program is conducted on a routine
periodic basis at the company's Antwerp (Belgium) and Decatur (Alabama)
fluorochemical manufacturing plants. Prior to 1994, otal organic fluorine was measured
rather than any specific fluorochemical analyte. Serum perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS)
and perfluorooctancate (PFOA) have been routinely assayed since 1994/95 rather than
total organic fluorine. An analysis of the 1994/95 and 1997 medical surveillance
program data in relation to Antwerp and Decatur employees' serum PFOS levels have
been reported elsewhere (Olsen et al, 1998a, 19992). In the 1994/1995 medical
surveillance program, a total of 178 employees participated (Antwerp = 88; Decatur =
90) and 149 employees participated in 1997 (Antwerp = 65; Decatu=r 84).A totalof 61
Antwerp and Decatur employees participated in both years. The Antwerp male employee
population was significantly younger than that at Decatur, had lower Body Mass Indices
(BMI) and had higher self-reported daily consumption of alcohol. In addition, the
employees' clinical chemistry profiles were different for several tests. The Antwerp
employee population had lower mean alkaline phosphatase and triglyceride values and
highertotal bilirubin and HDL values than the Decatur employee population. The
findings from this prior epidemiologic analysis suggested that significant clinical
chemistry and hematological abnormalities were not associated with serum
perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS) levels up to 6 parts per million (Olsen et al 19982;
19992). Nor were there consistent associations reported between serum PFOS and
several hormone tests including testosterone, estradiol and thyroid stimulating hormone.
CISHD. Twas vot prev to dev inferences from the few employees who bad sem 6 7
3PaMgeC7oompfa1n2y1 PFOS levels > 6 ppm. An important limitation of this prior analysis was the low voluntary participation of male employees (less than 50%) and insufficient sample size of female employees which prevented a separate analysis. Also, although serum perfluorooctanoate (PFOA) was measured, it was not included in the analyses.
Because the voluntary nature of the medical surveillance program may not provide foar complete understanding of the distribution of serum fluorochemical levels in the Decatur workforce, a random sample of 232 employees was selected for fluorochemical testing in the Fall, 1998. The distributionsof employee serum PFOS and PFOA levels were comparable to the results reported in the voluntary Decatur medical surveillance program (Olsen et al 1999b). This finding suggested that the distribution of serum fluorochemical levels observed in the prior voluntary medical surveillance program likely reflected the distribution of serum PFOS and PFOA levels of all `employees in the chemical plant
Detailed discussions ofthe toxicology and epidemiology of PFOS and PFOA have been reported elsewhere (3M Company 2000; Alexander 2001a; 2001b; Butenhoff
etal 2001; Gilliland and Mandel 1993;1996: Haughom and Spydevold 1992; Olsen et al 1998a; 1998b; 1999; 2000; Pasteotarl 1987; Seacat etal2001a;2001b; Sohlenius et al 1993). For the purpose of brevity, this information will not be summarized in this Introduction. Suffice it to mention that for the purposeof employee medical surveillance, PFOS has been reported to be an inducer of peroxisome proliferation and hypolipidemia in rodents (Pastoor et al 1987; Ikeda et al 1987; Haughom and Spydevold 1992; Seacat et al 2001a; Sohlenius et al 1993) and primates (Seacat et al 2001b). PFOA has been
inconsistently reported produce hyplipidemia in rodents Pastoor etal 1987: 0 0 08
3PaMgeCoSmopfa1n2y1 Haughom and Spydevold 1992;) and not in primates (Butenhoff et al 2001). The `mechanism of action pertaining to this hypolipidemia remains to be fully elucidated.
`The purpose of this report was to conduct a cross-sectional analysis of the 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance program for Antwerp and Decatur male and female employees. Unlike the earlierreport for Antwerp and Decatur employees which only analyzed for PFOS (Olsen et al 19984; 1999), the present study examined associations for both PFOS and/or PFOA as well as a calculated measure for total organic fluorine (TOF). Longitudinal analyses of employees who participated from 1994/95 through 2000 were not analyzed as this was a focusof a separate analytical report (Olsen et al 2001)
METHODS `The fluorochemical medical surveillance program is available, on a voluntary
basis, to all Antwerp and Decatur chemical plant employees and those site employees who may work in the chemical plant area. In 2000, approximately 340 Antwerp and 500 Decatur chemical plant and site employees were eligible to participate. In addition to the fluorochemical testing program, a standard batteryofclinical chemistry, pulmonary function and urinalysis (Decatur only) tests were performed on employees. In addition, several thyroid hormones were measured. A site-specific work history was also administered to all employee participants. Analyses of these self-reported workplace questionnaire data in conjunction with the employees' serum fluorochemical levels have been reported elsewhere for Antwerp (Olsen et al 2001b) and Decatur (Olsen et al, 20010).
000009
P3aMgeCdoompfa1n2y1
Hematology, Clinical Chemistry and Urinalysis Allina Laboratory Services (St. Paul, Minnesota) performed the standard
hematological and clinical chemistry tests. These included the following hematological tests: hematocrit (percent), hemoglobin (gm/di), red blood cells (RBC, 1000/mm), white
blood cells (WBC, 1000/ mm') and platelet count (1000/ mm); and the following
clinical chemistry tests: alkaline phosphatase (IU/L), gamma glutamy transferase (GGT, TUL), aspartate aminotransferase (AST, IU/L), alanine aminotransferase (ALT, IU/L); total and direct bilirubin (mg/dl), blood urea nitrogen (BUN, mg/dl), serum creatinine (mg/d), blood glucose (mg/dl), cholesterol (mg/dl), high density cholesterol (HDL, mg/dl) and wiglycerides (mg/d). Urinalyses were only assessed for Decatur employees viathe standard urine microstick analysis which tested for urine glucose, albumin and red blood cells.
`Thyroid Hormones Six thyroid tests were conducted by LabCorp (Kansas City, MO): thyroid
stimulating hormone (TSH; IU/ml); serum thyroxine (T4; g/dL); free thyroxine (free T4: ng/dL): serum triiodothyronine (T3; pg/mL); thyroid hormone binding ratio (THBR, %, previously referred to as T3 Uptake) and free thyroxine index (FTI). TSH, free T4 and T3 were determined by an immunochemiluminometric assay (ICMA). T4 and THBR were determined by a cloned enzyme donor immunoassay (CEDIA). FTI was calculated by multiplying T4 and THER.
000010
---
I
Pa3gMe CIo0mopfa1n2y1
Fluorochemical Analyses Sera samples were extracted using an fon-pairing extraction procedure (Hansen et
al, 2001). The extracts were quantitatively analyzed for PFOS (perfluorooctanesulfonate), PFOA (perfluorooctanoate), PFHS (perfluorohexanesulfonate), PFOSAA (N-cthyl perfluorooctanesulfonamidoacetate), MS70 (N-methyl perfluorooctanesulfonamidocetate), PFOSA (perfluorooctanesulfonateamide) and M56 (perfluorooctanesulfonamidoacetate) using high-pressure liquid chromatographylelectrospray tandem mass spectrometry (HPLC/ESMSMS) and evaluated versus an extracted curve from a human serum matrix Endogenous levels of certain fluorochemical were determined in the standard serum matcix and additional luorochemical was spiked into the matrix. The total amount of each specific fluorochemical (endogenous + spiked) was used to construct an extracted standard curve. All serum fluorochemical analyses were determined by Northwest Bioanaltyical Laboratory Inc. (Salt Lake City, UT). A description of the distribution of the serum fluorochemical levels is reported elsewhere for Antwerp (Olsen et al, 20015) and Decatur (Olsen et al, 2001).
For Antwerp, al employee serum values for PFOS and PFOA values were above the lower limit of quantitation (LLOQ). There was one employee (0.3 percent) with a PFHS value below the LLOQ (0.0027 ppm) and one employee (0.3 percent) with a M570 below the LLOQ (0.0057 ppm). There were 111 employees (44 percent) with PEOSAA Values below the LLOQ (0.006 ppm: 88 employees (35 percent) were below the LLOQ
(0.001 ppm) for PFOSA; and 13 employees (5 percent) were below the LLoQ (DG0 | |
Pa3gMe Cloomfpa1n2y1 ppm) for M5S6. For Decatur, all employee serum values for PFOS, PHS, PFOA and MST0 were above the respective lower limit of quantitation (LLOQ). There were 8 (3 percent) employees with PFOSAA values below the LLOQ (0.006 ppm); 111 employees (42 percent) were below the LLOQ for PFOSA (0.001 ppm); and 13 employees (5 percent) were below the LLOQ for M556 (0.0043 ppm). For statistical analysis purposes, serum fluorochemical values that were less than the LLOQ were assumed to be the midpoint between zero and the LLOQ.
A total organic fluorine index (TOF) was determined by calculating the percent of each specific fluorochemical's molecular weight that was attributed to organic fluorine (PFOS (64.7%); PFHS (61.9%): PFOA (69.0%); PFOSAA (55.3%); PFOSA (64.7%); MS70 (56.6%) and M556 (58.1%) multiplied by the ppm measured for each fluorochemical and then summed across all seven fluorochemicals.
Data Analyses Serum PFOS and PFOA levels were the predominant fluorochemicals as the other
five analytes were measured at considerably lower levels (Olsen et al 2001b; 2001c): therefore, PFOS and PFOA were the only two specific fluorochemicals analyzed as `explanatory variables in regression models. TOF was also considered in the analyses which took into account these other analytes in an aggregate index (sce above definition). Descriptive simple and stratified analyses, Pearson correlation coefficients, ANOVA and `multivariable regression were used to evaluate associations between PFOS, PFOA and `TOF and each hematological and clinical chemistry test and thyroid hormone assay. For saified nays. employees were divided ino quarts of their sem PO. )
Pa3gMe C1o2m0pfa1n2y1 distribution. Age, body mass index, current alcohol consumption (drinks per day) and cigarette use (cigarettes smoked per day), years worked at Antwerp or Decatur, and type ofjob (production versus non-production) were potential confounding factors that were considered in the analyses. Production jobs included cell operators, chemical operators, mill operators and crew supervisors. Non-production jobs included engineers, QA/AC laboratory and research workers, secretaries and managers.
Multivariable regression models were fitted with PFOS and/or PFOA analyzed as a continuous variable(s). Natural log transformations of the dependent variables were performed, when necessary, to normalize variables and to enhance model fit. Study results were analyzed using the SAS System (1990).
RESULTS Altogether, there were 255 Antwerp employees (206 male and 49 female) and 263
Decatur employees (215 male. 48 female) who participated in the 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance program (Table 1). Seventy three percent of the Antwerp male employees and 75 percent of the Decatur employees worked in production activities. Only 12 percent of the Antwerp female employees worked in production activities compared to 63 percent of the Decatur female employees.
Provided in Table 2 are the mean PFOS, PFOA and TOF values, demographic values and clinical chemistry and thyroid values for male employees stratified by location `and production or non-production work activities. Regardless of the production categorization, Antwerp male employees compared to Decatur employees had lower serum PFOS and PFOA levels: were significantly younger: had lower mean BMIs:
000013
Pa3gMe C1o3m0pfa1n2y1 worked fewer years: drank, on average, more alcoholic beverages per day; had higher mean HDL and total bilirubin values; and had lower mean triglyceride, alkaline phosphatase, GGT, AST and ALT values. Mean thyroid hormone values tended to be higher among Antwerp employees. All mean values were within reference ranges. Comparable findings were observed for Antwerp female employees compared to Decatur female employees (Table 3).
Given the differences between Antwerp and Decatur employees, univariate analyses were initially stratified by location. Antwerp data, stratified by gender and production, are provided in Tables 4 through 12. Inasimilar fashion Decatur employee dataare provided in Tables 13-24. The Decatur data also include employee urinalysis. results.
Antwerp production male employee data (n = 150), stratified by quartile of serum PFOS distribution, is presented in three sequential tables for clinical chemistry (Table 4) and thyroid hormones (Table 5) and hematology (Table 6) results. The highest quartile
(4") mean serum PFOS level was 2.61 ppm (range 1.76 - 6.24 ppm) compared to the
lowest quartile (1*) mean serum PFOS level of 0.29 ppm (range 0.04 - 0.41 ppm).
Production workers in the highest quartile of serum PFOS levels were older and worked more years at Antwerp. There were no significant mean differences between the quartiles for BMI, cigarettes smoked or drinks per day. There wasonly one significant difference between the four quartile levels for any clinical chemistry, thyroid hormone or hematology comparisons. This significant difference was the comparison of the mean
BUN value between the 1* and 3 quartiles.
000014
ee
Pa3gMe Cdoomfpa1n21y Ina similar fashion for the 56 non-production Antwerp male employees, their clinical chemistry, thyroid hormone and hematology results are presented in Tables 7, and 9, respectively, fortheir quartile distribution of serum PFOS. In this analysis, the highest quartile hadamean serum PFOS level of 0.90 ppm (range 0.49 - 1.76) compared 10a mean of 0.13 ppm (range 0.05-0.20 ppm) in the lowest quartile. No significant mean differences were observed for demographic (Table 7), clinical chemistry (Table 7), thyroid hormone (Table 8) or hematology (Table 9) comparisons between the serum PFOS quartile distributions. Among the 49 Antwerp production and non-production female employees analyzed as a group (Table 10), the highest quartile mean serum PFOS level was 0.26 ppm (range 0.15 - 0.55) compared to the lowest quartile mean serum PFOS level of 0.06 PP (range 0.04 - 0.08 ppm). The highest serum PFOS quartile did not significantly differ demographically than the other three quartiles (Table 10). The lower three quartiles had some significant differences between themselves for the mean comparisons of years worked and drinks per day. Only one clinical chemistry, BUN, was significantly
different between the quartiles as the 3" and 4" quartiles had higher mean BUN values
than the 1* quartile. All mean values were within reference ranges. No significant mean thyroid hormone (Table 11) or hematology (Table 12) difference was observed between the quartiles.
