Document v1xajpgyaMjagGm8RpG6k7RyY
FILE NAME: Caterpillar (CAT)
DATE: 1954
DOC#: CAT049
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: US Dept of Labor Bulletin - Workmen's Compensation 1954
PROCEEDINGS--40tk Annual Convention of the International Association of Industrial
Accident Boards and Commissions, Quebec, Canada, October 3-7,1954
Workmen's Problems
1954
BULLETIN 180 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
James P. Mitchell, Secretary
BUREAU OF LABOR STANDARDS Paul E. Gurske, Director
AL SMftl
Foreword ofTthheis4B0tuhilaentninuaNl coo.n1v8e0n,tcioonntoafintshteheInptreornceaetdioinngasl Association of Industrial Accident Boards and Com missions, which was held in Quebec, Canada, October 3-7, 1954. forPproucbeliecdaitniopnobfythtehecosntvaeffntoifonthheavBeurbeeaeun opfreLpaabreodr Standards. ru
w%
9
s&
%
126
1954 MBBTINO OF IAIABC
Occupational Cancer Hazards
V .ImD d. aHmo,t pUe.eS .MP.uDbl.i,cCHheieafl,thESnevrirvoionem, eWntaaslhCinogmtoenr, SDe.ctCio.n, Cancer
A. Scope
ofOyecacrusp.atUionndaluecaenxcpeorsuhraezatordasgheanrtse opflaoguurendamtuaranlkeinndvifroornmtheonutsasuncdhs
as solar tobium,
rhaadrieatidoonuobrtleinssfleyctiboenesnwriethspothnesibwleormfo,r
Schistosoma hema* the occurrence of
tchane cbelrasdodferthaemeoxnpgosfeadrmsekrisn oafmthonegNoiuletdvoaolrleywoervkeenrsduanridngofprceahnicsetorroicf
stiommees. 15H0oyweeavresr,aigtowtahsantootcucnutpilatthioenaaldvaenndt oinfdmuostdreym-reilnadteudstraiagleinsmts
hNaovteoantltyainareed oaccpurpeaetmioinnaelntcaprocsinitoiognenisnththeeohnulymwanellcadnecfeinredprkobnloewmn.
icnacurseeasseodf hsuinmcaenPcoatntceinrs,1b7u75t tfhiersitr nreulmatbeedr tahnedovcacruirertyenhcaevoefstsecardotilayl
canOcuerr raemaolnkgncohwilmedngeey sawndeepapsptoretcbiaotiiroenxpoof soucrceutpoastoioont.al cancer pro
ducing agents as phenomena of modem industrialism dates back some
F io n a * 1.
OCTOBER 6-- MORNING SESSION
127
s7k5inyecaarnscewritahndthaendoicsccuopvaertiyonoafltehxeproesluarteiotnobcoetawl teaern(tfhige. o1c).cuTrrheencdeatoaf gaidvdeintioinnsthteo ftohlleowininfogrmtaabtlieosn(1onanodccluap) abtrioienfalyl scuamncmerarhizaezathrdessamliaednet since that time. They list the various chemical and physical agents sTohefayr srheocwog, nmizoedreoovrerst,rothnegldyifsfuersepnetctoedrgaansscaanudsestisosfuceasnrceeprriensenmtianng. cthanecetarrcgaestesorpglaancsedofonthreesceoradgeonrtsknaonwdnthtoe hnauvmebbereenofroeccocugnpiazteidonaasl caused by them.
Table I.-- Occupational Cancers Recorded in the United Slates and Foreign Countries up to 1958
Agent
Sitesofsaucer cNaInnucUme.rSbc.eAars.o.efs('cNIannucmEeurbrceoarpsoeefs Total
ACorsaelntiacr..,..p...i.t.c..h..._.._.._._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._._._ _S_k,dine._._________ 1170 3,15205 3, 26302
SPheatrloeloeuilms__________________________________________. ...d o ______ 707 1, 92090 1, 90979
Lignite tar and paraffin........................ Creosote oil............................................
.
.
.
d
o
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1. 4104
4114
Anthracene oil.......... ........... ............... ...d o ............ ______ 20 20
Soot-carbon black................................. Aromatic amines...................................
. B. . ldadod.e. r. ______
350-4001
1,210900
1,610901
Roentgen- and radium-radiation___ 1(SLkeumk.e. m. . i.a.... (?)16 (?)13 (?) 29
Arsenic____ ______________ _____ Ih3ulmlgg....-.-..-.-.-..-.-. 7 65106 65203
ACshbroesmtoast.e..s........................................................................................ --. *,,ddotx........ . 2725 6635 18450
Nickel________ ________
__ ______
J( X. .udsoal. ...e..a.v..-... 1 ity.
0
84 51
84 51
Coal tar, pitch....................................... (NLuasnagl--s-i-n-u-s. 0 53 53
PBeetnrzoolel_u_m______________________________________________ Leukemia... U 3313 4420
Isopropvl................................................ (fLLaurnyngx.,,.,._.__ 41 00
41
Radioactive
chemicals_____________
(1BNoansaels.s..i.n..u..s... 1Nasal sinus.
90
00 0
96 3
*
Total..........................,..... ........... --.................- 750 7,650 8,400
1Approlimate.
128
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
T able 1a.-- Time Table of Discoveries of Occupational Cancers
Name ofagent i1 Dai 1j Discoverer :; Organs affected l|Nature aiespiare
Chemicals--'Organic: SOOt..................................
1775
Pott............................. Skin (scrotum)....___ Occupational.
Coal tar (lignite).............. . Coaltar (bituminous)___I
11887962
BVuoitklltnn.a..n..n......................................... ..S..k...ind.o.._.._.._...._.._.._.._..*....................
Do.
Do.
Coal tar (anthracite)....... 1 1910 Zweig...........................
Do. Do.
CArnetohsroatceeonfel.o..i.l......................................
1920 1908
O'Donovan................. Skin............................ * Oliver...........................
Do. Do.
Paraffin oil (shale oil)___' 1876 Petroleum still coke.........j 1890
BDeelrlv..i.U...e.....a..n..d......G...u..e..r.-.. ,,.,,,,.do.........................
DDOo.
Petroleum paraffin oil__ ! 1910
monprez. Schamberg................... -.-.do.......................
Do.
PSehtarloelleuubmricluabtirnigcaotiinl.g...o..f..l..
11993100
Heller........................... .......do.......................... Wilson.......... _............. .......do...........................
Do. Do.
Bemol............................... 1928 Delore Sc Borgoraano, Blood-forming
Aromatic amines (dye [ 1895 Reha............................ Bladder, ureter, kid-
DDoo,.
intermediates)* ^ Isopropyl oil......................' 1952
Weil, Smyth & biale.. Nanseayl.sinuses, larynx,
Do.
Chemicals--Inorganic: *
lung.
11AR227 i Paris _____________
Skind.o....................................................
Da, Medicinal.
Asbestos
......... *..........
11995.3
f SLayunpceh..S..i..S...m....i.t.h...*..,......-.....
Lung.............................
Occupational. Do.
1935 1932
Pfeil ............................ Grenfell....................... Nasal cavity and si-
DDoo..
atenta
!
nuses, lung.
Ultraviolet radiation....... 'j 1894
Onna............................
Stir,,.
...................... .
Do. Environmental
iloentgwi-radfaikm.
1902 Frihhpf},....... . 1906 Ws$s*_,
..,,..do*...,...,,do,,
Occupational, Medicinal.
j 1911
Von Schwurt A IBom!-forming von Shhcnrock,
Occupational.
I 1922 B c d r..,, .,, ,, ............. B o n e ................... Medicinal.
Rrulioar(>va substances.. 1879 flaming .0 Hb w ___ Lun$L-... 1923 MoXr.il, Ward mill kin.............
Occupational. Do.
im Willis ................. Blood-forming , Do.
m i .Mauiamt..... .. . . . . . . Bone.,,...*,...,**.,* Do.
theHoawcteuvaelr,scaoilpeinodfiscthriemoincactuepaatcicoenpatlanccaencoefrthheaszearfdigsuwreosualsd rseefrleiocutisnlgy
bcaenmceisrlehaadzianrgdfsorhtahse sfoollfoawrinbgeerenaseosntasb. lisThhede pfroerseonncleyofaofcecwupwatoiorknearl
glirsoteudp.s hWavhinilge, cfoonrtaincsttawnicthe,ointeisorgesneevrearlallyokfntohwencatrhcaintowgeonrikcerasgeenmts
polfopyeetdroilneugmas swtiollrsksananddhcaovailngtasrkdinistailnledrireessporireantograygecdonintatchtewciltehancionagl
athned spkeitnr,olaenudmappiptcahrenantldy taalsros,hoofwthaen leuxncge,sstihveereliadboielistynotot ceaxniscteranoyf
official
worker
reincoarldumoifnusmimiplaror dcuacnticoenropulsanctos.m.wphliecraetioannsexapmoosunrge
etolecfutrmodees
OCTOBEB 6-- MOENING SESSION
129
ipreotmrolethuemecleockterodeexsistcso. nsRisetilniagbloef ianfmorimxtautiroeno, fhocowaelvtearr,, ipsitocnh,haanndd tthheatrethsepsierawtoorryketrrsacstu.ffeTr hfreomexcteanntceorfs othfistheexspkoisnuraendh,apzoarsdsibmlya,yalbsoe eesleticmtroatdeed cbayrbothne isfaccotntshuamteadppforor xeiamcahteplyoutnwdoo-tfhimrdestaollficaapluomuninduomf Sprtoadteusceind,1o94f5w. hich 800,000 short tons were consumed in the United havIte icsaeuqseudalloyccsuigpnaitfiiocnaanlt cthanactearsgeanmtsonwghiwchorhkearvse obfeeann rienpdourstterdy toof oanneidceonutnictrayl,idnodunsotrtyseoefmantoothhaevrectohuenstraym, eifetfhfeectauvpaiolnabtlheedwatoarkwerosuoldf bfuonadcacmepentetdal atditsheeaisre-fpacroedvuacliuneg. prSoipnecretiecsarcliinkoegepnasthboegheanviec inmtihcreoir oanrgyandiissmtisn,ctthioenrse iisnnothseoirunadctrievaistyonotro eafsfseucmtiveetnheasst cfaorrcinanoygennsatmioankael rperaeshoennss.ibleIndifsaccret,paintciceasnarbeemsahionwlyncltuheatto slouccahl dscififeenrteinficceaslloyf rinecpoomrt ingTohfeoecxciustpeantcioenoafl acnanecxecrecssaisvees.liability of gas house retort and coke oCvaennadwao, raknedrs Etongclaanndce,rbouft tnhoet lfurnogmhaansyboeethnerrecpoourtnetdryfrdoemspiJtaepathne, ftiaocntsthaartethideeenxtipcoasl.ureTchoendoitciocunrsrefonrcewoorfkearns eamppprloeycieadblien snuucmhboepreroaf saerscetinciicdecsawncaesrsplaocfedthoen srkoicnordamdounrigngGreercmenatnyueasersrs. oIff faursllencirceadlenicne Swtoautelds,boengeivweonultdo breeploedrtstoonbealriesveneicthcaatnacresrcsnoiebaslesrvinedouinr pthaertUonfitthede wAogralidn, airteiscahracrindogtoeniacssufmore atlhmaot starseexncilcuaslisvewlyoumldedmicaiknealsurecahsodniss. ctiinncotgioennsic.ityAofsilmubilraircastiintugatoiiolsn osbeteaminsedtofroemxistpectroonlceeurmninign dthifeferceanrt ipnavretsstoigfatthoerswdourlrdin. g Arelctheonut gyheatrhse,resewveerraelphlaucneddreodn creacseosrdofbyskEinngclaisnh cneortshindugoistoofoficcciualplyatioknnaolwnconatsactto, wthieth elxuibstreicnacteinogf osiulsc,hpirnadctuisctarlilayl dtoisebaesecsonfrtoemnt twheithcoautntrtirbieustionng thheisresitdhee oEfntghleishAtolbansetircv.atioOnnse tsoeetmhes cwaarscindoisgceonnitcinaucetdiodnuorfinshgalteheoi1ls9,2t0h'es, laanrgde-tshcearleefoinreducsatnrniaoltuascecoofuwnthifcohr tmheechmanoirces, reencgeninteeErsngalinsdh octahnocrerwocrakseerss ohbasveirnvgedhaadmeoxncglussipviennceorns, tact with lubricating and cooling oils of petroleum derivation.
