Document r6p9w81zdXJdZveeDwOpdppBV
Supplement II Presentation of Dr. James T. Trainor J. T. Trainor Testing Co. LLC BMC/SAE J2430 Dynamometer Test Program (Standardized Effectiveness Test for Aftermarket Brake Friction Products) Presented June 4, 2000, at the FMSI Annual Meeting Key Largo, Florida
FMSI 01226
FMSI 01227
LARGE NUMBER OF FRICTION PRODUCERS Jft61 CHASE TEST IS NOT A RELIABLE BASIS FOR ASSESSING VEHICLE BRAKING PERFORMANCE. PUBLIC ASSUMES THERE ARE STANDARDS TO COVER SAFETY RELATED REPLACEMENT PRODUCTS.
J
I(/I>I
HI
> HI
j*S8
S gu 2
o
(oz<HAI
X
*sj
a *" os Uos KoOs
*5
&h
</> H
z
!
gJ O sxOS 1 2<
5 HI
M
2*2 < Sg
6 i"HZ lHH-IOODS
ssIU J HI
" < HI
ss
a hi x oHI oo uo o:
" aJ N<
KSI 2 2g < " <
Sh IHA (ft
II
H4 (Ho0sI su"
| 1
4 H
H O
oS
gse
s
O
1st
SS
<z
2< nr
MHI E
HN H
HHI rU*8
2:
g ss i" o .H 0
x8H>:I P#O%^"I5O
ti?
k
Ik
zHZ.
r
i*wHHn"I
iszz 5u MM O
HZHI oOS >I1 o< 5HI
S jo
&: N
= HI XHI
ss
H(Dvft u2MDoB (zA Qz UO OHI
<hOSi 5SH<aai
oo
Sn H
oH
o H H
P:
J
FMSI 01228
BMC/SAE J2430 DYNAMOMETER TEST PROGRAM REVIEW & UPDATE FOR FMSI JUNE 4, 2000
OCEAN REEF CLUB--KEY LARGO, FL. OUTLINE OF TOPICS
I) WHY A STANDARDIZED EFFECTIVENESS TEST FOR AFTERMARKET BRAKE FRICTION PRODUCTS?
II) KEY PROJECT OBJECTIVES III) BACKGROUND-KEY EVENTS (1987-1999) IV) SAE J2430 RECOMMENDED PRACTICE V) J2430 VALIDATION TESTING VI) J2430 APPLICATION TO AFTERMARKET PRODUCTS VII) ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA MEANING?
WHAT THEY DO NOT MEAN? VIII) CURRENT ACTIVITIES AND DIRECTION
IX) SUMMARY
J.T.TRAINOR TESTING CO. LLC 8 RIVENDELL DR.
SHELTON, CT. 06484
FMSI 01229
3. VALIDATION TESTING
** MATERIAL DIFFERENTIATION ** TEST/TEST A LAB/LAB ** DYNO/VEHICLE CORRELATION
J
s $ ss<0 s s as 3i2i><
0(01z?S101 HloI00lHI000SSbUbII 03I2U 2ooooo0ozP(zP0 30lo0U0UoU0b1lll 0
IU
>
a < 0
po
IU lb lb IU
H
IU
0
z 0 Hz
IU
oH
O
Z
o> s
0
H
u0z
230
S00 U >.
"In t30 50H
IHU
lb
0
Ul
o>
0 0
0Hz
Ul
0
Ul
J
s
0
<0Z 303 00
iglls
< o o>
0 z iu
300
>
=**
0 *
*
OO0 * **
0 So
o p0
p
o0 3
j
5
<
0 0
0
0
oUl
<
Ul
op
0s*
3u
|z
Ul
0 0
IU 3 n
ss
00
&
S3
3
lb
0U
*
0"
g sg
02
0 IU
0
0
O
Ul o
o
J
o
Ul
p .
