Document nmn0E9m6naGELJ00EqLrZGr12
FILE NAME: Metropolitan Life (ML)
DATE:
DOC#: ML
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION:D>'ZWZ,ZZ /
Dr. IIcCoDaell W.lter. D!T1sion lDiuctr1al. Health SectioD
R.tl 43-G-2 - JO!maOD'S Co., Thetford. il1Des Weet, Quebec
We iSllued. this paller in 1929, tud to date
or .e haye prell1U111S ot ~33,OOO o.gaiNit Death claiu $23,500
&Dd DicabW,tr claas ot $3,000. Tho ex,.,oricftce 1:1 TC1'7
. unf'a..,orable in the cun"ent ree:r, the p&-em.1DI8 8IIOUIIt1DI to ~,8'O with Death claw ot $11,000 am D1aabil1t7 cld... or ~l,ooo. , .
An anal.7a1a ot the claima showa a pr~ponderence or lUDf: diSorders. The CCllllpat/7 18 e12pged in the C;u::t.rr7iZ2; and
manutacturinr or asbestoa, and we reel that there is a decided occ1l;)&tioaal bazard..hare~ W. 1fould 11ke to ha.... 70U or Kr. Fehnel inspect the plant. ot this COllltaQT at ,our' coD'tenience.
t~y ;:'/, 19:3 5
GiiT/DB
l:' . At~cbed is a cOPT of the claim ana.J.7Ois
.c "
'I _t_-
/
..
G.W. Fi .hugh, Su~i8or
Actu:u-ial Division
CrOU? Lite & Health Section
Dr. WcConnell,
Welfare Division, Industrial Health Section
Re: Johnson's CompaDT, Thetford Mines West, Quebec
We cover the employees of the above compaDT for group
Sliefveerianlsuyreaanrscea,goandthetoedxapteeriethnececwlaaismsunafmavoounrat btloe, 83a%ndowfethreefeprrermediU!tlhlse. group
to you because There has been
there was a substantial number of claims tor lung diseases. an improvement in the experience in recent years and the
coverage has shown a profit since 1935.
In 1936 the question ot offering this. compAU;Y Accident
& Health benefits was considered and we asked you to ot the ~roperties. Iou reported that the employees
~ake
were
an inspection French Canadians
a~ looked undernourished would not be very good.
and that in your opinion the On the basis ot this report,
claim experience we decided not to
otter Accident &Health coverage.
Our representative has again raised the question ot
Accident & Health covera.e and advi.es us that the a considerable sum ot mon.,. tor mine improvement..
compa=J hal appropriated Poib17 this will im-
prove the group as a risk tor group coverage
e wQuld appreciate a turther inspection at thi.
compa~. properties is not large enough
and a report trom you at yOlJr convemence. The group to justit,. the expense at a .pecial trip tor this
inspection, but po.sib17 lOU will have someone 10 the vicini~ .oon aDd
can have him' make a report.
In advi.ing us whether lOU consider th1a co.~ an
accocnespidtaebraletiorin.kthtaotrtoArcctihdiesntin&dHusetarl7th(caosvbeer.atgoe. , mlOinUe.w) iwlel
want load
to take into our staDdard
rate. 40%. 140% at the
In other worci8, it lOU think cla1a rate in a DOn-baurdoUl
the cla~ induatrr,
rate rill be le.s th&n our ~~ rate should
be adequate. Of course, the pl.&D we will attar will nO'""F0vide benetit.
tor occupational accidents.
.
,
1Jl. ~7~-\'.41" Ac
-
Group Lit &Health Section
,~1ft9S16i~
. '
~
.
MEMORANDUM
July 3, 19JJ.
DR. .4.m~STF.oNG:
The Actuarial Division has asked ua to stufy the Johnson's
Mine Company on which we have Group Life covera.e, because in the last
three years we tuberculosis.
have paici The Grpup
28 is
claims or which 13 deaths increasing the premium on
were d\;8 to the compa~y
as
or July 1, 1944.
ff', is
Johnson's Mine Compaay quarries and manufactures located in Thetrord Mines. Several industrial hygiene
asbestos and surveys have
been made at Johnson's in connection with the
y.1nes st\.rly
in or
past years--the first'Toas in June 1930 an asbestos ind'UStr,y 'in Ca~aua. Ancther
study was made in March 19~1. As you will probably recall the conclusion'
reached in the asbestos study was that asbestosis did not predispose'
to tuberculosis. Very high dust counts were
with 99.!S% or the particles or less than 10
found at microns.
