Document reQ8GX0vndBE1bew3ZBz6aZOE
le pena
Gy 084 Signatur
C604 CYCLIC
(S. typhimurium and E. coli)
FINALREPORT
Viale Lombardia, 20 20021Bollate (MI)
aa ttt
Tnape, 214
ComteSoc Ero 8164000
BECER TcroRrevIeuEcin sar JE A
1 hende ws sense ore preprtisopnfr
a
---- oD
sy va 750
roe
harmonisation of laws, regulations and administrative provisions relating io the application of
(Relevant toQtUhAosLeIaTspYecAtsSoSfUtRheANstCudEyScToAndTuEctMedEbNyTRTC $.p.A)
Study phases monitored by RTC's QAU `According to curent relevant Standard
Operating Procedures
PROTOCOL CHECK PRREOLCAETSESD-TBAOSTEHDISINTSYPPEECTOIFOSNTSUDY TDeossteepxreecputairoant,ion
Qualit(yDAasysuMroanncteh IYnesapre)ctions Inspection | Reportio | Report to
Study Company Director | Management 9.032000 | 19.03.2000 | 19.03.2000
1131.00212.2000099
--
1116002122000009
tOytpheerofprstoucdeys.s-Tbhaeserdelienvsapnetctdioocnusmewnetraeticoanrriisedkeoputtoonnfrloeutailntehoaucgthivistpieecsifnioctidnisrpeeccttliyonredlaatteesd atroe (nhoits rAespsoorctieadtehedrel.aboratories and support functions are subject to regular facility inspections. RFeIvNiAewL RoEfPtOhiRs Treport by RTCs QAU found the reported Review completed methods and procedure o describe those used an the rests 0 || constitute an accurate representationofthe recorded raw data.
Date (Head of Quality Assurance)
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 4
Contents
Page
1. SUMMARY ................................................................................................................................ 7 2. INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................................................... 8
2.1 Purpose ............................................................................................................................. 8 2.2 Principles of the method ................................................................................................... 8 2.3 Study organisation ............................................................................................................ 8 3. MATERIALS AND METHODS.............................................................................................. 10 3.1 Test item ......................................................................................................................... 10 3.2 Control items .................................................................................................................. 10 3.3 Media .............................................................................................................................. 11 3.4 S9 tissue homogenate...................................................................................................... 12 3.5 Bacterial strains .............................................................................................................. 13 3.6 Methods .......................................................................................................................... 13 3.6.1 Preliminary toxicity test.................................................................................................. 13 3.6.2 Main experiments ........................................................................................................... 13 3.6.3 Incubation and scoring.................................................................................................... 14 4. RESULTS ................................................................................................................................. 15 4.1 Sterility test..................................................................................................................... 15 4.2 Toxicity test .................................................................................................................... 15 4.3 Assay for reverse mutation ............................................................................................. 15 5. ANALYSIS OF RESULTS ...................................................................................................... 16 5.1 Criteria for outcome of the assays .................................................................................. 16 5.2 Evaluation ....................................................................................................................... 16 6. CONCLUSION......................................................................................................................... 17 7. KEY TO TABLES 1-12............................................................................................................ 18 7.1 Structure of Tables 3-12 ................................................................................................. 18 7.2 Regression line................................................................................................................ 18
Tables
TABLE 1 - Toxicity test without metabolic activation ....................................................................... 19 TABLE 2 - Toxicity test with metabolic activation ............................................................................ 20 TABLE 3 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - TA1535..................................................... 21 TABLE 4 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - TA1537..................................................... 22 TABLE 5 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - WP2uvrA.................................................. 23 TABLE 6 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - TA98......................................................... 24 TABLE 7 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - TA100....................................................... 25 TABLE 8 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - TA1535 ............................................................. 26 TABLE 9 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - TA1537 ............................................................. 27 TABLE 10 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - WP2uvrA ........................................................ 28 TABLE 11 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - TA98 ............................................................... 29 TABLE 12 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - TA100 ............................................................. 30
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 5
Contents
Page
Appendices APPENDIX 1 - Historical control data without metabolic activation (2000-2008)............................ 31 APPENDIX 2 - Historical control data with metabolic activation (2000-2008)................................. 32
Addenda ADDENDUM I - Study Protocol ........................................................................................................ 33 ADDENDUM II - Certificate of analysis............................................................................................ 48 ADDENDUM III - S9 production and quality control certificates ..................................................... 50
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 6
1.
SUMMARY
1.1
The test item C6O4 CYCLIC was examined for the ability to induce gene mutations in tester
strains of Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli, as measured by reversion of
auxotrophic strains to prototrophy. The five tester strains TA1535, TA1537, TA98, TA100
and WP2 uvrA were used. Experiments were performed both in the absence and presence of
metabolic activation, using liver S9 fraction from rats pre-treated with phenobarbitone and
betanaphthoflavone.
1.2
The test item was used as a solution in sterile distilled water.
1.3
The test item C6O4 CYCLIC was assayed in the toxicity test at a maximum dose level of
5000 Pg/plate and at four lower concentrations spaced at approximately half-log intervals:
1580, 500, 158 and 50.0 Pg/plate. Concentrations are expressed in terms of active ingredient.
No precipitation of the test item was observed at the end of the incubation period at any
concentration. No toxicity was observed at any dose level with any tester strain.
1.4
In Main Assay I, using the plate incorporation method, the test item was assayed at the
following dose levels expressed in terms of active ingredient: 5000, 2500, 1250, 625 and 313
Pg/plate. No toxicity was observed at any dose level with any tester strain both in the
absence and presence of S9 metabolic activation.
As no relevant increases in revertant numbers were observed at any concentration tested, a pre-incubation step was included for all treatments of Main Assay II. The test item was assayed at the same concentrations employed in Main Assay I. Toxicity, as indicated by thinning of the background lawn and/or reduction in revertant numbers, was observed at higher dose levels with all tester strains, both in the absence and presence of S9 metabolic activation.
No precipitation of the test item was noted at the end of the incubation period at any concentration tested, in any experiment.
1.5
The test item did not induce two-fold increases in the number of revertant colonies in the
plate incorporation or pre-incubation assay, at any dose level, in any tester strain, in the
absence or presence of S9 metabolism.
1.6
It is concluded that the test item C6O4 CYCLIC does not induce reverse mutation in
Salmonella typhimurium or Escherichia coli in the absence or presence of S9 metabolism,
under the reported experimental conditions.
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 7
2.
INTRODUCTION
2.1
Purpose
This report describes experiments performed to assess the mutagenic activity of the test item to Salmonella typhimurium strains TA1535, TA1537, TA98 and TA100, and to Escherichia coli strain WP2 uvrA using the procedures developed by Ames et al., 1975 and revised by Maron and Ames, 1983.
The study was designed to comply with the experimental methods indicated in: - Test method B.13/14 `Reverse mutation test using bacteria' described in Council
Regulation (EC) No. 440/2008. - OECD Guideline for the testing of chemicals No. 471 (Adopted July 1997). - ICH S2A Genotoxicity: Specific Aspects of Regulatory Tests, Step 5.
2.2
Principles of the method
Reverse mutation assays employ bacterial strains which are already mutant at a locus whose phenotypic effects are easily detected. The Salmonella tester strains have mutations causing dependence on a particular amino acid (histidine) for growth. The ability of test items to cause reverse mutations (reversions) to histidine-independence can easily be measured. The E. coli tester strains of the WP2 series are similarly mutant at the tryptophan locus.
Since many chemicals only demonstrate mutagenic activity after metabolism to reactive forms, in order to detect these "indirect mutagens" the test is performed in the presence and absence of a rat liver metabolising system.
2.3
Study organisation
Sponsor:
SOLVAY SOLEXIS S.p.A. Viale Lombardia, 20 20021 Bollate (MI) Italy
Location of Study:
Research Toxicology Centre S.p.A. Genetic Toxicology, in vitro Toxicology and Immunology Department Via Tito Speri, 12/14 00040 Pomezia (Rome) Italy
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 8
Principal dates:
Study protocol approved by Study Director: 09-Mar-2009 Study commenced: 20-Mar-2009 (Toxicity assay treatment) Study completed: 30-Mar-2009 (Completion of scoring Main Assay II)
Study Director:
S. Cinelli, Biol. D.
Archiving:
The original data arising from this study, the original final protocol and a copy of the final report consigned will be stored in the archives of Research Toxicology Centre S.p.A. for a period of 3 years from the date of consignment of the report. At the completion of this period the Sponsor will be contacted for despatch or disposal of the material. An aliquot of the test item will be retained within the archives of the testing facility for a period of 10 years after which it will be destroyed.