130
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
theIrteishawsobrteleinnoatninaglminostthicsomcopnlneetectliaocnktohfatpudbulriisnhgedthaeddlaitsiton20s tyoeatrhse, lfirsotmoftohcecuUpnaittieodnaSl tcaoteasl,taarl,thpoitucghhasnudchcrecoasnocteersoihl acvaencberesenofotbhseersvkeind tahnadt athree raencnouradledrepaosrstsucohf tihneiCndhuiesftrIinaslpreecctoorrdos,f Fanacdtodreiespsiotef Ethneglfaancdt eaxntdenWt oalfefsrohmav1e00retgoul2a5r0lycalissetsedpenroytiefaicr.ations of such lesions to the occOunpeatmioanyalalcsaoncreefrlsecint oAnmthereicfaanctdytheawt othrkeelrasstapppuebalrieshdedinfi1g9u3r8esanodn lpiastneyd. lesDsutrhianng 1th00e ciansteesr,veanllinogccu1r5riynegarasm, otnhge etmotpalloyneuems boferonoef csoumch cfraosmes ahnays roifsethneseovtherearlcfoomldpaanndiesnoproofdfiucciainl gdaatnadhhaavnedbliencgomcaercaivnaoiglaebnliec oaxroidmaanttisc. amIninceosnutrsaesdt, inrectehnot preropdourtcstiboyn Eofngdlyisehs iannvdestriugbabtoerrs asnutpi pfiogrutreeds obny tthhee nEunmgbliesrh, cinhceimdeicnacle irnadtuess,triaensdhaatvteacskuprpislkiesdofadbelqadudaeter ctoantcheersaammoencgaErcningoligsehndicyearaonmdartiucbbamerinweosrwkeirths wwhhoicbhatdhebeceonrreexsppoosnedd ingFiwnaolrlkye,rsogmrooupcosnisnidtehriasticoonumnturysthbaovgeivoecncutopathtieonfaacltctohnattatchto. general pagoepnutlsattihornohuagshvathryoiinrgpdreesgerneecseoifncoinndtaucsttrwiailthwsaosmteesofretlheeasceadrciinnotogetnhioc ethnevisrooinlmanedntathleafirauannadanboddfielosraolfivwinagteirn, suanchd aepnotellruintegd seunbvsierqounemnetlnyt athned ouscecdurirnenpcaertofforson-ucatrliletidon"anl epiguhrpboosrehso.odI"n ctahseospaosft, ccalnaicmers ahsavtoe rcaarnecleyrsbeaemnomngadine.habTithaentwselolfeastaGbelirsmheadn froergmioenrionccwuhrircehncteheofdrairnskeninicg, wthaetefirrssut popclcyuwrreanscpeololfuttehdiswtyitphea.rsenic from mino slag heaps represents dyFeowlloorwkienrgs, tihtewdaisscaosvseerrytedofthblaatdadnerencavnircoenr mheanzatarldsplaamntoncgonGtaemrminaan tpiroonduwctiitohn ocafrbcilnaodgdeenriccanacreorms aatmiconagmpienressonws alisvinregspinontshieblevicfionritythoef tahtisthpalatntt.imeWbhiyleotthheeracitnuvaelsetxigisatteonrcs,e othfesurcehcecnotndditeimonosnwstarastidoennieodf u"nnreeigahsobnoarhboleodpocsassiebsi"litoiefsbseirnyclelioasishimghalkyespsoutechntcclaairmcisnoagpepne,arsuacshnoast rbeestual-tnsapifhtthheylawmasintee,diisspoinsavlolavnedd hwohuiscehkemepiignhgt mhaevtheodpsroodfuctheod psluacnht owferteheinlaudnegquaanted. bdIntoisapmroobnagbliendthivaitduthaelsfuwthuoreloivcecdurnreenacreboefrcyallniucemrsproducing or processing plante might furnish additional evidence of
OCTOBER 6-- MORNING SESSION
131
caanndcietrs hcaozmaprdosunrdelsataerde ntooteonnvliyrocnamrceinnotaglepnilcanfot rporalltustiaonndifrabbebriytlslibuumt eaxlsiostfoarromuannd. arSsiemniilcarsmcoenldteirtiso,nschorfominadtuestpriraoldautcminogspphlearnictsp, ocllaurtbioonn blaTchkefarecctoernietscoamndpoenilsraetfiionnercielasi,mass wadevllaanscuedraonniutmheobreasmisillosf. an alleged epxoissstiebniclietybeotfwaegenreactiegrarfeutttuersemimokpionrgtaanncdeloufngthceacnocmerpaelnsosaptiooinntastopetchtes scoounrnceecst,edsucwhitahs tehxeposoucrceurtroenccearcoinfogceannscecl'sontfaroinmed inindutshtery-erxehlaatuesdt fcuomnteasmfirnoamntsdiienseflooadnsdtugffass.oline engines, or present as additivos and theI taacptupaelanrsufmrobmertohfosoecccuopnastiidoenraatliocannsctehrastisthceornescidanerbaeblnyohdigohuebrt tthhaant tthheatnuthmebneurmofboearseosfpclaasceesdroencorerdceodrdi.n mIteidsicoaflsojomuerninatlesriessta,pmporerecoiavbelry, hlaisgthe2r0 tyheaanrs thhaevenucmombeerfoorf doeccciusipoantiboenfaolrecacnocmerpsenwsahtiicohn dbuorairndgs tbhee ccoauusret.coWmpitehnsaatfieown celxaicmepstiionnms,ansuycshucahs ctahseesinhcaivdeenbceeenofseltutnlegdcoauntcoefr CamzeocnhgosAlomvaekriicaannracdhirooamcatitveemoarenumfaicnteurrse,rsofanndasaalmsoinngus,Glearrmynaxn aanndd loufnsgkitnumcaonrcseramamonogngAEmnegrliicsahnciosaolptraorpyml aanlucofahcotlurmerasnuafnadctpurroecrse,ssaonrsd, cnaonrceelirasbolef itnhfeorvmaraitoiuosn tiyspaevsaialambolenogndtihffeeirnecnitdeonccceupraatteioonfaolcpcouppualtaiotinoanl groups.
B. Special Aspects of Occupational Cancers
canAcefrasiarlleagneddlcyocmaupseetdenbtyaodcjcuudpicaatitoionnal oafgecnotms oprencsoantidointionclsarimeqsuifroesr aanndaddeeqvuealotopmkneonwt loefdgtheeosfethtuemspoercsiaalnadspoefcttshereclartietedritao bthyewprhoicdhuctthioeyn mcinaayl, bdeietdairsyti,ncgousismheetdic,frhoambitunaoln)-oacscwueplaltiaosn"aslpoennvtainroenomuse"ntcaalnc(emrse.di cu1p.ationDaelficnaitniocner"ofistheapTpeliremd "toOcmcuaplaigtinoannatl Ctuamncoerrs",--orTighienatteinrgm i"noc iunsduiavlildyuparlsoldoungriendg etxheerccioseurosef,caenrtda/ionr oacsctuhpeatrieosnualtl, aocftitvhietieresgeunlatarilainndg caoctnitnagctinwpitrhopseormineteenxsoigtyen. ouOs,ccpuhpyastiicoanla,lcchaenmciecraslthourspaarreascitaiucseadgebnyt scpoencdifitiiconasgewnthsicohr feotiromlogainealilnytergerlaaltedpatrot wofellthdeefoinreddinaorcycuwpaotriokinnagl oenccvuirpoantmioennatl. caTncheerys dwifhfiecrhthrreosuuglthfrtohmeseorasfopleloctws furpoomn tshoemaeccoixdteranotar-l
132
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
odfinaarnyo,nsupnefcoirfeicseneant,uraec,cidental injury sustained at work and being ag2e.nts wTyhpicehs aanred kNnaotuwrne oorf OstcrocunpgalytionsualspCecatrecdinoagsenhsa.--viOngccucpauatsieodnal lcaarngceelyrs cohfevmaircioaluss. orSgoamnse ionfwthoerskeercshwemhoicbaelscaamree wexepllosdeedfintoedth, eomthearres cpoonusnidsts, oaf fveawriaobflewhmicixhtuproessseosfs acarlcairngoegennuimc bperropoefrticehse.miAcalseccoomnd gbryouthpeoirf oiocncuizpinatgioonralncoanricoinniozginengsriasdcioamtiopno.sedAofthagiredntgsrcohuapraicsterreipzreed hseanvteedanboycceunpvatiiroonnaml eanstsaolciaatgieonnt,sanadndwhciochndmitaioynbs e wrehliacthedstoomceetirmtaei*n itniofencatliocnosndoirtiosenvse, raalndspewcihfiicchcliinmaptiacr,t gheaovloegimc,odroietoarryl,esasndindniurtercit relations to carcinogenesis (table 2).
Table 2.-- Occupational Carcingena-- Their Route of Exposure and Their Target Organs
Qencral typo Specific typo
Route of exposure 1 Target organ
Ctsemf! earctangens;
BcruoL........ Organic eltciui-
Cutaneous, respira- Blood-forming o rg an s
cals--aromatie, polycyclic, het
| tory.
c(Iocmukac, mmiyoe, lolymmap).hosar
erocyclic
Bedtlan-en,a4p-hatmliiynloadmipinheo,nylb{eanutrfa-- Reosupsi,raaltiomrye,ntacruyt.ane Urdoegre, nuoruetsero,rgkaidnnse(yb)l.ad
mdimnee?.). magenta?) (tnlui- !1
'
Cotaalr
toairl,,
pcrietcohso, tseoooitl,, aasnpthharlat-,
1 Culuiieous___ K eiptm lury...
SLkuinng. .
I eene oil lamp black, lignite ,
tar and paraffin oil. Synthetic coal oil and tar
Cutaneous.
Skin.
Sh(aSleerogiiluasn),d paraTin oil........ , ..do ...... Ji Do.
Cutaneous..... Petroleum fu.-i oil, dunrl ml, lubricating oil and ros&e,
Respiratory. ..
Respiratory---
-I SLkairny.ra. Lung.
acsuptthinalgt, oitla,r,cucrobkoea, bclraucdke, |I
Cutaneous, ingestivo. AInloiprghaantiicc...(..i.i.e..t.n..l.-
,, j
isojWprMopffyinl oosill.............................. A rsen ic ,...,........ ................,
!
.do
SNkaisna.l sinus, laryni, lung.
Respiratory__ i X ieiret..................................... ........<to.. ......................
LNuansagl.cavity, nasal sinus,
Chromium...............................s........do .. ... .. Lulunngg. .
Bhysteal .reinogetw AXs-rbaedsitaotsi.o..n....................................................1. `..C...u..tdanoe.o..u...s................. SkinD. o.
tenfem radiation.
j Transentanoottt. Cobnlonoedc-tfivoremtiinssgueo, rbgoannes,.
Rabdeitos,acatnidvoeraamdimataio-rnad(baltpiohtas-),, TCruatnarstceuotua*n.e..o..u..s.... SCkoinnn, ective tissue, blood-
Respiratory..... Nafosarml siinnguosrgans.
Lung.
Tarasitic tarcincgtHW-.j Scbatowma hernatobinm Ingftitlve ...... BBolanded. er.
OCTOBER fr--MORNING SESSION
133
a nIunmabdedritioofnpototetnhteiasel heustmabalnishcaerdcioncocguepnastiwonhaiclhcahracvineobgeeenns sthhoerwenatroe eexlipcoitsecdancdeurrsining etxhpeeirrimreegnutallaranoimccaulspaatniodnatol wachtiicvhitiweso.rkeTrshebseecopmoe tceonmtipaelnasgateinotns cwlahimichs, aalrseolimstuesdt ibnotacbolnessid3eraendd i4n. the adjudication of
Table 3,-- Potential Environmental Human Carcinogens
Agent
Site of tumor Typpfocuor<fiox- Species Types of human contacts
Estrogens....................... Natural........ .... Synthetic.............. ..
Carbon Tetrachloride.,
Chloroform............ .
DrDoTp h(ean,ay-lB-ils,(li,l-ht!roi-Tacnhnloicroacetllmd.n..e..)............... Thiourea and derive-
tlves. p-Phenetyiurea (Dul*
cin). Diethylene glycol......... Mleetnheys.lated naphthaBcrgius coal oils and
tar. Flosihlse,r-Trtoaprss,ch wacxoeasl, greases.
Breast................ j Parenteral..........
Lymph nodes... Cutaneous.........
Uterus................ Oral .................
HLiyvpeor.p..h..y..s..i.s...............
.................. O ral..................
ural.................. Parenteral.____
.. ..do ........... Oral....................
i*u im u -m l.......
. T.i.i.ydrooR .............. O. .ral..................... Liver .............. ... .do . ..... Bladder............ ....... do..............
Skin................... , Cutaneous......
.....d o .............. Subcutaneous
CPaurmenntnenraisl.....,...,.....
tissue.
l i Liver.................. Cutaneous......... Parenteral.,.......
M aotu..s.e..,........... Rabbit........ HMuotnuot..p..i.g...,..
M-oi!?**.
R at............. ___do........ . ...,,.. . .d__o_,._._.._.. . - .... . ...do. .....
Mouse.. ... RMioluls.,,*.,.._,_._. ............... Mouse.........
MDiaentaurfyacatdudreit.ive. Cosmctio Ingredient. Industrial solvent. DDeryg-rcelaesainngtaaggaegnet.nt. Fire-extinguishing agent. PMraonduufcatciotunroe.f freon. GExratriancftuivmeigoafnoti.ls. Manufacture. ASonlevsetnhtetiacn, d Extractive of
oioildsi,nree,sailnksa,loruidbsb.er, wf axes,' Ingredient o( lacquer, floor
polish, cleaning Quid. Prpoldasutcictiso.n of artificial silk, IMnsaencutifcaicdteu.re. IFnogordedcioennttamionfant.foodstuffs
(fruits, wine, coffee, and Mteedai)c.inal agent. Tanning agent. CMietrduicsinfraul iatgpernet.servative. MSwaeneutfeancitnugrea.gent. Antifreete. Inmtearmnuefdaicattuere. in exposlve Sowftoeonder staoifns,lagcqluuee, r texIntikles,, humeetant (tobacco). Vehicle of Insecticides.