30hnson's Mines Workers were ver,r
care1es! about in bucket' and
expectorati!"-I on the common dr1Ilkill& cups
noors; were in
driDk1nc w~ter uae. A number
wu supplied or recommenda-
tions
were made to improve general uent 'stud,. has been made.
operatinc conditions of this mine. I bave ~13I...ted, inasmuch as Ir.
, J'~
'~r
No subseq
,~ehnel is plann1n,
to
visit
Canada
011 other .business,
that
he
include
. If'" Y
CJoomhnP&son1n'sprMopineertiineshainsd' traipsuwrvi etby, aiTt ipe"ostsoibaler,eccsbtetchkesulirTTeil,.lioetontah1.et1.".TOoIhl1Alson..J-i
of to
. .p 1 0 y e e l . go alone "11
It you think it this trip also'.
teasibl., It seem.
I llicht. b. able to arrange to .. reganUes. ot 1Ihether
asbestosis contribute. to tUberculosi., there i. a not only in .Tohnson,'s 1f.1nes but'in Thettord Mines.
tuberculosis probleJI, The latest mortalitY'" cJ)-
rigures 'that ! cou.ld culosi8 mortality c4
secure sho" that. 2'9 per 100,000';
~inttQOuZe'bdectiSnOepl eirn1.10904,010h0a;danadtuibner--=~;;
Canada 51 per 100,000. I bave written
dTice about the pre.ent statu. at
to Dr...Gardner in Saranac asbestosi. in relation to
to ask tuber-
~
Q
his a culcsis
a.J:2Ci
also
to:-
my
sUice.tionl a. to 1IAtter br1etl1'
wthiet.ha:pDprr.oaBc-harntoetttehwishelp1rhoebl1e1'.&.
0) C~
in Canada. I last here cd
discussed the he q,eated ,ettUac' in
toudl
with
Dr.
Tur,eon,
Director
ot the DiTisiOD ot Ia:t,.U1al BRiene in Qgabeo City_ I plan. to write
to Dr. Tur,eOl1 tttr JlCZ'e up-tCHiate tic='e. on tuberculosis mortality
":; ,'j) ,
end the
a brMlalGa bJ' ale
probl... lore treel.,-
ace croupa than I could
,U.~ UAt
by..n.
to Canada I could disCU8. Ci
~etore plung1D& into' -th:1.11,~~
;
:
however-.. I. procedtzrc
eho1ll.d llb to have ,-ow:' unee a. to the
a. to a~1d crossiZlC aDy adm1n.i.trative
FOp8%" line. ot
l1.n.es or st1rr1nc
0.. -
up
80
troubla witAol3
laacUnc
to
&n7cc:altructi"
result.
I might add that
the Actuarial Diri.ioll hal asked Dr.
in Johnson' Kine fro. t1M, to tiM.
IcConnell about the health com1tiona Dr. lIcConnell'. op1n.1on w8:1 tha't
II
el
.ere
rr~cb-CClad1an,
aDd
1ooked,UDdernourisbed
aDd
that,
the empl01e in hi. op1niol1,
tbe
cl.&1.m
experience
would ~ot
be
very
good.
It bas been
r or this reason tbat
AlII haa Dot 'b OOD 8014. ~
__'".. C! I
J'~0t:.~ ~.
I ..... " ~ _
",
l\1ETROPOLIT'\~ LrrE JXSt.:'RA~CE CO~(Pi\XY
..'~.
.J. R. LVNCH
SUC.VI.O
.J. M. MEEHAN
$Cllt."'cc Su~c ..ytSOIit
OkOUP OIVISION
April 16, 1963
'.'S c .... c... TowCIt
CI .. CIN ....~1 2,0"'0
Tcu....o ..c: 721'0280
Mr. Karl Krieg, Employee Relations Manager The Philip Carey Manufacturing Company 320 South Wayne Avenue Cincinnati 15, Ohio
1... PLAINTIFF'S
~
EcX.H,-IlBIT
Dear Mr. Krieg:
Su?plernenting our lett~r of A?ril 6, attached is a listing
received from the Home Office of death clai~s that were ,aid between 1957 and 1962 due to respiratory causes.
vie hope that this information will be of some use to you.
jrl/ds enclosure cc: Hr. E. J. Fasold, SecretRry
, . 'r
DeAth elD.!..v du:~g t:40 J:6:-~c..l :"i)'.' \'0 j.~w:. ;..r.;;....-..'.;., --, - .'- '-'-
.. I. .
