Document wEB2RDEypBQvDavyO5xvYRDV

FILE NAME: Metropolitan Life (ML) DATE: 1930 DOC#: ML211 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Unpublished Report of the Physical Examinations of Asbestos by Pedley REPORT OF THE PHYSICAL EXAMINATIONS EXAMINATC ONS OF ASBESTOS WORKERS HI Oa/TZfE^ AND THETFORD MINNS, QUEBEC P The re p o rt herew ith p resen ted d eals w ith th e e x a m in a tio n o f T*J1 mmployees o f th e C anadian Johns-M anv i l l e C o ., A s b e s to s , Que. and 5*1 em ployees o f th e A sb e sto s C orporation_of Canada,, th e K easby-M attison Co. and John s o n 's M ine, a l l o f T h e tfo rd M ines, Que. *10 o f th e men o f th e Canadiam Johns-M an v i l l e Co. were examinaecl by D r. D. M. S te v e n so n and D r. Jo se p h W y att, who p erfo rm e d th e p h y s ic a l exam inations and X -ray exam inations re s p e c tiv e ly . The o th e r ex am in atio n s were a l l p erfo rm ed by me, ex c ep t th e X -ray exam inations. A c tu a lly , D rs. Stevenson and Wyatt e x a m in e d 57 menj b u t s in c e 17 o f th e s e men were re-ex am in ed i by me I am in c lu d in g them i n my l i s t . D rs . S tev e n so n and W yatt c a r r i e d on t h e i r wok i n November 1929. My exam i n a tio n s were done^ i n J u l y 1930 i n A s b e s to s , and i n Septem ber 1930 In T h etfo rd Mines. The A sbestos andThetford groups a re very d is sim ila r, with, resp ect to age d i s t r i b u t i o n and le n g th of f se rv ic e in th e asb esto s in.dustry, but r a c ia lly and econ o m ic a lly th e two g ro u p s a re t much a l i k e . T a b le I g iv e s th e age d i s t r i b u t i o n o f th e men and T a b le I I th e d i s t r i b u t i o n a c c o rd in g t o le n g th o f 'se rv ic B in the^aelbestoe in d u stry . 1 .. .kO.-.T Ch j ;J. xjj..-j ;. L . .... 1 / ' x 1. t . l v ` i> js. . . m . *./ X t # _ /; -,,V! Af*.** #*..% */*>,>*%' \ ,w *W Tho r o p o r t hciv.viV h v r ito n to f . <?o-**lo v i t 'i :.*u. n^r-jiriti^ioi n i 1*11 o.t.^1o;"ooo oX ihn Cu.;: CUm : ,7 Y .lllo C o ., / phcnl-io, .;uc. t . f; 04 0 .JV'loyocs oX tho C oryorr tio : 0 - C-l C: , th o r o o r l - ; . v i i non Cr*. r r;i *.*v llii.o , f>.l3 o l ThotrCorC r .i r .r r , .uo. 40 oX il Vi - C rjj'irn f* Co. v.oro oircinij.oC. 1;,* i'r . h. jUsvn.-.Mor. uno J>r. Josopb V.vr-t'v, vho porfomio tho j hy:-j!?. ;?io n o ar.d rc-rr;' e r o in a tiv /j.c . r o r jc c M v iO y . Tho ''.'or orr.r'ir.riiionc '-oro r i i , crior.-jocl b" j3ot r e c e p ih v -rr*y erto-ileo lior.t. i r e . Stovor.sor. gj.S o:'m,'.3non 07 non; b u i ri n e; 17 o f il: oso wo:*. varo ro-o-.- 7\v no 1 h ij.cluJji.r, iioii ir. i-y I J o t . l>rn* ifccv/-..*.r-n ' * t t c r r r i o f l or th o i r v o r); ir. rovo. b o r 1U21.?. . e ......* roro dono i r fui;.