0 J
0
" 0
s
d2
N
"*
g
0
2
2
S*
uo
00 ** ** * ** *
0
N
FMSI 01230
IU o
.j p
H
2
o k
Q pH oZ CO
o
<H
>
X a
J LU 0 o1I >ZL <
D (0
Is IlEiX
5
a
s
0
t>
u< 1*
c z 1
<a
X
s
X
w
2
li X "
u.
f
* 2
111 a
<sxx
o t IU Ik
H O fc X
i
X O
M M
p5
u
t
jg
HI
P z
X
HI
Z u
>
-I H t s
IU CO 2 3)
-J X
o z
oh
o
o
8
3 u H
IU
>
lok
s X5
3
H XX
HHS
IX
p
o
Z X 3 9
Z IU
CO CO
<0 3
au
i
Eg
3CO
IU CO
o
P
u
w
X
^
U
"
CoO
X
xH
CO 3 X
IU
I
CO
3 X
oz
s
X
IU
XQ
& <
IU
Sfi
o?
X Si
9
CM
**
o IU
5
o
3
Z
< P
IU
u 2
CM
P
2
* * *
Si
IU X
g&
*
3:
10 <0
J
MECHANISM TO M AINTAIN ENGINEERING INTEG RITY ANALYTICAL APPROACHES TO GENERALIZE
X
x
H
FMSI 01231
J
CtL
LU
a.
< Q.
Osa
o iij z KH
oC/)
Q_
111 LU
S
JO
0
<
01
LU H <
o
h o
a:
u.
o
2
DO
J
FMSI 01232
J
U
O(H0 >H-
C3O 4
0
0
O = 3 IU
z<
ft
Is
<H
co
el 5 o 0
H <a
IU IU
O <
2 ill
a os
j" m<4
0zu
g
o a
<
2 -i
itCO S iu a
<H
CO
<.i
(0 S s
Z
zTMH<
<
5
IU
oS
H Z
LaU: *
IU
h
oo
9o CM 8
o<
oH 2
u
oOat
gj >
-<I
CO a z
CO
9 Eoa
o 52
oh*
CO
zoO
4Xo
IU
2
SnJ
IU
ao
<
sCO *
III CO
=Z 0IU
u
< *" o
X0
U
o>
3
oa
< CO
a co
2< OO
oo
CM
<H 9* H
0
IU
*
**
FMSI 01233
J
aIU
IU o
a i mHI
O ji
Klb O<
HI r
HI tt tt
O HI <HAI
-I
O
&
S .
Ms
o
(A H2I WHI O
sp2<<
oo
52 ((IUAA h5Q>
if 22
oHo
ooZ
IIWHI ujgj
HI
it(ft HI
<AJSUi
J
>w
i> :*
N
10 pMS/ 01234
J
in
u-i
o
oz
1J11 oC<O
<H
Z
2 g oJ3 3&
<
LU
111
oJ
z< oo UI
= SUH
III
>
3
a
Olk
HUI
a 5 CO U
<
5
LL
in TM CO
H< OIL "
as ui 2
1 liJ
E
o
o
o S Jl
S
Sit
<
4
lU
5i os o
a<
LU
sO
2 s!O
< CD
2
a2
Si
si
o2 <0
III fmid 0"
z ui 1 2
HOZ
CO
<
SUHI
111
CUOI
* uJUI XUI
>
J<3
0
0
X
CO
3 0
111
ZUI
>
p
0k
0UI
Ik
Ik
III
OZH O
k
20UI
III
0 13-1i1
3
0JUI
>
111
k
Ik
0U2I
UI 0
u2i
<
0UI XH H UIIII
2
<
UXO
C
05
go
<2 2<
2kk"
a 0 'a
tJu
2<
0IU
2UI
Xz
HUI
U. o
?S
0 u
as s.
