Document oeEpk7q03BYyXwqN7ezLOdxJX

From: Devin Watkins [Devin.Watkins@cei.org] ent: 2/11/2025 5:31:33 PM o: Amidon, Eric [Amidon.Eric@epa.gov] ubject:Fw: 22-1032 Competitive Enterprise Institute, et al v. EPA "Response to Motion Filed" (EPA-86FR74434) Caution: This email originated from outside EPA, please exercise additional caution when deciding whether to open attachments or click on provided links. Dear Mr. Amidon, I represent a party adverse to the EPA. As chief of staff, I thought you might wish to be aware of the below email, if your not already. Sincerely, Devin Watkins Competitive Enterprise Institute 1310 L St. N.W., 7th Floor Washington, DC 20005 202-331-2278 From: Devin Watkins <Devin.Watkins@cei.org> Sent: Friday, February 7, 2025 9:38 AM To: daniel.dertke@usdoj.gov <daniel.dertke@usdoj.gov>; sue.chen@usdoj.gov <sue.chen@usdoj.gov> Cc: Zeldin.Lee@epa.gov <Zeldin.Lee@epa.gov> Subject: Re: 22-1032 Competitive Enterprise Institute, et al v. EPA "Response to Motion Filed" (EPA-86FR74434) Dear Counsel and EPA, The only opposing petitioners in Texas v. EPA (which challenging EPA's auto emission rules) to the motion to hold in abeyance have made clear in their response that they do not oppose abeyance if EPA indicates that it intends to reconsider the lawfulness of EPA issuing fleet-wide average (rather than per-vehicle) automobile emission standards and its authority to allow credit trading. If the government wishes this case to be held in abeyance, you may wish to decide quickly if EPA wishes to reconsider this legal authority in its upcoming auto emission rulemaking process. This, of course, would not determine the outcome of such reconsideration. Sincerely, Devin Watkins Competitive Enterprise Institute 1310 L St. N.W., 7th Floor Washington, DC 20005 202-331-2278 Sierra Club FOIA Request: 2025-EPA-04193 ED_018475D_00000810-00001 SC_EVERSPLIT0007060 From: ecfnoticing@cadc.uscourts.gov <ecfnoticing@cadc.uscourts.gov> Sent: Friday, February 7, 2025 9:23 AM To: Devin Watkins <Devin.Watkins@cei.org> Subject: 22-1032 Competitive Enterprise Institute, et al v. EPA "Response to Motion Filed" (EPA-86FR74434) TE TO PUBLIC ACCESS USERS' Judicial Conference of the United States policy. permit attorneys of record and parlit i ng pro Igal is) t0 ele tr nk copy of do uments filed tronicBy, if recp required by law or dir ct d by th fikr. PACER c s I...to all other users. to avoid later chare.download copy of each dnent during this first " United States Court of Appals for District of Columbia Circuit Notice of Docket Activ'IR 11ng 1ction 07ift7/2025 02i7(202s 9;.22;59.AM kSt 'Indard Ti11Iilcd ,n Case Name: Competitive Enterprise Institute, et al v. EPA Case Number: 22-1032 Document(s): Document(s) ocILet: iSPONSE IN OPP -HON [2t,M3621 t(to hold casc in abcv nc [2099305.2] filcd by Anthony Kreucher, Compet tive tcrp ise InsDomctic y Piancc Mare Scriber, Waiter M. Kr oclir nd J in 22032 Is rviD lc: 02 071{12025 by CM/ECF NDA] Length Criif]Alion: 633 words. [22-1032, 22-103L 22-1033. 