Document ypJe0Lw6M6667OzKevQ2pKKQr

PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT DUP-1301 E. I. ou Pont oc Nemours S Compant CxtMKM Womci CoNiTowerig* OtrwT. N. J. oiou 5t4-*c*r SC*r"yfiT 8x OIVIMIOM S. Nsold, Jr., M.D. - Chaabars Works l. HeCarthy - Madieal Lab - Chaabara W. MeCarlty, Jr. ) la X. Carson ) S. CarInch ) Turn April 3, 1974 CONSTRUCTION DIVISION INGO 2EXSE ASST. DIVISION SATETT ESCZNZEX LOUVXZXS ICTIDING 'J-, w'y ASBESTOS ratu - OKT wall CONSTRUCTION (B.H.A. NEWS 3/28/74) __________ 12 you rafar eo tha capcienad rafaranca, you'll taa wa hava a vhola nau araa of eonearn wish aabastoa. This will aifaec tha Carpanear, Labor, and Palac araSta particularly (US - 173 ms), Ze la aoc llbaly wa will (at an aeoaoalcal aubatlcuca for ehls notarial coo quickly, (It is atill la tha 3-6 eaaes par aquara foot prlea raa|a). Zc la aur intant ta taaporarlly placa this naearlal aaong ehoaa raquirlas asbaataa control procaduraa. If you bora any thoughta on this, or If you Ioot of any activity for aubatltntas, wo will appraclaes your ca--aoca. Apparancly, tha haaard llaa in tha joint es^ouad and its uaa. Wa will aaak aultabla substitutaa whleh should bo available. J. V. MC CAILTT, J*. PIIL9 nDJfZCT KAKAGXX . '3S2 L .' V. Thseshor Safaey Suporlaeaadaat LVTsJaa 0U? 090332* 12103P DU 024709 TIi * m ttuwi i? l 1l.e I < U-r.l * U f w t^W'lon i . ft.rt pulil-fiiton ....... I * i.. !. iT.'t*. \ . * \ . rr-u'-ioj ( Mif> tin. CJv* vt tt -,r m t-r*%r tt.ui tot .rr.tc.iu may l *Uf U* WuiiU ulwmea sv prti*. Uulirfc leir:i Can?! nil A(:;u'C'.Ia FOR T1IE DISTRICT C>- rtuUMWA CIRCUIT No. '(2-1713 Ikiiustulm. Union Dr.r.'.RTUENT, AFUC10, ft il, rLTiTioNtns, y. JAMKS D. HOtVWJ.V, Sr.Cl'.CTARY, Dupactmj.'nt or L\:;o;:, ir-si'oxncrr EsvrtosfitKNTAi. Hryn<.*: Ftwa. Lxc.. inte.i\tnor. On Petition far Tievi \r >! tl-.a Secretary of T-abar's Standard for 1k;io ur to Abesta* Dust Under tha Quupationrl Sorely and Health Act Decided A.jril 15. 1974 Cairn* II. Cnhi ii, with vI.jv.i Zl'iot Ihr tha brief, for potitiar.iv?. Mir* III ! II. Cull entered an apitc.trancc for ixtiiioncr*. vrr on silo lfa.'Cr It. y'.ri-rher. At orncy. IVy.itr.incu! of Jv-tiee, with \thotn Ihar. II. dim Al .(.".'try. lUjittrlnio.it a: Justice. v.t> on tit? Icici. fur pendt-nt. .,f'.:/ I. Levitt, Attorney. I'tvicil St.ti-. incut of L..'j; r, hi Mail Ki.n:i:v'., Altwroo;, bo;>.:r.:owHt of Ju.'tiiv, ar.d `384 OUP 0903329 121040 DU 024710 ? u J -- ** *.J tk.% A 0 *" s * * .. n X <4 :?j 5 %= 1 .S*.y ?? 2 s Ji s *s 5 ** >( (t 3g r; :' * S 3 % 2 V 3 7S S' 8 2 s -3 * u iX "u Sf e 2 i: <3 ?f TJ o .ge oow -Hu <e c *5 Jj M M s ? wn o e. 49)> Gm n jf4wSt <n 5 _____--."n- saJa ** .<* 2 *.; ts:: < i: - 4? , t. 3V- " ;: - *n**;; -.C1i:l < 9 ',, 5 * 1J 1 . r 5 1 ' 2 > J " fi .Tv 3 Xvs | ^ S E a -s sr? 11 i -s 11-3 *2 ? H X 1 J o 3* n Jt < n- ' '* .: ^ c: i<rS Jt is S *! -., is " -tj <* : 1 n u 5- J J r. >j- ji Js * li ;; a 11 " : < 3 S "w f ^5y .<** ** s. o< :j-3 r.: ^ 5 H i! a'-jttpijjJ! t ~ * O '! :: : : >' . ( ri T: * Jt' ~ ** ;; :: > .; t, }; r? ' ' "o ^ !; :! " St <1 121041 DVp 0903330 DU 024711 f5 ; "" r_- 1'2* ,{r: M* A .u1. kJ ^ 3 2 r 4 . :j -<- S 'm ^ i 3m d _.?u*' 9 s:;.*S. s3 3 *** i:^i sa ,* s.* -i.J? !i i e; s CO i o* y* r**Ui <r * *3 l w Ti - ^ V. *Cfl 3VJ -v ? 4o (v4J r.*| w sU '< -j r< **:: '3 n 1 r? o' * . n * e "* ; x l- .: 121042 DU* 0903331 DU 024712 .t w 7 - .* -3 ; |"aj & ^il icIflU] 53 *-* S# ulM: 3a '! !| f5a| LJ 6 j. - *w a**2* - r H i-SSjf* ^ u :i S s* s.15 rs-2 g-g-SJ a. x" a i H * r. k*t. r* ,':; ci ** \ ;j .TJ.: Iss i|j|ir as* If! !ii till ! s 3j ^5-3; r*..I 5n M 25 |-ii* ,y !,U,S> "2 =? &t*-=5; fl "2 f! 1i 623? * 3 ** O fr --m *a'*-)x*j s? **3, i?