* liT.O i n Aubonion, juI i 1* . 'y !. . 3 0 3 ii j.oo uiO'ti Tao Aobonton oj.rt Vhotirfi ; v 0 r r n vr;:*.v 05: - rJs-iilnr v itli ro o ro o t to o/jo d ir t r i b u t i on tir.rt 30 l;h o l `o r r io o in iho asb n eto o ir.Aunti*^, Im t r c c i n ll y cjvj oo-ti.- om lonliy tho tvo groupa nro muoh r.lifco. * * f * Tabi I pivoo th np.o f l i s t r i b u ti o n o tho mor. n-.d TnVilo I I th o die t r i b u t i on oocordir./ to lonr.th o i r r p ; j r ! 1 ir. tho nobootoo in d u stri 00244 a/ ,. ..v::A .. i < V ! J m V < * j.'To V- i j J m it `i r ; i i... ? .* *i j\ . i. ^j .*ij* . '*. -: i JVL* 1 A; i Tho r e p o r t h o iv '.v ith yr~Lor.tcC, ` o - l c v if. o*:---..ir.-ti\>, o f l'< 1 err.,-loaron o f th o Cl;: Jt i* J..*>.:-;./ . v i l l e Co. , / :; r: s to vUO. . :' 0 4 o . i y l n y o c s o f >r.' tio i: o f c- , t* i :> :*oo. X t t i n o j ; Cn :.:ihC, I] :f lOtrCorJ r . i r . r r , .xio. 4 0 o. th C .-;:'ir.n J ohur-h* .-;ril; o Co. v.orG G;:r;:i.\ci. by >y. j l.ivo.uv-, r;; Jr. Jo sop' V ,vr-tlt vho yorform ou th o r t i ono er,a c:-r; y c r u c in e t i une roryee W viOy. i;-: '*"0 r 0"fV.ir.r:liO)ic *"Csro r i i , cror..ocl by ;ao, o s c e n i V- v -r'-y err* iinr li.or.i.- Je lu ;.l'y , 2 r c - tovor.sor. a.i.C, C o::;i.:5aon 07 tzon; nut e in e ; 17 o f tareco wor. vorn v e - - no i ni ii.cluJi.r. tlic-.i ir. y l i s t . r r r . Sfcov- -i*. 1 t c - r r i n<l or th o i r v o ri; 3* Covo. b o r lUIt*. o .... *; i. * voro ')<;o ir. i;iy ltT.O iti Auho;; to n , 5 - ***. '.i i i. J *iO uxO'*(i j . . X J Z O * Tho-Asbonton oufl TIi o t i o r ; o r r n v.v*;; C3: - *5;i51nr v it h r o o r o o t to op,o ir t r i b u t i on r.r.rt 3oj:-.i;h o > ir 'r r io o in tho a s b e sto s in Axistry* b u t r a c i a l l y :r no:.- A o.T.lcnlly tho two groups nro injieh r.lilio . * Table I rfv o s the ripe d i s t r i b u t i o n o f the me*. / P*.* Tcxlile I I tho d ie tr ib u tio r : aoeordir/* to lonr.th o f re c * i in tho f.sbocton industry \ 00244 A /. T /) B 7. r. / .o s D i5T ?.iB 37i'-: o r />-.r!" ;-.T03 v o m i s A rresto s I. .*OM> vrV cr ?crcor*-r-o 3.:> - .V.- : * n .i * M '/ * .* 1i f IW*.* 37 .0 ;*r . *:*n ! cr i* r 1 7 .0 i t t **0 * ^ * /n*vf io . n ... rJ% . 35 1 1 7 .7 i .*0 - '*4. ! m j us.n i 14 J1 1 0 .0 i J.f) , r .` : M Ii 2 .1 : * * *#| S 1 Ji 0 .7 i i *! ro - tr. ' 1 ti 0 .7 en - r? ! 3 0 .7 1 ij 1 0 ,7 ! f * M ' .* T . i 3/i3 _L 1 0 0 .0 0 i.'o tfu rr? ''5*/* j i 2 f) t 6 4 ! ir. i 7 1 * 0 4. 6 i- 1 rt i. ! M * *f O. ' J ? .1 7 v. 'V 1 lt.O te 1 1 .3 V .4 13.1 * 1 .3 i 1. ! ~~ i ij i 1 i __ J\ JJ J J Jit Xr.IlGTU OP SKSVICS IS A|iU.X*o' o f rerrlo o . A sb esto s I Jhrriher l PorcontnTO 0 -4 44 SI .8 n - 65 46.1 10 - 14 11 7.0 15 - 10 10 7.1 50-84 4.3 85 - 29 1.4 r o - r-4 1.4 * t ^ -.7 / o.