Document xjNRnYKRK5k76En0XdRyrYwog
yy^fl -- THuiiN
Sun., March 22# 1911
0y . VT- '
. 1
' tf :Vr? t
By-JEANNINE GOTTMAN; ;
; v.-r
.. . . Sun Staff Writer
tl.
What is the impact of PCB locally?
i'
r Followiiig is a breakdown of the major utilities and
industries in San Bernardino County that Use or have
found the presence of polychlorinated biphenyls in
their'machinery and equipment. 1. :1 < tv
Both types of eqiilpment generate heat and PCB haphazardly before 1979. No one. thought the.spills
cooling oils have been used to guard against fires and ;were anymore dangerous than an oil spill add that's
explosions. - V
, ; : ' 'how we treated them1. We cleahed them/dp/arid
/ Edison also uses PCBs in a large number of capaci threw tfffithe, soiled Tags in the trash,;\!-
tors in 17 jfower substations. In the county's central ; "PCBs have been .used a long time -- stacethe
district, which includes San Bernardino, Grand Ter 1930s. It's not like it's something that all Of a sudden
race, Fontana, Rialto and Bloomington, , . / . . imagically appeared."'' ,
'' . pW&Z
Falkher added thaf to his lqiowledge no Sbtitbefrii
, The list, however, is incomplete. The exact amount of PCBs present in this county is impossible to gauge because the chemical has been so widely used. , Despite the 1979 manufacturing ban on
Each capacitor averages about three gallons of
pure PCB liquid, which contains an average of about
500,000 parts-per-million (ppm) of the banned
chemical.
' 7 '.7 " ' ....
j . -
California Edison worker has ever had adverse he^ 'a!* lth* " p- -r-o,lbi 'lem sy* fr/'o, **mJ ?ex. p<o-s-u/r* e,n t o- PCC,B,. - ~ .-v*.
! '
Jf.` 7>f .! v-'-fjv
'* .*> jf.^J `` !
polychlorinated biphenyls, the toxic substance is still No spills have occurred this year and only one spill
'S4ti^rih! ddkinrtiiai.'CSKr, ^
found to some degree in nearly every home, business was reported last year. That incident took place in ' Although Southern California's largest natural gas
and office building.'.
..
Fontana in October and was handled' "quickly.and' utihty does not directly Use PCB, "trace amounts"
In fact, PCBs are virtually inescapable since they efficiently. No one was exposed to the PCB and no were recently found In five locations along its 37#0d'
are present wherever electricity Is generated, stored : health problems were reported," Falkner said. / miles of pipeline.
. ..
/ .../
. and/or used. This can encompass everything from
1 The PCS was discovered in routine tests made Feb.
huge electrical transformers and capacitors to tele The spill occurred behind the Stater Bros. Market 25 and two of die. five locations are in the North
vision sets, microwave Ovens and fluorescent lights. on San Bernardino Avenue and Sierra Way and was Needles area where the highest concentrations of
:-T ,55/' v. ----'i
.....
,
found when "an employee patroling the lines spotted PCBs were found, said San Bernardino district man
the leak. We, went out and cleaned it up, dug out the ager Bay Sharp.
....
... ",
-.Soatbern CaUfonUa Edison Co.
/ soil and replaced the capacitor with; one containing The PCB concentrations were more than 500 ppm,
. The county's chief utUity uses PCBs in 153 of the a.non-PCB solution," Falkner said.
preliminary tests showed. Sharp said; PCB also was'
electrical capacitors atop telephone poles in the city .Currently, all Edison electrical equipment contain found at the company's Hollywood base station, its
of San Bernardino. It does not use PCBs in its ing PCB oils Is marked with yellow warning tags. Beverly fflH'8 base station and on one of its utility/
transformers, said Edison's information officer Joe New equipment carries blue stickers showing it trucks that collects pipeline "drips," as the sedlmetit
Falkner. Figures for other cities were unavailable, contains non-PCB fluids.
:
. .. . containing the PCB Is called. . ... /
-m?./
Edison officials said the number of PCB-capacitors in "We follow very specific guidelines and pro v "After checking at 27 locations, we found that five
San Bernardino "is comparable to other cities of its cedures for handling spills in accordance with the areas contained trace amounts of PCBs," Sharp said.
< Capacitors ordinarily look Uke large grey or white suitcases and transformers resemble big grey cans.
And their functions are quite different. Capacitors store energy until needed. Transformers take "the
raw electricity off the (utility! line and `transform' it down to a voltage that is usable in your home, usually 110 (volts)," Falkner said.
EPA (Environmental Protection Agency),'' Falkner said. "The workers wear special protective clothing and full gas masks, gloves and plastic overshoes. The liquid from the spill is removed and placed in steel barrels along with any of the soil that is con taminated and any rags used to wipe it up."
It wasn't always that way, Falkner added. "Quite honestly, we cleaned up PCB spills rather
"We found the chemical in the drips, which are like
traps used in sinks."
,
; :
Since PCBs are heavier than water, the compound
filtered out of the gas as it moved along the pipeline
and collected in the drips."There's no clanger of PCB
entering anyone's house, through their stove or
anything like that The PCB couldn't possibly get that
far," Sharp said. '
PCB-ARCH-EXT0376232
"To our knowledge we have never used a synthetic
lubricant with PCB in it, but some gas companies do
use it as a lubricant on valves and fittings. About 00
percent of our natural gas comes in from out of state
-- from New Mexico and Texas -- so we assume
that's were the PCB came from."
-
Sharp said extensive chemical tests are now being
done to determine the exact amounts of PCB found.
"To our knowledge, none of our workers has had
any of the health problems associated with PCB -- no
skin rashes, gastrointestinal problems, headaches or
spiratory problems." .
