Document qdpGedmvx1dVkB8q3aZXo14EG

Message From: Sent: To: CC: Subject: Attachments: Laity, Jim A. EOP/OMB [ x . ' Personal"Privacy (P P )"3 7/1/2018 4:58:59 PM " ' Morris, Jeff [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=55c34872e6ea40cab78be910aec63321-Morris, Jeff]; Underwood, Patricia M CIV (US) [patricia.m.underwood.civ@mail.mil]; Waqar, Tayyaba [tayyaba.waqar@sba.gov]; kevin.bromberg@sba.gov [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=a79a0f905cda421984b3523ea0beaf85-kevin. bromberg@sba.gov]; Wennerberg, Linda S. (HQ-LD020 [linda.s.wennerberg@nasa.gov]; Moore, Beth [Beth.Moore@em.doe.gov]; Brenner, Sara A. EOP/OSTP [Sara,A.Brenner2@j Jones, Danielle Y. EOP/OMB [Danie 11e_Y_J ones@ (.e ; Schwab, Margo EOP/OMB [Margo_Schwab@CE; ll,TMATM;S.p.P|J]; Szabo, Aaron L. EOP/CEQ [Aaron.L.Szabo@|'r6'pTM,7.r,^7p'p7?]; Barringer, Jody M. EOP/OMB [Jody_M._Barringer@[` T S ^ R ^ w j`]]; Falk Curtin, Edna T. EOP/OMB [Edna_F._Curtin@[f;_6_p"" ^ pTMfippjj; Paul Winters PauLA _W inters@ (= 7^^j^^m J) ["Paul WintersPaul_A_W intersll@<[f;.6PiTMp|TMi"rl.pp.1.])]; Fine, Leah R. EOP/OMB [ Ex. 6 Personal Privacy (PP) i Bertrand, Charlotte [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=f044d768e05842elb75321ff6010elb8-Bertrand, Charlotte]; Baptist, Erik [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=10fclb085eel4c6cb61db378356aleb9-Baptist, Er]; Beck, Nancy [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=168ecb5184ac44de95a913297f353745-Beck, Nancy]; Blair, Susanna [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=6c869b985f3d43db982cl8aaabd826bd-Blair, Susa]; Nickerson, William [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=148f2clc05b54f358e29c59b841664aa-Wnicker] RE: [Non-DoD Source] Methylene Chloride: Information on Sub-lethal effects (UNCLASSIFIED) OM B Comments - methylene chloride 6-27-18.docx J e f f : A ttach ed are 01RA comments on both the 2014 r i s k assessm ent and the supplem ental m a t e r ia ls you sent to._the_.TM G_o ji. .Ju n e . iZIZZZZZZZZZZ.ZIZL., Deliberative Process / Ex. 5 "i Deliberative Process 7 Ex. 5 j? I Deliberative Process / Ex. 5 l - ' >---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------> Please feel free to cal 1 i f you would 1ike to discuss further. > > Jim > -----O r igi nal Message----- From: M o r r is , J e f f <M o r r is . Je ff@ e p a . gov> Sen t : Tuesday, June 26, 2018 2:38 PM To : Underwood, P a t r i c i a M C IV (U S ) < p atri c i a.m .underwood. c i v@mai1 . mi 1>; W aqar, Tayyaba < tayyab a. waqarOsba. gov>; kevi n .brom berg@sba.gov; W ennerberg, Li nda S . (HQ-LD020 <1in d a . s . wennerbergOnasa. gov>; Moore, Beth < Beth. MooreOem.doe. gov>; B ren n er, S a ra A. EOP/OSTP <Sara.A.BrennerlE/.Vp7re7n/7p)i)7cV(pp)]; Jo n e s , D an iel 1e Y. EOP/OMB <Daniel 1e_Y_Jones(Ts: 6 Personal Privacy (PP) >; Schwab, Margo EOP/OMB <Margo_clTwai't7JS L a it y , Jim A. EOP/OMB < Jam es^ ._Laity(;Tc/s^r itr^r> ; " Szabo, Aaron L. EOP/CEQ <Aaron. L. Szabo@[7I7p7TMoTM7p'r'iTM7ippri>; B a r r i nger, Jo d y M. EOP/OMB <Jody__M.,, B a r r i nger(0?r/p5^ Fai k C u r t in , Edna T. EOP/OMB_<Ed_na^_F_7_CurtinrEI 6 Personal ]>; Privacy (PP) Paul w in t e r s P a ul _ A_ W i <" Paul Wi n tersP au l_A _W i nters"(iElTp^i'mT^rTpS'j)>; Fi h7"Tafi"R"7 EOP/OMB <Leah . R. Fi ne@(]7/87.7."on".iPrt/7(pp) -------- ! Cc: B e rtra