Document zQMKjOOqJvJQkbmnJyeE32Ken

MEMO TO FILE AIA-20 Ret Asbestos Information Association - Revised Standards Torn*Dougherty, President of the AIA called to report on a meet ing he had on Wednesday, Oct. 15th, with Dr. Dan Boyd and Dr. ' Dwung Kwon in Washington. Boyd is Director of the Standard Development Division of OSHA and Kwon is Senior Project ManagerToxicology, at OSHA. These two men wrote the proposed revised standards and developed them with the help of the AIA. The standards they wrote recommended two fibres and other minor changes from the standard presently in effect. They were as shocked as we were to see the standards returned at one-half fibre1 Bas/d and Kwon told Dougherty that there was pi^eaenrly trffin^nrfntia dissension In <35IUI"Uwci. LliU'TfiwjSroposed standards. Kwon is particular^ distUiUerd- and dbesn' t approve of the action that was taken in any way. They both placed the blame for this new standard entirely on Marshall Miller, Deputy Administrator for OSHA. They say that he personally contacted Selikoff and Shelly Samuels and the three gentlemen prevailed upon Dunlop to sign the standards that were published. Both Boyd and Kwon are determined to have this proposed standard defeated and have made a number of suggestions which the AIA and the industry should be aware of and be guided by as we prepare our case and our posture for the forthcoming hearing. They suggest that we analyze and review all of the literature referenced in the new regulations and pick out all areas where unscientific and erroneous statements were referred to. The Association has assigned Dr. Hans Weill, their medical con sultant, the task of doing this and of putting together a medical panel charged with the responsibility of developing medical information which the Association can utilize. Boyd and Kwon stated that there is no way that anyone can prove tnat two fibres is sate --- ano tnereTs also no wav anyone can prove that a Any"regulation fflUbt be shown to be not only scientifically...be shoOrTTo be technologically and economically.feasible. Kwon strongly suggests'that we get to John Dunlop in some way and show him a well documented economic impact of a half fibre . level He suggests this because Dunlop is economically oriented and does not want to approve any standard that would have a disastrous economic impact on the economy. 01 -02 17872 AIA-20 -2 - Kwon has asked eight (8) contractors to bid on a Government Economic Impact Study. The successful bidder will be given four (4) months to conduct the study. The completed study must be published thirty (30) days prior to a public hearing date. It would, therefore, appear that a public hearing is at least six (6) months away. Kwon stated he felt there was a good chance that the AIA -would be granted a 90-day extension on the Dec. 8th date which was the time when all interested parties were to present their replies and responses to the revised standard. Kwon emphasized that it was very important that industry cooperate with the contractor assigned to make the Government Economic Impact Study and that we should divulge to this con tractor what each of us has already accomplished by way of reducing asbestos fibres in ambient air; what we have spent . to accomplish this; what the effects have been on our operat ing costs, etc.,etc. He warns that if industry does not cooperate with this contractor, they will in all probability report unreliable data to OSHA with obvious disastrous re sults to the industry. . Kwon also warned Dougherty-not to make the mistake the VCM people made. Kwon stated that they destroyed their eredit- 17-"y mv-;-- --* n.n.ivia ; - pnf iTTmti rn fto OSHA,^i.e., they asked for a reduction to 50 parts per million when OSHA had verified factually that some producers were far below this level. The industry also made contradict ory statements, some said they could live with one part per million and others said that the industry could not live with one part per million, etc. Kwon went on to say that our creditability would be destroyed if we, as an industry, stated that we must have five (5) fibres as a standard when he knows that many of us have reached the 2-fibre standard. Kwon recommends we state that we can reach two fibres and that we, as an industry, would like to review this standard in two to three years to see if it was not possible for us to do better. Dougherty got the feeling that Miller is thoroughly disliked by the staff at OSHA. They look forward to the day when he will leave and Morton Com will replace him as the permanent Deputy Secretary for OSSA. Com, apparently, is a sound, scientific man and when he is given the authority, he can and will override Miller if Miller is still around. oil7875 Oi AIA-20 3 Dan Boyd has submitted his resignation from OSHA effective December 15th. He will return to his consulting business which he placed in receivership when he accepted his pre sent position in OSHA. ` Dougherty also met with Roy Steinforth, an international labor representative. They discussed the impact these - regulations might very well have on labor. Dougherty told me that labor was keenly interested in working for a fair standard. Steinforth is willing to arrange a meeting be tween the AIA and other international labor leaders. At such a meeting, we would hope to convince them not to take an adversary position to a reasonable standard and failing this, hopefully prevent Samuels from appearing at the hear ing. He would, unquestionably, be a vociferous adversary to industry. J. G. Hall Oct. 17, 1975 0l-02 1787U