Document rx676z1nVNK4L2bMNKkD57xkr

//rd* fl S^'*/ /??</ ijff et/f/d f jj*1*// Ad/r ///"/> /r? <* c> ^se-s //$. i * *7*-* / t~te. - /-/c c~i//s?* /rj V To ETHYL CORPORATION INTEROFFICE T. R. Robinson, M. D. Address From h. M. Taylor SubjectAsbestos, Industrial Hygiene Survey, Baton Rouge Address Date September 18, 1973 Enclosed is a report which summarizes industrial hygiene activities relevant to employee exposure to air borne asbestos fibers within the Baton Rouge Plant. I shall be happy to discuss any questions you may have concerning the data or my interpretations. Sincerely HT: ws 0. J. Bergin cc: H. D. Borque R. Conrad S. A. D'Armond*.-----J. E. Gonce B. H. Hodge J. C. Klock S. D. Motsinger V.E. Rinehart, Sc. D. W. C. Strader Henry Taylor Industrial Hygienist E-02313 ETC 14615 SUMMARY REPORT OF ASBESTOS AND THE INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE SURVEY OF AIRBORNE ASBESTOS FIBERS WITHIN THE BATON ROUGE PLANT SUMMARY REPORT OF ASBESTOS AND THE INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE SURVEY OF AIRBORNE ASBESTOS FIBERS WITHIN THE BATON ROUGE PLANT Survey Conducted June 26 and July 27, 1973 by Henry M. Taylor, Jr., MPH Certified in Comprehensive Industrial Hygiene Practice Ethyl Corporation Medical Department 451 Florida St. Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70801 ETC 14616 E--02314 REPORT FORMAT Background 1 Summary Asbestos Insulation within Baton RougePlant5 Industrial Hygiene Equipment and Method _______________________ Airborne Asbestos Fibers; Impressions Storage, Transfer, Cutting Application, Removal, Disposal 8 Airborne Asbestos Fibers; Recommendations Storage, Transfer, Cutting Application Removal; Storage11 Suggested Future Industrial HygieneRelated Activities____ Tables ________________________________________________ 4 6 7 9 10 11 13 E-02315 ETC 14617 1 BACKGROUND General Information Asbestos is the general name for a group of naturally occurring, crystalline, hydrated, mineral silicates. The technological utility of asbestos derives from its occurrence in a fibrous state and from its properties of exceptional physical strength, resistance to thermal de gradation, and resistance to attack by acids or alkalis. MEDICAL AND INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE INVOLVEMENT Inhalation of asbestos dust has been recognized as an industrial hazard since the early 1930s. In 1935, evidence began to accumulate that certain other poor health effects were also associated with long term in halation of unknown concentrations of asbestos fibers. During the following years the effects of asbestos upon worker health became better recognized and accepted by medical authorities. In those industries whose primary interest concerned asbestos, various methods were being evaluated to characterize hazardous asbestos concentrations accurately in the work environment^ * Early procedures for characterizing environmental airborne levels of asbestos called for counting all the visable material which had been captured upon a sampling filter when examined under a light field microscope. It was soon learned this microscopic method had severe limitations. How ever, since most measurements of asbestos fiber concentrations in industrial environments are economically practical only for those fibers visible by light microscopy, an analytical technique has now been standarlzed that employees 400x magnification, phase contrast illumination and which counts fibers longer than 5 microns. ETC 14618 E-023l6 2 Baton Rouge Plant Within Ethyl Corporation, records indicate plant and corporate medical department personnel met in July of 1969 to develop recommend ations for a course of action concerning asbestos use within the Baton Rouge plant where asbestos is incidental to the mainstream effort. Consequent to that meeting, W. E. Rinehart had a survey performed to determine asbestos levels at what should have been the worse conditions. The asbestos concentrations found were well within the bounds of the Threshold Limit Value (TLV) and accepted industrial practice