Document mX23vp1NZVE3K1zneDYYaNeg
cller
l 1
t' nor-
: al. bUT
' `tani to (R was
p of the .inn
<.un one
lound. the out
data i >n
IIIC
'JSt -i- .i/a-
i six >*von ;nedic-
u*enxko in tv .
and
Vin\ l CUoride-Auoviated Disease
83
bone lesions presented with mild to marked thrombocytopenia (30-139 v 1 O'9 litreV Bone marrow aspirates in 6 patients permitted exclusion of disturbed platelet forma tion or osteomyeiofibrosU/scierosu. but in 12 of them splenomegaly was found. Ex cept for slight reticulocytosis in 8 and leueopenia in 5 of the workers, other Haematologicai tests were negative. The reduction of the number of leueocytes and platelets as well as teticulocytosis appeared to be attributable to splenomegaly, but further studies
on the nature of thrombocytopenia were thought necessary, and it was suggested by the authors that a decrease in the number of platelets might serve as an early and easily
detectable symptom. The high prevalence of thrombocytopenia (as determined by phasevontnst microscopy) found later on detailed analysts of platelet function and other parameters of blood coagulation in the total cohort of PVC production (and also fabrication) workers from this plant strengthened this suQPStion (fiacimcr et al. 1974a, b, 1975a. b, 19~f}\Sthrt-Baci\ner and Exzel 1977). Wepnan (1975) also commented upon abnormal platelet counts in 13 of 37 PVC fabricating workers who had only handled PVC powder which, however, might have contained substantial amounts of residual monomer. In contrast.Mis et al. (1975) detected thrombocytopenia in only 1 of 354 polymerization workers, but an electronic cell counter was used for platelet counts (personal communication).
According to Sehrr-Bac/intr and free/(1977). the mean platelet count in e cohort of 132 PVC polymerization (and processing) workers was significantly lower titan that in a nonexposed control group of ISO healthy men. As could be expected, Baeluicr et al. (1975b) also demonstrated a positive correlation between the degree of thrombo cytopenia and the prevalence of an enlargement of the spleen (palpable splenomegaly or spleen size determined by selective scintigraphy with l99-Hg-bromo-meretuy*hydroxypropane-labelled red cells) m 70 PVC polymerization workers (see Table 19). It tp-
Table 19. Prevalence of enlargement of the spleen1 among 70 PVC-polymerization worker* in rvijlwm to increasing degases of thrombocytopenia iBtckntr et al. 1975a)
A Croup
No. of workers examined
Platelets (x 1 O'*/litre)
Range
Mean
Enlargement of the spleen
A 14 B 24 C 25 D7
-0a 1
3
> 130 100--130
< 70
168 117 87 44
3*215) 11 K46%) 19(765)
6 (86?)
* As determined by palpttion or by selective spleen scintigraphy.
pears, however, that the development of thrombocytopenia is not dependent on the presence ofsplenomegaly since we observed mild thrombocytopenia (100-120 x I0*9/ litre) in e smaD number ofwotkets in whom spleen size was definitely within normal Hntia on aetectfte spleen edntigraphy (Mllzflldienindex <45 x 10** according to ftscfterajM l*W1963).
Thrombocytopenia wn accompanied by abnocmaHties In platelet function tests. There eras an increase in the number oflarge (> 10 fan) `juvtnle' platelets (increased
*84 W.K. Ulbjch anJ HJ- MarsteUer
platelet spreading), enlianced response (platelet aggregation) to addition of ADP and collagen (Bont test) and increased availability of phospholipiU<ontaining platelet tactor 3 (fiachner et al. 1975a). This pattern was thought to be compatible with the no tion of an increased turnover rate due to derangement of microcirculation (CDIC) in liver and spleen and defective reticuloendothelial system (RES) clearance of activated clotting factors (flec/mer et al. 1974b). hfortf (1976) and Ward et il. 0 976) suggested that thrombocytopenia could be construed as confirmatory evidence of an immune complex disorder. Hcusenmnn and Stutre (1977a) noted unusual focal aggregation of platelets in klatsch preparations of spleen tissue and increased platelet pooling (pinelets trapped within the subsinusoidal meshwork of pulp cords) in the red pulp of the spleen on electron microscopy as well as phagocytosis of thrombocytes by sinusoidal macrophages. Scheffncr-ti al. (1976) found platelet thrombi in and around hepatic sinusoids in mice after exposure to VCM. A direct toxic action of VCM(or metabo lites) on the bone marrow has not been demonstrated so far.
Although the pathogenesis of thrombocytopenia in VCM-induced disease is not fully understood, it seems at piesent most likely that it is caused by increased turnover and consumption of platelets within the abnormal vascular spaces of the liver and spleen. A similar type of consumption coagulopathy was described as complication of spon taneous haemangiosarcoma of the liver by Truell et al. (1973). A haemostatic defect more complex than mere pooling and destruction of platelets In the enlarged spleen has also been commented upon in the paper by Cemrs et al. 11974) in connection with splenomegaly of various nonorrhotic origin.
4.4J Central and Peri aheral Nervous System
Miscellaneous nonspecific and somewhat indefinite symptoms have been described in connection with chronic inhilatiotul exposure to VCM in PVC-production workers, such as dizziness, disorientation, blurring of vision and memory, headache, irritability. excessive fatigue and somnolence, sleep reversal or insomnia and other pseudoncurasthenic symptoms (Sucit et al. 1963,197$;&torre* 1969:Lifts et al. 1975 and others). This pnnarcotic syndrome was interpreted as a manifestation of a potentially reversible scut* toxic encephalopathy. Its danger to the individual was thought to lie mainly in resultant inadequate reactions to critical situations (Schorrek 1969). However, Vde et al. (1976) reported that several individuals in a group of 95 comparatively young ex-workers, the majority of whom had no ocher symptoms, complained of fa tigue . headache. Usdcssness end deprewon, with onset of symptoms having been de layed ss long es 2 years after cessation ofemployment.
With reference to such *pseudoAeurasthenic complaints*, which may be interpreted as the mildest degree of a toxic encephalopathy,farm et al. (1975) examined a group of21 autodsve cleaners et varying intervals after cessation ofexposure, all ofwhom presented with other (cutaneous, angioneurotic, hepatic) manifestations of vinyl chlo ride dlaeme. CMwfcal symptoms of a mote or lass distinct encephalopathy (including cerebellar ataxia in 4) were found in all but ooe of them. EEC recordings were normal In only five of these patients; In the others, paretuhythmia, dysenrhythmia or a socalled subvigil electroencephalogram was observed. Evidence of distal polyneuropathy, found in 19 patients, was atufbutrd in the first place to m abnormal peripheral circu-
lat: en aitclu vindii. Sih. 4.4.
JO ro ro co vt
^ J j -r . f , 1 .* *r .
*
' '-^-r:.O-
* r . k A-
.*
.* * *,*. o(j--.-yf
`taRteller
DP and ciet facthe no1'ilC) in ctivated iggested imune ^auon of eipiateof the msoidal rpatic u-tabo-
' not fully ~>wt and spleen. Mspon- defect <pleen
tion with
ohed in rKen, 'itbffity, -hrJIand
ndally to lie ' How* aracively of fa* **n de*
tcrpreted 1 a group whom
tatin| *7 normal a* -'ropethy, aJ nm*
V'inyJ Chlorid<.A,->jousted Disease
85
lauon with tesultani hypoxic damage. The pathogenesis of a possibly VCM-tnduced encephalopathy is not dear. It would be conceivable that clinical and biodcctne alter* ations found in some patients, in whom portosystemic encephalopathy could be ex cluded, may have been due to toxic or hypoxic brain damage. However, no other con vincing evidence has so far emerged to indicate that chronic irreversible cerebrotexic damage may have resulted from prolonged exposure to VCM, notwithstanding the pos
sibility of an induction of brain tumours.
4.4J Pulmonary Changes
The suspected development ofnonmalignant pulmonary changes due to VCM md/o; PVC dust exposure is still a aatur of centretutsy. Soon after VCM was recognized as a potent carcinogen, three groups of employees fa 290.250.445. respectively) from three large North Amencan PVC-preducing plans (A, B. C), characterized by different duration and keels of past environmental exposure to VCM as well as to PVC dust, were studied with uspect to chest x-ray film abnormalities and pulmonary function defects as assessed by spirometry and determination of maximum expiratory flow vol ume (MiUer ! 975 tUilfev ft ai. 1975;lt& ct al. 1975.1976. 1977). All cases with pre vious exposure to asbestos, silica or coal dust had been exduded in these studies. Unexpected linear, reticular and. less often, rounded opacities on chest x-ray films were found in about one-fifth of the two groups ofemployees from plants A (highest ex posure) and B (22.7%, and 18 respectively), but in only 4J% of thorn from plant C. with the lowest exposure level. The prevalence of cheat radiological abnormalities. for which no pathogenetic explanation was available, eras found to be significantly in creased with long :r duration of VCM^VC exposure (mote than 10 yean), but foe pievalence ofa posit ve hhftocy of smoking, although identical tat both groups A and B. eras also found to be significantly higher in workers with abnormal chat x-ray plates. The overall prevalence ofa peeitive history of chronic bronchitis (British Medical Re search Courted criteria) was 20.4% m group A (highest exposure) and 16JX6 in group B, although group B was significantly older. The somewhat higher prevalence ofchronic bronchitis in workers with abnormal chest x-ray plates did not attain statistical tigaif* fcance.
