Document oJEZ147YDQO20G8Mde9R0Lmw

FILE NAME: Westinghouse (WH) DATE: 0000 DOC#: WH092 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Clayton (Air Pollution and Industrial Health Consultants) Letter Describing Poor Industrial Hygiene and Working Conditions at Westinghouse (KORtitt D. C la y t o n & A s s o c ia t e s . In c -Ai FoujjTtoe AMO tnouttaiAi hiacth cowaoltaati <4129 tvotr oitworr *7 mch (0 4 t T) M u o n amo emrx*t i 4l Mr. ?att L T a t e l a P leat Maaagar Wcatiaghovac I l a c t r l c j t i K . a a t i l i , Ote1 C o rp a ra tla a Dear Mr. T v e c la : Qa r r i 4 a y , l t n k r 1 0 t h , M r. I . V . S y a l c h a r , 4 v l a - l a t r a t a r a t X a 4 a a c r l a l H yglaaa f a r eha W t i t l | k m l l e r l < C a r t a r a t ia i, *a4 tha v r l t a r r i i l t i f yaar ylaae ca avalaaca eha U T l r a a a a a t a l a a a 4 lt lo a a a f y aa r y l a a t , ca 4 * e ra ia a I f th a ra vara cay e g a a ta , hath p b y a la a l ca4 c h a a lc a l, which v a a l 4 a a c a a a e f a r eha r a a y l r a c a c y l l l a a a a a a w h ich hava aa~ * a r r a 4 aaiaagac y a a r a a p la y a a t . Va v a ra b r ia f a 4 aa eha kla t a r y a f eha 41aaaaa hy M r. V. 4 . l l c a h a y , l 4 a a t r i a l t a l a c l a a Caglaaar la yaar plaae. ta w lra a a a a ta l aaaylaa vara eahaa ca a a a a rta ls tha 4agraa a f c h a a l c a l y a l l a t l a a a y r a c c a e . 4 r a y a r t w i l l ha aae yaw c a a y l a t l a a a f eha a h a a ia a l a a ly a a a . With raayaae ta cha y h y c la a l agaata h a vave r, i a r l a g t a a a r a a a f cha l a v a a c i g a c l a a 1C waa r a a 4 i l y a y y a r a a c c h a t tha v a a c & la c la a l a y a a r y la a e vaa y a a a ly 4aalg aa4 aa4 v a ry la * a4 a g a a ta . Thar a vara a aa aaalva f v c l t i t a l r j I i m i N i t a a vaa y a a ri aa4 y a a y la jv a ra aahJaataM^ta^aaaaaap ly yaar a lr a a * t t a l c a a 4 l t l a * J 4 ^ 4 u 7 a a g h I a a a y U y c la la a '. i t la ay ha. 1 U ( t h a t th a v v a c& la ifta a l a cha y la a e a v a l 4 v a ry v a i l ha PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT - r - *1 . 1 : -4 .4 i .-j . > ' j r* ^ ''" y f > Ta: Mr. Paai Tattla Tou *111 a ta tk t a f ( k i M i i U i | f a r d a r a of " V a c la c ho d l a e a s a " aa t h a c c h a ra aa a a * d a a a a l a a t o r ) Chat cha r a p t o o f cha a p l o y a o s a r l a d . Tt 1 a y b a l i a f Chat Cha s t r a a a l y poer o r k t a g c a a d l t l o e co w h ich ch ap loya ara a b j ctd eould lo v a r t h a l r r a a ia c a a c a co ch* polar v h t n thy *14 ha r a a d l l y s a c c a p t l b l to oy palwg I r . Tha axhaacc o t lla c lo a la oiy * 4 t+ .t /t 4---ju--cX i ^ alaqaatai al achar placas aaay ^ ara la c a d o s aa co a p la ea ly la- ' * **- ~ *x* .JUj . (J>n ' V ** 4* *a*ai r-Vne 1 l a c a 4 ^ r Thaa ____* - TC. ------ d i c l e a a h a * a ha a a h ro ag hc c a y a a r a t t a a t l o a by Mr. S p a l c h a r l a th a p ase h a t a p p a r a a t l y a r a I g a o r a d . Aa ye r a e a l l , I a a t lo a * 4 c h a sa f a c t o r ae tha C I s a e f y o r a l r a p a r e , 4 yo asd y o r a t H a t l o a a a g l a a a r a t a c a d Chat c h a v aa a " a a a a a a l " ~-- i l t a t c l o a t Chat d a rla g cha a a s a r t ls tha a rk a t f lr a a a a a t la hoe a4 a a b a a r a b la , a4 d a r la g tha l a t a r d tha fra a h I r v a a c i a r a c l o c a d , aad C h a t f o r o t t c o a l d r a a d t l y ha aaaa vhy i Cha a t a o a p h a r a c a a i d bacoaa t a l a ad o b n o x io . Tt la a y ra c a a a a a d a e to a C h a t yo adopt ao d a ra a a t l l a t l o a < l a y o r p l a a c . 