Document nNowKe5QeO6xjb9GE7k2xLKw
oojrao t o x j t t o * axtr* jo s*XSDa 40X^m jo xoc^cmts X| * t9ST4maB 9T<prc t*U t*oosa3fH x*ojHdo P* (Tll) #J^Toy Taoqx x*THajjTa sjo n p o jj Tx n*##oD jo w x y * 4x$Oa jo x*mmn *211 n*X
*P
*u>33 ax&pra o j T^pton 2#a <0j*4ip 4psm 9t*&n sjsp T p*TT *Tfa** H? **#ck
jou oop xsDa 4t*x4ooaoT ro sa d o 20 vxs w s M xssa pwritT *00 tpW * ohtxo*X ao/pw xTote]D irp n so ^
o u p o H J o d o g p o u p a ! *<q pmUx*Wt T X 3 T * w o j > * n X W .
*T-*mpa O H S o q j o * > o * 2 d ot|H pw zm ax xi-p! *PP#* B^T^anr osotp JE^o shsjx po* X W x*%wm o*p o aj
pWMfftJGI* * * * T W * T O | O T H W B 2 0 J O T ,, * o n 3 O * & K 0 ao/pii
HJT****X trjojws oh srpssrj pojjtod*# sx3*S T! T TO-XOOJH OHW 204 Xx*W 4XS3tI JO **T**B JO *wb*S* *i
X^* *HH o *H*p jU jAirt 1 pjmxo** *XSO# M po*tim *Xdto*o BTsrj; tjj XT* jo H*p p r d |^ |t a ropnraoa ax^wj
T*i **^0 ompx ojhosssod jo uojejAjt *v& po Ufm*t *2 *S *<q SX***TK *OH*qy xo ojonpoaa TT othwbso^ X*T ** 0 3 jo
V0TH$THttAOX ofj JO HXso jo *tnX amm*B *TW XXK
**
iDaaviptaif
* t H 9 m 0 3 0 2 j j j p Xox-cc 4 p W q o H p x * 3 T 3 x u
si4oxaax *2 *s **a X `ttottjaodttoa jo ooodnd 20J popoxostj oxv rp ratoxa 03*038 20j noftpox o t J ojhmwoo jo pro* XSDC
Op 2J pwprjqo *H*f> SOT*|2*M XW JO 80J20 2 potjom v
9 a *
* H O f i p O j ^ O X X a p a M O ^ a * * n o o r > P** X o p S p o o u i 4(fP) * 0 W T T ? * * o $ p A p o y pxT4 * T n T *x**TR
ojooqsy 20J XTOay *,XSOa JO *mo*98 f*nn*H*X
iplt25 O O J H T 0 ^ O D ? 3 A p O * #w x n n o i
OOjHjMXltBOO HSmpOHa JOJ'O * T * a *h x ih m o i o m t
X i o x p a i p o x sz 'ftv m o o j o i T 9 j A x a xojooixct
< o t p - 0 o o w w o j a *r * o j !
pW2& tty:|?*Odttcr) 35*paJC
w * x *i ? W i
91/L /T S**
^ 7 * * 3 * 1 **& W f-M K *m n+ ~ iM *m x W ' m 19
]>**Xt*tt* itomi* XV* * * j
'n'fSMKXE * <rfn**| *35 *$ * * * & * J * i * ^ s n a X*t ^ T M K I * T W
*THX ,,^T^swajJTii X*H-a M
pa *3Tiew*^ ao* *T*X
o * 3 * o o
2<* * * # X j * i y * ttrn**x * 2 $ | / U m $ H * 1 * T W
*
~~
SAMPLE #
PRODUCT NAME AND MFG.
14 Desitin Baby Powder, Antibacterial; Pfizer
26 Helen Pressl "Little Lady"
29 Johnson's Baby Powder
35 Lewis Baby Powler
37 Macy's Scented Borated Talcum
38 Macy's Talcum, Apple
42 Mennen Quinsana Foot Pcwder
50 Quest Deodorant Powder;
52 Riviana Foods-Italian Stearin Talc; For Rice
53 September M o m By Pond's
54 Seven Winds After Bath Talc; DuBarry
56 Vaseline Intensive Care Baby Powder (same as 130)
57 Yves Saint Laurent Rive Gauche Spray Talc
58 Z B T Baby Powder
59 Zeasorb Super Absorbent Medicated Powder;' Stiefel
60 Ambush-Dana Dusting Powder
61 April Showers
62 Avon Unforgettable Perfumed Talc
63 Beloved Perfumed Dusting Powler, Prince f%tchabelli
CODE (1139Z) (028Q)
(2K4) (H202)
(19B) (021085) (1209) (F1021)
(9884)
S. Z. Lewin's Results (X-Ray Diff.) Trennolite (%) Chrysotile (%)
ND(2) '
ND
ND ?