On foe other band, age did not appear to be an important factor. Pulmonary func tion tests diowed a stzikia|iy high prevalence ofobstructive changes, but ance both smoking snd sge were related to changes in pulmonary function, it appeared difficult to isolate potential specific effects of occupations! exposure to VCM and PVC dust A restrictive pattern vs found in 9J% of group A and in only 2.3% ofgroup B, al* thou^i group A vs tignificandy younger. In coochaton, tide extern!e study, todndtag a total of915 workers expoied in the pen to VCM as well as PVC dust may point
to e potential msttipk factor effect ofsmoking end VCM-PVC exposure. In this connection.lt is oftaterest to note that according to a cohort study ofmortality among VCM polymerization-workers the OCRs for respiratory cancer as well as foe other respiratory disease' wen found to hm been In excess of expected figures (156 end 176, raapectheiy) (Mnrwefler at at 1976).
Bronchopulmonary changes thought to be due to longcontinued, intense exposure fo PVC dust ware observed by sevetsl authors (fiwmcgtof and Sestf !955;roua*rf
8 6 W.K. Lelbach and H.J. Mjmctler
l969:S:ettde et al. 1970; Verrkin and Mamontov 1910\Fro/tfia et al. 1914: Darke 1976.Arnaud et al. 1978). Considerable exposure to VPCdust is the nite in the drying, bagging and ftonfeareas of PVC-produring plants. Riotographs contained in Kantadt'i paper (1976) give a general idea of the potential dust exposure. Measurements of the concentration of PVC dust at various sites of the bagging operations were reported as long ago as 1955 by Permegguni andSasri. In 1969 Bmussard mentioned the possibil ity of development of chronic bronchitis caused by the inhalation of PVC dust. The insoluble and inactive dust panicles were thought to accumulate in the lungs blocking alveolar spaces and being taken up by alveolar cells. This could lead to elimination of these ceils via lymph vessels to regional lymph nodes, with either enlargement of the hilar region or a micronodular aspect of interstitial pulmonary fibrosis without hilar lymph node enlargement but progressive respiratory insufficiency.
Ssende et al. (1970) reported the case of a 31-year-old worker who presented with severe dyspooea: a chest x-ray examination revealed diffuse micronodular pulmonary lesions. He had been engaged for only 1 year in shovelling PVC powder at a processing factory. Lung biopsy revealed moderate diffuse fibrosis and snail focal granulomatous lesions containing ovoid or polygonal birefringent foreign material which could be eluted by treatment with a known solvent of PVC. Microscopic examination of PVC dust particles collected at the patient's place of work showed,them to be morphologic ally identical with the particles found in the patient's lungs.
Another anecdotal case of pneumoconioBs after 33 yean of employment in a PVC bagging area, with radiological evidence of diffuse micronodular infiltrates and granu lomatous lesions found in a lung biopsy identical with those recorded by Szendc et al.. was published by Amaid et al. in 1978. Histology of open lung biopsies in 1 of 14 VCMexposed British workers, who complained of breathlessness, revealed focal alveo lar wall thickening with macrophages in alveolar spaces and increased retieulin and col lagen on electron microscopy (Darke 1976). Although chest x-ray appearances were normal and routine respiratory function tests showed only slightly impaired C03 dif fusion in six individuals, perfusion and ventilation scam revealed strikingly abnormal pictures, including marked perfusion defects ofupper lobes. Darke pointed out that tome of the men worst affected had been engaged in the polymerization of *pIastisor. a very fine PVC powder with partide size around Oi ton.
StUkoff(1976) called attention to results obtained by Frortfia et al. (1974), who observed significant histopatbological changes in the lungs of guinea-pigs and rats ex posed for 2-7 months to inhalation of the airborne PVC dust in a PVC bagging area. Lesions began to appear at 2 months of exposure (alveolar histiocyte-macrophage re actions); they proved to be. fairly marked after 4 months, with appearance of foreign body giant cells, and proceeded to development oflarge Insestitial granulomatous fod. Vartkm and Mamontov (1970) who examined 96 workers engaged hi the manu facture ofarticles made from PVC powder, also found a considerable proportion of them were suffering from functional and morphological attentions of the bronchopulmonary system, which they ascribed to their exposure to PVC dust. They que ed results ofearlier animal experiment! conducted in 1963 by Gobvetyuk and later by ShfyakhetskU. These last authors had apparently diown that exposure of animals to PVC dost may lead to the development of chronic pneumonia and eventually to a sort of mfld fibrosa of the lungs.
\.
sti bl Sl; t'.:
w
O'
of dv er,.
ot despe
4.4
Th JD m-
mu tit
ter ,1ftme I4* co> re. po 1 an fab Jo ha> h-> of an ms pb
19' of VC
t J. Homelier
74;Z>enfce <n the drying. I inKanladft nits of the - reported as the possibtl* dust. The ngs blocking minaoon of nent of the Tbout hilar
ited with i pulmonary i a processing vmJomitous could be ion ofPVC morphologic-
.cm in a PVC and granu* '.tiuic et al.. - 3 of 14
*>wal alveo'iiin and col lects were i CO* dif- abnormal *j <nat that 4 ^pbstteoT.
i * 74), who >nd rats exggtag area, ropfcage re> of foreign hwnatota * the menu. iroon of broncho* hey quoted nd later by animate to -diytoa aort
Mnyi Chioride*Associated Disease
87
Certain ty pes of PVC dust (one of two samples tested) were found to exhibit a strong haemolytic potential due to the presence of an undetermined but readily solu ble surface-associated agent which was not VCM (Richards et al. 1975). These authors also studied the effect of the haemolytic sample of PVC dust on lung fibroblast cul tures. but they did not obtain any significant results.
Contrary to earlier indications (Lang* et aL 1974a) and despite continued efforts we failed to detect any significant restrictive changes of pulmonary* function in the overwhelming majority of patients we had occasion to examine.
It may be of interest to note that Maltoni et al. (1974b) reported a high prevalence of pathological changes of respiratory epithelium (squamous metaplasia, squamous dysplasia, typical and atypical adenomatous proliferation) in sputum samples from employees of Italian VCM-PVC factories.
Nevertheless, contrary to the now weU*stibIished role ofVCM in the production of nonnalignant lesions of bone, skin, small vessels. Uvar and spleen, it Is still open to debate piadaely what importance can be ascribed to pulmonary changes within the spectrum of VCM4nduced disease.
4.4.4 Genetic Effects ofVCM
The discovery of the carcinogenic properties ofVCM also stimulated interest in its mutagenic potential. A number ofstudies have been carried out that demonstrated a mutagenic response to VCM or its metabolites in microbial test systems. Point muta tions due to base^air substitution have been produced in various strains ofSalmonella typhomtnum by VCM in the presence of animal and human liver rrucrosomes as a sys tem of metabolic activation (Ronmtg et al. 1974,1976;5omrfr et al. 1975a, 1976; McCann et al. 1975;.ifrin,<tffret al. l9?5:Gsm>et al. 1976). Mutagenicity' of VCM metabolites was also demonstrated in yean strains (Lopnono et al. 1976,1977;Sho/wt 1976) and in "*" calls (Hubenmn ex al. 1975). In comparison to nonexposed controls, a rignifleandy higher incidence of duomoaotnal aberrarioos (fragmentation, rearrangement) in lymphocytes ofworkers occupationally exposed to VCM was re* posted by Dueaonen et al. (1975),/,<MfOurie<e et aU (1975), Asrctae et aL (1975, 1976), and Fomenko et at (1976). Fkif and 77tiesr (1974) had failed to demonstrate mi increased rate ofchromosomal aberrations in six chenticsl engineers and four PVC fabrication workers. As to the Influence on germ cells, Furcheae et al. reported that no doomam lethal affects were seen in fetuses of female mice mated with males which had been exposed to 3000.10 000 and 30 000 ppm VCM for 5 consecutive days. This, however, does not absolutely exdude genetic effects on human gonads, The outcome of pnpuney among wives ofVCM-potymerixstion workers as against wives of rubber and PVC-fobricstion wosfcars (JnJmte et at 1976a. b) and rates of conganital malfor mation per 1000 resident five births in three Ottio communitiM with PVC production plants hem also been sorted (Jnfentt 1976).
As pert ofa taigm survey ofworkers* tmlih. interview queirionndm {Infante 1976a,b) titowed that afar paternal agaadjunimntadgniflcsnriy higher inddence offind mortality subsequent to patamd exposure was recorded among the wives of VC1I ixptesd workers.This trend eras found to be maintdnsd after ettednation of
r-o to CO
s
$X W.K. Lelba,,h and H.i. Mare'.kr
pregnancies in women who had more than two abortions. The findings of this study raised the question or possible genetic risks of VCM to man and led to the suggestion that germ-cell damage in the father through direct VCM exposure might be a possible explanation.
No clear-cut linkage of PVC production and increased occurrence of congenital malformations (primarily CN5 malformations) emerged from preliminary studies in three Ohio communities with PVC production plants. But the need for further study of possible conuibutary factors was indicated (Infavtc 1976). In fact, none of the par ents of affected children in Painsvflle, one of the three Ohio communities, had ever worked at either of the two PVC polymerization piano in Painsvilie or lived within two miles of these piano (Eamonds et ai. 1975).
5 Conclusion and'Outlook
The combined efforts of multiple disciplines have been necessary to arrive at the full recognition of the range of pathology associated with occupational exposure to vinyl chloride. It can only be hoped that the lesson from the vinyl chloride problem may help to bring about an increased awareness of the risks and hazards which are inevitably the consequence of an ever^xpanding technology.