<-Manufacture.
LFuueblr.icants. PPleatrsoticchpemroidcuacl.tion. Manufacture, FLuadbr.icant.
134
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
Table ^.-- Potential Environmental Human Carcinogens--Continued
Agent . Light green SF brUgllraenetn bFlCueF.FCF fast Ceelnleo,phpaonley,apmoildyeet(hnyyl- Ion), bakelite teflon, polymethyl methac BeryrrlyatIeli.um.................... Selenium.......... ............
Cobalt............................
Site of tumor tissue. Subcutaneous.. Bone.................. Liver, thyroid. .
S utibsscuuet.a n e o u s
TyPp0eSUoTf9ex* Species Parenteral........* R at--...*-..
H a t..............
FisrenleraL. Rabbit........ Rwpiratory....... Kftt.............. Oral.................... . ...do ........
Parenteral........ .....d o ...... .
Types of human contacts
TFoeoxdtilaenddyecso.smetic dyes. FGoaosdoldinyeed(yoer.ient). FFilalmre,cfoibloerr., plastic-industrial
manufacture and uses. WMeradpicpiinnagl magaetnetr.ial. Metal elloy, X-ray tube. Repfhroacstpohroyrvmeaasneutsf.acture. Atomlo energy production. SCooillocroinngtamminaattnetr. of glass, Mceetraalmalilcosy, sp.aint, rubber. Rubber accelerator. PDheootdooerliezcetrr.ic apparatus. Fireproofing agent. MMeedtailcianlalolyasgeanntd. plating. Coloring matter of glass, Mceedriacminiacls,agpeanitnt, rubber.
T able 4.--Carcinogenic Chemicals Eliminated as Environmental Human Carcinogens
Agent
S ty r y l430....................... 3-ftityamlno-floorens.
Site of cancer Typpoesuorfeex Species
Intended use
1
Sutibsscuuet.aneous Parenteral.......
Trypanocidal agent.
Sutibsscuuet,aneous POarrael.n..t.e..r.al......... i. R.,,adt..o................ j! Insecticide.
Bladder..............
' Oog.......... -
Liver.................. Brain.
:1 Fowl...........
Thyroid.
Acoustic duct. BLereuaksetm. ia.
I
LKuidnnge. y.
? 1
1
tioSn.s Ebveatwlueaetnioann oefxpEovsiudreenctoe.--theFsoeragtheentsesatnadbltihshemsuebnst eoqfuecnatudsaelverleolpa nmaetnutreo,ftahecafnoclleorwoifnagnporecrceuqpuaitsiiotensalmgeunsetsbise afunldfiltlheedr:efore compensable
OCTOBER 6-- MORNING SESSION
135
had( )ocDcuefpiantiitoeneavlidceonncteacmt uwsittbheaanvyailoanbeleoifndthiceatvianrgiotuhsatatgheenctslaliimstaend,t othvaetr ptheirsiocdosnotafcattwleaasseti6thmeroonfthpsr,olaonndgewdasnaotfuraedeeqxuteantediinngteanssiatyrufoler ewlihciicthingmiaghctanbceeroauvsailraebspleonosno, tahciscoprdoiinngt. toSianngylepreexvpioosuusreesxpmeariyenbcee icoonnisziidnegrerdadtioatiboen eofrfetchteiveexipfostuhree cmaesuchalanaisgmentfacvoonrssisthtse opfroedxutcetrinoanl ooff athcearhcoinsot goerngiacndisempomt ianythenestuises.ues from which a prolonged exposure age(n)t Tinheadroduittieonoftoexiptsossupreecitfoic ocrheinmtricoadlucptrioopnerotifestheandcarmcientoagbeonliicc pcaencucelirariistieeslicdietetder.miTnheertehfeorsei,tenootf tahney ocragnacner,orbutitssouneslyincawncheircsh oaf spe(cci)ficThsietetsypaereorfeelaxtpeodsutoreadnoyespanrotitcnueleadr ctoarcbienocgoenntiincuaoguesnto.r extend uInp tfoactth, eatniymecoonftaacptpewaritahncteheofotchceupcaatnicoenra,lbcuatrcminaoygebneicintaegremnitttmenaty. hboafvoeroctehaesecdanmcearnbyecmomonetshms atnoifyeesta.rsEofrf,ecoticvceasciaorncailnloyg, eenvicenexdpeocsaudreess mopaeyrabtieonssuwstiatihneodccunpoattioonnlayl cbayrctihnoegoenrdicinhaarzyarodpse, rbautotraslsoembpylowyoerdkeirns emnateinritenngansuccehpoeprseornantieoln,sreopnaiarmtreann,stirtourcykebrsa,silso,asduecrhs, aysarsdumpeernv,isoanrsd, wtioonrks,erisf ehmoupsleokyeeedpiinngroaonmdseaxnhdaubsutidldisinpgossanlemaretthhoedhsaazraerdionuasdeoqpuearate and(d)enOvcircounpmateionntaall McoendtiacmaliSntaitgiomnastar.e--suFlot.r the establishment, of causal sreelqautieonntsly baeptwpeeaerningocccuanpcaetirosn, ailt eisxpoofsudriesstintoct cvaarlcuienotgoenasnaalnydzesuthbe dmiseedaisceal mhaisntiofreystaotfiotnhse cahfafcrcatcotderipsetircsoonfs afopraftuhnocgteinoincalacotrioannaotfomthiec opfatretnicuplraerpacraartcoinryogoern parellceagnecdclryouisnvsoylmvepdt.omSsuocfh entioonloegainccesrpoeucsificaintdy aaccttuaalsitystigofmaataproerviobuioslloygiscusftianigneerdpsrpinetcsifiscupepxoportsiunrge,nbout tonallsyo thites ctiaounssalporeslsaetsisoinnsghispuctho athseigcnaifnicceanrcpereasreen, tf.orSiynmstapntocem,actihcromniacnirfaedsitoa- ddeerrmmaattiittiiss,, cchhrroonniicc rtaadr iadteiromnaptietirsio, satirtsies,nicasbdeesrtmosaitsosoifs,thcehrolunnicg,soalnadr lCehuekmemicoaildarneaalcytsieosnsofaftitsesrueesxpfoosrutrheetoinbcerinmzoinlaatendd ciohneimziincgalraaldsioatmioany. s.sopmeceiftiicm, oecscbuepaotfioansaslisctaanrccienoingeensst,absulicshhinaag aprrseevnioicu,scchoronmtaicutmw,itnhickanely^ radioactive substances, and benzol.
136
1954 MEETING OP IAIABC
apIptliicsaibmlepoforrtaanltl, ohcocwuepvaetrio, ntoalncoatenctehras.t boStohmteheosfetphreocceadrcuirneosgaernesndoot
mnoatypnroodtuceelicaitnyaneytioplorgeilcimalilnyacryhatroaxcitceriosrticotshyemr pdtoismeass,einphfaecnto, mtheenya
dcaenspceitres oaf tpheersbislatedndterainnddyperoalonndgreudbbcearrcwinoorkgeenrsicmeaxypdoesvuerelo. p iTnhtuhse,
mabosreenctehaonf aonnye porreltiwmoinadreycaldoecsaloofrcgoennteinraulouwsa,rninintegrmsyimttepntot,mosradftiesr
coTnthineureedalesoxpdooseusrentoot cexeristatinancyarpcainraolgleelnisicmabroemtwaeteicn atmheinteosx.ic and/or
iqruriatlaittiievse, nporor,piesrttiheesreofa raenlyaticohnesmhiipcabloatwndeointsthpeodteengtrieael ocfatrocixniocgiteynoicf
any(e)paErxtitceunlsaivr ecaerxcpineorigeennceanwdithitsorcecluaptiavteioncaarlcicnaongceenrsicinpdoitceantceys. that
tthheeroenusseutaollfyexelpaopssuersesa tloateanctarpceirnioodgeonficyeaagresn, tifanndottdheecaadpepse,abraentwceeeonf
othcecurpesautilotinnagl ccaanncceerrs(tbaebcloem5e).mIatniisfelsotrwthitishirneatshoenfmirsotstyeuanrlikfoelllyowthinagt
wthheicinhcmepatkioenthoeficroanptpaecatrwanitcheaducarirncgintohgeenfiircstagthernete. yIenarfsacotf,oaclclucpanatcieorns
fionr
a
acamrcoinroegepnroicbaebnlveironnomnoecnctusphaoluiolduable
osruigbijne
ctbeedfotroe
severe
they
mscaruytinbye
considered from any occupational viewpoint.
Table 5.-- Latent Periods of Occupational Cancers
Organ and agent
Averpaegreioldatent latReanntgpeeroifod
Arsenic:
Shin
MOcecduicpiantaiol_n_a_l._.._.._._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._. .__.._.._.._.._. ._.
TOarfrinsotf! oil ........_.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._..._.._.._...._.-_._.._.._.._.._.._._
CMriundeeraplaoraiflf.in. .-o-i-l-_-_-_--_-_--_-_--_-_--_-_--_--_-_--__--_-_--_-_--_-_--_-_--_-_--_-_--_-_--_-_--_-_-
Solar radiation------------------------ -----------------------------
Years18 20-2245 50-5245 2105--3108
7
Year3s-40 41--5406 145--7450 135--3450 1-12
Lung Asbestos.................................................... ........................... -
18 15-21
NCihcrkoeml actaersb_o_n_y_l_._.._.._.._.._.._..._ .--................-.--. . ....-..-.-.-..-.-.-.-..-.-...............................- -
2125
56--4370
TIoanrisfiunmg ersa.d...i.a..t..i.o..n........-..-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-..-..-..-..-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-. . 25-3156 97--5203
Aromatic amines----- -----B--l-a-d-d--e-r---------------- - ...........-. - - 11-15 2-40
OCTOBER 6-- MORNING SESSION
137
the(/)adAmsinuicscterasstfiouln porfodauncytipoanrtoicfuclaanrccehrseminiceaxl poerriomcecnutpaaltiaonniamlaalsgebnyt siduepnptliiceaslweeffigechttyuspuopnpomratnt,o easpcelaciimallythiaft tshuechroaufteactoofr emxpaoysuhraev,ethane pphroydsuioccehdeimniceaxlpesrtiamtuesntoalf atnhiemaalgseanrte diduernintigcaclownittahctt,heancdorrthesepocnadnicnegr sapsepceicetss isnpehcuifmicaitny eoxfpeerxieongceen.ousHocwarecvineor,gebneiccauasgeeonfts,theo,vpernonpoousnitcievde eexnptierreilmyecnotnaclluesvivideeenvciedepnrcoeviadsetsomtheereelxyisstetrnocnegolyf csaurgcigneosgtievneicbpurtopneort taineds oirfresufucthabalgeenantsswfoerr minasnu.chOmnalyttehrusm. an experience gives a definite imp(go)rtPanactheoliongictheandeshtaisbtloislohgmicenetviodfentcheeisoicncugpeanteioranlaol fcoanulsyatliiomniteodf caanndcehriss,tosliongciec nsetirtuhcetrurteheofclicnaincaclerbseahraevieotrionloogrythsepegcriofiscs. apHpoewareavnecre, sintrasobmlee,moacncuifpeasttiaotnioanlscaanrecepl'rsesheisnttolwoghiicchallgyivoer choisntcoleuhsiovmeiocarlslyugdgeemstoivne bevoiddieenscaendasastobesthtoesiirs pinaraticluunlagr aeftfieocltoegdy.byTchaencperrepseronvceideosf parsabcetsictoasl caanrdcisncoimenat.ificOpfrsoiomfilaasr ctoausthael saigsnbiofsictoatnicceowrioguilnd ohfostuhcehdeampounlmstroantiaoryn soefctcihornosmoitfe tdhuestlubnyg loufsloacnheimndiievaildumaelthwoidtsh apnudlmboynainrycincearractiinoonmoaf. Tcahrecinhiosmfeoaehreepmriecsaelndtsemaonnosthtreartioilnluosftraatrisoennicofinththeevsakluine aofffehctiestdolboygica sthtuedpierseseinncteheofdeexteternmsiivneatioonndaorftetrhiteieetcihoalonggyesoifnaacfainbcroesr.ed Lsuikbecwuitsae npeicoiuosn ttihssauteXc-ornatyasinoinrgraadicoaarccitnivoemeanoerrgsyarwcoams acawusoaullldy arreosupsoenstihbelesufosr theItmaaplpigenaarsntfrloesmionth. ese considerations that a competent and critical euvalaluthaetiosnymofptthoemeantiticremeavnidifeenscteatrieolnastedoftothteheperxeppoasruarteoroyf tpheeriiondd,ivtihde hleinstgotehhoomf itchae! lcahteanratcpteerriisotdic,sthaendsitteheofetxhiestecnacneceorf, scoomrreeshpiosntodlionggicoobr speerrvtiantieonntseopnidecmaniocleorgipcroddautcatiroenprienseenxtpsetrhime esnctiaelntaifnicimbaalssisaseidsesefnrtoimal for medicolegal decisions in litigations of alleged occupational cancers.
