Document wr3xpQ4N7em8qXN2eQxnn0eqV
RSV0024696
POSTAL WORKERS NEED OUR SUPPORT
"...and we are ay being asked to make * sacrifices . "
there's a mighty effort underway to turn AEI is a right-wing Republican think-
PUBLIC SENTIMENT AGAINST POSTAL WORKERS, tank & that Adie's "comparable" jobs
The 4 major postal unions (Letter C - were in banking,, insurance, telephone,
Carriers; Postal Workers;-Mailhandlers; & electric utilities.
& Rural Letter Carriers) & the U.S.
The largely non-union banking &
Postal Service (USPS) ajre bargaining over a contract to replace the current
insurance industries pay notoriously poor wages. They pull down the average
3-year pact ending July 21. Past New
when lumped in with telephone & elec-
Unitys have'reported on the postal
. trie utilities, which pay Silk more than
workers' major needs (5/78) & the pos sibility that management will force a
financial industries. Adie's" statis tics, & the Council's as well, are
strike & a lousy contract on them (6/78). worthless--except to stir up resentment
The unions' announced goal of a
against postal workers.
$1965/year raise (in 2 steps, July '78
A better comparison was done by the
it July '79) has become "nurnber 1 on
U.S Commission on Postal Service. It
President Carter's hit list." (The
found no difference between the postal
press described this as a 14% raise;
average & the group-average for steel,
in-fact, for most postal workers, it
auto,transportation,- & communications.
will be around 12%. New Unity doubts
Meanwhile, United parcel Service
that it will keep up with the cost of - workers get about 20% more than postal
living, even when combined with the
workers. And the Labor Department's
Cost of Living Allowance that postal
Intermediate Budget for a City Worker
workers receive.)
Family of 4 is about 10% higher than
Carter claims he'll depend oh "vol
the average postal worker's income.
untary restraint of both labor & man
agement" to control inflation. But
HIGHER PRICES CAUSE HIGHER WAGES
his announced intention to limit govern
ment workers to a 5%% raise is, in fact
Carter blames wages for inflation.
a decision to impose wage controls on
The historic pattern, however, is one
government workers & set a pattern for
of raises trying to catch up with
ait workers.
prices. And even Postal Service wages
have fallen behind the inflation.
Postal workers get a Cost-of-Living
Allowance (COLA). But that only made
Carter has unleashed various bureau up 55% of What inflation stole from crats in an attack on pawif-al wnrltawl----- -their purchasing power over the last
UUftHhds". His Council on Wage & Price
3 years. Negotiated raises in the
^g&ic pay schedule have helped keep
close to inflation. But raises are
supposed to f*pJtoue ydur lot, not just
|p up with inflation.
non-farm workers.
prices '
USPS HIGHER PRODUCTIVITY
fflOif WOH.fzKi*
wag&4,
' I - v"~'" From 1970 to 1977 the workforce de-
ina S>o. 1/McJ dined by 12%, while total mail volume
se^ativecoluamist James jY^il^-g; -- increased 9%. Productivity junped 23%
Patrick claime(M>tev^--b8JP0t^i. ! H fi/lHo over 140,000 pieces of mail per
rtffat complfcra&le'' employee. It jumped over 6% in 1977
jobs. His source was the Adie
e. Few other-industries show any
feats.
Kilpatrick failed to_nQfcdJaaTfcfe.e
Monsanto Pay Is Tough
IS
IN LATE NOVEMBER 1973 CLARENCE MESSIER
WAS' DYING.
-
'
Neither he, his wife Alice, his doc-
"exclusion diagnosis," that is, a guess At the time there was ho way (there is now) of pinpointing a virus as the
MAKING YOU
tor, nor his Springfield co-workers knew cause of hepatitis.
he might be dying from chemicals at
After all the publicity about vinyl
the big Monsanto plant in Indian Orchard, chloride 2 months after Messier died,
But_2 .months later, the" world learned Flahive himself had second, thoughts. ,
.that.vinyl chloride, a-widely used
When asked by attorney Sweeney in mid-,
material in the plastics industry, could cause fatal cancer. Messier made poly-
vinyl chloride (PVC) plastic out!: or vinyl chloride gas. So Alice Messier,
1974, Flahive,, acknowledged that the "liv' er conditi.on c-o- u- ld- .H...a..v..e..'.,..been due, to Messier's work,
Headaches, dizziness, stomach trouble-, problems with ybur ears,.eyes, Jungs, or skin may be caused by materials y u
asked Springfield la^&yer Morton Sweeney to file a Workers' Compensation claim.