The importance of this lesson lies in its exemplary nature. A single substance of rather simple chemical structure, which was long held to be a comparatively safe com pound, even by experts, turned out after all to be a carcinogen with a very long latency1 period for those who were heavily exposed to it. But its carcinogenic properties would most probably still have gone unnoticed if the resulting malignancy had been any can cer other than of an exceptionally rare type. Animal experiments in the early days later proved to have been broken off before the oncogenicity of this chemical com pound could have been detected.
The lesson to be learned is that in future any new chemical which is to be widely introduced into the environment should be scrutinized closely, for e sufficient length of time, and with the aid of all available methods for the detection of potential car cinogenic efleets. In addition, we should keep in mind that in industrial surroundings we almost never deal with a single compound, but with a very complex occupational environment whose carcinogenic potential is still a completely unresolved problem.
If currently adopted guidelines for industrial hygiene an strictly adhered to, there it reason to hope that initiation of new cases of VCM-indisced angiosarcoma of the Uver can be effectively prevented. Unfortunately, however, it pan be expected that in view of the long latency period for tumour promotion additional cases wfl] appear dur ing the next decade.
Considering the ever-increasing complexity ofenvironmental influences, future re search will be faced with almost insurmountable obstacles in its endeavour to establish We* levels for potentially hazardous chemicals. Promising areas for further studies in the field of vinyl chloride and allied compounds may be the problem of the interaction
Vinyl Chlon
between pre*.1 tissue such a? short exposu will carry the
References
^ iB ^
w
Albright LF t Aibngtu LF < > Albright LF ( Albright LF <
polyvinyl v Albnght LF <
processes Alrenga DP i 1
198-203
Amann R (19 der Leber '
Anderson H \
CEA amoi; I560--I56* Andrews AW properties Angheiescu F V(l969jr
employees 473-482 Annua] Repc London.Ci Anronyuzhensian (ext). * Antweiler H ' Penpect l ' Amaud A. Por. ride pneurr
Aryanpur J t 1 Iran. J Occ<.
Assmann HU Austin GT (10
87-89
Bachner U. t und ttsoph.3409-241 <
Bachner U. Ft. Befunde be Jahreiberie!
Centner. S: Bachner U, Mu
1000 patier
Bachner U.Ei/ und Csoph:
Blutungen ..
'J Mamtihrr
this study suggestion . a possible
mgenitaJ *nidies in -the: study e of the par. !uii ever rd within
at the full :re to vinyl 'Jem may .re inevitably
:ance of ly safe com ing latency :rties would
-n any can* ft, days val cost-
widely i ntlength ,*adai car* trroundings cupational : problem. Ted to, there na of the cted that in U appear dnr-
.s.future ret to establish ^studies in lie ininaction
Vmyl Chlonde*Associatcd Dtsca*e
89
between predominantly hepatocytic metabolism and oncogenic effect on mesenchymal tissue such as vascular endothelium, and also the question of whether intermittent
short exposures at high concentrations or continuous exposure at a low concentration will carry the greater risk.
References
Albnght LF (1967a) Vinyl Chloride processes. Chem Eng 74:1:3-130 Albnght LF i1967b) Manufacture of vinyl chionde. Chem Eng 74 :19-22* Albright LF 11967c) Polymerisation of vinyl chloride. Chem Eng 74:151-158 Albnght LF f 1967d) Vinyl chloride polymerization by suspension processes yirlds
polyvinyl chionde resins. Chem Ent 74:145-152 Albnght LF (1967$) Vinyl chloride polymenzaoon by emulsion, bulk and solution
processes. Chem Eng 74:85-92 Alrenga OP < 1975) Primary angiosarcoma of the liver. Review article. Int Surg 60:
198-203 Amann R (1975) Bering zur Vmylchlorid-Knnkheit. - Ein Fall von Angioiaricom
der Leber. Dissertation. Umversitit Freiburg Anderson HA, Snyder S. Lewinson I. W00C. Lilia R. Selikoff 1J (1978) Levels of
CEA among vinyl chloride and polyvinyl chloride exposed workers. Cancer *2: 1560-156? Andrews AW, Zawistowslti ES. Valentine CR (1976) A comparison of the mutagenic properties of vinyl chloride and methyl chloride. Mutat Res 40:273-276 Anghelescu F, Otoju M. Dobrinescu E. Hsgi*Paruchiv*Oosrios L. Dobrinescu G. Cans* V < 1969) Clinico^>uhogeneuc considerations on Raynaud's phenomenon among employees of the polyvinyl chloride industry. (Rumanian text) Med Interna 21:
473-482 Annual Report of the Chief Inspector of Factories for the Year 1951 (I9S3) HMSO
London. Cmd 8772 Aotosyuzhenko VA (1968) On the occupational vinyl chloride intoxication. (Rus
sian text). Gig Tr Prof Zabol 12: 50-52
Antweikr H (1976) Studies on the mecaboiisa of vinyl chloride. Environ Health Penpect 17:217-219
Arnaud A. Pomnrier de Sand P. Garb* L. Payan H, Charpin 1 (1978) Polyvinyl chlo ride pneumoconiotis. Thorax 33:19--25
Aryanpur J (1977) Vinyl chloride: its impact on occupational medicine practice in Inn. J Occup Med 19:689-092
Assmean H (1921) Die Rbntgendiagnostik der inneren Erfcrakungen. Vogel, Leipzig Austin GT( 1974) Industrially significant organic chemicals, part 3. Chem Eng 81:
87-89 Bachner U, Etzel F. Lange CE. Mamciler HJ, Veitman G (1974a) Himoatasebefundc
end Gsophagusvarizen bai Vinyfehlorid-Kiaafcheit Dtsch Med Wochenschr 99: 2409-2410 Bachner U. Enel F,Lange CE, Jflhe S, Veitman G (1974b) Gerinnungsphysiolofisebc Befunda bet VsnytettioridkiankhciL In: Lahacrt G. Szadkowsfci 0, Weber KJ (ads) Jahrasbericfatder 14. Jahrestagung der Dcuschen GemUscfctft (Br Arbeitsmedizin. Centner, Stuttgart, pp 275--280 Bachner V, MGBer R. Eitii H (1975a) Clinfell relevanca of piaiafet ftmetion tests in 1000 patients with bamorrhagfe diathesis. Thtomb Res 6:139-149 lirtmar t/.Ettd F, Lange CE. MarsteUerHJ. Veltnun G (t975b) Himostaacbefunda nnd Oeophagumariten bat Viayfehiorid-Krankheit. In: Marx R. Thin KA (eds) Btutungen das GaetrointesOnaitnkies- Schattanor, Stuttgart New York, pp 67-73
90 W.K. Lelbach and HJ. Mareteller
Bachncr U, Etxel F. Muller N, Lange CE. Egii H < 1976) Praneopiastische und kollagenisierende Verinderutigen der Leber und Hamostasebefunde bet PVC-.Arbeuern. In: Gastpar H(ed) Onkohamostaseologie. Schatuucr. Stuttgart New York, pp 319-326
Banti G (1898) Splenomegalie mil Leberzirrhose. Beirr Pathol Anat AUg Pathol 2-*: 21-33
Barbin A. BresiJ H, Crouy A. Jacquignon P. Malaveille C. Montesano R. Bartsch H (1975) Liver-microsome mediated formation of alkylating agents from vinyl bro* mide and vinyl chloride. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 67:596--603
Baretta ED. Stewart RD. Mutchler JE f 1969) Monitoring exposures to \;nyl chloride vapor: breath analysis and continuous air sampling. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 30.557544
Bames AW (i 976) Vinyl chloride and the production of PVC. Proc R Soc Med 69: 277-281
Bartsch H, Malaveille C. Montesano R.Tomatis L (1975a) Tissue-mediated mutager.Tcicy of vinylidene chloride and 2<hlorobutadiene in Salmonella typhimunum. Nature 255:641-643
Bartsch H, Malaveille C, Montesano R f 197Sb) Human, rat. and mouse liver mediated mutagenicity of vinyl chloride in S. typhimunum strains. Int J Cancer 15/3:429437
Bartsch H. Malaveille C. Barbin A. Bresit H.Tomatis L. Montesano R (1976) Mutagen icity and metabolism of vinyl chlonde and related compounds. Environ Health Perspect 17:192 -- 198
Basalaev AV, Vatin AN. Kosetkov AG (1972) On the pathogenesis of changes develop ing due to long-term exposure to the effects of vinyl chlonde. Gig Tr Prof Zabol 16:24-27 (Russian text)
Basu AK. Boyer J. Bhattacharya R, Bani Maliik KC, Sen Gupta KP (1967a) Noncirrhotic portal fibrosis with portal hypertension: a new syndrome. 1. Clinical and function studies and results of operations. Indian J Med Res 55:336-350
Basu Maliik KC. Sen Gupta KP. Basu AK. Biswas SK. Pal NC, Boyer J (1967b) Noncirrhotic portal fibrosis with portal hypertension: a new syndrome. II. Histopalho! ogical studies. Indian J Med Res 55:351-359
Baumann E (1872) Uber einige Vinytverbindungen. Liebigs Ann Pharm 163:308 -322 Baxter PJ (1976) Epidemiological studies of PVC manufactures and fabricators, and
primary angiosarcoma of the liver. Proc R Soc Med 69:297-299 Baxter PJ. Fox AJ (1975) Angiosarcoma of the liver as the certified cause of death
1963-1973. Lancet 11:27-28 Baxter PJ, Fox AJ (1976) Angiosarcoma of the liver in P.V.C. fabricators. Lancet
1:245 Baxter, PJ, Anthony PP, McSween RNM, Scheuer PJ (1977) Angiosarcoma of the liver
in Great Britain. 1963-1973. Br Med J 11:919-921 Becker V. BQsscher K (1961) Uber das Himangioendotheliom der Leber. Acta Hepato-
Splenol 8:356-379 Benoit J-P(1967) L'acro-osteolys* d'origine professionals. Thtse, University of Lyon Berk PD. Martin JF, Waggoner JG (1975) Persistence of vinyl chloride induced liver
injury after cessation of exposure. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:70-77 Berk PD, Martin JF, Young RS. Creech J, Seiikoff U. Falk H. Watanabe P, Popper H,
Thomas L(l976) Vinyl cMoride-asociatcd liver disease. Ann Intern Med 84: 717-731 Berrod JL, Lasard P. Pierre C.Puech A. Ravier E, Rety J.Smagghe G(l97g) A Propos dc 10 obrerations d'angiosarcoaes hfpariques survcnus chez des ouvrien exposes au chlorure da vinyte. Paper presented at the 19th International Congress of Occupational Medicine, Dubrovnik, 2S-30 September, 1978 Berry G, Roetiter CE (1976) Vinyl chloride and mortality? Laaeet 11:416-417 BcnifsgenaaenschafUichcGnindsStze fQr arbeitsmedizinisehe Vonorgeuntersuchungen. Gefihrdung dutch Vlnylchlorid. Faming Juii 1974. Arbeitsmed Soziaimed Praeventivmed 9:226--229
Vinyl Ohio.