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 9
3.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The methods used were in compliance with the attached Study Protocol (Addendum I).
3.1
Test item
Details of the test item received at RTC were as follows:
Name
:
Label name
:
Batch
:
Expiry date
:
Received from
:
Date received
:
Amount received
:
Description from the Sponsor :
Description at first use
:
Container
:
Storage at RTC
:
RTC reference number
:
C6O4 CYCLIC cC6O4 (solution 16%) 150/28 31-Dec-2020 Solvay Solexis S.p.A. 05-Mar-2009 337.94 ml yellowish solution yellowish liquid colourless glass bottle room temperature 11663
On 16 March 2009 and 27 March 2009 two sub-samples of 7 ml and 5ml, respectively, of the test item were transferred from the Formulation Unit to the Department of Genetic Toxicology, in vitro Toxicology and Immunology and stored under the same conditions. A certificate of analysis, supplied by the Sponsor, can be found in Addendum II of this report.
Solutions of the test item, as received, were prepared immediately before use in sterile distilled water. Solutions were prepared on a weight/volume basis. Concentrations were expressed in terms of active ingredient. All test item solutions were used within 2 hours and 21 minutes of the initial formulation. No assay of test item stability, nor its concentration and homogeneity in solvent were undertaken. All dose levels in this report are expressed to three significant figures.
3.2
Control items
The solvents used in this study were: Sterile distilled water (Bieffe Medital, batch 08G2803). Dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) (Fluka AG, batch 1331319 30907P11).
Positive control treatments used solutions prepared as follows:
Sodium azide (Moltox, Inc., batch 6289SA) in distilled water. 9-Aminoacridine (9-AA.HCl, Moltox, Inc., batch 1004AAHC) in DMSO. 2-Nitrofluorene (Moltox, Inc., batch 2210NF) in DMSO. 2-Aminoanthracene (Moltox, Inc., batch 6306AA and Sigma, batch 58F-3462) in DMSO. Methylmethanesulphonate (MMS) (Sigma, batch 018K3765) in distilled water.
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 10
Positive control treatments are indicated in the following table:
Tester strain
Absence of S9
Presence of S9
TA1535
sodium azide 1 Pg/plate
2-aminoanthracene 1 Pg/plate
TA100
sodium azide 1 Pg/plate
2-aminoanthracene 1 Pg/plate (2 Pg/plate)
TA1537
9-amino-acridine 50 Pg/plate
2-aminoanthracene 1 Pg/plate
TA98
2-nitrofluorene 2 Pg/plate
2-aminoanthracene 1 Pg/plate (2 Pg/plate)
WP2 uvrA
methylmethanesulphonate 500 Pg/plate
2-aminoanthracene 10 Pg/plate (20 Pg/plate)
Concentrations refer to both treatment methods. When two values are given, the figures in brackets refer to the pre-incubation method assay.
3.3
Media
The following growth media were used:
Nutrient Broth: Oxoid Nutrient Broth No 2 was prepared at a concentration of 2.5% in distilled water and autoclaved prior to use. This was used for the preparation of liquid cultures of the tester strains.
Nutrient Agar: Oxoid Nutrient Broth No 2 (25g) and Difco Bacto-agar (15g) were added to distilled water (1 litre) and autoclaved. The solutions were then poured into 9 cm plastic Petri dishes and allowed to solidify and dry before use. These plates were used for the non-selective growth of the tester strains.
Minimal Agar: Minimal medium agar was prepared as 1.5% Difco Bacto-agar in VogelBonner Medium E, with 2% Glucose, and poured into 9 cm plastic Petri dishes.
Top Agar: "Top Agar" (overlay agar) was prepared as 0.6% Difco Bacto-agar + 0.5% NaCl in distilled water. Prior to use 10 ml of a sterile solution of 0.5 mM Biotin + 0.5 mM Histidine (or 0.5 mM tryptophan) was added to the top agar (100 ml).
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 11
3.4
S9 tissue homogenate
Two MOLTOX rat S9 liver tissue fractions were used in this study had the following characteristics:
Lot Number Inducing Agents Preparation date Expiry date Received from Date received Storage at RTC Strain Sex of donors Protein content
: 2273 : Phenobarbital - 5,6-Benzoflavone : 01-May-2008 : 01-May-2010 : MOLTOX, Molecular Toxicology, Inc. : 05-Dec-2008 : Approximately -80C : Sprague Dawley : Male : 37.6 mg/ml
Lot Number Inducing Agents Preparation date Expiry date Received from Date received Storage at RTC Strain Sex of donors Protein content
: 2378 : Phenobarbital - 5,6-Benzoflavone : 18-Feb-2009 : 18-Feb-2011 : MOLTOX, Molecular Toxicology, Inc. : 24-Mar-2009 : Approximately -80C : Sprague Dawley : Male : 37.8 mg/ml
Production and quality control certificates can be found in Addendum III of this report
The mixture of S9 tissue fraction and cofactors (S9 mix) was prepared as follows (for each 10 ml):
S9 tissue fraction NADP (100 mM) G-6-P (100 mM) KCl (330 mM) MgCl2 (100 mM) Phosphate buffer (pH 7.4, 200 mM) Distilled Water
1.0 ml 0.4 ml 0.5 ml 1.0 ml 0.8 ml 5.0 ml
1.3 ml ______ 10.0 ml
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 12
3.5
3.6 3.6.1 3.6.2
Bacterial strains
Four strains of Salmonella typhimurium (TA1535, TA1537, TA98 and TA100) and a strain of Escherichia coli (WP2 uvrA) were used in this study.
TA1535 and TA100 are predominantly sensitive to base pair mutagens, TA1537 and TA98 are sensitive to frameshift mutagens. In addition to a mutation in the histidine operon, the Salmonella tester strains contain additional mutations which enhance their sensitivity to some mutagenic compounds. The rfa wall mutation results in the loss of one of the enzymes responsible for the synthesis of part of the lipopolysaccharide barrier that forms the surface of the bacterial cell wall and increases permeability to certain classes of chemicals. All strains are deficient in a DNA excision repair system (uvrB mutation) which enhances the sensitivity to some mutagens. TA98 and TA100 strains contain the pKM101 plasmid which activates an error prone DNA repair system.
Tester strain WP2 uvrA is reverted from tryptophan dependence (auxotrophy) to tryptophan independence (prototrophy) bay base substitution mutagens. In addition to the mutation in the tryptophan operon, the tester strain contains an uvrA DNA repair deficiency which enhance its sensitivity to some mutagenic compounds.
Permanent stocks of these strains are kept at -80C in RTC. Overnight subcultures of these stocks were prepared for each day's work. Bacteria were taken from vials of frozen cultures, which had been checked for the presence of the appropriate genetic markers, as follows:
Histidine requirement
Tryptophan requirement
uvrA, uvrB rfa pKM101
: No Growth on Minimal plates + Biotin. Growth on Minimal plates + Biotin + Histidine.
: No Growth on Minimal agar plates Growth on Minimal plates + Tryptophan.
: Sensitivity to UV irradiation. : Sensitivity to Crystal Violet. : Resistance to Ampicillin.
Bacterial cultures in liquid and on agar were clearly identified with their identity.
Methods
Preliminary toxicity test
A preliminary toxicity test was undertaken in order to select the concentrations of the test item to be used in the main assays. In these tests a wide range of dose levels of the test item, set at half-log intervals, were used. Treatments were performed both in the absence and presence of S9 metabolism using the plate incorporation method; a single plate was used at each test point and positive controls were not included. Toxicity was assessed on the basis of a decline in the number of spontaneous revertants, a thinning of the background lawn or a microcolony formation.
Main experiments
Two experiments were performed including negative and positive controls in the absence and presence of an S9 metabolising system. Three replicate plates were used at each test point.
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 13
3.6.3
In addition, plates were prepared to check the sterility of the test item solutions and the S9 mix, and dilutions of the bacterial cultures were plated on nutrient agar plates to establish the number of bacteria in the cultures.