n d , C hari o tte ""<BerTrahdr/charl o tte e p a . gov> ; B a p ti s t , E r i k <Bapt4vc7tT_iTKe7>a. gov> ; Beck, Nancy <Beck.Nancy@ epa. gov>; B l a i r , Susanna <B l ai r . Susanna@epa. gov>; Ni c k e rs o n , W i11i am <Ni ckerson .Wi H i am@epa. gov> S u b je c t : RE: [Non-DoD Sou rce] M ethylene Chi o r i de : In fo rm a ti on on Sub-1ethal e f f e c t s (U N C LA SSIFIED ) TWG Col 1ea g u es, Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA Tier 12 ED 002061E 00001310-00001 EPA re co g n iz es how accommodating ag en cies have been in working w ith us to meet v e r y t ig h t d e a d lin e s . Thank you - we r e a l l y a p p re c ia te i t . T h e r e f o r e , we agree to a ccep t TWG comments on the m ethylene c h io r id e sub-1ethal e f f e c t s document u n t i1 F r id a y , June 29. However, we v ie w t h i s e x te n sio n as c o n ti ngent on agreement w ith our o b je c t iv e to have the f i n a l ru le go in t o i n terag en cy re v i ew by Monday, J u l y 2. We b e li eve t h a t the s c i ence i ssues a sso ci ated w ith the ru le have been much di scussed in the i ssuance o f the f i n a l r i s k assessm en t, the proposed r u le , the re c e n t te c h n i cal b ri e f i ng f o r the TWG, and most r e c e n t ly in the sub-1ethal e f f e c t s document. The use o f t h a t s c i ence to i nform an unreasonable r i s k determ i n a ti on under TSCA i s c e r t a i n ly ap p ro pri a te f o r di sc u ss i on d u ri ng i n terag en cy re v i ew, but EPA f e e l s t h a t i t has done what i t can to e x p la in the te c h n i cal basi s behind i t s e v a lu a t i on o f m ethylene c h io r i d e . I f agenci es would l i k e to have a phone co n feren ce to di scuss any comments th e y may have on the document, we would be happy to s e t one up. A l1 the b e st, Je ff J e f f e r y T. M o r r is , PhD Di r e c t o r , O f f i ce o f Pol 1u t i on P re v e n ti on & Toxi cs US Envi ronmental P r o t e c t i on Agency 1200 P e n n s y lv a n ia Avenue, NW (MC-7401M) Washi ng to n , DC 20460 (202) 564-3810 -----O r igi nal Message----- From: Underwood, P a t r i c i a M C IV (U S ) [mai 1to : p a t r i c i a.m . underwood. c i v@mai1 . mi 1] Sen t : F r i day, June 22, 2018 3:59 PM To : M orri s , J e f f < M o rris . Je ffO e p a .g o v > ; W aqar, Tayyaba <tayyaba.w aq ar@ sba.g ov>; kevi n . bromberg@sba. g o v ; W ennerberg, Li nda S . (HQ-Lp.020..<Jj.nda.,.s.1wejinerbe.rg@nas.a.1.gov>; Moore , Beth <Beth . MooreOem. d oe. gov> ; ---- ,Ex. 6 Personal Privacy (PP) i Jo n e s , D an iel 1e Y. EOP/OMB i Ex. 6 Personal Privacy (PP) i"Schwab" "Margo eId'p/ oMb "<Margo_Schwab@omb. eop . gov>; Lai t y , Jim A. EOP/OMB ! Ex. 6 Personal Privacy (PP) S Szab o, Aaron L. EOP/CEQ \ Ex. Personal Privacy (PP) I-; B a r r i nger, Jo d y M. 'EDP/MB"! Ex. 6 Personal Privacy (PP) i; Fai k C u rti n , d"na" TT"P70MB"i Ex. 6 Personaf PMvacy (PPj '] Paul 'j E x . 