2 d ui
ill
=2 3a u0
2 ui >
fe 2 a *k
0 0s 20
UI 2 2
0goX oJ o< 03 UoI
H UI 2
aS
az
5
5
5
ui
0X i M2
22
2f H UI E
J
ooui
sj
_
P
O
2
Z
< ui
2 ui
5
<
co
3 & S5 CO
2(0
(102
UI 2
HX
2
0
Z
<
0Z
-0
s
2UI
0 0
<
0Z o
2
<
P
UI
22
*
<
ik
Oz jlda
0SP
2U2
2k2
3<O
n20
kgj
a 3
l8
? Ill K
g5
Si |
0 u. K *ik Ri 3S ts a
i ia
i
a
co gj
&
2S
K
iSa
I * ? SJ
CM 0
FMSI 01235
J
FMSI 01236
J2430 DYNO TEST SETOP PARAMETERS
1998 FORD EXPLORER 4 DOOR
<> lira*** annum*
SUMMARY ANALYSIS-AFTERMARKET FRICTION MATERIAL CHARACTERIZATION SAMPLE BASED ON SAE J2430
J.T.T. 1/11A0
(**) imni annul**
FMSI 01237
J otO
o
dco
9
J
1
z
o
o
oo
q co
g
o
J o ^d wd nd ^d o dMU*N "IH3A
FMSI 01238
J
(0 IU X
o2
a
o
cn
LU
*
oc <
J2
LU
U. <
o
< 0
1
CO
J
0>
IU
HI O
<
a
(0
10
(0 (0 > i2k --<
co (0
zHI
HI
>
P
O
HI
5 HI Ik
H Ik
S 5 HI 9)
8j
2s
<H =EC u11j1
to >
2m
|L VI
7" a. to hu qg oa Uj &> H
t*
(0 *
Sg
<0 (0 (0 Z HI (0
IU UJ
0 Z UJ
Oil5 i(0
c IU Z
Sgg
>
I
s o
IU
Hz
2 3 Ko
8 S S&P to to 1 HI O m h
3 5u
o
2<
g * o
2
&<
7 Ik HI
* ik ik
< HI Ik
is"
Z
(0 U
HI
H H
O 12 3O
2 2 3
<oo
BOX
O
<
ik
(0
O
a
jjM :=:=>>
a* to *
N
* *
FMSI 01239
FMSI 01240
J
*D 22
CD O
o&
5 qs
s 3i
Q. Ill
XHI 5<
Q9
3 u. 3^
m
J Lo3OUc
FMSI 01241
FMSI 01242
GRAND PRIX FRONT BRAKE
J2430 AVERAGE SPECIFIC TORQUE
GTL M06024-06 GTL M06024-07
FMSI 01243
J
J o ; * *
0
li
W "" -1 0 * Z0
-I zat
3
0(0
H111
if IU
0 O
H <
" Is
t OUCiaoM CM
IU co
u
0
(A-a
0o
Si
u K-
IU |U
mh
il
if
I-
CO JU
g^ Q
V\ J2430 VALIDATION TESTING
"4. DYNAMOMETER/VEHICLE FIGURE 6 SUMMARIZES DYNAMOMETER/VEHICLE CORRELATION FOR THE BRAKES TESTED. ** 1997 HONDA CIVIC; 1997 CARAVAN; 1997 GRAND PRIX; 1998 EXPLORER; 1998 F250.
FMSI 01244
J
FMSI 01245
SAE J1652 COMPARISON OF COMMERCIAL DISC PRODUCTS
FMSI D-82, CHEVY CAPRICE
REGRESSED SPECIFIC TORQUE GTL TEST DATA
ly i SAE J2430 RECOMMENDED PRACTICE
8. DESIGNED FOR EFFECTIVENESS & FADE EVALUATION ** NOT INTENDED TO ASSESS WEAR, NOISE, ROTOR WEAR
OR EXTENDED LIGHT DUTY VEHICLE SERVICE.
J
IO Z ZO
15
<O O5
_gi Oi
z..
<
ZN
2z
Hji
zZ01 15
2<
SHI
>01 oz
U
0
021
01
u
001
H10930 <0<101
<Xa010
H H<010 OZ IO H
0 3 S3
k 2oe i- 111
2t
IO O
*-> |<
MZ
A<
<o
oi r
is
i:
Sz *z
0<0 oH S QII 5
is
1"
oo
So
0* zk z
01 O
ss
0o
"a
0z1
3
a<a
00z1 2Zoi
2z
Sg
1*0 CnM (u<0a<A01
< -i
oi z2
O01 I<
as
se
ok
-l
a
Z
2
H
25
XPC
ii
Sr a 01 W
"E 3ogZO*k
*5
S* <t
N-> * *
3 a
4
Q
8
z s&
2 ak n <0 uJ MH ^>
5:
<<
z0BL
a 01
01 Z
-1 -J
33 o
:
00E1
$ kj
s u >
5?
