To: Graham, Amy[graham.amy@epa.gov]; Hupp, Millan[hupp.millan@epa.gov]; Bennett, Tate[Bennett.Tate@epa.gov] Cc: Johnson, Tommy[TommyJohnson@consolenergy.com]; Aieilo, Brian[BrianAiello@consolenergy.com]; Freire, JP[Freire.JP@epa.gov]; Konkus, John[konkus.john@epa.gov]; Lyons, Troy[lyons.troy@epa.gov] From: Smith, Zachery Sent: Thur 4/6/2017 9:10:06 PM Subject: RE: Thanks JHPBaa.trBtveeirosv.o-pPndafCttererseoknACerrieael.kjpgLavout.pdf
My responses below to help your prep. Some details/visuals attached. Will get you list for the employees, roundtable, questions, etc. ASAP
Give me a ring with any questions; Personal Phone/Ex. 6
From: Graham, Amy [mailto:graham.amy@epa.gov] Sent: Thursday, April 06, 2017 1:50 PM To: Smith, Zachery; Hupp, Millan; Bennett, Tate Cc: Johnson, Tommy; Aieilo, Brian; Freire, JP; Konkus, John; Lyons, Troy Subject: RE: Thanks
Zach - Thanks so much for sending these photos. Per our conversation, here are our remaining questions for the event. Feel free to give me a call anytime at [pTrVon'aipVone/Ex76i
Remaining Questions as of 4/6/2017 - 1:00 p.m.
Press needs: Bio for CEO Jimmy Brock- attached Square footage of the bath room- Layout attached. This will be in in the waiting room of the bathhouse How many exits and where are they located - 3 direct exits- see photos and map
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00001
What is the fire marshal number for maximum capacity/how many people can the room accommodate- looks like 220 Where is the room located on the property- see map and photo Where is parking for press- see map and photo What is the distance for cable run What time on Tuesday can we access the room for setup- 8am We will begin bringing press into the room at 8:30 or 9:00 a.m. on Wednesday. -9am. Backup room? we can get a holding room We will need to bring in our own equipment, which includes: O Lighting o Mult box o Still and video cameras o Signage o EPA, PA, U.S. flags We will need to rent additional equipment, do you have any of these things on site or suggestions for a local vendor: o Sound system- we have a speaker system o Press risers- what are dimensions needed? We have a local vendor. Identify employees who are authorized to speak with press Pre-submit questions and names of employees who will ask questions during the Q&A Names of employees who will present Administrator Pruitt with a hard hat at the end of the Q&A Any press restrictions on site that we should be aware of. - certain safety restrictions/areas.. don't want them walking freely on the property.
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00002
Lunch and Underground Tour Needs What room will the lunch take place in - 2ndfloor conference room One large table or multiple tables-1 think we do U shaped table, approx. 20 attendees? Who arranges lunch and who do we need to talk to about payment- Our HR professionals will get from a local vendor, we can invoice after? Who will MC lunch discussion List of lunch attendees and blurb about their role List of elected officials who will attend event In addition to EPA officials, who will join the underground tour Can we receive safety training video in advance- Please do not forward. This video must be watched by all members of the team that are going underground. On-site you will have to do training on breathing apparatus (10-15mins) and there will be a signature page that you are certified. Let me know if there are any issues, https://consolenergy.sharefile.com/dsd313d463fea4d6aa
Amy Graham Deputy Associate Administrator for Public Engagement U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Graham.amy@epa.gov 202-564-4464 (office) 202-306-5038 (cell)
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00003
From: Smith, Zachery ["mailtoiZachervSmith@cnxlp.com] Sent: Thursday, April 6, 2017 11:35 AM To: Graham, Amy <graham.amy@epa.gov>: Hupp, Millan <hupp.millan@epa.gov>: Bennett, Tate <Bennett.Tate@epa.gov> Cc: Johnson, Tommy <TommyJohnson@eonso1energy.eom>; Aiello, Brian <BrianAie11o@,conso1encrgy.com>: Freire, JP <Freire.JP@epa.gov>; Konkus, John <konkus,john@,epa.gov>: Lyons, Troy <lyons.troy@epa.gov> Subject: RE: Thanks
Thanks.
