Document pOaKXG2QE9jx265wV0QbQqzE

FILE NAME: CertainTeed (CERT) DATE: 1972 Mar 16 DOC#: CERT017 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: OSHA Hearing 09/04/01 15:30 FAI 202 693 164 TECH. DATA CNTR. U S D eoartm ent o f Labor F Occupational Safety and Health Administration Washington, D.C. 20210 Heply to the Attention of: .S. Department of Labor/OSHA Technical Data Center 200 Constitution Avenue, 3STW Room N2625 Washington, DC 20210 TEL (202) 693-2350 FAX (202) 693-1648 l 001 THIS COVER SHEET IS FOR THE TRANSMITTAL OF FAX MESSAGES ONLY. FAX PHONE NUM BER:. H i d W Q 1 3 (>8________________ tq: b r. & & rr\f ( L a & ile g m a n B E ( a itM f i 3 / / ^ / ? 7 qL 'T esh n .m 'J / / 3 3 4 J^shestas~ FROM :. h o c k e jt ___________________ i / J i l l IfW i i \\Q ic i C a f j T ddacj I____________________ THIS TRANSMITTAL CONSISTS OF / / PAGE(S), INCLUDING THE COVER SHEET. If for any reason yon do not receive all of the page(s), please call (202) 693-2350. Castleman.CERT000072 09/04/01 15:30 FAI 202 693 1648 TECH. DATA CNTR. 002 221 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LAEOA WASHINGTON, D.C. K In the Matter of: STANDARD FOR EXPOSURE To PROPOSED BULB MAKING ASBESTOS DUST, ; k : PUBLIC HEARING * D X -3 H o 'iU Cooferenoe Room B Interdepartmental Auditorium 13th Ss constitution Ave., N,W. Washington, B.C, Thursday, March 16, 1972 The a b o v e -e n title d m atter came on fo r fu rth er hearing, pursuant to r e c e s s , a t 9*00 o 'c lo ck , s . m . , Thursday, March 15-, 1972. BEFORE: ARTHUR M. GOLDBERG, Hearing Examiner * AFFEARHCES: { As heretofore noted.) Castleman.CERT000073 09/04/01 15:31 FAI 202 693 1648 TECH. DATA CNTR. a 003 A* *'BEST AVAILABLE COPY con.SN fs STATEMENT OFi -? ,1 PAOE - Mr, J ,3. Jobe, ' Executive Vice P rsident, Johns-Manaylile Corporation.. SSS J . ' . Dr. Thomas H. Davidson, , .Corporate Medical D irector, Johns-Knville Corporation . ,29h Mr. 3 M, Penner, , D irector of Environmental Control, . JoDnB-Maijville Corporation . 301 Dr, Fred L, Fundsack,. ' , Vice P resident, .. . . ' - Johns-Manvills Corporation. , 306 Dr. Kingsley Key, * : Ph. D ,, U niversity o f Toronto . 370 _ James V, Sawlin g s , ' . v `v ; ' Vice-President, . V .. .Mining and Metals,, D ivision... Onion Carbide Corporation'.' 376 Dr. Horbert F-oberts., How VorV C ity , Ken York . ( . 38? )/&.. 