22
iios <
A2a
CM IO
FMSI 01246
J2430 PROCEDURE SYNOPSIS
POST TEST COOLING CURVES
J issss
|8
gg l
IB
Xn
N
l- N
** IS g 3
|
sillM
i
x0Ul
n
3 3 3 -g10eorear
sBanna Sl1Ui N $ N t n 8 aaa
i
I-
Nui
Ul
s
ui XU>l
s 5Ul a
SI SI Ul
FMSI 01247
Ill) KEY EVENTS 1996-1999
CM mi
< g o111 O
o<p oSc du
** 52
HI -i m
z283
jjj 5 C o OIPo 3< I>I yj 5 <
HE 2*z ^ ' A III
3 <z jo
M3
3*S
mS3 32zO
a ji< HI s II A
<m oO aBC 2
S* * *
vO>)
FMSI 01248
J
FMSI 01249
Ill) KEY EVENTS iag7--1995
SAE PUBLISHES J1652-SIN G LE APPLICATION DISC BRAKE TEST BMC/FMC FUNDING FOR REAR DRUM BRAKE PROCEDURE
II) KEY PROJECT O BJEC TIVES
6. PUBLISHED AS SAE RECOMMENDED PRACTICE
ak
P
a
&
kIU IU
o
a
a
a a
O
X B
Za
a
&
s 2o 2X (A
%0! -O1
Si ui g
as2a
2*
&
ui 2 Pz *
k ao
a2
s z3
&
22 22 pk aoi
a
I.A
> o o
a k z
Z Mag
o =J
Q Q-
a o
*Z
2- ui.
s
<a a oo
o
a s^ 2a 2
M Ik
Sg
i?
ss 3^ a*
<j
s i a o
zo
u &
a x aa
g
<
a a
a z
X a
Oa
S"| <
aao
sS
=BO
a*
> ik
Si
O
a
O
ui
-I
S
z
a
<
B
xas
2-i5t s
g
a
>
< i
-i
a I
k 4
n
22
X
a OH
O Ik
s
B2
Ok
Ik X
a2 k -i
<52:
ba<
atoaox
BOU.
poa
2a
ua
to
5 2p
Saghi gSSo
s
p 8(A
-* Ou Z<
S
<
IU
a
p
a
&
O
B B a B
2u
kX
<B
|o
a **
=
* N
a
FMSI 01250
J
BMC OBJECTIVE
IU
HX
2I za
22
5I
g&
s of! X
O u o ! HH| <iu
H 35SSO
x
III
2* * *z
<
oOo
-
o
HI
c 5
HI a
X
hi
2
3
a
g P2OQ %--1 o
x .tu LCUQ Ip
HI XX
= J iSg
X -
X
-
X HI
hi
a
w
gSS So J;I>II
po
111
111
III
oo
-I
X
s
- S g 8 P< Is
oH
S |Em
izhn
79$5 OU oo 2
^ j o aUJ
t
5
gi== "-J gco
UJ
wuQj
g
O
u.
2
3 CQ UJ
o5c
UccJ a
ao<as
CO
>tj
= UJ OC
O O co
UJ
g
UJ
OUJ
Q. UJ
O CXO
UJ
QxC
2
2
g
oUL
X
UaJ.
co
< 1LU
LU
UJ UJ
CO
UJ
a
LU
L<U
>*
20S0s 2i
o o X ^ >- *
> *c_> oe ^ 2CO UJ
CQ X "O UUJp
UJ UJ
>; a
2
s
Stf
3
CL
2
I-
3
1
i
2
w
co
fc
2
o
uaj uUj.
o-g
<2
UCOJ
>-
oit.
LL.
y iDC
CO
uj
_CQ-
O<
>Q.
L--UI
O
CO LU CO ^
t < LU O
oQ. x <
Ss oa. uj
<>
o
az
IU
o
u
HI X HI HI
o
a (0
-xi
u
5
H O
HI
X
O -I 3
O
Xx
HI
U
o
lb
u (ft
xg tH *lb
HI ...
<<
!2 -i
fc|
<<
22s
HI
>
X
H U
S
HI oS xO oH
DOw
a w io
OHM
X co >
w
X
wX
ib
HI J Ib w
2?
<
O I-
oib
HI
2
o
o
op
wa
2
Xw
>
ib
X
wX
H 2
X
X
zIU
I
X X
ziu
>
<2zS
2
o8
O iX
IU x U
So
3W at
Hi HI t
X
HI 0.
HI 8 O2
HI X
2
EHXXI3 Xfwl J2xHw
oxX<<
X Hi x x a S
H
FMSI 01251