FYI- attached are a few photos of the bathhouse where the miners congregate for their safety briefings, etc. before going underground. This would be the recommended location for the open press/discussions with miners.
From: Graham, Amy fmaiito:ciraham.amy@epa,qovl Sent: Thursday, April 06, 2017 9:23 AM To: Hupp, Miliari; Bennett, Tate Cc: Smith, Zachery; Johnson, Tommy; Aieilo, Brian; Freire, JP; Konkus, John; Lyons, Troy Subject: RE: Thanks
Great - Just sent a calendar invite to everyone with the conference call information. Let me know if you do not receive it.
From: Hupp, Millan Sent: Thursday, April 6, 2017 9:15 AM To: Bennett, Tate <BemiettTate@epa.gov>: Graham, Amy <grabam.amy@epa. gov> Cc: Smith, Zachery <ZacherySmith@,cnxlp.com>; Johnson, Tommy <TommyJohnson@consolenergy.com>; Aiello, Brian <BrianAiello@con.soletrergy.com>: Freire, JP <FreireJP@epa.gov>: Konkus, John <konkusiohn@epa.gov>: Lyons, Troy <lvoiis.trov@,epa.gov> Subject: RE: Thanks
Good here as well.
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00004
From: Bennett, Tate Sent: Thursday, April 6, 2017 9:00 AM To: Graham, Amy <graliam.amy@epa.gov> Cc: Hupp, Millan <hupp.millan@,epa.gov>; Smith, Zachery <ZacherySmith@cnxlp.com>; Johnson, Tommy <TommyJohnson@eonsolenergy.eom>; Aiello, Brian <BrianAie11o@conso1energy.com>: Freire, JP <Freire.JP@epa.gov>: Konkus, John <konkus,john@epa.gov>: Lyons, Troy <lyons.troy@epa.gov> Subject: Re: Thanks
Good here
Sent from my iPhone
On Apr 6, 2017, at 8:41 AM, Graham, Amy <graham,amy@epa.gov> wrote:
Does 11:30 work for everyone?
From: Hupp, Millan Sent: Wednesday, April 5, 2017 8:24 PM To: Smith, Zachery <ZaeherySmith@cnxlp.eom> Cc: Bennett, Tate <Bennett.Tate@epa.gov>: Graham, Amy <graham,amy@epa.gov>; Johnson, Tommy <TommyJohnson@eonsolenergy.eom>: Aiello, Brian <BrianAie11o@eonso1energy.eom>: Freire, JP <Freire.JP@epa.gov>: Konkus, John <konkus,john@epa.gov>: Lyons, Troy <lyons.troy@epa.gov> Subject: Re: Thanks
I'll have a site visit wrapping up a little after 11. I can hop on late or could we push to 1130?
Sent from my iPhone
On Apr 5, 2017, at 7:59 PM, Smith, Zachery <ZaeherySmith@enxlp.eom> wrote:
11am tomorrow is good here
On Apr 5, 2017, at 7:37 PM, Bennett, Tate <6ennett.Tate@cpa.gov> wrote:
Awesome timeline. Good on my end. Thanks for organizing!
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00005
From: Graham, Amy
Sent: Wednesday, April 5, 2017 6:41 PM
To: Johnson, Tommy < ;
' m ' >; glconso1energy.com>: Hupp, Millan
<::l
- - > : Bennett. Tate <Bennett.Tate@epa.gov>; Smith.
Zachcry < ;
'-V.-- ;
>; Aiello, Brian
<Brian Aie11oi n consol energy,corn>; Freire, JP <Freire.JP@epa. gov>: Konkus,
John <: . : : >
Cc: Lyons, Troy < .
