Document x8pVdO5zebeYobQJmEoEBNoE
FILE NAME: Shell (SHEL)
DATE: 1950 Apr 28
DOC#: SHEL009
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Memo RE Problems of Environmental Cancer in the Petroleum Industry
SHELL D E V E L O P f o ^ ^ f r ANY
TOFROM S U B JE C T
.
'
2 '95
-
.K.
R
/
E
D
b
S
S
t
l
l
ffilB
---
J
fflSCfAfU^F-
prU
28,
1950
C. H. HUE, H.D., CONSULTIeNMGERTYOVXIICUO-^LO--GIST
CERTAIK HiOBUMS OF ENVIRONMENTAL CANCER IK THE PETR0IR0M INDtJSTRT
creased concern atout'^the'inclSncr^f cancer^n S ^ " ' 0 J" " M 7 "OIIrc an In
Since it is my understanding that certain Departmental?
vorlcLnE age group,
occasion in the future to t o w an i n c r w L d
m \ w*???7 1,111 *"
volatile petroleum mixture,, I t o w prepr,d S e f o l ^ ,, f f
" d non
information. I can aee no cause for im^ttat. c o n c ^ ^ " "^andum for your
the province of your group to have acceaa to i.r.. .. * "Ter As rightly
occupational cancer.
t0 infrtu,tl< shout the problem of
causes an environmental carcinogen
There ie cnn*4a
*" * Wssues reprasants
increase in cancer due t H ^ ^ U 0 ^ ^ in diagnosis and treatment doubtleaaly increase' t t o ^ L t o ^ 7*Ctors " there is little doubt that there is a ^ S u U w ^ ^ ' S T '
improvement
environmental carcinogena. For e m e m n l H e r r ^ b ^ f ^ t o d "PCtn" rf
number of lung cancers recorded during the oast AO w^ r t ^
ihcrease in the
world. The emtrinaic origin of this etono-L.. * ^
froB " V P^rts of the
increase has been more pronounced in males tha in fSfles" 5 At
th
a lack of proof that a sinrie eitrinir
< /-" a188* At present there is
development. It is well established that^
s wholly responaible for this
physical and chemical properties may caufiM T ?r agonta ^ h highly different
origin.
Properties may cause puLnonaxy malignancies of occupational
be traced \ o
rt^ 7 -vironwntal cancer
carcinogenic o u a l i t i e ^ ^ - "
S "L ^ a r w n i T
Miinea, in addition to -radio-active elements. . " * ben2l, and aromatic
fined mixt^-e^of a r ^ ^ c h e n S ^ ^
completely known. The members of this
crude mineral oils caraffin o-n
g-,P
oil era030ta and k S L n a ^ ' ,, & d r
*" cauaed exposure to ill de
f
*" U ~
?" pitch, asphalt, soot,
s^^
possible mechanisms in producing cancer. Th^
COncer:ii^ thfi
the known action of the aromati? amines and^ predicates a direct action on cellular subatrate
TbiJ
W d Q ^
interfering with normal cellular encymatic activity ^ b T ^ ^ S i ^ ^ i t i
^
003343
- 2-
..reaulting in the formations.-of allergens. -A second theory relate a that car-ino-
genfl^d not poaoeas.direet carcinogenic properties, but that they-act through..
changing bobs normal chemical constituent of the cell or. tissue fluid so tha-
xt becomes endowed with carcinogenic properties. A third theory concerns ^ n t s
vnich may cause quantitative or qualitative changes in sane indicate
g and or the liver, which responds with a generation within the body of abnormal
endogenous carcinogenic products. Cancers of this type may be p r S u c S W ^
toxxc agents such as azo dyes or chlorinated hydrocarbons.
" 7 hfipato~
Human contacts with soot, carbon black Ditch Hnnhaif
j
t h^lP t i il,
+0i1' luhrlcatin and
oil, anthracene oil and otherrdisUa'
txnations and fractionation products of coal and petroleum apparently cause th*
majority of environmental cancers in man.
7
the
The specific carcinogenic agent or agents in these products i. r,n+
a c U ^ t y l 1S Pr0babl that 3,1-benzpyrene account for at least a portion of thi^*
Despite the observation that tar products, petroleum, and oil shale ^
ducts account for tb. m j o r i t y of envixcn^nt*! cM e.r iz,
Grftf.r, on
ing the incidence rate of cancer among the employees of an oil refinery did net fiod any s i g n i f i e d different from that of the geoaral populaUon. ^ i a M r ^ authority ^Occupational Cancer Problems atatee that he feels that the vSidity of
T t o l T T i i T ' questionable, due to difficulty in obtaining factual data!