*l ,. ,ui - il - .: <'. 4*3 si Ww X* IsM o j* - .2 ??-*: J% M< J or: _--i; - DUF 0903332 121043 DU 024713 ~ .r. *; DU 024715 if mu lit!1*! i s iII 3 - 3 2 X1 ? .* *-z* * ;:t S .2 * J 3 -3 :>! ! 11 s|s J .* Iv tJ:*58 5u*f ^ ? a * -a f, 3 DU 024716 mm OOP 0903336 DU 024717 v.lw iS cr lie Fci.-elasy m r r. i: K W v tJnI - wr: Vi ?O, -4 j '* u < s o $ " '> 'i* * a ? ?? - a -- *5 Sg o* Ix - a .i5t 3 $J * * .4 i b o- HH *rUi sZ ^ *X*5e *r: v S? . al JS U) ,, 2O - V --^ '"xl (S " tTi w b Ji 3* w2 ^ oS > * i = ni* 3^: JHi3t.3i s g U * e IS* Is |1 S.5 , go ci 3 ..a vT. a c; - o -5 & s w *! 22 -- *S 3 T . * o V "i c CC2 *a * >. 2 -- '3 H *ws III **2 13 0 3 mil w r; ` o - -t 'V c c . *.' r ^ ; 9 , ' * J *i - *: -<p- z a 'i . i j <1x :i H 4 ) c. .r - -- >. V Z46 .5 Z % ** ifns ir !*U .-'* S' '-U* 3ft : -. J s s 2 s .1 ^ a * ** 3* 2 * ig SSa* -*J,:? kztt,4r?, *2 S 3*j9 ,17 ** X 9 * Sr ^ * & - * - ' K S So * * 5 S'2 " _ 5." T s'ff-3 3 " ? . J S "' =. s ss r eg * -j: i- ^ - j* 2 (d ,i 2 m s-3 -3 . sli-^2s'Z : 1 iin i'i co r.ci'Jiki I::j r.iu .!ra tio a iHi sl-'l 2 2Sc* \k * Vi" `: s^i}S C*T3 S s* wu b w*.i |5*|S -sirtri :- s sh a --- = -B X 5n: n t:f. 2" 'I r: :: ^ M y* yxi *S i>: w*. 1 . > .. -: 5 't :? i|llgff|* g IMS-3 -- -.--3'os/> -J^U<:*g,2 e .s sr;j?25 " '.I " -j x a At ;:< *? - *;.; n .':j^.`* * >r Z" . ; ' '.'; ., j DUP 0903337 121048 DU 024718 5| u i* ViOO .11;: 3 - * *i ^ ii'rf ... j j . --,: v#i ?. v *- <m s . ' mr m f.t: --r`, (J wJ * s S .u S'. ; S |.-*-8 sra.wf lv<: ,*i? ^ S c f . g*.- .,?3 < 8 tC4 * *to Sy5 # o' S39 5. 1. ;S 2i 5* ?t- Wu :: % * - (J 'u & '*5- .' e a* p::i . . * '*-.o '**: 5. ;'*; -; '5j. 2 * . 3* *: rW3 : a* * O ci .. 3 v 3 * ! * e* *i "5 g 2 ^ 4 V~ * :^S fjTt :t'*a. <g*' . ~--i * *i 4<j vli; 5* VSa; 3* 3^:: rf*.f 23-*3 ^M * * .? S e S -2 a v.:i -I * i3 *#* ".....s.j w*H32*SJ~e*.frWic? f2l*-. ~ r lfl s| * rf ?s; :j3*>S |'H|j 3* w JcSCh 3 ?: * * 1 m 'ifs i ' .*** il 'J HALMStt * a w,rr. %# * 5 .m****: 9 ht;i ,r 7,3 w # f: nt*r out 0903338 12Jd49 DU 024719 .1 h c f/i . .; U 2 * 'Hi c ji fe* M--* #> A1 i* ^ *4* ZZz 9**. ^5"f* yi* r jgC -3= #*7: 3 ..1Ig i1w 3T5r%5j ~ Pti 3 * *f 1; 5 5 g 5 ' yj lid v} y :' w * ' *> w ^ V rl t:- 5 r* 5bJ** i* *3* Hr .- fe %1? UiUft(J 2 3 Z 4; iS"? ^, * s, *".f1l Vtc<* fs.tJ*, 2--j *.w=2 r! U *2 I J *: '-> '.s.* -a S-H 2 -<aJ -i a* c '3 > "3 2x g < "y V" !:* r.: ti *; ^ : . : c '*1 * 5 ! * ;> iii *5 *** " u< :.. 9 *. ;: w &/. 3 s i ri * n -sa !Wi2* ? sS-S-W 3 -- y --ti 5'** 'J* u r".-?...j*.;t ycm,-^/jI,.~^*c-re!.r?.1* 'i*' *:J j-o g,,.v^' 9* *4** .*u ?> v A IA >; * vt -j :* `w c 8 - i: ^ *. * / V tS yr*j s *' * s* o * t O '; iD3w * 2 r r % lx1 S-52 %'Z *+ JZ K - mZ z 5 li*u o c 11 23 1 & >; *. ii i Hs!.< lif ^ 2tl <H1 t4f 0 a n mt a*^ '^i-sS -2i! *3 n 3 a Ji -i 11 . = *2 <<* T: U ini 12 " ,, i1s .W -- 3 "* r! M y,,. , S g .... 'Q-.V.`i| - v a - :t a s. ,'A V. C! 5. H 2 :* ' .* " ii ;>-.i :: a 1 3 5 1 "x ~ <i| *4 3 5?. Ua w , H>i * & ;*< % W DVT 0903339 12105B DU 024720 f Hi *3 JS-5 B * :i 2 * 5 5 5 : i: *- a I j ? si* i S jj 5 sj l* J * -b ,, _ -e 5 H* .-la's g 3 g ? Si'f gi? a 5 o as t C -- 'S. * ili.; g ' i5<",3i h "i s a. s = 3 "*! , . . -s t; * * -5 ,j . 3.a * '3 i? ,a*s s 5 i23T .u= 9 n j * n ^. ot: ^^ --7 .r* .* ** o -i ;: >a :* >. *V4 - -1 P9.- v * :: .* " 2 -< A y w T* - 7/ ; i * tj 5* 21 so si* -I 21 i sra * X "o *3 0903*40 oo* J2J05J DU 024721 DUP 0903341 DU 024722 U tn ilo rir.g P.rqutrcutc ih ........i*. . . r i 'vj.* * .' * " '", / *; JS .. i M -*5 , .. , u f *, e .. * -i * - J .* n - ' - i i: ... frtii- r o i z. \ :t r :1 az r* - r *3 x S`.fi 3 . _ r wj * s s ^ * a ri r ? g * E8 j 2 *5 J? ~ | i; H. ii.Hgvl w -ft *' ?