Still, Messier's de._ath certificate .made it seem .doubtful that vinyl chloride
COMPANY SETTLES WITHOUT A FIGHT
Thus--had the case gone to the state Industrial Accident Board (lAB)--the
work with or by conditions n the-Job.
TALK TO YOUR D CTOR.
for more information.
. had anything to do with his death. The publicity in the media suggested that_,the
; only illness known to come from vinyl ,, chloride exposure wgs a very rare liver
argument would have rested off the real
possibility_. that Messier`was mlsdiag-_
nosed.
~-- .....
' Actually, no one Jknows. Neither
MASSACHUSETTS COALITIQN FOR OCCUPA TIONAL SAFETY & HEALTH (mASSCOSH). 32 3 HIGH ST., HOLYOKE'; MONDAYS S FRI DAYS I.-5 PM; CALL 536-3734 ANYTIME '
cancer. Messier's doctors said he died side .reviewed Merqy Hospital data to
from cirrhosis of the liver caused by a
try to pinpoint what Messier had.
virus infection.
Attorney Sweeney didn't', he says,
Nevertheless, Mrs.. Messier went affead because it Wasn't legally necessary to'
with her claim. And in 1976, Monsanto,
pioye., that vinyl chloride caused the
agreed-to settle. '
apparent Sirrposis. ^All he had Lb do
The cause of heir husband's death-re
was have an expert argue it was "more
mains uncertain, as we'll see below..
likely than hot."
--
But the case Is still-.significant--espe
And, he says, Monsanto wouldn't want
cially for chemical workers, their fam
to-make that re-examlhatioh because they
ilies , doctorsfit lawyers.
might find that vinyl cljloride indeed
killed Messier. Th,e company cpuld get a
weaker conclusion by settling before the
f'r
case went to the IAB.
(
.,
Sweeney feels a company would not
settle without a fight if they were as
sure as Monsanto's lawyers were origin
ally that the claim had'no basis.
Qf course, there's also Monsanto's contention,- in the final settlement agreement, that it was .simply cheaper ' to pay the/ claim than the legal fees
*9*
Pressure to Win
to. fight It. The claimwas small-'-$6600
plus legal fees.
'
'
(Mrs. Messier, having remarried, was
to Know
^^
nnlftr eligible only for, benefits from Mes- r
CIRRHOSIS'LIKE DISEASE. FROM VINYL CHLORIDE sj[er'8 death to the data of remarriage.)
Right up until September ,1976, Mon
santo fought the claim, resting its case
on the death certificate. - Monsanto-said
there1 was no -occupational disease in- .
volved-, because, vinyl chloride has never
been ,shown to - cause'cirrhoais-. of the
liver
,r
' ' Actually,. lC>as;-k^own :Xiv_1974
But a last-minute company move also suggests that Monsanto was indeed con cerned about this case providing a stimulus for other workers. The com-
pany'lawyer tried'to insert some lan
guage into the final agreement Saying:-
"The parties are 1 satisfied,that .
OSHA, IT SEEMS, HAS PUT OUR RIGHT TO .. . KNOW ABOUT CHEMICALS ON THE,BACK BURNER. ..
Health fit safety groups around the country have petitioned for the Occu pational Safety fie Health Administra tion (OSHA) to require labeling & full , information about workplace chemicals . & their;dangers. OSHA did circulate
a draft regulation fit. promised hearings.
TLub.ViBlfeiRlJaln'eag.. pres ante :made,'.'fehaflu~ lh
gat-oTrhsenw, ebrey lfaintedin,1,9^7s4t,r.omnegdiecvaildeinncveesthtia- t.
any way. relate-this employee's death to his work ...' [Mrs Messier] ac--
cancer is not I he . only-di sease related- kiipwledges the unlxkelihooql she-cpuld
to vinyl chloride. 'A'noh-cancerous dis- obtain a qualified^xpert to support
ease from vinvylc;chhlolorriidee7 exposure migeht
well.be killing'-tnore people than" liver
cancer.
-.
And this disease has probably been
miA-taken by doatofiA ^oft ai.Kfihoii.ii in
vi.nyl ahtoKi.da woKkaKi.
(
_ Dr.'John Lewis was an expert-witness
for Messier against Monsanto".' (Lewis
investigated reports of cancer deaths
among Monsanto-Springfield employees
- the alleged claim.Sweeney called this "tantamount to
a lie." & refused to include it. . Mon santo ,then accepted Swehney's reason for the settlement: the cost of hearing "novel, unique, 'fit complex medical & ( legal questions without legal precedent .in the CommonwealthI.""