C. Compensation Laws
staWteosrrkemveeanl'sacroemmpaernksaabtlieonlaclakwosfeunnaicftoerdmiitny vaasritooutshecotuynptersiesofaoncd cupational carcinogenic agents, industrial operations with carcinogenic
330588-- 83" To
138
1954 MEETING OP IAIABC
hfualzlacrdosv,eraangde olacwcuspaaptipolnyainlgcatnocearlls kcionvdesreodf. ocAcsupoaftiOoncatolbdeirse1a,se1s95in4, cthluedDinigstcriacntceorfsChoaldumbebeina;psacshseedduilne c2o6vSertaatgeesloafwtshenoUt nailtwedaySstacotevserainndg ooccccuuppaattiioonnaall dcaisnecaesres,laowrsalhlatdypbeese,nweenraecitnedfoartcethinat2t0imSetaitnes2aSntdatneos (MWishsiislesipwpi'oraknmdeWn'syocmominpge).nsation laws based on the principle of sdcishaebdiulilteycoavnedraignejumriaesy prersouvlitdinegsofmroemdeogcrceuepoafticoonmalpecnasnacteiornhaazgaaridnss,t sinuacdhelqeugaaltep,roifvinsoiotnosbdseosliegtne,edinfoarntheeraproofteactriaopnidolfywcohrkaenrgsinagreatnodtalilny carelaesgianlgaoncdcuspoacitoiolongailc dsitsaetaeseofpamnionrdamwah. ichSuicshmsatalatidcjuslatewds troefltehcet dyHnaomwiecvsetra, teevoefnmthoedebrnlaninkdeut sotrryg. eneral coverage compensation law wanhyicfhutiusresuoffciccuiepnattliyonfalelxcibanlecetrohianzcalruddse, unsoutaollnylyhatshae sptaretusetentofbluimt ailtsao tainodnsnwothitcoho iusniunsaudaelqcuiartceumfosrtapnrcoevsidminegt fwaiirthprinotoecctciuopnatuionndaelr ccaenrtcaeirn. Sceinsscaetioocncoufpaetxipoonsaulrecatnocoercscumpaatyiobneaclocmarecimnoagneinfeicstagmeanntsy, ayesatrastuatoftreyr ttiiomnealclcaaunsceerosfwfrhoimch6mmayonatphpsetaor 6afyteeraraslomnagyerbpeetroioods.hoIrtt ifsoradovcicsuapbale efovrenthtuisalirteieassoanretoproapdejurlsyt caollveerxeids.ting laws in such a way that such groIunptsheofwworokrmkeerns'socromemppelnosyaetieosn, lsauwchs eaxsisteisnpgeciniamllyosftaSrmtatelas,bocerrtaanidn dfaormmeinstgicassewrveallntass, haoreuseexwcolurkdehdavferombeccoomveeraagned abrye itnhcerelaaswin.glySinbcee c(poemsitnicgidoecsc,uphaetriboincsidheasv, insgynexthteentiscivefecrotinlitzaecrts,wiathntiinspdruosutrtiianlgpraogdeuncttss, hmoarcmhoinnearly,fartetseindiunagl oaiglsenftosrosfmluivdegsetopcko,tsl,usboriilcaimntpsroavnedrs,fuaenltiobfioftaicrms, dsceiteenrtgifeinctsr,eawsaoxnesf,orpoelixschleusd,indgry mcleemanbienrgs aogfenstusc)h, thocecreupiastionnossofruonmd cporovteercatgieonbyagtahinestwocraknmceerns'sarciosimngpenfrsoamtionexlpaowssureandto frpoomtenatdiaelquaantde actual occupational carcinogenic agents.
OCTOBER 6-- MORNING SESSION
139
D. Tabor Codes and Standards ciaAl nmyeaanttsemfoprt atocwaanrcderaocuhsiecvoinndgiatinonadaecqquuairteedcothmrpoeungshatcioonntbayctfiwnainth oficccuultpieastiobnuatl iasgealnstos onfotquoensltyionparbelseenhtsumcaonnesidmerearbitl.e eWcohniloemsicuchdifa pcaroncceedruhreasisbeevciodmenetlaynthaeccboemstptlhisahtedcanfabcte, dtohnee wafisteerr,anmoorcecurpaatitoionnaall, tarnodl oinf othceculpoantgiornuanl,cmanocreer ehcaoznaormdsiclailesaopbpvroioauchslytoinatrheeaisropnraebvleenctioonn whTehreisvegrotahliscains pboessaicbhleie.ved to a large degree by the enforcement of sporotpheart weiotrhkercoanndyitcioonnstaicnt oofpewraotrikoenrss iwnitwhhsiuchchcaangceenrtshiaszaerlidmsinexatiestd, oacrcroemdupcliesdhintog saunchinaefcfoecnttirvoel olefvoecl.cupAastiotonatlhceanfcuenrdhaamzeanrdtasl, isttewpoufoldr besetaabdlvisihsambelenttso phraovdeucailnlgf,achtoarniedsli,nwgoorkrshuospins,glakbnoorwatnorioers asunsdpeocthteedr caagrecnicnioegs.eniTc hmisatienrfioarlsmtaotiorengiwstoeurldwpitrhovSitdaetethpeubblaicsishefaolrthesatanbdlislahbinogr cthreeatseuptheervpisrioopneromf apclhanintserybyforhefaamlthiliaarnidzinlgabmoranaaggeenrcsioesf sauncdh owpoeurlad dtieovniscewsiuthsetdheinpothteenirtiaelstcaabrlcisinhomgeenntisc apnrodpwerittihesthoef tmheetshuobdsstananceds parnod cedTuhreesreblyatwivheicehfftehcetiyvemneigsshtofbeancyonmtreodlliecdal,orsaanviotaidreyd.and technologic cthoentrcohlamngeeassuirnesthtoeboecacduoppatteiodncaalncbaensctebreidnectiedremncineedamboynagsctehretaitnoitnagl pinotproudlautciotinona.t rIistkisocthcuerrerifnogredduerisnirgabsloemteha1t0 ptroov3i0sioynesarbsealmteardethfeoirr reoxuptoisneedlytoreoccocrudpiantgioanlallccaanrcceinrocgaesness. ocAclulrprirnogcaanmceornoguswanodrkcearngcreoruopuss lbeesimonasdoebnsoertivfeiadblaemwonitghmtheemSbteartseohfesaulcthh gargoeunpcsy.shoAullldpfeorrsothniss hreaavsionng iknngo.wleTdhgee aodf othpetisoencaonfcseulschshmoueladsubreesherledprreesspeonntssibalne fiomrpsourcthanretpsotertp ftroomdeaterpmubinliec htheealtehnvviireownpmoeinntt,albeccaauussees threesrpeonissiablegrofworingsigunrigfiecnacnyt chaAnggerseaint tdheealinocifdecnircceurmatsetasnotfiaslevaenrdal dciarneccetrse.vidence incriminates rsetacretnlitncghaanndgepsroignretshseivienidnucsrterays-ereinlattheed. luenngvicraonncmeernfrteaql ufeancctoyrsobfsoerrvthede
140
1954 MEETING OF LA.IABC
isnimailllarin, dwuhsitlreianloizteads mcoaurnkterdie,sridseuriinngmtohretapliatystr5a0teysehaarss b(geeranpohbs1e).rveAd desupreincgialtlhye lleausktetmwioasd, efcoardews hfiocrhctahnececrsruodfethme obrltoaolidtyforramteinginctirsesauseesd, f1r9o4m4. 1.0Thpiesr d1e0v0e,0lo0p0moefntthecopinocpiudleastiwonithina19m00arktoed4.3incpreeras1e0d0,0u0se0 oinf ieomnpizlionygmraednitaotifocnhaesmwicealllsashawviitnhgadwisidtienscptrehaedmiantdoutosxtriicalefafnedctms. edicinal
OCTOBER 6-- MORNING SESSION
141
adIjutsatelsdo mmoayrtableityofrsaitgensifpicearnc1e00t,h0a0t0thpeopauglea-tsiopneciffoicr, stkoitnalcaanndceargienwbehtwiteeemn a1le9s30aanndd w1h9i5t0e afemmaalreksedinshthifet iUn nfiatvedor Sotfattehse hyaovuengsehroawgne gskroinupcsan(ctearbslefo6r)b. otWh sheextehsermsauychhacvhearnegseusltiend tfhroemagtehedmistordibeumtiohnaboitf odfiestaurny bcaothnitnacgt oorf athme ogreenienrtaelnspeopeunlvaitrioonnmweintthal,aroscencuicpaalsti,onoarl waintdh mpraotdtuerctsofofsptheceuclaotailotna.r aFnodrpdeetrtoerlemuimniningdtuhsetryp,orsesmiblaeincsaautsaplressigennitfia caascnecretaoinf sduactha foanctoorcscuipnattihoinsadl,evdeielotaprmy,enetn, viitrownomueldntable annedcehssaabriytutaol contacts of the affected individuals, their complexion and race, and
TaPbolpeula6.t--ionAfgoer-spSekciinficC, aTncoetarl,inanWdhiAtegeM-aadljeusstaendd MWohritlaeliFtyemRaaletse,s UPneitred10S0ta,0te0s0, 1630, IQjS, and I960
Age
White males 1930 i UI-15 im
O1Vl8ti4fU5ei-eg5nM0t
Under 15____________________________ 0. 06 | 0. 08 0. 03 -6 2
2155--3244._.._.._.._.._.._.._..._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._. ._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._..
..2122
' !
. 11 .46
.. 8314 ++20796
3455---5444._._.._.._.._.._..._._.._.._.._..._.._.._._.._.._..._.._..._.._.._.._.._.._...._.._.._.._.._. 2.. 755 ; 2.. 8l5 21.. 74 ++6295
5655--6744............................................................................................................................. 283..07 : 156..03 152.. 89 +-2101
8755-a8n4d...o...v..e..r............................................................................-......................... 16948.. 22 !j 15722..34 7372.. 56 --53 58
AAlgleaagdejsu--s-t-e-d--1-.-.-.-......-..-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-.-.-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-..- 34.. 73 S 33.. 62 22.. 99 -------- -
White females
U15n-d2e4r 15.._.._._.._._.._._..__._._.._._.._._.._._.._._.._._.._._.._._.._._.._._.._._.._._.._._.___
25-34............................................. ..................__
4355--5444............................................ .............................................
55-64 ................................................... ...................................................................................
65-74........................................................... ......................
8755--+8 4 .________________________._.._._.._._.._._._.._.._._._.._.._._._..
All
a g e s.................... .. .......................... .. _______________________
______
______
Age adjusted !________________________
0. 0076
, .
23
1.. 563
131.. 46
14642.. 76
22.. 91
0. 0173
. .
23
1.. 505
28. 97
13262.. 73
22..01
0. 0312
. .
72
1.
1
28
3.. 6
6. 8
6ia8. 85
2I..09
+- 71318 ++ 211138 ++2840 -22 --24 98
<Adjustedlor age on total population
142
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
othnetshkeinlo(csaitteiodnisotrfibthuetiocna)n.cers in the exposed or unexposed parts of allAolclcsuupcahtidonaatal ccaonucledl'srewadoiullyd bbee ombatdaiennedotiffoiarbolce.cupAattiothnealsafamcetotrismief dtheigsremeetahsaunrehweoreutlodfobreeitnhsetruscmoepnetaolf ionccauscpearttiaoinnailngcatnocaermhuaczhargdrsoaatnedr ocefdtuhree icsasntcriekrsingrelysuilltliunsgtrathteedrebfryoma .graTphhe(gerfafpechti2v)enpeusbslisohfedthissevperroal
CUTANEOUS CANCER IN RELATION TO OCCUPATION
GRAPH SHOWING THE NUMBER OF CASES OF CUTANEOUS CARCINOMA IN M ALES t FEM ALES IN ENGLAND, WALES t SCOTLAND NOTIFIED ANNUALLY FROM 1911-1949 INCLUSIVE.
G raph 2.
OCTOBER 6---MORNING SESSION
143
yofeacrasseasgoofbcyutHaneenoruysincawrchiincohmhae isnhmowaeledstahnedsftermikainlegsriinseEinngtlhanedn,uWmableesr sahnadleScooiltlaanndd mattinriebruatlaobilleatfoteorcsctuaptuattioornyalneoxtipfoicsautrieosntowceonatl itnatro, peiftfcehc,t in 1920.