* : . v ", ri j> /. j i` 2S 2 S- .a .8 . - o 3 s 'O *' * o oi: 2 * * Z ^ J> * ? iS - C4! a 3.0 . t I: V. ? J - si 3 ii Z "3 h S 5 .2 o >? _ J 3 = = .C *T <i * = s I: * x f .j 1S -;8 ';- `io s -a 5 III?2 - 2;2.s-oO* =3 J'81'Si. 3 a v J I iat tf"3 J~ J5 Jt3 ti- 53 32 S*3 ii '5 S' * ff t til n * .t*.:. ^<* ft 9< C^ J : o 3 a5 - :3^" - =3i: ^ *' diri.t S - *r-*l ~ 2K M ft Jfif3 n = til 2 :i j .'or iliffc r.'itt iiu liiM iie * *ou!l n* ;i cu :.!e oni.o. iubi'.ks lo r dv.-.l-yor* in or.e 1121 .?. a a* 3t e<9 -- g|i ; u > * r *8a ^9 2zi * S .* TJ < ij ..- 3 St 3.* I- t m > .? 2o'./v: .,; gw .. . C u*: .1j a> ta ;u -j u od OUP 0903342 121653 DU 024723 it .....na^iigi,., iimiiBliiii Magiiii., come the minim 1:11 a* well, an ! IKm c. A V> ** *> : ,.j . 'i , *. i: .1 ; V fj ?: j'8* o ~ * ** * .aj * - w ** ` M *> v * ::"l' -' * J.a .iVr- ^ w C :2 r .- j* a 2n mi .2 V ,*'*i 1* ^Kil"jr? .a g <* 2 7j w 5 ^i. H- H -f2f*sstt Va*ajt 2* un5 37 ij.. tss "i IS* i 1?. 4 sf; -*3 = !5 JS ji g | si *s s- s-a 2IS - ill> 5 * ! iix2 2 K -j. it j n G. 3* tf ^ ^ v; CO 2 f* ^c. y*j,\cs " <5 ra li- *w.- r *. 5 M - rli. l* i ::: i w u * S7 "A i%.x : .2 .Si 'S bJ3 < .3 i s.c -i *w: o 4*. r_-i.: *{ 3 - C$*OS -* o 5 -- mV 3 w. S r>4: * 5S{ ti c- 5 u ii <? a .3 s - ?:* Systi f34t.. .2-sj *i?] *w5S ?^ 4a- *. * c ^ U S$\i > >>- <un JVk j _ 1--ss;5e-- j.. t. o: fui "til 2 S it rtbctlM in ih i s ir mar *t remain MabU .si .. J I= wn * 5s. s* ^ ^f;t. %j0i .; Z .S : 'i* *i id J. s&iaf *niJ3 nuS y f*:* J*S * oe. 2;3mw4jI1 T,.:.:: ow <:s;4*: -w 3.-:''8 : T- 4 ^2 . j S: ^ :: r. -o _j *"* **3;..-.i ^u* o ! Si DUV 0903343 r*c1i c> 121954 DU 024724 ^- tt * ifmr e! 1<4* v4. -f-* -r5v5r* ;u:J'* .r, ;r ;*. 2jj 7jv* rri? 'Vr rr .*<:' 13r-^*r5*I?S--* ??* _2*2* , n s~ V- mft 3 95S-- 9C*5 3 da% J ** :i ; ; : `* 3*y*' **SaT- *waSr* y> Vrff r' I s. 5.S .Li.?.r ^*? ~Ur* 'f\.: r*i ?* < ? a c W ' X1 % Vs ra> 9. ^ .*.? -, * .: ~ * i: . :t ?i e .* *3 *>l ;- ^ ^ * > r* .*. v . * V. n r* *'. * ; .* DU? 0903344 121053 DU 024725 i. .. *> y, * ' ' * - y. a <W W -5 S j* / o* * - ) M V- eJ s r - ~ C - ** /} J *j *> -C3 **r. <t*: 2 --s t * ;i s i 3'i fl U & s. X -3 EJ 6 jV wy "* -z . ^ 3 .5? 7. -j O vi ?..:?n. 3W2 1o vr Z^i -A *w1 k: <s j o Mt tut ei C u * c o 8H "1 **A d c*. u s L-tuj .3 .*1, .. Uu rt /:. :n 7* 3? H , i - 3? n <2 r! t < , " -J fc - -d o i .s , 2 a.,S153'^ *21i? * .a n . m ~ n 5 _ : ;* :j V 2 i- `2 *> Z >-- *s t* 3.a o^.; .i2 f?ts s Vawwgobi .S wct. ii. r ?a u . rj :i ! ;g ;3i -i ; si ptT v. ii *- -35 /: : T"! " .5 ^ ;; . 3<_S o*? ; 3 *i ! s. " *. -*i ?' . a r` 2 ';- ^ Jti -5 fi 2 -* ii a u8i -.3 ; i *3 3'i? * i: `* u J k* Ii s ** M ^ u V . k "'" _ -?s jJ r: y. si. 4 ; >' - ^ ..** *'i \i .: i " *'' *3 * ^ r j . r- i ` ** f* st ' ** 'l ' 9 : f "v: ' -I. < : r ;J ' ~ a- -- ft . . : > . ** > ~ *' .< ;; %* *' r. i * * 1: 'J W * > .. i -i . ? . 1 W) OUf 0903345 121056 DU 024726 3 - -3 " .. :: :t : -: . ;; . C* 'J r* r. v >^ii V 5! U'i r: ^ " c ii "> ~ i), > *; s cyw >; 5: .s r. " `j :' e> s _ -'. ^- !"* ^ iM ; 13. :! i$ ^ l/s U ~ .,; v -1 .gr: - ' - -e " H '* ** -* * S tI-IpI It4 "S'Jsl - Sf lS- va2!*;- irtZiViZ'iii* * UX V r- r. y ..I j.': . : y;.':i 7' s- Vi ..-: SnsKt r J 5 ^ -3 .3 ? *5:13*4 v> MS i :S:S - :! _ 3 5 ai 2 -I Hal. s th-3 * X:!;? 'si .L?2-S' 62 >: -J s - . rrils ;: = *1 u- L' / . r ; *V. r ** s.j!2.. w v t: i '-i if H5 4 : - .* DU 024727 Ui " i. ;; a i.* = -- Si i -r = t-. Ti. - . e" - n ji r <1 j X. -- <3 Ti .3 ii i n s -- ?i .W* ^S1 J .Vt 'a 3>` VH4a!*l 3 DUV 0903347 w . I ri J21050 DU 024728 -3 1lp 8 3 = M Sc `t>"~ v5 "i W -3 V " 3c 5 .:i, IS n 'ft , * if * 5 ^j5 * .;| - ^iv: 1ow-j 3l#vW} R g 1.3 .13 2 - 8 g" ^ z~ B 3 s4 -'1C? 4C -oU .?