Document vVO6YGj7o9GL4DQbL0Ra8vEOY

CY-? AVAILABLE RECORDS OF THE PHILIP CAREY CORPORATION INDICATE THE FOLLOWING COMPENSABLE ASBESTOS RELATED WORKMAN'S COMPENSATION CLAIMS 1949 - 1971 Year Employee's Filed Name Last Address Ohio Industrial Conun. Decision_____________ __ 1949 Albert Johnson 3124 Fredonia Ave. Allowed for-Asbestos is Cincinnati, Oh. 45229 1958 Herbert Gooch 624 Vine Street Wyoming, Oh. 45215 Allowed for Asbestosis 1959 Clarence Hulette 9515 Crestbrook Allowed for Asbestosis Cincinnati, Oh. 45231 1960 Henry Hoerst 10109 Wayne Ave. Allowed for Asbestosis Death Claim allowed for Silicosis 1962 Roosevelt Cross 1964 Earl Bolds 2484 Williamsburg Dr. Asbestosis Cincinnati, Oh. 45225 625 Oak Street Wyoming, Oh. 45215 Silicosis and Asbestosis 1966 Harlan Williams 9880 Dick Road Harrison, Oh. 45030 Asbestosis 1967 Grover Hill 207 Sturgis Ave. Asbestosis Cincinnati, Oh. 45217 1969 Robert Neal 1082 Jefferson Ave. Asbestosis Cincinnati, Oh. 45246 Disallowed Death Claim 1970 Gilbert Daniel 811 Leggett Ct. Asbestosis Cincinnati, Oh. 45215 1971 John Swikard 1345 W. North Bend Rd Mesothelioma Cincinnati, Oh. 45224 P-CECGTEX 05* w .. . k . ... . -sstC-TW. mine __an c. COttftthUS i. CfJIO AXifNlTI 1 January 30, 1961 Vr. L. A. Pechstein, Assistant Secretary Hie ihilip C~ roy lunufaCturiiv' Co crony LocJclar.J, Cincinnati 15, Ohio Dear }s. Pechstein: Clnic OD-lC/'d'.'r - Clarence A. Hulette, Dec'd Asbestos!a - A; ril 13, 195? Po^th - .inly _______________________________ Clniu UL'-IC: i_ V-t - ;.oro-_-rt L. Gooch, D-c'd /sbestoeis - CcULer IS, 1953 Death - Ai-i;rt IS 1P,M Clain OD-10/VlC - henry u. licerst Asbestos!s - June IE, 1957 Totally Pi -nU I - 11 /l r/iQ________ # The first two oleins ere both scheduled .to be heard .^before the arcsa in ClncjtnruU cn FebruaryylO/rlVd!on the' question- ' of fclloo'-ir^'a doatn"'cvchf to 'the'widows or 'dependents.'" ' binder v.he ;.;fhdlcayj.t.d desreloye clossiiication. .. -9 9< 7. y;.. -'3:; % '' As whs r.onticnod uurinr^^jUsc.irplon.vith your rand>cro rurir." :.y rreent visit, ti. egcljt i<g$g$2air.s that liaYdbccn ! .'..in t ; our mr-i-riihe ? i n -rccentr ivfririn7iU~dliiar *clair'.s will un- V:; - 9' %Sf :vTjrvriAlBB.0eV$'rjfer.l.^rJrecihtoyreehtvicoun s elf s':Y e v< j.drt cr.i !l 1 bi.-yie.: to : rovi-ie idu. with any sJditiornl iiucrxaticn or csrister.ee t;. .t would bo, helpful. . . Yours very truly, JTCAb Join; T. CANTLO.'I e ASSOCIATES, INC. c ' Ldont A PCnSONAL ACTUAfllAL S C T{ VI c,. r. Exhibit 87 \ JT mu rnuir ------- i if IF January 31 > 1961 Kr. John ?. Centl'cn, rre'aidcnt ' . John 'P, Unntlcn .'.* Associates, Inc, ` ko v/. Third A VC 4""" . . C cliffs us 1> Ghlo - Claim GD-106,?.~6 - Clarence a! Hulctto, Dccfd Ashootosis - Arr.t.1 13, 1959 Drnth - .T;^*) r O , 19d 0 * C isi:,, Gu)~.lv-.:;?7a - Herbert; L. uccch, hoc'd Achoctests - `Ictchor 1-3, 1955 r,.-.. fi-. -- 1- 1';' *' Claim CO-iOVv-lC - :>':nry hearst - Astertoe is - June ID, 1957 - vHro.i- - 11ATA.0;_____________________ . * '' . _ .. : Dear .