A total of 161 Decatur production male employees were stratified based on their quartile distribution of serum PFOS (Table 13). The highest quartile had a 3.22 ppm mean serum PFOS level (range 231 - 10.06) compared to 0.55 ppm mean serum PFOS level in the lowest quartile. There were no significant mean demographic differences
00005)
Pa3gMe CIo5mopfa1n2y1 between the four quartiles and the only clinical chemistry test that was significantly different was ALT (Table 13). The highest quartile hadasignificantly higher mean ALT
level (44 IU/ml) compared to the 1* (33 IU/ml), 2 (32 IU/ml) or 3" (33 IU/ml)
quartiles. There were no significant mean differences for the Decatur male production employee quartile distributions for thyroid hormones (Table 14), hematology (Table 15) or urinalysis (Table 16) results.
Among the 54 Decatur non-production male employees (Table 17), their highest quartile mean serum PFOS level was 1.66 ppm (range 1.00 - 2.95 ppm) compared to the. Towest quartile meanof0.19 ppm (range 0.06 - 0.29 ppm). The highest quartile worked almost twice as long as the lowest quartile (Table 17). There were no significant differences in other demographics, clinical chemistries (Table 17), thyroid hormones (Table 18), hematology (Table 19) or urinalysis (Table 20) results among the quartile distributions.
Among the 48 Decatur production and non-production female employees (Table 21). the highest quartile had a mean serum PFOS level of 2.04 ppm (range 1.38 - 3.62 ppm) compared to the lowest quartile mean serum PFOS levelof 0.20 ppm (range 0.06 0.31 ppm). There were no significant differences between the quartiles in relation to demographics (Table 21), clinical chemistries (Table 21) or thyroid hormones (Table 22). `The third quartile had a significantly lower mean platelet count than the 1* quartile (Table 23); however, the fourth quartile was not significantly lower than the 1 quartile. Urinalysis findings did not differ by quartile (Table 24).
Presentedin Table 25 are the number (and percentage) of Antwerp or Decatur employees which had above reference range values for hepatic clinical chemistry tests.
0000/6
a
Pa3gMe Clo6mopfa1n2y1 `These findings in Table 25 are stratified by serum PFOS quartile distribution within each of the gender and production/non-production categories. Because cach sub-population has a different serum PFOS quartile distribution, comparisons should only be done within each location-, production- and gender-specific category. Also presented is the number and percentage of employees who had one or more liver enzyme and bilirubin tests above the reference ranges (see aggregate total liver panel). The percentage of Antwerp employees whose liver enzyme tests were above reference range values was comparable for production and non-production male employees. Among Decatur employees, there `was a higher percentage of production male employees in the 4" quartile for ALT, GGT and the total liver panel than the other quartiles. For non-production male employees, the highest percentages occurred in the second or third quartiles. Neither Antwerp or Decatur female employees had percentages consistent with any trend in the quartile distributions.
Provided in Tables 26 and 27 are the serum PFOS quartile distributions for the combined 421 Antwerp and Decatur production and non-production male employees.
`The highest quartile (4%) had a mean serum distribution of 2.69 ppm (range 1.69 -- 10.06
ppm) compared 10 0.27 ppm mean (range 0.04 ~ 0.42 ppm) compared to the lowest (1%) quartile distribution. It is important to note that the number (and percentages) of Antwerp versus Decatur employees in each of these four quartiles differ (sce footnote to `Table 26). In the lowest (1*) quartile, there is a greater percentageofAntwerp than Decatur male employees and more non-production than production employees. In the subsequent higher serum PFOS quartiles, the percentage of Decatur production male employees increased and the percentage of non-production male employees, whether
000017
---
ee
Pa3gMe C1o7mfpa1n2y1 from Antwerp or Decatur, decreased. These differences were also reflected in the demographics between quartiles. For example, demographically the trend from the lowest to highest quartile increased with age, BMI and years worked and decreased with the `mean number of alcohol drinks per day. Likewise, the means of the clinical chemistry and thyroid hormone tests were reflective of the higher percentage of Antwerp employees in the lower quartiles and higher percentage of Decatur employees in the higher quartiles Mean triglyceride and alkaline phosphatase levels were lower and total bilirubin levels were higher in the lowest quartile compared to the highest quartile. For thyroid
hormones, T3 was lower in the 1* quartile compared to the 4* quartile and THBR was
significantly higher Combined analyses of Antwerp and Decatur production and non-production
female employees (Tables 28 and 29) presented a similar distribution of employees by Tocation and production patter as was observed with the production and non-production male employees (Tables 26 and 27). Antwerp female employees predominated in the Towest quartile and Decatur female employees predominated in the highest quartile. This distribution difference is then seen with the lower mean age, BMI and alkaline phosphatase findings and the greater number of drinks per day and higher total bilirubin levels in the lowest quartile compared to the highest quartile. Also observed was a lower mean GGT and blood glucose level in the lowest quartile when compared to the highest quantile. There were no thyroid hormone differences between the quartile distributions (Table 29).
`Summarized in Table 30 are the combined number of Antwerp and Decatur employees (and percentages) who had hepatic clinical chemistry tests above reference
000018
Pa3gMe C18omopfa1n21y range values stratified by quartile of the serum PFOS distribution. Among male employees, twelve percent of the employees had above reference range values for ALT
and GGT in the 4" quartile compared to 4 to 8 percent in the 1 through 3" quartiles. For
the total liver panel, 23 percent of the male employees had one or more liver clinical chemistry tests above the reference range value compared to 14 to 16 percent in the lower three quartiles. No differences were observed within the female employee population. `These percentages were not adjusted for potential confounding factors (e.g., BMI).
Because the higher liver enzyme function test results in the 4" quartile might be
confounded by demographics (higher BMI, older age) and/or clinical chemistry tests (triglycerides) reflective of dietary differences, multivariable regression analyses were conducted on the combined Antwerp and Decatur male employee participants. Each regression model had the following variables: production job (yes = I; no = 0); Antwerp/Decatur (1 = Antwerp; 0 = Decatur); age, BMI cigarettesperday, drinks per day and years worked. For the analyses that involved hepatic clinical chemistry tests. triglycerides was also considered a potential explanatory variable. Regression models analyzed serum PFOS, serum PFOA, serum POS and PFOA, and total organic fluorine. (TOP).
Provided in tables 31 through 34 are the analyses for these fluorochemical comparisons in relation totheireffect on cholesterol, adjusted for the other explanatory variables. Serum PFOS was positively associated with cholesterol although its explanation of the variability of cholesterol in the model was less than 1 percent (see
partial R?). (Note: This positive association is opposite that of the well-established
negative association between serum cholesterol and PFOS that have been shown to occur
0000/9
Staessen?
FaMse C1o5mopfa3n1y
in toxicological studies at threshold serum doses that were approximately 2 orders of `magnitude higher than those serum PFOS levels observed in these employees.). Likewise,
there was a positive association for PFOA and TOF but not the combined effects of
PFOS and PFOA, with cholesterol. Again, thisis contrary to the toxicological research
that has shown PFOA lowers serum cholesterol. Age and drinks per day were significant
variables in the model with cholesterol. PFOSor TOF were significantly associated with
HDL, but PFOA was negatively associated (Tables 35 through 38). As to be expected, BMI and drinks per day were strongly associated with HDL. Analysis of triglycerides
showed PFOS, PFOA and TOF were positively associated (Tables 39 through 42).
PFOA appeared to be the more significant predictor than PFOS. (Note: PFOS and PFOA have decreased serum triglyceride levels at toxicological doses, not increased `serum triglyceride levels.) Age, BMI and cigarettes smoked per day were significant variables in the triglyceride models found in Tables 39 through 42. Provided in Figures 1 through 3 are scatter plots of the simple linear regressions between the natural log of `serum triglycerides and PFOA for Antwerp male, Decatur male and Antwerp and Decatur female employees.
Multivariable regression model results for the hepatic clinical chemistry analyses.
are found in Tables 43 through 62. Because of the potential confounding positive association with serum triglycerides, this variable is added to these models. No significant associations were observed with PFOS, PFOA and TOF in relation to alkaline
`phosphatase (Tables 43 through 46), GGT (Tables 47 through 50) or AST (Tables 51 through 54). Although PFOS or PFOA were not significantly associated with ALT
000029
Pa3gMe C20o0mfpa1n21y (Tables 55 - 57), TOF was positively associated with ALT (Table 58). PFOS, PFOA or TOF were not significant predictors of total bilirubin (Tables 59-62).
Multivariable regression analyses of the thyroid hormones resulted in no significant associations of PFOS, PFOA or TOF with TSH (Tables 63 - 66), T4 (Tables 67-70), Free T4 (Tables 71 ~ 74), THBR (Tables 75 -- 78) or FTI (Tables 79 - 82). PFOS, PFOA and TOF were positively associated with T3 although contributed
`minimally to the variation explained in the model (see partial R?).
DISCUSSION, Although voluntary participation rates ranged from 53 percent (Decatur) to 75
percent (Antwerp), the 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance program had the most (in absolute numbers) employee male and female participants ever for both locations. `This is likely due to a combination of factors including 1) greater knowledge of the collective (individual and research) value of the fluorochemical medical surveillance program; 2) employee awareness about the persistence and prevalence of PFOS in human tissue and the environment; and 3) the company's May 16, 2000 phase out announcement that it would cease productionofperfluorooctanyl chemistry in certain repellents and surfactants by the end of 2000.
Serum PFOS and PFOA levels were comparable to those previously reported for `employees at these manufacturing operations. Serum levels appearteod be log normally distributed with the highest values for PFOS at 10 ppm. This upper til of the serum PFOS distribution was also reported in a random sample analysis of Decatur employees conducted in 1998 (Olsen et al 1999b). Separate reports examine the employees' serum
000021
Pa3gMe C21omopfa1n21y PFOS, PFOA, PFHS, PFOSAA, M570, PFOSA and M56 levels measured in the 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance program with their workplace operations in Antwerp (Olsen et al, 2001b) and Decatur (Olsen et al, 2001c).
`We continued to observe consistent differences between Antwerp and Decatur employees regarding their demographics and lifestyle differences. In particular, Antwerp `male employees, on average, were younger (and thus worked less), had much lower BMiIs and drank more alcoholic beverages than their Decatur counterparts. All three differences can be important confounding variables when analyzing lipid and hepatic clinical chemistry tests. We have also consistently seen higher total bilirubin values among Antwerp employees since 1995 which may be partially attributable to a greater prevalence of Gilbert's syndrome (Olsen et al 1998a; 19994).
An inconsistent finding from these aggregate analyses was the positive associations in the multivariable models reported between PFOS and serum cholesterol and PFOA and serum cholesterol and triglycerides. There is a substantial body of toxicological literature 10 suggest these associations are spurious because PFOS (in rats and primates) has been reported to decrease serum cholesterol and triglyceride levels (3M Company 2000; Haughom and Spydevold 1992; Ikeda et al 1987: Pastor et al 1987; Seacat et al 2001a; 20010; Sohlenius et al 1993). On the other hand, there is inconsistent evidence for hypolipidemia with PFOA in rodents (Pastoor et al 1987; Haughom and Spydevold 1992) and no effect observed in primates (Butenhoff et al 2001). In primates, there was no association observed between PFOA and cholesterolortriglycerides (Butenhoff et al 2001). There is no toxicological evidence that at the serum PFOA levels observed in our medical surveillance program that PFOA would have resulted in
000022
Pa3gMe C22o0m1pa1n2y1 hyperlipidemic associations. In addition, the PFOA levels observed among Antwerp and Decatur employees in 2000 was lower than those measured in 3M's Cottage Grove manufacturing employees whose serum PFOA levels have been assayed as high as 100 `ppm. Hypolipidemic or hyperlipidemic effects have not been associated with serum PFOA levels among these Cottage Grove employees (Gilliland and Mandel 1996; Olsen etal, 2000). Most recently, the 2000 Cottage Grove fluorochemical medical surveillance. `program analysis again showed no association between serum PFOA levels and serum cholesterol or triglycerides (as seen in Figure 4). (Note: The serum PFOA levels `graphed in Figure 4 are substantially higher than those cited in Figures I through 3 for the Antwerp and Decatur male and female employees.) We therefore believe that it i highly unlikely that these are causal associations observed in the 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance data between PFOA and serum cholesterol and triglycerides.