6 P e r s o n a l P r iv a c y (P P ) P[ x. 6 Personal Privacy (PP) P > ; F in e , Leah' R. p/ omb S u b je c t : RE: [Non-DoD Sou rce] M ethylene Chi o r i de : In fo rm a ti on on Sub-1ethal e f f e c t s (U N C LA SSIFIED ) CLASSIFICATION: UNCLASSIFIED Je ff, Thank you f o r sendi ng t h i s document. We would v e r y much 1i ke to p ro vi de feed b ack. However, I f our in p u t i s re a l 1y needed/sought, we w i l l not be a b le to p ro vi de i t u n ti 1 June 2 9 th . Our team i s s im p ly booked w ith meeti ngs next week from Monday u n ti 1 Thursday and i t w i l l be physi c a l l y i mpossi b le to re v i ew the document and p ro vi de any meani ng ful feedback u n ti 1 F r i day. I hope t h i s does not cause any major i ssues but i t the b est we can d o . As you know we s t r i v e to respond to a l 1 deadl i nes as p resented in the p a s t . But t h i s one i s j u s t s i mply not possi b le due to o th e r f u l l day commi tments by a l 1 who would be a b le to re vie w . Thanks, Tri ci a -----Ori gi nal Message----- From: M orri s , J e f f [mai 1to : M orri s . Je ff@ e p a . gov] Sen t : F r i day, June 22, 2018 12 :20 PM To : W aqar, Tayyaba <tayyaba.w aq ar@ sba.g ov>; kevi n . bromberg@sba. g o v ; Underwood, P a t r i c i a M C IV (U S) < p atri c i a . m. underwood . c i v@mai 1 . mi 1>; W ennerberg, Li nda S r...(.H0.ziHQ2Q...<li.nda.^s...WJinerb.tq@nasa. gov> ; Moore , Beth <B e t h . Moore@em. d oe. gov>; B r e n n e r, S a ra A. EOP/OSTP j_____ ________________________________ i Jo n e s , D an iel 1e Y. EOP/OMB <T E x l6'Pe'rsnrPrivcy(PP) \ Schwab, Margo EOP/OMB l.<Maj_gg_Schwab_^mb_..ep_p...ggy t y , Jim A. EOP/OMB H' r6Preon"a1>7rvTc7(PP) T'Szabo, Aaron L. EOP/CEQ I Ex. 6 Personal Privacy (PP) j B a r r i n g e r, Jo d y M. EO/MB'"<'jcTyTFr.'UEfff"n'gr@''ml5T'op. go.v>j...Ea)k..Ciirtdji.....Eima]T7/'0'F70MB ' i<Edna..E,...i:ur.tJi@Qm b^.QD...aay>; Paul wi n te r s Fi Ex. 6 Personal Privacy (PP) ) ; Fi n e , Leah R. EOP/OMB j Ex. 6 Personal Privacy (PP) i 1----------------------------! S u b je c t : [Non-DoD Source^ M e th y lene Chi o r i de : In fo rm a ti on on Sub-1ethal e f f e c t s Al 1 a c t iv e 1i nks c o n ta i ned i n t h i s em ai1 were di s a b le d . Pi ease v e r i f y the i d en ti t y o f the s e n d e r, and c o n fi rm the a u th e n ti c i t y o f a l 1 1i nks c o n ta i ned wi t h i n the message p ri o r to copyi ng and p a s ti ng the address to a Web b ro w se r. Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA Tier 12 ED 002061E 00001310-00002 TWG Col 1ea g u es, As in fo rm a tio n p r io r to in te ra g e n c y re v ie w o f EPA' s f i n a l ru le on m ethylene c h i o r i d e , the attach e d document p rovi des : Deliberative Process / Ex. 5 _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ I______________________________________________________________________________________ Deliberative Process / Ex. 5 Thi s i s a v e r y s h o r t , s i mple document, so we would ap p reci a te any comments by noon Tuesday, June 26. Pi ease send any comments to Susanna B l a i r a t B la i r.susanna@ epa.gov < C auti on-mai1t o : B la i r . susanna@epa.gov > . I f a s h o rt cal 1 i s needed Monday a fte rn o o n o r Tuesday morni ng to c l a r i f y a n y th i ng in the document, pi ease 1e t Susanna know and we w i l l s e t i t up. Thanks v e r y much f o r worki ng w ith us on t h i s . Al 1 the b e s t, Je ff J e f f e r y T. M o r r is , PhD Di r e c t o r , O f f i ce o f Pol 1u t i on P re v e n ti on & Toxi cs US Envi ronmental P r o t e c t i on Agency 1200 P e n n s y lv a n ia Avenue, NW (MC-7401M) Washi ng to n , DC 20460 (202) 564-3810 CLASSIFICATION: UNCLASSIFIED Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA Tier 12 ED 002061E 00001310-00003