Document n9Le8xea2QRrBn3OV1jJ38q82
v~
brite ISMM
EEnnvviirroonnmmenetnatla,l,
Heal
Heat
4
Safety Operations
PEertms an 0Box 1001
651 77964~2
am January 26, 2004
MMrr.. DDaavvee DDoouuglgalass..
Sic Unk SSuperidSecon Superfund Unit ~Supeffund Section Mrs md had Dion Majors and Rcmediation Division Nikon Pome Cnty Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 520 pa Resa 520 Lafayette Read North Ss St. Paul, MN 55155-4] 94
RECEIVED p Atrnr.l12rspkDnin
Re: Cont Onder AddendumandFalitywidePorsches lvestignion Consent OrderAddendum and Facility-wide Fluorochemica] Investigation er Pa, 51Cog Grav Work Plan, 3M Cottage Grave Site
Dea Me Dongs Dear Mr. Doughs: Ents, les fd bth te roped Co Order (CO) Added 1 he reid Fide Enclosed, please find both the proposed Consent Order (CO) Addendum and the revised Facility-wide frredonietetihs FlaoroehemieaI Investigation Work Plan. Se you ees, oe deelopd eccho o rch vstieion wk As you requested, 3M has developed a mechanism to continue the fluorochemioat investigation work under erroofpein CO. SM bie a 4 le drCOss hemk the existing CO. After review of the original CO, 3M believes that a simple addendum to the CO is the most cen ebcova apn 0B es to Bnd pe Pt efficient mechamsm to respond to this request. The use of an addendum in this manner is anticipated in Part SVE fnC0 ntsc wih MPNcorpndes cne Odobe 6,20be5cc,n ale XV] ofhhe CO. In accordance with MPCA correspondence dated October 16, 2003, the enclosed addendum emis gogomobhs 6 CO spFoat Fut] 8Fo VS RL provides language that modifies the CO specific to Part C, Part 1 and Part XV, as requested. lo rls fhe eid Bhindi eck pa. The work plo bad en rvisly Also enclosed is the revised fluor~ehemical investigation work plan. The work plan had been previously mint do oh PC oto com, WPCA st eeedah oh, submitted in draft form to the MY'CA for review and comment. MPCA staff approved the dxaft work plan, i saga mato. The MCA tgoscd pobre. hv ben rovowe1 Bove bee with suggested modifications. The MPCA suggested modifications have been reviewed and have been er ve onl wk po. Ti fk holo Sls it ori chars coin incorporated into the final work plan. This final work plan also contains minor wording 0hange~ consistent CO a sda Te wkpl + 22 Gi 0 CO 2 snd Bn develop of with the CO and addendum. The work plan is an exhibit to the CO addendum and during development of cb eh oe it gs HS ORs cones we 5 10 re the addendum the need for these minor changes was identified. Other changes were also made to more ee tid van dry 1 accurately reflect fluoroehemical nomenclature and history at the site. Pls review the dcaudemidesnniosr cops To Fin ofsylfa 65177 Please review the documents and provide any additional comments to Todd Farking of my staff at 651-778ot ry Sen ooft ean who Fa mt wi TCASl yo 5344. If you have any significant points of concern, 3M would be happy to meet with MPCA staff at your Tea. Fengyout al EMALhe wrk hows 6 lk hs el reque~. Pending your approva!, we will begin the work as shown in the work plan schedule.
sinceret.~..
R=obe. Pe PE DEE. Robert A. Pasehke, EE., D.E.E.
Nims Cope Ect Pogans Manager, Corporate Environmental Programs MMR CA co: Mr. Mark Rys, MPCA
Vi Tod adi, MMrr._ TPaoudldBFoaoskk,inEgR, 3GM . Mr. P~ul Book, ERG
Enclosure
.
r-- ave e~xLet72 ,
CCCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDOGEETNNCTTOIIAUARLL-T-,SSUUNoBB.JJEE2CC7.TT0TTv-OO10AA.P2P6RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE
ORDER
ORDER
ENTERED
ENTERED
IN
IN
HENNEPIN
HENNEPIN
COUNTY
COUNTY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00000011
Exhibit 1932
Pre 3M MN00044012
FIRSTADDENDUM TO CONSENT ORDER FIRSTADDENDUM TO CONSENT ORDER
entOOernnedMMaianyylo3300a,, C11o99n885s5,e, n33tMWOCCrdooemmrpparaennlyayti((v33eMM){)0aannthddetthiheneveMMsitinningeaestsoioolntaa aPPnoodflllurtteioomnnedCCiaaortnlirtoronoll oAAfggepernnoccpyyer((lMMyPPtCChAAe)n)
Knownas the entered into known as the
3M Chemosle Ste located a Consent Order relative
3M Chemolite Site located
into
in
the Citoyf Collage Grove. Minneso'a. the investigation and remediation of
the City ol~ Cottage Grove, Minnesota.
property
then
`addtIinnfoaanccaccloorarddcaatnniccieeeswwiiptthuhrsPPauarartnttXXVVoII pardodviitisoinoanloafcttihveitiCeosnpsuenrstuaOnrdt etro
toohffistthhFeeirGsCtoonAnsdseednnettnOOdrurddmeerr,t,o ntholis eFxpirrsetsAsldydeanmdeunmdetdo
3GtMMhe bthye
aaCrnoddnsMMePPnCtCAAOrnndooewwr (ddAeedssdiireeendttuoom)cc.oonnddAuunccytt iCsonAsdednet nOdrudmersh(Aaldldreonmdauimn).InAfnuyl
force and provision
force and
effect of the
effect
nl terminated Consent Order
until terminated
by the terms of not expressly
by the terms of
ho Consent amended by
the Consent
Order. this Addendum
Order.
shall
remain
in
full
11.. SSttaatetmeemnetnootff FFaaccttss
2.
a.
fTTuhhueerennaarmemfeeerooefnf ctthehsee ssshiitateel hhbaaesstobbeeheeenn"ccChhoaalnlnagggeeeddGffrrfooomvme""SCCihehe"emmoiliete"" tfoo " CCooftllaoggee GGrroovvee"" aanndd aalll
b.
b.
efBBuiyytguh1r1te09f88ro77er,,fmee33rreMMndcissesaapsttoiissssfhafalaaccltaltorboreierlayytsoccaootthmmehppei"lsCeltoeeotddtaaganeRdRe,GemrmbaoadevsiedeaidaSllioteIInnn"v.vheeesststiieggaatrtiieoosnnusaa,nndd1FFseeaaMssiPsibiCiilAiltyyaSSptptuurddoyyveoodff
S2eaiignRRcheeets'sfppooor1mnn9ss8eee7r,AAdcics3ttpiMooonnsaPPhllalaaasnrneffacoorosrhnatdhetuestchseleeeffdsooirtremgmraeeonrrudddn,iidssbwppaaooslsseeaadlrl
aaorrmneeoaatsnhs.ei. scernregsualtts,
the
site
MPCA approved
monitoring and
c. IpSpnrrinoo1dcd9ueu9cc7tt,iito9onon8f7wit,elhlels3sMraaennqdduheassssuutbbommcfioitlntteehdedducttMhthePeedCssAeo,grrreeoSssuuuMlnlttdsscwtotoomatpttelhereetWMmePdPoCnCaAitdA.od.rionngalatqrsoiutendumaotenritosrtinudgiesanfdn
d. `tIthnhceeo1m9arp9rloe7iaa,edaootafftnhttdheheaerpepffqorourromemvseeetrdrbowwfyattahshesteeMMddPiPissCCppAooA,ssaaI3lnlM2aa0rrce0eoa3ampDDlBe8.t.edTTahhdeedssieteionsstatuulddgiiereossunwwederwreeatessraattsiestfufaadcciietoosrrilliyny
.
e.