Previous toxicological and epidemiological research has also not suggested positive associations between elevated serum liver enzymes results and serum PFOS or PFOA that were at the levels observed in the Antwerp and Decatur employee population (3M Company, 2000; Butenhoff et al 2001; Gilliland and Mandel 1996; Olsen et al 1998a; 19992; 2000; Seacat et al 2001a; 2001). In this 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance program we observed, among Decatur production employees,a significantly greater mean ALT among those workers in the highest serum PFOS quartile distribution compared to the other three quartiles. This highest quartile of Decatur employees also had the greatest percentage of employees with ALT (28%) and GGT (15%) values above the reference range as well as the total liver panel (35%). A comparable percentage (36%) was observed among Decatur non-production employees in the second lowest
000023
Pa3gMe C23omopfa1n2y1 quartile with one or more hepatic clinical chemistry tests above the reference range, `When male employees were combined by production status and location (as seen in `Table 30), we reported an upward trend in the percentage of employees in the highest quartile with values above the reference range for ALT (12%), GGT (12%) and total liver panel (23%). However, after adjusting the employees' individual liver function values by potential confounding factors including age, BMI, number of alcoholic drinks per day, cigarettes per day and serum triglyceride values, we found no association between liver function values and PFOS or PFOA. We therefore suspect that the univariate associations were influenced by known confounders of liver function analyses
A battery of thyroid hormone tests were included in the 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance program due to preliminary, albeit biologically inconsistent, findings in toxicological studies that have yet to be completed. Our surveillance data do not suggest any biologically significant associations between thyroid hormones and `employees' measured serum PFOS, PFOA or calculated TOF levels.
Aretrospective cohort mortality study of Decatur employees from 1961-1997 reported 3 deaths from bladder cancer compared to 0.2 expected in the subgroup of `workers with the highest potential exposure to perfluorooctanesulfonyl fluoride (POSF)based chemistry and materials (Alexander 2001b). It was not determined whether this association was fluorochemical-related or possibly due to other non-fluorochemical occupational or non-occupational exposures. An analysis of episode of cares (Olsen et al 20014) reported a higher reoccurrence of cystitis among female Decatur chemical plant `workers than their counterparts in the film plant although the actual prevalence of unique individuals with episodesofcare regarding cystitis was similar. No differences were
000024
Pa3gMe C2o4mopfa1n2y1
reported among male chemical and film plant employees. The analysis of these 2000
fluorochemical medical surveillance data showed no association between the prevalence.
of abnormal urinalyses and employee serum PFOS levels among the Decatur employees.
Limitations of his study design include its cross-sectional nature which does not
adequately allow for the assessment of temporal changes. However, the large
participationof employees in 2000 who may have participated in the 1994/95 andor
1997 fluorochemical medical surveillance programs at these two manufacturing sites has
enabled a longitudinal analysis to be performed. This longitudinal analysis is the focus of
a separate 3M investigation (Olsen et al, 2001a). Although still very limited in numbers,
`we were able to provide separate cross-sectional analyses for female employees, for the
first time, which showed no biologically relevant associations between serum PFOS
and/or PFOA levels with clinical chemistries, thyroid hormones or hematology results.
.
Because 3M has announced a phase-out of the production of perfluorooctanyl chemistry-
related materials, we anticipate that the Antwerp and Decatur employee population mean
PFOS and PFOA serum levels should be lower when measured during the next
fluorochemical medical surveillance program. These future analyses may be hindered by
the fewer employees in the workforce as a consequence of the phase-out announced by
the company. Another study limitation was the lower serum PFOS and PFOA levels
`measured among these employees compared with those suspected to cause effects in
laboratory animals.
In summary, the findings from the 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance
program continue to suggest that Antwerp andDecaturfluorochemical production and
`non-production employees do not show substantial changes in serum hepatic enzymes,
000025
Pa3gMe C2o5mopfa1n2y1 cholesterol, or lipoproteins associated with the serum PFOS and PFOA levels measured. A separate longitudinal analysis is reported for the fluorochemical medical surveillance. Antwerp and Decatur program data from 1994 through 2000. ACKNOWLDGEMENTS
`The investigators acknowledge the contributions of Kimberly Young in the prepartion of this report.
000026 pees ----ES-- em ------------------
REFERENCES
Pa3gMe C26o.m0pfa1m21y
3M Company (2000). SIDS Initial assessment repot: Perfluorooctane sulfonic acid and its salts. St. Paul (MN):3M Company, (unpublished report).
Alexander BH (20012). Mortality study of workers employed at the 3M Cottage Grove facility. Minneapolis (MN):University of Minnesota, (unpublished report).
Alexander BH (2001b). Mortality study of workers employed at the 3M Decatur facilit Minneapolis (MN):University of Minnesota, (unpublished report).
Butenhoff JL, Costa G, Elcombe C, Farrar D, Hansen K, Iwai H, Jung R, Kennedy G,
Lieder P, Olsen GW, Thomford P. Toxicity of ammonium perfluorooctanoate (APFO) in
`cynomolgus monkeys (unpublished report)
after
26
weeks
of
oral
dosing.
St.
Paul
(MN):3M
Company,
Gilliland FD, Mandel JS (1993). Mortality among employeesof aperfluorooctanoic acid production plant. J Occup Med 35:950-954.
Gilliland FD, Mandel JS (1996). Serum perfluorooctanoic acid and hepatic enzymes, lipoproteins and cholesterol: a study of occupationally exposed men. Am J Ind Med 129:560-568.
Hansen KJ, Clemen LA, Ellefson ME, Johnson JHO (2001). Compound-specific, quantitative characterization of organic fluorochemicals in biological matrices. Environ Sti Technol 35:766-770.
Haughom B, Spydevold O (1992). The mechanism underlying the hypolipemic effect of perfluooctanoic acid (PFOA), perfluoroctanesulphonic acid (PFOSA) and clofibric acid. Biochemica et Biophysica Acta 1128:65-72.
Ikeda T, Fukuda K, Mori I, Enomoto M, Komai T, SugTa (1987). Induction of cytochrome P-450 and peroixome proliferation in rat liver by perfluorinated octanesulfonic acid. In: Perixosmes in BioanldMoedigcinye. (HD Fahmi and H Sies. eds) New York:Springer Verlag, pp 304-308.
Olsen GW, Burris JM, Mandel JH, Zobel LR (1998a). An epidemiologic investigation of clinical chemistries, hematology and hormones in relation to serum levels of perfluorooctane sulfonate in male fluorochemical production employees. St. Paul:3M Company (unpublished report).
Olsen GW. Gilliland FD, Burlew MM, Burris JM, Mandel JS, Mandel JH (1998b). An epidemiologic investigation of reproductive hormones in men with occupational exposure. to perfluorooctanoic acid. JOEM (40(7):614-621.
000027
Pa3gMe C27omopfa1n21y OanldsehnepGaWti,c BaunrdrliispiJdMc,liMnaicnadleclhJeHm,isZtorbyeltesLtsRi(n1f9l99u2o)r.ochSeemriucamlpperrofdluucotrioooncteamnpelosuylefeosn.ate JOEM 41(9):799-806.
OMlasnednelGWJ,H (L1o9g9a9n6)P.WF,luSoirmopcshoenmiCcAal,eHxapnosseunreKJa,ssBeusrsrmiesnJtMo,fBDuerclaetwurMcMhe,miSccahlumapnedrftilJm.C, plant employees. St. Paul:3M Company (unpublished report).
OhelpsaetnicGeWn,zyBmuersri,scJhoMl,esBtuerrollewanMdMl,ipoMparnodteeilnsJiHn (a2m00m0o)n.iPulmaspmerafclhuoorloeoccytsatnookaitnen and production workers. Drug Chem Toxicol 23(4):603-620.
OslesreunmGpeWr,lfBuourroloecwtaMneMs,ulfBounrarties (JBP,FOMSa)ndaenld JpeMrf(l2u0o0r1o2o)c.tAanoaltoneg(itPuFdOinAa)l laenvaellyssiisn orfelation 0 lipid and clinical chemistry test results from male employee participants of the. 1994/95, 1997 and 2000 fluorochemical medical surveillance program. St. Paul, MN:3M Company (unpublished report).
JOKl,seMnaGndWe,lSJcHhm(i2c0k0l1eb)r.MNDe,scTriieprteinvseJsMu,mmLaograynofPsWe,rBuumrrfilsuoJrMo,chBeumriclaelw lMevMe,lsLaumnodnbgerg
`employee program.
participants St. Paul:3M
of the year 2000 Antwerp fluorochemical Company (unpublished report).
medical
surveillance
(Ol2s0e0n1)G.W,DesLcorgiapntiPveW,suSmimmaprsyonofCsAe,ruBumrrfilsuoJrMo,chBeumrilcaelw lMeMve,lsLaumnodnbgeregmpJlK,oyMeaendel JH
participants of the year 2000 Decatur fluorochemical Paul:3M Company (unpublished reporo).
medical
surveillance
program.
St
Olsen GW, Burlew MM, Hocking BB, Skratt JC, Burris JM, Mandel JH (2001d). An eepmipdleomyieoelso,gi1c99a3n-a1l9y9s8i.sofSet.piPsaouldeMsNo:f3caMreCoofm3paMnDyec(autnuprubclhiesmhiecdarlepaonrtd).film plant
PstausdtioeosroTfPa,mLmeoenKiPu,mPeprerriflMuAo,rooGicltlnioeastPeJ-i(n1d9u8c7e)d.heBpiaotchoemmeigcaally aanndd mpoerrpohxoilsoogmiecal proliferation. Exp Mol Pathol 47:98-109.
SAS Institute, Inc. (1990). Institute Inc.
SAS Users Guide:Statistics Version 6.
Cary, NC:SAS
S`Seuabc-acthrAoMni.cTdhieotmafryortdoxiPcJi,tHyaonfspeontaKsJs,iCulmepmeerfnluLoAr,ooCcatsaeneMsuTl,foBnicuatcied inJnLrhat(s2o.00fT1oafx)i.col Sci (submitted 2001a).
Seacat AM. Thoford PJ, Hansen KJ, Olsen GW, Case MT, Butenhoff JL. Subchronic
toxicity Toxicol
studies on perfluorooctanesulfonate Sci (submitted, 2001b).
potassium
salt
in
cynomolgus
monkeys.
000028
Pa3gMe C28omopfa1n21y
SPoehrlfelunoiruosocAtKa,neErsiulkfsosnoincAaMci,d HisoagsptotreonmtCi,ndKuicmelraonfdpeMr,oxDiesPoimearlrefaJttWy (a1c9i9d3)B.-oxidation
and other activities Pharmacol Toxicol
known to 72:90-93.
be
affected
by
peroxisome
proliferators
in
mouse
liver.
000029
|
e3MaCormpanny
Table 1
{
Number ofEmployee Paricpants nthe2000AntawndeDecratpur Medica Surveillance Programs
Antwerp (82259) ProductMiolne(NNo=n20P6r)oduction _ ProductFieomnale N(oVa=-1P9r)oduction som sean sae Bes
a. Mana) Decatur (=263) Female (N=48) Production NonProduction Production __ Non:Production
was sss
WE sane
"Percent in parenthesis
000030
|
;
Passo
Tab2
Demographics CliealChemie and Thyid Results
hepaom DEm_0AempT(ESipsotiDoen w ETo) Amvep(iNaosnrtucbioen en)
ros
ast
Lo
ue
wo
oe
on
rox
Lo
i
a
an
os
os
|r
Lat
205
17
a
oar
on
ne
o
x
o
PS
PB
a
us
2s
ue
no
62
ne
Vers Word
w"
w
is
PB
2
Gipsy
`
.
5
.
2
s
Dinky
we
0
ue
a
ww
0
.
Chose
ns
as
as
m
ns
wm
wou
ss
"
ss
o
ss
"
hers
ne
wo
I
1
2
0
Akos
w
"
wt
w
a
cor
nt
n
nt
a
ww
ast
TM
%
nt
%
u
x
ALT
n
as
3%
2
a
00003]
oo
1 Creatinine
2
"
ue
12
12
nu
p< OF comparetdoDecatur (test)
"Pp <.0001 compared to Decatur (t test)
000032
Table 3
Mean
Values for Female Employee Demographics, Clinical
Participants' Serum Fluorochemical Chemistries and Thyroid Results
Levels,
PFOS
Antwerp (N = 49) 013
PFOA
007
TOF
017
Age
36
BMI
28
Years Worked
2
Cigarettes/day
Drinks/day
Cholesterol HDL
2?
0s?
208 68*
Triglycerides
94
Alk Phos
4
GGT
2
AST
18
ALT
13
`Total Bilirubin
0.8"
Direct Bilirubin
ol
BUN
16
Creatinine
09
Glucose:
85
TSH
23
T
102
Free T4
1
ke]
148
THBR
30!
