Document q4Jx42DYK5EN6Xx6D0OjbVqn
Region 6 - Enforcement & Compliance Assurance Division
INSPECTION REPORT
Inspection Date(s): Media Program: Regulatory Program(s)
May 9, 2024 Water NPDES Stormwater/ CWA 402
Company Name: Facility Name: Facility Physical Location:
(city, state, zip code) Mailing address:
(city, state, zip code) County/Parish: Facility Phone Number Facility Contact 1:
Facility Contact 2:
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC
Painted Tree Village District South (Phase 1)
Taylor Burk Dr and Painted Trail Dr
McKinney, TX, 75071
6201 W Plano Pkwy STE 150
Plano, TX, 75093
Collin
817-410-1037
Bruce French
Vice President (Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC)
Bruce.French@TriPointeHomes.com
Jeremy Boucher
Consultant (EnviroServe)
jboucher@enviroserve.co
FRS Number: Identification/Permit Number: Media Identifier Number: NAICS: SIC:
N/A TXR1582KY N/A 236117 1521
Personnel participating in inspection:
Destinee Agwuna
6EN-WR
Carol Johnson
6EN-WS
Sharron Crayton
6EN-WS
Inspector/Enforcement Officer Inspector/Enforcement Officer Inspector/Enforcement Officer
EPA Lead Inspector Signature/Date
DESTINEE AGWUNA Date: 2024.07.01 14:31:24 -05'00' Digitally signed by DESTINEE AGWUNA
Destinee Agwuna
7/1/2024 Date
Supervisor Signature/Date
ANTHONY LOSTON Date: 2024.07.02 10:53:45 -05'00' Digitally signed by ANTHONY LOSTON
Anthony Loston
Date
6ENFORM-019-R8.2 (02/12/2020)
1
Section I - INTRODUCTION
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
PURPOSE OF THE INSPECTION
U.S. EPA Region 6 inspectors Destinee Agwuna, Carol Johnson, and Sharron Crayton arrived at Painted Tree on May 9, 2024, at approximately 9:15 AM for an unannounced Compliance Evaluation Inspection (CEI). The inspectors met with Construction Manager, Mr. JB Giddens at the construction trailer near the intersection of Wyler Drive and Marilanda Road. We presented our credentials to Mr. Giddens and informed him that a random stormwater inspection was being performed to determine compliance with the Texas Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (TPDES) program and the Construction General Permit (CGP), in accordance with the Clean Water Act (CWA).
The generation of this report is based on information supplied by Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC representatives (the permittee), observations made by the inspectors, and records and reports maintained by the permittee, the state of Texas, and the U.S. EPA.
FACILITY DESCRIPTION
Painted Tree is a residential construction site consisting of three separate districts (the Village District, Lakeside District, and Woodland District) (shown in Site Map 1 below). Painted Tree is a large common plan of development, with multiple operators developing and building within the community simultaneously. This inspection report focuses only on the construction activities of operator Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC in the Village District Phase 1 (TCEQ permit number: TXR1582KY), which was in the building phase of construction at the time of inspection.
Painted Tree (Village District Phase 1) is located northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive in McKinney, TX (denoted in Aerial Image 1 below). Coordinates to the site are in the vicinity of Latitude 3313'40.4" North, Longitude 9639'26.6"West. The area operated by Tri Pointe Homes totals 80 acres with approximately 34 acres of land to be disturbed for Phase 1. The site discharges to Franklin Branch.
2
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
Site Map 1: The overall site map of the Painted Tree Community. The inspection area is in the Village District by Tri Pointe Homes (Phase 1 is depicted by orange lots). The site map was obtained from the Painted Tree Digital Map Guide on the community website.
3
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
Aerial Image 1: The Painted Tree (Village District Phase 1) constructions site. The area of inspection is within the boundary of Marilanda Road, Painted Tail, Taylor Burk Drive, and Wyler Drive. Aerial from Google Maps Imagery, 2023.
Section II - OBSERVATIONS The following points of discussion are derived from on-site visual observations on May 9, 2024:
The construction site is located immediately east of an outfall and tributary (near the intersection of Outpost Trail and Marilanda Road) that feeds into Franklin Branch (Aerial Imagine 1).
There was evidence of a recent discharge of sediment at the outfall/tributary near the intersection of Outpost Trail and Marilanda Road at the time of inspection. Because the site has many operators developing and building simultaneously, multiple operators are likely responsible for the sediment discharge (Appendix 1, Photo 1).
During the opening conference the construction manager, Mr. Giddens, advised the inspectors that the large Construction Site Notice (CSN) would be located at either the intersection of Taylor-Burk Drive and Wyler Drive or at the intersection of Taylor-Burk Drive and Painted Trail. The CSN was not observed at either intersection or any other location on-site at the time of inspection.