recognized at that time. Nevertheless, a strong recommendation was made for con tinuance of the practice of wearing "Dust-Foe" type respirators. The results from the 1969 report and an additional column which presents the same data in terms of todays permitted exposures as defined in the Depart ment of Labor, Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) standards follows:^ Site and Condition 1969 No.of asb.fibers? (mppcf)? In shop of second floor alloy area 0.3 at breathing zone during hand sawing of asbestos board Near vibrating conveyor of second floor alloy area at breathing zone 0.1 during hand sawing, slicing and fitting of pipe insulation In shop of hydrocarbon area at 1.2 breathing zone during hand sawing of asbestos board (doors Closed) 1973 No.of asb.fibers3 11.0 3.5 42.0 ETC 14619 17 Outside shop of hydrocarbon area at breathing zone during ripping of asbestos Recommended standard and present OSHA level 1976 OSHA level 4.2 2.0 150. 3 5 2 The 1973 conversion assumes all the 1969 fibers were'greater than 5 micrometers in length. / T - i rsrr\ xl .. _ i .. . ... - J-J u .. xu. -- r-___. r*.._______________________....______x i 111 i?u? viixr Vaiuc I ewuiiuncMucu ujf me nmci Kqii uuimciciiuc ui uuvci nuiciaat Industrial Hygienists as a TLV for asbestos was 2 million particles per cubic foot (mppcf) of work air. This assumed repeated 8 hour workdays under relatively constant exposure conditions. 3 In 1973 the value permitted by OSHA requires appropriate respiratory protection for those exposed to asbestos fiber levels in concentrations of fibers in excess of 5 fibers longer than 5 microns in length per cubic centimeter of work air. In 1976 this will be lowered to 2 fibers. This limit is an 8 hour time weighted average. However, it permits only brief excursions above base level to a ceiling of 10 fibers per cubic centimeter. etc 14620 e_02318 4 SUMMARY 1. Although a complete indepth study was not made of every location where asbestos fibers might be stored, transferred, cut, applied, removed or disposed of, there was no indication that a significant acute environmental health hazard was present at any of the locations evaluated. 2. There was no evidence of a chronic environmental health hazard. 3. There was indication in light of the Occupational Safety and Health Standards of need for engineering controls to be instituted in certain processes which handle asbestos. ETC 14621 0 ASBESTOS INSULATION WITHIN BATON ROUGE PLANT Insulation handlers at the Baton Rouge Plant constitute a craft within the maintenance worker organization. They are reported to be a very stable group with very little turnover who for the most part are long term employees. Of the 14 insulation workers, seven are assigned to TEL and sodium areas, six work in the hydrocarbon area while one works in construction. Insulation is handled in PVC on a routine basis, but not by the same men each day. Some nine men may handle asbestos within the PVC area on an irregular basis. In addition, there are three or four caustic chlorine operations people who are involved in preparing caustic cell diaphragms and assisting with the cell installation. Insulation material is brought into the plant storage area often from railroad cars and is then withdrawn as needed and generally goes to either of three areas, TEL, sodium and chlorinated hydrocarbons. During the past year it has been and still is plant practice to en courage substitution of asbestos with non-asbestos materials where feasible. This has essentially been accomplished with pipe covering and spray type insulation. However, to date a satisfactory substitute has not been found for Transite, Marinite or insulating blocks. Finally, it is understood the plant has adopted a policy of bagging all nonwelted asbestos materials which go to waste. ETC 14622 e_02320 6 INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE EQUIPMENT AND METHOD Environmental work air was sampled by use of a personal sampling system which was powered by a M.S.A. Montair portable pump which was clipped to the belt of