Kaiser Steel Corp.
The Fontana steel plant uses PCB "in various
places in the mm and we are currently In the process
of phasing it out," said spokesman Joe Clark. Accord
ing to the federal EPA, the chemical is routinely used
as a cooling oil in mill equipment because of the
intense heat involved in making steel.
Clark also said that Kaiser operates two electric
substations at the plant and both facilities use PCB in
"enclosed systems," which means in its electrical
transformers and capacitors.
"I think we're Just like everybody else. We've been
using them and now we're phasing them out," Clark
said. .
..
................... i> ........ .
Hoover Dam
The Department of Energy facility on the Colorado
[liver near Needles uses some PCB liquid in its giant
electrical capacitors. Like most other users, the
Department of Energy is "working to replace the
capacitors as they fail and replace them with non*
PCB equipment," an official said.
.
m
'Don t touch me ... i i
a
I
may be contaminatedv
SAN BERNARDINO -- The driller's
wife said she doesn't remember much
about the day her husband came home
barefooted and said. "Don't touch me.
-I may be contaminated."
.
i After the initial shock, her first reac-. '
ition "was panic. I said, `Where are
your shoes? Where are your socksT
'and he said, `Ob, they confiscated
them at work. I worked with some
kind of contaminated material; some
kind of chemical and it got on my
[shoes and they said 1 couldn't take
: them home.' "
; Her husband, Bob, (not bis real'
[name) bad gone to a site in the desert
* to do what he thought was routine soil
sampling.
What Bob didn't know was that PCB
'had accidentally been spilled at the
[site and officials at the local water
.agency were afraid It bad seeped into
| the water table. The officials wanted
some soli tests run and Bob's company \ was asked to do them.
' The true identities of Bob and his
wife, who will be referred to as Amy,
! have been withheld because they fear ;
recriminations. Bob thinks bo may bbj
harassed or fired if he talks to the
press about the PCB spill that went
had,
"But I felt it was more dangerous not
to talk about it," Amy said in a recent
Interview. "Because I'm afraid that if
we don't get something in the paper
about this -- something to prove that
Bob was actually at the spill -- we ll
have no way of Unking the spill to any
cancer Boh may develop in the coining
years."
.
After Bob arrived at the location, he
quickly discovered "that the whole
thing was a bit weird. Because when I
got there, the foreman toid us that
some PCP or something like that had
spilled; that it was cancer-causing; that
it can harm the liver and stuff if you
breathe Bin.
.
"Then they gave m protective
clothing -- paper coveralls and a full gas mask and gloves and plastic-type
hags to tie around out. teet. At that point. I started to get nervous about th* PCP or PCB stuff, hut l teU l had to do b or get fired,"
The protective gear, however, didn't
seem to afford much protection for Bob. During the eight-hour drilling job, "one of the bags around my shoe
Just gradually wore thin from walking on it and it tore apart. I got some of the 1PCB) oil on my shoes and that'y the
reason they confiscated them."
And even though the rest of his protective gear remained intact. Bob
was admonished-10 throw out all the clothing he wore to the spill -.
"They toJd me never to wear any of 4 those clothes again. They told me to throw out everything when I got
home." he said. "That'S when I storied , to get scared, really scared, l thought, 'What the hell's going on here? { was ..
wearing protective gear, wasn't jr j
PCB-ARCH-EXT0376234
When he got home -- minus his shoes and socks -- "Bob seemed a bit shook up. He started taking off all his clothes, every single stitch, and put them into a plastic trash bag," recalled
Amy. According to Bob, "They told me to
put all the clothes I was wearing into a plastic trash bag -- they said to make sure it was a heavy-duty type plastic
bag -- and to tie up the bag good and
take it to a garbage dump." Bob's boss told him he would be
reimbursed for the clothing and boots. Within a week, Bob received a new pair of boots and a check to cover the clothing he'd thrown away.
Bob did not go to his doctor for a skin and blood test, like Amy wanted, "because I guess he didn't even want to think about the possibility that he might have been exposed,to the PCB,"
his wife surmised.. !" : After that first day, which Amy said ' "has become a big blur to me," she spent a week "trying to find out just what this chemical was. Someone at the (state) water resources board told
ipe they thought it caused liver cancer but they weren't sure.
"I called all kinds of different state and county and federal agencies and got a real run-around. It took me all week to get no where. I just wanted to see if this stuff was dangerous or not." - Amy said one official told her PCB could be breathed through the skin's pores and absorbed through the eye tissue while another told her it was basically harmless and that she was overreacting.
The more phone calls she made, the more "these officials would say 1 was overreacting. I found hardly anyone sympathetic. And the ones who were concerned gave me a phone number to call someone else. They really didn't want to have anything to do with it. No one Wanted to get involved.
"I don't know much about cancer and I'm not a chemist," Amy said. "But I know that if you are exposed to a known carcinogen, then 6 times out of 10 you'll get it; you'll develop cancer."
Bob says he feels fine "right now. I feel great today. But what about 10 years from now? Will I be fine then? Or will I be dying of cancer?"
The problem with PCB is that, ah though it Is a known toxin, its full I impact on human health is not known. Borne scientists think PCB may be linked to cancer but others point to new evidence that suggests the com pound may have no long-term effects.
But to anyone who's been exposed to
PCB, that academic debate doesn't
mean very much,
1
"It's the not knowing that Is killing
us," Amy said. "It's like this constant
worry In the back Of your mind. You
try to forget and think it's nothing
because you don't feel bad- But cancer
doesn't make you feat bad at first, does
It?"
.,
. - By JEANNtNE CUTTHAN^ |