{* i -4 J S3 b fi ? n '*c. ? * DUV 0903348 9 S aw rv i;/ (2 2$ ftfrl * 121059 DU 024729 r ^ M * V VZ 5 rrc*, u ** ^a s * *-- fj c* jo,: \X w * o "J v IJ _5`3 fi Jw .?!- S a ***.--;. >. 55 ~c**f*i 5* V TJ 9 n;it;i Ss 1`ji> 3Jr,,t >. vr< ** 3 -3^ g 2 ':z **J `*s* - {3* is 3 72 * S-3 2- a<v .* j*S^ .7.3 2 : K C : *j :i 3 -O.:. *u"r2" s>"> ,1-~2*^<m.3! ; v 55 -- ii .v V..Z j .< .. ** ' .; o % *t? <4 it Jt ?: - ; *? *M<C# '!* .*? -:t L; !.* 'y*J. . M. 1? ^ I IB .ii* rP f-! .<c21: C3 w 2 no :: -e ^ 5 * o> - " .e ^_"s5 n *}* :i r "S -SM*5* *< ?. :: v .>2j2 w s m :>, Tl n J M * ^ ' Vi 2- u. "<! r?*1* ' *.' ' ' I, i t :! . .J :. :1 ?i. : j >: .* DUP 0903349 121060 DU 024730 / a*rurtan iRail fumun to git tmaioyar of tft *minr4 <tnai># %u tji# mcuon ih*otJfitUy rujr4 ay tftu pining any tiMr m4ieti m* 'araauan rtlatoa to oeeuotuorttl tt* pau/i to uhiwi ftaon )) Mtixctl Cm* cti T>9 mOkiytr tnu: sro a ar matt trivial* at hu coat. otra>w ciimat*- Lam to ttoeiurt ; unium r- aa.ffd or uv* Mninan 2 J*ffiae#mrm Tht tffi8ia>fr iKaJl pfow4t or mat# to taeft ai mj tmoloyaai. wiUtin 3# coiatiatr aayt (i* fonn* hta Jm ampjoymcnt .a u oceuyatian ctao*4 to - irto*n can- ontrauofu uatiui ft*an. a erotora* htfui*a mtdteal miruntuci vrucn mail maiur* u * minimum a cA*t roani* ln*tram *urt#r*tru*rmr la t It Uicftos > a nttcory to alien imittit* auloar ( rtootratory 4iuua. ant pulmonary (uncuon uoto to incluaa faft*4 *lta) eaoacuy FVCi aa4 farcod syiratory vtlwna at 1 aocona 'ITT, .) ij ooaaof *aami*oiiom On ar M* taro January 32. IftJ. aa4 at siait an* nuallr tftarrt/Wf, tvtry myiay*r mail afoviit. or makt nvauiiia cacaarAt* iivt moOicai asamtnauona to m*h of hi* omaioroaa imano to ooctipouana as* 9ooo0 to aJrtoroo concofttracina* of y* Ooat AMfl ftueft annual csnmtnauoo iftati inafuaa. aa a minimum. a chan rntftnocrtM ipoatrnar-antartar la a It tna*aa>. a Mitacy to auet iympta* atoioy of metratary OUaaaa. n&4 pulmonary funouao wot* to rncluoa fortoO nioJ aaoaaity ta4 ftrtt4 aaouttory vaiuma at 2 aaeono <fTt> > >4) rrouaofoa o/ rmflormrw Tht omtiaytr altail pnrtOo. ar oat trul- oio. ontiitA It coionou ton ot/or* or oftor tAa tonmnauon of tmoioymoot of any tmplayaa aotacot in ao occupation oiiiMii4 to itftorac aaocootrouana af icMiui nano a MioaoooiiMao loaiml taaiotnauoo onion anon toamot. ao a muiimiMO. a ehaoc naoniicitocrnm <a*- tortar-anumr 10 s it uta&oa*. a ttatorr to U4t tyatoumatalty of ratotratory otioa-- ano onlionarr funotto* toata to iaciato raroot vuu aatocity ifvei ao4 faroot otmtoay ooiuma u l aoeand $t torrl woiaafiaai. Ko attaot ruftMoUoo It rooiitrot a# any itfw. If aOamta rororoi tftov tnoa U oail(44i hao Ma mauiMa l ao* o--4anat otfli tM paratroon ouftio tita > 44141 fcor4i--lt ararara* nanat. fcooiayara af amyloyooa aaaoiwa4 maww to thio nmtaia anait caoao to it ooioaiiwO woaoy ao ucwtia ioow4l af aft loaft atootcai rtamma* uo4o lloaoroa attoft to rauiaap ay amptoyart far tt aait N nut ti 4ttm. tha aootontt af Uta roa* or4a af tit* *a4*cal oaarotnauafta roaoiraft ay tfua paroonaft ftfti aa safto aootioaio. far uupoauoo a4 ooaaiaa. ta tfto AMiuai ftocratory af tooar tar Oaaupauanot ftafaty ono Mroiui. too OuHtir af MSOftM. to auutaruao Mini* ciitu a*4 *00**1 tartamtonu of *u>ay of Utooit. ana. upon t/ta r*uai af ao un* atayaa or ;onwr ataotom. to Ria Oftrai* atao Afty pAniciaa no contact* a MOtaai aaonuoauan f%auir4 ay Oiia 0Uf 09033S0 121*34 DU 024731 floUco: 7:u* ontnien fa r.U>,cct 'a fotncJ invivion K/ors im'jHf in U'.r ! c'lcvnl k^ppiici* jr l'.S. !/.C, K< r^ri-. L.~ci r,.j t4 notif) t!ic C.'wii. u n::* fo^na) cr.cn in cr^cr t.ial co,cc;;c:i ;nuy be made tcToic <lo !wtmd vclvmcs <70 `0 ;>rc&l TUulrit Sl'L*.tr:i Ciui.vi at Aitj.uv.Iii FOR T1IE DISTRICT CF COLUMRIA CIRCUIT No. r< 2-1713 Industrial Union Depautment, APL-CIO, at .ll, PETITIONERS, v. James D. Hoduson, Secretary, Department or Labor, ussroNDGfr Enyironmi-intai. Erfcnf..