-mIArt" ! U > t!i T OTA 1 141 100.0 A3T43703 r:W TK Y T hetford Tlinon ;:nrber P o re o n tv n o 1.05 14.0 14.0 16 9.0 1 C .7 1 C .7 1.05 r a n HT5..17--TMTL-r- I 54 JI_ 1 0 0 . 0 I t w i l l bo n oted th n t whilo CO p o rc o n t o f tho mon in T h etfo rd UinoB -wore over 40 y e a rs o f ego only 20 p e r c e n t o f th e men in A sbestos v?ero o v er 4 0 . And f u r th e r w ith ro sp o o t to le n g th o f oorvice GS.4 poroont o f * th e men errimi nod in th e tf o r d Hinop had worked i n the ao be sto b Industry for 10 yonro or more, but in Aeboetoi i o n ly 22 p e ro e n t had vrorkod f o r moro than to n y o a ro . i ' ' !; Table III shows tho disposition of the men in various parts of the1industry Sinoe tho numbers are nmnXl Vronfl ouottrniinnrjl *r o t * M ' ' viiu* ir* Anbontoo tho occup ations nro dividofi in to Z croups - m i l l , p i t and f a c t o r y ; in T hotford Xlinoa o n ly tho f i r r t tr:o o c c u p a tio n a l c r ,iro aro u so d , o in oo no nobontoe m anufacturing ic o rrrio d on th e ro .. A ll # tho non o f tho Thetford Hinoc croup could bo so c ir c o i f io d , b u t 5 mon v>ero oxolufiod from tho A obooton croup oinoo thoy d id c o t cpyoar to bo erposod to an unuouol amount o f d u s t. iia?*rn o f norrioo 0- A ii j ': ! i i i ! H r- y ' .AG 10-1A 6 -ir -in ro-r.^i r r --r.n : o-: a r.r-:*o / n . 7 S 3 1 1 l 1 1 VJTM 1 69 T A B IE III 0? S3EVIC7. BIT; ^ i RCUPATIOV3 iv. ' 3 *V-T-V / kSTThrros ! B rillin n r11' i Pno^ory till Tuy/rT-r? i : i ; M,*.t, P rillin'* P it t 7 24 1 0 U 3 r> . 6 i ! 3 1 ' 1 ,'1i i 1 7 i 1 12 0i 0 l 4 1 1 1 i i 1 I 27 i it <*. I t 0 ! 1 40* n i ii i t 40 ! 1 n K Tho past occupational history la industries i I ' othor thnn the asbestos Industry w o oicnifioont only in 5 oases* Of those ono had boon a c ^ i n ioopootor 00244 fo r 6 yonro nnO so eupoood to vory duaty o o n d itio jm , nr.* h -a boon an undorcround ooppor minor f o r 18 yor.ro, one o ooppor minor fo r 2 y e r r s , a fo u rth had roi'kod in o oomont p la n t fo r 9 y o n rn , ond tho f i f t h had op eratod a d r i l l in nn ir o n m ino. Tl/io l a s t in d iv id u a l ohovrcd ~-rr.y oviCor.oo o f p n ou u ocon iooiu , tho othoro did n ot havo pr.ovunoconiocis. Ir. Table IV uro pivor. obcorvatio.no o f vajight in r e la t io n to h o ip h t by ap,. Tho nvoruge 'volRhtD aro tsGion from tho fig u r o e com p ii od by tho ;cce i a Lion o f L ife InuuriU.no H iro cto ro and tho A o tu a r ia l S o c ie ty o f A noriou. T A B I *# TJTT* eights ;;i' )! aoco*d i :.;q to i Bound n Vnflor nv-orr^o Boundo ovov C T o r -c i no-no 1 *T >r. i.n . 21 i o - i o ! n-o -4 to U D-0 j i 20 10 PA ! 10 10-3.0 1 20-20 1 19 * l 0 ! m .o .00.0 ir*.o 17.1 i I 11.4 i 1 2 .0 ! ! ! (A ..... y , t n . i 1.1 o . 