2203-1.22-1036+ 223Watki . } Nofsvilelectronicath. mai1to Deboh A_ Sivas: dsiv1du, !ff-e Mr, Scott Lawr:ricc Nciso.n: sn 1scitilicnuor La U7cm trtk7. C veTLQF Cluistophcr Gene Ki4 ssistant Corporation Couns.L c...1 \C ' Alphon Michael All:ino; b:rnai.t .,t)n cwt bm 1we MrL James K. N'mcs: j ncssims nkLcomrs msfunkL.cont,, sthnktorn, farnw cirn srn. _ _ Nli-, J m Emory Smith, Jr,i AAttorny Gcnerl 1Ihia.,,cs 1 Mr. Carter -Glasgow s: cphillidley.com, Itran(ni!sidley,com. nyetiling'ksidlcycorn. gnoticela sidiey4m. c rter-phil lips-4rpro.ci Rotha Ifle Mary Dcutsch. Attorney! rdcitsch4Ocutschhont.corn+ ruthanncLdCtitschgntailLcom. midtitawgeorgctowwcdii.dlrf.i*dcchhunt,com Danic..1 RdarneldcrikIv Msu Ann Brewster Wks Senior Counselawck 1+,1jchaemin Schon Attorn-Q,:mihotlier.corn. mke-schon-2330rri,icpacerprcl-frn Rafe P tcp t; rafc.pc-5rif4]liklawcorn kinth rihompson(g:hklaw,com Mr. John ravincsO'Q johnoqrnnnik1andcorn Joantic M Sp&luting: jortnne_spaldirrgIra.srtadeb.org. davirl-ahe ierraclub.org Scan H. D3rtaltic: seanr..-,:i,dondbCrZ1 C Erie Philip Gc tt, n ehlaw.com pa4i2atn lia'khlaw.com Mr. NI ittliew J. SintIcr : mthwjsnd1brdWn. anslanford,edu Mr. Willi nt . Granthm. Assi ta Attomcy Gen rat: rgranthin4nrudokgov. rga: `4.,nntdosi.go 1 t)990047090094ChigarLgOlrilMaTch4WiRi.H' *Pfl.g )V Sierra Club FOIA Request: 2025-EPA-04193 ED_018475D_00000810-00002 SC_EVERSPLIT0007061 Stuart A. Drake: stuart.drakeAirkland.corn Ms. Eli abethWydra, Chief Counsel: EizabettO'theiisc0nstittition.org Mr, Toms Ryan McCarthy, Attorncy; tom consoYoyrncarthy.com Ms. Vickie Lynn Patton: ipatton(kedliorg Mr David I)-DCAAirtsehddonitter(a.nrde.org Mr, Patrick J. Morrisey:patnckumoffiseyAvvvago,gov Robb William Kapla. Attorney: robblapla(ii:!sicityatry.org, lauren.skcP f . MsHyland HuntAttorncy; schhtint,com Ms.. Vera P. Pardee: pardeelaw.namaddie,lipscombsierraclub.org Stacey ..y nn VatiBelleghern: t_ eY.VanBelleOcrinklw-corn, staeey-varilv.Ileghcm-36lecf.paC W i-litiIL!-a:!kx1pact,.-1-pro.corn i1i ii Attomc'-, org Mr. Ski(iH :Al n Keller: scot ...Li , Kyin James .Poioncarz, Attorney: kpoloneark: i.-covcorn Mr. Scott Normon W1L?. AtLint Attorney Gem ra scott.kosc.hwitzriic g o v Mr. Oa 'it:Gerairin y McCabe, Denoty orney Geneta g, tbef Margaret.:Elai.neMeckenstock: Elaine.Meckens.toekAdoj,ca.gov. david,landriidoj.ca,gor, debra.baldWin.doj.ca.gov Mr, PauI Andrew Gal i ahtin; pauLgarrahaoregon,goy Samara Lackman Kline: skliklincappeltccom MiaSi-ramie, Assistant Attorney General: mich.ael.strandemarylatid.gov Ian Fein: ifeilyiTtnrdc,org, rseditt6iinrdeLorg Ms. Lisa Jo Morelli: lisa.moi cLi.J doi.lps atc_rij.us ... ... Mr, JonhaAndrew BcnY ib rt1},lengray,com Seth GardnerSchofield. Assistant Attorney General: seth,schoficld;J:rnass.gov. epdetiling:s,:P.rnass. gOV Slie Se Chen, Trial Attorney: L'.ll11.1'.ehL d{H . O \' ..t1eds .! . did,gov Mr, 1Gc aCour, Jr,: odmand,Ic 1 k c vatd!r abarnaag,g Scott Steinbr !cher, Assistant Attorney General: scon.steinbrc :"s rate.co.us, Sitzanne.burdickstate.co.us A.ndita andreaisaotiOsierracluberg Patrick Fr ncis . easy: patrick,Yeasykstoel,com Michel Bw ger, Attorney: mburgenAlaw.eolumbia.edu Ms. Brittany NI, Pemberion, Attorneybrittanypembertonbr