The first experiment was performed using a plate-incorporation method. The components of the assay (the tester strain bacteria, the test item and S9 mix or phosphate buffer) were added to molten overlay agar and vortexed. The mixture was then poured onto the surface of a minimal medium agar plate, and allowed to solidify prior to incubation.
The overlay mixture was composed as follows:
(i) Overlay agar (held at 45C) (ii) Test or control item solution (iii) S9 mix or phosphate buffer (pH 7.4, 0.1 M) (iv) Bacterial suspension
2 ml 0.1 ml 0.5 ml 0.1 ml
The second experiment was performed using a pre-incubation method. The components were added in turn to an empty test-tube:
(i) Bacterial suspension (ii) Test item solution
or control item solution (iii) S9 mix or phosphate buffer (pH 7.4, 0.1 M)
0.1 ml 0.1 ml 0.05 ml 0.5 ml
The incubate was vortexed and placed at 37C for 30 minutes. Two ml of overlay agar was then added and the mixture vortexed again and poured onto the surface of a minimal medium agar plate and allowed to solidify.
Incubation and scoring
The prepared plates were inverted and incubated for approximately 72 hours at 37C. After this period of incubation, the scoring was effected by counting the number of revertant colonies on each plate.
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 14
4.
RESULTS
4.1
Sterility test
Since the test item is an aqueous sample, a preliminary sterility test was performed. An aliquot of 500 l of the test item, as supplied, was added to 4.5 ml of nutrient broth and incubated at 37C for about 24 hours before evaluating the outcome of the test. Based on the results obtained it was not considered necessary to filter the test item before use in any experimental procedure.
4.2
Toxicity test
The test item C6O4 CYCLIC was assayed in the toxicity test at a maximum dose level of 5000 Pg/plate and at four lower concentrations spaced at approximately half-log intervals: 1580, 500, 158 and 50.0 Pg/plate. Concentrations are expressed in terms of active ingredient. Results are presented in Tables 1 and 2.
No precipitation of the test item was noted at the end of the incubation period at any concentration. No toxicity was observed at any dose level with any tester strain, in the absence or presence of S9 metabolic activation. On the basis of these results a maximum concentration of 5000 Pg/plate was selected for the Main Assay.
4.3
Assay for reverse mutation
Two experiments were performed; individual plate counts for these tests, and the mean and standard error of the mean for each test point, together with statistical analysis are presented in Tables 3 to 12.
In Main Assay I, using the plate incorporation method, the test item was assayed at the following dose levels expressed in terms of active ingredient: 5000, 2500, 1250, 625 and 313 Pg/plate. No relevant toxicity was observed with any tester strain at any dose level.
As no relevant increases in revertant numbers were observed at any concentration tested, a pre-incubation step was included for all treatments of Main Assay II. The test item was assayed at the same dose levels as in Main Assay I. Toxicity, as indicated by thinning of the background lawn and/or reduction in revertant numbers, was observed at the higher dose levels with all tester strains, both in the absence and presence of S9 metabolic activation.
No precipitation of the test item was noted at the end of the incubation period at any concentration tested.
No increases in the number of revertant colonies were observed in the plate incorporation or pre-incubation assay, at any dose level, in any tester strain, in the absence or presence of S9 metabolism.
The sterility of the S9 mix and of the test item solutions was confirmed by the absence of colonies on additional agar plates spread separately with these solutions. Marked increases in revertant numbers were obtained in these tests following treatment with the positive control items, indicating that the assay system was functioning correctly.
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 15
5.
ANALYSIS OF RESULTS
5.1
Criteria for outcome of the assays
For the test item to be considered mutagenic, two-fold (or more) increases in mean revertant numbers must be observed at two consecutive dose levels or at the highest practicable dose level only. In addition, there must be evidence of a dose-response relationship showing increasing numbers of mutant colonies with increasing dose levels.
5.2
Evaluation
Results show that mean plate counts for untreated and positive control plates fell within the normal historical range included in Appendices 1 and 2. The estimated numbers of viable bacteria/plate (titre) fell in the range of 100 - 500 million for each strain. No plates were lost through contamination or cracking. The study was accepted as valid.
The test item does not induce two-fold increases in the number of revertant colonies, at any dose level, in any tester strain, in the absence or presence of S9 metabolism. On the basis of the stated criteria it must be concluded that the test item C6O4 CYCLIC is not mutagenic to S. typhimurium or E. coli under the reported experimental conditions.
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 16
6.
CONCLUSION
It is concluded that the test item C6O4 CYCLIC does not induce reverse mutation in Salmonella typhimurium or Escherichia coli in the absence or presence of S9 metabolism, under the reported experimental conditions.
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 17
7.
KEY TO TABLES 1-12
7.1
Structure of Tables 3-12
These tables show, for each Salmonella typhimurium or Escherichia coli tester strain, the individual plate counts obtained for the negative and positive controls, and at each dose level of the test item. The mean number of revertant colonies and standard error of the mean are also presented. The "untreated" plates received no treatment. The titre of the bacterial cultures is given (million cells/plate).
7.2
Regression line
i) The regression analysis fits a regression line to the data by the least squares method, after square root transformation of the plate counts to satisfy normal distribution and homoscedasticity assumptions. The regression equation is expressed as:
y = a + bx where y = transformed revertant numbers
a = intercept b = slope value x = dose level (in the units given).
ii) The regression line includes the untreated control data.
iii) Regression lines are calculated using a minimum of the three lowest dose levels, and then including the further dose levels in turn. The correlation co-efficient (r), the value of students "t" statistic, and the p-value for the regression lines are also given.
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 18
Tables
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 1 - Toxicity test without metabolic activation
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
EXPERIMENT: Toxicity test
___________________________________________________________________________
Dose level (g/plate)
TA-1535 Rev/pl.
TA-1537 Rev/pl.
TA-98 Rev/pl.
TA-100 Rev/pl.
WP2 uvrA Rev/pl.
___________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
25
20
32
151
25
50.0
25
24
30
156
28
158
23
22
34
144
28
500
26
17
31
151
34
1580
27
21
36
140
28
5000
23
16
35
149
27
___________________________________________________________________________
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 19
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 2 - Toxicity test with metabolic activation
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
EXPERIMENT: Toxicity test
___________________________________________________________________________
Dose level (g/plate)
TA-1535 Rev/pl.
TA-1537 Rev/pl.
TA-98 Rev/pl.
TA-100 Rev/pl.
WP2 uvrA Rev/pl.