Conclusions
cia1t.edThweithratphide adpepveealorapnmceenotfomf amnoydneernwioncdcuusptraitailoisnmal hhaesaltbheehnazaasrsdos of 2w.hTichhethionscerecaasuinsgingractaencaetrswohciccuhpyoacncuipmaptioorntaalntcparocsiintioogne.ns have btheeenadctiuscaollvyereexdisdtuinrginginrdeucsetnritadl eccaardceinsosguegngsesitss kthnoawt onnlaynda ftrhaacttiohneroef tthofeorpereusneknntowinnduasntdrianlewenovcircounpmateionnt atlhcroarucginhogthenes dmevayelobpemaedndtedantdo use3.ofTnheewre cisheamgirceaalst daenadl porfoedvuidcetinocne minedtihcoadtisn.g that only a relatively spmataiollnafrlacctairocninoogf etnhse hcaasncbeeresnprroecdougcneidzetdhraonudg/horcopnlatcaecdt wonithreoccocrud. wBeocrakuesregroofupthseweisthtabklnisohwedn owcicduepspatrieoandalincdaurcsitnrioaglencso,ntthacet pooftelnatrigael sthcoapneapofpatrheentofcrcoumpathtieonraelpocratendcenrupmrobbelremof oecvcidupenattiloyniasl mcaunccherlacragseesr an4d. hMazeadridcooulesgianldduesctirsiiaolnospinercaotimonpse.nsation procedures of occupational ocfanthceerecnlatiirme sevshidoeunldcebreelbaateseddtoonthae ceoxmpopseuterentcoanndditcirointiscaolf etvhaelucalatiiomn saynmt, ptthoompatriecsemncaenifoerstaabtisoennsceobasnedrvethdedutyrpinegotfheanlayteentitolaongdy,despveecloifpic mofetnhtealcapnecrieord, sanoyf sthpeeccifainccheirs,totlhoegilcenagntdhhoifsttohcehelamteicnatl pcehrairoadc,tethriestiscitse, tthhee ipnrcordimucintiaotnedofagceonrrteasnpdonpdeinrtginceanntceeprsidienmeioxlpoegriicmdeanttaa.l animals by pro5.tecStciohendaugleaincsotvoecrcaugepatliaownsal acraencienrahdaezqauradtsebfeocraupseroovfidthinegdypnraompeicr scthaetme icoaflsmoadnedrnpirnodduuscttriyonresmuelttihnogdsin wthheichconmsatayntenadtadiiltiohnereotfofnoerwe uconnktnaoinwend oicncuthpeatigoennaelraclanccoevrerhaagzearldasw.s Trehperessetanttusteitsofmlaiminitadteifoencst ipnenthsaetifoanirlaawndtoeqoucictuapbaletioanpaplliccaantcioenr hoafztahridss.type of workmen's com fin6a.ncSiianlcecotmhepenpsraetvieonntifoonr oefstaobclcisuhpeadtiooncaclupcaatnicoenralhcaaznacrdesrs aanpdpenaorst
to be the more sensible and humane method of occupational cancer
144
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
ceolinmtrionla,telaobrorrecaosdoensasbhloyucldonbteaipnroopcecrulpyaatidojnuasltecdanacnedr ehnafzoarrcdesd isno masotdo ern7.inFdourstraisecse.rtaining the actual scope of the occupational cancer pesrsoebnletimal athndat foocrctuhpoatiinosntaitluctiaonnceorsf aadnedqpuraetecacnocnertroouls mcoeansduitrieosn,sitaries ma8d.eAnoctoifmiapbrleehwenisthivelocsatludayndoSf taotcecuhpeaatlitohnaalndcalnacbeorr haauzthaordristiews.ill papropvairdeentaexsoteunnsdionbaosfisinfodrustarny-reeqluaatelldy cuarngceenrthainzvaerdstsigtoatiloanrgeofpatrhtes of tho general population.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. HuSepprbinkg,fiWeld., CII.I,., O1c9c4u2,papt.io8n9a7l. Tumors and Allied Diseases, C. C. Thomas,
ReIcnenptreDsse. velopments in Environmental Cancer, A. Review. Arch. Pathol.
A HMeeatlhthodoTleocghy. foMroEnnovgirraopnhmNenot.al1a. ndUO. cSc.upPautbiolincalHCeaanltcherSSeurvrviceey,s.DePpuabrtl.
2.
T
ment
hasko
,ofVH.
e
aMlt.h,
,
OEcdcuucpaatitoionnaaln
dDWiseealfsaere,R1e9p5o0r,tipn.g.37.
U.
S.
Department
of
pH,e8a0lt.h, Education and Welfare, Publ. Health Service Publ. No. 288, 1953,
3. StIelilnineoris, LB,ulKl..,48R; eNcoe.nt69T,r1e9n5d1s, ipn. 3O0c. cupational Disease Legislation. Univ,
4. MoOhcgciusp, aGti.onGa.l, aDnidseaDseasv.enBpourreta,uS. oJf., MStiantees CIonmfoprmenastaitoonry CPirrocvuilsairons705fo0r,
5. WaUt.eSr,s,DTepha.,rtImnednutstorfiatlhePhInytseicriioanr, a1n9d52,Wpo, r1k2m5.en's Compensation--Current
T25re1n-2d5s5,in19C49o.mpensation Legislation. J. Indust. Pyg. and Toxicol. 31:
6. SuPbcoollmutmioitntLeeegiosnlatiLoeng. islMatainounfacPtrurinincgipClehse,mAistsR' aAtsiosonca.,l 1A95p2p,ropa. c2h3. to Air
7. ToHueraalnthgeoafu,WFo. rkJ.m, eHneaAltrhe oEfxpWosoerdkmienn:InAdpupsrteryciaitnionProofviRnciseksoftoQWuehbiecch.
Canad. M. A. J. 54: 352, 1946.
The AQcuceibdeecntWPorrekvmenetnio'snCAosmsopceiantsiaotniosnULnadwer the
L. H. T . Clegg, PresideInntsduQsutr&iabelcAcAcsidsoencitastion for the Prevention of
[In the absepnrceesiodfenMt,r.QuCelbegegc,Ahsissosctiaatteimonenfot rwtahserPearedvebnytiJo.nAorfmAacnciddeDntess]rochers, trice
latIerw, ilbleoiungtlinmeobrerieffalymtihliearsewtuitphotfhtoheovrgaarinoiuzastsioanfetwyhaiscshocIiartieopnrse,seanntd, Iacstihvailtliees,ndeavour to elabora_te on a few of. i.ts. maj..o..r.. pr.o..motional
APPENDIX A
Officers and Members of the Association for 1954-55
PPraesstidPernets,idJeonhtn, JMoaocuhliimn, GCroemnimeri,ssQio.nCe.r,, PIlrleinsiodisenItn,dQuusetrbieacl WCoomrkmmisesnio'sn.Compensa VitcieonPCreosmidmenist,sioJna.mes J. Reid, Vice Chairman, South Carolina Industrial
Commission. Secretary-Treasurer, Paul E. Gurske, Director, Bureau of Labor Standards,
U. S. Department of Labor, Washington, D. C.
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
GR.obLe.rCt oEu.sFleayn,cMy,anMitionbnae.sota. Richard W. Morse, Ohio.
HWa.rHry. AN.icNkeellss,onJ,r.,'WVisicrgoinnsiian..
HONORARY LIFE MEMBERS Former Presidents
11991145-- 1156 JFolohyndEL..KDinangagneett,, DSpeotrkoaint,e,MWicahs,h(,d(edceecaesaesde)d. ). 1916- 17 aDnucdeleCyo.M, 1.4H00olHmaannc,ocMkaSntargeeert,, QUuniintecdy,SMtaatesss. Mutual Liability Insur 11991187-- 1198 FG.eoMrg.eWAi.lcKoxin, gWstiosnco, nTsoinro(ndteoc,eaCsaend)a.da (deceased). 11991290-- 2210 WChilalrlJe.sFSr.enAcnhd,rBusu,rlSipnrgianmgfeie, lCd,'ai1i1f1.. ((ddeecceeaasseedd)).. 11992212-- 2232 FR.oAbe.rDt uEx. bLuerey,, MSta.rPylaaunld, M(diencne,as(edde)c,eased). 11992243-- 2254 0F.reFd. WM.cAShrmanset,roSnagl,t HLaakliefaCx,itNy,oUvataShco(dtieace(adseecde)a,sed). 11992256-- 2276 HFraeldeMri.cSMta.nlWeyi,lliAamtlas,ntWa,aGtear.bu(dryec,eCasoendn),. (deceased). 1io9o287_-oq2/8J amAensdrAew. HFa.mMiltcoBnr,id2e0,00MW. Da.s,hPinagtteornsoAn,veNn.uJe., (NdeewceaYseodrk)., N. Y. 1929- 30(FraWncaeltserPeOr.kmStsa,ckC,oCsmlaoypmoolintat,n DCellub(,dNeceewaseYdo)r.k, X. Y. 11993301-- 3312 WPaerklleingPt.oDn eTa.nsL,eRonicahrdm,oCnodl,uVmab.u(sd,eOcehaiosed(d).eceased). 11993323-- 3334 JRo.seEp.hWAe.nPzealr,k4s2, 24664EaSsotu-WtheOstraHniggehwAavye,nuCeh, eOvyrlaCnhdaos,eF, lMa.d. 11993345-- 3356 JG,.DCelwayeyBDakoerrs,eTtto, p6e0kJao,hKnaSnstr.eet, New York, N. Y. 1936- 37 Donald D. Garcelon, Augusta, Maine. 1937- 38 A. G. Mathews, Granteville, W. Va.
222 -----------
APPENDIX A
223
11993389-- 3490 VWo.y'hta. WNircakbeelstz, ,JrM.,aRdiiscohnm, oWndis,. Va. 11994410-- 4413 WC.ilKli.amNeHw.coCmhcbsen, uWt, iPnnhiiplaedge,lpMhaian,itPoab.a (deceased). 11994434-- 4445 TE.mAm.aWSi.lsToonu, sHaingth, QPuoiinnct,y,NM. Cas.s. 119944,6>--4647L. D0.. JA. rGenasl,bSraailtehm, ,TOorreogn.to, Ontario. 11994478-- 4489 SMpiesnscMeraHry. GDiovnelnosn,,JNefefwersYonorkC,itNy,. MY.o. 11994590-- 5510 JHaamrreys AL.. HNiellls,oDn,etMroaitd,isMonic,hW. is. 11995512-- 5532 SR.aWym. oMndacEdo. nBaaldrn, eSsa,nOFrlraanndcois,cFol,a.Calif. 1953- 54 Joachim Grenier, Q. C., Quebec, Canada.
Former Secretaries 11991145-- 1156 LR.icAh.arTdarLr.elDl,raRkoeo,mHi5g1h6l,anCdasPwaerlkl ,BMloicckh,. 152 West Wisconsin Avenue, 1916- 20 MRoilywaal uMkeeeek3e,r,WHisa.rtford, Conn, (deceased). 1920 Charles H. Vorrill, Washington, D. C. (deceased). 11992312--3324 ECthhaerllebserEt .SBteawldawrti,n,W8a2s1h0inLgatorrny, PDl.acCe., (CdehceevayseCdh).ase 15, D. C. 1934-46 Verne A. Zimmer, Washington, D. C. (deceased). 11994497--5494 WMailrlsiahmal!I,D. aCwosnonno,llNy,ewProYvoidrke,ncNe,, YR.. I.
Adive ifcmberSf 1954-55 ABrlbiteisrhtaCWolourmkmbiean'Ws Corokmmpeenn'ssaCtioomn pBeonasradti.on Board. MNeawnitBorbuansWwiocrkkmWeonr'skmCoenm'speCnosmatipoennsBatoiaornd,Board, Newfoundland Workmen's Compensation Board. ONnotvaarioScWotioarkWmoernk'smCeno'ms pCeonmsapteionnsaBtioonardB.oard. SQausekbaetcchWewoarknmWeno'srkCmoemn'pseCnsoamtipoennsCaotmiomn iBssoioarnd.. DAleapbaarmtmaeDntepoafrLtmabeonrt ooff CInadnuasdtar.ial Relations. AAlraizsoknaaInIndduusstrtiraiallBCooamrdm. ission. ACarkliafnosrnasiaWDoerpkamrtemne'snCt oofmIpnednussattriioanl CRoelmatmioinsssi.on. "OCaoTlornreacdforrcIrnrtdrAusVtoriraklTrC^ommission and StaCtoerrCmorimsspioernnsation Insurance F--u--nd. FDleolraiwdaarIendInudsutrsitarliaCl oAmcmciidsesinotnB, oard. GHeaowragiiiaBBuoraeradu ooffWWoorrkkmmeenn's's CCoommppeennssaattiioonn.. IIldlainhooisInIndduustsrtiraial lACcocmidmenistsBioona.rd.