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND ND p
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
ND ND
5% ND
Tremolite (fiber/mg) Chrysotile Optical Microscopy (%) - DTA
- ND
ND ND
ND 200 (.02%)(3)
ND ND ND
600 (.06%) -
ND p ND
- ND
- ND
- ND
- ND
- ND
- ND
- ND
- ND
700 (.07%)
ND
- ND
36,000 (3.6%) ND
68 Faberge Flambeau Deodorant Spray Powder 70 Jeris Talc, Flesh A & B 71 Jolie Madame Dusting Powder, Balmain 72 Lady Esther Face Powder, Rachel 73 A&B Max Factor Face Powder, Rachelle 74 Medicated Comfort Powder; Parke-Davis 75 OH! de London Talc; Yardley 77 Touch and Glow Face Pcwder, Creamy Peach; Revlon 78 Toujours Moi Bath Powder; Corday 79 Yardley April Violets 80 Chantilly Dusting Powder; Houbigant 81 Cashmere Bouquet, Imported White Talcum Powder 82 Jean Nate Talc 84 Shower To Shower Body Powder; Johnson & Johnson 85 Pure Baby Powder, Dart Drug
86 Pond's Dream Flower Perfumed Talc
87 Almay Hypo-Allergenic Face Powder
88 Constance Carroll, Bouquet Talc
89 Djer-Kiss Talcum; Kerkoff 90 Flamingo Dusting Powder, Tussy 92 Mavis Talcum; Vivaudou
iNi_> ND ND 3% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 3% ND 5% ND ND ND ' ND ? ND ? ND ? ND ? ND ? ND ? ND ? 4% 5% 5% 5% 3% 5% 5% 5%
500 (.05%) ND ND 3,300 (.33%) 2,800 (.28%) 96,000 (9.6%) ND ND ND 7,000 (.7%) 2,900 (.29%) 4,000 (.4%) 7,300 (.73%)
ND ND ND ND ND ? ? ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND
94 95 96 97 99 100 101 102 107 131 133 134 .135 136 137 138 143 144A 145 148 149
Tangee; Luft-Tangee ZBT Baby Povder Blanchard's Dusting Powder B o m Wild Existing Powder; Del Labs A&B Lander Lilacs and Roses Deodorant Body Talc Miss Dior Dusting Powder Tai Winds Spray Talc; Avon A&B Tosca Dusting Poder Coty Muguet des Bois Dusting Powder Johnson & Johnson Medicated Powder Johnson's Baby Powder Johnson's Baby Powder Johnson & Johnson Medicated Povder Johnson & Johnson Shower to Shower Body Powder Johnson & Johnson Showier to Shcwer Body Poder Johnson & Johnson Shower to Shcwer Body Povder Pin-Zow Talque; Perfection Beauty Products, Inc. Overton's "High-Brown" Face Poder Softee Face Powder Lady Wayne Face Powder Solitaire Cake Makeup
4% - 2% 8% 12% ND ND 15% 10% ND trace ND ND ND ND ND ND 5% 5% ND 2% 8%
?
3% 10% 15% ND ND ND 7% ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 10% ? 2% ND p
2,500 (.25%) 300 (.03%) 5,600 (.56%) 13,000 (1.3%) ND trace 60,000 (6%) 8,900 (.89%) ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 1,800 (.18%) 400 (.04%) ND trace 3,000 (.3%)
ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND
152 Corsage Dusting Powder; Lander 153 Ammens Powder, Medicated 154 Bismoline Medicated Powder 155 Rite Aid Pure Baby Powder 156 Warner Pure Baby Pbwder 157A Mavis Imported Talcum 158 Avon Brocade Perfumed Talc 159 Avon Blue Lotus Perfumed Talc 160 Avon Beauty Dust Refill -Charisma 163 Pinaud Clubman Talc 164 Grand Union Baby Powder 165 CashmereBouquet 167 Tawny Tone Body Talc From Blade Heritage; Beauty
Mustus, Inc. 168 Colgate Tooth Powder 169 Dr. Lyon's Tooth Powder 170A "C" Bouquet Talc; Winarick, Inc. 173A Corsage Dusting Powder; Lander Co. 175A lander Baby Powder 176A Lander Lilac & Roses Body Talc
(101672) (4212DX)
(2662)
ND ND ND ' ND 2% ND ND ? 2% ND 6% 8% ND ND ND ? ND trace 10% 10% ND 1% ND ?