Biercack HJ sztntigrai renagunj: 3 10. (Bn.
Biersack HJ Cf 1975r ten mit \
Biersack HJ gnphy (Stuttgi J
Biersack HJ schiden IVmylchio 88
Blendis LM. sion in vir. 75:206-2
Block JB ( 19' 229.53-5-
Blomfield J. current he:
Boll HM (1 97 HM.Bann. England, p
Bolt HM. Rap 1:1425
Bolt HM. Kap of ,4C vir
Bolt HM. Ki| 33 m the rat r~ Bolt HM. Lj:; 3^ in the rat Vo Bolt HM. Kar
lite. In: G.. ehlond-Kr..
onneton G de nipnin rure de vin;
Bonneton G. < Many F. r leurs du ch.
Bone G. Urbj oxirane tor perfused ra-
Bonk J (192* Neurol Psy.
Border EA. oxide and . Interact 17
Boyer JL. Sen (1967) Idi. cirrhosis an-
Brady J, Liber Polan A. Vi Natl Cancer
i Mantelie:
*id koftagem* -euera. In: *p 319-326 atbot ;.
rtsch H ?nyl bro-
. i chlondc J 30:537-
Med 69:
mutagenicmum.
.r mediated .`5,1.429-
'*>) Mutagen* Health Per-
'v'-'s developfZaboJ
4 \onnical and JO ~hi Non* ' itopathoi
308 -322 ran. ini
... death
I mm
4 of the live*
\ctt Kcpaio
.v, of Lyon meed liver
".Popper H. 0 84:
S AFropo* ers exposes cssof
Vinyl Chionde*.Aociared Disease
91
Bierjack HJ, Lance CE. Vltmaft C. Winkler C I975a> Bestemung dei Leber* nd Milt* uinneraphie fGr die Diagnose der Vinylchiorid-Krankhen. Beriiht Sber die IS. Jah* restating der Deutsehen GeseliKhart fUr Arbeitsmediiin. 24:-26.4 1975.pp 305310 (Brenner W. Rohmert 'V. Rurenfrant J. eds), Gentnet. Stuttgart
Bienack HJ. Lange CE. Ebmger H. Manteller HJ. Lelbach WK. Vltmjn G. Winkler C 1I9?5bi Sequenuzinugraphii'Che Unremjcftungsn von Leber und Milt bei Pauerx-
ttn nw Vinyichiond-Kranxheu. Duch Med Wochenschr IOQ:6i5-61" Bterxack HJ, San Luh T Jr, Lange CE. Tiieien M. VeJtman G. Winkler C (19rrai Scinti
graphy of live: and spleen m vinyl chloride workers. Acta Hepato Gastroenterol (Stung) 24 ?5"-36l
Btenack HJ. Ebinger H. Winkler C ( 1977b) Leber-Malt-Siinugramm bei Vinylchlortd* scftdden In: Gutaeker HW. Lelbach WK leds) LsberschSden dutch Vm>ichJond -
Vinytehlorid*Knn)eheit. Wjttstrock. Baden*8aden Brussel Kdla New York, pp 6-4ffi
Blendis LM. Smith PM. Lawn* BW. Stephens MR. Evans WD (1978) PortaJ hyperten* lion in vinyl chloride monomer workers. A hemodynamic study Gastroenterology 75:206--211
Block. IB < 1974) Angiosarcoma of the liver following vinyl-chloride exposure. MMA 229:53-54
Blomfleld J. Ois.on SR. McCrvdie DA (1971) Potential hepatoioxicity of copper in re* current hemodialysis. Arch intern Sled 128:555-560
Bolt HM (1978) Metabolic activation of haiogenated ethylene. In Retnmer H. Bolt HM. Bannasch P, Popper H (eds) Primaty liver tumors. MTP Press. Lancaster/ England, pp 285-294
Boll HM. Kappus H. Buehter A. Bolt W( 197J) Metabolism of vinyl chloride. Lancet
I: J 425 Bolt HM. Kappus H. JCaufmann R. Appel K.E. Buehter A* Bolt W {1978a) Metabolism
of **C vrnyl chloride in vitro and tn vnro. 1NSERM Symp Ser 52:151-164 Bolt HM. Kappus K. Buehter A. Bolt W U9?6b) Disposition of {I J-1 * Cjvinyl chloride
in the rat. Arch Toxicol 35:153--162 Bolt HM. loib RJ. Kappus H. Buehter A (1977a) Pharraacokmt ics of vinyl chloride
in the rat. Toxicology 7:179-168 Bolt HM. Kappus H. Buehter A. Bolt W f (977b) Reaktmtgc der Visyichloridmatabo-
life. In: Gutaeker HW. Lelbach WK (eds) Lebenebides durch Vinylchlorid - Vinyl*
cJUorid-Krankheit. Witmrocfc. Baden*Baden BnHxel K6la New York, pp 32-35 Bonneton G. Champetier J, Sorto J, GuidicelliG, Letoubion C. Panh M < 1975> Ua caa
de rapture sponunie d'anposveome hipatioue chet ua tnvailUuf txposl aa chlorure de vinyl*. Chtflufie 101:936-942 Bonnetoo G. Champ*tier J. Foumct J, GiudkcUi H, Legmnd J. Duprd A. Mostein 31.