FTL
29
--
2 p<.05 compared to Decatur (student t test) pp<<..00011cocmopmapraerdedtotoDeDceactautrur(s(tsutduednetntt tetsets)t)
4p <.0001 compared to Decatur (student t test)
Decatur (N = 48) 093
123
176
4
217
13
s
0.1
200 59
133
65
18
2
19
0.6
or 2 08 87 23 93
10
128
23
25
0080033
Pa5gMe C32o0mfpa1n2y1
es
ecmra
|
Pcnbricl, DegAvendryCMaelPCrhcteoyn ERneplhoebey(Q8ui1t5e0ofSraPROSDison
aRwePEOamEa soa aI me ten aan owan E wwquotoem ewvS e eer Pana ie toe
OY A
owow mmeam ommams wmeowww+ mmeww mome mwowe mmemm mow wow a4 ammw
| Coin YenWotes #24 350 .1 em2-28 s a" 4 j2e-m3 "4 ano 4 e1-m9 1i" isoe 46 e5-n3
ot www ew mW 4
aw
wm
we a
em
mo
mw I
mow
ts --
awaan
em um
wm om @ eos
xs wm
wm om wm ow wow ww
em a ow
on uw
ae aw
w om e
wom moa
am mm
om ow
mmosw
aw ww
ow won mows
wk mm
x on
mwoew
nmw C
bMiasme 10
m1om03
wm sets
mdowm
oa or
we esa
mwoamsmmsmw
mde mee+
aa een
pti w1 eoem wwemr ewwaee wmeems
oowosam
ow wn
w mmmar
ees um
Gee 5 mw wo ww 6 em wu wn aw wn ew
| T m RbEE atreShaelettE <I08ifbBernsGmm oonaE e etn s
00003,
aes ThyridAnRtweesrpeMabyeQPuarrtoofdSEemurpalcoPyRtO(SiNDi=os15bn0o)tion
vr QSuee 105152)
Qdune20810:30To Wn Queadi a30Stb3 Tonge
Wow was sens 85 8 14 cen 81 81 14 sous Pet 2 wm eis Wu on nie LW 02 066 mw om os owes mo mon mew mm op wow mew x 3 mae Mw 1 mw ww 3 me ma a6 es wan as ds on ma 3 2 ea 1999 fNiosirheifetP< 05, Bokve)e1c r vies
Passio
We QVeuienst5o0 ) ame 8 82 Wo -n0 WW 02 0s be mm ses x x 2 va 2 a ok 16
000035
-- HematoloAgnytwReerspulMsa*lbeyPQruoadrutcitlieonofESmpeluomyePeR(ONS=Di1s5t0i)butionTM*
Mein Qbiudes =SO) Torge Wem QMeudne4S-D30) Forge
HT 4 6 3 4-H 4
3 wes
HOB 155 Ise 08 M0-D4 ISS ISS 09 B21
REC 52 sa 03 4e-s s1 S20) 44-s5
WBC 70 64 18 42-04 73 20 08 A4-NS
Pads 20 9 peu 2s Bo SL W0-m
""LNSoegtTiiaosiefrsacPROS< qu5a,rtBoosfirotniio(Dnoe) 15)msn aes
ewQuMietdea =Sb) Tome
dw 3 es Ise ISS 08 B6-03 SI S103 4759
76 74 16 S2ME 29 0 Me
P5eMCsosmaplaznly
ew QMuedem44S-b31) Farge wa 3 ans S313 09 Gaon SO So 03 40-58 72 69 21 4s-ise 2 ws 19.36
Ther
FCaosmspelr
||
Fluorochemical DemograpAhnitcwearnpd CMaileaNoCnhePmriosdutcrtyioRensEultms pbylQo(uNya=e3ro6etf)Sierluem PFOS Disibution
To i awe on 5 e om oman
ox a am os oom or a an eM om-nw
x ow mw TM Me mow wean Yaw 85 wm Cmemay 1 0 5 om busy 1 01 ois
om om Saom omen
ow ais on eecos ow 0s on omos a @ oo ws me wn we ww 6 em 0 0 0 ow 1 1 mse
Woawe a
on om ow os uw we WM nn 40 Lu
Saom anda
on ovals on oy-ew os mum 0S MDs 4 aa 1 om es ale
W ow e ow e 5000 on oo
ead 0a os omen mY 10 om ossea0r 0 a 1 es MW 30 em ss 9 am 2 0 4 om 13 0 16 sees
ws uw ow em
Tres 9 Ww een
Mma mm nm wm
aor
mw es
ae wom 7 mew
nr wom ow wa
Twimiebs 1312 0 ass
a os mo wm mmm we @ @ new mw 2 nam om on 1 sw mom ow ea 12 02 or oad
se ben mo ma es a a ow ww ow ww ew 3 om 1 wm ww om ww 00 0 0 esr
sw 9 uw nm wn nm nae mw un wen 3 6% ew ow n+ lew uw nu nw 0 lo 0 aris
ov Wom
swam wow wm
Cone 1312 0 wen as 0 0 ees
Gu Mw uw wow wm 5 mm
erBr an fom nf 5 le Nhe hr bnma
mw 4 mm 22 wm ees ms aw
wma wen 0 0 er ois a wu ams 000037
|
Tables
"ThyrAonitdwReerspulMiaslebyNoQnuaPrriolduocftiSoenrEummpPlRoOySesDi(sNi=ut5i6)on
Via Qeudinet vS=D14 Ringe
[tn a 20 wee i 8 89 LL Gs-4 Bem 12 12 02 does mm me wel TER ww 2 was m 2 30 03 moa
MemMeQguainteSO24213) Tonge
20 9 ese Ts se 1s So-se WU 12 02 09-is mus no wows sm 4 oe@ 26 2 06 20-3
Wein QuMiedtaen34xSD15) Fane
a6 17 10 0m 9 17 13 S798 WW 02 09-lS mm 3 dele 3 M3 mea 20 2 04 23s
o35 gFTc fserraePE(O<S0q5u,aBtoenfdenraotni(oDnua) es) ean aes.
FSageot y
Wes QMeuienaStD14) Tum 20 16 14 ea 9 70 19 42-u Li i202 09k ns mw sew 3% Mw 2 nea 2 27 06 13-37
aes
aMagSny
HemsclogAyrtRyesMiablyPrQouduacrtitoonEfmSpelouyPeReO(S=Di49rbuion*
Qruee0114 i Que 20t-1n l Questial Que a0i-10
wr wow 2 ww 0 0 2 ne 6 63 ams 8 2 a
WB
ow mame me ws 07 wis me 53 03 Mame 3 3 08 dere
Wie a sie ee as 1 4-1 es 6 a dems 6s 6 13 49% Mas 3 mB wen wm oe mem ww mes mM om mow tetty lreFS< neBdoinoOn e is
000039
rae10 FuooshenAinctlw,eDrepmFoegmraalpehPirocduncdtiConhriacnld hNoenrPsrodiRcetsiuolnts bypQloyuee(eNo=f9e)rm PFOS
comp
| To e iom om a om amsm e am om oo am-am ai oi en oawEow W 0x5 a en S an w ars.om
mor an em omes-ow Gn om oo em-m ow on om smom 0x em on omen
or on om om oman mn om oo oman an on om mes ow ew ou anos
waa
wow x we wow + wm wows wa ww 6 men Booms ae mews owe we a mem mow 6 mem om me 1 mess
ET
Commty 1 0 3 ew 2 0 6 em 2 0s ews 2 0 4 ap
may 0 01 wo ae ase een 66 eae oes 06 as as orete
Com ww wen wm 6 mew mo wm wem wm wm neem
we eu ws mm ow wm a wm em m6 6 mew
nese ww 9 wa mom on wem ww a wm wn 4 mm
ama 5 ww mw 4 ww ma ws ow wa a a on ww
wor Wom os wm moms wm wom 6 em ww 6 ww
ar Wom em omomoa wn won 1 ew ww a mC
Gr mow x smo owm ows aw www a ww a sa
mse 0 ww esa le ee eno orm wes 0 0 meen
eames 01 01 om ao-es ai or am asec ar a ew enw ol 0 aieor
woe Wow a ew moma wm wow 4 em ww 3 na
om 0 a 02 eeu 0 mo om 0 te wee ta 0 a oni
N Gowam% ewtwag ww swu cwmm nteyfwc[<B5wmeer wtQ hemnmoomeemwsrmrr mrtewc new
-- G T ara NS emeth hrS oSI iSImSeR he
Ee 3 44 a
000049
. _AntwoerrpFeReesPiribyounasndeNooferudumcPiEoGnSEmDplaoyeae (n= 49)
a coop
que 101212a TRT apace? T Quuteseis lQS uestia TH a0 1s ia oes a 24 to ea 2 is is meer 26 2 16 tees. [mw ow mesos sn sr a ens ws 07 36 ews wo 8 2 eon ES Bom wm owem mm a we mw 6 mews ww ou oem mm moms mew wn 4 mx wm 1 me mm 4 es man mes aos 39 0 es dase ow te mew mm or moe
pont feari<e 5Born onDu nis
00004
J
scormp
|
An`HeemratoFlolgyeRePsruoldsu*cbiyoQnuasrntdiNleoofFSreorductmiPoRnOESmDpilsotiybeuet(iNon=4*5)
i
oQue ite1 01212 ToJ TS i Qute esie1n TS i PeR ae
Wr ems me a 4 3 mw 6 wo: ma wa 2 wa
WB Bs Be as sews BS ms 0 mmo msm swims 5s Be of mses
ME as 47 oa ds As 45 03 Aes 4s ks 02 ase 4s 4s 03 aes
We ww ae am 6 wa wes a mw sens 6 6 1 ses
"Wm wm ms Wm oe mem Wm me mew ww a ww
tA swasn --
|
00004,
Tis
Passat
FiocchI endmChailCcarayr ,R-- eDl yeQumalofSgeuaPROpSDihibiion
Equa e 101mt0 l Que n ln queso lPn U. 3
To awn es ow Gin en am on mem ies an nam ame am um iew
mona un we amam ME IS meses a 2% 16 067s SES Se 9m
Te
ix ap awan eM am an amen Man Me meen 9 sn in mena
we 8 ws me a ws wa a os mw a a ow ne
wi me mw wews me mm mem me mos meas wm 0 sew
ve m4 Bam ns wm am wom om aw ww uw
Gust+ 0B em 5 0 mem 3 0 a ew + os om
Ce m8 mm mw 8 mem mm 4 Wow Md ew Ww oe 4 + me sw 4 mm 6 oe om mm os 8 5 me ee mm mm Ww we mw mw om wm wm mom wm
Cr wm om wm mow ww om ow wm x ww wn
A
wr ow wom ome wom ow ew ow uw om ws wh ow nw
I
A
Wem ss em sw + emo mw 3 am ow ss ew
Comoe 4 uw ee Mw Gwen Ww Gm ese wu mos
Gee 9 wb mw nm nm mw wm mw wm ww a nw
rr
Ere a Slee.kn i ea t a meeetn 02g
000043
|
Table 14
PesMaCormpainaty
"ThyroidDeRceastuulrtMsablyeQPuraordtuiclteioofnSEemrpulmoyPeFeO(SN=Dis1t6r1i)butions
Tei QSeudaen| 4S4D0) ange Wem MQefiuane S20D4240) Wangs TS 4s 24 104 05-63 24 18 29 02-85
79 82 13 46-07 8s 85 0S 23-Me FeeTe 10 10 01 06-13 LI LL 02 044 mo omome Bb sew mm Bo wo TBR ww 3 wuem % 2 wey m 20 24 03 1230 25 2s 0s 10-4
NrSoegTae yT oisrfmsPRO<S0q5u,arBtosterobdat(iDown)1s) ca vibes
Wem QMuetea 04S->41) Tage
24 20-45 05-86 8S 82 17 4-9 WW 02 02-5
mu mem ww 3 mm 26 25 05 As-4i
Wow QMeudems S(3D=40) Tame
30 24 34 asm 85 84 12 Si-l4 WL 10 01 0813
Bs ne B90 WW 3 mn 25 24 04 19-34
000044
aes
HematoloDgeycaRteusrulMsa*lebyPrQoudaurcttiiloenofESmepulmoPyR(NeOS=eD1i6s1t)ibuton*
HT HOB [wc WC Paw
Vin QMaudaen1 0S4D240) Tange as as 27 ms 2 183 09 BIn2 as so 03 wos
61 60 13 43-02 26 Wa mem
Vin QMueisteu2nS20,Tonge as es 22 ws ISI S205 D403 so so 03 wise
62 59 Le 3-l02 Ww Wm Wem
We QMuedea34-S4D1) Range 6 4s 20 ws 2 ISI 10 MA-MS s2 so 1s 41-0
64 59 IS Alo WW 0 mem
#+5o5iTganbflcent1lfyrdsefusP(O0S5q,uao tedis o(Dnune) l es)meao nves
FuSeMCsoimapla2n1y
"Mew QMuediatnesvSD40) omg 4 as 24 S2 ISI 08 129-166 so so 04 3s-ss 65 63 18 38-ns me Ww 4 mew
Table 16 UrinalysDiescaRteusrulMtaslbeyPQruoadrutcitlieoonfESmeprluomyePeFO(NS =Di1s6t1r)ibution
Pa3gMe Caosmfpa1n21y
Albumin Blood Sugar
Quartile N(%)
1
10)
3)
36)
QuNar(t%il)e2 26 400) 13)
QuNar(til)e 3 10 400) 202)
QuaNr(ti%l)e4 10) 13 00)
N*SeeuTabmolfeEbm13plfeooryesreesr:umQP1F=O4S0;quQar2ti=l4e0d;istQr3ib=uti4o1n; Q4 = 40
000046
Table 17
Fa3e0 Cdoimopla3n1y
ClinicalCDheecmaitsutrryMaRleesuNlotnbPyrQoudaurcttiiloenoEfmpSleoruymeePR(ONS=D5i4s)ibution
e21S) a
wQuetnic101S =14 R en Qbueeams a$10 ) Emp Wen eQuied$ a e
os as 00 oo 6.0m 0 0% 0m m-0m 07% om ols o%-0s L&T Le on im-2ss
or ox om ow ober 0% 0 ois Ol-ds 0S 04 0% ow-in LY In ae 03-2
or aa on ow mio 0M OW 0 iz OW 0% 0M 0G-1 29% im ool Ln-sm
a uw ow mew oe ow on ma ws 8 os 8s 6 nw
a 3s me 6 mien ws ms 40 wise mw 4 ww m1 me 3 wm
Yemwetst 181 WI U9 0M me m3 Ba 2eMs M0 me 6 DoW mE
se 4s
Cpe 5 0 3 oe 5 0m jee 2 0 4 om 8 0 3 ow
sy 02 @ ows wo 01 20 eo as ous a 0 0 oor
ed Ww a ews mm a wm ww a ww om ma mem
ou " @ wu wm oe wu ww a @ + uw a un un
mda 19 WS wes ms 6 sow de is 6 eam om mom em
| mma wa us ww @ @ no ww nm om a as mn 15 soo
oar 2 ws wes % 3 pas 0 4 ma mm on mC
ast 5 om 1 wa mw ow wa m3 6 ww mB 5 ud
ar a 0 we ww wm om ow we wx 0 om we mmo ma
TwBabe 08 03 02 @s-io 0% 0s 02 0s-is 05 07 03 G44 or op 02 0aew
Diabla 41 01 om apex a1 01 0m oi-o2 of G1 om 00-2 01 a1 om e103
a Wom
em wo wa mew as ss ex ww 4 na
cms 10 10 01 G2 0 Ma ok LW 01 en WW a Weis
iw 8B 4 ww B 6 mw wm 0 wm ww x we
NNieieeemrnmbdenbntantiytyyffllfnrsn (((7<<<<025055.DDDDenelrerrornnn((((DDeDnre))rs1 ))foooommm ehemimcnooofffhe243{octtllleee
00004 7
ers "TyDrerdcRteaMlitbeyNQounaPrrtiofoSnevEmpPlFoySeDei(si5b6ot)ionsTM
Que 01=13
!
