Document npmj1EEXM2BrNrXj6Kkezo488

2286$Federal Register /Vol; 51, No; 119 / Friday,, fane 2Qi 1986 / Riiies andt Regulafems. Table 27.--Annual Compliance Costs--Continued, shown-, in.Table 29 were obtained,from, [Mo price orouartfrty changes)' ~v Industry, sector ilflll spits Most 1 expensive' provision , Annual cost of'the-mostexpensive: pfovisena* a~ - . percentage ' of-annuai: compliance costs comments in, the: record'and: from information presented- ini the studies; by; CONSAD [Exhibit 84-74?| and; RTL. Finally, theexfent-.txj, which protective controls are currently/ utilized was considered whenicalculating' the' annual! compliance; costs. Thesexosts are; presented: at! the. bottom of Table lh. Secondary manufacturing) Based1 oni these Gosts;. OSHA. believes A/C them_____ 1.260.6 .....do...'......... 71 ' thati only the; demolitionsectorway.' Textiles'........... -- - Plastics....... ............. ,,............................. -__________ ....................................... Automotive remanutecturing............... ..... ,....... .............................................. Service arxTrepair 096 6 .....do....._.... 4[675.a ......do-........ $.670.6 ' .....do-........... 62 experience financial difficultyini .45 complying; with the requirements: of the 72 76 revised standard:- According' tdi the: August 1985: edition' 0f IheConstruclioni Automotive repair......,,..................................... -................................................ Construction;1 44,654.7 .Solvent . spray. 3.916.6- rooms:. 100 Report "Value:of Construction! in: Place,." theinetivalue of-new cpnstmiction-.in: 1984'was $3T2.98B'billion in 1984>dollars. Given estimated!annual compliance Asbestos-abatement:.............. ................................................ ............................ Demolition....-........................... ........................... ,, --................................. Renovation.............................. .......... ....................................... ........-.......... 27.670:0' 'Respirators;... 13,610 5 Vacuums...... 144,6955 Protective dolhtng: 87 costs of less than:$10;million-for new- 36 29 construction; the:costltb'revenue ratio is less than 0:1 percent. Thus; OSHA, ha9- Routine mainlenance in general industry......................................... .................. 45.450.0' .....do'........... . *459.088.1 74 determined that it is economically feasible: for this sector, to:comply.: The. preponderance: of the: compliance 'OSHA assumes that an construction workers exposed above the PEL in negative-pressure regulated areas will use suppliod-alr respirators in order to avoid the costs associalod with daity monitoring Total may not sum Ouo to rounding error. Source: U,$ Department of labor. OSHA. Offico of Regulatory Analysis. costs for construction. (8T percent) are associated with abatement..renoKatiotr. andiroutine maintenance (i'.e:, $285.3: million)-. According.fo the'April 1985 Table 28.--Economic Feasibility in.the: Pri construction-, abatement, demolition, edition:of,Construction Reports mary Manufacturing, Secondary manu renovation, routine maintenance in "Residential: Alterations: and'Repuir;" facturing and Service Sectors commercial andlresidential buildings, the-total; value:of maintenance and': and routine, maintenance in general repair act;vitiesuro 1984: was. about Industry Sector CornpOarice costs (m&ons) dotiers In Gross revenue - (millions) dollars in Costs/ revenue (percent) industry. OSHA.determined.the specific controls necessary to meet the requirements of the revised standacd'for $23.7841 billioni in 1977 dollars (i.e., $38,929 billion in 1S84: dollars).The' estimated: annual, compliance: cosf-to-- each, of- these subparts,. Different, revenue: ratio'in these: sectors; combined Primary Manufacturing:- A/C pipe-------------- A/C sheet_____ _ Friction materials..-. Textiles ____ Floor tiles.------------- Gaskets and packings-------- --- Paper........ --....... Coating* andt sealants. ------- 0.068 .643 22.661 .611 ..90S .759 .635 \22i .441 69.0 82.6 666.4 41.4 95.1 84.0 356.4 468.0 12.6 construction acliyities'requireidifferent1 0.10 .70 control practices and/or combinational 3.30 of these practices, Theunit'coat 1.96 .32: estimates for these control, practices is estimated to be: approximately 0:7 percent'. Thus, OSHA has determined! that it isieconomicaliy feasible forthese. sectors to comply;- .00 .23 Table 29.--Item Cost Estimates for Control Requirek!Ents:tn;Construction: .26 3.71 ttem< Unit-cost (rh 1964 dollars)- Comments'usodMo-devetop estimates. Secondary Manufacturing: Exhibh'84'-474, Friction.materials.... , 12.382 Gaskets and packings----------- Texfies.. ............ 5.553 .697 Ptastice..:............... 4.676 Automotive ,, remanufacturtng... 5.071 Service and repair Automotive repair.... 44.655 Ship-repair- . 3.918.5- 592.8 2.16 1,156.0 703.8 764.0 U2s:o ! - .48 .10. .60 .48 228.150.4 2.667.1 .02 .15 Source: U:S` Department of Uabor, OSHA. Offico of Reguiatory*Ana)ysia. Shrouded' toots- with- HEPA . vacuums:' Vacuums (for-one drillend one- saw): &. ac cessories. 10.48/bag.......... HEPA vacuums: Unit and accessories.'........ Regulated areas: Non-negative pressure: Exhibits 64-473, 84-474] 179 and 272: Exhibits 84-473. B4-474:and;179 Construction Negative pressure: ' HEPA ventilation systems: Unit and accessories....... 2,750/unit.............. Exhibits 84-474. I79 end'272. - The compliance costs for the.- construction industry were estimated in a manner similar to that used fbr the manufacturi'ng.andsenvice sectors. The initial step'was ro identify'the requiredequipment and'procedures. Based'on the industry feasibility analysis, the. construction industry was divided into six. major subparts including new Enclosures and signs...... .448/enclosure.... Decontamination areas: ! 204. Assembly, of adiacent-.unit.. 500.00/pet-unii..... Hall-mask supptied-air:. Respirators: Respirator and accesso :Exhibits 64-473, 84-474|` 123A. 179 and'330. ries. Compressor (tor.' 2 ! 1,000.00/ masks). compressor.- Suit of protective dothing........ 3.00/suit............. .. -Exhibit 84-473, 64-474:and?179. GLEASON-000916