PUBLIC IGNORANCE IS COMPANY BLISS
while working, for the state Occupation
al Hygiene'Division in 1976. .His ef forts helped precipitate a federal
study- that is currently.underway here.)
He described the symptoms of this
oon-caocerous disease as.the same as
cirrhosis: "The patients look just
like cirrhosis, & they die just like
cirrhosis,."
-
;
Expert pathologists. found-the disease
in the livers" of workers both with &
without liver cancer, ft's a-,thick,
scar-tissue-like growth.
.
'-'Mos.t. pathologists, seeing that
-
So, it may never be known,what killed Clarence Messier. But expfertzs like" Lewis are certain-there are workers who are, mistakenly assumed by their doctors
& families to have died from alcohol, viruses, & such, when in fact their .work
was the real killer. Without the full" public airing of
the issues such as this-page would have
provided, the- general'ignorance about
what may be a wide-spread, occupational disease remains intact.
And all for only $6600 (plus legal
growth, woitld.say, 'That's cirrhosis,"'
fees of course). To an enormous inter-
-Lewis comments. "Only a few in the country can-tell the difference. And they say that-'s not cirrhosis. Instead they'call it'a 'fibrosis of the liver'-
national chemicals company, that must
* . seem like -a real bargain* , / adapted -from an article
by Peter FTiedland .
that's distinctive in vinyl chloride
workers." ,
i'
-
> *
RULING ALCOHOL Ol)T.
,
^Messier's doctors were faced with a choice of 3 possible causes of what they'saw as cirrhosis'& "hepatitis," or swelling, of the liver: alcohol, chem icals , or. an infection due to a virus.
, Alcohol was out, because Messier did not drink. . Even if Messier.were an al coholic, many alcoholics don't get cir rhosis. This suggests that "other fac tors are involved. The other factors, Lewis argues, are often chemicals that people are exposed to in their work.
- But in November 1973 the chemical-- .connection was unknown. So Messier s
family doctor, John-Flahive, w^nt along with a -Mercy Hospital lab report that
attributed the hepatitis to a virus. The death certificate diagnosis became: "post necrofic [infectious] cirrhosis^ secondary;to'chronic viral hepatitis."
But LeWiS:characterizes this an-an
"The "guys In the raw mill ar^gettlng higher than a Kite on our last grinding* aid additive, Jerry."
now asking OSHA* chief Bingham for firm"
commitments & a time-table for action. ,
To help , .'please contact MassCOSH T
(seelboX above).
.'
Seabrook - from pkge 1
American Federation of State, County,
& Municipal Employees..
Jerry Gordon of the Amalgamated
Meatcutters fit Butchers Union spoke;
"We have to counter the/_big lie that
the labor movement is the enemy of the
anti-nuclear movement. The enemies-of
this movement are the' same as the
.enemies of the labor movement. They
are the big corporations-, fit the poli
ticians who carry out their desires.'"
. United Mine Workers representative
Ren Hunter called the jobs angle that
utility companies push "i'a down-tight
lie I Coal produces 40% more jobs than
nuclear power plants."
'--
Pete Se^ger, Arlo Guthrie, & Utah J
Phillips led the rally in songs.
.PART OF OCCUPATION ---
\
The.rally was part of a 3-day legal oecupation/restoration by 8000 Clam shell Alliance members, including .at least 350 Western Mass, 'residents.
It took 4 hours for the thousands of people to march onto the site--with
shouts of encouragement from local
residents who lined the street. They
organized into homesites fie regions,.* pitched their.tents, Rlanted trees, fie set up alternative energy displays.
,, Last year 1414 demonstrators were arrested for occupying the site. This
year. New Hampshire officials, made a
'compromise so they, would not' have to
deal with mass arrests.
,-
On June 26, 2000 occupiers traveled,
to Manchester, N.H., where the Nuclear
Regulatory Commission (NRC) was holding
hearings on whether to suspend Seabrook
construction, They^marched,.through
;
the streets, stopping first in front
of the Public Service Co.-, -the princi
ple buil-der/utility company.
They then encircled the Federal
Courthouse where.the NRC was meeting.
The NRC is expected to decide,Seabrook'S
fate by' July 30.
To get involved, contact' Susan Gar
vey or Dave Potvin, Hampden County
Alternative Energy.-Coalitipn,- 532-3635.