T^ttifi1' 1
h! PrC " 0f UndertafcLne S survey among certain msmbers of the
Institute wno have kept aoequate medical records; their report should be forthcoming
in about a year. Information of a highly confidential type has reached me that
Esso has conducted such a survey and has obtained information which is causing con
siderable concern. The role which the inhalation of tar dust and fumes p l ^ i T
the production of cancer in man is still unaettled. Animal experimental evidence
shows that soot containing gasoline motor exhaust products cause cancer nf tv, i
after inhalation or sarcoma of the subcutaneous tissue after injection in mice 1 S T
* \ v,H!WeJer' th8 1UDg C" Car rate
in Pittsburgh was found to be lower
than that of any other large city surveyed with the exception of Denver.
w
, to Hueper has pointed out that the great majority of cancers which can bo
traced to occupational origin in modern times have resulted from carcinogens which
entered industrial processing during the last 50 years. In the following tablfare
presented all- the known or commonly suspected chemical agents causing cancer that
S s i t T w L ^ S ! il, f dr tr7* <* a gBnaral rule occupational cancers arise at
ilth th
the particular carcinogen has the moat prolonged and intense contact
with the tissue. Consequently, we would expect the majority of cancers in the
petroleum industry to occur on the skin, mucous membrane and surface organa
CHH/mw
cc: N. W. Jacobean R. R. Ward
003344 C. H. HIRE, H.D., Consulting Toxicologist
CARTER 1C -50
Substance An~n~lne and derivatives Anthracene, crude Aromatic organic chemicals Asphalt
Organ or System . 1 Bladder, ureter, kidney Skin Liver Skin Eye
Benzidine and derivatives Benzol Benzol derivatives
Bladder, ureter, kidney ~'
Blood forming organs
Blood forming organa
Chlorinated aliphatic hydrocarbons (?)
Liver
Creosote
Skin
Lip
Eye
Mineral oil, crude
Skin Lip
Respiratory system Ujre
Naphthylamine, beta Oil shale
Bladder, ureter, kidney Skin
Paraffin oil, crude Pitch
Soot Spindle oil Tar
i
Skin
Skin Lip Bladder Eye
Skin
Bladder
Skin
00334 o
Lip
Skin
Respiratory system
Bladder
Blood forming organa
Eye
1
I
I
CARTER
----d _ i
TABIZ 1 - Page 2,
.
. -
of agents encountered in the petroleum industry elicit
pre-canceroua r a t i o n , vhieh an. eharact^iatic to a e.rtaia ^
Qf
= TM . egenta and which represent ^
iuws ^
^
original normal tisane and the final r . n
ho final cancer. In Table 2 ,, a enumerated
certain of tha nor, C0Bmon of the,,
.
6
wgetner with the portion of the
7 affected and a description of the lesion.
003346
CARTER
^
JKDi: Atrophy:
StLn-groEly thlM a d ^ gu sUnlng
in patchesa, associated with '
keratotic areas.
Pitch, tar, asphalt, radio
active substances, radia tion (including ultraviole
Keratosis
Hyperkeratosis:
i
Verrucas Ulceration? Leukoderma:
discrete, scaly area on skin vith raised pearly borders. Usually on parts of skin exposed to carcinogen, but may occur in unexposed parts, par ticularly about sweat glands, with arsenic.______
Rough, fissured keratotic plaques with
" " J1 * hard> w a r l i k e horns, usually
on hands and soles. May become nodular and ulcerate.
Anthracene, arsenic, asphalt creosote, crude mineral oil paraffin, pitch, sodium nitrate, soot, tar, radio active substances, radiatio (including ultraviolet rays
Fora of hyperkeratosis
.Breakdown of keratotic
Absent Pigmentation alone.
Leuko-melanoderma:
Melanoderma Scleroderma;
Patchy increased and absent pigmenta tion of akin. Most common in areas of highest pigmentation, and may in volve oral mucosa,
.Increased pigmentation a1nn>|
Dry, scaly, parchment-like akin, with enlarged pores, associated with laukomelanoderma
Anthracene, arsenic, asphalt creosote, crude mineral oil paraffin, pitch, tar, radic active substances, radiatic (including ultraviolet ray*
Crude mineral oil, paraffin oil, radioactive substances,
Hemorrhage submucosal
Papillomas:
AfES: Papillomas:
Varying size with telangiectasis
Located mainly in trigone and about
ureteral orifices.
.
Polypous or villous, pedunculated or
sessile, often multiple about trigone
_ and ureteral orif !<.
6
Aniline, benzidine, beta-
naphthylamine and deriva
tives.
003347
Pedunculated, develop mainly on lids
occasionally on eychaVi
'
Arsenic, asphalt, creosotej
crude mineral oil, pitch, tar, radiation (incl^riinc' ultr-Holt rivj).
riT?TVB