TH
Mean
nm
mw esa Median SD__ Range
Ww a ees
EO
mom mp maw
mm we 2 mex
mw oa ee eee
Que ia 1
mw MeanMedian
SD
43
Range
omesz
se 6 own
mm on em mw a mas 2 36 0 wer
L ptyrrs <5,ritrsvne es cs
Quuseanizta
Mien Median SD Range
0 2 a tems ww 1 ees mm DK wu 5 ms 1 0s man
oMopnars
PO
Mean Median SD__ ange
ds is 0 0436 a @ iz 70-9 wm Bo uw 3 mw 2 2 ok en
|
000048
Table 19 HematoDleocgaytuRresMualltsebNyonQuParrotdiulectoifoSneErmupmlPoFyOeeS(DNis=t5i6b)ution**
3PaMgeCsotmlpa1n21y
Tei QNuelasi1 vS=D11) Tonge Wain MQautuini2eS84a1)ngo ewn QMuedean304S1D4) Fangs Wem QMuediatne S40D4-12) Tange Her us es 3 wes 4s 4s a wen ws 3 ae ss 1 8-e
HaB. 152 154 12 120-169 154 150 1 2-178 149 150 08 136-167 150 ISI 05 140-160
REC 50 So 03 47-55 S649 2 4s-1 45 48 03 43-53 Si S103 46-53 WC 61 $7 22 41-B1 60 61 le 30-82 60 ST LL 44-86 64 60 16 44-98 De Pads Meeme @ eet m e A rWW--m--6--B-- W -- Ne-- W -- Mel--se-- memw -- seere eeree rsrele es N05oaTagea1 foirsrereumtPRPO<Sq05,aBedesinbi(oDnu) 6) mes vas
|
000049
Table 20 UrinaDlyesciastuRresMualtlsebNyonQ-uaPrrtoidluecotfioSnerEummplPoFyOeeS (DNis=tr5i4bu)tion*
Pa3gMe C49o0mfpa1n2y1
Albumin Blood
Quartile 1 N(%) 00 2015)
Quartile 2 N(%) 00) 00
Quartile 3 N (%) 00 205)
Sugar
000)
00)
00
--_--
N *SecuTam bolfeEb 1m7plfe ooryesr eesr:umQPIF=OS13q;uQar2ti=le14di;stQr3ibu=ti1o4n; Q4 = 13.
Quartile 4 N(%) 18) 00)
00)
000050
Table21
SPMuCosmapat2n1y
DelcinteuarlFCehmeamliestPyroRduecstuilosn bayndQNuaorntiPleroodfuScetriuonmEPmFpOlSoyDeiest(rNib=ut4io8n)
|
EEN Que 4-1
Que 221
Quuieaary
Quuicsmay
MOS MOL
om" om om a-oN 0s 00 on 6m-0% mi om 0 om-1% 2 1s on Two ow ax 0moom On ow a om-i mY uw un osama is im oss-sa
or ou ou ou e-em aw an nam 1 In om owes Aw 2% wes mem
ne EE
na
PS ma es mses) m9 Mss W0-w3 ms W245 2ne me
[| Yeas m1 0 rm ow mow amon 6 ow am ow
ms es ne-us
nw am
Comey 20 5 0s 3 0 9 em 4 0s ee ns us ow
Day 0 0 01 0003 ooo @ 0-0 eo 0 or eo-r ar a0 or soa
Ove m0 wu Wm 2 ow ms wn me es on
mee mw 8 wen ew we ew sme
mmo ss on
mem wen
Ts % We um mms Mma ma mw es ow
am wm
me mm eeoe ee om aw
mms wm
dem wes
car sr
Mose ex 2 ws oma
won 6 wows
0 wm
wm om ow ow a
ww am
wns ow ns
ew um
aT mo wom ew ww 0 we moon ow eo ww 6 wm
Tibiae 06 6 02 0200 06 m6 a2 ovo oe 05 oi eeor as as or esa
Dibinte 01 G1 01 0002 01 or oes oa-ar a1 ol oa e001 oor ows ae-or
mx em 4 sw omom a Wm nom 4 em om ns ew
Coie 08 08 a2 Gen ox 0s ol ea ae 00 02 alr a as or ore
Ouse mw ws mens % wo mm ww + ow ww on wm
anteofel coloresbypodci QL
cocaybQquuanleNMecisnchsdtptcelllfiefnnn <<000555.DBBaortskeornonn(((bDovem)e)fommoibteemmmeeohbfbe
gootmree
PNernibomncion 3so 08a np
nt Bll brn oe eo 000) .1
Te DecatouvrrFoedmRaleesrsodubcyiounasntdeNoofnSPnruhiPoEnOSEDplioeosn(4 = 48)
masta
|
ET Qr ue 1-12 r quem
Ques TT Quuesct
|
TR
Free T4
Cm mw
wo
mom om
01 09-13
ow mem 5 mew
Loo
or 09-13
ow wm wen
mw we 10 10 01 07-n1
0 0 01 08-12
mm 2 wes
mom 3 Bw om x 4 mm om om 4 wm
YE
ifo ar r Ou ic)t nlc
000052
Table23 DecaHteumraFteomloaglye RPersoudlusctbiyoQnuaanrdtiNloeno-fPSreorduucmiPonFOESmpDliosyterieb(utNio=n48)
WinQMeudaen 1 0S41a2)rge Wim MQeduanieStD 12 Tonge MT w 3 wew s ew2 kes Wo me m7 12 9a-l4 BIB 06 RI-MS RBC 43 43 03 eds 43 43 03 ai-48 WBC e163 20 4-u7 66 6s 19 43-108 Pads W020 @ aso Mm New wom
#n c5 nTale2e 1 aonrsyerda et rFnO(S5.q2u0ar35t,ileDa deriooi (nDopr Le)fote he cnss fae 1) gruee "iMiennmfelyaltrcnay0<0 Daonlkerr ((uane) foomhe es fof h34qgale
WenQuMeedasvS=D12) Range 1 ea R925 05 OBS 44 43 03 3950
S92 17 28-ks 00 We MW wen
P3ueCisnsziaote2ry1:
Wem QMeudeans SvD=12) Rum 0 0 4 uw Ba B44 H3-I 43 44 04 39-50 76 75 19 42-104 wm S I9w
Table 24 DecaUtruirnaFleymsiasleRePsruoldtuscbtiyoQnuaarntdilNeono-fPSreorduumctPioFnOSEmDpilsotryiebeut(iNon=* 48)
Pa3gMe C5o3mopfa1n2y1
Albumin Blood
Sugar
Quartile 1 N (%) 00) 207)
000)
Quartile 2 N (%) 00) 0
00)
Quartile 3 N(%) 20am 305)
00
Quartile 4 N(%) 0 00)
0
N*SeeuTam bolfeEb2m1plfeooryesreesr:umQP1F=OS12q;uQar2ti=le1d2i;stQr3ibu=ti1o2n; Q4 = 12
00005k
ess
se IMCompany |
roo ent Core Coy eh Goofolr Poo ition
- EEmer rr e a ,r sar
rrde on om
nm A
aE os to as voy 0 am oh on oh TE am
n eaen veeo vm veme re en m SernNa ivwn oMinen tvenr i a E I T aona LLLa. E EEL T
oens tom imonot
iBonn rmoa mria om
000055
|
Tube 26
stor
Fluarechemia,ADntewmeorgpaapnhdDiescnadtuCrlMaelaePrCodeucrtitonRaendsNtonb-yPrQoudurcltieoonfS(Nu=m42P1R)OS Dion
|
a PO,
Qeuie105
venPOSee
en Qeueot0e
Me mo
om a on ewon os ax oman
ow ow on oacom a om im owem
Lin on ems LS UB ue one
16% 4 10 1010% 20 ia omaw
Te we
ew ao owen % mae
we iw om owose 4 ew me
Le @a
om owe 5 ma
Wr? an in imam wo 6 0 ne
ma
mw wear we wy de mem mw 4s mam ma me 8 nas
TE
oso 0 ome 5 0 wm ew sr o% wd os eee a on
oo wm ee as or ees
0 oe 08 ew os
Gin We. wa em am a mow ww won mm 4 mem
onda Bs i nm am me wm wee we no momen msm wm
Wma wr
oe wm
www @ ow mm
6 ow mom
we ew
@ ow
@ on ns
wwe ew
wm
on wm nw
EE
wr ow mow mew mm uw we wx ow ew wm on ew
TC
TE
Co we
2 Ws ols wu e wep mw 6 mw wm neem
D0 wan
wes sas
We es a 0 am
000056
mtrot iecemseein
--
PM
[. =
EEE
sIMComypany.
"Table 26 (continued)
a
ionI apye dary ee pe) es gee
-w
N.
PM :
M
-
.
wwe
mE etth Sshoe<3bBree oPDmovttseremeeee mmeeceCoSmer,
|
000057
J.
3MSCompaany.
Antwerp andrDeoctaursMitle Pbyrooducttieon sfndeNoon PFrodSuctiDonoEmoplnoyee (N= 421)
||
ael 2 1s 1am Wm ws sens et ue mers Cm ae mop ose WW Mm Gem
i et 08 i a 0 es ase mow am mW en wel mm www to Tm es
a Saeta um 4 a0 om mow as Bem uM ol mmm sew mm a
a S Sa p a5 1p 2 sens Mm en W120 ote nr mn mem
a WT We
fPFIeo em +5Lrmm ong.urtefnpfrtesie0nsik CCTooett
000058
|
ens
LIMeCoemparny
Fiuoroshemical,ADnetmwoegrrpapahndicDeancdaCtluirnFiecmaallCehePrmoidsuecytiRoensualntdsNboy nQuParrotdiulcetoifonSe(rNa=m9P7R)OS Distribution
RE re See Wan ew |
ros a a om os-ow ai on om owen 0W 03 ais 0mm IS ix 0% omela
or oot om om co-an om ons 0g oman 06 0% 0% 004% mH in 1m exes
Tor a ae om aco on ou 0 am-o3 wom oa ono AMY dw La omer
a wows wm ww 1 mea wm 9 ms 4s wm
ma ne mew omews ne om a mm ws be @ Wess WP mss was |
Vamwekt 1 9 8 am usw 1 am nw 5 am wm 0 3m
Cows 0 4 ow #0 seus 2 0 1. ew #0 on oe
Dy 0 oe oo of @ oe oo 0 04 ea oo ol om
ves Www mem mm moe ww ow wom mm a mew
Le a
wm ee 6 wom 6 6 8 Mem es no %
Teds B 4 Bem aw 4 dem 0 9B wm le I
a-ow
Mma wm mew Ww 0 mes
% 6 me @% nu am
wr wom os we ww 1 ea moms omen ww 7
ar Bors Eww mon es es 6 a mw 0 en
Tbe 08 08 02 0siz os os 0) ear of 06 a ons of 0s 01 oes
Deambe 01 01 G1 00-04 a1 01 oi Gz 01 01 G1 00-01 ol oi On 0-0
ow Wom
em ww 4 mw ow 4 sm oB ms am
Coe 05 00 02 oe Mo lo 01 e-l 00 or a 02 00 or 01 oe
Gwe Wm Mw ww wm ob eas 8 om ew wom on om
--_--00005y
Table28 continued)
MCompary | prsespofiat
"NumberoffensecQmpulyee.s by ain,prdicionctorQusederqari (pect inens) uae
qutes
TS
TT
non 3
2
"
'
.
o
o
I
'
'
.