^ >
Subject: RE: Thanks
Hi all - Looping in a few more members of our press team. I noticed that our schedule is different from what's listed below. Here is the latest proposed line-by line I have for the event:
11:10 AM EST Administrator Pruitt arrives medi1a1a:v1a0i-la1b1il:i4ty5, oApMenEpSrTesDs.iscussion with coal miners in locker room and 11:45 --1:00 PM EST Private roundtable lunch with leadership, closed press. 1:00- 1:45 PM EST Safety training and gear up, closed press. 1:45 - 3:45 PM EST Underground mine tour, closed press. 3:45 PM EST - Depart
Let me know if anyone has any changes to this.
Would an 11:00 EST call tomorrow work for everyone to go over press logistics?
Thank you,
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00006
Amy
From: Johnson, Tommy ["mailto:TommvJolinsoii@consoleiiergv.com]
Sent: Wednesday, April 5, 2017 6:05 PM
To: Hupp,;M; illangc,'m..rr ; Smith, /aeheiy Bennett, Tate:r :i =
Brian < . ;
:: :
"
Cc: Graham. Amy <
Lyons. Troy
v.
Subject: RE: Thanks
Aiello.
; i v>
Zach is your guy. He will get our safety professionals in to assist.
From: Hupp, Millan fmailto:hupp.millan@epa.qov1 Sent: Wednesday, April 05, 2017 2:09 PM To: Johnson, Tommy; Bennett, Tate; Smith, Zachery; Aiello, Brian Cc: Graham, Amy; Lyons, Troy Subject: RE: Thanks
Tommy,
Thank you so much for this info. I will be traveling
jf " j
____ : _ , a ____ ______________________ 1 ______________C L .-f_______ a___ i _____ _____________________ n_________________j . _ ____________________ n v i ____________ ,'j u ___________ j . _ . __________.________________
Personal Security Detail/Ex. 6/Ex. 7C/Ex. 7E/Ex. 7F
Thank you,
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00007
Millan
From: Johnson, Tommy ["mailto:TommvJohiisoii@consoleiiergv.com] Sent: Wednesday, April 5, 2017 10:14 AM To: Bennett, Tate <Bennett.Tate@,epa.gov>: Smith, Zachery <Z3che1wSmith@c11xlp.com>; Aiello, Brian <BrianAiel.lo@consolenergy.com> Cc: Graham, Amy <graham.amy@epa.gov>; Lyons, Troy <lyoiis.tfmy@,ep3.gov>; Hupp, Millan <hiipp.millan@cp3.gov> Subject: RE: Thanks
Adding Zach Smith and Brian Aiello to this communication. They will be helping plan and stage this visit.
Below is a proposed framework to further discuss. Let us know when we can revisit this talk to put a finer point on the plan.
Harvey Mine- Patterson Creek Portal
1100am- Arrival at portal 11:15am-1200pm- Private roundtable discussion and lunch 1200-12:30-Safety training and overview 12:30-12:45-Gear up 100pm-300pm- Underground - Harvey- 25 minute man trip each way gives us about an hour underground at the longwall 300pm-330pm- Press conference and employee event at the portal
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00008
Tommy Johnson
CONSOL Energy [ Vice President - External Relations CNX Center | 1000 CONSOL Energy Drive | Canonsburg, PA 15317 724.485.4390 -w | 412.759.8112 -m
;; www.consolenerav.com ::
From: Bennett, Tate fmailto:Bennett.Tate@epa.qov1 Sent: Tuesday, April 04, 2017 5:26 PM To: Johnson, Tommy Cc: Graham, Amy; Lyons, Troy; Hupp, Millan Subject: Thanks
Tommy,
Thanks for your time today. Fve cc'd everyone who might be bothering you with questions (in addition to myself) over the next week. Standby on invite situation.