IccInnhoem22m00pi00cl3e3a,t,led33MMparnoppdprreoaorvvtpiiipdcdreseo,ddvettoadonbMMdyPPtCChtehAAeMssttPraaeCffsfuAffloolinuusrr2cc0ooof0mm3p.npauacmctet rddoiissukksssssuhumemmamalarrizzaiinnndgg tthhseaefepplhhyyyssiiscctaaulldiaaennsdd,
eacchhhtaeahrmraeacicctCtoaeorlrtiizzapiingnrgeogpGcceererrortttiveaaiesinn,Sppteeae.rnrlfdluuoordtihnneaatteorddesccuoolmmtsppoouounfnddsns.u. mTThheoerossueesssuuhbbsestataaltnnhcceessanhhdaaddsbbaoefeee~nn" pprrsootdududuccieeesdd,
1.
f.
`aBBtoecttthwwoeeomeeCnnopt2t2oa00ag00uel11nsGeaardlnnooddvcste22cS00l0i0tse33.,,moa3nMiMtoccroionmmgppoelenttdeeddprggodrrouocuutnniddowwnaatitelersr .tteesstTtiinhnegg rooeffsttuaasrrgogeeftthppeeerrlftlueuscotrdsinnwaaetireeedd.
9. ppcInroroom2vv0ipid0do3eeu,ddnttdaootsthtahhoetesMMerPlePeqCCcuAtAeissiitntneo22fm0000to5h3n,e.itoMrPinCgAa,nd3Mprocdoumpctlioetnewdegllrso.unTdhweatreesruslttsuoifetshefotceusstsinwgeorne
g. ttsIanatrrugg2deei0tot0spp3ee,wreraffrltuueootrhcdieonnmaarptteeleqdoduteccehshdetemimonific2cat0ahl0less5.iMinnPtthhCeeAra, re3eaMa oocffottmhheepflfeootrremmdeergrrwwoaaussnttdaewddaiistsepproosssataulldaairereesaafoDD1cI.u.siTTnhhgeesoseen.
1.
h.
sipInnrtuathdchtoieeiscffaelwsllleoofrffeo22rc00o00pm3e3,r,pf33lueMoMteriadanggairrnteeo2eed0dd0ftc3ooh. ccoooimcmappleletteesuaabsfcaticatinlyicty-e-wswiiddaefe eetvvhaaelluuaaCtotiifooinnagooefthf.e thGerwowavsaets.etedSdiiissppooassnaadll
spsWuuroabbrcmmktiiiPcttteleeasddnwfaaoarFFsaapcaceipilriipftylyru--oowwvriiiednddeaetbeFFydilutuohocerrhooMeccmhPheeCicrmAaiiclciaanlsluNIIbonnsvvvteeeassmnttbciiggeeaasrttiio2oa0nn0t 3WW.tahorerkk CPPollatatnangtteoo
tio MPCA. Grove Site
the MPCA.
Theand
The
1i.. NW NroeonosnperekecoPtoflfat10nthhaewenayffasacactatsispsmpserseottvfueofnodrrrttbahhythehtehedrereeoiMinnosPrshChapAaellrlibnsboeNencosocvnnoesonmtisbadideeeprrraee2rddt0ya0da3fmod. imisissssiAioodnndssebnbydyuaemti.htheerrpparatryty wwiitthh
respect to any claims unrelated to or persons not a party to this Addendum.
22.. SSccooppee ooff tthhee AAddddeenndduumm
WorT"kThheePlAAadndddaeenndddeuusmmcrissbhheaadlll iggnooEvvXeerhrnnbitthh1ee opprrhoovvsiissiAoidnodnseoonffdtuthhmee. FFaaccliliyty--vwiiddee FFlluuocrroocchheemmiiccaall iInnvveessttiiggaattiioonn
Work Plan as described in Exhibit 1 to this Addendum.
`CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALLRT--,SSUUNOBB,JJEE2CC7-TT0TTV-OO10AA.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00000022
3W_MNO0D44013
3M MN00044013
33.. RReeccoovveerryy ooff EExxppeennsseess
`aFalssussAAooosrsccoiiacaa2thteeeddmccioowwcnniadidttlihihtliIoonMMnnvPePsCooCtffiAAgttahtaiaiicsscoitinivAvAWiidtdiioedderseseknnrrddPeeuulllammaatn,i,inagg33sMMttaooppaaccrgagarorrrrerveyyeeeiindssnggbttyoooouuMrtrtPeeCititmhAhmee,bbuupprrTrssrhooeeveviiststahiihomeoenonsusMMnoPotPfofCCfttAAhrheeefifoomFFrrbaauececrixxilispptbyeee--mnnwiessidndeeetses
fossFrhhlatualhollleronnycooethtaeeermxxsccice2eaee0ldd0I4nftvwaweeensrndtlitgy2ya0ttt0hih5oo.onuusWsaaonnrddk
(520,000) dolars pr Plan as approved by
($20,000) dollars per
calyeeanrodrpaararl calendar yea! MPCA. The amount of reimbursement
calendar year or partial calendar year
for the years 2004 and 2005.
4. Effoctvo Date
4. Effective Date
"This
This
Addendum
Addendum
iiss
effffeeccitivvee
uuppoonn
tthh e
ddaatteo
tthhee
llaasstt
rreeqquuiirreedd
ssiiggnnaattuurer
is
aaffffiixxeedd
hheerreettoo..