xwell,com, mesa,botts,3-efa bract1,corn Robert Alt: robertbuckeyeinstitute.org Matthew winnzninsrnwla _e. rTi, breckenridtzaw.com, obalagopahlu,,,:a,!t3rn\vtaw..Qt)rn Ms. Briannc Jenna Gored; briarmci)nst it i cli,.abcthAthcitscenstilationorg, brian4thensconstitution.org. mirianI:..heusconstitution.orgsmitailhensconstitution.org, aletheuseenstitwion.org Mr, Joshua Aries Berman, Senior Attorney josh ,bcimaniAsierrachuh.org james A. Hamc james.bartat:atg.i.gov, katherinejacoh0-in.gov, Jonna.andersonOi:atg.in.goV Alice Henderson; ahenderson{cdforg C . Van Zile, Deputy Solicitor General: caroline, van.7ilo:4,.de,gov. osg.ei ilintakeAdc.gov (i1 Len: greeir, cr1a{di1.brig, ahellwen:a:el florg Mr.ew 'k)rrison. nbc.1I!Isbur .1ncciI Isbo1corn Mr. Danieljacob Feith, Attorney: dtcithsidley.com, cfilingnotic I:a.! idley..com. da-ferth- 2962 f4:eetpacetpro.eoin Mr. Asher Paris Spiller Assistant Attorney General: aspillerCO!ncdoj.gov, pajonesr doj.gol,P Mrs_ Elizabeth Baker Murrill, Assistant Attorney General: murrille{itag_louisiana,goy. nclsone@ag.euisiana.gev, inotickts*:a . .v Mr. Devin Watkins: devin.atkinsC!:cei.org, devin_97035,1yahoo.com Mr. Frank a Garrison, Attorney: trriso4!pacitieleeal.orn,, ineomingli dorg Devin O'Connor: devin. connor@lve.com,.devin.-oconnor-4608erpro.com, washinon-dc...litigation. Sierra Club FOIA Request: 2025-EPA-04193 ED_018475D_00000810-00003 SC_EVERSPLIT0007062 se i 5 :..f,paet-rpret.C-43111 Joshua Diyinc, Assistant Attomev General: Josh.Di n artuny_g to.gov. diana_haines(41ago,rtio,go Mr. Matthew Franklin matt_kuhntjkys selina.howniaw'riiky.gov Christian Brian Corrigan, ehristian.eorrigan(krnt.gew, ?ylat-thew Ireland, Assistant Attorney matthewirelandAmass.gor 1%,I, rs_ Heidi Parry Stem, Solieitor f!t)v, rearreaui:riagalv_gov, karms riEure./ ZOV, adN,:`nsi,;-k I Mr, Galte Johnson.Karp. johnsorikarpg:4!doi,stute.wi.us, hane oldSr[..q,d,i)j,state vR,11. r. [?ulan iLlebbS, Assistant Solieitor General, dylan.jaeoh arkansasai,,,gov. kel ie.hudsciti gtarkaiisag. Mr, Christopher Hiiriaux Reiti. Assistant Allorney General; cliris,reiti atg,wagoN,, ceyolyel-ihatg_wa_gov, nith_wilsonrer': Peter Surdii, Assistant Attomey General, poter. urdorii,!ag.state.mn.us, eatiterine_ri( - keating(itn, g_state,mit,us, kelly,plet ag,stute,ntn.lis Gillian \Vener, Assistant Attornev General:. ,rniehigan.gt gittsonj16i rnicliigan_gov Brian. Rene Fraielle: Theodore NAcCombs: Theodore r,i;!doj,,eu,,gov, juanilorensgg doj_ca_gov Mr. RLihert iMichaels: rtniehaels2,irr,cipeorii, Mr, Nliehael James Bostrom: michael,Frostrotri laktity,or,g,, david,torre-. :ietty_org, dan Edward...James Ciorman, Senior tinga-hon Anorney: edward,gomilarrit:deL\ e, _r.,1 org, (4Z4.4.!1UCity org maxximilliari.ritesser(ii,!derivergov.org.,, shannoiteptii'& v,org, hita_christop.hr2r[a... janct,,`raldez@!denvergov,,org, stefanie.raph(kdenvergov Ms. Ann R_ Johnston, Sr. Deputy Attorney General: ajohnston(kattorneygeneral ov Theodore Larntri: theodore,larrirnifr/Stnail,cont Shelby Leigh Dyl: shelby,dylt4!pillsburylaw_com. dorkehrr.oillsburylaw,,eom Caitian L. Mel_oon, Dc