Best. Tate
Elizabeth Tate Bennett
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00009
Sr. Advisor to the Administrator Office of Congressional and Intergovernmental Affairs U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
"This communication, including any attachments, may contain confidential and privileged information that is subject to the CONSOL Energy Inc.'s Business Information Protection Policy. The information is intended solely for the use of the intended recipient(s). If you are not an intended recipient, you are prohibited from any use, distribution, or copying of this communication. If you have received this communication in error, please eimnmtireedtyiaftreolmy nyootuifrysthysetesmen."der and then delete this communication in its "This communication, including any attachments, may contain confidential aBnudsinperisvsileIgnefodrminafotiromnaPtiorontethctaiot nisPsoulbicjye.ctTthoethinefoCrmOaNtSioOn LisEinnteerngdyeIdncs.'oslely for the use of the intended recipient(s). If you are not an intended recipient, you are prohibited from any use, distribution, or copying of this communication. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify the sender and then delete this communication in its entirety from your system." ************************* ATTACHMENT REMOVED ************************* This message contained an attachment which the administrator has caused to be removed. ************************* ATTACHMENT REMOVED ************************* Attachment name: [image001.jpg] Attachment type: [image/jpeg]
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002184-00010
Jimmy A. Brock
Chief Executive Officer and Director
James A. Brock was appointed Chief Executive Officer and a director of our general partner effective March 16, 2015. Mr. Brock also serves as Chief Operating Officer-Coal of CONSOL Energy, a position he has held since December 10, 2010. Prior to this appointment, he served as Senior Vice PresidentNorthern Appalachia-West Virginia Operations of CONSOL Energy from 2007 to 2010. From 2006 to 2007, Mr. Brock served as Vice President-Operations. Mr. Brock began his career with CONSOL Energy in 1979 at the Matthews Mine and since then has served at various locations in many positions including Section Foreman, Mine Longwall Coordinator, General Mine Foreman and Superintendent. We believe Mr. Brock's extensive knowledge of our industry and our operations gained during his years of service with CONSOL Energy in positions of increasing responsibility in its coal operations provide the board of directors of our general partner with valuable experience.
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002186-00001
To: Hupp, Millan[hupp.millan@epa.gov]
From: Jessica Garrison
Sent: Thur 4/6/2017 9:04:57 PM
Subject: Plant Plant Miller one
Miller, pager
Alabama - FINAL -
r0e4q.u0e6s.1te7d.pidnffo
Hi Millan. Hope you guys have had a good week. Per our phone call and the remaining action item attached is the information on Plant Miller. This is the site that I mentioned. We hope this site visit will be one o f the top priorities for Administrator Pruitt's schedule when he travels to Alabama in the Fall.
Some of the key points for Plant Miller that I think Administrator Pruitt would find noteworthy include:
1. It is among the most productive coal plants in America
2. Invested $1.6B in major environmental enhancements to comply with EPA regs
3. Significant economic and philanthropic boost for local communities
Let me know what other information you would like in advance as it pertains to this trip. I can certainly make sure you have everything you need to help analyze his schedule. Thanks again!
Jessica Medeiros Garrison (205) 568-4371
17cv01906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523B 00002188-00001
.NT
. . Ahbama Power
DRY
* Construction began in 1973
* The four units went into commercial
:;
production between 1978 and 1991
CAPACITY/GENERATION
* 2,916 MWs of capacity
*
21081,1693,039
MWhs
of
net generation
'
in
* Produces enough energy to serve about 1 million homes
* In 2013 and 2015 ranked first among our nation's coal plants in net generation
* World class availability when compared to peers
FUEL
:
* HTn A n n m ir > c i !iw rsrir'/oiH
j'jFyj" P O W C lS T
i tons burned
ENVIRON I l, , C " ' CEMENTS
* cInovnetrsotelsdtoS1c.o6mbpillliyonwiitnh eEnPvAirornemguelnattaiolns * TheEsleectcroosnttartoiclspIrneccliupditaet:ors
Cooling towers Selective catalytic reduction Flue gas desulfurization Mercury removal systems * Projected to spend an additional $500 million on future EPA land and water regulations
WORKFORCE/ ECONOMIC IMPACT
* 365 full-time employees * 210 of the full-time employees are part of the
IBEW union * Mbyoeremtphlaonye2e,7s0in0 2h0o1u6rs of community service * $34,5 million annually in labor including
overtime * $127,3 million annually in contract labor * Over $12 million in property taxes paid
annually