AAAUNU5TDTBYHHYSOOTU"RHiRB-IHESITTEIIYYDIRRITTASSOORIIGIBBGENIINNSNAIADDTTTUUTT1RHHRS EEEESSSOPPAHAHAERREGRTTRREIIEEIEEINESSN,D,TT:TTHHHHEEEEYYUURRNNEEDDPPERERRERESSSSEIIENGGNTNN,TEE,DDTTHHRREEEIIEPRRRAAPEGGSEERENNNTTETSST,T,SHHCCAAOEOTTNNTTNTTHHRREETAAYYCCTTHHOOAARRVVSESE
AND SUBSIDIARIES IT IS SO AGREED:
BrBy: 3M Company 3M Company
Signature: Signature: ie: - 3 Title:
Date
IT 1IS5 S5O0 OORRDDEERREEDD::
BByy:: MMiinnnneessoottaa PPoolluluttiioonn CCoonnttrrooll AAggeennccyy
SSiiggnnaattuurree:: Tie: -
Gain
Date
Title:
`CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALLRT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTV-OO10AA-PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00000033
3W_MNOOD44014
3M MN00044014
EXE 1 EXHIBIT 1
`CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALLRT--,SSUUNOBB,JJEE2CC7-TT0TTV-OO10AA.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00000044
3W_MNO0D44015
3M MN00044015
FFaacciilliittyy.-wwiiddee FFlluuoorroocchheemmiiccaali IInnvveessttiiggaattiioonn WWoorrkk PPllaann
33MM CCoottttaaggee GGrroovvee
Prepared for:
Prepared for:
3M
3M
EEnnvviirroonnmmeennBtutaailll dTTieenccghhn4no2ol-loo26ggyy
aanndd
SSeerrvviicceess
9900B00SutBBi.lduuPiassnuhhgl,AA4vvM2ee-N2nnEuuee
St. Paul, MN
PPrroeppaarroeddbbyy::
EEnnvviirroonnmmeen1nt0ta0al0l
RRDeeSssooCuuorrnccteeerGGrroouupp,,
LLG:
LLC
M88i00nnSS1aoo0au0upt0tohhlIiDEEsiSi,gghChMtteNhhnSSt5et5trrr4ee0ee2tt
Minneapolis, MN 55402
January27,
January 27,
22000048
`CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALLRT--,SSUUNOBB,JJEE2CC7-TT0TTV-OO10AA.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00000055
33MW_MMNNO000D04444001166
FocCotaisdsGrFovue rFoarc vestytonWet ln Faciti~-wide Fluorocarbon Investigation Work Plan
3M Cottage Grove Facility
Sonny 21,2000 Janua~ 21,2004
IINNTTRROODDUUCCTTIIOONN
sOOSmttennaatfffifSSntteeoogpp,ddltieiessmbmccobubutessehrssr 3p22pe3M3er,,rffal22lun00uo0do0r3r3o,ot,cchhtthohehaeemmMiiMPMcciaCainnllAsnsnee((saFsFoocCCt'tk'aassn))oPPaawootell}ttdhuhugteeiooen33ndM}CChoCConaontottrttrttootaallhggoAeAeuGggGgreehornnovccFvyyeeCs((ffMaaMccwPPileCCitAyrA))((sKsmmitnteeeeot))t.wwwniAi_t0AhhtLttI3hhbMiieMse:
prmpOOherrereedsdeseeepternirrnnetgbbtsa,yyaetntbCCcoottohatnehnesassene3slnidnMtotet pd((aoduCCntruOOdior)in)nn,,gtightthlehtheehiMeesttckePecoccCoohhmfmAnnpFooplClalloeeocag.gtkiiyyonnnoRwwowoaaofclssefodantnnagtsoosekltkadssnaaaavvtlaghaaygartiilritaeaecbbeaetlhllddeeouauauapdgltpiohoattnhhnnFiaactCtnienststittimhahmweeeneedrtt11oeot99h88ffkue55nly!Rco)R,oewmeeesnpvvsplaapotellooutnuniaasbsotteeeene
tooahfnfedsstpuhprdeeuirsedfeslnarrcoeeerllaoaattoenecdddiaftpnooocttsthheuenftorrianiisalektroissofkft(towFofOoFSppC)oes,rr.iflunuRooorerwaocooeaccnilttaaoranwynylla3lFFHyCCtisc1s,a, lppeaaevdrarffvl!uauuoanorlcrcoeeoosctcthataaennnsdceoiitcchaenaadcccioddamb(pePlrFeOtiFoACn).
compoundsot he ste pursuant 0to CO. and perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS), now
compounds at the site pursuant to the CO.
allow
3M
to
evaluate
these
and
other
FC
MANUFACTURING.
MANUFA C TURING
pT"oThrhteeissoiintetofootcciccuuspppiireeosspaaepprppyrrhoostxmibameteaoltyn8e8u6l6i5y5liaazcecrdefesoosorfmpparroonppaeecrtrttyyu..riGGneegnneearrnaalllye,,sootinlnlyygotthhfeeIssoMouupttrhhoeedaasustcteetrrsnn
Thfhcpoaaohhmbbreetmiiitoeraraenrott,mcmoaiafiai3GnnlthMiiMninpsggrrfoppepedrcocuoooorcptrrrtiedodinrsnsotynhhsshoaahhafssooswbPwbebeFeetetOhhennAaantutuspsummerataidlodainzdfnufeououfdcrfaatrrcfcoeeitbcrucurerrimeignenaaagagtnnitouebnbal,ae,ebcggffoataaauurrntnmdmnii11angn9tgg7a5th0ohn.eredhhtPaasiessiFtsteetOrrieneSmgiimnnaraoiai11fnnc99e3eo44ddMr77caaspaassrinnonnnddddaaiuutucttcrhahrtaatsaalel.}t
cpdpi1nrori0doo5mcidd0camusuatc.cteteetriiFocoFGinnaCCel nspppoweortwrtooeeaedrnnlrutteei,caibtaleibloFylienCninbbgogeemflggaatnaaPesunnFstftOaeeaacdAdssfkuofpeeonrraanrorrpgdlpyyr,urocoaapdtdsrssuuoccdbttthutehuceegutsasmamnesitoiddaoorrbrago11gge9u9ee6n6t 0no0as1er's.n9ra.da7lt5eep.ddPPrraoriPidaoouFtrracOatttpoSotpietitrslhhetotiiscsti,o,nssgrccdddahasoolalcceeisuuinmmidnnleiaecnktatnhtehtteassne
ppCt9lloa5amcc0pee'osn.iinen nGsstiietoetnfebpbraruuollilplydir,iinneFggtCssarym77,,farne11u55S,f,aucp11tp6u6r,,reinsaagsnn,addnpir22oo55drum((cusstedeeasettooFFrniaiggsguuertreeeastn11e)d).d. cProomdpucotnieonnot foftphreopperireltuaortycfoircetasnuypipFreCs'ssawnatsfoprmhauslaetrioonus bteysttheed
pIroIItnndhueaacddat rddteieotaisnotno,inf, gBFFuhCClasdssinaatgarreke4e3.naa einntdhoefa2re0a02o.f Building 43.
Production of the perfluorooctanyl FC's was phased out by the end of 2002.
