Document zQLZwLYJjR9NqXL2vxV0n0BNR

-ENERGY I December 23,2016 VIA US .MAIL & ELECTRONIC MAIL RMWA12edaa0gmis0lihniCPnianieosgMndttrneocasnCt1yo,1alrDvr0,ta1ChUnAySia2E0A4nv6ve0i,roNnWmental Protection Agency DECW12nlaea0vvas0iihnrdoPinARnegmniitrsnoelMsennyy,talaDvrlkaCPenrti2soa0tDAe4ci6vvt0eiio;nsniuoeAnNgeWncy, Mail Code 6204M ATTN Docket Number: EPA-HQ-OAR-2015-4)500 Re: PAeptiptliioendftoortRheecSotnastiedoerfaIntidoinanoaf t(h8e1CFreodsesraSltaRteegAisitrePro7l4lu50ti4on(OUcpt.d2a6te,2R01u6le))as Dear Administrator McCarthy: BPoRInpoyudelllitreuahantihtiseaaosslnteocttUhotceeaporld,pnmaWotittineenhune(iet"tseiCataoSlSnttrAdoaellPslsyiuRiogponnpUniElfpiciendocseaaarclntgeotfy"laoy)lrrReitpmoquoupflweeaascecatirtssligtttahiehpeenaspetalirbiEnaeiPtdlIiiAonttynodr.ioetahcnfeoae.nlSestcAiatdtrseeicrfoitngfhaeIelnnifedzireinaadatn,ilantC.hgerWuoCnshsiStisSAtet(Pa"StREetaGUAllUiiporsdn"a)tein tIoehnmxeitidhcseesuir(ofrNinennOsatlbxCru)udrelogems,esitEsSasPsitAoactneoisnmAbtrpiuoraddrPgueoedcltelstusoataintohdnneetRhwparuotmlepmeoateshntehoddodcdrouuolrollreogegyanyntfdoesmruebvcissaestlnacionumntliasoa.trlielnyTgshruseebtdasbuttueacdneogtszieaoItlnnliydesiraasesendaacus'osocmnefidpnnaaaitrllremodgotesont 250 N. Cross Pointe Blvd. Evansville, Indiana 47715 Tel: 812.473.0700 Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA Tier 7 ED 002061 00069327-00001 r5fmA2aeri03osrdo%,mu3rqEe0cuPeE3asfAdrt,lGorirtiamnUeynlopgmsbtrteeheeionnsnsesteetiIcbnnfnu1iutdtii8rsdntir%.sagegnenFfaattarsocCrwfetmSuedSrrAuttehhhcPete3eeRir6otb,nibau3ncu5dcocd3grfoegeomtaetovstipneentasrht.Enha31yteP3iEwA,nc0Poga'0Asss0tthNshatecoonahnfvsdeisends,amaeub3ltlbi6erltei%hudtrelyet2fof,tr0ioo2tn1am0ua5k1lsepe5I2nr0ecoodf1ozpfi5aeaoolcnnastwaeecMdteisutmehaCaayoliSssueoAs1mtin,oPsi2NinRsg0ssOn1iUobi7xfnupi1scddea.amga4nntedTeittshosiRasieztouonlnese.2 EmmtrteahhexsPooetaspiAtuddrlUewmeeamd.nllShiiiiannned.itlgggnieSnotiauusonnnnnptoboaitrptythelfsry"emto2srhav0epierist1iesridCo8irrnneepoeetidotuanewi,snrgr"etcer.mdoomdapnl.Wora5pnutdnooehleyecritltlhituwueniaonngatEniisttmPasywtpAheatpitaorthreshtootrEaiiaeddttcvPsoelhieAsleCodotwgl,hareysiaaaw.s.tennuh.id,AmtPynaocemoidowddtdmalerraijunremossngPrusenlcuebnaiodnnstntnigotat(ch,snn"eaatCitritsnhnaPidelnswPsonEn"uitueP)temhewrAfiuEfbnmleheePctare,hAtstiewohv'pfsoefhricldimonycooavhaetllilhotdwrheugeuoanydlsdseiatono,msorlitotaetghyaayepesdpnaenebawdyrs MrwhTtbOuerefaenhiibsfolstieeulrahlrieavclemoditdttnoonreoaoocwavrndofwnaeAeeolmrtdEh.d,lptlihemaEolnaearnrCgPitnnhCOAPsiAi'tPsPbss'fdtsPrarwcmwoammlsmteihiihmaobnoio-cdsiinaCnsrhiet.tttcel",lleriiyr.6awnn"etttSoga7aiiootfspnh"ctnWieencoctCraognhiinttnflteahmiiiddmcnkctuoauiihhatnlcnesealtgttysenhtea,rgtoAllaotytiefhnomcfaeiestipcinsiil-ontteesdriAnu.acoaotmtFnndPirwosiomeltcinnaretipnibanerooomiexianlfssvlantttsithmh-rdee2abaewaptt0vyihmCl1oeeoed8nP,rhfosCPterauah,pe,lslbeaeteltirlpahaPraeenreetn-reomndetPdCmiois-elogSiwycindwisAotteeissaennnPdlrowdotRr-PtifilheEctolUegahaalnxeuttonpegciliudsdaetattta'trnwistitandholenitigenlrkypmlaiseerrn"mlooeiysissvdanciestleettrauioenaluoseniptunnnodttrigcthtttabhcesoebmyeuasalrmeeu$ts.hs5aet