,
n
2
2
Ww Tm wm
Sm wee meme aw
hiicstnnbst cnylyt ififnnny (((<<<0035,BBBoeonrkkerssDOnueutes)))ffooomehheereecc sie21 ritlcl.e
"Menafectr <y0,Baler (un om nf 4 gle
|
000060
|
Tables Antwerp a"nTdhyDreocisdtuRresFuelmsalebyPrQoudaurcttiileonofaSnedrNuomnPPrFoOdSucDtiisotnrEimbpultoioynee (N =97)
FIMCuomepaln2y1
Vi WiQunite01. Range We WehQrueSrh Wan We WeQluwesSb Rage Mon VetqwunnieSsO Ram | TH 22 22 12 ome4s 22 20 Ls 0m- 25 20 14 036s 23 22 10 10-52 TM 2 102 20 ee-n8 98 98 M1 46-3 99 95 23 SEI a1 87 20 S82 Rem UL 00 0nd 12 Wo 07 07.46 LL 4 01 09-13 10 lo a1 07-2
TR ST I I AJRE ER 0 4 p% Wm 6 ma wm ow 3 mw wm 4 wen wm 25 29 0s 21-3 30 28 13 ures 27 27 05 1238 24 24 04 16:30
NSoeseigTnaibfilcean2t8lyfodrisfeerreunmtP(FPO<S0q5u,artBiolnefdeirsotrniibu(tDiuonna) es) msn values
000061
een
a 3MCompany
Which Had AboveReferenceRaNnugmebearofePfro iHanps (CPeentsiCnhPeamrnesT)esbtybEymQpluoyaelsPogSuleiuonPFOSDison
rn ee
en
naan
ree.
ASe
Marnk Baapslotues 40 10 30 20 0 0 0 Ge e: d om mew me se ne no
rire rat
4b
0m
ww
am
0 6 te ce
cm ke om em ow ew iw
am wom
|
Ae et,TAL. Te i Bn sE e ol teR un 8 rR est
|
000062
Tabet MuivareinsdhiOcthReegrPseinotnakExlploanfahtory VearisebsyPeOS {or A550e 0ndMDeecar tSMauleEmnpPPrrogiampns,
_
parameter
os
pave
eens
son
oon
wor
) pros
om
oo
o
Prion Jo Geshe) TM
oo
P
AnweDecar
ous
os
at
he
ous
om
wo
-
oat
oo
@
Cipretestiny
aor
oor
a
Drink
ams
oon2
ot
Yours Worked
om
ool
is
a 3M Compaay.
||
Partial
. <n <a <a o pr pr @ <n
RpN=oo0r8ge
:
000063
Table 32 M{ooriAvrntrederOytRhaeenrgdePDsoteiecontntiarMloMEadxtpeelaoEnfmaCtpohlrooyylVesasrPrsaileisbnytPsO,A
S000 Meta Survie rogram
r3M aCompoany
Parameter
SE
erent
S000
oom
.
Pron
ois
ous
Producion ob Oech) 002
ona
AnverDecauc
002
ons
ne
oor
om
ot
oor
oo
Pr"
ous
oar
Drinkstay
on
oor
Yours Worked
00m
oon
pvalue
wor
Partial R*
.
os
<a
<a
2
<a
wot
0
"
<a
2
<a
05
a
pr
Natio R= 08
AdjR*= 06
000054
i
Table 33 MalivarsbleaRnedgrOetshseironPtMeondgealloEfxCplhaonlaetsotreyroVlarbiyabPleRsOS and PFOA
for Antwe"r2p00a0nMdeDdeiccaatlurSMuravleiellEamncpeloPyreoegrPaamrticipants,
Pa3geM Ctoomrpa2n1y
Punmeer
SE
pave
Paral
Intercept
5066
oos1
<0o01
.
-
Pros
oots
0010
a6
<0
|
PFOA
0009
0008
2
<0
|
Production Job (esha)
-o018
[
46
<0
Antwerp Decatur
-0033
oos
2
<0
Ae
0007
0002
01
0
|
BMI
0001
oo
@
<on
Cigaretesiday
00007
ooo
5
<0
Drinksldsy
os
oor2
004
o
Years Worked
-0002
ooo
1s
oo
A'd=GRI0=8.06
"Natural log
000065
|
|
Tes {MailAimOteaenRdFDoeeatmMioEsdexEpofmaiCothtoeVinrPriepsbysTO,F
ihc umes Pog
eJwosm |
mere
Parameter
SE
sass
oon
p value
<omt
.Partial R*
: or
oois
000s
<n
Podion bein) 0018
oon
"
pr
AnverDesaur
oom
oon
n
<n
re
oom
oom
oon
0
a
oon
ao
@
<r
Cameteitny
ooms
oon
5
<n
Dray
oom
aon
os
n
|
Vous Woke
oom
oon
15
<n
Neorg R'=.08
AdjR = 07
000066
||
neers #ros PrionJo ese) Averecate a Bt Cipetestny Drininy Yours Worked
No* R'=33
AdjR'= 32
Tabs (oMr AomOlevrvyeaarndRPeDgeernecisitonMEMxeopdaeFnlsoofrnyHDeVLP?rbayisnFtOsS,
S000Medal Suen bogum
Pumeter
SE
pale
an
amo
<oon
000s
oon
"
ows
ons
ES
"aos
oon
oo
om
=
"aon
aos
<n
004
acon
wos
om
oon
<oon
"oo01
oo
st
000067
rMComepany |
Paria
. a pr 0 <a @ a <a
Inert Proa Producion ob esi) AnwerpDecsur TM
i Gipsy Drinksday Years Worked
RANio=gr34teiog
Table 36 Maund OtlherRPeiogteesvnitonEMrxopdaenlistofryHaVDaLrlbiyesPeFOA for Antw3e0rp00sMndiDteceatSuruMrlevEemlplaoPyrnoegecrPaeimricpans,
Parameter
se
pvalue
as
om
<oon
0018
ows
o
ous
oo
EF)
006
oo
5
oui
oon
B
00
ous
<omi
000s
oon
oot
00s
0014
<omi
0001
oo
st
000065
raiiCoemparty |
Paral RY
.
TM <or
"
<0
o
a
6
|
<a
TEpeLiR enka
oo Paamer
se
pvalue
oon
oom am
ooonno
-o
robin oo
on
-
powa
ai
wwrn
<a"
crmany
i
on
a
rYoem r
o-m
woon
o-l
#0 Ri=34
AR =32
000063
IM Company
|
Paral RY
-on i"o i-"
|b
Table 38 MuliavnadrOitbhleerRPeogernetsisailoEnxMpoldanealtoofryHVDaLri*abbylesTOF for Antwe2r0p0i0nMdDeedciactauSruMrvaeliellEamncpeloPyreoegrPaamrticipants,
P3aM Ccoompainaty
_
Parameter
SE
Inercept
am
00%
.
Tor
-0010
0007
Production Job (yesh)
oon
oon
Antwerpecatur
-0050
[
Ase
0001
0002
BMI
0019
00
Cigaretesiday
-0004
0001
Drinkslday
0084
ool
Years Worked
-00009
[3
puiloe
Panial
<.0001
.
kg
o
a
<0
08
15
4s
<0
<.0001
o
0008
or
<0001
0%
58
<0
AR=GR3=3 32 Naural og
i
000070
Table 39 MalivaraanbdlOtRheegrrePsostieonntiMalodEexlpolafnaTtrogryceVarriidabsl*ebs yPROS
for Antwe2r0p0a0nMeDdeicaaltuSruravleiellEamnpceloPyreoegPaamriipnts,
IM Company
v ner ee 2768
SB
0224
.
pros
0066
0026
Production ob (resin)
[3
0065
AmwerpDectur
01st
0068
Age
oor
000s
i
005
[a
puke
<o001 o n 9
<o001
Pak
-
os <on a0 @
10
Cigareestiay
0008
0003
0
Drinksday
0033
oo
EY
<or
|
Years Worked
0007
0004
o
<or
ARiGeRs= 21 "Naural log
000071
Table d0 M{oirAvratanedrOyReahgnrdesaDseiiconnaitolr MlEaxtpoelafEnTmatprolroiyyVegeahPscaeiesbniytdsP,eFOsA
2000 edie Survelanc Program
Parameter
i SE
pale
ere
270
oz
<a
.
Pron
ass
oa
oo
Production Job Geshe) 0004
00s
ss
AnverpDecauc
om
oom
Fs
ae
oie
aos
0s
oa
ooss
oan
<oont
Cipuetestsy
ome
oom
wo
Dinky
om
oo
is
Years Worked
oan
oat
a
rIMCaompoany |
Partial B
. os <or
1 <a ws
R'=29 AdjR?= 27
Naural log
000072
|
Table 41. Multivariable aRengdrOetsshieornPMotoednetilalofETxrpilgalnyacteorryidVeasribayblPeRsOS and PFOA
for Antwe2r0p0a0nMdeDdeiccaatuSrurMvaeliellEanmcpeloPyreoegrPaamcpants,
Pawmee
SE
puke
Inereept
2m
0224
<0001
.
Pros
[2
[
2
PFOA
0053
[3
o
Production 1b (yes/no)
00
0087
76
r--
0109
oom
n
Age
oot
000s
004
M1
o0ss
0007
<.0001
Cigartesday
0008
0003
0
Drnkslday
0050
00s
15
Years Worked
0007
0004
o
ARiG=R2I9 =2) "Netwral log
000, 073
PIeMrCroompta2n)y
Pari] B o <0 08 o 10 o <0 <0
To Tor Podwion bso) AnmerDecatc we Cimetestny Dinky Yous Worked fh AR'G=R2I9= 27
Ta MfoliAvmdrereoyRtgndreePsoiotsniMoiEdtexofEpTrtilVegaaaiclsby ,TOF
Soo edn eile Pog
26 Parameter
SE
on
pvalue
<omt
005s
oon
oo
0007
00s
a
on
oom
0
oon
oo0s
os
ooss
oom
<omt
ooos
oom
w
oon
TM
=
oom
oon
@
MCsoemprany
.Partial R*
"
<a
F
|
|
<a pr
000074
a me Pingo) J-- ws on -- _-- -- sri wars
Mrs oe
oe A r piA tmeaso-- p ton
oss |
|
Parameter
SE
ae
he
oan
-
00%
om
oe
on
oon
oz
om
own
-
-
won
ome
wane
am
wn
ome
puie
Partial
com
o
=
wo
ator
"
=
on
=
on
"
0
Pp
"
a
-
"
|
000075
sn S pror eT onu--s--
Ss
I
se
pave
Cm
oso
ome
roa
om
i
J
os
ows
<aon
-
oss
our
"
a
os
ons
u
Greer
oe
om
-
--
oor
om
=
Tiger
-
-
J
wen AdiRI= 16
*Naturallog.
3sMCormpany
Partial
-
!
<a
|
wn
on
on
wo 00 0076
|
re
Multivariable Regression ModelofAlkaline Phosphatase*byPFOSand PFOA
eso |
|
ee
-me m Sw c n n. Ye mms o eeIemBE s BE n NE
Ri=.18
AdjR*=.16
000077
|
|
Tues Mu{loriAarntedRergGyreeasnssdioPDneoceatnlr MoEaftxeAplBkaalltionsetVhsasPrpanhiesispaasnetsb,yTOF
S00 Nee Sumeans rg
Pubs 3M Company J
Apres
:J
Paameter
SE
pale
Patial B
370
ois
<r
i
or
ows
os
Pr
on
Production fb eso) oon
oom
PF
<a
Awerpecsr
oir
oo
<0
wo
ne
ous
oz
<a
Bi
"oot
oot
Fl
pr
Gipsy
a2
oor
pr
Drinks/day
-0024
0016
14
<o1
!
Yours Worked
"2
om
a.
<a
Tgeeridst
ose
oo
oes
en ANdejRt?t= io1g6
000078
Tbe? MuliavnrdiOstihcerRPegoretssiionEMxoldaenltorfyGGVTartblysPROS for Antwe5r5p0a0nMdDeetcaatuSruMnaillaEnmcpeloryoegsrPaamricipns,
P3eMtCromeprandy |
nee i Pros
Parameter
SE
L246
om
aos
oo
pvalue
Partial R*
<r
i
2
Production Job (yes/no)
0003
0059
96
<1
!
AmverpDecaur
025s
006s
<omn
@
I
000s
oo
ss
<a
Ba
as
our
5
[erm---- Drinksiny Yours Wort
ous
ous
on
ons
om
aor
PY
o
oe
as
<r
Tagheendest
024
00s
<a
os
RA"Niju=wR2r5elio2gs
000079
|
ot Reoncr s Table 48
for AnnSd0e0Ol0endinDdecaaaSMEuaxrtpeEimlrpiayaPprnoVegearrPaeamah ins
PIeMCotmeprany.
|
oom oon " py | Parameter
SE_
Incr
1205
ozs
i
Pro
om
oo
Production Job ges) "oo
0x0
Jr----
os
ous
nt [re---- Dinky
Years Worked Tigheeidest
aces
or
om
ou
ous
om
oa
oo
oa
o0ss
<0 p value
oo El 003
iPartial R* o <a
3s
2
a
2
"
pr
<omn
w= 25
fchitid
000080
LL
ner Fro mou Pocono i) j---- ae a Cipeesiny Dray YeasWorked
erst
----
Ria28
ANdejwR't=o2n3
Tes M{iorvAmaerRoyegaernedsaDioin dneeMlEoxkocfpGlOootTrebVsyaPFRnOasSisnrdsPFOA
ede Sues Poa
Pameter
se
1246
oa
aon
oon
aos
om
"ons
oo
os
aos
ooo
aos
aos
aor
oo
oo
at
oon
oo
os
oa
ooss
--
pvalue
<oon a ~ 2 st 2 wz " <n
--
P3a4Ccotmprueay
Partial R*
.
pr
o
0
o
|
<n
00008]
|
081
|
oo. -- - on -- ro
RB=i3s
R T wea_A pp on
fttynid
LE
Panmeter
se
value
Paral R?