Marry* F. Panh M (1977) Anpesareom* h<paaque *t Gbrose portale chet l*s txavailleurs dtt chlorare tfe vinyls. Noov Press* Mid 6:735-742 Bonse 0. Urban T, Reichert 0. Heaachler D (1975) Chemical reactivity, metabolic oxirsne formation and biological reactivity of chlorinated ethylene* in the isolated perfused rat liver preparation. Biochtm Pharmacol 24:1829-1834 Borak J (1927) 2ur Pathogen*** und Thertpie der Raynaud'schen Kmokheit. Z Gs Neural Psychiatr 3:1-16 Border EA. Webster t (1977) Tb* effect ofvinyl chloride monomer. cUerocthylea* oxide and chioracatsldebyde oa DNA ryathem in sifeseradni tat liver. Qwiit Biot Utenct P:239-247 Boyer JL. Ses Gupta KF. Btswm 5K. Pal SC, Ban Maflflc fCC.tber FL. Basa AX UH7) Idiopathic portal byperetailoa. Compaosod with the portal hypertsaaton of cirrhoais sad oxsabspatic portal vein ohatiucrion. Ana Intern Med 66:41-68 Brady l.Ubetitoia F. Harper P, Greenwald P. Burnett f, Davies JNF, Biahop M. Polas A. Vienna N (1977) Angiosarcoma of the liver: an epidemiolotic survey. J N&U Cancer tost 59:1383-1383
C
-& r~
W.K. Leibach and H.J. Marstcller
Bndbord K.Brubaker PE.Gay B, French JG (19751 Exposure to halogsnated hydro carbons in the indoor environment. Environ Health Perspect 11; 215-220
Bront'enmajerS. Schaffner F. Popper H (1966) Fat-storing ceils (lipocytes) in human liver. Arch Pathol 82 447-453
Broussard Cl 11969) Paiologia da resinc poliviniliche. Med Bull (Naples) 52:102 -- 108 Bruder U. Straby A t ] 075) Exposure to vinv I chlonde in PVC processing industries. --
Report TK 176 on a survey in collaboration with the Swedish Plastics Industry and the Agency for the Protection of Workers. Stockholm. February i975 (Swedish text > Buchter A. Bolt HM. Kappus H.BoltW(1977) Die Gewebsverteilung vo.: 1.2-'* CVmylchiond bei der Ratte. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 39:27-32 Buffler PA. Wood S. Suarez L. Kilian DJ (1979) Mortality experience of workers in a vinyl chloride monomer production plant. J Occup Med 21:195-203 Byczkowska Z. Langauer-Lewowicka H (1974) Raynaud's syndrome in workers em ployed in production of polyvinyl chloride. (Polish text). Pol Tyg Lek 29:14611464 Byren 0. Holmberg B 11975) Two possible cases of angiosarcoma of the liver in a group of Swedish vinvl chlondc-polyvinvj chloride workers. Ann NY Acad Sci 246: 249-250 Byrtn D. Engholm G. Engiund A. Westerholm P (1976) Mortality and cancer morbid ity in a group of Swedish VCM and PVC production workers. Environ Health Per spect 17:167-170 Carr J. Burginson RM. Vitcha JF. Krantz JC (1949) Anesthesia. XXIV. Chemical con stitution of hydrocarbons and cardiac automaticity. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 97 | Chainuvati T, Viranuvatn V (1979) Idiopathic portal hypertension and chronic arsenic poisoning. Report of a case. Am J Dig Dis 24:70--73 Chateiain A. Molillon P (1967) Un syndrome d'acro-osteolyse d'origine professionnelk ei de constaution nouvelle en France. J Radiol Electrol Med Nuel 46:277-280 Cheney WD (1965) Acro-osteolysis. Am J Roentgenol 94:395-607 Chowdhury AR. Biac; M. LorberSH. Chey WY (1977) Haemangioendotheliomaiosis of the liver. A 12.x ear follow-up, Gastroenterology 72:137-160 Colardyn F. van der Straeten M. Lament H. van Peteghem T (1976) Acute inhalationintoxication by combustion of polyvinylchloride. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 38:121-127 Conolly RB. Jaeger RJi Szabo S (1978) Acute hepatotoxicity of ethylene, vinyl fluo ride, vinv! chloride sad vinyl bromide after aroclor 1254 pretreatment Exp Mol Pathol 28:25-33 Cook WA.Giever PM, Oinman BD. Magnuson Hi (1971) Occupational scroosteolysis. H. An industrial hygiene study. Arch Environ Health 22:74--82 Corbett TH (1975) inhalation anesthetics - more vinyl chloride? Environ Res 9:211214 Cordkr JM. Fievez C. Lefivre MJ.Sevrin A (1966) Acroosteolyse et lesions cutanees chez deux ouvriers affeetds au nettoyage d'autoclaves. Cah Med Tia 4:14, 3-39 Comoh HH, Abar EL (1969) Toxicity of pyrolysis products of vinyl plasties. Arch Environ Health 19:15-21 Couderc P, Panh MH. Pisquier B. Pasquier D. N'Golet A. Faure H (1976) Angiosarcome irtttvw livflateur d'une tumeur hepatique chez ua tnvaillcur expose au
chlonsie de vinyle. Sem H6p Paris 52:1721-1722 Covriishaw JL. Pollard EJ.Cowen AE, Powell LW (1979) Liver disease associated with
chronic arsenic ingestion. Aust NZ J Med 9:910-313 Creedi JL. Johnson MN (1974) Angiosarcoma of the liver in the manufacture of poly
vinyl chloride. J Occup Med 16:150-151 Creech JL,MtkkL( 1975) Liver disease among polyvinyl chloride production workers.
Ann NY Acad Sci 266:88-94 Creech JL. Johnson MN. Block A (1974a) Epidemiologic notes and reports. Angio
sarcoma of the liver among polyvinyl chloride workers. Morbid Mortal Weekly Rep
23:49-50
C. 33 rO
oJ
Vinyl ChlonU.
Creech JL. M. vinyl clilon Gastroentv
Daiderup LM < 1 7:285--2?
Ddlderup LM Lancet 1:24
DtmnaherC. ) coma cheni-. May 16-29
Danziger H (I 0 Med Assc.
Darke CS(197< lion of PVC
DattaDV.Mit;. toxication a cirrhotic po
Davies JW.Per: Environ Poll
Deese DE, Joyr lnd Hyg As*
Delorme F {19' chlorate de
Delorme F (19" ouvrier du c1
Delorme F. Me? tact prolong. Union Med '
Delorme F. T;i Quebec. J O
Devignevjelle l` polyvinyhq..
Dmman BD. C tionai aero- -
Dod'on VN. Du rional acroo-
Doll R( 1975) . Domininghaus i:
-- Anwendi Dor JF. Arlauu
(1975) Anp, rare de poly Dressman RC. v miration of \ Sci 15:69 Du JT. Tambun chlonde expo Ducatman A. H>. chromosome Duck BW (1975 i Duck BW (197o > 307-309 Duck BW, Carle Duck BW. Carte chlonde prod
:
j-`L
:'La if
_ f .*
;. it.*. , / . -
*-rA
66! 1-161 l-tl
uopmpoid apuoftp
iXtiuXiod t n u>vm jo Xpius Xircuom (161) f3 q3 if Jau*o Ag *m<j
561 -11
-jojipa oj Jin (9i6i) jj jw:\g )pn<|
60f"i0 69 P*KS 90jj *sjio* poofip (Ao** jo aoovtBfcum ft*p*n (9161) Ml
19Z-09Z'Z D f J| nMPopi9 apnow |Xoia (S161> Mt V0 89I-f91-C/l f sty mtiK nioptltaqe woonutaiqs
ocnmi pvt aiaaodxa apuorqa |XoiA ($161) fl JPJR9S '* tuovpwrn *y muenQ
*SH :$ 90J6 P*d 'nu pasodxa apuoTtp \Auu m i**n o Ajyqwt *mn)dsoi|d^onn|t pmhmq (pj^i) HD cuxnquiE^ `if n<j
jSottaioJtQ f
imn
tl-69iffIPS wrdojmtuqM it jaic* tn appopp fXuu jo uonemiu
^taiap am jo; poipaui linfend apsoq-aiduin y ($ jj jg aajjtjsK -3* uttunuQ
0Zl~60l:ZI I PW
**fXUA|od p miu
oms np jiuircacji un iaqc `moj np tnjjip xa9Ua* sa cftcntdcs awo^cy <$*,$ | j
K H!*WK 'f [utAoptj > Rtiaiqri `r orutqst* *j aintj `3 37 pnepy 'j; to<j
popl**e0 `HA'lOA P put 'urfunpua-nuy -
uauotjjojoran^ - saipipsoatft pue mqjny j ajjojsjiBnj (;i6U H nnutniinsoo
i:"0Cf 9t P$ Pwv AN WV dd uoin.>pQ <5i6i) y roq
J<-t~t m*H
qmy Apro* (tsiiifp y ] reXjoawooc* jtuon
cdnsoo (116!) m o*nirt?iv *KNY **N *KA oqniVG8 uew?a *KA uo*fOQ fi-19'Zr mi*tH uojuoj q.\iy Xpnjs (tncfoionsapida uy i nsAjoatsocuae piioi)
*edia?o <1161 11 lPi?0 TH uotmiirn;
acnoqaini^-yA V^O'QB uawu'O
uouia '(UJCK-iincs p surootfnucK np ateatpajs *at*js 'S*nbt|Auy..\jod
sauisai sap aicjuautpadxa nbi*0|09txoi apnjg (c$6! > WY laqantd 0
Or- 8C:OC PK dnwo f ssqanO *uc6niuk*qs ui ja!| aq} jo atuoaiccoifiit jo tans ui (g^qi) q )|nrum .niuc^o
JTl-9fiiyoi 5 P*K uorun
*raoiCfi np anbifoioqdaoa uonduanp :afXuu p atfuorqa a| sbac a3uo(0Jd inn
uoa ua tuale uaui.no sop zaqb ate; np tuioajttorfuy (SL61) *1
d auuojaa
rl l --SO! *fc
icuy uuy a|AUiA ap aiiuom^ np jauxno
un iaya 'auioiedjq un.p laaioj np auibMtsoilu* ttn,p uopetsony fqgial > d aiuiojaa
rOl't6:n
iomtj jcuy uuy |Xuu ap vmotqs
np uaiMnc sap mijji aio; np saUiO-'jciotSu^p suatpcucp sta o( (tgf61) J *uuo'9(]
iSl"6*r:0t f
* <H PI
iuy -ajnsodxa urumq dtuosqa jo Xpmt t :imt |-<u<a (6961) 3)1 nu.Xof -ga m>(J
> **UK npog uoiuug
sapjoq OAd Ul Pnbi uo jsajja s.iaojouom apuow? jauia (5161) V Xud U
ffi-fil;OI jn0 C*PU! Ul
|tuod 3rjoqu:s
uouj uoisuauad.lir i^uod nruiedoipi ui joinc; rratlotonaf aiqissod c sc uoacatvot
ui Masj ro aiuorqj (6i6I)KM ,4AgtiQ -'.sj Toeunqqj *^SJ1!K`AC *a
is:-08r :69 V*K U 3g
) uop
snpojd ai|) p apuomfl }.<u?a :saweg ^-y :) i(jeuiaj uo!n.**sifl(9i$i)SD
Of 8-S:8:Z8 flossy pK
uc^ sases oaI jo uodan apuofqp jXuu Xq ftnuostod frjuappfy (0961) H wStiurQ
curtsmo-7 `sutajio
'6i6i '61-91 'CK
iuijaa|v '*r*u| `unjaasa^ la^ur^ joj unnrr.'osfy urr*uauj\ \dc;a;j;ou:si(.' cuo?
icsotfuc rucdaq p.^jcnoisr apuojq?