the various process operators involved in the study. This pump, set at a pre-calibrated flow rate of 2 1/min. drew work air through a flexable tube which was connected to an open faced 37mm, 0.8/j pore size, type AA Millipore filter. The filter holder was clipped to the involved workers' shirt collar. After sampling, the filters were taken to the 6SRI laboratory; and mounted in a high-vicosity solution which consisted of membrane filter material in a 50/50 mix of dimethyl phthalate and diethyl oxalate; then covered with a No. 1 cover glass; and viewed through a binocular Leitz microscope using a polorizing substage condenser with corresponding objectives and parfocalized eye pieces equipped with a calibrated grid and at a 400X magnification. A minimum of 20 optical fields were ex amined for each sample. ETC 14623 -02321 7 AIRBORNE ASBESTOS FIBERS Based on past experience in other facilities, little or no asbestos fibers have been introduced into the work air by incidental handling or passive use of the type of asbestos rope, listing tape, safety gloves, paper or asbestos cloth used for hat shields as purchased by the plant. Likewise, the hand cutting of gasket materials of the type purchased has not introduced fibers into the work area. Consequently, processes which involved use of these products were not re-evaluated. For the purpose of brevity, the system of reporting which follows in this report presents a series of impressions or observations related to the 18 work situations which were evaluated and to asbestos in a general manner, followed by relevant recommendations for your consideration. IMPRESSIONS Storage 1. Generally, asbestos materials in the various storage areas and shops were ? not identified with warning signs in accordance with OSHA requirements. Transfer 1. Asbestos materials were not identified per OSHA requirements. Cutting 1. All fiber exposure levels produced during cutting of asbestos were in excess of OSHA lower limits and therefore these processes require the operators to wear respirators for OSHA compliance. In most cases, asbestos handlers were using OSHA acceptable protection by wearing Bureau of Mines approved 3-M respirators. However, in several power sawing operations, in the R&D maintenance shop and in the central shops carpenter shop area, dusting spread throughout the immediate area and if cutting had continued, would eventually have produced fiber levels high enough to require every- ETC 14624 E-02322 a one in these shops to wear approved respirators for OSHA compliance. 2. Asbestos materials which were cut included Transite (of known composition) asbestos blocks and Marinite (a Johns-Manville product which contains about 23% asbestos.) Application 1. Installation of asbestos blocks was not evaluated. % 2. Caustic chlorine workers exposure to asbestos fibers was again found to be well below the minimum OSHA levels. In addition their work environ ment is stable to the point that adverse weather conditions could not produce a more concentrated fiber level. 3. Fiber production during operation of the machine in the R&D laboratory glass blowing room was minimal and below minimal OSHA level. 4. It is understood the plant now uses a non asbestos substitute in place of 'asbestos shorts to prepare "mud" used to seal insulation. Removal 1. Inside removal produced asbestos fiber levels which were found to be at the lower levels of OSHA requirements. 2. The data indicates outside removal produced personal exposure to a fiber level significantly less than the minimal OSHA asbestos concentra' tion. Disposal 1. Airborne asbestos was not witnessed or quantified for a complete disposal process. ETC 14625 E-02323 9 AIRBORNE ASBESTOS FIBERS Recommendations Storage 1. It is understood the plant has adopted a policy to post appropriate asbestos warning signs. Transfer 1. Presumably, development of storage warnings will also produce a system which will identify asbestos materials in transfer and also at temporary depot locations. Those employees who eventually cut asbestos material should be