SITE SETTINGAND HYDROGEOLOGY
SITE SETTING AND HYDROGEOLOGY
"TTMinhseeissssietieippisslllooRccraatt.eeddoBonontaahfftalatottstooouggleehnntetlalyystuunnaddnuudilaaSttionnguglbbwleuusffftoovsveerelrsloooookkfiinntgghetthhseeiemmahaiainnvcechhbaeanennneslntooeffeettphhlleey
iMiinnnciccsiirssseeiesaddssiepbbpiyyni Rtsshittvrireeceark.amnmeBsasaoctcfhtirtvtohitsmiee.snso.orutthTThhhe(0eeasstsosaiutoetnhdiiassscoruuuonntshddswoeretrlihsaaetinnsiiodbb.eyysTggohalfaoctckshioeoe--Tfsduliuetvevipiaaohllasviddeeepapboroesesieiuttrsnssdetwwerhheliaipccilhhyn
ibbSnhyycarttlehheaeesPFPeroraariinmirraiiteehtiiDDcokuunnGeC(hsaheseciifonnrnofGGmirrnooinuunogpprtalahannytddoerth)shoeesuJJthooprrraddecaasrnenonsSStsaanantthddesstlhtsooeintnebee.aFFTsooherremmosaftaeittiodohnene.p. oJTTsohihrtsdeeaaSSnr.te.FLLouaarnmwwdarreteerinnloaccniene, S`ahpaplercFmaotrmatayt2io0n0(faeocobnfinoingtwhlayceern)trisalpproerstieonntoafthtehescbas(eseeofFithguereJo2)r.dan Formation,
-
approximately 200 feet below the central portion of the site (see Figure 2)
AA{bnnvoeeuxxgttheennpssriiivvoeer sbbooeddyyinoovfefskktinngooawwtilloeenddsgg,eeperreerggmaairtrddiiinnngggpttrhhoeecesssiittseeeshhyyaddnrrdooiggneescoullopoggpyyorhhtaaossfbbioeeeennoddpeeervvaeetlliooopnpese.dd
tFFlhoiircggoauuturrigeeonhs33.,,pdaatotFttiraagcscuhihtreeeeddi,4,nvpsperrhosoovtviwigidsdaeetstisohneaasp,amopalpepernmoolffitotssimnittegelggpcrrrooosucuuennfsddaswwceaeastteefarrrnomdmmootinnnihicstourlripaintnpeggostraatrnnooddfusnppidrrteoooddfouucpictetoiirooannwtiaowwtneeeslrl.l
llleoeelcvvoeeavlltaiotmmnoosonn.nsoitrrFoeoirgcignuog.rre.de4dTTsaaahbbollsewees!1.,tmhoebbneeiplloooorwwtie,,nngptpiorrwomoevwleiddlt.eedssc Asaalursssfauuicmememmmfaoranrorimyytoootrhfifenhhgiliawssettteoolrsrliitsccarorsluteaantdiifcioswvfahsaleitteederriwnlletaevvhteeeelrl
upper unconfined aquifer atth sie. elevations recorded aL site rnonitor{ng
upper unconfined aquifer at the site.
wells.
All site monitoring wells are finished in the
`CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALLRT-- ,SSUUNOBB,JJEE2CC7-TT0TTVO-O1AA0.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00000066
33MW_=MMNNO000D04444001177
Fo E m T------ Facility-wido Fluorocarbon Investigation Work Plan 3M Cottage Grove Facility
amann 00 January 21, 2004
Cota roeGrouTsoannttrEton Sumary Table 1
Cottage Grove Groundwater Elevation Summary
P F ommefa eniremr A PrE T ib S e i r aa eaes toaee) MW-1
742.57 751.07
1986-2002 757.6 756,,t6i 756o0~. 751.64 758.~0 755.6~ 756.5=
[me aiamae aaTs ha es MW-2 MW-3 MW-4
693.41 679.42 674.83
702.1 689.83 683.33 ,
705.8 694.3
713.53 703.07 69~).9~
711.89 702.02
724.29 696.21, 690.[}2
722.15 710.75 698.33
721.68 721
713.5~
713,0t
700.64 ,,, 7,,~.2~'
MW-5
749.23 756.31
760.~
759.54
7-57.36
763.16
7,59,13
r H t Hatee om nl ras realT a e o ounory MW-6 ...MW-7 MW-8
MW-9
706.81
699.15 706_99
713.85 736.10 700.11 7!4.02
702,3 724J
739.35 702.12 722.21
738.~2 701,06 721.67
734.98 700.58 713.36
7~I0.16 705.50 72687
739.5~ 724.65
7392; 703.9,'. 725.6~
MW-10
663.92, 688.30
692.25 691.30 691.73
696.29
E toe E S aiedo e te]me olt) MW-11
.iii'. MW*12 MW-13
MW-14
678.62 676.62 685.09
687.63 679.31 687.21'
694.28 684.1 689.1
693.23 683.71 689.01
681.85 o66.09
~0T.57 684.8~ 689.31
699.4}' 686.63 690.4~]
701.43 688.33 690.73
699.5~ 689,7; 690.91
MW-15
~.I
MW~16
MW-17
MW-18
MW~~ig...
660,0
650,0
648.0 651.50 653.20 655.57i 657.2...
ane en 664,0
664,0
662.0 664.41
666.09
667.0"
668.5?
,, ,
709.3 706.09 705.02
709.95 712,45 712.9~
714,6 711.05 711.05 700.79 713.96 718.30 717.0.=
701-31] 705.62 706,05 706oO~
Six Nighcapacty pumping wes (P-1 tough PAS) supply valor fo supocet Six high-capacity pumping wells (PW-1 through PW-6) supply water to support operations a he he (56 FUT 3). The Gourcaate om fo of te wake Gis. operations at the site (see Figure 3). The groundwater from four of these wells (PW-2, PW.S, PA ana PWS) loads Da on Sis wer supp Akinbuten yon on 3 PW-3, PW-4 and FrW'-5) feeds the on site water supply distdbut;on system on a conivous bas, for various sil nee Inching procutin and samara. Boos continuous basis for various site needs including production and sanitation. Bottled aor has beanprovided or 8 br ofyear atie ae of dink water, Th water has 13een provided for a number of years at the site for ddnking water. The Tomaiing two wots are ulzed Independent on 3 periodic bass 15 Sie do fra remaining two wells are utilized independently on a periodic bases for site-wide fire Drtackon(PW-1) and irpolo onl 1 he chert (F.5), repocivl, protection (PW-1) and air pollution control at the site incinerator (PW-6), respectively. Thosesie High-capaeclys were stalled dig the period 1647 0 1970, Foouf trhe These six high-capadty wells were inslalled during the pedod 1947 to 1970, Four of the Wels arecred mio he Jordan Fomalon audno. ofto.wets ars locwed wells are drilled into the Jordan Formalion and two of the wells are located in unconsokdied avian neat the Nssissop Ror: Howat, al pumping wets coain unconsolidated alluvium near the Mississippi River. However, all pumping wells obtain roundvatr fom the suiial, unconinad aqui, Shalt have secmenios but groundwater from the surficial, unconfined