*!:< Cent2on: . .' . ' Then!: you for your letter of January 20- r . Mr, 0hcr.5hf.in end I conferred r.t the office cf ?nft, L-tettini'. and 1-ellistor yesterday, end I turned over to him cur cenplctc files on the Mulatto nrid Ocosh death c Inina. Mr, Cber.r.halri v/5.11 attend the hearings net on feezurury 10, I cun furnish!nr I'r, Ctenohniu a copy of your letter and ho ~ny he in. touch wit you if ho frola ho need 3 odd It tonal Infcrnetf.cn cr erristr.nsc, v;g kn\*9 drawn a drr.ffc of a letter to he furnished.to Dr, :..rebb I, Verye, an attorney at: Columbus, c ro ere cant s' the* Ohio funui'ecturerr. -Association of which we era a render. After the draft is polished, it will bo nter> r.unecr cnc in cur effort tc c! an;e the statute law to Inc 1''.do Anb c r C ce 1 s 'ith! n. tho pro visions covering tho henuiceuyou employees clear, if .lent: one 1. A, TechetcIn Assistant feerotary .. cc: A. Cbmshsin - Toft, ftettiniwo l: fclUsfcer - . r/v r. consuiti.nTi .\CTU.\itas w. naKO av;.. COIUMUUS I, OHIO AXiNrrn 4-U.S9 &pCembr 14, 1961 Hr. E. J. Faoold, Secretary The thill,) Carey Kanufccturing Cosrpany Dockland, Cincinnati 15, Ohio ' Dear Hr. Fusold: Workmen's Compensation Insurance Net rr" Hum r..-.ta - 1951 Claim CJ-1CJ274 - H. L. hooch Disabled 10/10/53 - Death S/15/60 Cost - C l,M37.c-0 Claim Cb-lUoddO - C. A. Ifuletta Disabled 4/14/59 - Death 7/3/60 Cost - 617,465.00 Clain CJ-10791U - H. H. Uoerst Disabled 11/16/60 Cost - $75,000.00_____________________ . . The cost in compensation and itodical expenses and reserves of the above three asbestosis claims v.r.s included as clvargcs against your company's experience upon which your 1961 tarit-rating codification was computed. Your 1961 merit-rating codification, as computed by the Bureau of Uorkcun's Compensation and released a feu days ago, is a carlt-rating credit of 151. We are now in the pvo:e6s of auditing your experience for the fiveyear period ended December 31, 1910, upon which this rate was based, and you will receive lurticr detailed ro; ores, a.d 1 will later consult with you axd your managers personally about tea experience and tho rate computation. At this time, no.-cvcr, I felt it would ba interesting for you to 1-now that tho cost of the above throe asbestosis clcica total $61,602.00. The inclusion of this cost in jour experience results in your r cv 11-rut ir.g cod ifio.-tion being 104 less than it von id have been without this ci-orgc. In ether words, without these asbestosis claircs, your merit-rating ne.1 ication would have been a credit of 35, instead of a credit of 1ST. This difference of 20T in your merit-rating modification would account for tn increase in premium, of about $16,000.CO a year, baaed on your current payroll, or about $1)0,000.00 over tho five years that these claims will effect your merit - rating isodii icatlon. Exhibit ibd Kr, E. J. Faaold, Secretary Tha Philip Carey lAnuiacturing Cocpany Lock.land, Cincinnati 15, Ohio 2Septeaber 14, 1961 IV . During our discussion last year of your experience and premium rata, 1 specifically caplvicired the fact tlmt the decline in your merit* rating codification fron its high of several years ago, was due pria-arily to the increase in the asbestosis claina being filed and paid. We pointed out that_becnuse of this precedent and tho activity in these claias, it is probable that mora asbestosis claims would ba filed