puty Attorney General: eilitian_metoririfU:doj.easov Jeffrey B, Wall: walli(-4-sulicrorn,,eorn Micaela Harms,, Deputy Attorney General: niicaela,harms(ri!cloj.ea.gov Mr. NAichael B, Bitseb.hacher, mhuse-hhaehergit boyde,,rigray_eci 111.b.huschbati...,,-zmail_com Vanessa L, Kassab,Deputy Attorney Generul: vanessakassahi4delaware,gov, ian.listorifk,delaware.go zaehary.deitts(it!delitsvant.gov Mr. Robert Donald Swanson: robert,swarf-r,,-n ,gov Jessica Morton: Jinorton democracyforwarclorg, ect" ;!de ocracyfonvard,org Justin i.. ktathen)[, Solieitor: justin_rnathenyirij.ago.tins.griv, fonda.helleivi4!ago_rns. Nicholas M. rivaz@j:riag,ri,gov, rnspoonen@l:riag,ri_gov, acarnev le(Priag, Mr. Michael Ray vagosov, choffmaii{ii,wvagosor Ms. Mathura Sridharan: Niathura_SridharanguiOhioAGO.eov, joshita n Ms, Elinbeth Duhats: elizaheth,duhats(ri:::ilag,gr>v Mr. Lylc T_ Leonard, Deputy Assistarit Attorncy General, lyle t.leonard( haw Mr, Andrew Sa: astt@cdfort:, Mr, Martin Levy, Attorney: malev),t:ri,!cov.corn Mr. Wesley Scott wesley.williamsi'_ii,:eiaw,.texas.li,ov, du\ id.latirent(iioar!,.texassor Garrison Tdd: garrison,toddi:4alaska,gov, christina,fishcrt alaska,gov, anadela,gallego al 'a.gov Sarah Goetz: sgoetifitlidentoeraeyfonsard.org, goetzfftliau_org, eet'gri;demoe.raeyforward_org Stephartie lee iariii-,,,safiliAylselinies.org, Emma Akraw i, Assista ttorriey General: Emmia,Akrawii ;!maitie,,gov Mr. Max Sarinsky: max.sarinskyknyu.edu Sara A. Colangelo; sac.54-i4,,law,geort,gelown,edit, s' colangelegfdla orltelown,edu Morgan 1_, Rauter: rumermi sullcrom,eont ,,Mexandria K. Doolittle: alex.eloolittleatg.wa.gov, april.gerdtsi:aratg.wa.gov Ms, Jermi fer L, L4cc is: jetinifer,lew isti4!otig,ok,gov, maranda_spears@uag,ok,gov, doeketil4oatt,ok,gov Mr, Garry M. Gaskins, IL garry_gaskins(riXtag_ok.gov, mararida_spelarsi-4,oag_ok,,gov, doeket(Woug.ok,gov Sierra Club FOIA Request: 2025-EPA-04193 ED_018475D_00000810-00004 SC_EVERSPLIT0007063 Hannah Yindra: hannah vindrilii,vermont.R,O V Stanford Purser: spurserfkagutgoy, rauvaai Grant :SOW: grnt1stroh14incbra ka,gov Ff Jstein: sgoldsteinki'4a. tate.nid.us Thoma c try_ ical1cov.com Je my RoYAn$ky,..j.roz.ariskyrA!sidleyLcorn., jercmy.rozansky.80696*ecI paccrpro,com, dcefilingnoticct.:4:siley_cont Mr. John A. Sheehan, Attorneyjohn.shcehanfAcarthanilw.atergroup.com (daily summary) Jefisj .1 113arcifiy.-Strobel, Cf.9,1Set J-etist,ca.BatvlayStrobe.ii:!doica.gov, joyce.aguinst*dc3.gov (daily i'> Titrany Bates. Attornc:i - 4,corisovoyn1c-,_[[-thy.com Wady suuumuy'l Tim DtineontduncO1L1.c : ( . "I Notice will he stored in the notice cart for: Mr, David P41,1Wc,,-ndoINA- Orlin The following dcK unientlisi) are::.associateh this transaction: D,content Ciescripium Reonto Motion Filed Original Filename: Texas EfAosion to Abeyance vIpdf Electronic .Ctocunrit tit Starp: [STAMP acmrStampi11119186S23 1 2 [ jcNorntr=209.936.2,0] 19cd3bacbc1fia I 9d5cc2bf2.44d6Z!Eliac4 I c x2 f4a,3clkng94d757b I Oadfc8624351(0c94cflthh8 lacod .t5-01q1.1941:. 3Re511.5ah984 Sierra Club FOIA Request: 2025-EPA-04193 ED_018475D_00000810-00005 SC_EVERSPLIT0007064