Document qmpMp0jRD0116xD4eD7GNLz45
Fires of the Eighties -- Are They Different?
A popular allegation--that today's fires 1980, annual plastics production topped 37
contain more lethal gases or bum "hotter and billion pounds--almost a 20-fold increase
faster" than those or the '40s because of the since 1952.
greater amounts of synthetics involved--is
not supported by fact Carbon monoxide, the Opponents of plastic materials wantpeople to
proven killer in fires, is just as much of a believe that removing synthetics from our
problem in fires now as it was then. The buildings will eliminate most of the hazards
1941 Handbook of Fire Protection states:
of a modem fire. But the facts are clear:
sharply increased use of plastics has certainly
"A great majority offire deaths are believed not made the fire fatality problem worse.
to be due to the effects of smoke and hot
gases produced in fires. Carbon monox Why People Die in Fires
ide. . .and various other poisonous gases may
be generated in fires involving materials What is common to the tragedies listed be
ordinarilyfound in buildings."
low? In each, conditions existed which al
lowed a fire to become very large very
Eight years earlier a study by the National quickly. It does not matter what is burn
Fire Protection Association stated:
ing--wood or plastics--if conditions are pre
sent that allow rapid fire growth, tragedy
"Every year in the United States about results.
10,000 people lose their lives because of
fires. It has been observed and com
mented upon that many of these victims are not burned but succumb to
U.S. Fire Death Rate vs. Plastics Production
the effects of 'smoke' and gas."
(G.E. Ferguton, "Fire G*et," NFPA Quarterly, Vet. 27, No. 2, p. 110, 1933.)
nr OnMim mMm
pMpto
BMwm
U.S. Fire Death Rate Declining
In 1939, the U.S. population of approximately 132 million people suffered 10,000 deaths in fires, a death rate of 76 per million people. By 1980--after our population almost doubled-^-fire deaths decreased to 6,500 people, the death rate dipping to 29 per million. Yet, at the same time, the fuel load content (amount of
combustible materials) present in buildings increased dramatically.
EfraPWiOate Mitm* Pbi *aelan Aaitoi
Social factors stand out as strong contributors to fire deaths.
During this 40 year period--when the fire death rate dropped 62 percent--use of plastic materials also grew astronomically. Plastics were not commercial products in the U.S. in 1933. During 1952, only two billion pounds of plastics were consumed in the U.S. By
Our habits as consumers have changed since 1950. Our houses are larger. They are carpeted and contain more furnish ings. In short, they are filled with com bustibles. They are built with large open spaces through which fire and
-over-
The Vinyl Institute, A Division of The Society of the Plastics Industry, Inc. Wayne Interchange Plaza II, 155 Route 46 West, Wayne, New Jersey 07470, (201) 890-9299
CTL016755
smoke spread easily. They are better insulated
ways, improperly designed heating, ventilating
and hold in more heat--whether it is at 70F or
and air conditioning systems and smoke spread
1200F (the temperature that typically can be
ing through elevator hoistways.
reached in a fire). Also, due to the increase in
the number of families where both adults * Lack of detection and suppression sys
work, many homes stand vacant during the
tems contributes to fire deaths.
day. Fires that start in these homes bum
longer before they are reported. In addition,
Fatal fires often start during early morning
according to National Fire Protection Asso
hours (about 40 percent of fires start between
ciation (NFPA) estimates, one-third of all Fire
midnight and 4 a.m.) when people are sleeping
deaths in the United States are due to fires
soundly. Effective detection and alerting sys
started by cigarettes. Most of these fires start
tems are especially important and are the most
in upholstered furniture or bedding in single
promising solution to the fire problem today.
homes or apartments. Over two-thirds of the
These systems include:
deaths occur in fires which start at night, when
most victims are asleep.
Smoke Detectors. In 1976, less than five
percent of the homes in the United States had a
Alcohol consumption increases the chance of
smoke detector. Today, as a result of support
dying in a fire. The senses are dulled and
by the fire community and public interest
resistance to toxic fire gases--such as carbon
groups, over 67 percent of all homes have one
monoxide--is reduced. The ability to act
or more smoke detectors. A review of 699
quickly, decisively and correctly is inhibited.
fires in residences protected with smoke detec
If intoxicated, people are less likely to be
tors showed that detectors reduced the potential
aroused by smoke or fire, and thus, less able
for severe injury or death in 90% of the fires
to escape.
that occurred when all occupants were asleep.
Failure to comply with building codes is evident in fires with large loss of life.
Violations of code requirements have occurred in almost every fire with large loss of life. An outstanding example is the MGM Grand Hotel fire in Las Vegas, Nevada, on November 21, 1980. In that fire, in which 85 persons lost
Fire Related Deaths in Buildings of Public Assembly
Data
1940 1942 1946 1946 1977 1980 1980 1981 1982
Construction
Rythm Club Cocoanut Grova Night Club LaSaHo Hotal Wlnaeofl Hotal Bavarly HMa Suppar Club MGM Grand Hotal Stouffars Inn, Harrison, NY Las Vagas Hilton Hotal Wastchasa Hilton Hotal
Numbar of Fatalltlaa
207 492
61 119 165
85 26
8 12
their lives, some of the factors cited by the NFPA that contributed to the loss of life were: lack of automatic fire extinguishment (no sprinklers in the part of the building where the deaths occurred), unprotected vertical open ings, substandard enclosure of interior stairs, lack of smokeproof towers and exit passage-
Sprinkler Systems. Fire safety experts believe widespread use of sprinklers in homes could be the single most important factor in reducing loss of life and property from fires. New, fast-response sprinkler systems using plastic pipe have been developed as a result of research sponsored by the U.S. Fire Administration. In a series of tests, these systems reduced fire property losses by 85
percent and provided a life safety environment by controlling toxicity levels and temperature in the fire environment The new systems are less expensive than traditional sprinkler systems, which puts them within reach of most homeowners.
What's the Solution?
Experts from government and the fire service community agree that greater emphasis should be placed on fire safety education and on the increased use ofdetection and suppres sion systems. The wholesale removal of plastics from our environment is not the answer. In fact, many plastic materials that are used in construction and furnishings actually can help stop fires from starting and from spreading.
Fire prevention programs which focus on these approaches will prove the most effective way to reduce the current U.S. fire death rate.
September 1986
CTL016756