aware of the associated hazard and what protective measures to adopt per OSHA requirement. Cutting 1. All of the asbestos cutting procedures are of variable duration and con cern processes which may last from a minute to an all day operation. Consequently; depending upon the job requirements for a particular day, the 8 hour time weighted exposure level which will often increase with increased production will range from low to high in relation to the OSHA Levels. In addition, most of the locations observed in which asbestos is cut are subject to wind effects. During those days when natural venti lation dillution from the wind is nil, even minimal asbestos cutting might produce levels in excess of OSHA requirements. Consequently, there doesn't appear to be a convenient practical operational base upon which to recommend when to require employees to use or not to use respirators. Therefore, after the table saw dust capture systems have been upgraded, it is re commended plant management continue to require employees to use approved air purifying respirators while cutting asbestos. If fitted properly and replaced when needed this type of respirator will be adequate for operator protection and will meet OSHA requirements. ETC 14 626 E--02324 10 Asbestos fiber levels found when cutting in the insulating building is low enough that air purifying respirators should be acceptable to OSHA. How ever, housekeeping is less than desirable. A shop vacuum, if maintained and used routinely, would help. In addition, less material would be spread around the shop if the inlet to the present capture system was in a usuable location and iot in the operators way. Finally, the OSHA inspectors interest that asbestos fibers be re tained as well as captured and the consequent capitol cost for efficient fiber collection encourages the establishment of a single asbestos cutting location with a single collection system. It is understood this possibility is now under evaluation. 2. Band saw cutting of asbestos should be encouraged over wheel cutting when ever possible. Asbestos fibers can be captured more readilly if they are propelled from a slower velocity cutting blade. 3. The dust collection system for the lathe in central shops should be in spected. Application 1. Although asbestos block installation was not evaluated, dusting from this process require the installer to wear an air purifying type of respira tor. If the installation occurs in an enclosed or poorly ventilated area and requires several hours or more installation time, an air line res pirator will probably be required for OSHA compliance. 2. No action is suggested concerning the handling of asbestos during caustic cell diaphragm fabrication. 3. No action is suggested concerning the R&D laboratory glass blowing operation. ETC 14627 E-02325 11 4. Although asbestos shorts have been replaced, t.he nuisance levels of the new replacement material will require the operator to wear an air purify ing type of respirator for OSHA approval. Removal 1. Conservative application of the 8 hour time weighted employee exposure concept to the inside removal data suggests those exposed in the area will be adequatedly protected for at least 1 1/2 hours by an air purifying respirator. (If reasonable dillution ventilation is present and insula tion is handled in a manner to limit dusting) 2. If removal operations require longer than 1 1/2 hours of man exposure, the man should be rotated out and not exposed to asbestos for the rest of the day or he should be required to wear an air line respirator. 3. Since we cannot control weather conditions, a similar recommendation is necessary for outside removal jobs. (Air purifying respirators for jobs lasting up to 1 1/2 hours and air line type respirator for jobs of longer duration) Disposal 1. If asbestos scrap is put into bags or kept wet, employee exposure to asbestos fibers from this source should not be in excess of OSHA limits. Suggested Future Industrial Hygiene Asbestos Related Activities 1. Obtain exact data on fiber production resulting from an asbestos block installation procedure. 