Mr. Giddens was unable to provide a physical copy of the Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP), an updated site map, or inspection reports for the Village District Phase 1 (TCEQ permit number: TXR1582KY) at the time of inspection. SWPPP booklets for other phases of construction were available in the construction trailer on May 9, 2024 (Appendix 1, Photo 2). 4
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
We observed Best Management Practices (BMPs) present on-site. Multiple AOCs were observed as described below in Section III of this report with photos included in Appendix 1.
Section III - AREAS OF CONCERN
The following areas of concern are derived from on-site observations from the May 9, 2024 Compliance Evaluation Inspection (CEI) and from documentation provided by the permittee's environmental consultant, Mr. Jeremy Boucher on May, 17, 2024 (see section IV).
The TCEQ Large Construction Site Notice (CSN) was not posted on-site as required by Section E.3.c of the CGP at the time of inspection.
The SWPPP, site map(s), and inspection reports for the Village District, Phase 1 was not available on-site at the time of inspection and no notice was posted to describe the location of the SWPPP as described in Part III Section D.1 of the CGP.
Wyler Drive: We observed sections of damaged silt fence and worn erosion control blankets along the front of some lots. (Appendix 1, Photos 3-4), allowing sediment to discharge onto the street.
Eddington Drive:
We observed sediment on the sidewalk and street due to ineffective BMPs (Appendix 1, Photo 5).
We observed improperly installed inlet protection (i.e., the inlet protection had a large gap in the middle, allowing materials such as trash and sediment to enter the inlet) (Appendix 1, Photos 67).
We observed blowable trash and building materials not properly contained (Appendix 1, Photo 8).
We observed uncontained stockpiles of sediment due to damaged or missing BMPs (Appendix 1, Photo 9).
We observed sections of missing or damaged erosion control blanket along the lots (Appendix 1, Photo 10).
Section IV - FOLLOW UP
The following information was received by the EPA after leaving the site on May 9, 2024: Upon request, a digital copy of the SWPPP, including an updated site map and inspection reports were emailed by Mr. Jeremy Boucher (Stormwater Consultant with EnviroServe) on May 17, 2024. No areas of concern were noted upon reviewing the provided documentation.
Section V - LIST OF APPENDICES
Appendix 1 - Photo Log - 10 photos taken on 5/9/2024
5
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
Appendix 1 Photograph Log
6
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 1
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney
County: Collin
State: TX
Description: Evidence of a sediment discharge at the outfall immediately east of the site near the intersection of Outpost Trail and Marilanda Road. Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Sharron Crayton
7
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 2
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney
County: Collin
State: TX
Description: Site maps and the Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) provided by the construction manager Mr. Giddens for phase 2 of construction. Mr. Giddens was unable to provide the SWPPP, site maps, and inspection reports for Phase 1 at the time of inspection. The phase 1 documentation was obtained digitally from environmental consultant Mr. Boucher on 5/17/2024.
Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Destinee Agwuna
8
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 3
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney
County: Collin
State: TX
Description: Section of damaged silt fence and worn erosion control blanket along Wyler Drive. Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Sharron Crayton
9
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 4
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney
County: Collin
State: TX
Description: Zoomed in photo of the damaged section of silt fence and worn erosion control blanket along Wyler Drive. Also picture is evidence of sediment discharged from the lot onto the street/MS4 near the curb. Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Sharron Crayton
10
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 5
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney
County: Collin
State: TX
Description: Ineffective BMPs on Eddington Drive allowing sediment to discharge from the lot onto the sidewalk and street near the intersection of Wyler Drive and Eddington Drive. Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Sharron Crayton
11
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 6
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney
County: Collin
State: TX
Description: Inlet protection on Eddington Drive with a large gap in the middle. Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Sharron Crayton
12
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 7
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney
County: Collin
State: TX
Description: Additional photo demonstrating the large gap in the inlet protection on Eddington Drive, allowing for debris and other materials to enter the inlet. Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Sharron Crayton
13
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 8
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney
County: Collin
State: TX
Description: Building materials and blowable trash (i.e., plastic water bottles and beer cans) discarded directly on a lot on Eddington Drive. No permanent or temporary trash bins was observed at the time of inspection. Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Sharron Crayton
14
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 9
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney TX
County: Collin
State:
Description: Uncontained stockpile of sediment on Eddington Drive. The pictured erosion control blanket is worn and not in effective operating condition. Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Sharron Crayton
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 15
Tri Pointe Homes DFW, LLC / Painted Tree Permit #: TXR1582KY
Inspection Date: 05/09/2024
Appendix 1: Photograph Log
Photo no. 10
Location: Northwest of Taylor Burk Drive and Painted Trail Drive
City: McKinney
County: Collin
State: TX
Description: Missing section of erosion control blanket along a lot on Eddington Drive, near an inlet. The inlet protection is full of sediment. Date of Photo: 05/09/2024 Photographer: Sharron Crayton
16