___________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
22
27
47
164
34
50.0
19
22
43
162
38
158
21
22
47
166
34
500
24
23
50
175
35
1580
18
25
46
173
35
5000
21
27
40
162
37
__________________________________________________________________________
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 20
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 3 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - TA1535
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: TA1535
Titre: 252
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
17 12 18
16 1.9
14 21 20
18 2.2
313
18 17 18
18 0.3
19 21 19
20 0.7
625
18 21 19
19 0.9
16 25 20
20 2.6
1250
23 21 26
23 1.5
19 19 19
19 0.0
2500
19 19 24
21 1.7
21 24 26
24 1.5
5000
19 28 20
22 2.8
23 25 21
23 1.2
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 -
3.954 0.0007
0.64771 2.2493 0.05926
1-4 -
3.961 0.0007
0.83070 4.7186 0.00082
1-5 -
4.164 0.0002
0.54765 2.3600 0.03458
1-6 -
4.252 0.0001
0.48831 2.2383 0.03978
1-3 +
4.284 0.0004
0.27142 0.7461 0.47990
1-4 +
4.359 0.0001
0.08088 0.2566 0.80269
1-5 +
4.294 0.0002
0.52489 2.2234 0.04454
1-6 +
4.366 0.0001
0.53004 2.5003 0.02366
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
Untreated
- 17 12 18
16 1.9
Sodium Azide
1 g/pl - 555 533 508 532 13.6
DMSO
100 l/pl + 17 17 19
18 0.7
2-Aminoanthracene
1 g/pl + 121 131 124 125 3.0
________________________________________________________________________
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 21
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 4 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - TA1537
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: TA1537
Titre: 229
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
15 20 12
16 2.3
19 23 21
21 1.2
313
15 22 20
19 2.1
24 25 26
25 0.6
625
26 15 24
22 3.4
19 20 22
20 0.9
1250
23 23 19
22 1.3
28 26 23
26 1.5
2500
21 17 13
17 2.3
17 19 28
21 3.4
5000
17 22 20
20 1.5
21 24 21
22 1.0
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 -
3.958 0.0011
0.53730 1.6855 0.13575
1-4 -
4.094 0.0005
0.50989 1.8744 0.09036
1-5 -
4.328 0.0000
0.00666 0.0240 0.98120
1-6 -
4.317 0.0000
0.07307 0.2931 0.77324
1-3 +
4.731 -0.0001
-0.11334 0.3018 0.77156
1-4 +
4.636 0.0003
0.43631 1.5334 0.15619
1-5 +
4.765 0.0000
-0.04490 0.1621 0.87375
1-6 +
4.763 0.0000
-0.08031 0.3223 0.75142
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
DMSO
100 l/pl - 23 17 18
19 1.9
9-Aminoacridine
50 g/pl - 108 116 121 115 3.8
DMSO
100 l/pl + 28 23 22
24 1.9
2-Aminoanthracene
1 g/pl + 119 105 113 112 4.1
________________________________________________________________________
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 22
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 5 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - WP2uvrA
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: WP2uvrA
Titre: 304
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
21 28 25
25 2.0
35 34 32
34 0.9
313
20 20 28
23 2.7
31 35 36
34 1.5
625
21 27 28
25 2.2
32 27 29
29 1.5
1250
23 28 31
27 2.3
29 35 33
32 1.8
2500
30 31 20
27 3.5
33 38 29
33 2.6
5000
25 28 19
24 2.6
28 33 30
30 1.5
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 -
4.876 0.0001
0.07522 0.1996 0.84749
1-4 -
4.834 0.0003
0.34752 1.1720 0.26837
1-5 -
4.897 0.0001
0.29491 1.1128 0.28595
1-6 -
4.995 0.0000
0.01307 0.0523 0.95895
1-3 +
5.875 -0.0006
-0.62924 2.1420 0.06943
1-4 +
5.758 -0.0001
-0.26638 0.8739 0.40266
1-5 +
5.695 0.0000
0.00892 0.0322 0.97482
1-6 +
5.724 0.0000
-0.23872 0.9833 0.34010
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
Untreated
- 21 28 25
25 2.0
MMS
500 g/pl - 185 169 164 173 6.3
DMSO
100 l/pl + 27 27 33
29 2.0
2-Aminoanthracene
10 g/pl + 204 193 195 197 3.4
________________________________________________________________________
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 23
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 6 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - TA98
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: TA98
Titre: 278
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
24 31 33
29 2.7
35 43 35
38 2.7
313
26 30 33
30 2.0
39 36 33
36 1.7
625
30 26 22
26 2.3
34 32 38
35 1.8
1250
33 35 31
33 1.2
40 37 42
40 1.5
2500
30 34 38
34 2.3
40 41 36
39 1.5
5000
31 34 35
33 1.2
45 46 41
44 1.5
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 -
5.468 -0.0005
-0.36065 1.0230 0.34034
1-4 -
5.288 0.0002
0.30198 1.0017 0.34010
1-5 -
5.299 0.0002
0.48961 2.0246 0.06396
1-6 -
5.385 0.0001
0.45801 2.0609 0.05595
1-3 +
6.126 -0.0004
-0.38130 1.0913 0.31129
1-4 +
5.994 0.0002
0.25503 0.8341 0.42372
1-5 +
6.017 0.0001
0.33136 1.2663 0.22763
1-6 +
6.000 0.0001
0.65894 3.5041 0.00294
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
DMSO
100 l/pl - 33 30 32
32 0.9
2-Nitrofluorene
2 g/pl - 157 169 159 162 3.7
DMSO
100 l/pl + 36 43 39
39 2.0
2-Aminoanthracene
1 g/pl + 459 465 488 471 8.8
________________________________________________________________________
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 24
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 7 - Experiment 1 - Plate incorporation method - TA100
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: TA100
Titre: 267
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated 150 168 157 158 5.2
150 171 178 166 8.4
313
161 151 154 155 3.0
181 157 167 168 7.0
625
157 169 147 158 6.4
176 165 161 167 4.5
1250
147 144 143 145 1.2
159 173 164 165 4.1
2500
149 156 160 155 3.2
170 166 161 166 2.6
5000
151 164 149 155 4.7
181 173 162 172 5.5
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 -
12.545 0.0000
-0.04005 0.1061 0.91851
1-4 -
12.638 -0.0004
-0.58866 2.3027 0.04405
1-5 -
12.485 -0.0001
-0.21556 0.7959 0.44038
1-6 -
12.438 0.0000
-0.07312 0.2933 0.77308
1-3 +
12.908 0.0001
0.04880 0.1293 0.90079
1-4 +
12.936 0.0000
-0.05952 0.1886 0.85422
1-5 +
12.928 0.0000
-0.07354 0.2659 0.79450
1-6 +
12.883 0.0000
0.18116 0.7368 0.47189
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
Untreated
- 150 168 157 158 5.2
Sodium Azide
1 g/pl - 656 611 707 658 27.7
DMSO
100 l/pl + 165 173 171 170 2.4
2-Aminoanthracene
1 g/pl + 1352 1281 1181 1271 49.6
________________________________________________________________________
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 25
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 8 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - TA1535
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: TA1535
Titre: 264
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
16 23 16
18 2.3
17 20 15
17 1.5
313
16 19 20
18 1.2
23 25 27
25 1.2
625
17 25 20
21 2.3
21 21 18
20 1.0
1250
15 15 20
17 1.7
23 18 22
21 1.5
2500
13 12 16 * 14 1.2
17 14 14 * 15 1.0
5000
13 9 12 * 11 1.2
12 14 17 * 14 1.5
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 -
4.225 0.0004
0.31541 0.8794 0.40836
1-4 -
4.362 -0.0001
-0.18002 0.5787 0.57557
1-5 -
4.419 -0.0003
-0.58176 2.5789 0.02290
1-6 -
4.379 -0.0002
-0.75031 4.5399 0.00033
1-3 +
4.384 0.0005
0.32231 0.9008 0.39761
1-4 +
4.471 0.0001
0.18231 0.5863 0.57064
1-5 +
4.639 -0.0002
-0.49210 2.0382 0.06241
1-6 +
4.591 -0.0002
-0.63518 3.2895 0.00462
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
Untreated
- 16 23 16
18 2.3
Sodium Azide
1 g/pl - 495 508 479 494 8.4
DMSO
50 l/pl + 19 17 20
19 0.9
2-Aminoanthracene
1 g/pl + 108 111 107 109 1.2
________________________________________________________________________
*: thinning of the background lawn
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 26
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 9 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - TA1537
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: TA1537
Titre: 233
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
15 21 18
18 1.7
17 26 25
23 2.8
313
23 23 25
24 0.7
24 25 27
25 0.9
625
20 24 17
20 2.0
24 30 28
27 1.8
1250
19 13 15
16 1.8
28 26 24
26 1.2
2500
11 8 7 * 9 1.2
17 25 23 * 22 2.4
5000
11 8 4 * 8 2.0
20 10 12 * 14 3.1
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 -
4.399 0.0004
0.29922 0.8297 0.43410
1-4 -
4.596 -0.0004
-0.41083 1.4250 0.18462
1-5 -
4.719 -0.0007
-0.82886 5.3418 0.00013
1-6 -
4.529 -0.0004
-0.82454 5.8293 0.00003
1-3 +
4.757 0.0008
0.55031 1.7438 0.12472
1-4 +
4.882 0.0003
0.36824 1.2525 0.23889