,.rn1eved reque.t.
ill order to ust'lBble data to
The 14entit;r1ng intonation
comp17 vith this policyholder 1.8 IbCJl'm below .eparated b7 pneral
CAUl. ot death.
Hslig2W1t neoplum (cancer) or the respirator)" disease I
l!Ia
~ (' "'-,..
I, . vHaynie,
.,.r, -----, ""IIMlller,
Joe. Geo.;
' (
C-...
~'/~'
rh." . .'
J. ."
c.J.~.-~
.
.' ~I Aahbr1dge, llt'red'-;
I~'~_ 'D-_j __~_ (.
'.,J!:.'
'.
e J 1./-.,.....,
V"" J....I,....-.f-.
,~ . ~, ~ ~ ..
--
I.eesard, 'hl. I:'.. 'Johrt1n, Edva.rd _
,.... t. u; -
,....\. Betancourt, F-l.I.f1no. I
.- ,:.: . SADtel, Be.rrr . ~ ! _
..'"' Stall, Arthur
.'~ -
. ':::jScott, Young . .' "'/" ""
----. lnUev:sk1, W'incenty-'"
~,"\.., .,.;... =~ ,\,,1-., ____
lih1tley, Do:ll'1- '
woods, Alo!tZ:>
. Suis~, Stephen
I ,. _..... '/
...' ..-' -. (,1. ,"."" .;-,)
,
_____
~ , .. " l.
. .. ' .
!u
1.4 51.. :t. 66'"
7)-l-
'iT
67 43 65 S6 58
'iT"' 58 56 ~
-47
'J "''-
or l)o(...sea..!e8
the Resp1.""St0%7 System:
;
.
V:!.nce, Eava.rd. .
. -:;
76
'I
Jclwon, Es,ie (.--J'
~-
. -,' :-"
62t
~ ......-. r"'-J Maletta, Cls:-enco
64"-
Gooch, Herbelt -
63 .\'
EarlJ, Richard -:
57
P4t t6rs on, WI!..
70
I'
., l .. \.~. c-.,..,
Ra;.ond, Levis
. - ~~, Cbu.
54~
7l
I
!
. tI
. ;,'
. '/.~i;
,
.
!
: '
. / . I
, . ,.
I .
I
I
/
h ,
0:.
. ..
"0 .::. ."! :.. .... :.: ..... ~ ..... . .
--'----- . --_._---
-rhi.-. is', .. ,ertif'y chat this is ~ ~ruc: copy or ,he: rc:c:ord which is on file in chc Pcnnsvl''ania Division or V'~I S .
. t acc:n:ili"Icc wich Act 66, P.L J04. approved by the: t';c:ncr:l Assembly. June 2?~ 1953
0
I ,ausu ..
(Fee for ci.is cerciLic:uc. SJ.OO)
'0
_____ WARNING: It is illegal to duplicate this capy by photostat or photograph.
~N_O_V_\_3~1S_8~t__~'1
~(~;!"~;~____~
Date
No.
----- .-.._-.. ~--.
.- --... .... ---..~ ----. --.-
'S::'~~H ~P.~~;t~iiiA lSU.\lU,.C:fT CJI' ""''''TN OI't::U::C ::III" 'IITAI. n"TI:T:=
CERTlr-'ICA'I'E OF DEA'I'H
15680
........ ... ~-
oU. 'ArHII'1 /tANe
-;:;g;. George Lewis
111. "'aI __ u. uauAl. OC:C:IJP'ATIO/t c_ If nUt.'
Shi~t)inCl" clerk
,.ft...... l"nJ...l.:::O IJa.re., h ..~nes .a. ~O.
.,.1 '.'l ' la. :A"ilAsa"T01". o0lA"'h,._ [I"\a_ t ..., - ..... -
1"- MOT"""" :&AIOCM lIAMC
th Breaks
n"Y It__ .1'1.1"1'0....,,'
13h \oI&~~~ Aft.
:t..ar"J' ~son N,Vn;;",C'~~ ~a '
.MCDICo'" C::nIll"ICATIO..
I"'" ,.,. 'a). ", "
alT~ eMCr_ DC.