3P. Lasmon, Vice P resident, . Rational A f i & i . e o d Products Corporation, V diey Porge,. Pennjyl'rani.a 391 Jo geoh G. S a li, : ' Vico Prpo rient, CAP Corporation ' a B uilding and In d u s tria l Products Gi-oup 399 E* A. DiSalvo, . Vice P resid en t, panacoa Corpoi'a tio n 40? e u b m 1i - Ite. 13 353 Na. M 36? .No. IJ5 392 N. h i 3C4 N, hp 321 J Castleman.CERT000074 09/04/01 15:31 FAI 202 693 1648 TECH. DATA CNTR. l 004 .. _ * . i 60 1LL0 ?SLE -.DOCUMENT ` ` 392 ;_ ; 1 . ; . MU lEAHM!? I am B, F,, lea cran, Vice I^onldeat fot National Afcrcf Certaitir.oad Stoc-uct a,, Valley Forgo,Pontinyl- 3 vnaia. 4 ' /. " : ;_ . ` ; . Beiore eupnttvir.3 ny got reoearka, X oould lik e to 5 praaent-"Wliich X liave disais fo r the record inT Inpliaete tha * uritfcoa viens rS ny oer-tae? on th e prepend ei&ndnrd for " ' , 4 . , ' ' . _ J , ' '. ' t ' 7 espesare to a sta s son''fast. . . .' . v ` 3I&IXfiI?. GGlEH&G: He o il! mark tha-.snbmicaica 9 o f. Cer^isVceed Csoeny ca exhibit 45 And i t is received* . (In h ib it 45. is nfcnd in evidence. ,. . . *' " . ,, *1 ; * . ' ' ' . .. . T . s * I S . iSN; Cesfcinteed Sfedncrs Corecretien ' '' .* ` - *' 1` * ia ia a diversified sm iSactracr cS Q a ^ i t rcofr.?, g il'cag i^a ... - ` i, , ' .'.'i. is iksa irfcioao, pelyvinyi fin e rid a, pise. sS' c id ia ^ tiU i o o rk ;--* u empatias aricatos chsnt pipe cr o t W tena in b- \ iP aiUdrs *>?::.na;?i i;* c f * - . - , . . - . . - t 'its: ' i - r-nr.i'ikr.a,.; &ne -'vkjitetlcs l-ii.vier; r-s e ria ie ce-i- " . , ... ,. . , . . . . . 17 rrndaotfca in vrio oaafcino avouai tto . eeuxtty, Cv.:.z ' . ^ , 1 '` * , . * ' i i'JL &5> rJJJLlrr.; "hs ug e f iic --v `;v: ; - . . . . r 1 1 .- - . y_7.7 io .M cha jr/.^'.tiSiK.'OK aubilitas .c.::;: " Vhi . [ ?-*-! i' *'k " *'V V: *T* *.Tii*.*ll ^*%''.'**1*_rP^^I1; I * I!' J r,i \ \ w: : i \:'Z> . ' ' " ' ' ! b . mm i * ||< M f Wt * .i >4 4*1 fih.. I'haiifl f M ] U V fi ^taKtlalt'Vnra I*.'. " ^ *. ++ 1 i:?.'./-* ^ mni .1 y *. >, - - - '! %|%- ' * a *< - t iijj cei.aeLr:- f* !i . mm S i1. ' i r'r.n.l a rn i a ; c c e : `u;-n m * * * , % r . " 4 I * ^1 gJj *m .V1 * <1 m -*b > r- !! VI . f l ^ a p * | B > im w%<T m H ! < ' * P < * \ * ' * I < N<( I|1 'yr' I . . ti te v |.V 'r * !** i " J J4* ' I ' *r i I Castleman.CERT000075 09/04/01 15:31 FAI 202 693 1648 TECH. DATA CNTR. @005 1. _ I :: " - " . 393 . r ' 61 ` . . In th e rltto ti v itan you jU fin d a d eta ile d z attaJLysia ca ilio eiiicfc on Corfcafct'iisd, i - a , esyloyi end I 3. jsihile ., comiooo b the p ^ r a ls e tip n o too hekch a tendard ' .4 ,b y 'Cha Aaboi* taparCitant wi a re req u retl to terniaafce our ' - i '' . 1 - * . 5 asbaotoa cH&at p ia ciiftiA ea^ia^ busneco. * V ; . ' ' " . ' , , ' .* . 