-- . .
-- -- p.s .. || --- -- 5. ..
- --- a. -. |
00003,
|
|
LL
Intercept
rere
Age
-- --i WHry
Parameter
ms
ReE e,
~ SE
0133
value.
<.0001
I"
-
0003
0002
x
hoo - -
htoo
."
sem
Partial RY
.
.
<o1
" .. 0000gg
abe s2 fMo AievrtaeanrdRBeDgereescnoniEcxepeaElmotrfroyAVsSaTrFbiayeiPsFnOtA,
So ee Sunes rg
Parameter
SE
pvalue.
|
ner
ams
om
<0
Fron
aos
oon
wn
PrionJb (ein) om
oo
2
AnverpDecau
os
ons
oot
re
om
oo
a
a
ow
aos
st
Cipretesay
00m
ooo
o
Dry
oost
oon
on
Yous Worked
aos
om
os
5 fr
oon
ons
o
|
RRN'uo=r09oiof
ccorop
.Partial B a <a pr <a <a a <n
000084
oceosm
Tbe ss Mli(ovraAitmOiyRreagedsDPioeotcnenaMtodMEeleaxf EApnSpTol"obtVyeaPrPRaOalScsstdsFROA
Sood umesFog
| Sem te . . _ Parameter
SE
ner
ams
om
ros
os
oars
rox
oon
oo
Pocono in) oom
oon
pyalue
Paral RY
<oon
i
<n
<n
a
<a
ne
oon
I
5
pr
a
oom
ooo
0
<a
Cigaretiesday,
-0003
0001
"
<0
)
Dray
oon
oon
on
@
YeasWorked
000s
ooo
o
o
a erst oon ons o <n=
| NwAerreog
000085
Pcasosmipoanny
|
Table st
Maliuvnadrtishbrl RPeotgernetsisailoEnxMploadnealtoorfyAVSaTrSisbbyesTOF
{for Antwe2r0p00sniddDeesctSrMvateelEnmcpelPoreoegrPaamricpas,
Co mn |
Paw
oterept
ams
Tor
oon
Production ob ese) ~oon
AnverpDecar
0105
P SE pukeR
om
<o00n
-
0009
Fd
o
oon
6
<a
00%
0
@
J
BMI
0.002
0.004
st
<0!
Cipseesiny
000
oon
o
<a
.
Drink
00s
oor
ws
@
Years Worked
0008
oon
"
o
Tigerdest
aos
oos
o
<n
or
Sing
000086
Tess
|
orMAid ovarD RecgenVEMipEoootnf AseVLTPbnoytPenSt,
che Sues Peron
Parameter
SE
pualue
[i
1a
oes
<a
os
oon
os
2
Pdi oh yesh) oon
-
o
Aner
om
oon
<a
"
om
ons
on
ous
oon
<a
Cimsedty
"oom
om
ons
--
owe
oon
Ves Worked
om
om
0
Tons
ow
ous
<a
Mas R=. 27
w-- w
Pais
. o p o pe " o <a <n os 000087
--_--
Intercept
Pron Production Job (sie) AnwepDecar xe i Cipmreesiny Drikatdy Years Worked f--
R= 27
Nav iog
Table $6 MuliavnadrOsltchRPeogteenstiiaolnEMxopdlenlsoofryAVLaTriabbylesPFOA {or Antw2e0r00nMdeDdeiccaatlurSMuraveeillEamncpeloPyreoegrPaamrticipants,
Pum
SE
puke
1761
0.165
<.0001
00s
ous
n
oo
oon
st
0186
oon
<0
0002
0003
"
oo
oon
<oon
-0007
oon
a0
~0005
ons
5
"0004
oo
1s
01%
oa
<oon
sar
Pa
.
<n
<0
o
<or
2
o
;
<0
<a
os
000088
toes
MalfowAarnesd ROeparedsDPieoonncitdMeElexofEpAorsLgVaPTraEaOpl*Ss1tnsbd,PFyOA
|
S00 tl Suerongram
hme
SE
pale
J
1251
oes
<n
ros
ao
aos
Fron
aos
om
1s
Facion Jo es) oon
oon
EF
Anerecan
os
oon
<oon
ne
002
oon
0
oi
os
ooo
<oon
Cieresty
0007
oon
oon
----
0006
vous
YeasWoked
"aos
oon
n
Traore
om
oon
oot
a
ANdajRt'=i2o6
ectotmepr
PartiaRl
. a <a <a w <a 2 <a <a <a os 000089
Tae ss Muld ia RePO gorneissioEn: xi patofd AVLaTrbse byiTsOR for AneSr30a0ndMDedeicltSMuomtEeroogrFaairs,
| en a ws co Co
Pumeer
SE
p value
nen
196s
om
<n
or
oo
oo
Prodcion Jb sh) 00st
aos
2
| ae
om
oot
BS
a
oon
I~
@
----"
0007
om
woos
Drinks
ont
ons
@
Vers Worked
"0002
oo
"
Tred
oi
oot
<ao0t
Po
Partial B
<a.
<a
o
on
}
pr
<a
os
oRR= 32
000030
oo neers ros Proecon ob sin) AntwepDeca re a Cipresioy Drnstay
Years Worked
Trends
ee Riz. 2
Tae MfooirvArweeORenagrsnedsDPsieooncnMttoMdEextpofaETnoaoatysBVioallipsnnby ,ROS
0 ete Saves Frog
teme
pie
os
ous
<oon
"oon
oars
as
"00s
os
o
0
oo
<r
acer
00s
=
000s
ooo
os
ow
<1
0s
on
M
0.0002
0002
94
aos
oan
5
rSsceotp
Pa . o i <n <a <a
<0
<a 000091
eso Milfot eAptaisOrond DSneocmot idofBTemoporlyaBVcauttsiby,PnFO
caoSmeogera
J
plac
|J
oa0
ores
<omt
ron
"000
aon
7
Podion ibe 0m
aon
"
AnwerDecs
06s
ao
pre
"
I
oo0s
"
p"
~ao0s
oon
2
|--
0008
om
<om
Drinks/day
Vea Worked
0005
0.019
acon
oon
a80
Treat
"oo
oon
2
v3MCsompeany
PartiaBl
. o o " wn wn o
<0
}
<n
<a
Ri=29
at,
000092
Co merce Pros Poa Producion Job esi) AnmerpDecar Ae a Gigaretesiday Drinkslday Years Worked Tiglyerdes
AR=R29= 20 "Nowra log
Table 61 `MolivarfoabeAnRatenwdesrOipthoaennrdPMDoaetdcenaett!iuaorlfaETxoetpallaEnBamitpollrroybyieVaneriPbaabyrlieFcs:iOpaStsa,nd PFOA
2000 Medica Surveillance Progam
ewes
SE
pale
0209
om
<oo01
018
0016
2
[3
003
Ea
~00m0
oon
06
026
00%
<o001
oon
0003
5
-0005
000s
x
0008
oor
<o001
000s
oo
8
00002
oom
5
0016
oan
56
nSeMsCtomapany
Pui R* -
0
o
o
16
<or
<on
.
<on <0 <on
000093
Co
eran Tor Producion ob eso) AverpDecar Ae al Gipsy Drnkatay Years Worked Tigoordest
R'=20
ANGaRIw=2io1g
Tae 2 MulivranbdleORtegcrePsostieonntiMal EoxidoafnTetooltryBVairbiiesnbyTOF
for AntwSe0r00ndMeDdeicctSMualneiEmlploPyreoegrPaamicpans,
rmeer
se
palue
020
0144
<onn
~o0n
oop
=
0084
oo
0257
oom
<omn
oor
oon
ao
0005
oo
i
0008
ooz
<om1
os
oo
Ed
oar
ooz
58
00
oar
rcaosmapar
Partial RY
.
a
6 <or
<or
ks
.
<or
<or
<or
000094
Tee) MaliivnadrOithhieRPeogtreenstsiailonExMpoldaenlatoofrTySVHariabbylePsROS forAntwe5r0p0a0nMdeDdeicaaltSuruMravleeEimlplloPayroengercPaaemricipats,
ame SE
puke
Pros
oot
003
Production ob (eso)
0109
oom
1
AnwerpDecar
os
ooss
o
Are
000s
00s
36
BM
~0005
0009
56
Cigareestiny
~0005
oo
un
|
Drinksiday
0057
| oor
""
Years Worked
~0008
000s
5
Tilyeridest
0204
0061
on
R= 07
Shion
PCoomrpaanty
PwlR
<or <or @
<0
<or
<a
}
<0
<n
000035
jo A MoliosmeerRFeesoanaMgomdionfeTvHFobyarOrrA.
Tn soos ogi
J
Cs
pue
ener
asm
om
wou
oars
oon
5
Sot
om
oars
Avene
os
oom
on
I"
oo
oom
| no
os
ome
5
ny
os
oms
nw
pony
ooss
oz
etn Years Worked
oan om 0.008
0.005
13
on
Ri=. a
Sion
Fcoomp
Parial B
. p pe Pp an <n a "<o1
000096
Table 65 MaltivariaabnledROetghreerssPoitoenntMioaldeElxpolfaTnSatHo?rybVyarPiFabOlSesand PFOA
for Antwe2r0p0a0nMdeDdeiccaatuSrurMvaeliellEamnpceloPyreoegrPaamrticipants,
| tne as wn 0 Parameter
se
pale
PROS
0007
0036
8
PFOA
oois
0029
5
Production Job (yesino)
0096
ost
2s
Anwerp/Decatur
om
0089
os
Ase
0006
0006
3
BMI
-0005
0009
51
Cigaretestday
-0005
0003
n
Drinkslday
0056
0002
a8
Years Worked
-0008
0005
13
Trglyceridest
0200
0062
01
RAG=R0=05 Naural log
FaagMeCdeoanlpu2r1y
.Paria B
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
;
<0
<0
<0
2
Table 66 MalainvdaOitbhleer PRoetesnstiiaol nExMploadnealtoorfyTVSaHribbiyesTOF for Antwe2r0p0a0nMdedDieccsatluSrurMvaeliellEamnpceloPyreoegPaamrticipants,
oo vee
SE
puke
Imereept
-05%
os
10
Tor
001s
oot
4
Production ob yesine)
0097
[
2s
AntweryDecator
m
0088
05
Ae
0006
0006
EY
a
-0005
0009
5
Ciguretiestay
-000s
0003
n
Drinkslday
0056
oo
1
Years Worked
-0008
[es
Triglycerides
0201
0062
oo
Reg "ANdajtuRr}a=l l0o5g
PaCeosmpa1ny
Pek
-
o
<or
o
<or
<ot
<or
;
<ot
<ot
o
000098
Tale 67 forMAalnaitnvdwaeitrshbalrnedPRDoertceeansttiuiarloMEnaxlMpelondEsemtlpolorofyy4Vee+raPbabyreiPcsRipOaSnts,
2000 Medical Surveillance Program
PasoCnoalury
oo
| J.
wae
260
SE
oo
pwe
<on
Pw
.
Pros
-0003
0009
a
<ot
Production Job (yes) -0003
002
51
<0
AntwerpDecsur
oon
oo
o
<n
TM
0003
0002
os
<or
i
0001
0003
<on
Cigaretestiay
00009
00009
2
<a
}
Drinkatday
oo
oor
o
<n
Years Worked
001
000
3s
<n
Thycerides
00s
oor?
<0
R=. 2
fin. -
000099
|
RrEeener
-oo wl Pemmeter SE
value
"
aL
om
Partial R*
ARG'R=.I0=3 01
000100
eens pros won Production 0Geshe) AverDecar ree Bi Cipeetay Dinky Ves Worked
Triglycerides
em Nog AiR =<01
Tew Mo{orlAvOatRsengdesPDiooennctMtodMEaextofpo4o+esbsyVoFrFObSaissindrPsROA
S000 Medel Suen Fog
Parameter
SE
pvalue
26
ooo
coon
"0003
ooo
"
oat
os
5
"ooo
oo
o
oon
oo
"
"000
02
ocr
os
o
ows
oom
2
Er
oon
"
owl
aon
5
-0018
LL
29
ferrit
Partial RY
i pr pr <a on <n <a pr <a <a
<01
000101
Table 10 MualnivdaOrtihbelrePRoeegnrteisaslioEnxpMloandaetloorfy TVa4riabbyleTsOF for Antwe"r2p00a0nMdeDdeiccaatuSruMrvaeliellEamnpceloPyreoegrPaamrticipants,
PuScMlC0ormopra2n1y
| p-- i" w- ero weer
SE
pyalue
Panial B
TOF
00002
0006
9
<0
Production Job (yesno)
0005
00
=
<0
Amwerpecatur
oot0
oon
<0
Ase
0003
[2
0
<0
BMI
0001
[2
o
<0
Cigaretestday
ooo
00009
a
<0
.
Drinksiday
0024
ooiz
o
<0
Years Worked
001
0001
a
<0
Trglyeeridess
-0019
oor
a8
<0
R=03 A"NRaw'a=l<lo0g1
000102
| TS Tae for AndtweersndhDenct MExlpelaEnamtpolroyyVeearPiaesrca S00 Midi Surelnc Program
SR
SE
pvalue
|
erent
I
oome
<a
pros
0008
ome
ProductionJob (ene)
000
009
a
AnwerpDecaur
"om
oom
=
ne
0003
oor
a
0003
om
1
Cpeesiay
oom
oonoe
n
Drnksday
ous
000
56
Years Wake
oom
oon
a
Tigherdes
oo
oot
5
ro
Paral RY
.