1-5 +
5.037 -0.0001
-0.23365 0.8664 0.40198
1-6 +
5.159 -0.0003
-0.72443 4.2035 0.00067
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
DMSO
50 l/pl - 20 21 22
21 0.6
9-Aminoacridine
50 g/pl - 101 162 152 138 18.9
DMSO
50 l/pl + 27 27 25
26 0.7
2-Aminoanthracene
1 g/pl + 107 105 92 101 4.7
________________________________________________________________________
*: thinning of the background lawn
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 27
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 10 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - WP2uvrA
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: WP2uvrA
Titre: 313
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
18 21 25
21 2.0
31 31 32
31 0.3
313
30 32 30
31 0.7
27 27 26
27 0.3
625
27 24 27
26 1.0
33 35 27
32 2.4
1250
31 33 28
31 1.5
27 34 35
32 2.5
2500
22 24 23 * 23 0.6
24 30 22 * 25 2.4
5000
25 32 29 * 29 2.0
22 20 20 * 21 0.7
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 1-4 -
4.836 4.892
0.0008 0.0006
0.46480 0.59215
1.3889 2.3237
0.20744 0.04250
1-5 -
5.151 0.0000
-0.08198 0.2966 0.77148
1-6 -
5.095 0.0000
0.15178 0.6142 0.54770
1-3 +
5.450 0.0000
0.03096 0.0819 0.93699
1-4 +
5.418 0.0002
0.24987 0.8161 0.43348
1-5 +
5.559 -0.0002
-0.38595 1.5084 0.15536
1-6 +
5.590 -0.0002
-0.74254 4.4344 0.00042
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
Untreated
- 18 21 25
21 2.0
MMS
500 g/pl - 162 153 139 151 6.7
DMSO
50 l/pl + 23 24 22
23 0.6
2-Aminoanthracene
20 g/pl + 184 184 173 180 3.7
________________________________________________________________________
*: thinning of the background lawn
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 28
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 11 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - TA98
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: TA98
Titre: 278
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated
36 36 40
37 1.3
39 39 37
38 0.7
313
33 33 38
35 1.7
36 36 41
38 1.7
625
29 34 37
33 2.3
42 37 36
38 1.9
1250
36 35 28
33 2.5
38 48 38
41 3.3
2500
31 38 36 * 35 2.1
35 30 38 * 34 2.3
5000
30 24 28 * 27 1.8
24 25 24 * 24 0.3
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 -
6.091 -0.0005
-0.53265 1.6651 0.13983
1-4 -
6.025 -0.0003
-0.44374 1.5659 0.14845
1-5 -
5.924 0.0000
-0.14337 0.5223 0.61023
1-6 -
5.992 -0.0001
-0.63457 3.2842 0.00467
1-3 +
6.173 0.0000
-0.00749 0.0198 0.98474
1-4 +
6.122 0.0002
0.36516 1.2404 0.24315
1-5 +
6.258 -0.0001
-0.31406 1.1927 0.25431
1-6 +
6.370 -0.0003
-0.83048 5.9634 0.00002
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
DMSO
50 l/pl - 34 28 33
32 1.9
2-Nitrofluorene
2 g/pl - 171 193 161 175 9.5
DMSO
50 l/pl + 40 45 39
41 1.9
2-Aminoanthracene
2 g/pl + 654 604 647 635 15.6
________________________________________________________________________
*: thinning of the background lawn
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 29
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
TABLE 12 - Experiment 2 - Preincubation method - TA100
STUDY NO.: 76250
SOLVENT: Sterile distilled water
________________________________________________________________________
Strain: TA100
Titre: 264
Dose-level Without metabolic activation With metabolic activation
[g/pl]
Plate counts Mean S. E.
Plate counts Mean S. E.
________________________________________________________________________
Untreated 166 151 167 161 5.2
171 171 162 168 3.0
313
165 166 159 163 2.2
171 162 176 170 4.1
625
157 162 168 162 3.2
167 178 160 168 5.2
1250
119 95 93 * 102 8.4
94 114 108 * 105 5.9
2500
60 78 62 * 67 5.7
75 76 61 * 71 4.8
5000
76 60 71 * 69 4.7
75 68 55 * 66 5.9
________________________________________________________________________
Regression analysis:
Points S9 Intercept
Slope Corr. coeff.
t
P-value
1-3 -
12.719 0.0001
0.08026 0.2130 0.83738
1-4 -
13.259 -0.0022
-0.83593 4.8165 0.00071
1-5 -
13.210 -0.0020
-0.94478 10.3947 0.00000
1-6 -
12.452 -0.0010
-0.84726 6.3802 0.00001
1-3 +
12.980 0.0000
0.01914 0.0506 0.96102
1-4 +
13.529 -0.0022
-0.85193 5.1448 0.00043
1-5 +
13.446 -0.0021
-0.94855 10.8010 0.00000
1-6 +
12.742 -0.0011
-0.87601 7.2655 0.00000
________________________________________________________________________
Positive and negative controls
Treatment
S9
Plate counts
Mean S. E.
Untreated
- 166 151 167 161 5.2
Sodium Azide
1 g/pl - 649 625 607 627 12.2
DMSO
50 l/pl + 119 121 134 125 4.7
2-Aminoanthracene
2 g/pl + 945 1021 975 980 22.1
________________________________________________________________________
*: thinning of the background lawn
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 30
Appendices
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli)
APPENDIX 1 - Historical control data without metabolic activation (2000-2008)
STUDY NO.: 76250
Untreated
TA1535 Mean value
SD n TA1537 Mean value SD n TA98 Mean value SD n TA100 Mean value SD n WP2uvrA Mean value SD n
Plate incorporation
18 2.6 185
17 1.9 184
31 3.2 187
143 15.4 187
28 3.1 127
Untreated Pre-incubation
18 2.4 190
17 1.8 187
32 3.0 179
142 15.2 186
27 2.9 122
Positive control Plate incorporation
565 76.4 185
169 33.2 184
183 24.3 187
782 123.5 187
180 17.9 127
Positive control Pre-incubation
567 73.5 190
164 41.1 187
180 23.4 179
791 121.9 186
210 42.5 122
SD : n :
standard deviation number of experiments
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 31
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli
APPENDIX 2 - Historical control data with metabolic activation (2000-2008)
STUDY NO.: 76250
Untreated
Untreated
Positive control
Positive control
TA1535 Plate incorporation
Mean value
16
SD
1.8
n
185
TA1537
Mean value
21
SD
2.4
n
184
TA98
Mean value
39
SD
3.7
n
187
TA100
Mean value
152
SD
15.7
n
188
WP2uvrA
Mean value
35
SD
3.4
n
126
Pre-incubation
16 1.8 189
20 2.1 188
39 2.9 169
150 14.2 184
34 3.1 117
Plate incorporation
142 28.3 185
120 19.9 184
611 137.7 187
1261 196.5 188
205 35.2 126
Pre-incubation
96 12.7 189
97 11.5 188
661 179.7 169
1135 186.9 184
191 32.6 117
SD : n :
standard deviation
number of experiments
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 32
Addenda
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli
ADDENDUM I - Study Protocol
STUDY NO.: 76250
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 33
RESEARCH TOXICOLOGY CENTRE ROMA
Version 08/2
C604 CYCLIC BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY
(S. (vphimurium and E. colt)
Final Protocol prepared for
SOLVAY SOLEXIS S.p.A. Viale Lombardia, 20 20021 Bollate (MI) Italy
by
RESEARCH TOXICOLOGY CENTRE S.p.A. Via Tito Speri, 12/14
00040 Pomezia (Roma) Italy
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
Commercial Office
RTC 5 0.> Ve Tao Sim, 12 00040 Pomona (Ronal ITALY Tot: 3905.91095.1 Fax . 39089105737 ormil:inktencit ww.rIc
- 1 of 14 -
Head Office and AdmIniatratIon
RTC 89 Tao 3074512 03040 Rome Mono ITALY Tel.: 3908.01095.1 Fax 39438.912.2233 P.O. Box 15307-00143 Rem Eto Lawmen>
March 2009
RTC SPA Candate 590818 E965 5.184000 C C Aw. 6. 375378 Reg. Soc. Tra. a. Roma n. 2828/72 Coe R.50.. 0065312058,1 Panda len 00920611001
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 34
Version 08/2
BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. colt)
MANAGEMENT OF STUDY
Scientific Director
Head of Genetic Toxicology, in vitro Toxicology and Immunology
Study Director Sponsor
SOLVAY SOLEXIS S.p.A. Viale Lombardia, 20 20021 Bollate (MI) Italy
Monitor
QUALITY ASSURANCE
Quality Assurance Manager
LOCATION OF STUDY The study will be performed at
Research Toxicology Centre S.p.A. Via Tito Speri, 12/14 00040 Pomezia (Roma) Italy
The laboratory facilities, archives and administration are located at this site.
TIME SCHEDULE OF STUDY The Study will be conducted with a time schedule agreed between the Sponsor and RTC.
TEST ITEM IDENTITY
The test item will be: C604 CYCLIC
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
-2 of 14 -
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 35
Version 08/2
BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. colt)
1.
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Objective To assay the test item for the ability to induce gene mutations in Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia colt, as measured by reversion of auxotrophic strains to prototrophy.