6 X uso id ilici to hihilsl:: esc e. fe: f t i n a ts tin h z m I 3. u; ; 0- 7 tin s t h a t sto in nrjcli Erpete:: d e ta il in th e d r i t t o rijpqst a- l .3 i t g'sswH be uacecoitay to c u r t a i l jt;osiitio3 and 3. f o t goce B cat tif she ti-sioeoa oS ircrw fh a m ic s ' Sabeatea c cm n t p ip s, 0 th e p ress p r o f it ould ac e o ^ Ie ta Z y la s t to tb s eorAsny* lt obvic.-j.ly. , ' . ... . 13 jn.viMta lia c i it i o a ;v.chir.25.'y and nqnipsaat "ifciie ,ths , - cncer. a t&feni w rite o ff no fchit .. . . , KH 4 r t^ r *1: :\v y/cJn-A ia r.-Kr-'.for any r/r cS -iS j.-.-JH'.rV.-.'.i.v rtrfjy * i v t^ i-r ld -V-iiy "y ' .) i* . ' ' EtCl'l 3 `M'J.y vir the -r*.rovai cstj- - :' . / ' . &I i! " I1 4 -" . ' . ` '. . ' . .. ' a av-'aaanVii-it;'. 2sa.z-r.v auildii'^ ia\n. i3 -v.'J-t'j-.i - :::! - ; r t ' rirpsio of t / w sr-acvi r.n: bock \k:::v'*"v-?b l*o rrtw ^ ro i o-ki: *a iter.ita' a? j Z\ |] <*' i!... 11 *'* i' 1 'Sf y. . - . ;. : . ; : ; `; . . yt: "'a c, ' o::; vsrr'`':r..*:'..vi rnc e.h" r-.'.nsnq.y " ^ .4 ` < * -1 A * . 4.-* - t * , . '.": C . v - 4|> ' 1 m i ; ti r * -1 * ~ ,, * . 1; - ' (*t * '!* i t `h 'b M * * * . . I _ - . ; |/>> M 1 - '' * ' I- *u- ' . f * , k .%! ir < . ! * ai 4 *1 "i! t1t Castleman.CERT000076 09/04/01 15:31 FAX 202 693 1648 TECH. DATA CNTR. @006 Il l e g i b l e d o c u m e n t 62 1 2 . . ' . 39^, v Fos fin is hod ceccnt pipa inventory, oia oreaeaum liis ' ',{*'** . -, ' / ' ' ; * 1. ` > ` a 25 per coat lose, oji flhtafca! jex in -proseas inventory.. Tbo 3 p ro fit'-lo ss fre e cawoct.os corone pipa operations rcuid be . . 4 Bftsswbot reduced from the coepony* s standpoint ;dsa lio Sfco 5 cosoonoadSeg rcducSicas la sdiifcicnrJ. opor^lias and, .. . ' .6 7 choro&ce ta pearocnac, , . 'She e ff este dtaeiscosd above-eco be dolSorisSif. 6 es foioto; -, ' %' ' ' 9 , ' 1 Xhe pat oob.t vaina of oor asbestos corset p ija ' to 'o r ftta S 26 s illic o doH ora. noKpui ennmz a -toco ip is e f " , . . ,* . . . . ,i 11 sa ofi li^SS/OD, Tha ;c;e o ?eopis sad ' 2 nesso 13 1i 1 la cs33ia r 5a3 tike e ffe c t o e sSfitdofia of ckkkss;.. 14 fco cessas v-5.p eparatfos aa . .. * ; ' ' .' -snd rasgos sre te re ' ., '.. 5 t3 tt e ra*-:aE#iMd ar- foi* the previoa;: c ' , . . 1* * , - 1 ` ; 15 sr.iaa&tar- ,. ' ' , . .. ..' ' J ' , ' . , < 17 u Ouhvr -ZC.llii -* Ow* - 1 U&sctc? 90Pt rlrat civejaos'; eli, cf r.cbar^a oc:" i : J ! --jjzizd- ..rei a l i s-tli-a . i ! T; pet: ;'.:-.s nf . 1 j , 1 s . >1 I r . Vli1*' I -c!>? JT ^i' Tf. , #* V. ri . . i t?`*k- *" *.1-*| "', r ` }*.' '**""'i*JLi.> .* V* i1** '`'I- * .'I*- ti i*t> * |f. - >m l-f i i I , t * I V* ^r +t' l '/ < a <1 l,,t ' ' *r- ;.o..: ;:s: -if l r'X2 - r /v .