11 10 ! o i : ! r. : 7 x j ' n. *.i. JO, (VO =n3 It w 10.7 Ti*.'us't r i a l v^v/.o-n !.2 ____L i ____ 2 0 .4 10 14.0 11 lo .v . 21 ! n.n ! 1 1 : 0 11.1 12.0 ' J I ; i ,l 14 i 10 j The group o f 10,000 roalo indue t r i n i ro rk o r s ro - I j forxjod to in the obovo jtablo r/ao studiai! by tho Uni tod . i * S t? to o T u b ilo E o a lth Soryioo ( goo T u bilo H e a lth H u llo t i n i lo. 162). I t w ill be notod th a t thoro Is very l i t t l e d iB tin o tlo n between th is larg e group and the group of BBbostoe w orkers so f a r .a s degrees o f overw eight o r underweight aro oonoorned. In the consideration of individual defoots 8000 in te r o o tir .g f& ots have beon found. In t h i s study only the 101 men a t A sbestos and tho 54 men a t T hotford H ines aro c o n s id e re d , sin ce th e re c o rd s o f th e mon ex amined by D r. Stevenson aro n o t s t r i c t l y oomparablo w ith m ine. TEETHt D iv id in g th o .ao n in to tv/o groups aooordir.g to w hether th e te e th did o r did n o t nood a tto n tlo n , of the . AobOBtos group 4 9 .5 fro q u iro d a tto n tlo n , and o f the T hetfo rd Wince group 51.8 H/ftIKG : - ' Aouity of heoring was tostod by meons of a wntch. fliy ora hearing, uhioh In b been tontod by an audlometor, wao considored norinai, and U Bed as a standard) ; * i The w&toh test b odmittedly vory rough. In noisy ooou- f\ pations impnired hearing is froquontly found in th oldor employees. i Of th 101 nen at Aobestoe 10 showed definito j b.nrlns Io b . Thla la noi on axoaaa proportion elooa an.- 00244 > ro u r' o f a d u lts v.111 chow,a c ira ila r p i c t u r e . In T h etfo rd U inee 20 o f tho 54 men s u ffe re d from Troll marked h earin g lo s s . . This i s a very high poroont0.30, ond oomparable to v h a t nay ho found in Yrervin/* ehods and b o ile r shops. A ll thoso men, e x o e p t.tv o , had boon exposed to loud noir.e in t h e i r vrork f o r 10 yoare or n o re, and i t I b reasonable to suppose th a t noise played a p a rt in th o ir hearing d is a b ility . ' Tho nunbor o f non v l t h in fe c te d TONSILS rras 27 in A sbestoo and 13 i n T hotford U inoe, and a l most in d e tic a l r a tio to tho to ta l in both groups. D e fe o ts o f tho THYROID vroro r a r o . 4 non in A sbestos and 1 in T hetford Ilinos had enlargod th y ro id s . BIPOD rrasnU TS:- .IiondingB r?oro rooordod in a l l non ovor 40 years o f ago. Sxoopt in e x c e p tio n a l oircunotnoos the blood p ro sm tre ta n not token in the younger mon. Consequently although the .groups oxrm inefl in Thotford Ulnes vas smaller than that in Asbestos more blood prosnuro readings trsro taken thore. 2 men in Ashontos had blood proseures of ovor ISO and 2 blood prosouros t under 100 xr.a* of mercury. 8 mon in Thetford Jlinos ! had blood pressures of ovor 150 and 2 blood pressures under 100. # 1 . 