aquifer. Studies have documented that Srounduatrs consti fa owed verbal flow by ho Undo or Lovrenes groundwater is constrained from downward vertical flow by lhe underlying St. Lawrence Formation (31) Groundwater, LeowIh SIL. has been Cocaine as bein conned Formation (8tL). Groundwater, below the StL, has been documented as being confined below the facil, and wols. fished boow he SIL Pave froGueed Towing anedan below the facilily, and wells finished below the StL have produced flowing artesian condiionsa oot sevaton of ne hr. conditions at pool elevation of the dyer. Although itrical waer level cela indica natura hyaulc raden toward the Although historical water level data indicates a natural hydraulic gradient toward the river, Bumping of the wells WHEN Saied in 1047) as este peremion cons. of river, pumping of the wells (which started in 1947) has created a persistent cone of `Gptession in he roundler beneath hedevelope erions of he ve (ov Fir 4). depression in the groundwater beneath the developed portions of the site (see Figure 4). "Toc coneof deprsssion sfecively mis movement of roundwter Fom in ote to -The cone of depression effectively limits movement of groundwater from the site to the ciocent iver. Allgrusdate sed ot 1h poucion proHceateed asevsee adjacent dyer. All groundwater used for the production processes is treated after use, at
`CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALLRT-- ,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7-TTCTTV-OO1A0A.PP26RR9OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE
ORDER
ORDER
ENTERED
ENTERED
IN
IN
HENNEPIN
HENNEPIN
COUNTY
COUNTY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00000077
au_tnooosots
3M MN00044018
FactwsFusccatbon vesWorktPn Fac{tibJ-wide FIuorocarbo~ |nvestigat~on Work Plan SH CoeseGovFay 3M Cottage Grove Facility
amy 21.2004 Janua~ 21,2004
tMthihesesisssiistteieppwwiaaRssilvtoeerww.aatteTerhrettrrroeeasattmmneeonntptoftfaaacbcililieSl,jg,roppruriiororrdwttaoolrNNuPPsDDeEEdSSowppnoegmrrmiatidtiteeenddt ddoifisshcchohaaarrggteee atfonodttnhhoee
twwMeheilesllblsssaisaassrrieepaoppprifreRes(sievheenenrtb.tbubeTetfhtwweaeredeeejnaniscttenhhnoeet pssoioteetatbhaaelnneddrigttvrhheoreeu,fntdidhyvweeer.ra.fteoNNrrooeud,sdiesigscrdcrooreeuwttneendgwssrappatrrdeiinirneggnsdstiaaosrrcfeehthapperrrgeesessiteefennrtoat mnaadllotonnhngoeg
area round the base of
area around
thosie nlers thepaolo the bluff adjacent to ~he
the site enters the pool of
the river bydiffuse s2e33ge. rive~, therefore, groundwater
the river by diffuse s~epage.
discharge
from
the
RREEMMEEDDIIAALL IINNVVEESSTTIIGGAATTIIOONN
prOBOpoornncotcehSSpeseeassppsr,tt,tee0aemm5ssbbsaeseegrerrt22ef33ooo,r,rdtt22hh0t00iih0nn3a3P,P,atMMahrrePPt RCCIlIIAaAasnnaahddnnoodduouudt33tiMWlbinnuseseltddodaffioifnnnoEaEggtxrxrheeheieeibRdtdlitthphAAaratefotvfhtihottoehhueesRRlCoCyeOmmOce,o,demsidsphaihallooeluutIIlndodvvbdoebsafsetortiirgrgeitaaithntinoiotsninaieet(.eR.d). Both parties agreed that the RI should build on the RI previously completed for the site.
Ta"vThaheielaRRbil!ei.iss Tttooobbboeeffocococunusssieesddteoonnnt wFFiCChcctoohmmoppMooPuuCnnAdd-ssafpfooprrrwwohvhieiccdhh NaanPnaaDllEyy'iSliccaasllitmme aemtthoohdsrs aairreo pccruuorrgreernnatmtll,yy
available. To be consistent with the MPCA-approved NPDES site monitoring program,
tmhoeniftoolroewdinafg tfheeeeF:C carboxylate and sulfonate compounds (target anabtos") wi bs the following five FC carboxylate and sulfonate compounds ("target analytes") will be
monitored at the site:
2"1..}. CCC686AAAcccididd---PPPeearrrfllluuouorororhoecoxchatenaxoniacadnaaciccdciidd(((PFPFFOHHRAA))),;
235....CGCC4B48SASuSlculildfouon-naaPllteee-rf--lluPPPooerrenorufolourcoratarolonhbloueuixctoaaoanncreoisdusoslu(uPllbffoFoonnOunaaaAltltse)e;((aP(PFPFnPEBHSeSS)));; and
5.4;
5.
C8 Sulfonate - Peruoroocians sufonals (PROS). C6 Sulfonate - Perfluoroheane sulfonate (PFHS); and
C8 Sulfonate - Perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS).
PPsataroraarppihvraassiinngg
from
from
Part1
Part I1
of
of
he
the
CO,
CO,
as
as
appld
applied
1to
target
target
analytes,
analytes,
the
the
purpose
purpose
of
of
his
this
RI
is to:
11.. ddieefffiinnweeastththeee deeixxsttpeoonnstlaaalnnpddrammctaaiggcnensiituuoddfeeFOooff:oonn-sstitee ccoonnttaammiinnaattiioonn rreessuulltiinngg rfroomm tthee ppaasstt
2.
2.
site waste
adenfdine he define the
hycrology and gecloofgy disposal practices of FCs;
hyc~rok)gy and geology of the
sesite
and
and
the
the
potential
potential
routesofexposure;
routes of exposure;
33.. apprnroodvviiddee iinnffoorrmmaattiioonn aanndd ddaaltaa nneeeeddeedd ffoorr ccoonnssiiddeerraattiioonn ooff rreessppoonnssee aaccttiioonnss..
o]"-bThjheeecffioovlleloosw.wiinnSggpawwcooirrikkc pptlaaasnnkswwialillrl opprdrooevvviieddleotpthheeed
i0innffo2orarmcmraaettiisoosnnennaeeccchaeossfssaatrrayy
tfoohrrrecceooammbppljleeetctiiiooenns.ooff
the
the
RI
RI
objectives. Specific tasks are developed to address each of the three objectives.
A4thsse
pppooasssstsiibbillee,,
uddsaeoffionnfee
FtthChees.eexxtteonn~t
and
and
magnitute
magnitude
ofon-site
o~ on-site
contamination
contamination
resulting
res~/Iting
from
from
the past site use of FCs.
