Document oD43k6oYrymE5aDBB4zKboy1o
Ti1bNEW_ YORK
th_ 1916
ACHEM1GALPACT
Charged With Not Curbing Use of Toxic Substance* Affecting Fpods
By CI.YDF. H,' FARNSWORTH
i Itperiil To< Wf Tfl*l 7>nH
PARIS, Jan. 18--7he United 'SiMet hit been charged with
not living up to lit obligitloni under whs! It In effect an international treaty to retlricl use of a group df toxic cJitfnH cals and prevent them from
enlennc the environment and contaminating the human food
chain,
. --
This was reported yesterday
by officials of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and
Development who noted that
the United States and other nations In the organization had
signed a Commitment nearly three years ago to control the
rhcmlcals, known aa PCB's, for polychlorinated biphenyls.
By poisoning fish, the sub
stance enters the human food
l chain It has caused liver.can
cer and reproductive failure?
: in tome laboratory animals.
.
Other nation* who are major '
offender*, according to data
collected by the environment
aecrnarlat of the Weilern coor dinating Institution, are West Germany. July and Spain,
Among the countries that nave best met the obligation* of the
undertaking are Japan and the nations of Scandinavia, . 1
Had the United Stalespasaed the legislation envisaged under
the organization comifiltment, the Ganoral Electric Company would be birred from dlnhargIng PCB contaminants from two capacitor plants Into the
Hudson River.
'
| in New York, s spokes man for General Electric said '
that the company, voder a permit granted s year',ago ,
by the Federal Environmental Protection Agency, Vaa djacharging about three pounds'
of PCB chemical* a day from
the two planlt, at Hudson
Fall* and Fort Edward, Into
the upper Hudson north of
Albany,
`
.
(The permit, the epokea--
man said, allows the com
pany to discharge up to 30
pounds of the chemicals a
, '
d*y-1
jiA- ..
^11* W organization member[ untrjei from Western Europe, j
>nh America and developed t :ie signed a council decision
on Feb ' 13. 1873 to control the use of the chlorine-laded
PCB'i and are nov,- exchanging information about what pro
gress they have made.
An organization lawver ex
plained that a council decision, under the organization's rule* df organization, "has the bind
ing effects of a treaty",
'
Organization officials here
were aurprlsed by the terminol
ogy of Russell E. Train, heed
lof the Environmental Protec tion Agency, In referring to the council decision In one re cent statement si u `trecom-
mrndatlon.".
-i
The council also adopts in-1
commendations, bill these 4re not binding on the members
"I don't understand," -aaid one organization apecialiat Who
asked not to be cited by nami, `how the United States could
olemnjy make on agreement
ahd at the dame time not be in the position to carry it out
A toxic substances control act has been bottled up In
the Congress for five1 yeara,
having run Into Intense Indus try opposition, `But officials of
the Organization for Economic
Cooperation and Development cannot fathom why the Admi
nistration doea not propose leg islation to deaf specifically
vrilh PCB control, especially aince there la only-one major
American manufacturer of the ubatanoe, the Monsanto Che mical Company of St, Louie,
Without controls jobber* can distribute the substance freely
and imports can come In from Manufacturers abroad. PCB'i
are relatively easy to make, and because of their inertness,
fire resistance and -hbllity to
hold an electrical charge, they tre, widely Hied In the manufac ture of capacitors and genera tor* in the electrical Industry. They are also used In lubri
cants, paper coatings.'hydraulic
fluids, plasticizers, inks, paints and adhesjvea.'
High bfficialt front the org*
itiration's member countries are to meet in Paris March
IS to discuss application 'of the council decision Christian
Herter Jt., Deputy Assistant
I Secretary of State for EnvlronlJ mental and Population Affalta,
it to lead the American delega
tion,
,
The councfl ' decided that PCB't shall be used oply for
specifically defined Industrial
and `edmmericti purposes where the substance la main
tained M a dosed gyatem.
-The accord also tald that member countries "*ha11- con trol the'manufacture, Import and export of bulk PCB'*, Insti
tute adequate arrangements for Jthe recovery, regeneration, ade-
Suite incineration or other safe Itposal of sulcus and waste ' materials; institutue a special i uniform labeling -system for
I both bulk PCB'a and PCB-contalnlng manufactured products,
* and established safety specifi cation! for containers, and transport,
Th* United Sates Is by far the largest producer of PCBs According to organization data
for 1971 --more recent autistic*
are unavailable--the United
Bates produced 18,000 tons; West Germany, 8,000; France,
7,000. Britain 5,000, Japan,
S.800; Italy, i;500 and EpMn ,M0.
t. The Soviet Union Is also be tieved to be an tmporunt pro-
flucer, but figure* on Its output are not available. In Eastern! Cuhope, Bast Germany Is prob
ably the biggest manufacturer,
organization officials believe. At the coming March meeting
In pans, the United State? Is
expected to run Into criticism
from the countries that have met thtir PCB control oblige
lion*. .
.
Since the council decision,
Japan has flopped all manu
facture of *he product and banned'Import*.'except for e
UpeelficMIy defined apcdial case. El Jung 1988 about 1,000 Japa-
hete were poisbnpd as the result
of leakage of a heat-tranefer fluid containing KB In a rice
oil pasteurization plant West Germany, like the Unit
ed States, hat no KB legisla
tion and la believed to be In creasing production.
France passed a law In July,
last year controlling the produc
tion, manufacture and use
Britain enforce* control pro
cedures throogh what I*
known as a gentlemen's agree
ment among users and khe
single manufacturer, a Mon
santo subsidiary. AH the Scandinavian coun
tries and the Netherlands,
Austria and Switzerland are
believed to have effective con
trols.
.
July and Spain- have not
(Carried out the council de
cision luty la said to provide
Ifigurt* on tu production, but
Spain to far bts rtfusw to oo
thtl.
HONS 206940