Tecgdnurrhoacrermwoecmtnahhttpa.icAanaTsgdlsehlmymei,innobreiarpseqsoteurltlaihiicrtaniiynnoetgnjhau'gaassattraicennaaetsrnxite-afwnpmooehsawisinlcilahbotfeifuEoteePnhlxAeopaCgefmcetPhtnoPeeddd.aeruflTaerlhondeemd'sCPtptoSrhrAeeefsomPinsdRietesewenrUstsA-.piEdgdlanmeticefitincthihasauntsrstalpyitsriooiannmbc,oirmseueatodstreoetdoocverheecavron,engwroesmiellitche 1 The Original CSAPR Phase 2 Budget for Indiana is 46,175 tons. 76 Fed. Reg, at 48,414 (Aug. 8,2011). 2 Indiana's budget in the proposed CSAPR Update Rule was 28,284 tons, and its budget under the final CSAPR Update Rule is 23,303 tons. 3 "Fact Sheet: Key Changes and Improvements: Final CSAPR Update Rule for the 2008 NAAQS" at 4. 45pa6icUnnhrpdiyaoder,raapttctheeotenesRtdrheIIEieudnzenndl.ienci2eit--fegr0sfg.2ehRtyRrhtreemeeIunsnmsnpltpd.ocyeoanhpenssaaese"rrnea,rtdetcoeoettxienCrCcrceieoedozpm,.ma"tMtmimfooBaenerknansusittnshen,,"gdaitEvasAoePtnt.mAh3aa2evst8rtaih.aciatIlaetavsbGealptreahpenaeainntatofirAotsur"gntmchacoaieanntdt,isEophtPrnltaat,Apinhnssome:/dwt/aoweythrvweehetwarimr,v.egeio.t"rddeieseaEletuatPmnogAceape,durr"iets.aCvgoieormnonvwest/sprhueoSantiittiiractpsetyerma/aeAscentn"ieirctirdaPgpllyroeoi-ldmlj"uepcttiotaoiconatn,vsoifid Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA Tier 7 ED 002061 00069327-00002 FMuwInggcdaaa(onnsnosnuiieethnvhdiaaynnaimtidttieaikhcdetunaeirrlhbiselrnnlrgonie,aewyfandaolgattwr,lse.iuonscaooto.,gosyutlmhsunToytfalusliereraddsrht"liacoase)tdaernewtebvpmeleuceshfetnidraogwnoinsasneuyouenirgvwt"owtcnnlehfsetdtsahraeeuori.upoltoterdenrr,loanrmanoseeicostteilnswdciasttj,nadcooenisaotttgonecvpoehennbartett.eucIeliletrtnyoaedhnhntTobsdneioifpebtihrossiosdwupadynetrefanhrrtea,oocEosfnratsismrchugeeP'nheuosadrrcwaoolAmaanseosluramlesct'mueprlnasstgtdun.rtr,tdspaiuIeilitopgcPletswrciisnr-eniMatponofiinsntidoiongvhtrenceanmwleeiarevydldantbloeaoebtethplurigdfdeioaergddeesnyonmvrgine.leoveniereensiwanivTsrthtdagtdisiaehilfecmf.itfrurooiseiatesnierCs.nflan4tllgsnshdotehg6iEoeleyxwua,8bPwrinunmuaabbAergnindnieteumeeilsdgcedtienas.stieenutsirysittsuacTsapnautsinfneunahomMoeAdnkrneantrciereondatnahdtehasymuhsga,aleinaeelsltdi1oerrchfnepieexe,fwensaio2eaisdtinttasc0adtsretotrntosno1yhinaucnMddr7netteiegiiunenaossnaccwieslhcnyoesftuwoiciowmfpnofeno1trfomonig,ptniunnrclte2lvoiinogieincsl0eaeliiwfsyest1nrmniasr7scothaaiuiee,gonnatnttne.irnredoidedwtnaosett,rfo8er FfionralthCeSseArPeRasUonpsd,aWte,hiatteleSatasltlaiosnaprepqliueedsttsotthhaet SEtPaAte uonfdInerdtiaakneaaifpnuobtliacsparowcheoslset.o reconsider the If you have any questions about this petition, please contact Rashid Hallaway at 202-380-5118.*4 4, Table E1P(AAu,g".A2l0lo1w6)a.nce Allocation TSD for the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule Update for the 2008 NAAQS," at Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA Tier 7 ED 002061 00069327-00003