+ DcDioosccpuousmmaelennattt aathnneddsisseuu.mmTmrmaiarsiriwzzeeiltthIhneeclNhusidsietootrhryy oaofrfeaFFsCCusmmeaandfnuofuarfacetcautrurlriiynnggp,,rottdeeussctttiinneggstaainnnddg
boadannitsddphopllsaraarorglgceeeastssstccheaaesll.eesitmmeIa.danenuTnufhtfaaiosccditwuupiirlilonniglgn,a,cnluaatdnnleddstotthhueeercadderiieslsapposoocssauaatslolerdllsoocfcwoaairttiioeobnanosrslypaaipssorstsooeodcdciuicaactttneetddeaswwtsiinitttgh.h
+
bbbAvaaoassthieeapmmvriaoaepcp:e;hsissteosr.i
Identified potential
information vil be
source locations
compiledon the
will be plotted
reatment and
on a site
disposal
AodofifvsapFFiolCCasbawwlleaalssohtctieesaststoirottinhchsrooifnouufggohhrsmuttahehtegeiolnwwaaawssshitltleewwbwiaelattbceeeorrmltGrpoeeitaaletotdmmdeeoonnnnst
tahpplelsaantntter.te. baetmIIsddaeeennnmtttaiiffpaiie:neddd
polental disposal
potential
disposal locations for sludgefash will be plotted on a site base map;
`CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALLRT--,SSUUNOBB.JJEE2CC7-TTCTTV-OO10AA-PP28RR8OO6T-2~EECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00000088
3W_MNO0D44019
3M MN00044019
HFahcCtoynnaigtsGrPovaevFeasyi esionion ork Pn F~cility-wide Ftumocarbon Investigation Work Plan
3M Cottage G~ove Facility
Senay21,2008 January 21,2004
+ AcAovvmaaplillaaibbelldee ahhniissdttooerdincctiIinnaffoodrrmmpaaottliiosonnntaoolnnsoaauirrcrreeelleleoaacssaeetssionoosff wttiaalrrggbeeett paanlnaailleyydtteessonwwiailll sibbteee.
+ c<HbbHiooaaissumssttreeoopcrrimamilieccaaldpifopn;co;faaortnrmidmoantaisditwieooinnnltiobofirneo~adpanlnpyoyottsosedpiniotltlissanlooafsfoiFFuCCercsbseawwisliollelcbbmaoeaticopcon;omsmpaiwpnlidilleet ddbaeanndpdtloththteeesdseeoppnoottaeenntstiiitaaell
+
scHHiooissutmtroocprdeilccldofincoifanorttrmiomaabntausitliaoowrnnilflooobnnremSsp.iololilttaaenndddoggnrroaouusnnitddewwabatateesrrettmeessattpiinn;gganoofdf ttaarrggeett
analytes
analytes
wil
will
be
be
compiled in tabular form.
Defing the ycoatndogegcoygy ofthe sit and the potential routes of exposure
Define the hydrology and geology of the site and the potential routes of exposure
= A
AoAlttlaabbplloeenwwteiilllabbtalethddeeesvvieetlelooappeendd wlaebll lpooinwtlsbaot thGeovsoitleoapnedd
tsshuuemmsmmqaruairizizriinndggeptththhee mccooonnnisstitorurucectdtii:oonndedteataililssooff tchoecauqmueinfetrrdgetphtehpmurogniitonrgeda; ctiof he
al exstng
all existing
production
= AwASwXiesetltslatellist-sbeewlaaeiptpdtoewtthtghieleorlnoobsstiueiottenm;d;deeeavttdeeclsroruspurleefrdfvtaaecdclesoe;cmimuamappewonwthiinllgbbmoethcceoonepnsustmtrruutpccinttegeddiuaulctitiilvzciziitiynnggoftthhtheeemmoposrsottdrrueeccctieeonnntt
= AnAsiatMMepO-,OwDDhidFFeeLLgOgOreoWWougnrmmdaoowpddhaeietelcwwrfllieelllavbtbeeuelrdsed;esevvaeenlldooppteehdde ttahhvaaeltreraefgflleeecactnssntuthhaeelpppooultmeeprniitinoogmmeeatttireiccsfssouurrrfftaahcceee
= ssmPtPiiotataaueerpttreipp,crrilasoeoitdtdetthuurhacacgetccteikiksoooiiknnnng.ggrwwaewweplTillihlllhsslil.ce;bbeefMeccaOootuDmmrFpeplsLleeOtaoenWdddttmotoohdvveeeealrivyfwyeirttlla~hlgeebeeppoaouttnseennentudtiiaaatlllopggvurraomoiuudpnnaidndlugewaagtrtareetorerusrrneefdccoeeerppltthteooerrr
+ fhftrnlhoooieeuuwastilseiinniltggeae,tpbbpatreheroognneddereusaoucaituctttehhntii.doohtnwhnTeaeehwteppleerrrsleeMls:vsv;OiiaoomDuupsFslllLyyeOiiwdWdieelnntmfbiJofofiiedcededolfppweootciteletlnenbtditeiaaflulorsssoeotuduarrrtgccoeeetvaaaarrnleiedaaalassytteiiesssgccraaoapnputatnuuldrryweesddastbbeayytr
+
TaaInhllleitssriaieittlaeleyf,tmmeoaron,gniriaotoorumriinonndnggiwwwoareetiesllnsr;g;sawmelplenawtwillorbke vciolllebcetepdrofpoorsteadrgtehtatanfaolcyutessesaonnalkysnioswant
+
oTongrhressourueussanppfedetcewctrat,tssaeooruumrsrccoaeenmiaaptorrlereienawagsslw; belol cnoeltwieocrtkewd ifllobtearpgreotpaonsaeldyitheastafnoacluysseiss aofnakcnhowonf
+
tABTBhhueouegiilrdddssoioiixxunncgngssuidimtt11weee11an66ptptreccroraaopdlsfdoueeaulcttmeceettrinipiiaoaoll.enn;lwwwgeierllllolsbsuenaadcnnvoddalltaaeocrssteaaddmmipspflocleerhwatwairlriglglebebet1e0accnosolaullrlleyeflocaettcseeeddafwnfraraoollmmeyrstitshohueeatts"lleioodaooecpph""tahoatetf
tTwdwdhieeoiellffliind3bbnMeoeeedcdTeeuasz2smioc0taaennkbben6iyltiisooospfhfnhoeccettdaadehppnaaelttutuniarorttlheeroegoorfbsbfoiaattuhdhssneeeeedoppwoorrfffaootttdtdhehhuuereecctdrtbbiiaioilsouilnncfrlhfwwoabbeaereedlgltltiewwnngeeeehtoeettwnnnosorftturkhhkrw,efe,aayffMMco.oieuuissrsrwsBissisasaasstmimeaippprppplioloieesunRRtlliaosiovviceccdeeacarertetiiaaosdtonhnnsnedd,ss
`ttwwtehhhaxaeeestste3teenppMwodwoiaeifanntadtttecetssroirlitotowwyuhiutioellfflfwanalallbbtlthoeeaaernnddncetsosadGirtbatriahrlboebelcsicisitstfdlhyhyteeohssddoeoofsuutrrtehtoohheluuoogogrcfhafhalilMItlyyriNoWo-anee1-dqsq16uu6r.iaii.dgdnihidssAAtttaoaa"Plg~nnPrutwtuosasubbhhynee.PPdttowowBwaineneatetetsennerppdsrr1tooaohhbbnmeeeepalwwfcfaieacicllcewliislibbitstleeyy,
debbexeetteenccrodomlelillendececttdtoeedidtnhteffhooewrr faittteeaalrdrrggtbaeeatbtsleeaadnanaatolyltnyhtteeaescss.ceesalaosnnc:aayltyiossni.ss.