^ a a - -:= W i ^ i:i.!. J SVf?. O . -'b-* , ;.:ie ; ; y? :v.;;;.C `f o ir: ' !t V**t Castleman.CERT000077 09/04/01 15:32 FAI 202 693 1648 TECH. DATA CNTR. 1^1007 63 1 .2 a v ' Xurgast employac 3?5 . .. coim nity. AH paoplo dSsalased feo ouj? pay coll* tf'lth alios? cwtalfitsy souId ha added to ttbo inieopAOTssBBt SAfece eolla tto se edsauaitilco.. r * 3 ' Thtodiy, CU o2 ahaetiLos .w' oa oad othac ceeiiaf-isats. ' Ife aisid aboafi $30 n lillo a a yeaci I bm ' 6 4$&vaPi.1 j . 7 I . 6 g 9 3 10 !1 12. Q .13 to oapplSiCS csaCi. ijrclaiiliis idso. idtc'jsfrsi Cw--oa* . -b - pcaaro to be a c^ .e009ft& ' t h a t . 30 ptoflle eaoid , fc . ' ... * t. . , , t e W . <* '* " . / bo tsses&' rot c cotfS: by ova vaaioca end '!ez#1web._ . . , EcaaEiy iqjoctotit a 3&roS9 v1eS)1.entocpciss ' bsvtog OD9333Sd 0.877C33 Sa i!o&2Ct& 2=3rca fcaasa . . ' . '' 4 ' '*,*_ * i ->v- V' . rj^ia $3JES0 Ji; l-Jisl ** >??.e 3 z t 5- * . - '. ,vl>A beofcKoa * sm a tiK * fitfcSaa at 5 ^ oae'*w w ft. ficfecaUy raba^iaiog c v b -^ 3 $ i4 - 4 U.-'ca taoc. 3a 1r.xir.2C3 ss;; 25^7 ynaa:a are;?Ajr, to -rcapsT:" ; . . 5 5 shoe i t s ^h5"ij-ctri 7.5"-^.%. j^t*xr3v:Ci 7.2 7.'a Id lia 0 C e i- tr k c ^ r s .6 *-.,;ov tez^Ssa'ir&Sj&az ssd fihi ;`"br, a.-.* m i? `r^c.be'-ti^csETSci ;-: '303^X4:?.sa ficic ta ci 1.x-j ri.yX Ci-t*./.i *s - / c r*?r-fc^3r *.j s . ^ 7 . ' i a * - r iv s v 2 > t : && & ?--"*' ."' ' 1 . , ' ' ' . 1,1 *;:?":: *-l .a i-hvi . . * ' ' &. -i . iI : : .-.... y ,, - ;.v rr.v ;:: ': 1 : ".a*. ' . ' ' . I , . . ** * * ' " ** *' * ' ' . - . . m , t .* : t - , , i *Li ; i * ..7 ,, B , , * _.i. ,> '* i^ r - *^ i**. ' w *r **. . .'.l'a .,` ,, i- I. '. ' N i t ! a !i '* r '* i*i -1- *1I Il 1 4 I .1 - ** 1 .1 . i m A - 'i >. **'< *, . I `W h * . - . m i ." i 1 " * * * '' . **. Castleman.CERT000078 09/04/01 15:32 FAI 202 693 1648 TECH. DATA CNTR. l 008 V , ' .. ... 396 ' : 64 1 . ( 0a have -meda seca sotish calculations cs fio th . ; z cosi: o ecapllenoe with ubo propo3ed EUC3ircl ahi: Ai'/ifiory , 3 . Ctireatii:<t9 ?apo?fi. Keapins n aiad (a fi caca pisafi has , . , 4 certain potklis- piraV.icza a l i lea owa, i t ia oae heat flfiitafie .5, fthct egt^iisaco Tilth the prtjbstid fiai&s 1.11 rasiiAt^ Sa on 6 c.TCrsa pcffl-pinrtt eiipar-dJ.tiira o i ^COjCOO o* with oSk . 7 picifiSj a t e t t i e d i t a i -i?csc^2nt o 91#2p5,C03a . ' i . *, .<'. 1 i 8 . .freaififcii fihio aapstttditCEa $e vie? t Icsst. 9 ..fifctea sesafiiaia zLth&i kiv piaafce fcaafc nnss th e Siva iihsz. IO ceofc i?ial sfiqcicG fifct apioysa cafcrciag tua ob to .cesar 0 ! a rsar& ^toy- ta addition, tMo. issa flpfi a stia sse tho . a n ojaitatir-s co st th a t ottH bo li* zc cOviicfios .fibs paossisEV a i fihs ra.^j;'.