00244 The inoidonco o f 1b o f in te r e n t from th o com pensation s ta n d p o in t. In ABbostoB n i l now onp- loyoos must p ass a p h y sic a l exam ination before employ m ent. Thore trere 4 canon, of in g u in al h o rn ia discovered among tho 101 men oxaainod th o r o . In -a d d itio n to theeo 5 men had been oporatod upon f o r t h i s c o n d itio n In Tholforfl Hinoo phyoical crim in atio n 1b not roQUirod b o fo re employmont. There T?oro 5 o ases o f i n g u in a l h e r n ia anong the 54 men examined and 2 oaeoa rh ic h had beon operated upon. Some i n t e r e s t h as a rio o n i n oonnootion v/ith tho ooourronoo o f tho so -c a llo d 7t5BT;ST0S COTwIS. Thene a re u s u a lly p in bond oizod o lo v r.tio r.s o f tho ak in , aomor h a t lik o m inute T a r ts . "'inn o f thoBS Tore d e te c te d in th e A aboatoo mon probably duo to my ignoranoo o f t h e i r rp p o a ra n o e . 8 o f tho T hotford H ines mon hod thono g ro rth n on th o lr hands and sovoral o th e rs re p o rted having thorn a t ono tia o o r a n o th o r. Vi *. ) 1 | ) ' | 11 j f' i . \ i t t ** (. * Of tb e 101 moa examine by me a t Aoboetoo only 4 B ufferd from d e f in ite f i r s t stogo pneumoooni o s i s These w i l l n o t ho oonaiderod on aooount of tho doubtful diagnosis* Of th 40 inen oxaminod by P r s . Stovcncon and V'y o t t 14 r e r o diognosod re f i r s t Btnge pneumoeon- io o i s (a s b e s to o is 1) ( I ma in c lu d in e th 17 mon ox- aminod by P rs* Stevenson and V/yatt and subooquently ro-exarainod hy me in my group of. 101}* * The much lo o o o r in c id e n c e o f pneum oconlosis in my group o f mon moy soom e n ririo ln g , b u t i t must he ronomborod th o t tho X-rny n e g a tiv e s r e r e n o t road by tho corno mon* In my group i tho T-rny diagnosos vero nade by Pr* K orirothor of P itc h e r , Oklahoma, and in tho o th o r group tho intorjrro?- tn tio n B r e r e by P r s . Vtyatt and r v.no-o o o t. . F u rth e r tho rmp oxaminod by Pro* Stovonson and tfy a tt r<oro, in gon- e r a l , o ld e r th o n thoso i n my group. Of th 54 men examinod a t T hotfor Hinn 24 re re dlngnosed hy X-ray as su ffa rin g from pnownoooniools ( r n b o s to e ip ) , o f th e so 4*.r a r e dictgrtosed &b probnbly f i r s t stano asb e sto sis, 0 as early stogo, as d e fin ite f i r s t stege and 5 as sooond stage* j The pertinent fa e ti r e g a r d e th doflt&e eaooo of aebeetele ore circo In tableo V end TI. Tabie V . i; Ui-;,- y-j i n f i l i A"9 Oceu.-ntlonnl M *'tor;' ar/*.* }4* ** rx -jn .t ______ Aobor.ton Crou:. </> A .l yj Pcrenn cycluao n*' yonro cu >'* *.o?i c lo n i o.r; miino .looy or strun./Ih occ, ere, ita lio ti 1 7 t a,*a.t. 71* A .l *7 [/nom i o ^ o rn to r vr,a!it fo ro v in COU^'l, V^i nna /o o r *\t, >iifiuu, ; o re fr-,.ont c j1*o u*rl?n U iii -'io i l r i '1 yo-irn , c.o al, c r* .it'U v i~ 11 uvor b.A $ li.M / A.l An cara in n njivlo.