Spociic locations wil and a groundwater sample Specific locations will
bewill
be
=
hAAdseesuteubFrbsmrsuoiurnrTfefraadaccieisnnisstnhaagemmApfvpiieeliarlnd,ggbwppiaallsabnen,ed, dttoooenveeeavvlcaaoc}luepeasusdtae;;
potential
potential
contaminant
contaminant
anspor
transport
rom
from
+
tSbSheaaemmupFlpliirliieznneggTdrppfaorrinooiccnseegaddumuArprreeiessna,,g, ppawrrieellvavbililooeguursdsloelyyuvneaadlppowppparretoodevv;reesddambbpyylitthhneeg
MMlPoPcGCatAAiooantst ;tthhaeendDD11
area,
area,
wil
will
+ Able ustailmizpeldesfowrislambeplitnrganastpoarlltgedrofuondthwealtearbosraamtoprlyingunldoecrataiopnprso;parnidate chainf-
o
`custody procedures All samples will be transported
custody procedures.
to
the
laboratory
under
appropriate
chain-of-
`CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRLT--,sSuUNBOB.JJEE2CC7-TTCTTV-OO10AA-P2P8RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00000099
33MW_=MMNNO000D04444002200
Court ReMMpEERRaRRIIrLLLLtLLEEiGGVAAioLdLeSSnogOOrUgUaLLpT'hTIyIOOTLNNrSSea Sgeravicles Court Reportiong*Legal Videography*Trail Services
Pogo257 Page 250 Page 257
Page 259
1 be onExtn nmaasd kunever | 1 dust 1
been marked as Exhibit 48, and ask whether
1
discuss that.
2 yoorocalovecsoong spuromat | 2 Andi olaststracans,wer 2
you recall ever seeing this particular e-mail
2
And in the last sentence, "An answer
3 om wha Sorta dolooron 13004, | 300 ces,Shen ncatnocto 3
from Michael Santoro dated April 13, 2004,
3
to a question, Sheryl indicated that no
3 SibecimWPeCAsGionmnisgowns, | 4 orwas underwayocsseyse 4
sub, ect meeting with MPCA Commissioner,
4
effoFi was underway to classify these
ShemtCompen wisuchas meekog nos. | 5 hares (FOS. FOR)vastus 5
Sheryl Corrigan, with attached meeting notes.
5
substances (PEGS or PFOA) as 'hazardous'
. NR ASTROS.Agen16 18 neriors EnvrmmeraRepasions 6
MR. ARMSTRONG: Again, the
6
under Minnesota Environmental Regulations."
5 cothasomononsieamisng? 17 Soyouseomar 7
question is has she ever seen this'?
7
Do you see that?
. NR BATT veonekats Aven 8
MR. BILOTT: Yeah, I think that's
8 A. Yes.
5 amt Docs rtclsyourecsectvotn. fn 9
what I asked.
9 Q. Does that refresh your recollection that, in
10. No sonore pve 10 at ho ks of ho asaaisnote of 10
No, I don't believe I have.
10
fact, the issue of the hazardous nature of
1G Aeron. Woreyo,ovr 2 pod 1 PRONand FOS atdscuvsineMd7 11
All right. Were you aware that 3M had
11
PFOA and PFOS was discussed with 3M?
12 ut rote eved st? i MRASHLEY: Gbjctotheom 12
created notes of its meeting?
12
MR. ASHLEY: Object to the form
a Bde 13
No.
13
and fourlda[ion.
13. Wharsu arangeciocome nangmsstuin [14 A. `Aparoty mih avebeenascsoda.ns 14
When 3M arranged to come in and meet with
14 Ao Apparently, might have been discussed, and
15 youwas hore aysoni snetforth 15." way otneo hs Dtwos 15
you, was there any sign-in sheet for the
15
the way that rm reading this is that we had
[16 ening? 16 a ncoson shotat was con nbony 16
meeting?
16
a discussion about what was going on broadly
17 2 Thoka sortwoseprkpecoivamol [17 aroundomermenabraposionnds 17 A. I believe from a securities perspective all
17
around environmental regulations and
1a" atorssig at oor 0 18 hezdoussogratons Andparnaps Wo 18
visitors sign in at the front door of the
18
hazardous designations. And perhaps Mike
18 oa. Sort- sraweregana 10 sukea saves sbot ourcm,0d 19
agency. So there's -- and we're given a
19
asked a question about four chemicals, and I
20 Sadeondemibcdooaridhoociongo [20 wedhavasodknowol moroymy 2O
badge, an identification badge and had to go
20
would have said to my knowledge or to my
21 ooh agate. 51 Vom re wa rascty. t 2g00, 21
through a gate.
21
knowledge there was no activity. But, again,
320. \Whtayoaars commision ba PCA nas 32 nts hacbhyWeoowardss. 400 22 Q. While you were commissioner of the MPCA, was 22
that's to the best of my knowledge. And
25 tenponspacietocote tsof 25 olspamely ave et or cs oe 23
it the MPCA's practice to create lists of
23
others probably have much more access to more
54. ences tec win ve Commissioner? [24 scootcsd ce as e otawd 24
attendees at meetings with the Commissioner? 24
accurate knowledge since I was not a part of
|25 a was sotmypoctonte, [2s wwsectwes. -- 25 A. It was not my practice, no.
25
those activities.
Pagezss| Page 200 1 Q Wes tyourprkaeecp inotoesaoftsProyage 258 | TQ. Doyourecal
1 Q. Was it your practice to keep notes of any
1 Q. Do you recall 3M-
Page 260
2 niches [ER it 2
kind of meetings?
Fi 13 Devore simian youn 3 A. No.
30 Wns wsprc mating ith occ | 4 co appro n orachos stat 4 Q. Was this particular meeting with 3M recorded?
2 A. Which Mike knew.
3 Q. Do you recall 3M raising with you their
4
concern that apparently one of the assistant
Le 5 tomeygant, paricterm 5 A. No.
5
attorney generals, in particular Alan
Wes ary somovasoipacits coroc? | 6 Wien, naduredanapion PFOA 6 Q. Was any -- so no videotape exists, correct?
6
Williams, had authored an opinion that PFOA
TAN | 7 orProswor. miae maartosunder 7 A. No. Nodpectamnomcosntc? | 0 Mansoaiod 8 Q. No audiotape of any kind exists, correct? ANotary movie Is WR ASHLEY. Objector or. 9 A. Not to my knowledge.
7
or PFOS were, in fact, hazardous under
8
Minnesota Law?
9
MR. ASHLEY: Object to the form.