-: Fund, Inc., intervenor. On Petition for Review of ike Secretary of Labor's Standard for Exposure to Asbestos Dust Uiular the Ociupntionol Sufety nn<t Health Act Decided April 15, 1374 Georg* II. Cohen, with whom Elliot Bredhoff was on the brief, for petitioners. Michael H. GoUcsman also entered an appearance for petitioners. Walter U. Fleischer, At.ornsy, Department of Justice, with whom Erie. 1). Chat'.in, Attorney, Department u Justice, was on the brief, for respondent. Mudtacl J. Levin, Attorney, United Stairs Department of Labor, Michael Kimmel, Attorney, Department of Justice, and )384 DUP 0903351 DU 024732 DU 024733 o n i: - ^ j w 5ii S y: a -- K* ^ o v i. a a 5 "g" 32 -- 0^0 "l mm* "2 ~__-: c!Tjt CX* >*n 5 3 o-- <o e S2? Pi 2 'if. s 2-S-S 2 S U -J -- - *7: a o 3 CJ > V <: jj * 2 ?{= 3 " o c> yo" e .2 -- JJ "f.* P e. rJoJ 3 - 2.w ST 3 so* <4 --~ _2 --* -= U rt I -" <1 2 '3CJ 1 mj JJS3 1.35 .2 g ? S5 w O r *y " 2 .- o t** 3 I* f->s. aa| 2 is a. c o ti r??.4$ <~i 33 3 " S? 5. ci js v -5 ^ 2=53 c^ c co 3*3 5w P S.T3 y ~ ? o > 5o j3 JS TJS5 H3 cnv on i/i H 41 f4 rp cs > - -e 5 P .5 n -n 2 .2 n Q <J "C w mm. Z<1l o r: * 8| e == 2 <' 3 3J o ii i "a* j! mm --n . O Ocs S S C K V cs o 33 ^ - 3o .2 o\ Mu 2C ,a5 nJs sO-i U -j C = 2s 2 *-- .- S. j=---. g 2 ;; va *5 i; ^ * r: ^ * 5 z. i ./ _-XCoO J55 e: -z 0 C ro. Z;.' 2*= uw 3 ~ *3 O .5 - ^ 'JT X ~ rl ln.5 T S?--^3 *'* <- co *a W yC ^ Ifise ! ,3 - ^ . 1 Si'H 5 ^ ^ ; y .ii 1 - S -3 ii o s 5 P < g-J li rp "(r-V ^ = ii i co^ as . J'sil t- = jj-o W 5 -JO 5 p CO '> f14i-^sTC . a* up o-- ?,, 4foff-5- < O. P. wT O O C9 P. . ^h aa. O --` m X oO *_i o5 M.W. 5S'* >S% =rt 2 seS C cl' (i 3 tnS --TM ewi oJ 3i i2 .3 .2 1 O u> S5 t.-jy: U 5 a. 2 3 s o ^(1 VM 3W Ou !.1 */- "*u3 o m sl 9 d. *5 5O> -ac 4U1 . 5 3 59cZc<^*afo?i. "'*5-=^: ?23v?3-^8oa O 2:f-= y 5fi wi uo 5C 3oil '2 5? ^\n -T3l -s| <+4 JUS Puun-, C 7 30' -J5S Q 2, e. * - s f! !! s ;r " I fS O <: 3 : f*:i u:4$ s 8g o6 15 i 3 ,,s* js|S 3II U -a ^1- 53 a 3d . 2 w 3- fc :* JwS S'Co4lI: *c(31 W <Oo4* " *C,P--#4Jl SC" v*-S'<3 i! m a ft) o = r. V. ? ;* *' | ^il-< .2 I " J B"3h- SU |o4 n3 M2 os .;; go fe;j | fj o ci c2 Is* o ai 3 s~ |cgo J3^|a* -a . j 3 | S': 8 cs g , 3V 3 c a W ::<3-3 frl g.. m.;i d ^__ aT C -J w*g V Q ,,l-2? '' ; s.,:sj ,*' St ^ L" # ' ; "i ;! ',Ot -* rTtkl S . X ?^1 &w: i. o Oi, tl CtfJs9| &c3 Vo oS o f* ow -Mr '3 [O ^ 3= o -o?* Si? *' VI 73 O u. +Vj PI. - ^ r-J "*. 2 l. o Is -- 54 OUP 0903353 DU 024734 DU 024735 *: *1 o ^ ^ <-J . J3 I ss j -j --: ---: ~i -o --rj * s; " ~ t/7 wS ,,7 3 ^ fc- laJis Ci - < cj jg -2 ch?*` W t3 >! s 3 -3 M .2 s ; = 5S - - .a <* ^ (J w 5 O 13 - (rt si ** fc-7 j (V 43 I- 3 o 5 fj 3 /J .* ,w-- s .c4 j; ^c3 j= Q *m a T^ ^w>* *5 .2? <W .S -j7SS ^ o = -3 _ cj;i 3 3! '3 ~ 53 gS,e 5a5 fc* -m c :* -^ -- c " o X53 O CJ O V c.2 ~v - *oi -- ^ c ;i ^4J CO 2 Cl -- .3 - -- u. -- > y -2 *3 G o.^ ^ CO,* OC so' 'e~Z: -v*5l u c: ,, > "* rt 'J5 3S - ^ .s i g > s. JT5-?. *s*e. 5r fOi* C " < . -* " j* n.1 3X 5O. "*=5 o.e 5 sS ,---c: -:=J s ~ -je si E -c bi -oc 3 o js i/f --i < = o'* ^3 6-5 &> e. S 22 = ix -.S - S ~ ~ tJ : 2 - r: isso4n*s :~ u r Sua 2 5 .* " a DU* 0903355 DU 024736 SI >* *.i 2 A -3 ?< - assa^ISJJ J3I** -H o W . *5 o s. " /. ,,: S! O ' ' Z <J ~'j C " - ~ 'Si L - c y -f. -: = s |g|u-P= >: -2 5^5 O < C= li ds | =13 ? .2 y r-. -a | Jw P:J-3 *5 II g >*5 * 6 ..u5 Zt ^ = o ^>* 2 we rt +* 0 = 0 o^ * 3-s 3 ,.2^ s-s-s = 3 * ^ | a -3 s -3 a* > C 2 o4--a OU? 090 3 3S7 DU 024738 f K Li * J O r *r -->a <4 2.3 * - 2s . i*. o til ,lV-!