224
1954 MEETING OP IAIABC
IInowdiaanWa oIrnkdmusetnr'isalCBomoapredn. sation Service. KKaenntsuacskOyffWiceorokfmWenor'skmCoenm'speCnosmatipoennsBaotiaornd.Commissioner. MMaairnyelaInndduSstatrtiealInAdcucsidtreinalt ACoccmidmeinsstioCno.mmission. MMiacshsiagcahnusWetotsrkDmeepna'srtCmoemntpoefnsIantdiounstrCiaolmAmciscsidioenn.ts. MMiisnsnisessioptpai IWndoursktmrieanl 'Cs oCmommipsesniosna.tion Commission. MiRsseolautriioWnso. rkmen's Compensation Division, Department of Labor and Industrial NMeobnrtaasnkaa IWndoursktmrieanl 'As cCcoidmepnetnBsaotaiordn. Court. NNeewvaHdaamInpdsuhsitrreiaDl eCpoamrtmmiesnsitono.f Labor. New Jersey Department of Labor and Industry. NNeeww YMoerxkicWo Lorakbmorena'nsdCIonmdupsetnrsiaatlioCnomBomairsdsi.on. NNoorrtthh CDaarkoolitnaaWInodrukmstreina'ls CCoommmpeisnssioatni.on Bureau. OOhkiloahIonmduasStrtiaatleCInomsumrainsscieonF.und and the Industrial Commission. POerengnosnylvSatantiea IDndepuastrrtimalenAtcocfidLeanbt oCroamnmd iIsnsidouns.try. PRuheordtoe IRsilcaondInDdeupstarritaml eCnotmomf iLsasiboonr.and the State Insurance Fund. SSoouutthh DCaarkoolitnaaInIndduustsrtiraial lCCoommmmisissisoionn. . TTeenxnasesIsnedeuWstroiraklmAecnc'sidCenotmBpoeanrsda.tion Division, Department of Labor. Vermont Department of Industrial Relations. VWiragshiniinagtIonnduDsterpiaalrtCmoemnmt oisfsiLoanb.or and Industries. WWiessctoVnsiirngiInniaduWstoriraklmCeonm'smCiossmiopne.nsation Fund. WUnyiotemdinSgtaWteosrDkmepeanr'tsmCeonmt poefnLsaabtioorn. Department.
Associate Members AmSeercirceatnaryA,c5a0d1emFyiftohf ACvoemnpuee,nsNateiwonYMorekdi1c7in, eN, .InYc.., Barnett S. Fox, Executive AmpeenriscaatnionAsCsolaciimatse,dStI.nsLuoruainsc, eMCo.os., William G. Burch, Superintendent Com AmDe.ricCan. Federation of Labor, 901 Massachusetts Avenue, NW., Washington 1, AmcielroicnanInMduesdtirciaall HAessaoltchia,ti5o3n5, NCoormthmDitteeaerboonrnWSotrrekemt,enC'shiCcaogmop1e0n,s1a1t1i.on, Coun AAmmeerriiccaann MTeuletupahlonLeia&bilTiteyleIgnrsauprhanCceo,,CoJa.,mBeosstRon. ,SMhiaeslds.s, Attorney, 195 Broad Aswsoacyia,tiNone.wjaf_Y_oCrak&7u,alNty, aYn.d Surety Cos., 60 John Street, New York 7, N. Y.
APPENDIX A
225
Association of New York State Mutual Casualty Cos., M. J. Murphy, General AuMtoanOawgnere,rs60InEsuarsatn4c2edCSot.r,eFet,, SN. eWwaYrnoerrk, A17t,toNrn. eYy., Lansing, Mich. Bethlehem Steel Co., F. R. Bamako, Manager of Compensation and Safety, CoBmepthelneshaetmio,n PIan.surance Rating Board of New York, Henry D. Sayer, General CoMngarneassgeorf, I1n0d0uEstarsiat l42OdrgSatrneiezta,tiNonesw, 7Y1o8rkJa1c7k, sNon. YP.lace, NW., Washington 6, E.D.I.Cd.u Pont de Nemours & Co., 7058 Du Pont Building, Wilmington 98, Del. JEomsepplohyDeresanMEutduwalarLdsia,bAiltittoyrnInesyu,ra1n44ceJoChon., SWtraeuets,auN,eWwisY. ork 38, N. Y. E.OhI.ioE. vans, Consulting Actuary, 520 Huntington Bank Building, Columbus 15, TFahremFBiduerleitayu&MCutausaulalAtyutoCmo.oboifleNIenwsurYanocrke, CRoa.,yCmoolnudmbNu.s C16a,vOerhlyio,. Vice Presi FodrdenMt, o8t0orMCaoid.,eJnamLaense,L.NHeiwll,YSourpke,rv3i8sinNg. AY.ttorney, Workmen's Compensation ThSeecBt.ioFn., G30o0o0drSicchhaCefoe.,r CRhoaardle, sDFe.arNbuotrtne,r,MMicahn.ager, Workmen's Compensation HaDnenpaarCtmoaelnCt,oA.,kJroohnn, OJh.ioB. abka, Compensation Director, St. Clairsvilie, Ohio. HaSrtdewveanres PMouintut,alWCisa.sualty Co., D. S. Parish, Compensation Claims Specialist, E.LHos. AHnegrleilheys, 14H,eCrlaihliyf. & Herlihy, Attorneys at Law, 412 West. Sixth Street, ISnadmuusetrliaBl. HMoerdoivciatlz, AAststoocrniaetyio,n6, BDera.coEndSwtraerdet, HBoolsmtobnla8d,, MMasasn.aging Director, Li2b8erEtyasMt uJatuckalsoInnsBuroaunlceevaCrdo,.,C1h7i5caBgoerk4e, l1e1y1. Street, Boston 7, Mass. LHuomwbaerdrmMenag'seeM, uAtuttaolrnCeays,u5a1l0tyVCaon.,N4e7s5s0ASvheenriudea,nSaRnoaFdr,anCchisiccaogo2,4C0a, l1if1.1. MiBcuhiigldainng,MDuetutraolit L2i6a,biMliitcyh.Co., W. R. MacGregor, Vice President, Mutual Na4t0io7nMalicAhsigsoacniaTtihoenatoefr CBluaiilmdianngt,s MCuosmkepgeonnsa, tiMonichA. ttorneys, Benjamin Marcus, National Association of Mutual Casualty Cos., 919 Michigan Avenue, Chicago Na1t1io, n11a1l. Council on Compensation Insurance, 45 East 17th Street, New York 3, NaNti.onYa.l Council of State Sclf-Insurcra' Associations, Walter Linn, SecretaryThTerePauslulrmera,nFCinoa.,ncFe. BRu.ildCinalgl,ahPahni,laDdeirlpechtioar2, , BPuar.eau of Safety and Compensa E.tiEo.n,WMatesrocnh,anCdoisnesuMltianrgt APlcatzuaa,ryC,h2ic7a3g0oL5e4v,e1q11u.e Lincoln Tower, Columbus 15, WOeshteior.n Elec.t.r.i.c....C. --o., V. J. Gilb' ert, Atto~r~ney, 195 Broadway, Now York 7, N. Y. WYooodrwk a1r7d, &N.FYo.ndiller, Inc., Consulting Actuaries, 200 West 57th Street, New ZuSruicpherGinetnenerdaelntA, ccCidomenpte&nsaLtiioanbiliCtylaiImnssurDaenpcaertCmoe.,nt,Ltd13.,5 HSeonurtyh BLuachmSaalnle,
Street, Chicago 3, 111.
880588-- 65-- - 1
APPENDIX C
Ofofifctiahle AInttteenrdnaanticoenaalt AthsseocFiaotritoinetho fAInndnuusatlriMaleAetcincig
dent Boards and Commissions
CANADA
A Iberia
A. Farmilo, M. B. E., Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Board, Ed
monton. Dr. H. H.
H epburn,
Chief
Medical
Officer,
Workmen's
Compensation
Board,
C.EMdm. Monatocnl.eod, Q. C., Chairman, Workmen's Compensation Board, Edmonton.
British Columbia FA.damP.BAerlclh, iCbahalidr,mSaenc,reWtaorryk, mWeonr'skmCoenm'speCnosmatpioennsBatoiaornd,BVoaarndc,oVuvaenrc.ouver. C. W. Pritchard, Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Board, Vancouver.
M anitoba
G.nipLe.g.Couslbt, Q. C., Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Board, Win
P. V. E. Jones, Assistant to Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Board,
Winnipeg.
New Brunswick
A. A. Chisholm, President, New Brunswick Accident Prevention Association,
R.MoGn.cJtoonh.nston, Vice Chairman, Workmen's Compensation Board, St. John.
J. A. LeBlanc, Claims Officer, Workmen's Compensation Board, St. John.
Newfoundland
Clarence V. Hancock, Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Board, St.
John's.
Nova Scotia
FArrathnukrRPoewter,ieC,hCaiormmmanis,sWionoerrk,mWeno'srkCmoemn'psenCsoamtiopnenBsaotairodn, HBoaalirfda,x.Halifax.
Ontario JM. aFx. CDaoudldesy,,OVnitcaeriCohFaeirdmeraanti,oWn oorfkLmaebno'rs, CToomropnetnos.ation Board, Toronto. FG.eorFginecGhaamrr, oWworGkrmeeenn'se,CDoimrepcetonrsa, tFioendeBraolarGdo,vTeornromnetno.t Employees Compensa W.tioJ.nJBorhannsctho,nD, eWpaorrtkmmeennt'sofCLomabpoern,sOattitoanwBa.oard, Toronto. J. B. Lane, Department of Labor, Ottawa.
-- - m -
APPENDIX C
229
L.TBo.roLnetpop.ard, Physicist, Division of Industrial Hygiene, Department of Health,
Wills V. C.
PMhealcalna,cDhliraenc,toPrr,esCidaennatd,iCananBardainanchInofduthsteriIa.l
LS.aOfe.t,
yOCttoanwfear.ence,
Toronto.
G. E.
Allan
PPooorltee,rW, Dorekpmaretnm'senCtoomfpLenabsaotri,onOtBtaowarad.,
Toronto.
AE.. ER.oSbipnasrorno,wW, Corhkamiremna'sn,CWomoprkenmseanti'osnCBomoapredn,sTatoiroonnBtoo.ard, Toronto.
DWra.bEb.enC.WS.teSetleea,rnWso, rCklmaiemns'sMCaonmapgeenr,saLtiibonertByoaMrdu,tuTaolrIonnstuor.ance Co., Toronto.
DrT.oBrornutco.e Young, Director, Rehabilitation, Workmen's Compensation Board,
Quebec
SAt.eGph. eBnalBlaacbhine,y,SPafreetsyideDnitr,eQctuore,beQcuMebeetcalIMroinni&ngTAitsasnoicuiamtioCno, rNpoorraantidoan., SoreL
Dr. W.
B L.
erBternannedt
tB,
ellemare, President,
Workmen's Compensation Commission, Quebec. Quebec Pulp & Paper Safety Association, Quebec.
JDarc.qLu.esAB. eBrrnoacrhdu,,MWoonrtkremael.n's Compensation Commission, Quebec.
JAa.cqSu. eCs oCoaks,gbSaecinr,etDareyp-aMrtamnaengetro, f QLaubebore,c QPuuelbpec.& Paper Safety Association,
PaQuuleAbe.cC. ooke, Joint Manager, Quebec Industrial Accident Prevention Associa
A.tHioner, mQaunebCeco.le, Safety Director, Canadian Car & Foundry Co., Ltd., Montreal.
J. Armand Desrochers, Vice President, Quebec Association for the Prevention
J. oAf.IDnduucsktreitatl,AMccoindternetasl,. Quebec.
JPeaaunl
DDeesssjaaurldliness,,
Shawinigan Water & Power Co., Assistant to President, Casgrain
Montreal. & Charbonneau,
Montreal.
J. J.
E. E.
RD.ioDne,mWerosr,kmWeonr'ksmCeonm'spCenosmaptieonnsaCtioomn mCiosmsiomni,ssQioune,bQecu.ebec.
JJ.osHe.phDDeleisllaeg,e,CoWmomrkismsieonn'esr,CWomoprkenmseanti'osnCComompemnissastiioonn, QCoumebmeci.ssion, Quebec.
AHrotnhourrabFloestMer. ,LV. iDceuPplreessisdiesn, tQ, .WCo.,rkPmreemn'iserCoofmQpuenebsaecti.on Commission, Quebec.
HDor.noGruasbtlaevOe nGeisnimgreaGs,agMneodni,caMl iDniirsteecrtoorf, FRinehaanbceil,itQatuioenbecI.nstitute, Montreal.
SW. illGiarmegoGrayl,lCaghhieefr,ClMaiomnstrAeagle.nt, Canadian National Railways, Montreal.
JJ
ean Ga
oachim
rGneraeun,i
eWr,orQk.meCn.',s
PCroemsipdeennts,atiWonorCkommenm'sissCioonm, pQeunesbaetcio.n
Commission,
BeQrnueabredc.C. Hamel, Quebec Power Co., Quebec.
RHoodno. lWphilefrHedamHela,meVli,ceMParyeosridoefntQ, uCebaetch.olic Conference of Labour, Asbestos.
A. H. Honsberger, President, Quebec Metal Mines Accident Prevention Associa
H.tioHn., HNooruagnhd,a.Chief Claims Agent, Canadian Pacific Railway, Montreal,
LMe.oMpoalrdcHLuabceorstt,eS,aEfedtiyficDeirCeacdtoilrl,acQ,uMeboenctrNeoarl.th Shore Paper Co., Baie Comeau.
Maurice Laperriere, Quebec Iron & Titanium Corporation, Sorel.