-* n< n in o r-a ! o l^ in . 111 *. fo rc -a n ` a* ye *rn . # , A.l i A r i l ia r 7 y o iro no o.T...t * no a* nor.vil r i ,nn. n * A .l Ai r . i l l a r l ^ 'it "I yonrn *3; P. tioa,e-.uji no nbnor al al.ym * 1 A.l t .% A .l T ::ot'r n tla .il-rit no r*y yt-'i:o fc r il yo r V- n i l l o r l s 'it 1% yonro n. n;"..,-V*..n fn in t ;jolnt r;iv:* * * '< rii* in rr-itit. no ni n o n .ti n li.110 n # A .l ?.* in lo u ro r * natelinan In d i i *1 yonrn no * n J i .M luinon- ri-*.'! la':>, l o f t r\-> *t o.-, -*(/ aura l ni r i 4; *t. ' ` ? f i A.l 1-M u ra r to,- f lo o r l ir c tl roo'iA* 't v i *?*!' A ^ A.l : m A.l \.l ' 7 A.l A.l % oI A .l - y. A.l */t A .l 1 A.l " U l , * yonre no -w t \ . o . li -.rrh A/ in n i 11 Ifi yonr m t.,,yt'>n *a .iiliw ri'V it J ' .y atro no rysyt-*. .-n r.o nl*nr*.'U ni.,*!** r.t1**:i'ivo tii;;'iU y li.ltr* l /*.' .v o li in n i 11 ?.f yo- rn no v::t ml'sion 1J A Mino (tur:-. n o t o tn lo l) no tu .ilo ' n l * ya irn n*t r.\a * , vl r**,-iiit V. .vi A i l r i i l a r ' ymrr no u,, -4t *..n un i *v*i- t i *! ?; ' Al tiri i l or y o iro no ry. v Lu..p. no : ;w r..al rlii* r*) irli 1or A y-rarn no ir tru a tn ' yuan . t n u lru .it vocrV fil>i Uim ,T-* ./A*. . f irn :an yn-*ro * *7 d r i i l o r n yoara trac!: van *i yonro no b;m;,K Ira n ciii a l mini i * l o r i Di-in ' ;;; "A j*ijo eovorer no oyuytoit no abnorm i nir^io. - , < ' r ic lo rv ) A y(>ro *< . ..U. *-*' " . ' .;-i'7:Sf ' >/" " :.VY .f v-7\ ^ - .*.**- - 00244 ______ nJ. dily. ~ ~n in h ._________________ I r li.v x . A-'o_Ocru a t i on ) hi "ter;* '.fi- -r Thotford fiinnn Promt r.lj-no. ;i A.i p f i l l i n g bngn ^ yorao no oyryt uo eonrro o l ic :.o a la r ; -rt o il or 1*5 ye.*ra 1 rt both banvn i-culnd. t"1 /, Corevn ' yenm ? A. 1 ' d r i l l e r **'> ym ro * no ay yto .0 no abnor..nl i<l,,>a ` A.I :; oi*n:ior itt i l l * yro. dyrynea no al'M-'rjini nl*.nn (r/.. niilyi f i l l i n g s ba;;r* A yro, u a. *. y r ajl (e xrly ) M illwright P? yvaro ooeper 1 * yenm dye, con no nbnonAl cdu;*U o*;;*- oonrnn ern.-i l 'lion* coloration, l o f t n, ex bciilnd. Ooc, blo.td In njv.'.f.vn, 3^i lor:' of ~ai ;.it M A.l E.iilri'it 31 yearn c **!; o:t;-- dry r<i.a ovor r t , ciiu.it o d o r )li u n , behind, o "inni on 'rfit*i*rt dy:. .<*1, loos of `.tul.iht *. ta A.l V V; rob My) 1 : A.l V. if A.l A'. ( HiMy) n lllw rig h t ".1 ynaro d r i l l e r 11 yearn d r ille r 17 yeara n tr j:;tu eo;i,;h no ty .. t j ;a hti'tery of j-lo.irlny, ol*W *iio1 oeca ln ,.:l dry m l on n t l o f t bneo no :* .or..