~'" ** ' 'n. - *1 . ~2 r: o o 4> W r - " a~ -* j /> S -1 -* => a i' = tO h' = - = *3 fJ ' .z ig ~ ? o <M i: Jj o o </> n !!S"5 p fi'PgpS tn 3 * ` 60 O) to 9 pM f co * m *> ^ :: o O' 0 a * s c< I'=^11^0 = = -- <: V., c -- v *C C- o --2 . l-\.Y1 " -5 M 5 '* .d ^2 S o F - 2 Tw .El ^ Yj 25.5.^ -* H` r*. v c- *. o - S. Si ~ H </t O .^, c - C5 - Ci <* - rs s, ^ '2 2 "j|i r 9 = 5 ij ^ S " :*t*z Jw J S | a 2 3 -rii 5 ^ \ H c: .% .S 3 J > ^ MS . -Cm* AO J/* m* j t/ o c/j ^ >. O j, ^ oM -J 5 3 n 1: w M2 i 3 , * - 2 u o :> 'rt u r,o g CW .-- -2 s* -"2* wo 2 C/J u oc 12 fi O Ji?". _.* ! yfi ^ r-. J o w~ ?; =2 r: o ti Sf -- 0--> crS.-.? *'s -- .1 4V I ra= 3 II 11 > 2 .2 2 ;j S ^ -- Z V <J J} ;- 2-- o CJ M >423 c > fJ: Jft ^ .; o -o & 4 -1 Js ' SV5sitfs \X. *>~7 a35 aM.3 ?S' a;'s * 5 3 R - "'"Ssis sgC-Sf . S ja ^ o S .g<?4jf3.i ^. rs -- > * o* * <i M W m 'I OUF 0903358 DU 024739 to w hether the S'cc.-otary may tal.e uoi'.oai c tio r.s in to account. - H= 352 ih a 2 -5 a ,pc5 p~ ---f5l o--CO . E ) = - w ?3 v 3 w .2 J2 im m -* e O *r*t .7Pi .3 ^ ^-- '* o^- S' --" w -29; -woS--2C>J.-S---S-fiO*M 5 g j5 5 c lire-5? - -I 2 2 3 3 " S 5 S s ..B L- S? 3 .3 55?1, "= ii "3 wo 2 a 2- = S ^ j3z > -- r* t; '5 *C ** <;a * j ^ 2 8^.2 h 13 - .a 25^ F rie n d ly concluded his ru m in a tio n s in -4ssoi.u h ts iric a w ith an expression o f d o u b t as to .5p ps Or; gy t; S *8 g <8 H o H2 - - lj *S tu_ 123 *_. Es i -a ij gin v4r cj >% - S aw9 *"5 ^3 23 <S ot: v XJ vHs 2 5r* 5{" i| s s s 5L * S d * 2 > js e O .t5A? a %a g 2 U Vi .%..> . i ,cof ?~t* _e a-? 2 ^ 31 O > Is5 < .o o - ti.S ,. S5; >.! <J o ta 2 .w ail^ g Ss g o ,,' H "l? 3 r' s? ; 3wg "S -u <n Sj?j 2oo jCe~$T! "i PS ' g 3 =6C_ t .S U 'Q< lf_i o ; 3 g O j *3 ,*P M".. (Si o*> OH u - r. wa ii -A 2 4* - * .3 . . o<3 %.,,.* .' . J ii -o CJ J: . .i DUP 0903359 DU 024740 DU 024741 S3*I -rj o C ti 2* ^ -j ^ a- 'J3 3 s s A2 23 W^ <** `Xj O .X S .2 S O 'S c tsrs c; si rz CJ 3 2 w '3 3 j= 1 B. _ s 5VI V^ 535 y. ;> .rJ ii a -X o <7M^ C1! *.' j CJ i- s * -- - <J .i ~ ir: ui jf-c u o W '3 e Ci 3* al a ^e 25.*.2^ x: o <: `s r tm -- *o y ? c ,c Wo i* 1*9 -4 li 5 Z 4 Ji . 7? V r | % .8 S im S* rvjfli -3 c/1 .S J `5 C4 3 j 45 . ? H ,,% |I 2 ii 2 a 5 < :. O 6 .-or K2 w `J -- *C. *. w - O \J < '- v -i -- .ri - n -J d a a ;1 -* - r: 2- 'C- t-M- ' ,->: t<-i> V * .- .r; o v u % ?"* ?. j* .? ^ - $; ? \ - - 2 '"* t-3 :i U 5* *a J' ^ 3 ^ 2 i.. ^ o/ j-:i7i3i 5--r.' _3* -c 3 :; 5 "r " ' Txt H-- |ii " . ::i I ? ir^ g-i- 3n * jj -. 5 t: - >o tOg w,--*1 <y ^ ;"-; w 7; 'J2 3. 2 * ~ S -.* u ,- o *j ?* ks*: ^o i n ?; J #*' r? "^ ^ S 8 "5 ' U S ~ r " -.22?^ g c> $ ^ r~ 5cjsss 7 * * .jj 5 ^ 2 '?." ~ - s a -S w *ri|E5a e.= r| s 3C :o >55 o O /; i* ;1 1-3 4-w j -- aa SI?js -**2 jj g=ii - -*3 t ^ s ? s Z i$ c /J-lsl O O ~ `-* ^ sSa .5 o-:* 5~ U 401 W ls| g is .2 A i. jT:3 -- ?ua s S *3 a s > Joc H *<ac *3 u a *u ?-* c-* , 3-- >i* ?! a H ,, ' '-' ' = ,, -: -C <- (j I 8-3-5 ^3 a *cn -a* ^ <:2*^ S_2 " * fcJ *; -a a Sir K i Mr u 4 o 13o * c H <; t X o *M U > : -- <J t*l s rj I J .ri 0 vo 3 > u 3 e 3 u 1 1 <4 ga S 3 > `2 ^ 12 Is !a >.i.-<ao. Ua JnS H '?i J o >7j* u. 1 to --vi o ;r."* r: 'J *4 (r* J '! < DU? 0903361 DU 024742 ,0 Cl u V, A - "3 n .* _: ~ o ^ J vj o r*. j -- c ot* - t: 'Ci J 1 O - -C - O c y cl ' 2 >* - -,- ^ .2 .: -- /* V: -- r-j 3 -i?-' i2 7 ~ JR ~7i " ~ <> 4; _ R v c; o ;?- 5 " ^ * " - .r:. B r *5 -- *3 H O J >* 5 - 2 ' *= S *o to C. a--.S (/) U 23fH 25 <Z -3 Z v2 .5 s c s. .t * s 1Il!l jlS = 5 h < CO f* -2 '; .. - - * s ~3 C c 7: c> .5 ... Sol. J 2 - J jj - 'r ~ 2 ~ jR *-- --- a .tr u>... * c/J ^; -- 32. ?O. y 0 3 y 'J r tr ' ** c Zi ^ u ?* <-- c V .7 C` -T> Jf . >- _: - ^ ^ -- . - ^ .. ..-". f .i cc: 3o o< s?J' *3 '"n" %i *r* -"*.a3 -<*3 i, J is xt.