1.2
Regulatory requirements
This study will be conducted in compliance with the GLP regulations of:
- US FDA [21 CFR part 58, 22 December 1978] and subsequent revisions; - Directive 2004/10/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 February
2004; - ENV/MC/CHEM(98)I 7 "OECD principles on Good Laboratory Practice -- as revised in
1997"; - Decreto Legislativo no. 50 of 2 March 2007 and subsequent revisions.
In addition, the study is designed to comply with the experimental methods indicated in the guidelines of:
- EEC Council Directive 2000/32, Annex 4D. - OECD Guidelines for the testing of chemicals No. 471 (Adopted July 1997). - ICH S2A Genotoxicity: Specific Aspects of Regulatory Tests, Step 5.
1.3 Principles of the method
Reverse mutation assays employ bacterial strains which are already mutant at a locus whose phenotypic effects are easily detected. The Salmonella tester strains have mutations causing dependence on a particular amino acid (histidine) for growth. The ability of test items to cause reverse mutations (reversions) to histidine-independence can easily be measured. The E. colt tester strains of the WP2 series are similarly mutant at the tryptophan locus.
Since many chemicals only demonstrate mutagenic activity after metabolism to reactive forms, in order to detect these "indirect mutagens" the test is performed in the presence and absence of a rat liver metabolising system.
2.
TEST ITEM
2.1
It is the responsibility of the Sponsor to supply the test item, accompanied by analytical data
confirming the identity, purity, stability, strength and composition of the substance, the
solubility and stability in the proposed vehicle and details of any known hazards to
laboratory staff. The test item should be accompanied by a certificate of analysis.
2.2
Approximately one year after the submission of the final report, remaining amounts of the
test item will be destroyed by incineration. An aliquot of the substance will be retained
within the archives of the testing facility for a period of ten years after which it will be
destroyed.
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839
March 2009
RTC Study Number: 76250
-3of14-
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 36
Version 08/2
2.3 The test item identity is indicated on previous pages of this protocol.
2.4
Unless otherwise indicated by the Sponsor the storage conditions for the test item will be
room temperature.
2.5 The precautions necessary when handling either the test item or prepared formulations of the test item are based on information supplied by the Sponsor. The minimum safety precautions necessary are detailed under the RTC Hazard Classification System, according to RTC
standard procedures.
2.6 The amount of test item received and used will be recorded according to standard procedures.
2.7
Fresh dilutions of the test item as supplied will be prepared for each day's work at
appropriate concentrations. One sterility test, using nutrient broth, will be performed before
commencing all experimental treatments. Concentrations of solutions will be expressed in
terms of active ingredient. Preferred solvent will be sterile distilled water.
2.8 No assay of test item stability, nor its concentration and homogeneity in the solvent/vehicle will be undertaken, nor samples of formulated test item consigned to the Sponsor, without express instructions from the Sponsor. No determination of the absorption of the test item in
the test system will be made without express instructions from the Sponsor.
3.
MATERIALS
3.1 Bacterial strains
Stocks of Salmonella tester strains (TA 1535, TA 1537, TA 1538, TA 98, TA 100, TA 97 and TA 102 and some other related strains) were obtained from Dr. B.N.Ames, University of California. Stocks of E. coli tester strains (WP2, WP2 uvrA and WP2 uvrA pKM101) were obtained from Life Science Research, Occold, Suffolk, UK. Permanent stocks are kept at -80C, and overnight subcultures of these stocks are prepared for each day's work. The cultures used in each experiment contain a high titre of viable bacteria (1-5 x 109 cells per ml). The titre of each tester strain culture will be demonstrated in each experiment through
the determination of viable cell numbers using nutrient agar plates.
The presence of the appropriate genetic markers in these strains is checked on a monthly basis for those in regular use, and as necessary for other strains, as follows:
Histidine requirement
Tryptophan requirement
uvrA, uvrB rfa pK.M101
No Growth on Minimal plates + Biotin. Growth on Minimal plates + Biotin + Histidine. No Growth on Minimal agar plates Growth on Minimal plates + Tryptophan. Sensitivity to UV irradiation. Sensitivity to Crystal Violet. Resistance to Ampicillin.
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
-4 of 14 -
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 37
Version 08/2
Strain identity is also confirmed by reference to the spontaneous reversion levels and responses to mutagens during use. Bacterial cultures in liquid and on agar are clearly
identified with their identity.
Detailed information about the genetic constitution of the tester strains may be found in the cited publications ofDr. B.N.Ames and Drs. M.H.L. Green and W.J. Muriel.
3.2 Media
The following growth media will be used:
Nutrient Broth: Oxoid Nutrient Broth No 2 will be prepared at a concentration of 2.5% in distilled water and autoclaved prior to use. This will be used for the preparation of liquid cultures of the tester strains.
Nutrient Agar: Oxoid Nutrient Broth No 2 (25g) and Difco Bacto-agar (15g) will be added to one litre of distilled water and autoclaved. The solution will then be poured into plastic Petri dishes and allowed to solidify and dry before use. These plates will be used for the non-selective growth of the tester strains. Incubations on Nutrient Agar will be for approximately 48 or 72 hours.
Minimal Agar: Minimal medium agar will be prepared as 1.5% Difco Bacto-agar in VogelBonner Medium E, with 2% Glucose, and poured into plastic Petri dishes.
Top Agar: "Top Agar" (overlay agar) will be prepared as 0.6% Difco Bacto-agar + 0.5% NaCI in distilled water. This solution will be autoclaved, and stored. Prior to use 10 ml of a sterile solution of 0.5 mM Biotin + 0.5 mM Histidine (or 0.5 mM tryptophan) will be added
to 100 ml of the top agar.
All incubations will be at 37C.
3.3 S9 mix
The S9 liver tissue fraction will be prepared according to RTC standard procedures or will be obtained from an appropriate supplier (MOLTOX, Molecular Toxicology, Inc., USA). Induction of drug metabolising enzyme-levels is routinely performed using phenobarbitone and betanaphthoflavone (Mixed Induction); induction with Aroclor 1254 will be performed if specifically requested by the Sponsor. Records pertaining to the preparation of the S9 fraction are kept on file at RTC. The mixture of S9 tissue fraction and cofactors (S9 mix) will be prepared as follows (for each 10 ml):
S9 tissue fraction NADP (100 mM) G-6-P (100 mM) KCl (330 mM) MgCl2 (100 mM) Phosphate buffer (pH 7.4, 200 mM) Distilled Water
1.0 ml 0.4 ml 0.5 ml 1.0 ml 0.8 ml 5.0 ml
1.3 ml 10.0 ml
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
-5of14-
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 38
Version 08/2
3.4 Control items
Positive control treatments will be used in each experiment. The positive control agents are obtained commercially and characterised by their labelling, and their stability determined from the scientific literature. Sodium azide and methylmethanesulphonate will usually be dissolved in distilled water; 9-aminoacridine, 2-nitrofluorene and 2-aminoanthracene will usually be dissolved in DMSO. Determination of the stability and concentration of solutions of these agents will not be undertaken since it is sufficient to provide evidence for the correct expected response of the test system to them.
4.
PRELIMINARY TOXICITY TEST
4.1
Experimental design
In order to establish the concentrations of test item to be used in the main assay, a
preliminary toxicity test will be performed. This test follows the method described in section 6.1, using only one plate per dose level, a single S9 mix concentration (10%) and covering a wide range of concentrations of the test
item.
The highest dose-level for this preliminary test, unless limited by the solubility of the test item, will be 5 mg/plate, and the lower dose-levels will be spaced at approximately half-log
intervals.
4.2
Selection of dose-levels
The toxicity will be assessed on the basis of a decline in the number of spontaneous revertants or a thinning of the background lawn. The highest dose-level for the mutation assays will be selected as a concentration which elicits moderate toxicity. If there is no evidence of toxicity following treatment with the test item, then the highest dose-level will
be 5 mg/plate.
5.
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
Each experiment will include solvent/vehicle and positive controls, and at least five doses of the test item, tested in the absence and presence of an S9 metabolising system. Three replicate plates will be used at each test point. If a first experiment produces a clear positive
response, no further experiments will be undertaken. If negative or equivocal results are obtained in the first experiment a confirmatory experiment will be performed using the pre-incubation method. A further experiment may be undertaken if inconsistent results are obtained. The five bacterial strains S. typhimurium
TA1535, TA1537, TA98, TA100 and E. coli WP2 uvrA will be used in this study.
