Document vBNkeGOn6X2M250nL4GMeMq46
UNITED STATES
*UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
ENVIRONMENT
PROTECTIONBoston, MA 02109-3912
AGENCYReg5 Piosto Ofnfic e S1qua
re, Suite 100
Sent via Electronic Mail (Dated as shown on electronic signature)
Joe Ciesla, Owner
Apple Road Gravel Site
PO Box 87
Webster, MA 01570
Joedciesla@gmail.com
Subject: July 21, 2023, EPA Inspection
Dear Mr. Ciesla:
On July 20, 2023, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (" EPA ") performed an inspection
at Apple Road Gravel Site in Brimfield, MA, regarding compliance with the National Pollutant
Discharge Elimination System (" NPDES ") program of the Clean Water Act. A copy of the
inspection report is enclosed with this letter.
Based on observations made during the inspection, it appears that the site is subject to EPA's
NPDES Multi - Sector General Permit for Stormwater Discharges Associated with Industrial
Activity (" MSGP ") See https://www.epa.gov/npdes/stormwater-discharges-industrial-activities-
epas-2021-msgp. Discharges of stormwater from sites that fall under Sector J of the MSGP
(" Mineral Mining and Dressing ") are not authorized, unless such a facility obtains coverage
under the MGSP or an individual NPDES permit.
Within 14 days of this letter, provide:
1) a plan for completely eliminating stormwater discharges from industrial activities at
the site; or
2) a plan and schedule for obtaining MSGP coverage for stormwater discharges from the
site; or
3) if you disagree that stormwater discharges from the site require MSGP coverage, a
statement explaining why you believe such coverage is not required.
Please provide a response to Andrew Spejewski at spejewski.andrew@epa.gov. If you have
questions about the MSGP compliance, contact Alex Rosenberg at rosenberg.alex@epa.gov.
Legal issues may be directed to Jeff Kopf, Senior Enforcement Counsel, at kopf.jeff@epa.gov or
(617) 918-1796.
1 For more information related to Sector J see: https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-
10 / documents / sector_j_mineralmining.pdf
ED_019088B_00000183-00001
Sincerely,
Todd Borci, Manager
Water Compliance Section 1
Enforcement and Compliance Assurance Division
Enclosures:
Inspection Report for July 20, 2023, EPA Inspection
CCs (electronic only):
Mary Grover, MA DEP < Mary.Grover@mass.gov >
Jeff Kopf, US EPA
Andrew Spejewski, US EPA
Alex Rosenberg, US EPA
2
ED_019088B_00000183-00002