(61611 3 oiinqtuci `n ujc^ iatrruurQ
OfT I sa^ur-j
jjAii aqi jc cuio.-jcvoisuv (9161) Si lSJOtj^wo-ia `js^a 'DS ujj
diuap^a
9s:->s:it
r^J%; di^O f '9A!l 1,l* )o nuo.MCsorgueuxatq puc apuc'lV-' jXuja (Si6l > l\*T dnjapftg
981 19 (8o|oiMuaoj]Sf>i)
wciiojd aaur(|ia.uns jo jcaX juij tuunp ua!jio.n uon3npojd (j(\d> aruo|q? |.f i.\
|Od Suouic Ait.`>ixojojrd>H qribl HJ OAinqturi *jf Jf nMM -1
'Tf q.-oajj
i`6 wcasiQ piei^n?Y*apuo|tQ t.<u:A
d**XW*A otSsy 'l-
-ua^oa oms.
Xjod jo atm-
tfiua patco>>>
ns aaodx-v. 'otfuv
qajy 6C-OI saaucsna -oi.
tit*** TTs.ljoaw--i
rw <*H -onu (Xuiv
mrH r--
UUIIPTfqU!
osc-n: auauuotsaj\ i
Muastc .'tuc'iu I -16 `U
UO5 {totuiat;
-JSJ mftaH piqjoui tarv
Off S Pc;,\ * ui iaA>:
-19W-6r ua uamo.
* ui ur>.v.
o*.*n (iv qstpa^<
puc .Uisnpui - safiimpiit
80t-:ot:r
ucuinq ui -
or:
-oip.<q pv
jaioistvj^ ( i
94 W.K. Lelbach an-f H.J. Marsieller
Dugoij P. Ambbrd P.de Bigmcourt B.Lecrand J (1972) Acropathic polyvinylique profesionndle. Bull Soc Fr Dermatol Syphiligr 79. 197-198
Dupas J. Badelon P, Daydf G (1956) Osteolysc esseniiellc profrevive de la main gauche d'origin* indeterminde- Mem Acad Clisr 62:148- ISS
van Duuren L (1975) On the possible mechanism of carcinogenic action of viny l chlo ride. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:258-267
Dyer RF. Esch HV (1976) Polyvinyl chloride toxicity in Fires Hydrogen chloride tox icity in fire fighters. JAMA 256:393-397
Edmonds LD. Falk H, Nissin JE (1975) Congenita] malformations and vinyl chloride Lancet 11:1098
Edmondson HA (1958) Tumours of the liver and intrahepatic bile ducts. In Edmond son HA (ed) Atlas of tumor pathology, sect VII, fasc 25. Published by Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, Washington, pp 1-216
Elmore JD, Wong JL, Laumbach AD, Streips UN (1976) Vinyl chloride mutagenicity - via the metabolites chlorcnaxirane and chloroacetaldehyde monomer hydrate.
Biochem Biophys Acta 442:405--419 Ebon L. Bumstein N (1954) Idiopathic atrophy of bones of feet with typical "neuro
trophic" changes. Am J Med 16:909-914 Escartin Marin P, Alvarez Bustos G, Garcia Plaza A. Fernandez Corugedo A. Arenas
Mirave I, Chantar Barrios C (1974) Hipertensi6n porta idiopatica. Rev Clin Esp 133:255-262 van Esch GJ.van Logten MH (1975) Vinyl chloride: a report of a European assess ment. Toxicology 4:1 -4
Fairhalt LT (1957) Industrial toxicology. 2nd ed. Williams & Wilkins. Baltimore Falk H, Waxweiler RJ (1976) Epidemiological studies of vinyl chloride health effects
in the United States. Proc R Soc Med 69:303-306 Falk H, Creech JL Jr. Heath CW Jr. Johnson MN, Key MM (1974a) Hepatic disease
among workers at a vinyl chloride polymerization plant. JAMA 230:59-63 Falk H. Heath CW Jr, Carter CD, Wagoner JK. Waxweiler RJ. Stringer WT (1974b)
Mortality among vinyl chloride workers. Lancet 11:784 Feron VJ, Kroes R (1979) One-year time sequence inhalation toxicity study of vinyl
chloride in rats. II. Morphological changes in the respirator)' tract, ceruminous glands, brain, kidneys, heart, and spleen. Toxicology 13:131-141 Feron VJ, Spcek AJ. Willems Ml. van Battum D. dc Groot AP (1975) Observations on the oral administration and toxicity of vinyl chloride in rets. Food Cosmet Toxicol 13:633-638 Feron VJ. Kruyne A. Til HP (1979a) One-year time sequence inhalation toxicity study of vinyl chloride in rets. 1. Growth, mortality, haematology, clinical chem istry and organ weights. Toxicology 13:25--28 Feron VJ, Spit BJ, Immel HR, Kroes R (1979b) One-year time sequence inhalation toxicity study of vinyl chloride in rats. III. Morphological changes in the liver. Toxicology 13:143 --154 Fiechtner JJ, Reyes CN Jr (1976) Angiosarcoma of the liver in a rural population. Four cases diagnosed in a 29-month period. JAMA 236:1704-1706 Filatova VS. Babochkina MS (1964) Hygienic assessment of some types of equipment employed for drying and screening of polyvinyl chloride resins. Gig Tr Prof Zabol 8:9-13 (Rusrian text) Filatova VS. Gronsbcrg ES (1957) Hygienic working conditions in the production of polyvinyl chloride resins and measures for improvement GigSanit 1:38-42 (Russian
text) Filatova VS, Balakhonova LI, Gronsberg ES (1958) Hygienic characteristics of vinyl
chloride production. Gig Tr Prof Zabol 2:6-9 (Russian text) Fdatova VS.BIagodatin VM.Goffman FE( 1964) The efficacy of health measures in
the production of polyvinyl chloride resins. Gig Tr Prof Zabol 8:3-6 (Russian text) Fischer J. Wolf R (1963) Die quantitative Abschitzung der Milzfribe mit Hiife der
Scintigraphic. Dtsctf Med Wochenschr 88:1430--1437
3? ro
t_n
Vin\ I
Fisch.
(19 Fine 1
AriFJejscf
. Ho, SIO1 Wc.
Fome of ' poi-
Fox A. Fox A.I
sele. Fox A.1
mor 34 ! Frentz. Arb, Soz Frey HI hani A-b Frong:..' zion Funes-i Goll. Laru
Futh L tion
Gabor Apri
* PGanu'
86 Garro A
effci. Gay BW
ride Gedigk .
vinvi
278 Gedigk
bei v
Leb' Yorl. Gthrini for,. App Gehnr.i to vr 15 -. Gemts ' with Giaccai 29
aa*i\
^****r^-***y5 f>5**
' -. ' f-. I't
t
'it; f f T. '*>: X,*,
1v "
:"-n-
-^
-* ;
. J HJ Mantellcr
rlyvinylique
J* la main
o oi vinyl chio*
--n chlonde tex9
i vinyl chloride.
in: Edmond* i by Armed
le mutagenicity i:i hydrate.
i typical '`neuro-
ciio A. Arenas Rev Gin Esp
Tirpean assess*
. Baltimore Jc health effects
'-pane disease *0-59-63 hT(J9"4hi
*tudy of cmminou-.
< observanoi.' on i i'ohmi Toxicol
ih toxicity .Unicsl ehem-
^nce inhalation in the liver
<1 population. 06 res of equipment i$ Tr Prof label
a production of iij ::Jg-42(Russiaa
Tctsbs of vinyl
jtth measures in t 61Russian text)
mil Hilfe der
Vinyl Chloride-Associated Diea
95
Fischer J. Mundschenk H. Wolf R < 190S) Mtlasainuenphic mit l-Bromomercun i 19*H^i-Hiydrosypfopan (BMHP). ROEFO 103.3-9-366
Ftetf I.Thicss AM 1I974f Oromo*omn-Cntenuchunfen tei Vinylchlorid-Exposiuon Arbeitsmcd Sorialmed Praevennvmed 9:230-283
Fleuchmann R. Schlote W. Schomerus H. Wolburg H. CastnUunOberndorfer WL.
