Document zdXrO1Z95o9m2bRmKMKKKyvv7
FILE NAME: Asbestos Information Association (AIA)
DATE: 1977 Oct
DOC#: AIA033
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Letter to Lawyer from Dr. Hans W eill, Tulane Univ. RE Asbestos & Lung Cancer Lit Review Findings
*
tu.-.'.,.V/ !i>hr/s.>ox<<>v<:.'ri.<":*,' w
T U LA N a U N ? V S R $ " V )\ K'^'i <.
-.'7 C''U : \X'ir LA ro! i:
Ocths 1S, ^ f :
V, ttleLl 2 . :'- S 1*-,
A: torn57 &t Law
C ad iv eii- er, '.V>c<csharr. i '
Crr* V/aJ. Street Yrt<, N'tf York !,OOOr
i! ta,r YYer.dclLc
,
i ' , ! eareu'/ renew ed
ca ta lo g in g s: cr.ai.irtY: laiaf'-
_ v-rt. -'v
c" Sjt' ? c?:-c^r an a s b e s to * Eioa-lxh
by
I vrh. attem pt*<-3 r o n d e r o a w ith m y iioagnt's n e x -
d J? th* x&ctnai ch ron ology *1** ir tho S ritcrtm e m i t o ;
In to r o r e ia r ic n or m e d i c s g n a t e l e * * . m ' y F - ' c ;
- a c c i o n e s ' * F in a s e b a s ir rrir.d h* t h e s e
.**A y `~f .,
^ g m e r .t a l a n d i is <JT1C0 likftly that o f c .r J ^ o r k r g in chrl d m tg h .
ia v i ribst3Ticiair d ifferen t ri:rpr3ta.t.ios.
'
i
T i r s t ib a rcoootatit to r o c d g a ltn th&t sin.ce l ^ a whon
&* z * t ,u * fa o * * 'w m ad e that c a r c in o m a o 1 ^ S ^ b* t T ' v,Mh a s b e s t o * , the St****** o the e n d e r e c e s u p p o r t *
^ a v ia tio n i o the m ed ical literatu re as grad u ally f - y r f;
t i Vi unt a o n r o x t m n t d y H ,
H i t a r e concerned p n m s n v y ;-- - ;
re co rta o lung c a c e a r fe patier.U who a lso had a s b e sto * * * " - * * '
at a n te a s e D uring this period, ed ito rial com m ent a m ajo. * , ^ 1
^ u r n a U wa* C rtc^ v rt, at t e . in su p p o rt o f Ihao a s s c n a t i - n , a m
v i d , ib* T o v t e o & A m erica n M ed ical A M O * * a o a * ****'-
r e U t e h i o w h ile the B r itis h M ed ica l Jm urm a ix*;TM
the a o s s r o lly " that su c h an a so cia teo n **X 4:Sa*'" a* -'* V.T ~ "
ng a c rim e con tin u ed to be ca*i= g, * * r t t c U r iy as at v / s .u
-
* 4 ; a c m e c a r r e r a that aU te* a lso e a r n e d an e x cess
d W o p r t e o f lung t e ( t ? -- oration ^ c h
been
show n not to b o rreaen t}* Dario* tta s tizt*K.
Y^~~ -'
'
rhrtt r o n c la c e hat the a sso c i^ io n , , a: nr > e s t p o s s ib le !" and e s s e n tia lly c o n s titu te d a su SS* s u iw --
;:uba:::vnt.lv le d 10 fu rth er tn vesagiitlod ..
s PLAINTIFF'S
1v32 EXHIBIT
24 5*.
s: PRODUCED ma AVw'it
item 24.max
Aa~S?TS
. ;:' r ~ "
F r e t 1941 u n i c? ? r o x im c te lr
** * * * r *v l*ws
*- , \ 9 l i t e r a t e a d d r s ts ir .* th * q u e tta o n of * H a s s o c i a l .
evidence suggested th at asoestof.