I RSV0024G97
Monsanto Cancer Victim //ants Union Help
WHAT DO -^OU-DO AFTER DECADES OF WORK .
THAT SPREAD CANCER THR6UGH YOUR BODY? Stanley Byceriski, 58, considers `the
cancer throughout his body to-be work- related. Dyrfhg 26 years, at'MonSan to-
Springfield, 'mainly in Mainfenarice as
a pipe-fitter-, qr carpenter,, Stanley, :
was 1 exposed^tp^everyichetnibal used &,?
made .there.
" "'
. j. `
Since las'tJ, December he1 s,-be:en :o.ut.f i
on sick leaveDrihas applied ,fora: medi- ,
cal retirement'; ` Atty i Morton'Sweeney
is' representing him ih1 a ;Workers ' /
Compensation claim;- Sweeney also rep--
resented Clarence Messier's widow
(story on page 4),
.
His union contract also has pro
visions for him to receive 80-100%
pf his pay. if ,he wins the. Comp claim.
Because he needs uniph action to get
that supplement from Monsanto, & union
support right now, Stanley wrote the-
following letter to his president,
'/
Joseph Bernardo.
DEAR PRESIDENT `BERNANdOj-7
' - \Y 1
I wish to appeal to you as Prestden fc-
of my Union [International Union,of ..
Electrical. Workers Local-2881 for ad
vice, support, & financial assistance.
% As you know, I have been on sick
"leave since December 1977, have had'one
operation, & have completed a second
series of radiation therapy treatments
for prostatic cancer.
^
Because"this type of cancer is one
of many which .has. been found in excess
'among -former Monsanto-Springfield work
ers by-both a federal study (NIOSH) &
Monsanto's own study, I consider my-ill ness 'to be workTrelated;
-Therefore, I havetaken the neces- -
sary preliminary steps to file- a claim
with the Industrial AecidenfBoard for -
Worker's Compensation benefits. Need
less to say, this type...of case is both
'difficult & costly, since vast amounts
of research & testimony of. niany_ experts
will probably .be required, -if-Monsanto denj.es my claim.
I call upon Local 288 for financial support to defray the cost of this in-
vestigation, riot only for myself, hut
for past, present, & future victims who,
may benefit from my action.
">
I also request the-necessary steps be taken to as.sqre that the- supplement.",
- pay provided: for- in. Art; 17, Sec. 17 of
the Union contract is provided., A
i It is my'understanding) as well; .
- .. that a, separate agreement "has been in
force for.many years (copy requested) r
^ which further entitles me , to 100% of my
--pay, since if my cancer--is work-related^,
. it is through no, fault' of mine.
i
.Would appreciate your immediate at- ,
tenfcion & action on these matters.
-Thanking you ..in .advance, - -
Yours truly,
Stanley^Bycenski
NO SUPPORT
Your
Bernardo answered that -the union could not give any funds.' He also
wrote, "the Local Union has .yet to re
you cough or,sneeze? make your throat
ceive any conclusive, evidence from any
dry.?, or hurt your eyes?
- studies conducted by-various groups
The.more hidden hazards should then
indicating that the cancer of our em
be spotted. Is the machine safe? Does
ployees is work-related." , --
it have guards? Does it work" correctly?'
Stanley's other requests went tin-
What about the wiring? Is the on-off
answered-. His letter was nor read at
switch easy for the operator to reach?
a union meeting & the members, are gen
Is the floor clear? Ape exits clear &
erally not aware of his plight. -
marked?
After years of activity in the.
Is protective gear (goggles, masks)
uplon, Stanley feels let down. TJniori
provided?, Is an operator given-enough training to run the machine safely? Does the job have to be done too fast tp be safe? Is there a clean place to eat? Are there eriough hathrooms & wash
officers, perhaps, are afriad to rock the boat--Monsanto, after .all, is a huge wealthy global corporation.
But that's all the more reason for
it to take responsibility for the
ing facilities? Are they clean?
health of its workers *4 who ,,actually- ,
1 Also excessive beat, cold & rad- produce the wealth its owners control,
iation should. ,be ..checked,. . .
.Anf that s all the more reason for-the
'
YOU DON'T HAVE TO RE AN EXPERT TO
INSPECT YOUR WORKPLACE FOR HAZARDS. The people who are best -qualified
to identify dangerous situations are
the workers who have to face them
daily.