*:oa^a c*S fiS:3 , `ASrSc'csjy OCOTlfifiai m aatiriafie sit espir* W S . &y 'BEtl 13 -tefc; fiati: r e n t e d as:*.* Sia :gs20-sea.-atsacai# 3w, 15 J L J ' 'O . r^.r f..i cjiih. fio e?"-lisin a ::Lc-ia& afisrr.ji.v , Z.ivt r de t t e t tlissi p fissi th a t c.vtasS&fc'fifct' - ' . ' m 4 . , i , p p f { f T . . , , ! . . . t p ,1, . T>.^ #' * n $ H ., > W ' r ^ ^ V j ^ T # .rv^'tl {".< ^ *" V * * i * l* li ^ H i P* M * . . i / l -- , J *.! ;<4 < NlV'-M ;/ I -i-'U HhP" *- l*L - 4 + 4 H iT t* .1-- I j ^ -- l *' . I j-* v * *m **l m ,Ww k * 2 !.. .-- 'I ! r r 1! . % r - J.H ' - , .' V * I* * i i *- -' " i f t t * i r-i V - I r H* T . A ,Ji > -* m * '* T * ' A T j L ** li <,.>/ t A > '4 1 1 f i i Am * i n t u iJt > UIIBIMU 'M * Castleman.CERT000079 09/04/01 15:32 FAI 202 693 1648 TECH. DATA CNTR. @009 I'} 65 z. H '' m 3' Uo. tu a GEI m - t. ;! . ,, ' M '397 / t*. 1 , ' `' . , I ' ... ' * ` '1 . ** *.`' t - ' i proposed standard which in se t fo rth in th m itte n materi&JL ; ..." . . ' > I adopts cany e> eha poatitui capoucodby thaA dviacry . . i ' I * 3 Cp3aittG3 rapCUj 3y om* peoposad standard, we era eubrriteir. 'A. Carttaiptaed to coat o2 tb s esps^dStwres se t iosfh bovo. 5 *' csfc - th a t tbo labr P e^C g q at nat <5 ' o .ctejsislcs going 1*0 e to->2iGr a Cani sed and thisrcwy *" I .* ` 1. " 1 ` ' B! 1 *. , * t . 7 ioarense these cuate to hat csy be au intoiexifcia Ltnat,. 9 Cettiafcssd io c .d iv ersified a s c ^ .e flra r snd ora? kj^ oesoI: 9 t i i t a c t cabale c a p ita l fund to ese scsnsat o cu t tasi ses . , ` >i * i 1 10 to the a te te iS 2 otfcc aesaena e ear business etxaps&dn;? . .11 fiar the etffi CnlSuzz iS Sha <nig*d&tci:e3 esa not te jicae^e^-j 12 aad cay not ci'ss preascroe fcfce l t t&gfr dfcrip&zu] 13 Z toare So cff-7 dosbt bo;. the f te ra ,o ocrant . * . * . 1 i 14 ra?/i?,csisi; vSltrttQ to.i7CT d0, ; ' ' . :- 15 , Gin.* bas drd&stc i t w l ac-sfJA- *'3. 3 io lir r a nsceaas te cn^incer. to u &fri 17 .arfient tVj,t i;: frs:.lTv:.c;;icaiiy enuL3 bc ceso .Shoy hssre... 1V*f` icaaidsra;?. k>t uot c rc a ittc . *&a-,a s s a r t- ic e .'c. .ixp.te*'-. ' 1 * * ' . ' * . . 13 i tUr; o t ^ r d - i a s&'.sfc.fcaa 5f.':a. ' ' ' ' ; 23 1 t iTtrffS^s '* ; iv.tctC'o s fa itirr, fa:;. fi Ij ji'1.!".i ,;1a1*i'A>llavr>*'v. C'aaa'-..*a.t...ua. a**2*`"*/.a i? -a'-a'-,>.rutrPrf.' ..'*T%<<*". .*..2 T"'*r""*1*r* !*' `-, I j i j* . ; *K~i'*va*~.'f, ~ ?,'-'..* I . 1Ii . I " . . . . . . ... 1 ` V ' . : . || 0,1- V ' 'Vil/,"'! .` -*v 'i C'.:i* . ' 1 . ' . . ]| . rrF;:^ :!:. I t-w-nss'i .