-*i ii;;nn nonbnor 1 rl;;to I :.a *v* (n rly ) 1 A .l O (erly) lllw rlg h l llr y.nro d r i l l e r Ar- yenro 0? t,b,o. lwyn*i-noa rio no *tlor.m nl**.i! w.ny oro,it tie n r l :'tt bnoo. V . A.l <*riy) d r ille r C yoaro Cer \l war;: in ;*lt ;.'0 oy i.*to~.o no abnoruvl nirtto **** A.l 1ri'i ' ym rn f i l l in,; ba; 1 year b l'.tiry o f no 1nvr ni pl*;:n * A.l (trly) la:t rbol yenro in - .iil J y .* T9 in tunnoi fooling J.(.: .o.ftyriu 1 i, 'V^l ' 'l ', no nl nor ..1 el (;no mto ootol t,b . e orun::er 1 ynaro in *. V A.l to cr*o)iorii yoarti no oy.*yt'to no p' nor >*tl 1 no (o n ly ) o:eo. or in t i l l A yro. o ile r in n i l i ? yoma f . A.l Ion line boson in p i t oIotorMio-i a nhvno a o f fin e crcyll"Vun **1 yo'iro, fooling o f t.b .o . b', !:<' lv.ith lungi bohind fro.t * Uio 1'iill * yearn r vortai ra duett,; oreyo'-ion 5 . note diulninh**! V A.1 V riyl alilw rlfj t j^yoaro forvjon V yearn dyn;tnca no itbnor.x! ninno I h A.l d- fo o lin g 0ro d or U' y n r dynpiioa oropl la ti otta in rl.n r.llln oloanltig In Bill H y ro . l . l oo-: bo`iul, I *1 A.l V f e e lin g erpo'ier in r i l l i no oy-.pIberna no il.no'ml eigen (.troiai!/) f y -a rt, drlere lyoar, f-rornn in m ill n yev* 7ault VI (co n tinuad) u Dina ro* HM:* Ai*. Ocnu. n tl ^*1 h trto ry ry " t rr * is.ni) Titotfor.'. **i*V'* r.rou4. (contM ' '} . A. i :'* (***riy) *>1 A.l -a (jirohthly) A.l T . T*' A.- I l T A.l A' U to) longing Vj ::o in ;-lt 'yrn, flrilln r * yro. o.[orator in f i l l .* yjjn., alllw rl":.t 1 ' yoarn oU 'ir ir. :A ll i*"! ra . for ah u l l l ;* yr*. .-Ill rt, airs 1' yrn. ".Il* Toro .an i' yrn. Foroam t- lll n yr.# ttlllw rich t 7.yr. na cy.j:to-o . O non -Ho! t.l>.C. 'i >.;Mv-r .'i.nn lu'.orculoni*. cwijJ, nco no nyu/toi in no n1>norn>l ni. tir. . ;|t`rc.f i*! l f r r r : --:it ovor rl<;t ln :r;, rio ri., t i*rj .1 ino , **vyr i u. t or lri f r -it o tj.a.ni-Mi }' *, r **v orc/i ! t i *ur i . : Iti r . n el (..*<, cr-, i n r . ' 1 u ; or In. i -t.t -i nv h^tM ! ir !* o i. .:> . y r* .; loor 't '.lern , tin r-*-, no limormi i . i .. .* . . ........... / Xt * i l l 1>o notv tim l.of ilio *'il btr. otv*. briod at. ArLorlop 17 iter- o n o l a i f i r i t ta<;o ailvootooi,' v illo o f Iho JJ' o si Ino*) n i TnolTor* r.1 oro d ln jn o ia J a i f i r o t o tv .o ani .tinnii an " ainccorv nta..o a* r ie r i . T li 1 o *l lo bo in la r , r o t c l n i in * .ic atih an osconn in Tiijir**r-* ?:inoi. Tjo in e ro a io l in o l'o n o e o f ;nou.onooor.lori in 7hnlf:r-1 c in n - in , * 1 n r o fio o tio n 0f tho tlif r n r o .it 'U rtrlw u tio n Triti ro, e t t* 1 lotijt! *if l a r v i c i . Jlnforenoi lo tn*>2on 1 ani .*! v i l i ro c a li tuo y.ro.al .Ui`r**r- oncon in theno Ivo thirir;. In Ih*? j;ro it stnjority of enson tu lon^tii of oorvico in ilnrty wor; v r moro tluin C ym r an in Ucttlo ' in lu ifo l l*orin tablot iV:;;tb Of r ir v i co ,.u.