1 aa a r p r l a a d aaa d l a a p p o l a t a d t o asa Cha a coa paay ach aa Vaattaghou would a s h ja e t lt a aaployaaa to cha to e - d lt la a a Z fad la yr p la a c . l t la q a lta ah*loa Chat faaa hava haaa l a a t a l l a d , b a c h t a b rla g la a l r aad t a sha c i r , vieb l t e l a o* ao a a g la a a rla g . lt la y ra a a a a cid a tla a that ya la a a d la t a ly l a a t l t a t a a ch *rs h tady hy a pataat * t i la t a a a g la a a r , aad tha d l r a a d a a of Mr. S p alch ar ha la v e r y h a a a la d g a a b la l a t i l a a r c a , t a d a t a r a ia a tha aachad aad i "1 VI -i . 5 -'1 -*3S ;--j rs ' V*5 '.'V* ^ -i To: Mr. P au l T u t t la r' > * 3 * cost " f p ro vld lag co u fo rtab la worklag i t v l r m t a t la your p l a a t . 1c la c o a c o l v a b l o , duo to eha typa of i c r a c . cura o f your p la n e , th a t you w i l l fla d I t a a c a t s a r y to supply c o o i l a g a i r during tha aaaaiar aad hattad aaks-up a i r d u r l a g tha w la t a r . Tou la d lc a ta d tha a x tr ta a coat c oaaclouaaaaa of your eoapaay. T h a ra fora you al g hc l n i - c la ta a study to d a ta ra la a tha eoat of propar v a a c l l a c i o a warsus lo o t t la a by tha a a p l o y a a a . Aay c o n c a r a your c o a * paay haa f o r l e a a a p lo y a a a would bo oa t ha ' p l u s '* a i d s . Tou sh o u ld hoop l a la d th a t you ara d a a lla g wi t h a h i g h l y s a a s l t l v a work p o p u la tio n , sad say l l l a a s s t s , w h a t h a r or a a t J u a t l f l a d , w i l l ba b la a a d oa tha work at u o i p h a r a , aad t h a r o f o r a s p o e l a l e o g a l t a a c a a u a t ba aada of th is face. 7ry truly yaur. GDC r f Gcergt 0. Ciaytom Pr ldac wC CEORGS D* CLAYTON h ASSOCtXT S S f '. NC. ! " ( k o r g e D. C la y t o n 8s A s s o c ia t e s . In c . -Ait tOCUiTIOM A t O I t O W T A A HIALTH COMMktAJir (D ft 4 F T) <4ta*S MfVOtT orrworr *7 wich VSMOM7 ^OOM PthSOMAL AMP COMTIBtMTI AL M r. P a u l T u te 1 ?lu*. Maaagar Wt t ia g h o a a o S l t a t r i c j f U t i u a u U , Obla Corporati Osar Mr. T a ttlo t a P i U a y , 10th, I r . I . V. Spalahar, U a la * i i t r i c a r af I 4 a t r ia l Hpglaaa fa r tha tfaatlaghoaaa S la a e rie C a r f i n t l M , aa4 cka r i l a r r l i i t a i yaar p iase ta a v a lla t a tha a a r ir aaaaatal ait Iosa of yr p la n t, to arala if chara vara asp g a sta , hoch p h p a la a l aa4 e h a a le a l, hiah a l i a a a a a a c f a r eh r a a p i r a t a r p l l l a a a a a a v h le h ha cm trm aaaag at y a a r a a p l 7 a i . Sa a ra I r t a f a as eh h ia t a r p mt cha 41aaao hp M r. tf. A. I t i a h a y , l a a c r l a l t a l a d (a g ia ta r la paar p iase. t a r i r sa sta l aasplaa ara tahas ta a a a a rta la tha 4graa of c h a s i c a l p a i l a t i a s a p r a t o s e . A r a p a r e v i l i ha ose aa c o s p la tla s of tha hasta l aaa ip ta a. With raap aat ta cha p h p a la al gasta har, ia r la g ta* a re a of tha l s v a a t l g a t la s I t aaa r a a i l l y apparaat th a t tha a s t i 1 s tla s i s paar p la st aaa paaalp 4aaigs4 as4 varp i s - a4ag sta. Thar ara sasaIva 4 *a (ta t ****** " * p a art a4 p a sp l a ra aahJoataM ^ta*"rair a a y lp paar a s ir s M a . a JL ala* c a l a a i f U l a M g A lth a s g h 1 mm MM p h p a U la s '. ic io p v*. l u ( ha th a ! 