2% ND ND ND ND ND ND 8% ND ? ND ? ND ?
ND ND 200 (.02%) ND 200 (.02%) 9,000 (.9%) ND ND ND 9,000 f.9%) trace ND
? ND ND ND ND ND ND ND
ND ND ND . 6,300 (.63%) -
-
ND ND ND 'ND ? ND ND
194 Tinkerbell Dusting Powder; Ttm Fields,' Ltd.
ND ?
(1) Results are shown for only those talc products analyzed by both Lewin and DCST.
(2) n d - Not Detected
(3) DCST tremolate % is based on following conversioni 1000 fibers/mg talc = 0.1% tremolite
where average tremolite fiber dimensions are 5 x 15 JM.
If itiassumed that microscopist sees 10% of fibers present, % values would be increased 1 order of magnitude.
ND
Sample No.
63 71 77 78 88 89 90 92 93 94 95 96 97 101 102 131
c, iinu/uK CHRYSOTILE
S. Z. Lewin's Results (X-Ray Diff.)
Tremolite (%)
Chrysotile (%)
5 3 3 5 4 5 3 5 5 4 2 8 12 15 10 trace
ND ND ND ND 5 5 5 5 4 ? 3 10 15 ND 7 ND
DCST'S Results
Tremolite (fiber/mg) Optical Microscopy
36,000 (3.6%) ND
2,800 (0.28%) 96,000 (9.6%)
7,000 (0.7%) 2,900 (0.29%) 4,000 (0.4%) 7,300 (0.73%) 5,100 (0.51%) 2,500 (0.25%)
300 (0.03%) 5,600 (0.56%) 13,000 (1.3%) 60,000 (6%) 8,900 (0.89%)
ND
Chrysotile (%)~DTA
ND ND
? ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND
--
ND ND ND ND
143 144A 145 148 149 154 156 157A 160 163 164 167 170A
i'remolite (%)
5 5 ND 2 8 2 2 6 ND 10 ND 2 ND
Chrysotile (%)
10 ? 2 ND ? ND ND 8
trace 10 1 ND 8
Tremolite (fiber/mg) Optical Microscopy
1,800 (.18%) 400 (.04%) ND trace
3,000 (0.3%) 200 (0.02%) 200 (0.02%)
9,000 (0.9%) ND
9,000 (0.9%) trace ND
6,300 (0.63%)
Chrysotile (%)-DTA
--
ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND --
--
ND ND
COSMETIC TALCS ANAT.A!'7111 BY LENIN AND REPORTED TO CONTAIN CIIRYSOTIL : AND/OR TREMOLITE
WHICH WERE NOT ANA1.Y2 ,D BY DC ST BY EITHER DTA OR OPTICA .MICROSCOPY
rCaVipl No
66 67 76 91 108 109 111 130 172 . 183 184 187 188 .189
Treirolite
ND ryc/ro/
Lewin Resuits (X-Ray Biff,} Chrysot
0-/7o
ND
3% ND
ND 5%
2% ND 2% ?
1% trace
ND trac
2% ND 1ay ?
J~ /i
/o ND
2% ND ?
1%
1% ND
According to John Stuart's notes, the above samples are not present in the lot of Lewin'! Inventory of Levin's talcs verified that DOST does not possess the above samples.
Analytical Method
Source
Total Analyzed
Chrysotile Detected
Tremolite Detected
BY DIFFERENTIAL THERMAL ANALYSIS (OTA) AND OPTICAL MICROSCOPY (OM)
S. Z . Lewin 78
Differential Thermal Analysis
FAS Investigational and Consumer
7f-
-82'
2
5? (2)
0
0
NA NA NA
Optical Microscopy -
S . Z . Lewin
FAS
Investigationa and Consumer
57 u )
oK 47
//. *
00
0
30 0
o'
(1) Includes 25 of 37 samples in which S. Z. Lewin reported presence of tremolite by x-ray diffraction. DCST detected tremolite in 22 of the 25 samples. DCST detected tremolite in 8 samples where S. Z. Lewin reported none detected.
(2) Results on all 5 samples were ambiguous due to Interferences and/or low levels of chrysotile.
TABLE IV
SUMMARY OF S. Z. LEWIN'S ANALYSES OF COMMERCIAL COSMETIC TALCS FOR TREMOLITE AND CHRYSOTILE BY X-RAY DIFFRACTION
No. cf Samples Analyzed
195
Samples Only Chrysotile Detected
6
Samples Only Tremolite Detected
24
Samples Tremolite and Chrysotile Detected
13