: , i r S r i , r Po r t a t a t - , . . . 11! * " h ! . W l l c `" f ^
i
::::r "
d so s a n d s e v e r a l r e f e r e n c e s w jr
*A K'a<s l~""_ -
o ,--.,. * . ... * ^ ~ ~ r- * *
' 4 4 4 ~d *ftt>ft*tols f o r ew apxt*4 tio a p u r p o s e s . In W* - * n * t **1?'*
- com pare s w U n e t flu** cancer in w >rs*r Y^S
' < - s" - 3*s -th tv* e j e c t e d n u m b e r in th e g e t t s r i l p o p u la tio n o o r r - .^ ^
ftS b " S w 3 - s,, r
I , - - , , ^ a * tv * , *>* * ^ c * a c '
&uoos'y*
-* "
^ i
o e ^ c i 1 thft <iv^<l?ic~ in fivoY
.^<.u - -
a s su so e e c e d ,. D urucg t 1* ?e-~c<*,,
- 4;
,, .. , . ,,*,, a ~ '3 t th e a s s o c i a t i o n wouxs S till
a i a c s u s s J a s s o c ia tio n w a s alifn tx .; sfc.ons**. - yt
h a v a :x b e c l a s s i f i e d a s `'p o s s i b l e ^
'
'
^ next relevant tim e p erio d w toch have selected is from
194* er.fcil 1 9 3 5 , This p e r i o d b e g a n * M e r iw e & e r ,
c a n c e r of Ch* 1? or U vx* * * * - * a so e sto sis ab t o w .
^ ln ^ H o u s ls the JToriI of the A m erican
U e ^ - n X s o c i t 4 o a a c c e p te d the a s s o c i a t i o n b e tw e e n a s h c a to s is *<t^wsg
^ 4 4 v t i l d o u b t i l y W ow, th* JAMA U the ** w idely * -*
4 4 : : n , a a i e r a c ttid****,i* th is c o u n try , * ^
tTM *;TM 01
i f e u M ! . ad paim onary
ilrm in g the findings of M ^ ^ e r . A i o ^ r o d * - ^
itxd ivid~
d irn e ta d to a n in c re a s e
-o -
^ puiatloil, gam p o r t i n g
,,* is w i t a a o e a t o **
l xtn rr^ fc H ard y and colleag u es published
t;.vo c* a f a 4 4 -4 , 4 ^
i m ention this because the A c x d
4 xr4 T c f M e d ic in e b a n b e e n 'srtdeiy r e a d by p h y s i c i a n s s p e e x a ^ x n ^ ; *-
s s s ^ s a i -
W25 n o w 1'p r o b a b l e '*.
? *.
UJ
Stern 24 max
P80DUC JH - 33
1
,,
A
U S S uatlt tb* R o s e s i, SThs
rt,hs-i^i o,, cou" 3 '' 3
*h* * ^ *eii<. *heinv-es*ti4ga-teua."a.u*sar.. a-v""T ' ` - wtw * * *><<
':.: L V L t c i r e . i * * X * * * * " * * *," * " *
etcrnxpti.l?eTTjace?toujry; ^ i r ^ - o i n a t ^ y* t4ela?touatuteU* ttihc ,r isHkos^geevs-teeWds*gU *S
c ^ c e r ^ tn *>*
Vi n ^ # h o *1* Hsd b e s & w s . A is a ,
S t lS
* * B r i * M ^ icel ^ J ^ J ^ Z ^ S L ci
^ X o *^
SS
% S S t X . *.- .i
s id e r e i 'p rsv 1* c r ''d e ila it e "-
-- " --
Uo io E-h S'rass&* fii tu rai, ta c re ^CvvtKttutixwises ta he sera. d iii.,,aW?f -. e**
- -
*.* attesti* oi whether fee hmg e&Ktt*r risfc -S
os oemuon c o c c e , su-g
, , ;i,c9S oniy rith asbsstos <k*>
p**. Th * ? rte r y *
L f l ^ n e i e m e m igh t he b a.cd <m tw r-
* fc* * */'*
Jh(. vrfw j, Luag e v e ila U e , ^ 0 * * *
attgh Ittsto io g c Msm.aa~o~ * ~ V a A ie s r s o h ic a.til p h y sic io g ie c ric c h ia . My
Stght deoend c= vera! clixtt ' tob t^ t fee le v e i of b e w a 9 *
afe p r t w tfaet -t ^ ^ ^ L v s k io r developfcg i*mg c * a c i*
nec****if? restii., la * deM c*V**
* ,
of 5^ ^ ifcre*vs
^<*be*tc>*i#5<. * H* *o wi s m* r, *thte*?!dfww *; asebestouu t * 5i ^
y
or
yadiogts-phlttSiay aptt&retti-
,.
.
I * * "
a a t f e . tm ? e o d i to lto te i
tc. is c u a s arw of m e se oeam wifch y
1 Y o w i l l eours a p o re d a ts
r to mJ fl~4
, ,,-oCidis c ia r lit a t io v * .r
or *0
-
V/ith kindeai: r i a r d a ,
Sttcerciy y<iur9
f Ti ^rrt c ec: M t. Guy Cebrielaon
Msf, Robert Meranos/
H-tts i'ill<b*D,
PROQUCEO -? ;.? 83
iierrt 24.R5.3X