.....COIATit c:,t.USC Cal
lZGI. ~ ACCIOC"T JVICIO' ~IOMI12a.. O'sc:All' IIQW IIt.IU"" OC:C:UM&O.
~
~
clae
,.,
......,,"U""' OCCIJ""CO
:\20.. ~cc IW IIU\,lA" ,.....
""'II. . . _ /let _ile _
...... ,.... ,. . ." "'Mt. ,I'" .
Cln. DOROUGH.
.~., ,
1m.. n.. .-.
..
t"","
"l-or.
TOWIl"'I~ :'
COUll"
_
a.-. ...
.TATe
-a u a"_a Ll
~..... L-
.. , ...... 1 .. -.
.,," ... tt2'1.57.. ..... .. S.:.s.O' . e" ..P. 21. I /Mr.........,. 1M' I ."..... U&8 " ....... ''''''' J..Ijo,J~";., .... 11_ Ie '._~".~'.(.I'l"'." aa.c I .... _ elY ~~
~ ~ 'ltce ....,,' _ _,
~.s.~ ~ ,a. ____ .. ,a. cI.e,.ICC
.' r ..."=.,.-,.=.., II' ... ..'.....l..B. - .:..:..'.".. I iff'J ( a" diAn, r'';''c:.r.r.~ti_ .. -l~-H" ~--Oc:6522 en. . A ... "it .,,-."!...
O H IOOIVICSEIOPNAAOT~ l oVtIETNA 'T-
Of" t-fEAI..TH
STATISTlC
... - - ,....
I ;",......... 0... \ -
:S
C:ERTrl'"'CA.TE01'" CEATH
-
.. -
.......... N..
,J "'Ilt .
" ~'-"<:c I .. ~, 1
I' I. USUAl. A&51DtNei .,.~ .'..............' _.....:.
I .
:t3r.:4._ ..
.:-cm,-;,'~Oi ux..iiOee
"
t.
UooG'"
QI
S f
,.
I.
0' .
; - - - : : - 0S f' ". f.,i'. 1~1: 0o..
'"
'IC~~~"O"
-....C.i.C.-IUo!o.".l.".f.t:.:.:,:...... ..
_._._-_.::,- -
01
~
..
1:;X.u:.:!UldTt
.. ... 01
,"~.~.f',...!... RE..,rDP..N..".'E
II ...... ~..,.,
~'N!f AOO.III
" - &.,
._--._-
-.,"'::i"ro::"~ACI~'::"':M~'lIO~U~I.::'~'''~I.:~'D:'l.I'''C:':'l"~,~,~.~,,:'l,,:------------.:...-.~la!!'. !',ll.~c~ !Slr:GI!.;.~Cl~r.Ie.."vOi.
~
"
. ..A.Y.e
" u"
...
.
----"!,.-,~,.,i.si
~.
342.'; SErfS ?ENUE
c
.' ". .. I
, ..
----'''' ...."'! ",.....,....
"
...,... '" 050502 "
".
OHIO OEP"RTMENT OF HEAL.TH
DIVISION 0" VITA&. STATISTIC:S
CERTIFICATE OF OEATH
a - . Not.
::-:-~,~,"'I'i"!".- -
(
I .., ......,.... __.. ' . ':::.:1.:"" 7.~"'A"'C 0
_
~
w.
' ., ..... ....... u..
_Dec CASCO I":!!~"-"
Cl.a.renc.
0-
R u l e t . t . . ..... Jlllr" 1960_
J.an
: ., co~o. o. UCI ,P. ........ J;I ....,.. ........ t..::. ....... 0- ..... 1 4IG& ". -" If ._ ,_. II ._ :
_~".
.
,I _....~ II..,~ .., o_ ccur.."..I,t._
Wl?,1t..
_ .' _
.....::!.~ 4_. I....... o.
C1U,ts
0fW01Cft
o......."
C... .I!t .=...'j1'.i-i~;';:\i ~
..
64.
_..
~ 11__ I I II. a ...... I,
.. I ..., , 12_I,~ e..,.,.,c,,.-g, ,-r',-"r.- -,-" - , f~f~iQt~:u-=.r. 'IlAa~u=lP'!"m1i:O.D.,.).,,.,..M..x_ O~",''~'''~_J.q...._.
-CIDlUSMfILOr9- _
, _ _'!:.aae gu.lA.tt.....,.~...- _ ___..--........