230
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
EuQgueenbeec.Larochelle, Secretary General, Quebec Metal Mining Association, DNore. lArLtahruorchLee,cWleorrck,mCehni'esf CMoemdpiceanlsaOtifofincerC, oWmmorikssmioenn,'sQCueobmepc.ensation Com Drm. iDss.ioLn,eoQnuaebredc,.Workmen's Compensation Commission, Quebec. TW.. EE. .MLoitnttlgeo,mDerirye,cStoarf,etQyuDebireecctoMr,etKalenMneinthinBg. AS.ssRocoibaetirotsno,nN, Lortadn.,dMa. ontreal. Phmilisipsipoen, MMoonntertetael., Q. C,, Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Com JJ,eaAnlpPhhonnsiex,MOorrtheonpceyd,isWt Torekcmhneinc'isanC, oMmopnetnrseaatli.on Commission, Quebec. RDoomnaeot QPuaiqmupeetr,, WDeoprkumtyenM'sinCisotemrpoefnLsaatbioonr, CDoempamritsmsieonnt, oQfuLeabbeco.r, Quebec. GP.. AMn.t.RRoocuhsesleeaauu,, WCoomrkmmiesnsi'osneCro, mWpeonrskamtioenn'sCoCmommipsesinosna,tioQnueCbeocm. mission, DaQvuiedbeRc.obillard, Workmen's Compensation Commission, Quebec. Evariste Rochette, Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Commission,
Quebec. IW. . HH.. SSoluotaanrs,,ASsasfiesttyantDtiorecMtoinr,e CMaannaadgiearn, CJoahnnasd-iMananJvoihlnies-MCoa.n, vLiltide.,CoA.,sbLetsdto.,s.
Asbestos. DDrr.. PC.aJm.ilTleouSriamnagreda,uW, Dorivkimsieonn'sofCoInmdpuesntrsiaatlioHnyCgioemnem, iMssioonnt,reQalu.ebec. DGerr. aEr.dAT. rTemurbcloaty,, PDreespiudteyntM, Iinndisutesrtrioafl LMabedoirc,aDl Aepsasortcmiaetinotn,ofMLoanbtorer,alQ. uebec. JLa. cPq.ueTsesVsbierrr,eaWulotrk, mSeecnr'estaCryo,mWpeonrskamtioenn'sCCoommmpisesnisoant,ioQnuCeboemcm. ission, Quebec. AD,r.CR. .WEa.lLk.erW, aStuspoenr,inMteenddiecnatl DofirSecaftoetry, ,CCrarnaen,e LLimimititeedd,, MMoonntrtreeaal.l. St. George White, Workmen's Compensation Commission, Quebec.
Saskatchewan OM..WD\ .VTalhloemapus,oCnh,aiCrmomanm,isWsioonrkemr, enW'soCrkommepne'snsaCtioomnpBenosaardti,onRegBionaar.d, Regina. C. C. Williams, Minister of Labor, Department of Labor, Regina.
UNITED STATES
Alabama J oe L. Coleman, Director, Department of Industrial Relations, Montgomery.
Arkansas
OG.. LW. .GHraonltm,eAs,ttoCronmeym, isUsnioitneedr, MWinoerkWmoernk'esrsC, oPmorpteSnsmaittiho.n Commission, Little
ArRnooclkd. B. Sikes, Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Commission, Little
Rock.
California
JCohseetphF rJa. zGiearl,laGguhaerarn, tMeeanInasguerra, nScteatCeoI.n, sLuorasnAcengFeluens.d, Burlingame.
W. WWMacdnLU^ChairinnTTdustriaT Accident ^Commission,' 'San Trancisco,
APPENDIX C
231
PaFurlancSiscchoa, rrenberg, Director, Department of Industrial Relations, San DH.r. BMe.rtWSm.lTsoh.no, mDaesp,aDrtempeanrttmoefnEtmofplEomympleonytm, Seanct,raSmacernatom.ento.
Colorado
HR
ay H.
arold
BCr. aTnhnoammpasno,n
,CDhairiermct
aonr
,ofI
nCdluasimtrisa,
lSCtaotme mC
iosmsiop
nenosfa
tCioonloIrnasduor,a
nDceen
vFeurn.
d
,
Denver.
Connecticut
DA.. HE.. CGoruugbhs,liPnr,esHidaertnfto,rTdoAllcGciadteentHSocuIsned, eImvonriytytowCon.., Hartford.
W. 8, McCormick, The Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., Hartford.
Delaware ADbr.elI. KJ.laMwa,cSCpoelcliaulmC, oMunesmelb,eEr,. IIn.dduustPrioanl tAdceciNdeenmt oBuorsar&d,CWo.y,oWmiinlmg.ington. JFaomrdesNA.. WMaurirxiinng,tPornes, iMdeenmt,bIenrd, uInstdruiasltrAiaclcAidcecnitdeBnotaBrdo,aWrdi,lmLainugretol.n.
District of Columbia AnFderdeewratiJo,n BoifeLmailbloer.r, Member, National Legislative Committee, American FrIanndkustFribarlnObragcakn,izaAtisosoncs.iate Director of Education & Research, Congress of BParuulceEA. .GGurrrereen,eS, eUc.reSt&. Drye-Tpraer&tmsuernctr,ofIAL1aAboBrC, , U. S. Department of Labor. DrD. eWpa.rtCm.enHtuoefpHere,alCthh,ieEfd, uEcantvioirnonamndenWtaellfCaraen,cBerethSeescdtiao,n,MdC.ancer Institute, JHoohnn. AEr.thLuarwLyearr,soCnh,aUirnmdaenr,SEecmreptlaoryyeeosf LCaobmorp.ensation Appeal Board, U. 8, MDareipearVtm. eLnkt poffinLgawboerl.l, Office of the Secretary-Treasurer, IAIABG, U. S. WiDlleipaamrtmMencCt oafulLeayb,or.Director, Bureau of Employees' Compensation, U. S. FrDanepkarMtmcEenltroofy,LUab.oSr,, Department of Labor. RFroabnerctesVCa.nSHmyitnhi,nUg,. US.nDiteedpaMrtimneenWt oofrkLearsboWr.elfare and Retirement Fund.
Florida JBa.mTb.sCColaemmearno,nG, MeneemrableCr,oIunndseuls,trIinadluCstormiaml iCssoimonm, iTssailolnah, aTsaslelea.hassee. Rodney Durban ce, Director, Workmen's Compensation Division, Industrial J oCseopmhmAis.sioPna,rTkasl,laOhralsasnedeo.. J ames T. Vocelle, Chairman, Industrial Commission, Tallahassee.
Georgia Richard W. Best, Secretary-Treasurer, Board of Workmen's Compensation, W.CEol.leBgeucPkanrke.r, Member, Board of Workmen's Compensation, Atlanta.
232
1954 MEETING OF lAIABC
Idaho
BC.liffWo.rdOpJp. eHnohpekimin,sC, hPariersmidaenn,t,InNdautsiotrniaall
Association of Self Insurers, Accident Board, Boise.
Lewiston.
Illinois
DHaennryAdBairc,hNmaatnio,nSaul pSearfienttyenCdoeunnt,cilC, oCmhpiceangsoa.tion Claims Department, Zurich
EmGilenMer.alCAalccieidnednot,&CoLmiambiislistiyonIenrs,uIrnadnucestrCiaol.,CLotmd.m, Cishsiiocang, oC. hicago.
FlCoyasduEal.tyFrCaozmiepra,nDieisr,ecCtohric,aIgnod.ustrial Division, National Association of Mutual
SM. rJs.. HMoai.rdjeorrmieanW, C. hGaririgmsabny,,ICndouunstcriilaol nCoInmdmusistsriioanl ,HCehailctahg,oA. . M. A., Chicago.
Robert S. Howe, Lumbermen's Mutual Casualty Co., Chicago.
D. Dr.
MWi.lJtoohnnsHto,nK, Croomnemnibsseibogne, rM, IenddiucastlriSaelrCviocmesmMissainonag, eCr,hiCcaagtoe.rpillar
Tractor
H.CGoe.,nPeeoMriial.ler, National Safety Council, Chicago.
JDorh. nC.MTo.uOlilns,oCno, mCmhaisirsimonaenr,, CInodmumstirsisaiolnCoonmmWisosrikonm,eCn'hsicCagoom.pensation, Indus
J. tAri.aPl aMsekdieicwalicAzs,sIollciinaotiiosnD, eCphairctamgoe.nt of Labor, Chicago.
SP.aJu.lSSt.evWenisse, ,WAemsteerrincaEnleMcturtiucaCl oA.,llCiahniccea,gCo.hicago.
Indiana HoRweacirpdroTca.l BAasstomcaiant,ionG,enTeerrarle HMaauntaeg. er and Counsel, Lynch Coal Operators DErm.aAn.uKel. FH.aMrciloluerrt,, HInedairainnagpMoliesm. ber, Industrial Board, Indianapolis. Joseph P. Miller, Chairman, Industrial Board, Indianapolis.
Iowa C. H. Greenley, Deputy Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Service,
Des Moines, Kansas
Edward Curry, Commissioner, Office of Workmen's Compensation Commis Alsbioenretr,MT.opReoksas., Examiner, Office of Workmen's Compensation Commissioner, RaKlapnhsJa.s TChitoyr. ne, Examiner, Office of Workmen's Compensation Commissioner, SimHeuotcnhiWnseonb.b, Examiner, Office of Workmen's Compensation Commissioner,
Pittsburg. Kentucky
Paul Combs, Acting Commissioner, Department of Industrial Relation^ H.FWrainlklfioarmt.s, Attorney General, Department of Labor, Frankfort.
APPENDIX C
233
Maine
J ohn Mrs.
MWa. dBeallinloeuB, aLranwayredr,,
Bangor. Industrial
Accident
Commission,
Augusta.
JCarmaens, ME., MJ oitlct,heMlelm, Lbearw,yIenrd, uBsatrnigaolrA. ccident Commission, Waterville.
F. E. Richardson, Portland. Maryland
DMre.lJvoinhnLV. F. iHnoep, kCinhasi,rBmaalnti,mIonrdeu.strial Accident Commission, Baltimore,
W. Amlobreer. t Menchine, Commissioner, Industrial Accident Commission, Balti
PaCuol.,SBieamltiemrosr, eJ.r., Manager, Compensation Department, Maryland Casualty
Henry B. Suter, New Amsterdam Casualty Co., Baltimore.
MastackuseUt
DaA.mAelreicxaannCdoelrlegPe. oAfiStukregne,onCsh, aBirrmooaknl,inSe.ubcommittee on Industrial Relations,
ADlapvhiodnDse. BS.anBkasc,hEomropwlosykeir,sAGttroorunpesyI,nSsaulreamn.ce, Boston.
TR.hoBm.aCs oWo.peBro,wDei,reMcteomrboefr,MDeivdiisciaolnRoeflaIntidounsst,riAaml AercicciadnenMts,utBuoasltoLni.ability In
E usugreanneceHC. oG.,irBooustxo,nC. hairman, Division of Industrial Accidents, Boston.
Frank E. Godfrey, Director of Self-Insurance, Division of Industrial Accidents,
StaBnowstoono.d L. Hanson, Assistant Vice President, Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.,
G.BSo.sHtoanr. lan, Vice President, American Mutual Liability Insurance Co., Boston.
JaBmoesstoGn.. Harnedy, Attorney, Massachusetts Bonding and Insurance Co.,
MMaarrcyelFl.aHJi.cHksic, kMs,emBbosetro,nD. ivision of Industrial Accidents, Boston.
EEdliwaas rJd.
JK. oMloufroplhiays,,AMtteomrnbeeyr,,
Division Boston.
of
Industrial
Accidents,
Boston.
AMsahrlyeyAS. tN. oColnaairn,, CBooustnosne.l, Liberty Mutual Insurance Co., Boston.
JMorsse.phEmAm. aSuSl. lTivoauns,aCnth,iePfaEstxaPmreinsiedre,nLt,ibIAerItAy BMCu,tQuaulinIcnys.urance Co., Boston.
Michigan WHa. rCr.yBFis. hBorpi,ggMsa,nSaugpeerr,inStteantedeAnctcoidf eCnltaiFmusn,dS, tLataensAincgc.ident Fund, Lansing. CW.illEia. mCaEb.oBtuhcebhsa,nFaonr,dCMhroytsolrerCCoo.,rpD.e, tDroeittr.oit. JHo.hAn. CC.oCmhpeiladue,rAs,ttLoirnnceoyln, SMtaetrecuArcyciDdeivnitsiFounn, dG,eLnaernaslinMg.otors, Detroit. WCyilrluisamE.JD. Dureivoe,rCs,hrCyhsrleyrslCerorCpoorrpaotiroanti,oDn,etDroetitr.oit. JaMmeostoLr.CHo.i,llD,eStruopiet.rvisory Attorney, Workmen's Compensation Section, Ford
"S5..... Xfl
234
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
W. G. Georg
eHEo.tJcohhknissso,n*C,
oMmapneangseart, i
oEnm
Spluopyeerev
iSsoerrv,
icCehsrDysel
epra
rCtmo
erpnot,r
aFtioornd,
MDoettoror
iCt. o.,
WDilelaiarbmoJrn. .Jones, Lacey, Jones & Doelle, Detroit.
