Document oD9z8OmMLx84vobVVj88kMyzX
!~>b:n end --1" handles. the creator ilik-Theic is also
gooH evidence - doss response relawcnshtp fur ashcstosis
and bronchix' =.r.zsn and thus., if the du levels air kept
v.-iik:.i the fit- strr.ittd;. the risks of asbestos;* ana bron
chial cancer; :r .h: fuittst tiiouid be very small.
The risk c: ir-z.^.r.x mesotheliomas has a different
relation to f:rrr tyyr. !: ;s probably highest with crocidolitc
and U-west
cr.-Tt'- i- So easer clearly related to
aiultrpkylLta -
fees ...repotted, despite careful
search. TV.:
*:*.h :mo<;;e probably lies between
crocidjlitc iz.i ch-ysj:a_^IIIrevidaaceJur a dose response"
relationship is lets clear in the case of mesotliclionus and
hence tite ih:az.P. Lt.h value is more difficult to assess^
(n the Afberrcs Regulations IVf9'* the standard for
ciucidolite is iet a: or.e-ienth of that for other types of
asbestos.
COMPARISON CF OCCUPATIONAL RISKS
What is the magnitude of the risk of developing 21-liea I th
from asbestos? No fir-gie index prosides a satisfactory
measure of injury to health--
Thus the excert risk of death before a specified ace may
be a useful index for uosediseasesausint sudden or iapid
death, but it is an ittapptcprwe. index for diseases causing
a tone period of disability out-ini* iho.*un..:g of life.-Tlte -
cancers associated with asbestos exposure fall into the first
group and ash-er.osts the second coup. In different occu
pational gratis s cc-stsassons of mortality are easier to make
than those of illness. But even for mortality the compari
sons are nar straishtfetward. For example, the more the
selection is limited to a definable group with a high past
exposure, the worse the risk will appear. Allowance has
also to be made for the effects of age, length of exposure,
-and how Ion; the occupational croup has been followed.
When such allowances are made the excess mortality
from `all catties' if. groups of workers heavily exposed to
the more di.-ccng types of asbestos dusts in the past is
closely' comparable to mat of coalminers who have developed
the severer torn: of caaiworkers' pneumoconiosis or that
of deep-sea f.shcnr.e'r. who hast the highest rates of acci
dental de.thc cf any occupation. However, the excess
mortality from 'ali causes' in these occupational groups is
less than -ha'. rr.a e smokers of twenty cigarettes and
more a ca; c-: mrartJ
t'.oti-snyifcers.
This is 'he a;; "fr.
heaths from 'ali causes', bm
dent?-5 f;c*r.
.cu es, such as mesothelioma.-. .rdics-
tc;:s. or ic'.c
:: c.oe tv t..at of the actieia: public,
are cu.:.-:
rc.fiy much more increased. This
ii he.cuse m
,,ri a>hcoosi* are extremely rjrc
in ... . .-c r v. irked *;tli asbestos. Cenl'uMtin
jrttti'.imes .
r.- .;tr. the proportion of individuals
exp.-ed v.:; :. rl.p a d.-sta-t and the excess tisk nt a
pcri'cclc: :
:-r :.d l:.J't duals compared with the
genera! p.r . ':r.;\ be relatively small and the
sccntd c.x'rr-:-; ..c
THE fi/7. ~:
As in rn ._. newcnrrr:.:
it
ar-C
r; -J.:;---es proof of' the cfficacv of . . : r.j.Mie the v-jluluv >( the
.a:', only Ci.mc iiiiim Iiiikiiic ii..- ir.aivaiaciuri!:-,- p>o,-c\,
. 2 .rr nuteruU nwti. :iv mea
surements of ex'^'ueputhe.-mcdical recoids o-4ho*e-- exposed. C'ompuv. nownnake it easy to store tha-infor--- matron, hut we still need tlie fotesigiu and adininnsniion to sec that ir is achieved. If it ia not done we may stflf fct 20 years or so be in no better position to answer important questions which ate at present unanswei able because-of the paucity of past records.