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
-6 of 14-
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 39
Version 08/2
Solvent/vehicle controls: untreated and solvent vehicle controls will be prepared for each experiment; when the solvent is distilled water, these will be considered to be equivalent and
only one set of controls will be performed.
Positive controls: treatments are indicated in the following table:
Tester strain
Absence ofS9
Presence ofS9
TAI535
sodium azide 1 g/plate
2-aminoanthracene 1 g/plate
TA100
sodium azide 1 g/plate
2-aminoanthracene 1 g/plate (2 g/plate)
TA1537
9-amino-acridine 50 g/plate
2-aminoanthracene 1 g/plate
TA98
2-nitrofluorene 2 g/plate
2-aminoanthracene 1 g/plate (2 g/plate)
WP2 uvrA
methylmethanesulphonate 500 g/plate
2-aminoanthracene 10 g/plate (20 g/plate)
Concentrations refer to both treatment methods. When two values are given, the figures in brackets refer to the pre-incubation method assay.
Test item: the highest dose-level of the test item to be used will be selected as described above. Further dose levels will be selected at intervals of a factor of two.
Where it seems advisable, further test points or controls may be included in experiments.
In addition, plates will be prepared to check the sterility of the test item solutions and the S9 mix, and dilutions of the bacterial cultures will be plated on nutrient agar plates to establish the number of bacteria in the cultures.
6.
ASSAY PROCEDURE
6.1 Plate-incorporation
The components of the assay (the tester strain bacteria, the test item and S9 mix or phosphate buffer) will be added to molten overlay agar and vortexed. The mixture will then be poured on the surface of a minimal medium agar plate, and allowed to solidify prior to incubation.
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
- 7 of 14 -
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 40
Version 08/2
The overlay mixture will be composed as follows:
(i) Overlay agar (held at 45C) (ii) Test or control item solution (iii) S9 mix or phosphate buffer (pH 7.4, 0.1 M) (iv) Bacterial suspension
2 ml 0.1 ml 0.5 ml 0.1 nil
The volume of test item solution, as indicated, will usually be 0.1 ml; in the event that it is necessary to alter this volume, the quantities used will be carefully recorded.
6.2
Pre-incubation
The components will be added in turn to an empty test-tube:
(i) Bacterial suspension (ii) Test or control item solution (iii) S9 mix or phosphate buffer (pH 7.4, 0.1 M)
0.1 ml 0.05 ml 0.5 ml
The volume of test item solution, as indicated, will usually be 0.05 ml. Where control or test items are dissolved in aqueous solvents, the volume used may be 0.1 ml. In the event that it
is necessary to alter this volume, the quantities used will be carefully recorded.
The treatment mixture will be vortexed and placed at 37C for 30 minutes. Two ml of overlay agar will then be added and the mixture vortexed again and poured onto the surface
of a minimal medium agar plate and allowed to solidify.
6.3
Incubation and scoring
The prepared plates will be inverted and incubated for approximately 72 hours at 37C. When the test item is a liquid at ambient temperature, the plates will be incubated in separate closed containers for each dose-level. After this period of incubation, the plates may be held
at 4C prior to scoring. Scoring is effected by counting the number of revertant colonies on each plate, either manually, or using a Cardinal - Automatic colony counting system
(Perceptive Instruments). Contaminated plates will be considered on a case-by-case basis.
7.
REPORTING
7.1
Presentation of data
The data will be presented in tabular form. The individual plate counts for each experiment will be given, together with the means and standard errors of the means, and regression
analyses.
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
-8of14-
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 41
Version 08/2
7.2
Evaluation of data
For the test item to be considered mutagenic, two-fold (or more) increases in mean revertant numbers must be observed at two consecutive dose-levels or at the highest practicable doselevel only. In addition there must be evidence of a dose- response relationship showing increasing numbers of mutant colonies with increasing dose-levels. Evaluation of Ames test data based on a `doubling rate' has been shown to be as effective as statistical techniques in allowing the correct interpretation of test results (Chu et al. 1981).
7.3 Reporting procedure
A Draft Report will be supplied, and a Final Report issued subsequently to include any agreed changes or amendments. If comments have not been received within 6 months of despatch of the audited draft report, the final report will be issued. If any corrections or additions are required to the Final Report, these will be in the form of an amendment by the Study Director. The amendment will clearly identify that part of the Final report that is being added to or corrected, and the reasons for the changes, and will be signed and dated by the person responsible.
7.4
Final report
The following information and data will be included in the final report:
name and address of the facility performing the study and the dates on which the study was initiated and completed;
objective and procedures stated in the approved protocol, including approved changes to the original protocol;
the test article, identified by name, chemical name or chemical number;
method used; any unforeseen circumstances that may have affected the quality or integrity of the study;
data generated while conducting the study;
statistical methods employed for analysing the data;
a summary of the data, an analysis of the data and a statement of the conclusions drawn from the analysis;
historical untreated and positive control data;
the name and signature of the Study Director; the location where all raw data, specimens and final report are to be stored;
Quality Assurance statement.
One original unbound, one copy bound and a PDF version will be supplied.
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839
March 2009
RTC Study Number: 76250
- 9 of 14 -
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 42
Version 08/2
7.5 Records kept
Full records will be maintained of all aspects of study conduct, along with the results of all measurements and observations. Prior to final archiving of the study data a full list will be prepared of all records associated with the study.
7.6 Archiving
All raw data, records and documentation arising from this study, including the original final protocol and a copy of the final report consigned generated during the course of this study will be retained at RTC. Archiving will be provided for a period of 3 years after which the Sponsor will be contacted for instructions regarding despatch or disposal of the material. The original final report will be despatched to and archived by the Sponsor.
8.
STUDY CONDUCT
8.1
Language
English language and Italian language versions of the study protocol, Standard Operating Procedures and other study documents may be used interchangeably. Similarly, English and Italian renderings of chemical names, including that of the test material will be considered to
be equivalent.
8.2
Scientific decisions
The procedures described in this protocol may not comprehensively cover all the circumstances that can arise in the assay of test items. When the study director considers it
advisable to modify the procedures described for the selection of a solvent, selection of dose
levels, interpretation of the outcome of the study or other aspects of the study conduct,
he/she will record carefully the decision he has reached and the reasoning which led to it.
8.3 Quality assurance
According to the RTC quality assurance programme, defined in the RTC QA SOPs, this study will be subjected to the following procedures:
the protocol will be inspected,
study/process based inspections of procedures/facilities will be carried out at intervals adequate to assure the integrity of the study,
the report will be inspected to assure that it accurately describes the methods and Standard Operating Procedures and that the results accurately reflect the raw data.
Periodic reports on these activities will be made to management and the Study Director. All raw data pertaining to the study will be available for inspection by the Sponsor's representative and regulatory authorities (following authorisation from the Sponsor).
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
- 10 of 14 -
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 43
Version 08/2
9.
DEPARTURES FROM REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS
Items which are the responsibility of the Sponsor are indicated in sections 2.1, 2.4, 2.8 and 3.3 of this protocol. Since full compliance with regulatory requirements may depend on the performance of some of these items, the Sponsor should ensure that appropriate actions are initiated or undertaken.
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
- 11 of 14 -
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 44
Version 08/2
10. REFERENCES
Ames,BN, J. McCann and E. Yamasaki (1975) Methods for detecting carcinogens and mutagens with the Salmonella/mammalian microsome mutagenicity test. Mutation Research 31, 347-364.
Chu K.C. et al. (1981) Evaluating statistical analyses and reproducibility of microbial mutagenicity assays. Mutation Research 85, 119-132.
Claxton L.D. et al. (1987) Guide for the Salmonella typhimurium/mammalian microsome tests for bacterial mutagenicity. Mutation Research 189, 83-91.
Gatehouse D. et al. (1994) Recommendations for the performance of bacterial mutation assays. Mutation Research 312, 217-233.
Green M.H.L. and W.J. Muriel (1976) Mutagen testing using TRP+ reversion in Escherichia Mutation Research 38, 3-32.
Maron D.M. and B.N. Ames (1983). Revised methods for the Salmonella mutagenicity test. Mutation Research 113, 173-215.