1 s t l a s l a ha p la s a s a l4 v a rp m H ha PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT \\<stt S " " H-' :. 4i -Cf 1 '>i , > - .-*! "Vf; ;-j 3 'i T o : H r . P a u l T a t 1 1* (?a ,d tLcM Jia /^ h **< *I (L*1CJV\S*JlJ L C m ~CCJl- I aL Tou 111 n a ta Chat a* a f tha p o s a i I s f f a a a a r a o( "V a t la g - -5=- hou* 4 1 '' a i t h a t t h a r a aa a a a a a a a a d a s a a l s a t a r i c h a t tha a y s p t o s a <*f tha s p l o y a a a v a r i a d . I t la y h a l l a f that tha s t r ly poor o r k l a f c a n d id o * te h leh cha ap lo ya* ara a n h ja cta d eould lo a r c h a i r r a a la e a a c a co cha p oin t har th a y a u ld ha r a a d l l y a u a c a p t lh la to ny p * la g I r a * . Tha axhauat v e n t ila t io n la any l a c a t l s s i aa c o a p la ta ly la - ~ adaqucc a i a4 ch a r p la a * a ra o v ar-van e 1iacad^ Tha* aa- --- j m --* A g ^ a . ty r*-*y . ~ ~ ! d it lo a* haa haan hroughc ca yanr a t t a n t lo n hy M r v a ie h a r *** r'7*C- l a th a p a s e , h a t a p p a r a n t l y a r a I g n o r a d . Aa you r a a a l l , I aatlo aa 4 chasa f a t to ra at cha t l a a of y o r a l r a y a r e , cad yoa and y o a r v a n t l l a t i a s a a g ln a a r a tacad Chat th ta aa a " a a a a a a l" ' i l t a t t l o a t Chat dnrlng tha itia a a rtla tha ark a a lra r a it la hoe aa4 a h a c r a h la , aa4 d u rln g tha v l n t a r t l a a tha fra a h a i r v a a t i a ra e l o a a 4 t a4 c h a r f o r a l e eo u ld r 4 l l y ha aaaa * h y ^ tha a t n o a p h a r a e a a l d bacoaia c a l a and o b n o a lo u a . _"^v Tt l a a y r a e a a a a n d a t toa t h a t y ou dopt aodarm d i c t i o n <1 l a you r p l a n t . 1 aa a u r p r l a a d aaa 4 1 a a p p o l a t a 4 t o th a a e on-r^rf paay auch a W aatlngheu* would a u h ja e t l t a a p lo ya* to tha co a- d ltla a a t (atad la yaur p la n t. It la q u ita ahla u a that fana ^ hava haan l n a t a l l a d , hoch t a h r l a * l a a i r and t aahauac a i r , ^ ich l t e l a av na anglarin g . tt la y ra a a M a td a tla a that y Iw a d & a t a ly l a a t l t n t a tharnh atudy hy a eaopataat vau t l i t t a n a | l h * * r i n a d a r th a d l r o a t i o n a f m* . S p a t c h a r h a l a a a r y h a a v lsd g n a h U la t h t a a r t a , t a d a t a r a i s tha sa ch a d and oC i "1 4 :-X) 'i-2 r'~*r T ' c m m -' 7. ' V:-^1 y c .r To: Mr. Paul T u t t la > " 3 * c o s t *< p r o v i d i n g c o a f o r t a b l a w o rk in g a a v l r o a a a a t l a y o u r p l a n t . I t 1 c o a c a l w a b l a , 4 to tho typ a o f i t r a c - tu ra of your p la n t , th a t you w i l l fin d I t a a c a a s a ry to su p p ly c o o l t a t l r d u rin g tho i m i r aad h sa tsd aaka-up a i r d u rla g tha w l a t a r . You la d lc a t a d tha a s t r a a a coat co a a clo u a a a a a of your eo ap aay. T h a ra fo ra you s ig h t l n l * d a t a a study to d a ta r s la a tha coat of oropsr v a a t lia t lo a v a n u a l o s t t t a a by tha a a p lo y a a s . Aay c o a c a r a your c o s- p sa y has f o r I t s a s p l o y a a s would ba on tha ' p l u s " a i d s . You sho u ld kaap l a a la d th a t you a rs d a a lla g w ith s h ig h ly s a a s l t l v a work p o p u la t io n , sad any l l i n a s s s s , w h a th a r or aoc j u s t i f i e d , w i l l ba b la a a d oa tha work a c - a o s p h a r a , aad t h a r o f o r a s p a c l a l c o g a l s a a c a a s s t ba aada of th is fae t. Vary tru ly yours. GDC: f Gaorga 3. Claytou Pros Idaae CEORGE D. C H YT O h f. \ S S O C I \ T S S , 0 s--