. i"
Illella.La:b
.!OCI", IS ...; er.....D , .... ,. u." ....... IOICI"
,
frIO.N .........o ._ " .,... . _ _... ~, ,_.,
IlCUI'" NO, {". IN'eRMANT'S 5iGNATi'U,.RII"IEI!I'""--"O:.-.'~. _~.~-
., ......
aSl': Crest.".".-cl.
a.
7;J
w
,. (;AU5C OriSE"TW : .,,. "..,." '_11,,, II.. ,.. .,.........;
.-.....----'-. _.
I .--.eo- .' Oto,,, ;
, ..., I. DIA'" W"S CioUSI. p. - .....,. CAlI.. _
fg&' rl.1I
, 41==~
..
"
i ...~. c
L _-_ 0 ~.
.l.:" / ' I }DIII '0 ," / . I '-- , I
c...'...,.._,.... .I"f., I ...
.
P
:l~ ~,.,..,.7,~
v
~~~ ".~"
k:.~-.!...t::.:.
_.._.. .",. . "a-r I
--J--' ._. - - -,' 1-'" "i~-/"::-,-: - -,--7'",--
. I .. (".J4-- ,. ....,' :=~:;: 011' to'ff ~~~
I . . . , .I!.::!'~
;I .."I . _,:rZ_:e..:,.. ....-' ....... ..:._M-- - .. .... .... .,.;'::,:.",.r:: 'r, 'i\" ......
~~
,= ::.. I; __. ---Ln CCIOINf
"'ICIDI
1 . ~_ "
lIQM.aol I 20'. GI,calli IItOW I.""~ 0=
. ',/
0
~I!D...~....!.:..
~~ . . . . . 1 ,." I. ,.,... I.., U .9, ,.~ , . ,
;; . -
1i r:: ..... "- .... ,: 2;'~~r.:'
::! I b"., i .... ;
-"
~<f'~'
~~ -'0 ."
;:.01 ~ i ',CIot',';"," OeQ/II.D
... IUCI 0' ...,un 't. , , ........., .._. _:-~. .""...
loC....... ; ..:-!\sc. COlI"'"
"I \.
w " ...,,... NO' W."I ~ !
':!'!
At wo.. _.
1- 1-...... - ,... *44....... ,
/,. . . ')
\" ,..'~.
',e.:.. (.. . , ~i""'--~--~=:---
n.'_....... r: - 11O.,? ,,,::1.- 4.._'...
8:-;;0
~.""".;_:=-~~ I ::A~_
t, ". -& ,....., D...1t ..,...,4
'1"'~ I : . . I. ,IN "" ., . ,.....-~ ,... ,~......t.: "
."",...z:, -n~SIGN.'TUlft~. _,
,"6 , ... _'1 --;In.'aiTai.:.!'1 T ~&'7 .~. 2b....rIS'C
~ I : ~.J... \of~ (7,":
~ ~. 1:,1;4 .......'..... ~,:z:::.-)-=, -'\~.~. 'l~
'4".t
,........ ....6.... "r....' .... ~,
,we. _.t
;.1. ,,,......, o...ao..a I.GN~U'U
...e.....
:
"!'hr:)=U P. Wat.Soc______":"!',mA-.,.'""!I'Iro"~-~_'-
-~".".:.I.-::C.I=."-,
_-'=.' ----'1
"/""...
t
.
.
<
.
.
-
.
....
,_._.J..22.5
_
_
; '2-,v-i..., ;ii.'_0 ADaHU'
IIIKII ..0.1 ..
: Vorh1s Funeral Homes, ~c. 310 DImA St.
~ckl.Iincl
Ohio
J1'''''''''"hilS~Giih;';i'' iiiN.,Ui.
29. tu".I~." i'il'c:;.."'UI'-'--"----
'" ~...~fi;') ,
.' I
')
RWirib 5 &:a**?if s
LWL
" -.
l
- --e61Sas:::: _-D-'t- 1,-_ .' .....: u.-o. s..
.... ,,,., -r__O.- .:~
~
OHIQOIYIOSIEOPNA0R"TMYIET"N'T~
OF MEAI..TH
STATISTICS
! I . - ,. . . . .
CERTIFICATE OF OEATH
-.-......... _
.. '"
(
..
' - .~
(
'he:, 9 NaRK Eb "
..
-----_ .-.............
... _.
...
-. _...._.__.....-- - .-._._. -_-......................-._---