Hoensch H (19?") Kleinknotipe Leberzirrhose mit auspepriifter portaler Hyperten sion ais Folge einer Vitamm-A-Intoxikatton bei Psonasis-Behandlung. Dtsch Med Wochensctu 101.1637-16-0
Fome.-ke V\, Katosova LD. Pavlenko Cl (1976) Cytogenetic analysis of lymphocytes of the peripheral bicod from workers employed in the process of vinyl cblonde poiymeruanon. C.i| Tr Prof Zabol 20:46-50 (Russian text)
Fox AJ (1976) Vinyl ehloride and mortality ? Lancet II.41? Fox AJ. Collier PF (1976) Low mortality rates in industrial cohort studies due to
selection for work and survival in the industry. Br J Prev Soc Med 30:225-230 Fox AJ.Collier PF (1977) Mortality experience of workers exposed tovinytwhloride
monomer in the manufacture of polyvinyl chloride in Great Britain. Br J Ind Med 34:1-10 Frenttei-Beyme R. Schmitt T.Thiess AM (1978) MortaiitStsstudie bei VC-fPVCArbcitem der BASF AkticngcscUscbafr. Ludwtphafen am Rhein. Arbeitsmed Soaialmed Praeveno'med 13:218-228 Frey HE < 1973) Vinyl chloride and polyvinyl chloride resins. In: Chemical economics handbook. Sranford Research Institute (SRI). Menlo Park. California, pp 580.1881 A-580 1885 B Frongia N. Spinaxzota A. BuearcUi A {1974) Lesioni polmonari sperimeatali da inalatione prolungau di potven di PVC in ambients di lavoro. Med Lav 65:321-342 Funes-Crarioto F, Lambert B. Lindsten J. Ehrenberg L, Natarajan AT, OnermanGolkar S (1975) ChromoMrae aberrations in workers exposed to vinyl chloride. Lancet 1:459 Futh U. Pictzke HU (1974) Klmangioendotheliom der Leber naeh Thorecnst-Applikation vor 30 Jahien. ROEFO 121:398 -399 Gabor S. Radii M, Freda N. Abrudean S, Ivanof L, Anca Z. Valaczkay C (1964)
Aprecien asupra unor modificari hiochimice ia mur.ritorii din industria sinteteik si polimcritati chiorunide vinil. Igiena (Bucharest) 13:409--418
Gama C. Mem JBB (1978) Occupational scro-osteolysis. J Bone Joint Surf (Am) 60: 86-90
Carre AJ. GuttenpUn JB. MHvy P (1976) Vinyl ehloride dependent mutagenesis:
effects of liver extracts and free radicals. Murat Res 38:81 -88 Cay BW. Lonneman WA. Bridbord R. Moran JB (1975) Measurements of vinyl chlo
ride from aerosol sprays. Ann NY Acad Sd 246:286--295 Gedigfc F, MSUtr R. Bechatshciracr K (1975) Morphology of liver damage among poly
vinyl chloride production workers. A report of 5! eases. Ann NY Acad Sci 246: 278-285
Gedi|k P. MQUer R. Schattenbeig PJ. Totovif V (1977) Morphologic der LebenchSden bei cfarenischer Vinykhlorid-Intoxikation. In: Guaefcer HW. Lelbach WK (eds) LebeochSden dutch Vutyichiorid. Witzxtrock, Baden-Baden, Brfasei R6ln New York, pp 43-52
Gehring PJ. Waunabe PG. Park CN (1978) Resolution of doss response toxicity data for chemicals requiring metabolic activation: example - vinyl chloride. Toxicol Appt Pharmacol 44:581-591
Gehring Pi. Wannabe PG, Pack CN (1979) Risk of angiosarcoma in workers exposed to vinyl chloride as predicted from studies in rats. Toskoi Appi Fharaiacol 49: 15-21
Getrits WBJ.vaa Aken WG.van darMatrJ, Vnrtn J'(I974) Splenomegaly associated with chronic consumption coagulopathy. Acta Med Scaad 195:425-430
Gleesai Lf 1952) FamiUul and sporadic neurogenic acroasteotyris. Acts Radiol 38:!?29
C 33
|N_> ro <y>
,7
i
$ A
*
r
k
<* i V
6 W.JC Lelbach and H i Marstclkr
Gitsins CT ' |97li Acro-vHWulysis in PVC workers. Med Bull Stand Oil Co 31 -5o Ookel JM. Liebczeit E. Eder M ( 1976) Hcmangiosarcuma and hepatocellular carcinomj
of the liver following vinyl chloride exposure. Virchows Arch (Pathol Anati 372: 195-205 Good WO. Ellison C. Archer VE f 19751 Sputum cytology among frequent user* ot pressurized spray cans. Cancer Res 5516--1 Gordon DE. Thomas LB. Kent G. Calandra J. Bahu R. Popper H i 19`,4I Hepatic angio sarcoma in man and rodents following prolonged exposure to vinyl chloride. Gastro enterology 67:79-1
Grinms FW (1975) Guido Banti's hypothesis and its impact on the understanding aud treatment of portal hypertension. Mayo Gin Proc 50:41--47
Green T. Hath way DE (1975) The biological fare in rats of vinyl chloride in relation to its oncogenicity. Chem Biol Interact 1 ] .545-562
Green T. Hath way DE (1977) The chemistry and biogenesis of the S<ontaing metabo
lites of vinyl chloride in rats. Chem BioJ Invest 17:137-150 Green T. Hathaway DE (1978) Interactions of vinyl chloride with rat liver DNA in
vivo Chem Biol Interact 22:211-224 Greenberg BE. Street DM (1957) Idiopathic oon*familial acro-osteolysis. Radiology
69:259-262 Gretm H. Bonse G. Radwan Z, Reichert D. Henschkr D (197J) Mutagenicity in vitro
and potenual carcinofrnicity of chlorinated ethylencs as a function of sietcbohc oxirane formation. Biochem Pharmacol 24:2013--2017 Gretm H. Bonse G. Henschler D (1977) Mutagenitat von Vinyichlorid und anderrn chioriertcn Athyknen. In: Gutacker HW. Lei bach WK (eds) Leberscluden duich Vinyichlorid. Witzstrock, Baden-Baden Brussel K51n New York, pp 36-40 Griciute L (1979) The carcinogenicity of vinyl chloride. 1AR.C Sci Publ 22:3-11 Grigorescu l.TobaG (1966) Clorura di vinyl. Aspecte de toxicolofie industnale. Rev Chim (Bucharest) 17:499 Hahn E. Aderka D. Supmn H, Shumler B (1979) Occupational acroosteolysis in vinyl chloride workers in Israel. Isr J Med Sci 15:219-222 Haley TJ (1975) Vinyl chloride: how many unknown problems? J Toxicol Environ Health 1:47-73 Harms I (1954) Ober die famililre Akcoostcolyse. ROEFO 80:727-732 Hamasch H (1949/50) die Akroosteolysis. eui neues Krankheitsbiid. ROEFO 72: 352-359 Hams DK. Adams WGFI i 967) Acroosteolysis occurring in men engaged in the poly* merization of vinyl chloride. Br Med J 111:712-714 Heath CW. Falk H, Creech JL (1975) Characteristics of cases of angiosarcoma of the liver among vinyl chloride workers in the United States. Ann NY Acad Sci 246: 231-236 Hefner RE Jr, Watanabe PG, Gehring PJ (1975a) Preliminary studies of the fate of inhaled vinyl chloride monomer in rats. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:135-148 Hefner RE Jr. Wacanabc PG, Gehring PJ (1975b) Percutaneous absorption of vinyl chloride. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 34:529-532 Henschkr D (ed) (1972/73) Gceundheitsschidliche Arbeitssteffc, VerlagChemie, Weinheim Henschkr D (1977a) Meubolismus von Vfaylchiorid. In: Gutacker HW. Leibach WK (eds) LebenchSden durch Vinyichlorid. Witzscrock, Baden-Baden Brtiesel K61n
New York, pp 27-31 Henschkr D (1977b) Metabolism and mutagenicity of halogenated okfins - a com*
parison of structure and activity. Environ Health Petiptct 21:61--64 Henschkr D f 1977c) Mechanismcn dcr Aktivierung chtoHerter aliphatischer Verbin*
dungen - experimentelle Zugftnge und klinmchc Bedeutung. Arzneim Forsch 27: . 1827-1832
Vinyl Cljlonde-.*
Heusermann U. chlorid*Krani
Heusermacn U. smikturelie L Arch (Paiho:
Holmberg B. Kr mice. Acta V\
Hooper NK. Hjr 603
Hruban Z. Russc in livers of tw
Huberniar E. Bocells by two vi hyde IntJC..
Hublet PU975) Belg Med See
Hublet P, Lefivr. sarcome du To
vinyle monon: Huet PM, Guillat.
sinusoidal por; Gastroenterol Hussain S, Osterr vinyl chloride IARC( 1974) lot vinvl chloride Iber FL (1969) O CZ tension. Ann I Iber FL(J 970) V H NY Acad Sci 1
ro Imanaga H. Yam. ^ tension accori. --j Infante PF (197
nde producin' Infante PF. Wag-'
of-viny|<hlen Infante PF. Wj*.
of vinyl-chlonIrish DD (1963) <
Toxicology. V pp 241 rn Ito T, Nemoio M len" (fat-ston: Okajima Folia Ivanetich KM. A* hepatic micro-> 74:1411 -- 14J j Jacob PJ, Thiriui province of Qu Jeeger RJU975) action with 1.. Jaeger RJ. Reyminjury by vm\! 726 Jaeger RJ. Conolh ated hydrocart
j h and HJ MarsteNer
.1 OU Co 3 i 49-56 'locellular carcinoma 1 Pathol Anat) 372.
:.-vquent users cl
:9"'4> Hepatic arpo oyl chloride. Gastro*
understanding and
chloride in relation to
c S-vonumf metabo-
: -at liver DNA in
olysii. Radiology
lutagenicity in vitro fction of metabolic
rid und anderen beoctiader dutch
pp 36-40 i Publ 22.3 -1 ' -<ut industnale. Rev
-osteolysta tn vinyl
i Toxicol 1* iviron
7J2 id. ROEFO '2:
-npflril in `he poly-
tgsosarcoma of the <Y Acad Set 246:
of the fate of 35-146 "sorption of vinyl
. Vertag Cbemie.