= .,-4 H 3-Z* , o *v s- A = O- ~- ^\* a^aa ?i <, rs -3 o o>* ^ . i. 5 3 x o 3 ^ u2 3 S.> *.?> i. 5n i! r.. = r2t ^2l: f|-2 s- ^s ; a: 0 ' c<a/: --!- S: 5S 3 * u -- 4- .5 } t>KWO ~ "E - Sof -c o Si U 5 m n Sofc=c3H His B^o2'cc i:t = || *-- "-r - s 4 -s 3 - ? . t: 2 m * s " -j-u. i a", i';? -S5;;:5og . yW c ia eq--5?..2 r~ j *`.s * - i:f w S-* :52Crc*^"=i'o-s <5r~*=3-^<^_<~Jle!B3*ai"5`5535*=^3=ojc-<v=_c:'r4^^v'J5o*.c'=Z>2Er2.-2Sc-Z5 5<T"VCS9r2i uf--Ki..*f(tl.iS-y<go-g52 '<-,,Sdc7-.S e^'w5 v^39<3j2 wou*._3 "5-i c, x pi 5 a 0I Jt* . j-. y-d S3 2It 3 *1 H= a'fr a io c *-* 3 3? fs C744 *T3 jO ue .? 2 T) iS u;. a cs) i d "'3 .d-: i- .; O DUP 0903362 DU 024743 Jia,E.fei2i .... ro O j-t ) .. is {: ij Z 'ft "Z . rs -. ^ o^ >- w ;j / y w /' r; j J r. c : 3 SjT o 2^ fl o ^ . <y 3 " = {//J} "oC o-. . 2 g ' = r. s o?*'. n 5 ! - ~ - -r ius&; -j- S 2 O w r s- - <A -- *i o > 3 <" a ' *n-:i s 3 - i2OO fcU>- .S4> _*5_5 - 5<uJ J2\Aj C U- 2 CfvS tJ-l ^O- ->> *fl * J? 1| flu SI V *2 *s * & ss J *0 fl *fl. el l! r* *. .? * ;* '.'. ' *'z . j o'; z . *3 % .!; ^ w ,, j -.: ,k. -. o V: o j* J ^ -f O s - -- .. c /i -a o .11 ^ lligg to .fl w Ss .-- 5 ^ -- , 3 i/) 2 --S c P s *J fl 3 O -- *2 >. 2 s ? 3^ *.p2 u -= e o .-- wCJ 3 Ji ? o t, ., "B;-; S3 a w C P5 ^ 2 *3 3 U- O s'o = a 2 os, <y - *' i 0> a< -5 2 .2 "3 2 ti a >e Jl y o' 35 5 ^ t: .u s J2* 5 "2fr-S -s;: J `id Z H <-- 1.-0,, J5J} a .. ri c S. ':-o e. II ??! c s ti 2S* s .5 wa= 238 o -- '# * o c2<22o2"j5S"_| O = *" t! "3 2 S o 2 e i'.S e "SSI fl l -- ^ __ 3 : :J " 'J *T 12-2 2;s ie s;c S zs <*a '" -- o *--* 'C ' `o ^ o * Z ?h i5 ? = g o fj -A u ^ > . - c ^ k u- co IT js r . Hcj c , 2,, ='; a -r2. rii-v: o --^-- n 2 = S !l^'5 (5- .-- *rJt o2 >> -- u *22 s " &1 2 3 .--:*: *;uj * ! ;': :r*j t1T; -c,uf-*,j 2.`J /! 3 a* Jo ;;.`Jd ^ "* - o ... #" " r.2 ;; 2 <S -f3t jr: vl * j j ' :: ^':.* :s :I . # '5 .i.` M 1U * co OUP 09033S3 DU 024744 tMi o w 9 <j v <j *fS H r O 'c;*j S w r c; ?: w u -- CM 3 = f5 --' :t ~ o. BZ E? 2 r-s Ji - 2. c-- -* u ?: *c . y UWy 04 .2 y ri 5? * S .2 g. e. g O i js 3 a s-gC4 vJ .- ' <n -- 5> -2 -- i!: *o4 (/) c *43 2ii a n o| s = Jfi j>S.g 5 >. s 2* f SV, <y S *r? r5ei rss 2*5- aM 2 *4 o CM 11S-2 i.2 5 SI 5 5 2.2 "-S fl3 6 *n ^3 fl e-s c iii 3 fi* 3` I ipi M *2 o 3 S|g 1 g j* isi '1 |5gs 111 23 u3 ww ! rtVJ ojs e '> -J -j* s-- : ;i ** 44 JH.; 7; O ^ cn s .% 4 .rf I- DU* 0903364 DU 024745 DU 024746 ?M / o-- It., o *v ^p 1/1 a 3s os H .S J "5* s. = 5 3 e.i '- S.S 2 Hi !- -- fl -- '> b ,-- o u,o j >, - .i >> Tt - rz *o ,* 2 ?i =*i->. 3rtxZ o* -3i-* "C C) * ~ * P 3 3 Q :.. w< j tj - - 5a .>. -s3 2 3-i 'i c: *, fjl-C - ri , cwj 7 :* v 2 OA ^"J S ", * sa `3 . s<\> CZ/ , _> vd " V. O : J = s t. z fl o `. i 2 ? :* 5 !r uo ; : *3 Sr i. S "? S? = o_ ^ ^ or^ .2 *3 ' ** ' q /. - 3 - /J0 --- a -- c c - 7: 2 2 r* q i V 7j ^ ^ >i J 4| ^ O cj - o " - :; _ ^.-"2 !" w .34 I-s. Ie:` 5S *3 * o HZ - -22 * - ^ - CJ ov >U J>3. J T3 s-Mrj^-s (VA). 2 8 - -Mc_ *j32Jj -2 8 ^ai S ||3 o as 2 ! 5 .2 fc* : <! 3 O Si 3 - *5 <3 r. "h a w- s o >. "OS 2 2 i s I 1 3 'IIS-Q *2 5 *i -fl . S i *3 ?b<*! TU. I,t* ----*.< ^ s < S u- 5 3i/i --=6; .2 1 H a Ja 88^ *3 5 t; o ;w 3, 3. V G tfl C. CJ o c y s < S ^3 C - ; s r: 2 .2--2. o sX*; o 2 ^32!! v ^.2J JJ2- ,wHV ^w 9". 5 4. -">-- .^et f_- :| g a ?j3j (h w r3 g ?- 3C2 3 a ir. Z ii j c .3J y 7^3 O `3 3 31 n S b si 5.2 5 = 3 Crti " r2 O o n. ;> -3 llilfi jsg^ fill!* s.s as5s o ^ n.~ <= a tt-* -* o u Si -r3i S2 5'-* '^Si 0.1^4 o OJ ;i i5 !'!**, 'i J; u iu* S e"S i s -sTf S-S 3 DUP 0903366 DU 024747 11 ,, . c/) 3 a <3 u. tcs .. n i. - 3 I 7, o 2 3 . 