2. Re-evaluate asbestos fiber production every six months at: A. Caustic chlorine cell fabrication. B. All power cutting asbestos operations. ETC 14628 E--02326 12 3. In addition, determine the fiber levels consequent to the following operations: A. An inside hand saw asbestos cutting operation. B. Re-evaluate the lathe dust collection system in central shops after it has been upgraded. ETC 14629 E--02327 13 AIRBORNE FIBER COUNTS Baton Rouge P la n t Sampled June 26, 1973^ i1./ a X u. 44o o x4(tatQ/0-o1;) CO 4C0O 00 o *iOOnr CCMO 00 o CM CM COC 4iOt-A/) QJ r-- ID X in oo lr/o) Ol o O -c3o o So>co qj S- JC <u x TJ T5 E ns o o i--ns p-- 3 0J Qj in r- QJ 5 F-- C 0J >C ro QJ in 5 </> -C x; ro J 0 Wp* 2 0J a. > ro OJ r-- f- c " O CL > in ro T3 fO ro 4-> "O IA L*D L ro ro ro ^ ro L (U LO X) C #-- QJ 3 JZ in L- OJ 0J 3c r--" I- ro QJ *D (0 C QJ ro jr C > ? >o QJ JD ro OJ ^ ro XJ 4-> QJ XJ O 0) ** rO ^ vn ro ro -o E c p ro f-- ra 4-> = X) 4-J 00 ro = 4-J 2 00 c o oro s f-- D>*f- CM C Q.-'-s, r- r-- "O -o f- ro r-- -- QJ 3 -E X in *o C 'O lO D) C J3 C ro t/> 1" X) 4- o Ot- ro p qj o. O CL D> Ec O "F- O2 C O 01r-0-- id E r-- ID o os- ns E o o s_ <u qj M 4- .n $d-) = = > LL. O r-- = OS <4- CM E I-- o s- o i- 4-J <4- JE 00 c l/) c o- |- 4/1 O o -u 4-J 4-> ID i. QSJ EO O 4. E i-- 4/1 3 4/1 O ID CO Ol Q. 1-- VO O ~^.i- I- ID ID 4/1 Ol E 4/1 <4- O in i/iMfl i-- > 4-J f-- r-- OJ CO 4/1 O -E e e i i I-- o ID 3 3 -O r-- -I-- ID 4/1 ID ID Q> QJ QJ i-- E O ID 4/1 4/1 i-- 4-> f-- E S- S- 4-> 4-> QJ 4- o cc E= = ns 00 CO s- &- c 53 E X i3 *>= c O *r- - E E ns 4- -ijQ c CID QJ ai o U. Cl Cl Oo i--ns <_) 34/1 4-> E CD O r- >1 4-J s- ns O 4- o E-- -- ns ns oj innsz S_ r-- o o> c aacn ID >- 4-> QJ ID Cl c 4-> O DIE O E 4/1 31 1- O o E Q1 Dl Dl Dl r-- E -r- J-- Ol C71 'r* 4. E O <_> i- E E E E <4- -l- 4- 4-> C C $_ O >- JO Ol > U1 O >ID !-- *r-- *f-- 'r- ID *r- -- ID ns e *o ST "O I-- -a I-- 4J O 1- r-TJ r- a oo __i !*-- e<0 qj >- ai'i- oOO 1QJ- 4idJ M<U- +idj QJ q: 4/1 E 4/1 S- QJ 4/1 4- ns 3 OJ QJ 4/1 QJ ID 4. C >4- 4-J Cl i4_ aEj o s- s_ Q3 oO T3 a: in O *" E 4-J ID C O ID TO t/1 E E3 QJ JO oj ns J4-> -E X 4- QJ^ 4-J TS" E O E 4J O 0) 4/1 4J ID 4-- OJ -r- Ol 4-J 4- . EOJ I--ns <s"- > >1 ns i-- >-- ns Q> _X J- 4-> 4. 3 ns O5 4i-fliC- 0 0*1- 4. <D QJ 4-J E u --4-J U ro r- QJ QJ E '-> <D ro -i- JO -Q E 4-1 3 in E 411 in QJ 4-> >> U 4/1 r-- sC f--ai U O 4-> f -O l/) u U rco ZU3 a> JO OJ I-- 5- M- OaJ. ea) O r- 0) E in u L. o 3M Oa OJ -Q r- OJ QJ E fc. "5 -O >> o <o ro u S- E Ur- <o4- ro (/) E in c o 4c-> a> in o C 3 O Q- c 4-> JC u E ro o 4-J 5 -Cro -C i- r- QJ 10 -P 4-> c OJ L. <U c a; u O 4-> C tO O N ro O i- " QJ O DO U LL. 3 *Ci- 0)x0:) -c m 4-J M L. "O rO OJ C 3 QJ -Q CJ U L- mU u-.X2 U *r- O <0 CM CO etc 14630 ^"02328 CM 4i0~>1) *r-- U. tO o 4- +-> O to <D .O O to z *t lO in CM VO Oo oo in 10 o CM CO o * CM 000 L 190 ro r** o> CM UJ c 1--, * in 3 C CO H- "D Z 4-> O) ZD C 3 O rO E o CL 4-> or C UJ a> o |-H 3 u. O "O OC E UJ ro zE a: o o 4-> CM CO ro C GO >> -- p- 3 X) X> c; Q. ro CO CJ u oo p* *-> 4-> in +-> 3 ro ro > u o 4J E O P" 4-> ro U p Q. Q. C 2 o o ro S_ X3 O 4-> c +> (0 ro r-- > CJ CL ft--o i~ 4-> i~ 3 *o E (/) ro M ro i- a. c O 3 r-- 4- a. cc A r-- ro s a> o T3 CJ p-- OJ U > -- XJ o a #> c O O 0) E > in 3 /> E3 o o -o 4-> cn 10 EE a> O *r- ro jc 4-> i- L. to ro ro "O ro s. CL 0) 0) 4- Q. i- i- O E o o- L- 3 to to 1 -o r* CD J_ c in to -C E &) fO -O Cl O E in ro *r- - C71 O M "D C 4-> r" in >C T3 -o p* E <D C I-- E 3 in jO O E ro in aai. r-- ai o X ro o o E -o 3E JC E *r- -M 4-> -= E 4-> S- ro X> 'p" O o2 X 24- CJ m 4-> r" E CO 0) E ro p- ro E O aj CL p CL a> 4-> pcn E ro 4J : cn E p e c p U 4-> p in in a. ro o5 E in &. p- 4O-> ro ro L- Sm a E CL 0) o u E t--t a; CL ro in E rO c= ro 4-> O C ^-O* L. O 4-> U 0) o o M in 3 T3 01 E 4-> m 4O 4J 0) -M 3 O Lr* rO 4-> ro 5 in 0) X) r0 4-> ro o> E p in 3 0) +J p in E ro E 4-> " CO ro CT> E p 4-> 4-> 3 U s. o 4-> ro QJ CL O 3 ro m 0) E ro 4-> ro cn E p* m 3 m u o p-- -Q E O p4-> ro 3 in c F* a> E r* 4+ 3 U so -> ro L. a; CL o -^463'1 ETC e- 0232^