F.Det.roLitu. x, Staff Attorney, Workmen's Compensation Section, Ford Motor Co.,
WaLdanesinIIg.. McC-ree, Jr., Member, Workmen's Compensation Commission,
BWe.nEja. mMinacMGarrecgoosr,, RVeicperePserenstiidnegnSt,amMuicehl iBga, nHMorouvtuitazl, LMiaubsikleitgyonC.o., Detroit.
RRoicbhearrtdLR. .ON'Coornrnies,llC,hRryostlheer, CMoraprsotroanti,oBn,oDhnet&roMit.azey, Detroit.
Thdeaoled.ore P. Hr an, Chairman, Workmen's Compensation Commission, Dimon
Richard L, Schmidt, International Representative, Compensation Department,
A.UAA.WS-cChImOit, tD, eVtrioceit.President in Charge of Claims, Corporate Service, Inc.,
FrDedetrSo.itW. arner, Attorney, Auto Owners Insurance Co., Lansing.
Minnesota Robert E. Faricy, Commissioner, Industrial Commission, St. Paul.
Mississippi SJoamhnS.A.AlClkraeido,, CCohmaimrmisasino,nWer,orWkmoreknm'senC'somCpoemnpsaetniosantioCnomCmomismsioisns,ioJna,ckJsaocnk.son.
Missouri WiAllssiaomciatGed. InBsuurracnhc,e SCuopmeprianntieensd, eSntt., LoWuiosr.kmen's Compensation, AmericanCEahralrlFe.sCEh.eCita,tAess,-NMtaenmtbPerro, fIensdsours,trSiat.l LCooumismUisnsiiovner,sJiteyff,eSrst.onLoCuiitsy.. RW.. REo. bFerreteClaonhdn,, MAettmorbneery, ,InKdaunsstarisalCCityo.mmission, Jefferson City. SpCenitcye. r H. Givens, Director, Division of Workmen's Compensation, Jefferson Stephen J. M-illett, Chairman, Industrial Commission, Jefferson City,
Montana W. W. Gasper, Secretary, Industrial Accident Board, Helena.
New Jersey WDrin. sHto. nE.BRlarnicnk,eChh, uNbebw&LSisobnosn,.Managers, Federal Insurance Co., Short Hills. CDaarnlieHl oAl.dSepramira,nD, Ciroemctomri,ssDioivniesri,onDoefpWartomrkemnteno'fs LCaobmopre&nsIantidouns,trDy,epTarretmnteonnt. of
Labor & Industry, Trenton. New Mexico EbSeannetzaeFre.J ones, Assistant Commissioner, Labor and Industrial Commission.
APPENDIX C
235
New York EvOeirleCtot.,RIn. cA.,lNdeewn, YMorakn.ager, Claims & Safety Department, Soeony-Vacuum LHo. uDrsudAlrebyeBiti,erAacutu,aDryir,eWctooro,dCwoamrdpe&nsFaotiuodnill&erS, aNfeetwy, YAoWrke.ncan Locomotive Co., MSiscshGeneercttarduyd.e Cavanaugh, Workmen's Compensation Board, Albany. ROlaiyvmeornTd. AC.lCayatvoenr,lNy,ewVicYeoPrkre. sident, Fidelity Casualty Co., New York. JM. arAs.haDlblnDkascwisieornz,,PSaesctrSeteacrrye-tCaroym-Tprtreoalsluerre, r,NIaAtiIonBalCC, oNuenwcilYoonrk.Compensation BeInnjsaumrainnceD, iNsseiwn, YSotartke. Insurance Fund, New York. JM. iRssalMpharDyyDkeosn,lUonn,itCedhaSirtamteasn,CWasouraklmtyenC'os.,CNomewpeYnsoartkio. n Board, New York. JRoicsehpahrdDFeaonndEildlwearr, dWs,ooAdtwtoarrndey&, NFeowndYillocrrk,. New York. G.FKalalsk.le Fox, Secretary, Casualty Division, Glens Falls Insurance Co., Glens Dr. Leonard J. Goldwater, National Chairman, Oardiae.-iKrluduBtry Com WmnxititseeC,. AGmoerrtihcayn, CH.e1a2r.,t DAisrseocctoiart,ioInn,stNiteuwteYfoorrkt.he Crippled and Disabled, New MYisosrJke. anette Hanlon, Associate Economist, Workmen's Compensation Board, AlNfreewdYHoerkin. en, United Steelworkers of America, Buffalo. Theodore Hetsler, Jr., Attorney, National Association of Mutual Casualty Cos., P.NHe.wHYuomrkph. ries, A. C. F. Industries, New York. H. M. J ackson, Manager, Industrial Health Program, Johns Manville Corp., AnNderwe'wYoKrka.lmykow, New York. EdNweiwn YDo.rkK. yle, Counsel, New York Compensation Insurance Rating Board, JMo.hLn. MLa. sMkocwDsoknia, lWd,eDsteirrenctEolre,cWtriocrkCmo.e, nI'nscC.,oNmepwenYsaotriko.n, Associated Industries RoobfeNrtewE.YMorakrSshtaatlel,,IAncd.m, Ainlibsatrnayt.ive Deputy, Workmen's Compensation Board, GeNoerwgeYEo.rkM. illigan, Manager, Workmen's Compensation Disability Claims MiDcihvaisbilonJ,. AMmuerripchayn,SGuerneteyraCl oM,,aNnaegwerY, oArkss.ociation of New York State Mutual RaCyaJs.uaOltayklCeoys,.,SNtaetwe IYnosurkr.ance Fund, New York. MMiissss MMaarryionPoPi.oolkaoxvo.vB,uSfefaclroe.tary, United Steelworkers of America, Buffalo. JRa.mVe.sRJy. aRne,gFaind,elSiteycre&taCrya,suTahletySCelof.-IonfsuNreewrs YAossrkoc, iNateiown,YNorekw. York. Henry D. Bayer, General Manager, New York Compensation Insurance Rating .BMoa.rdS,cNhemwidtY,oIrkn.surance Manager, National Council of State Self-Insurers
Association, New York.
236
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
JCaymbeusb RF.. SShmiyetlhdbs,, CAltatoimrnseAy,ttAormneeyri,caNnewTelYeoprhkonTeele&phToenleegCraop.,hNCeow., YNoerwk.York. JW. iHllaiahmb:tHT.ieStrineagnu,tAz,ttAorsnsoeyci,atUenAittetdorSnteeye,lwSotarkteerIsnosfurAamnceericFau,nBdu, ffNaelow. York. GWeaos.bDen. WC.elTlus,ckWeres,tCeronunEsleelc,trUicticCao.M, Iuntcu.a,l NIneswurYanocrke. Co., Utica. DN.h.MMo.rgWainllWiamooZdus,cAkessbo,cDiaitrieocntoorf oCfaSstuuadliteys,&CoSmurmeteyrcCeos.,INndeuwstYryorAk.ssociation
of New York, New York. North Carolina J. W. Bean, Commissioner, Industrial Commission, Raleigh,
North Dakota OBt. iMs B. Rbyyaannt,,MCehmaibrmera, nW, Workomrkemne'sn'CsoCmopmepnesantsiaotnioBnuBreuaruea, uB,isBmisamrcakr.ck.
Ohio
JHa.cDob. BCalanyomeratn,,ESmecilreetEar.yW-Tartesaosnu,reCro, lOumhibouCs.IO Council, Columbus. JB.. MGa. yGnaortdteDmoiceklelerrs,onS,uVpeicreinCtehnadiermntano,f ICndlauimstrsi,alFCarommmBiussrieoanu, CMoulutmuablusA. uto W.InCs.urHaancretmCaon.,, CAottlourmnbeuys,.Squire, Sanders <fcDempsey, Cleveland. M.GeHnoelrallanMdotKorbsi,bDe,ayDtoirne.ctor, Workmen's Compensation, Frigidaire Division, JRoichhnaKrdumWp.elM, Uornsitee,dCRhauibrbmearnW, Ionrdkuersst,riAalkCroonm. mission, Columbus. TChhoamrlaessMF,. HNaortmtearn,,BJ,onFe.sG, Dooadyr,icChoCckol.e, yAk&roRn.eavis, Cleveland.
Oklahoma FMraerdxAClhbielrdte,rIsn.dIunsdturisatlriCalomCmomismsiiosns,ioOn,klOahkolamhoamCaityC.ity. JTuodmgeG.AMlbaerrttinC,. CHoumnmt,isIsniodnuesrt,riSatlaCteomInmsuisrsainocne, OFuknladh,oOmkalaChiotym.a City. EM.oJn. tSRut.hPeorwlaenlld,, CInhdieufstAritatol rCnoeym,mSitsastieonI,nOsukrlaanhcoemFauCndit,y.Oklahoma City.
Oregon WL.iOll.iaAmreAn.sC, aMlelmahbaern,,ICnhdauisrtmriaanl ,AIcncdiudsetnrtiaCloAmcmciidsesinotnC, oSmalmemis.sion, Salem.
Pennsylvania F. R. Barnako, Manager, Compensation and Safety, Bethlehem Steel Co., FrBaentkhleKh.emBo. al, Deputy Secretary, Department of Labor and Industry, Harris A,bCur.gC. hristman, Chief Supervisor, Indemnity Insurance Co. of North America, W.PhDil.aCdeolaphkilae.y, Secretary, Fire Association of Philadelphia, Philadelphia. RE.. GMw. iHllairatmm, aMn,anAasgseisr,taSnttaMteaWnaogrekrm, Ceno'ms Ipnesnusraatinocne aFnudndS,afHetayr,risBbeuthrgle.hem Steel
Co., Bifitehem.
APPENDIX C
237
RoCbaesrutalCty. HCoe,r,oRne,aSduinpge.rintendent, Compensation Claim Department, American RuHsasrerlisbCu.rg.Reiser, Assistant Manager, State Workmen's Insurance Fund, WaAlstseorciatLioinnn, ,PhSileacdreeltpahryia-.Treasurer, National Council of State Self-Insurers JFo.hPnriLt.chNaartdl,oCeh, iDefirSecatfoerty, BInusrpeeacutoorf, WStoartekmWeno'rskmCoemn'speInnssautriaonnc,eHPanrrpisdb,uHrga.rris A.bSurcgh.roeimsr, General Attorney, Pennsylvania Railroad Co., Philadelphia. David M. Walker, Secretary, Department of Labor & Industry, Harrisburg.
Puerto Rico EMdiussarRdaoquAe. lSaNnigtiaaogloi,oAnic,tuMaerym,bSetra, tIendInussutrriaanlcCe oFmumndis,sSioann, JSuaann.Juan.
Rhode Island
AnPtroonviiodeDncie.Pinto, Executive Assistant Curative Center, Department of Labor,
DbP,roJvoihdnenEce. .Donley, Medical Director, Curative Center, Department of Labor,
South Carolina
JMaimssesFJa.itRheiCdl,aVyitcoenC, hCaoimrmmains,siIonndeur,stIrnidalusCtroimalmCisosmiomn,isCsioolnu,mCboialu. mbia.
Miss. H. 8. T ate, Columbia.
Tennessee
WP a.uHl.AP. aPrhhialmli,pCs,oSmamfeitsysioEnnegri,nDeeer,paDrtempaernttmoefnLt aobfoLr,abNoars,hNvialsleh.ville.
Deowf eLyabWor,hiNttaslhev, iDlleir.ector, Division of Workmen's Compensation, Department
Texas
DR.rL. V. .ECck. mBaanir, dV,icCehiPerfePsihdyesnitc,iaPne,trHoluemumbleCOaislualtRyeCfion.i,ngHoCuos.t,oHn.ouston.
LF.e
H.
ux
FAl.eRwaeyllmeenb,,
CPhreasiridmeannt,,
PInedtruoslteruiaml
ACcacsiudaelntyt
BCooa.,rdH, oAuustsotinn..
Mbs. C. B. Hitch, Richmond. Virginia
W.RiHch.mNonicd.kels, Jr., Chairman, Department of Workmen's Compensation,
Washington
ElamnedrInHd.usKtreiensn,eOdlyy,mSpuiap.ervisor, Rehabilitation Center, Department of Labor
West Virginia
DFrba. nJkolhinn PW. B. rKicekr, nC,haEirxmecaunt,ivOeccSuepcarteiotanrayl, DWiseoarskemMene'dsicCaloBmopaernds,aCtiohnarlFesutnond.,
RuCdhoalrplehstoJn. . Murensky, Legal Assistant, Workmen's Compensation Fund,
GeCohbaorelesWto.nS.tokes, Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation Fund, Charleston.
238
1954 MEETING OF IAIABC
Wvtoonein
SBt.uEre. nKmxmJ.imHLatj,tdVuicceh,PArettsoidrneenyt,, EMmilpwloayuekrese.Mutuals, Wausau.
3M: Eoo. rLmratwnmLas,viCrnlasirm, sACssoiustnasnetl,AEttmorpnloeyyaGeMneuratul,aMls,aWdisaouns.au. HasBY A. Nelson, Director, Workmen's Compensation, Industrial Commission, VbMtaAdiWsobn,abw*, Chairman, Industrial Commission, Madison.
Wyoming WnatM P. Pbtrt, Manager, Workmen's Compensation Commission, Cheyenne.