10 0 Toke rweroonemo | 10 A hadnodeat 10 Q. I'd like to refer you to the meeting notes
10 A. I had no knowledge of that.
12 trosacheatome Sanooserat, | 1. Tho nxtgaarfra.Sano noes ! 1
that are attached to Mr. Santoro's e-mail,
12 whchboon onhosacopnogdo. Doyourans [12 say,aute, Forho bt wesarco 12
which begins on the second page. Do you have
1 beemmaton 15 ma conminkaabtapecenssvneoedued 13
those in front of you?
ia 1 sotbare woudsbeporarmoar 14 A. Yes.
15. And h tof senwedSamso 15 see NPCA CM Boje seo at 15 Q. And the list of attendees Mr. Santoro
11 Q. The next paragraph of Mr. Santoro's notes
12
says, quote, "For the future it was agreed
13
that communication would take place as needed
14
so that there would be no surprises for
15
either the MPCA or 3M." Do you see that?
16 pce,n ot3scurto, 4187 i a er 16
provides there, that is accurate, isn't it?
17 2 einen 17. Dasen rocommunicavtooincse 17 A. Yes, lthinkso.
16.0. nn st pogoofbose cing es bho [10 wna? 18 Q. In the last page of these meeting notes, the
To. idepompagh osbegios aves ave | 10 A Alorot mock, 11d Jon Wocna at. 19
middle paragraph that begins questions were
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. Did such future communications take place
18
with 3M?
19 A. After that meeting, I told Jim Warner that if
20 akecoyausteaer 20" erowere so lkeconversionos 20
asked, do you see that?
20
there were any future conversations or
22G.a YMeeS, onos tcc,Cusstons [2212 ovtawtc e fo m3Mw btosneo.oSouitrosnypeerston 21 A. Yes. I 21
22 Q. Mr. Santoro states that, quote, "Questions / 22
S2i5 oenreeshsedsmmnoeykmevsoeancrooPmFeOoruAnGt.R. | 2[243 huakvcobnoaonn oneocthonverbsticooonrsd, | 23 were asked about the impact of the PFOA work, I 23 Ts nies: Arovennagossont [25 0. Vousepeatsesaimeoctnmg wsin 24 on the state agency and environment groups I 24
2~ .............within ~2~
I~ g~ts ~ [~...........................!~
oveKuresfrom 3Mthat hewould bethe person that would deal wilh those. So there may have been other conversations that occurred, but certainly not with me_
tO thiS. partilUlar mee!i.~g, %1~ ...........................
65 Pa2g571e0 2s00) 65 (Pages 257 to 260)
2131dA0ve0n North, Suite S60Birmingharm, Al 35205" 2100 3rd Avenue North, Suite 960*Birmingham, AI 35203* "1300.55DEPO 1-800-888-DEPO
`CDIOCSNTOFRIINDCEFTNCITOIDAULRE-T-NS,SUTUNBOBI.JJEEA2CC7LT-TCTTVO-O10AA.PP26RR9OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
3M_N00D#4021
3M MN00044021
11993322..00001100
Fock iceFcrscarion IestgsonokFn Facility-wide Fl,.~orocarbon inveslig~tien Work Plan SH CorogeGroveracy 3M Cottage Grove Facility
som1,n20y08 January 21, 2004
Provide informationanddata nofaorcodnsiodoradtonofresponse actions.
Provide information and data needed for consideration of response actions.
Tt"ThhheeeMrrPeoCssuuAll.tss
ooTffhttehhreeepffaoacrciitlitwtyyi--lwv:iiddseaasssseessssmmeenntt
wiwill
be
be
presented
presented
in
in
a
a
wren written
report
report
lo
to
the MPCA. The report wil!:
2 InCIcnolcmulupddaeerfefiletklddhemmeaentathhloyodtdoioclaloolggirieeesssuaansnddtaoannhaaleylyttaiipccapalrlorrpesrsuiulaltstse;;ecotoxiclogical es results
+
DfPfCDioorsiorroscmvcPPuiupFFsdsaOsOesrtAAerthahetaeenchnoediidmmammPPpneFlFaipncOOldaySlaStt;iitco;iianoclsonraeosfsfstfusouluitbsbmaomtidodtintietttehsdodefnaraoelpscpsurkulotasps;wraiaoannrteddkoecostpoxoicnosloegiaccatlente.st results
,, Provide recommendations for additiona} site work or response action.
scHEDULE
SCHEDULE
Td"Tahhteeesffooalllroloewwpiinnrggedssiccchhaeetdedudulloeenhhaatsshbibteeyeenn(dd0ee)vvdeelylooppMeePddfCfooArrcceoosmmppoplnletstieinnfggortthheeeassecehwwodorelrkkivttearssatkiise...
Nolo,
Note,
the
the
dates are predicated on a thirty (30) day MPCA response for each deliverable.
`CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7-TTCTTV-OO10AA-P2P8RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD INN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00001111
33MW_-MMNNO000D0A444w0=22
NEL ) TN
Hi]
i | Spo ral
Ny 4vIIRN |2
( HO SN = Po Hind
KX 0oo d 2% ( E =aa Add8
ne is Sc ENOL 4
Marate os T7B |
|aeOf
WRTm EeE ld | i
Mo >) Nob J p em m
3:
IoTe =AALES TZ ah N
C 4i a T yy= EaR a oa 2
| pi
TG
pr 7 id
88 SAY 2
WN
S7? r?7J tr72 TNoAy
SE
ot
a
EE
Cam
Ze
oi A
a HE a
Zo bo
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00001122
3M MN00044023
eee |
F | w fwT im
om =
hie
FH
1
wl |
dd
wlio
Se
a
|
a
AE
|
hii i
fired
i
8
wll |
dst
!
i
:
g
PL
E
le o | EEE
Yi
i
| Ll apd
:
Be
EF
|"4
!
&
i
ay | 1c dl
i
=
HE 1
: | e Lm= I
I!
:
Hb ap
i
%
{ iz
i
oi
o 1i
|
tH
a
Il
I
ie
EE
i
i
er
EEE
-
!
Cee
|
SE aaa CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY
DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00001133
3M MN00044024
or er TR
FTH
bles
==
2y 15HHlHIHes
INT d CHn T
u IR y A <p
dS na d
POA Sar
44
2 Fas a
4
pan
7
Sosy ii
AC ag iZANT
|
PA
wt} ET a
Tr
[= Be
Fre RATS nh
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00001144
3M MN00044025
+
NE
Ja Lm EL y:.]
oNc C
Each
=A ER
La
CF rare Sh, .PrOper~y Line 50 mwe caym iE EIev~ion P-_,~.dours
-@
[-- Source: Barr 2002 Ar~nual Report
round Watr imine uy,2002 Ffigguurreed4
Ground
Coltage Grove, MN. Water Elevations July, Cottage Grove, MN
2002
| FESR ee ON7 7] Easiss24
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00001155
3M MN00044026
Er
i
iL
HH
yo
|
L
:
glk
j
Al
hell
31
3
na
i
|
|
||
t|H Fol
Hin bn oll oHgo
i
H|l
pSiida iaarlam
| ch aa |
L i Fob bo FFY FEE ETRR i
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862
11993322..00001166
3M MN00044027