*i> .ivii-; ' 1 . t l I . Castleman.CERT000080 09/04/01 15:33 FAI 202 693 1648 TECH. DATA CNTR. l 010 ILi-'EGIBUe DOCUMENT 39 66 ttanBdioQion oculd Ipuosdia&al iir.M 1C unsalable* \ 'i - 2 , MwSclpit'JLGs oebjcct: to p l i t l c ! preoaoraB eoa.ld 3 nct Cato' a eh-iaca cu o p i'o& ct so itfaeiod. ^Iiaro is .no, A evidente tbjfi .lnsaaion o cs'ijaoucic t:ar iri cay tccy io , s panSai. foTsaytsr, c l l V.: to pahHc nnd cha pujlic ,ocQr.' 0 a l l ac aln Clwy coa Cha labo- ,o;Cha,oad 'caraoc'1 ecj , \ , 7 Sha "H-3aSjalt o.fy> w $;d ej, ' . . a . Ehstss, Sn cbcstcs pipa ceasn: cha Qcaaacc . 9 is. fccnaid. nCo tho pjofiuoc cn5 jtiso afee? leavins &a .pisas : to i t occisa cara t'nzi c 'i tc i a d e s i s t o Jtsei. the pipe .la ;. vi ' . cnoh, c, ` . . ` .- . * ac. to- sha i 'tu c a c ia . - :. i . . t., . ', ,, 12 ` * * . ` * ,\ ' , -Wo cercciiy d so t ccsi-el B ita ftho oaSsai o 13 dinpDse o c r sonfsr locea cebestoo iiiara fcsc to nv 14 uoc i$%e s lies p at fa tea to toeaSy tona per <fey IS. FX&ecCeo a;o pisucio W.^s, , . . . . 16 . .IC oc ha tlcaa buc .mIZTI acsC asisl bs psohb:;f" .% I. .V t V fea i tactos caio? ai'Banco- leoaaitts sjhsbtos 1:- . ,, Jl . ; - ; - \ . "IjA.'rcc .v-`. !:c cce.l .nfi f a t^jahfij i? i? a la a U .h';y-t : t |iC,to ^*.V'::a 3r,^: bs #*. . * '' * i,". , * . 4 , . %. ---* . I ar'rh ay -itcl wtvAJ. painaot; ra ila'o*r-" . . , . ' ' . : ' ii . ` < .. . * . * / ' _ . , * ll'i ` " " * - <"/? T .%p ' i M-MiMfe S # J i y W ' m`*m" *1 . I ^ .. ; . ' (. 7 `1 ~ i*- ^ " ' m" " i' '** fl* * " * " '" `r - ^ ' a i M i i n i . * .t* * a TiVt F 1 * r * V 1, n m f ' " ,i * J "i " I a t .. _ . I / T"!,, i* .V/4 ,, u' ! * ***/-! *i* ~ 1 '.uI * j '. * ; * i **-,**+ . . * f. . a U. . .. i - , , 1 1 * bu i, f . i j , . , , . m jm A -i m . i V. VI - `; .i y * , . 7 ' J i ft! i m i . i .. ^#,\ r `-I i r . 'J V- ' V 1 " |, -!v' 's.^ . .... ` ` , n^2 ha1-'vt't.'d Lv 1 .. ' ] ' - & Castleman.CERT000081 Castleman.CERT000082 ILLEGUELE DOCUMENT * - ** , w S S . w i -- .8 *o o J tft te. w .* ' l I fi t I-.1 u >* Vi i-* '-J r: Cr ** i * * i- sti -M i !. V *1 <s i.i 1 : C5 * S- H i , * ~.*i 'A'2 Sl ti5. . 1 V ,* 7 *5 r -* " ' 13 U i :j TV fnrll. 1 TY il fcj ir e% a E3 a;- K S fa ' a Li ' ^ ' sV vt , j 2i- 'i w. "n * '.i;,i. i: i . ,a~ .A.% - 8 ' L1 `M . I? r? *, V. N-' *w;.. . V*' ! : n i i o O. a a : 6: r> t H 'S- (I . H e g *O . U 8 i a G* U , Ri b 'l o i? fi - % ` I f Vil '.IS fe & s :v O* M Ci rl M vt ? fl o ty . 1.1 Vil i.* ^R te ft ta va &gs 1 a sr; C* fi t* B1 8 S j U ti vmtnm ^ts _r- n En & B a. v gn sta-. * -. 'O f E rUi; cr a O & iO* & n- fn* ; .f-- w I'S Prt i et B r s g a. Pi rrt- us f* g O .J O ct* s rIOsos & os 0D SO m o s O JT .j`r / Castleman.CERT000083