Venitt S., R. Forster and E. Longstaff (1983). Bacterial Mutation Assays in: Report of the UKEMS Subcommittee on Guidelines for Mutagenicity testing. U.K.E.M.S., Swansea, 1983.
Venitt S., C. Croften-Sleigh and R. Forster (1984) Bacterial mutation assays using reverse mutation in: Mutagenicity Testing - a practical approach S. Venitt and J.M. Parry (eds.) IRL Press, Oxford, 1984.
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
- 12 of 14 -
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 45
Version 08/2
PROTOCOL APPROVAL PAGE for
R.T.C. S.p.A.
APPROVED BY RELEASED BY
Date
IIIMIMIP Date
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
- 13 of 14 -
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 46
Version 08/2
PROTOCOL APPROVAL PAGE for
SOLVAY SOLEXIS S.p.A.
AUTHORISED BY Date
Name and Title* Please print or type your name and company status below your signature.
S Date ofProtocol Approval:
RTC Enquiry Number: 75839 RTC Study Number: 76250
- 14 of 14 -
March 2009
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 47
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli) ADDENDUM II - Certificate of analysis STUDY NO.: 76250
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 48
SOLEXIS
R,D&T Analytical & Structural Characterization Department %hale Lombarc1.a. 20 - 20021 BoHate tMU Italy
Sample Description: C,O., Ammonium Salt. sample 150/28
Analysis Requests: Ammonium chloride and fluoride determination Salt title quantification Organic impurity determination
Method (Equipment): Ionic Chromatography Potentiometry NMR Spectroscopy
Performance: MDL: na MQL: na
Results: The analyzed sample shows the following weight/volume of: NH4F =28 mg/I NH4CI = 601 mg/I O6O4 (NH4 titration) = 160 g/I
The organic impurities are dioxolen based and represent 0.8% by mol on total mol of organic phase of sample.
Analytical & Structural Characterization Department
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 49
C6O4 CYCLIC: BACTERIAL MUTATION ASSAY (S. typhimurium and E. coli) ADDENDUM III - S9 production and quality control certificates STUDY NO.: 76250
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 50
POST MITOCHONDRIAL SUPERNATANT (S-9) PRODUCTION & QUALITY CONTROL CERTIFICATE
LOT NO.: 2273
SPECIES: Rat
PREPARATION DATE: May 1, 2008
PART NO.: 11-105
STRAIN: Sprague Dawlev
EXPIRATION DATE: May 1, 2010
VOLUME: 1 & 2 ml
SEX: Male
BUFFER: 0.154 M KCl
TISSUE: Liver
INDUCING AGENT(s): Phenobarbital -
REFERENCE: Matsushima, et. al.. In: In Vitro Metabolic
5.5-Benzoflavone
Activation in Mutagencsis Testing (F.3. de Serres, Ed.), Elsevier, 1976. p. 85.
STORAGE: At or below 70C
BIOCHEMISTRY:
- PROTEIN 37.6 mg/ml
Assayed according to the method of Lowry et al., 1BC 193:265, 1951 using bovine serum albumin as the standard.
- ALKOXYRESORUFIN-0tDEALKYLASE ACTIVITIES
Fold -
Activity P450
Induction
EROD IA1, IA2
55.5
Assays for ethoxvresoruib-0-deethylase (EROD), pentoxv-,
benzyl- and metho,q-resorufin-0-dealleylases (PROD, BROD. &
PROD 2B I
19.7
MROD) were conducted using a modification of the methods
of Burke, et al., Biocheni Pharm 34:3337, 1985. Fold-
BROD
2B1
19.9
inductions were calculated as the ratio of the sample vs.
uninduced specific activities (SA's). Control SA's (pmolcs/min/
IvlROD 1A2
11.2
mg protein) were 31.0, 14.2, 57.4, 10.4 for EROD. PROD,
BROD and MROD, respectively.
BIOASSAY:
- TEST FOR THE PRESENCE. OF ADVENTITIOUS AGENTS Samples of S-9 were assayed for the presence of contaminating microtlora by plating 1 .0 ml volumes on Nutrient Agar and Minimal Glucose (Vogel-Bonner E, supplemented with 0.05 mM L-histidine and Dbiotin) media. Triplicate plates were read after 24 - 48 h incubation at 35C. The tested samples met acceptance criteria_
- PROMUTAGEN ACTIVATION
No. his-'- Revertants
The ability of the sample to activate ethidium bromide (EtBr)
EtBr/ CPA/
and cyclophosphamide (CPA) to intermediates mutagenic to
TA98 TA 1535
TA98 and TAL535, respectively, was determined according
342.8 1528
to Lesca, et al., Mutation Res 129:299, 1984. Data were expressed
as revertants per pg EtBr or per mg CPA.
Dilutions of the sample 59, ranging from 0.2 - 10% in S9 mix, were tested for their ability to activate benzo(a)pyrene (BP) and 2-aminoanthracene (2-AA) to intermediates mutagenic to TA100. Assays were conducted using duplicate plates as described by Maron & Ames (Mutat. Res.I13:173, 1983).
l S9 per plate/number his* revertants per plate
Promutagen BP (5 g) 2-AA (2.5 pg)
0
1
181
297
184
165
5 387 1075
10 650 1727
20 855 2026
50 1065 1283
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 51
POST MITOCHONDRIAL SUPERNATANT (S-9) PRODUCTION & QUALITY CONTROL CERTIFICATE
LOT NO.: 2378
SPECIES: Rat
PREPARATION DATE: February 18.2009
PART NO.: 11-105
STRAIN: .Sprague Dawlev
EXPIRATION DATE: February 18. 201(
VOLUME: I & 2,,,nli
SEX: _Male
BUFFER: 0.154 MKCI
TISSUE: layer._
INDUCING AGENT(a): Phenobarbital -
REFERENCE: Matsushima. et. al,. In' In Vitro Metabolig
5.6-Benzoflavone
Activation in Mutagenesis Testing (F.J. de Sevres. Ed). Elsevier. 1976. p. 85
STORAGE: at or below - 70C
BIOCHEMISTRY:
- PROTEIN 1.73-mg/rul
Assayed according to the method of Lowry et at., JBC 193:265,1951 using bovine serum albumin as the standard.
- ALKOXYRESORUFIN-0-DEALKYLASE ACTIVITIES
Fold -
Activity FQ EROD 1A1, 1A2
Inductim 60.7
Assays for elhoxyresorufin-0-deethylase (BROD), pentoxy-,
benzyl- and methoxyresorufin-0-dealkylases (PROD, BROD, &
PROD 2B1
25.9
MROD) were conducted using a modification of the methods
of Burke, et al., Biochem Phorm 34:3337, 1985. Fold-
BROD
2E1
23.5
inductions were calculated as the ratio of the sample vs.
uninduced specific activities (SA's). Control SA's (pmoles/min/
MROD 1A2
34.8
mg protein) were 14.0, 7.5, 22.6, 2.6 for EROD, PROD,
BROD and MROD, respectively.
BIOASSAY:
- TEST FOR THE PRESENCE OF ADVENTITIOUS AGENTS
Samples of S-9 were assayed for the presence of contaminating microflora by plating 1.0 ml volumes on
- Nutrient AgarAnd Minimal Glucose (Vogel-Bonner E, supplemented with 0.05 niM L-histidine and D-
biotin) media. Triplicate plates were read after 24 - 48 h incubation at 35C. The tested samples met
acceptance criteria.
- PROMUTAGEN ACTIVATION
No. las+ Revertants
The ability of the sample to activate ethidium bromide (EtBr)
EtBr/ CPA/
and cyclophosphamide (CPA) to intemiediates mutagenic to
TA98 TA1535
TA98 and TA1535, respectively, was determined according
276.8 863
to Lesca, et al., Mutation Res 129:299, 1984. Data were expressed
as revertants per pg EtBr or per mg CPA.
Dilutions of the sample S9, ranging from 0.2 - 10% in S9 mix, were tested for their ability to activate benzo(a)pyrene (BP) and 2-aminoanthracene (2-AA) to intermediates mutagenic to TAI00. Assays were conducted using duplicate plates as described by Maron & Ames (Mutat. Res.113:173, 1983).
pl S9 Per olate/numberh/s* revertants per plate
Promutaggn
14
24
BP (5 pg)
113
186
281
431
801
1105
2-AA (2.5 lig)
114
196
486
1249
1433
1497
RTC Study No.: 76250
Page 52