,-
,
The "first step is ; to collect the
Information on hazards in a .well
organized notebook. .These facts can
then be used to pressure management
-5c help solve the problems.
In the notebook be-as specific as
possible. Nte"the exact location,
the people affected, _ttie probable
cause, & the possible solution, & .
.whether it is an occasional or daily
problem.
Questionaires are available from
.MassCOSH that can help you firul out
from other wprke.rs what problems they
have'& how widespread the problems are.
These questionaires may also arouse
Interest among fellow", workers .
ASKING QUESTIONS
Start with spotting the most obvious problems. Ask yourself & others questions like: Is the noise.loud? Do vapors or fumes smell? make you dizzy? sleepy? -give you a headache? oes the dust, smoke, or vapors make
cause accidents too & should.be rioted. A record of accidents-helps identify hidden or repeated hazards.& is use ful in workers compensation cases.
HEALTH HAZARDS
;,
''
I
Ask workers about mild symptoms
like headaches, frequent colds, cough,
dizziness, or skin irritations. . The -
same complaints from a few workers,
in an area may bfe.,traced to a cause.
Health problems are often related
to chemicals, oils &solvents Used.
It is important to note all facts
'given on the label. .Also such inform
ation as where it is used, how it is
used,-how often, the,type of container
it is in,. & peopled complaints abopt
it is important.
-Determining what problems are the
most serious' & immediate threats to
health &-saety, & which problems
people are mobt angry about is a,good
place to start in working to eliminate
the hazards.-
Tliis article is adapted from How
to Look at youJL tllo/tkplaae., a booklet1
by Urban Planning Aid. It is available1 for 80q from MassCOSH (see box p.4).
Monsanto as ; tried to -put obstacles
in the way of any group seeking the
truth,''including a,rank & file group
of employees & the1 National Institute
for Occupational Safety & Health
(NI0SH).
..
v.'
To fight back requires an informed,
active-, concerned union & labor move
ment. Certairily a first, step would'
be to read'Stanley's' letter at a union
meeting.
,
, All Monsanto workers;;who want to
pursue the cancer issue.at Monsanto
should feel free to contact MassCOSH
(see box on page 4);
-
Skin
SYMPTOMS redness, dryness, itching ulcers, skin cancer
Eyes
redness, irritation, watering-
grainy feeling, "welder's flash".
Ears
' ringing, temporary"deafness, hearhiglosa
Teeth A Gums corrosion of tooth enamel blue glims
Nose ft Throat sneezing, coughing, sore throat nasal cancer
Chest A Lungs wheezing, congestion, dry cough.
- shortness of breath Oiiriiild exercise
*Y. '
flu-hJka symptoms f`metai fume fever")
Head
dizziness, headache
lingers . .
toss of clrculation, numbness, swelling
Bones -
arthritis---
4
Muscles ft Back soreness, strain
Nervous 'system stress, nervousness, irritability sleeplessness, tremors, speech changes -
Reproductive System-
miscarriage irregularities in menstruation damage to fatufl or chromosomes sterilization
COMMON CAUSES
solvents, epoxies, oiJ, fiberglass, caustic soda, nickel mineral oils, arsenic, pitch, lar, radiation
smoke, gases (ozone), fumes (ammonia), mete) dust, acids ultraviolet radiation.
excessive noise
acid fumes, cellulose acetate production lead poisoning
ozone, ammonia, solvents, jaustic enda, dusts hardwood dusts and resins _
cotton dust, TDI, detergent enzymes, beryllium, solvents
long-term exposure to mineral dust (e.g.. asbestosj
metal oxides from welding V
`
'
solvents, ozone, heat exhaustion,ipoise
vibration from rivet guns, sic., vinyl thlo'ride gas
excessive vibration,, constant dampness
excessive or improper lifting, bending: vibration"
speed up, piece work rates, noise ( metal poisoning (lead, mercury)
lead, pesticides, radiation, anesthetic gaspolyfityreueKproduction, xylene, some solvents benzene, lead, mercury, radiation recitation '
MASSCOSH IS-PRESENTING A SERIES OF EDUCATI0NALS, "
The first series is with member local United Electrical Workers (UE) 274, Greenfield.' These educatiottals are available to any local &' can cover a variety- of health. & safety problems. Topics'include-"How to Us,e 0SHA" & "Health fit Safety Committees & Contract Clauses''. MassCOSH will work"with individuals & locals to help discoyer**& solve health & safety problems in the Shop; Contact MassCOSH (see box on page 4).
Work Kills