CONCLUSION
_
The recent increase in the number of cases of asbestosis and
other diseases related to past exposure to asbestos is the
result of relatively heavy exposures io the dust, particularly
in parts of the asbestos industry not covered by the-}93|
Asbestos Regulations. .
Much new information about the biological effects of
asbestos has been acquired recently. The new Asbestos
Regulations 1969 based on this information. if EOracily
applied, should greatly reduce the risks in the future:--
. . The selection of which types of asbestos to use in new
processes should take into account their biological effects
if the risk of dust exposure is likely to occur duringgame-
facture or in the use of the products.
1.. -- .
When working with extremely fine fibres of anymaterial
which may become aubdme. cauiion h necbed. AirexatiJUK
"niiiohiof tfie pogible~bfblogical effects is~reqinethi me
product is to be widely used and rules of damage to health
are to be avoided in (lie future.
Proof of the efficacy of present preventive measures
depends on much better record keeping than has been the
case in the past.
^
REFERENCES
1 Nora Lro. Americtn fiutuuritf ttygjtne Association Journal,
iw:.(i 195 (II**! 2 More* ether E. R. A. and five C. W.. `Report on the effects
of asbestos dust on the hangs and dust suppression in the
Asbestos Industry'. London. HMSO (1930)
3 Preesscn W. C, DaUaratle J. M.. hdwards T. I_ iSex J. W..
Sayers R. R-. 'A study of asbcnosi in the asbescon-textile
------ r indowry'. US Treasury Dcpvraoem. 1`ubtie IleaUii-Setrice.
Public Health BulfctN24i (Aiapsst I93St
- ---------
* Mcrewcther F.. R. A. Anawai Repwei. Inapectoe of Facwin
London. HMSO 1194?!
.< ` !VO Kk'hard. Prmsri ltr'T".r! of InJuunc! stedkur*. Vo! !2,
- p SI f 19551
___
( Knox }. I - Jlotmc.v S_ OoU R.. and Hit! I. D..BririsftJournal
of litJiiuiia! M'-Jico;-'. t'ol 25. p 2v.f
--
? tielikAti' I. J.. J.-mkj: t>} the Anu'etei* McJicat Atutcianon. I W 3i*-t. p HU I'tr
> W'acni-r J. ('.. Gii*oi; J. C... Bern- G.. ar:J TunbreU British tl.-Jical Bulletin Ia.'2". p 7l{l9?l)
9 C-iIsun ].
'Adw<u .`K-olth hujrJt'. in Shapiro. H. A.
lejitori. 'Pr.eumocor.K^is'. Piocevdmss ot the Intematienal
fontkreiu-e. Johann.-,tvre. 24 Aprii-2 M4J- tVb. p 113.
I'.ipv To** i err., O.O'ord Universiiv Picvi (1970)
! 0 .-Ii'lvi I.. Ashcsiov exposure m Soutl. a flics', ibid, p i 20
11 Cunr.incJum it. NS. and Tontciract R.. .\anjre. I'of 2J2. P 5J2
'1971/
17 1'ci.LIjLi- Marearci R.. i'ounuci-Matscy Ciarlc. M.Oonild J.
Sunnarjcti J.. icJ Komilet C. E.. Bulletin Ur Phyuo
ruthuU,pc fiequ'ctcure, toj A. p t>J? (19711)
1 .* M Ilonalil J. Corbett. M.-Po;uUi Ati>n 0., CihbsGulvani W,,
.'Mcnnaix.ki Jack, and Ko,,ilct ( hiries L.. Archives of
I hi iii-ii'u-nu! Ilci!;u l-'o/ 22. p A 77 f 1971/
14 J clout liilii'i. lii'ih, G \V.. MacUcm P. T.. NkUmaM J. C..
Ii.. ii.it,- Vji-.-.ii, : e I
on Kctuw- ttf Kcsptrcto'y
/iVi.ii i l III III.' / *.V 'fv,'//
I' Si.i-jinn ln,iius I jo`l ViiiiW. IMrunirv The Allvia
It.- -il :11,*,, f'l-v | .in. HMSO ||Vi,9i