in the future, particularly as employes reached retirement age or became dis abled duo to a combination of asbestosis end age. Tha potential liability therefore ia very great, and I will be glad to discuss this with you in greater detail at tha tii&a of oy next visit. Yours very truly. JTC/kb JOHN T. CAhTLON S ASSOCIATES, INC, <v. JoUii T. Cantlon, President - P "Cqlo'Vc* - lie BUILDING MATERIALS INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTS CINCINNATI 15, OHIO TELEPHONE: 82L3000 December 2, 1963 C A8L E ADDRESS "PHILC AYCO" Mr. John T. Cantlon, President John T. Cantlon & Associates, Inc. L(.0 W. Third Avenue Columbus, Ohio U.3201 2. EXHIBIT 1 c'///v'r^W / ^ OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH PROGRAM Dear John: We have given a great deal of thought to the question of whether to continue, modify, postpone or terminate the ex cellent services of Dr. Thomas P. Mancuso after October 1, 1963. We have concluded that the services should be post poned 'until the undertaking of corrective engineering mea sures and future study of our health problems indicate the need of his additional services. We appreciate all that has been done in determining the scope of the health problems and the work required in designated critical areas. Please extend our thanks to Dr. Mancuso. Since much of the services consists of observation of ex posures, sickness and mortality and an evaluation of our operations, we assume the data collected will not be dis closed except to our personnel. Sincerely, L. A. Pechstein Assistant Secretary RECEIVED DEC 2 1963 JOHN T. CiMU:l Cr ASSOCIATES, INC. Oe u.'t (f UtUNiULTi.NG ACTUASJ 5 . V7 thuis avx. COLUMBUS 1. OHIO AXiiismi 4-4CS9 January 30, 1961 Hr. L. A. Pechstein, Assistant Secretary The Philip Carey Manufacturing Company Lochland, Cincinnati 15, Ohio Tear Kr. Pechstein: Claim 0D-106226 - Clarence A. Hulette, Dsc'd A-sbestcsis - Anril 13, 1959 Death - July P, I960 Claim GD-iC<E274 - Herbert L. Gooch, Dec1 a Asbestooio - October 13, 1956 Death -- Avgust 15. i960 Claim 0D-107910 - Hc-nry N. Ho erst . Asbestosis - June 12, 1957 TotrJ.lv Disabled - 11/15/CO The first two claims are both scheduled to be heard before ;ae Lureau in Cincinnati on February 1C, 1961, at 1:15 p.m. cn the question of allowing a death auard to the widows or dependents. " Ve have discussed the claims at considerable length and have unt you numerous reports on the questions rosed by these three claims, and ve .'lievs that-you would vamt ycur counsel, Mr. Cbcnsh-ain, to attend these .arings so that he will be familiar with the claims and can determine whether there is eny basis for petitioning the Commission for relief in these claims under, the handicapped employe classification. " As was mentioned during my discussion with ycur managers during my recent visit, these are the three most costly claims that have been charged against your emperience in recent years and similar claims will un doubtedly arise in future years. Ue would appreciate rrcsivi: port and will bn glad to -provide him with any -assistance that would bo holuful. copy cf ycur counsel's mo tional infermatien or Yours very truly, n X UN,r C Cl e to Hr R. u. Locklnnd,