-l.cr of anco .'a-,ber o f .w r-.i Ir.ol. <n>-. y r i. *m 7;*U 1 . f; 7 1- a ovnr f Vt.*; Total /.1 t -, Tra i tbio tahlo on* coucli'io tb n t nn'.orlotw u in noi il:. ,]; iv Involo, o it!i in. is, 001TO of le m than '* y o tr i, k i t t h n t .Uh nnuro ;* toro Ibv f yaaru Ihoro io a ;rot ;o co b ility of i l levai \ In,*, I l 1, Inov'tr, of in to r o it to ro-iio-ler tn tm n y non vrit* lon^ J 5rlt*, i of en nrnr lo not bovolo, e ony i#* of nnbontoole. Ao lo oceu, nllontt of At d rllio ro 1 *n jro W*oe of nobo'itoeln, of l . ili worHor *7woro enooa o f imi Antonio An*l o f Ai' orrore in Ih* frr.l-.*r; * ! nly 1 cura elioto* x-rny oviltnoo o f tho Uoonao. EvHunUy 11u ro io iitlfci *I rfiffo ru io in tlio Inanrd in t a lli bori*# ami d r i* ln r u . ' 7'h--o--olimi.i or.....o...r.? ' * * 1 n.i*r lo lio ox'oiol to far r.roat0r 44?t eonewtnliorio l'*an tlm d riller " ~~~ ` II ' .. - . " . n -1 l i l o n t h o r d if f io u lt to undorrtdn't >iar tho high inel'lone i of nl orlenlo nnotij Iho d r ilio n Howovor, i t any r nny not bo of in lo ren l lo* nolo tv :# V f *'' ^ i f r r ,: ,-AVi**<j^V.V.> -,;f 6- '\;s:.\:`/ . 1 . V ;' ^ S v'^ . ' f'if' ! ' 'a .. A'' " '" ' ' :; r?'fy'". Twi iViiWrrilhi.fiil.. did not y in /o n l:.,;rrtint part l . tHo r** ir: tir *W^'s; *,*0*A0f :?Snnt8il* ft';*a*`o1 to ! eonylle.ttof vi lit:tWo tlA ^ ..\ ' jSfcfi'W. ''VM M :Hi*`IncHonco of d o f ln iti tuboreulooio in ih o |tio ?'Vy < . ; : 'W ' ' of i:!^ ?l-Wi;V O * fi/ A; j L .l ^ g .^ o 'f w r ; lo r . Thoro woro lovoral ur^ieVol oasoai on e lln le a l osv.innli v '`TpSpf. .''<?.V' . ` . ...'. * '. M*". , . :iAOVJ: :i' 'aA' ;''' ;VV ', /.rjlon i n not eonflr^ol x-rny iuP novoralout>c8to.1 cn*fn ; w v *.i'ii **:i y-i:AV*%.-' - AUJ.- iy; '';.a - ,;v'y ;.;.y' . : '<?# ; A oiiro* no f i l l o v l l o n o o l n t h o hi; ofrl^na an*i l y n / l ^ i . Only on* enr* In ^ f t i> |;ria 4.r enn \:y t nr.i*1<jril no n o tiv ijy tu'.orculouo. *VSv ' . * !' ''? ' ' m r ..d iffic u lt to obtain ; utu*.i Croc, aonViof Uj u i> -' ; v-jiv ;*r I P # : ;-^ rir " - - Vi-M A : : ? . ' - ' ' . : - ' - y Al^of^tM ' . rtjro c o u s in s .. About'1.*i o. i;tn r->ro o x a iln o /fu r tul-orcl- l -ciill C l * '. . 'r "; . fe* . .' .. . j ' '..;.*V-\-a.; ' ;VAAy . ' ; : 1,-p ^iMMOato V tlwt, no tmnrri to hoiltH rto o-*>.ooto3 in eonnoetlnn nllii ^r:V V V -- x ooWotn* nlnlnc an! n ilil n j in'uotry. :- p\A.i<L-rtj Dnon^oC45>itOii) i"iln ftor il I t Kl.iay bo onlA tisnl liv? Inr.irl of ;.nou ln ;l\i / i":'' d & M i f l , ' . : S L " ' > n'p/ffito* ulnlTif, an*i a l l l l n i ; ImUintry !in ijfinn Ao .onntr ilu 11 1*%t *?vi . A; . 1 not":1mpaol to- *" - vT M ililrljrAMooeLntol ^&;!.&'&$It-si;U;.' ........ .. [>7. V. j !: ..<v = : vVANA.-'; * ' . ... t _ * ^ , .' r . ... -