73 _n o 2 w JK S o ^ to u r5, oo V > n c<<<' s -* u* jwo; ji o O' S-' ei- .2 -5 os- --"7 ..sZ- ^ g -3 5 * S^ 0w 2 'g v <3 > rt - u _N r: " 3 ?? =i ~ J .. > ^ :j ^ -rj -- w ^ 5 2 g~ M u t: w > 2 ii *} Zj. >' Ju3 C^ p *S : il 5 w f 5 ~j ^ * il 2 .2 3ji 0 'J ~ r* Trt* ; _ ju2 - T: n . - .2 .5 3~ = *J - o :: ,-- : *3 S c 3 --O ti *" <y " .f* 5* JJ *S 5 g-t j$ 2 < CQ c4 v "2 32 U1 ^ 3 ili S3 6-*3 R >. ^ a :; ~ < * 3 = 3 2*3 ~ 50 = -K J3 ic-gO ' 2 . ".s 5 3 " <5aif?3^='sfit*nO =3c3l o S ;. JT* eM ." ws Oc z a TX* *3T ~r * e -- '* 5fi UK S _j c is fc 2 Oo SS 3. o a M s'= i 5 r '" ijj* li i- .id t! V. t* n^ xfc:- cP? 2ft o eGM 44 SO t* ci w* s 33 >. u` ^ - a-g ^.a >. "5 5 .2 s 9 >:1*0|Srj ?1|3 Ss3- 'aSia l-_-lcSi oV --S S3 O o 5^ `ww 52*. * ^ AC *_* bk _2 .m> 15 .. , a- f5t (I J3 >, --" -3t**I!! 3CJ=v3Z 22v ?o? $* is .2 & \n 3 .j5 2 *!aW----.-*<rC1v; s3ofw3t M f3 tf SW n J3 2 ft * B 5 ~ n 8 g && > a (I';Cnii),;5, 5Js ^2l(.3-l ?"v. rr j .: H.O s - s5 .5 -5 * h Ti?Z > O tfl >3 '3 .5 II "= -a .. S 2 ,;i 2 3 c> >2 a i' -- = ~ S '2 CO .eJ . 3! 1 1ft -.10 3 t ,-- S a ii 'S s ^C ' u ":-'=i .3 OOP 0903367 DU 024748 " -v u 4- /~ *! JT: ^' -r; 4 --> "* ^ o n *y <3 ^ V. ^fH3,* .-i-*3-.. ,2 "1 a oft 7i 3 "n? J -- i; -7 o X *- <y t* U) .3 .3 .a n ** . > a r '' -5 ,, S. o^ s-* j ^a -? > ^ -R^ 35 , s * g JH su y 5 *= c cu^.3 3^ *s 2 -2. Soo. r -- 4.1 o O 51 a s. C O a. Z CJ '--XORrt TJ o j2 y il 1 * <at5t.'O4 2 .?. tn O "cw; 52 5g M2 a<* 9 *"1 8 -*7 ou y--" og ^ | w w "C3/ C2J 2?TI '-3 ? **5 0 fi " 1*3 1o. -- m3 .5 .5 </} oC *0 - ~ *2 ays s '3 -- ^ JSK J "3 f-1 c 5 "S' >. 2 S' DUP 0903368 DU 024749 jgfcaiigiiBlfciiiall employers,'1 23 U.S.C. { 6 iV ( c l|, ti e See;'" to require retention o f only record.- J'ror.i t cau*ea and prevention of occupational accidanU and iMeesice. 2!) U.S.C. J 6 5 7 (c )(1 ). O " f ' ff*i uu no# s '* s7. & u* 2 aJ o n <; 4. -j .c t3 *- ej ~n o <--: .*>*. ^ ^ o <r eyt ? o . '* Z m Uo o U w i* t> V3 ... y J2 O V) O , *-*-fc^1cooas !.es2t!wO73- J~"Soc,co*5t*3--sC ,S0-~C^o?2S?'ii-2~sl 3J?-s3 2rf s >* a .5 w9O ?*> CES SB '3 I* it S* >*"C ^ 2 coO"> -- : ? 'c z - y - .o> ~> ^s" --*TS y ^ o t? rt `5 r. 3 ^ P ..=.*. -O o-J .a s. 2 ^ s ? " >3?: C g *;; Z'js> a -5 o6 H > c a : 5 ^ V ca A .d Sh|u m .22 tej -a2. .5 S' i e =. a - . i JS j2 CJ i* 4 it--ao r:t ^55=2 a lei-3 S-3 4i ySS Z5m +2 Sm ii^ sjs s / V7 u .i >?! > 2s 5eo -^f ^ *1a g *e >. .J. c 3flane-n 3 f 8 o = -3 -s S-shia tS"."sC .5 IP* a si sslii* I I 3 G rl "8 aP - PsP! S 2 5^71 g 9 "jf M * *> A- 3 gJSs 1-IiliJ t- W _ l3-8 SB * Ts. s> N ^a fltsIM3 a'llSS .- S a1 -oS -V3* 3 -3 - >M ?s liilJtfl tl - 'l ' fl % t; s 2 i- 45g S 4 *5> *> tj .% " :: v.* -- *rt vs *% ;j :.: s; L-'ii 2 'i; B.i 1.1 g"3 a =*. cf o^g go'2^ C2 esi a 0 5* <ia ao rjI >'. si ^Sti III *K* <o* Hrt gsj vi O o* <*j w ... :P trW. r- . DU? 0903369 DU 024750 O* a w </ -* y <: *1 fJ ?: ~ -2 Z<aJi ~ S2 3 .3 - 3 r* m ? * ? 5 fJ U g e js -- 14 > u / c w ^ si m bj CJ *- H GQ '*4 .H3 cj s 5 fj _ r* 0 35 % *c 2^ "3 <1 iOn 3 Su' 2 - 1'% 0u c? *-- e 13 77 rt wC '3a* 2 0 13 rt _ -i /j v: ^ - r; kJ CzJ 2CJ wo /; (oJ oo" ,y- CCOi Si 2. 5 -- 2 s'3 ,,: :^ni ^ <1 o* ^ -^ cl c?> u ssS1 -n 'Z. ai,, /* ViA % w* 3 ^ -- e <5 Ws1 Mo S*2 *f cft 2 U (/" O -- o -S 2 m a p 21 -3 S 32u SS '3 . .*. o -- i / 5 a,_; =' - $ - ;: 3 i: " o " a r; " :H -J U A r* O s: ;VI V) - Ji 5 o= ?i .5 2" a c: * - s 4 .* I jr t_: ?z s e - 2 :* 5 H U ^ r' S 3 sw -U :~ 7, =: rt ag >:s -=2 r- o* j S.-J M *< -:j J' i Ty ~J'd -ij - S i S ? u j. 3 ; a S O t2 A e--5 *r ii " 3 .ii^ t: 7 .. ^uu-j^Suet iial 3.S o : *J 0 L`x S3 .;.*:? .r. ,r,. r* - "r -3 "c? . .4, ft* u 2 -j o =?, 53 -w jv fI /. -<j vi .* 2 T3 cs <A *2 3 -j S S c i" r. 7* w - *2 ^ 0 -j 55 .2 w* Si k2 art d> a <C^d4 rj a. ? -< co 3 3 *> 3' 5 O O a 3 +sr 3 U2 -< . M SI I DUf 0903370 DU 024751 s wiiiBgigatg; mm DU 024752