<a
<a
a
<or
<a
.
<or
<or
<a
RA=aR%eo
000103
Tab 72 fMourlAinvtnrwdieaOlteaeRreDgPeecstaitoeunrMMEoxdepeaElnmotpfolrFoyyeeVeaP4raiberyscPFaO,A
5500 MedicalSurvPriogream
oo Parameter
SE
pave
|
Intercept
0299
0076
"0001
Pro
0006
0006
at
ProducionJob (eso) 002s
009
i
AnwerpDecatue
017
oo
"
ae
0003
om
a
000
omz
5
Cpmeresdsy
00
00s
xz
Drinks/day
0.006
0010
53
YearsWorked
oo
our
gerd
oo
0014
El
[caotimvpeu
Partial R*
on
<on
a
<or
<or
.
<01
<or <or
Ri=07
"ANdajuRr}a=l
i0og4
000194
Table Ts MalivarisbalndReOgtrheesrsiPoonteMntoidaellEoxfplFarneaetTor4y*bVayriPabFlOeSs and PFOA
for Antwe2r0p0n0dMDeedciactauSruMraelielEamnpeloPyreoegrPaamrticipants,
PeSM0C8om0pa1n2y1
Puameer
|
Intercept
0299
Pros
-0005
PFOA
0006
Production ob (peso)
00s
Anwerpecatur
-000
Ase
0003
BMI
-0003
Cigaetestday
-00009
Drinkslday
0006
|
Years Worked
0002
Triglyeerides
0004
SE
pula
Puri] B
0076
01
-
[
96
<0
[a
=
<or
oo
2
<n
0210
a
0001
o
a
[2
B
<0
00008
7
0
0010
2
<0
0001
)
<o1
oot
mn
<0
RA=G0R7= 04
|
"Natural log
000105
tcp
|
EsCrt Eaonar--
_
_
Parameter
SE
mee
oonm
aeoss
nimi ams wn
pyalue.
Partial R
. on" on
o-a
"Jann Io"n
".
an
| aunnr Coawasn faoe Njs w
Cre
ou
on
on
Twa w ow w
R=. %
AGR'= 04
000106
Table 75 MulivaanrdiObtlheerRPeogtreenstsiialonEMxopdlealnaotforTyHVBaRriabblyesPFOS for Antwe2r0p00anMdedDieccaatluSrurMvaeliellEamnpceloPyreogeraPamr.ticipants,
Pa5gMeConpun12y1
| _ween
PROS
umseems
oSoEn
p<uaolumc
Puri B
-0003
0004
"0
Production ob (yes)
-0006
0010
55
<0
AnwerpDecator
-00%0
oon
<0001
30
I
-0008
0008
50
<0
BMI
-0001
ooo
2
<0
1
Cigaretesiday
-00007
00004
an
<0
;
|
Drinkslday
-0015
000s
00s
on
Years Worked
00002
00007
m
<0
Trglyeerides
0003
0008
as
<0
R= 3s
oc pd
000107
Tbe 76 fMo AimoevdrOay aenRdePDgtrenecsioaoniEeelpoEoTlnHBoVRaPsebaysiPFnOsA
Sooo Mec Sunes gm
I
Pumeter
SE
palue.
|
Intercept
3.589
0041
<.0001
Fron
00
oo
Prcion J ee) "00
aon
Awe
"00s
oon
<n
re
0000s
aooos
"
a
"0001
aon
] pr----
"000
oo
5
Dry
oois
00s
os
Yous Worked
"00002
oon
n
Tete
"002
os
%
Rpio=3r5
|
Natural log.
r[iro
Partial B
" <n FY <a pr pr a pr pr 000108
|
Taben
|
MolifvoarrAinbnldeRreOgrarensdsciDoneiMcoltdeMlExokpfaTEnHtmBoRonytVbeyaPFraOaSihnsntdsPFOA
S00 Nhe Suen gm
_
Parameter
eens
ss09
Pros
"aos
Fron
"a2
Prion esi) 000s
AvepDecae
"aos
ne
"aces
a
"0001
Cipuetetsy
"000
Dri
oois
Yeas Worked
"ome
Tred
"oo
on
Not AGjR}= 34
SE
pvalue
aout
<0
oms
=
aos
"
oon
"
oon
<onon
oooos
a
oon
oot
8
ose
ot
00007
oo
Pasar
Partial R
i
on
=
<n
pr
}
<n on <a <or
000709
Pastor
Ter
|
(aMAoolvta RFeSrsetionniMgemEl oymfTpyHFobEay TnRO,F
Tnen
Parameter
SE
pvalue.
Partial R*
[--
asm
oon
<omn
.
-
om
os
0
Poscimiduh 0m
om
on
sre
om
ons
<a
"
oom
aos
-
en
wa
aon
aon
on
--
oom
oom
M
on
Drekutey
oars
aos
TM
o
------
"oom
oon
"
on
T0 Tiaterr oe"moon 0 aon 7 a
| pSoirig
000110
Taber foMr AanitnwlderiiphsanedRPDoeetcgeaenttsiuiarloMnExlMpeoldaEnemaltpoolfroTyyIeVe*arPbsabyiicePspEaOrSs,
S000 Medical Surveillance Program
vee
SE
erent
129
ooss
pros
0006
0009
Production Job(reso) ~0009
oan
AntwerpDecaur
008
oo
I
0003
oon
ar
~o0m1
oon
Gipsy
ooz
00009
Drinkaty
0008
oon
Years Worked
om
oon
Tages
-oo2
0016
pve
<0
a 5 00s p 5 2 " a 1
R=10
Shir
Faro
PamalR
.
o
<o
0
<n
<n
.
<on
<a
<a
00011
Table 80 Mali`vanadrOitshbelrRPeogtreentsisailonExMpoldaenaltoofryFTVIa*riabbylPesFOA for Antwe"r2p00a0nMdDeedciactauSruMraveliellEamnpceloPyreoegrPaamrticipants,
Pu5cliCioomnpiaanly
Peer
SE
palo
Panial
Inercept
129
oss
<0001
-
PFOA
-0002
0007
mn
0
Production Jb(eo)
-oo12
oo
36
<0
Antwerpecatur
-00m
oo
0006
0
|
re
-0003
0002
3
BMI
-000007
0002
8
<0
Cigaeteslday
00002
00009
0
<0
.
Drinklday
-0008
oon
a
<0
Years Worked
oor
0001
"a
<0
Triglyeeridest
00m
0016
15
<0
-
R= 10
A"NdajtRu'r= l0o8g
000112
Table 81 MalivarsabnldeORtehgerresPsoitoenntMiaoldEexlplofanFaTtIo*rybVyaPriRaObSlesand PFOA
for Antwe2r0p0a0nMdeDdeiccaatuSrurMvaeliellEamnpceloPyreoegrPaamrticipants,
_ Parameter
se
pale
terept
1239
oss
<.0001
Pros
0006
0009
49
PFOA
00002
0008
9%
ProductionJob (yesno)
~0010
oon
%
Anwerpecatur
-00m
oon
007
|
Age
-0003
0002
Ed
BMI
-00001
0002
9%
Cigaretelday
00002
00009
2
Drnkslday
-0008
oon
"
`Years Worked
001
oor
-
Trigleeridest
002
oot6
a
RA=G1R0= 08 Nawal log
Pag5eM1C2o0m0pa1n2y1
Paria B
N
on
<0
<0
06
2
2
;
<0
pr
on
04
I A oenan-- ELIA
|
pePaneer
SoEns
pcaoloen
or
i
mitt
oon
-
Aca po
po
om 1 oo
wr o
TM --
-
om pt
" -
aeries
-
oon om
" "
cen
.Partial o I" o on on
|
Mn AR=G.R1I=0 08
000114
PMaCasmpiang
|
Tables
MulainvdarOiarle PRogtrenetsiailoEnxMploadnesltoof3y V+arbaybcPsFOS
for Antwe2r0p00anMdeDdeicaaltuSruMraelielsEnmcpeloryoegerPaamricipats,
Parameter
se
pase
Paris R*
Inereept
wn
oom
<oo01
.
pros
oot
0007
0
o
Production Job (yes)
oon
oois
o
AntwerpDecatr
009
5 oon
<oo01
o
Are
-o002
ooo
a
<or
Bm
0005
0002
o
Cigaretesiiay
0003
00008
on
o
}
Drinklday
00
0009
os
o
Yeus Worked
00006
001
<or
Trgyerides
002
oon
15
<ot
Ran
| Siniios
000115
een ron rotons) Avena ow pits Dona Yer Wakes
eid
og Ri=13
Ten Nor Aovieee:DRPeeslonpNlkoEdigofe3VaoFbtyoPoFsOA,
esot Pog
Pameter
os
pave
m
om
<a
oats
om
a
ons
oo
a
oi
oa
pr
om
om
ows
om
om
ous
on
om
om
ws
oor
om
n
oon
oan
cirrop
Partial B
<a wn p <a
000116
Intercept
pros PrOA Production ob (yesioc) AntweryDecatur ae Bi Cigarettes Drinkstdy Years Worked Tigyeerides
RAGeEn= 11 "Netra log
Table 85 MultivariaanbdleORtehgerrePssioonnMiodEexlpolafnTa3to*rybyVaPrFiaObSleasnd PFOA
for Antwe2r0p0a0nMdeDdeiccaatuSruMvaelleloEnmcpeloPyreoegPaamrticipants,
rwmee
470
0009 oor oor2 0109 -0001 000s 0003 -008 -00006 oon
SE puke
0073
<.0001
0008
2
0007
0
oot
E
000
<o001
0001
3s
i om
o
00008
oo
0009
0
0001
oo14
[5aMCnosnary
Pail
-
o <or <ot <ot
} <0 <or
|
ner Tor Ss sve ne oi ---- pony Yous Worked geen
R=13
Seog
|
tegeTnesot 008
E EE Tony kotedaStats ,
J om Parameter a SE
<a pvalue
oon
oon
TM
oon
oo
-
RE
oom
com
om
om
oon
oon
a
oars
sour
o
oom
oom
os
"oor
-
%
oon
ao
2
Partial R*
pe po " " on wo
000118
rSMaComrpany
Figure 1. Linear Regression Model of Trigigycerides by PFOA" for Antwerp
Male Employees, 2000 Medical Surveillance Program
=
55
.
5
LC
.
En#] LCieade.
wTidl
.
enh
I.
`Summary of Fit
RSquare
i"
0.029
ws
Analysis of Variance
Source Model
Error C Total
DF_Sum of Squares
1
1.863
204
61.193
205
63.056
Mean Square 1.863
0299
ParameterEstimates
__F Ratio 6.211
Prob>F 0.014
Term Intercept
In PFOA.
Estimate 4.695
0.073
Std Error _t Ratio Probalt] 0042 11143 <.0001
0.029 249 0.014
*natural log
000119
Pag3eMCo11m9p0fan12y1
Figure 2. Linear Regression of Triglycerides by PFOA* for Decatur Male Employees, 2000 Medical Surveillance Program
TM
5
Fi
LElAe.
5
LEN
Ez
-
2 is
z a oo ..
"
SL
is
tat
ERE EE CIC wu
`Summary of Fit
RSquare a.
0.028
-
Analysis of Variance
Source Model Emor
CTotal
DF Sum of Squares Mean Square
1
2.164
2.164
213
73.969
0347
214
76.133
_F Ratio 6.232
Prob>F 0.013
Tem
Intercept In PFOA
*natural log
ParameterEstimates
Estimate Std Error_tRatio Probl
5.052
0041 12227 <0001
0.098
0.039 2.50 0.013
000120
Pag3eM 1C2o0omfp1a2n1y
Figure 3. LinFeeamraRleegrEemspsliooyneeofs,Tr2i0g0ly0ceMreiddiecsa*lbySuPrvFeOiAll"anfcoer APnrtowgerrapmanc: Decatur
7
5
.
"os
ul Wn eaeh
| nlSdo AeNA T | s wr
`Summary of Fit
RSquare
0078
SMooudrecle Error
CTotal Tem Intercept In PFOA
Analysis of Variance
DF 1
Sum of
Sq2u.a5r1e9s
Mean
Sq2u5a1re9 _F
R8.a0t1iQ
95
29.877
0314 Prob>
%
32.39
0.006
Parameter Estimates
Estimate Std Error_t Ratio Probalt| 4690 0081 58.14 <0001 0091 0032 283 0006
*naturallog
000121
Pag3eM C12o1m0pfa1n2y1
Figure 4. LinearERmepglroeyseseiso,no2f0T0r0igMleydciecraildeSsu"rvbeyilPlFanOcAe"PfroorgCroatmtage Grove Male
7
5s
.
" ST
BL FN
gf I o = NETe
"
an
J
15
:
:
n SAT5 AA Tas wn
SummaofrFiyt
RSquare
0.008
In
Source ErMrodoerl
C Total
Analysisof Variance
DF Sum of Squares Mean Square _FRatio
1291
504.245512
00.442512 Pro1.b0>7F6
130
54.704
0302
Tem InItnePrcFeOpAt
ParameterEstimates
Estimate Std Eror_tRatio Probl 50.003222 00.003517 881.0044 <.00300021
*naturallog
000122