Document oDV4eRY9VGY8Z7gxDQ4r6ZnxE
AR226-3339
Roy S Thompson Ilaria Colombo Watze de W olf
(AstraZeneca, Brsxham, UK) (Solvay Solexis, Bolteie, Italy) (DuPont, Mechelen, Belgians)
David G Farrar Robert A Hoke Jacques L'Haridon
for:(ineos Chlor, Runcorn, UK) (DaPant, Newark, DE, USA) (CIT, Evreux, France)
APME (Association ofPlastics Manmcterera in Earops) d-Hoc APFO Eavimaffisatsl Woridag Group _____________ _____ A p ME /
Acute & Cfer@icCAoqunatetinctToxicity of APFO Background Physico-chemical properties of APFO Acute toxicity Chronic toxicity Risk assessment Potential role of ammonium ion in APFO toxicity Conclusions Acknowledgements
AJpME
1
ArairAtucfutitielii&iitiCphtrrollniiic Arquacttic Tsio#xaitcit-yBoaf AckPgFrOtjiiiid
Most commonly used salt o f perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA)
Essential processing aid in fluoropolymer and fluoroelastomer
production (e.g. FIFE) and application (e.g. non-stick cookware)
KyiRting data on aquatic toxicity, but with various test substance
formulations, purity etc. and o f variable quality
- Variability in toxicity values
Need for complete and uniform set o f data to current regulatory
guidelines and to Good Laboratory Practice
For this9w9.o7r%k:Purity; 78% nonnal-chain: 12% branched
_____________________________________ __
ajPm e
Ammonium Perffluorooeteiioate (APFO)
CF3.tF 2.CF2.CF2.CP2,,CF2.CF2.C(0 )0 'NH4+
(CAS No: 3825-26-1)
H20 Solubility:
3400 fng/P]
(Fully ionised Log Kow:
in
water
at
enUvnircoenrtmaienn(tasilspfaHc)tani)
Log Roc:
1.7 - 2.4
Bioconcn. factor (BCF): 4 (Rainbow trout)1
1.8 (Fathead minnow)
1j USEPA (2002) [2] Dekieva et at (2003) (31 Martin el ai (2003)
7
Kmmmkwm Prfflwirctate(AFFO)
Acote Txtettf
Fish (Onmrhynchm mykms) (OECD 203)
- 96 hr LC 50:
7 1 0 m g /I (nominal)
(Mo effect at 500 mg/1; 100% mortality at 1000 mg/1)
Crostcea (Daphnia magm) (OECD 202)
- 48 hr EC50:
4 8 0 m g/1 (nominal)
(24 hr EC50 600 mg/1; No effect at 320 mg/I; 100% effect at 1000 mg/1)
Algae (PsmdoMrcImerleih subcapitaia) (OECD 201)
-- 72 & 9 6 hr EpCSO: > 4 0 0 mg/1 (measured)
(72 & 96 hr EbC (biomass) also > 400 mg/1)
CAmtama&iimiewTmPexrMfIiityr-@SkcytpaikMmitme (wAmFFgOm) 21-day Growth & Reproduction (o e c d 211 - semi-static)
No effect on mortality at highest concn: 89 mg/1 Length o f parents at 21days, NOEC - 44 mg/1 Reproduction: NOEC = 20 mg/1 (mean measured)
a firn e 7
ChAromamkoTnimumfcWii&y M- Ommmmmtmkpmmttk\ m myMm
Early Life Stage test (85 days) (oecd 210-Continuousflow)
> No significant effect on survival, length or weight o f the fish at
highest concentration tested
rtfhmu
` NOEC = 40 mg/1 (mean measured)____________
40j
.-*35 ' iI -- -- ------- f ------ f ------- ? --
821 3D 2250
fg
10
~J -
E6
0 Control 2.2 4.5 11 21
APFO Concn. (mg/l)
I !
40
1000
3E. 800
QC+O1 tSc(00>
600 400 200
0
-H -H
Controi 2.2 4.5
H-
11 21
A P F O C o n c n . (mg/l)
40
h F Ml
Acute & Ornate Aquatic Toxicity offAPPO
Chronic NOECs for 3 trophic levels
Fish 50 mg/1
Crustacea 20 mg/1
Algae 12.5 mg/1
Assessment (safety) factor:
Therefore:
PNEC =
1 0 (EU Technical Guidance Doc)
1.25 mg/1
Predicted No Effect Concentration
Few data on environmental concns (ic;i: Generally < LOD
Lake Ontario: ca. 10_<5mg/1 (PFOA) (Scott i,2003)
(P
Local to manufacture: <
)EC/PNECs < It)*3- Very
1L0o"3wmRgi/s1k(PtoFAOqAu)a(toics eOf ar,g2a n)isms^
^
Ammonitimi PerftaoreoetaiMMt (APFO) a l as
APFO dissociates in water yielding NH^
n h 4+ n h 3+ h +
Ammonia Dissociation Curve (20C)
ammonia
mmmmmmmMmmmsmm
ua2_*
5
0
'
6.5 7 7.5
pH
Free ammonia ca. 100 times more toxic than ionised
mmmiMm PerftaorwMtanoate (AFFO) f tentiti Ente of Am m sa^am Ioa
Calculate free ammonia concn from EC/LC50 and test pH
S p ecies
Oncorynchus mykiss Pimephales promelas Daphnia magna Daphnia magna
L C 50 (m g A P FO /1) 710 300 480 240
m g N H j-N /l
0.38 0.3 0.47 0.61
R ef T his study U S E P A (2002) T his study U S E P A (2002)
Free ammonia EC/LC50:
Oncoryynchus mykiss 0.16 - 1.1
Daphnia magna
____________________________ __
0.53 - 4.9 mgNH3"N/1
__________{_U_S_E_PA_,_1_9_84_)_ jPME
/
Acute & Chronic Aquatic Toxicity ffAFFO Cadnsliiii
APFO shows relatively low acute & chronic aquatic toxicity (Lowest NOEC = 12.5 mg/1)
Based on available date, concentrations (PFOA) occurring in the aquatic environment are orders o f magnitude below die PNEC, indicating negligible risk
The ammonium content o f APFO may contribute to the acute (and possiby chronic) aquatic toxicity, and may explain some o f the apparent variability in the historical data. A f,i ME 3