r HW, Ulbech WK Jen Bribed K61n
d olefine-acorn61-64 -iftkariseber Verhin\rzactm Fonch 27:
Vinyl Chloride-Associated Discxx
9"
Hcuscrmann U. Siutte HJ i l977ji 2ur Atioiope der Thromborytopemc bei dcr Vinyl*
chlond*KranUieii. Blut 35 J17-322
Heuwmiann U. Stutte HJ t l977bi Enzymhuiochetm>che. histoinemsche und ultra-
strukturelle Untemtchungcn von Milzen bej der
ichlond-Hrankheit. Vjr.-s-.owj
Arch i Pathol Anaf 375 :303-31 "
Holm berg B. Kronevi T. Wined M 119Top The pathology ot vinyl chloride e\po.ed mice. Acta Vet scand 17:238--342
Hooper NK. Hams RH. Ames BN i 1979) Chemical carcinogenesis. Science 203:602 605
Hruban Z. Russell RM. Boyer JL. Glagov 5, Bagheri SA (i97-- Uitrastructurul chances
in livers of two patients with hypervjuauaosis A. Am J Parhol 76:451 -462
Hubemun E, Baruch H, Sachs Lt1975) Mutation taducuon in Chinese hamster V79
cells by two vinyl chionde metabolites, chloroethylene ox>de and 2<hloroacctaMehyde. Int J Cancer 16:639--64U
Hublet P (1975) Expose des nuisances industrieiles dues au chlorure de vinyie. Arch Beig Med Soc 33:75--89
Hublet P. Leftvre MJ. Decuyper L. Hanin C. Hamels J. Ficvex M (1977) Un cas d'anpo-
sarcome du foie chez un rravailleur ayant (d loafuetnent expose au chlorure de
vinyie monomite. Arch Beig M6d Soc 35:601-622
Huct PM, Guillaume E.Cote J. Legare A. Lavoie P. Vullet A i 1975) Noacirrhotic pre-
sinusoidal portal hypertension associated with chronic ancnicai intoxication. Gastroenterology 68:1270-1277
Hussain S. Oirerman-Golkar S (1976) Comment on the mutagenic effectiveness of vinyl chloride metabolites Chem Biol Interact 12:265-267
IARC (1974) Internal Technical Report no. 74/005. Report of a working (roup on
vinyl chioride.'Lyon 24-25 June t9?4, pp 1-55
Iber FL (1969) Obliterative portal venopathy of the liver and idiopathic portal hyper* tension. Ann Intent Med 71:660-661
Iber FL (1970) Portal hypertension in the pretence of normal liver morphology. Ann
NY AcadSci 170:115-126
Imanaga H. Yamamoto S. Kuroyanagi Y (1962) Surgical treatment of portal hyper-
tension according tosute of intrahepatic circulation. Ann Surg 155:42-50
Infante PF (1976) Oncogenic and mutagenic risks la communities with polyvinyl chlo>
nde production facilities. Ann NY Acad Sd 271:49-57
Infante PF, Wagoner JK. McMichml AJ.Wtxweiler RJ. Falk H( 1976a) Genetic risks
of vinyl-chloride. Lancet 1:734-735
Infante PF, Wagoner JK, McMichael AJ.Waxwetler RJ. Falk H U976b) Genetic risks
ofvinyh&loride. Letter to the editor. Lancet 1:1209-1290
Irish DD < 1963) Halogenated hydrocarbons: 1. Aliphatic. In: Fasset DW, Irish OD (eds)
Toxicology. Wfley.New York London (Industrial hygiene and toxicology. vol II. pp 241 ff)
Ito T. Ncmoce M (1952) Die Kupffenchen Stsmieilen und die "Fempetcheningizel-
lenM (fat-storing cells) in der BlutkapUUtenwand in der oenschlichen Leber. Okajima Folia Anat Jpn 24:243-258
tvanerich KM. Aronson 1. Katz ID (1977) The bstenctioa of vinyl chloride with rat
hepatic microsomal cytochrome p-4S0 in vitro. Blocfcca Biophys Res Commun 74:1411-1418
Jacob PJ, TMriault GP (1975) Distribution of primary cancan of the liver in the province of Quebec. Can Med Amoc J 112:305-307
Jaeger RJ (1975) Vinyl chloride monomer comments on its hepatotoxsdty and in(er
ection with 1.1. dkhloroethylane. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:150-151
Jaeger RJ. Reynolds ES. Coooly RB. Morten MT. Murphy SD (1974) Acute hepatic
injury by vinyl chloride in mo pestreated with phanobevbitaL Nature 252:724-
726 Jaeger RJ.Conoily B.B, Morphy SD (1975) Short-term inhalation toxicity of halogen-
tied hydrocarbons. Arch Environ Health 30:26-31
_
-*
j*. 03
98 W.K. Letbach and H.J Marsteller
Jaeger RJ . Murphy SD. Reynolds ES. Szabo S. Moslen MT (1977) Chemical modifica tion of acute hepatotoxiciry of vinyl chlonde monomer in rats. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 41 ;597 -607
Jayson MIV. Lloyd-Jones K,Berry DC, Bromige M 11976a) Resorption of the mjndible in vinyl chloride acroosteolyns. Arthntis Rheum 19:97 1
Jas son MIV, Bailey AJ, Black C, Jones KL (1976b) Collagen studies in acroosieolysis. Proc R Soc Med 69:295-297
Johnson MN, Creech JL Jr (1974) Angiosarcoma of liver in the manufacture of pol- vinyl chlonde. J Occup Med 16:150-151
Juhe S. Lange CE (197') Sklerodermieanige Hautvemnderungcn. Rjynaud-Syndrom und Akroosteolysen bei Arbeitem der PVC-henteilenden Industrie. Dtsch Med Wochenschr 07:1922-1923
Juhe S, Vellman G (1972) Zur Klinik der sogenannten Vinylchloridkrankheit. (Sklcrodermie-ihnliche Veranderungen bei Arbeitem der PVC4tenteilenden Industrie.) I. Internationales Symposium der Werksarzte der chcmischen Industrie. Ludwigshafen. 27.-29 4.1972. pp 267-276
Jflhe S, Lange CE. Stein G. Veltman G (1973) Ober die segenannte VjnylchloridKrankheit. Dtsch Med Wochenschr 98 2334-2037
JQhe S, Lange CE. Stein G. Veltman G (19',4) Ober die sogenannte VinylchlondKrankheit. Berufsdermatosen 22:4-22
Kappus H. Bolt HM. Buchter A. Bolt W (1975) Rat liver microsomes catalyse covalent binding of 1 *C-viny)chlonde to maeromolecules. Nature 257:134-- 135
Kappus H. Bolt HM. Buchter A. Bolt W (1976) Liver microsomal uptake of *`C vmvl chloride and transformation to protein alkylating metabolites in vitro. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 37:461--*7]
Karstadt M (1976) PVC: Health implications and production trends. Environ Health Perspect 17:107-115
Keplinger ML, Goode JW Gordon DE. Calardra JC (1975) Interim results of exposure of rats, hamsters, and mice to vinyl chlonde. Ann NY Acad Sci 2-16:219-220
Kettner H f 197$) Umweltschutz in der Sowjetunion. III. Maximale Arbeitsplatz-Kontentmionen (MAK-Wene) von Schadstcffen und ihre Nonnierung. In: Bench te des Osteuropa-lnstituts. Heft 108. Freie UnivcnitSt. Berlin
Kistler HJ. PIQer 5, Dickenmann W, Pirozynski W (1977) Poitale Hypertonie ohne Lebeninhose bei chronischer Vitamin-A-lntcxikation Schweiz Med Rochenschr 107:825-832
Kluge T. SommerschOd H. Flatmartt A (1970) Sinusoidal portal hypertension. Surgery
68:294-300 KnoUe J, Fflmer E, Rocssner A, Themann H, HOhn P. Meyer zum Btbchenfelde KH
(1974) Die nkhsirrhotische portale Fibrose (hepatoportale Sklerose) nach chronischer Anenvcrfiftung. Dtsch Med Wochcnschr 99:903--908 Koischwitz D. Marsteller HJ, Lackner K. Brecht G. Brecht T (19801 VerSnderungen der Hand- und Fingerartehcn bei der Vinylchloridknnkheit. ROEFO 132:62-68
Konetzke G.Bittersohl G.Grund W, Schramm T.Teichmann B.Zschunke E (1978) Ober die Bedeutung des Vinyichlorids als Schadstoff aus der Sicht der Arbeitsme-
dizin, experimentellen Onkologie und Industrictoxikoloiie. Z ges Hyg 24:501-507 Komblum K (1929) Bone changes in Raynaud's disease. Am J Roentgenol 21:448-
452 KovaS A. Kurajica L. Jurid-Rulic D, Pared B (1969) Aeropathia cxtremitatum in poly-
mcnzatione visyl<hloiidi - nova profesiooalna botest. LjjefVjcsn 91:5-17 Kramer CG, Mutchler JE (1972) The correlation of clinical and environmental mea
surements for workers expoeed to vinyl chloride. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 33:19-30 Kubota J (1957) Occupational diseases in synthetic resin and fibre industries.
(Japanese text). J Sci Labour 33:1 -22 Kurokawa S, Inagaki T, Okuyama S (1977) Elrctron microscopic observation of the
liver in portal hypertension following chronic exposure to vinyl chloride monomer. Gastroenterol Jpn lJ:64-69
Vinyl Chlo
Kuzmack A posure l
Laib RJ. B> and in v
Laib RJ. B vmvl ch:
Laib RJ. S> parative Congres*
Laib RJ. Si parative 463
Laib RJ, St-
compare zyme de:
Lander JJ. b the liver
Langauer-L.
aemia in . Health
Lange CE.\ Gutacker Baden-B..
Lange CE. J--
heit - er
Lange CE. K'
C Leber bo.,
jo i--
99:15S .
Lange CE
ro product!-.
ro 4*.
. Lange CE. b
<J Veltma-,
heit bei "
sche u*vi tisch E. * 16. Jahrv
Lange CE. b worker- >
Paris Lr>t Laroche (
neuro-ei.
Lassiter DY 176-17:
LawjJW.l:
tis and m Laws JW.F'
digital an LeeFI.Hai
1:1316-
Lee FI.Har: chloride
Lefaux R (1
Lefevre .MJ Interned 27.-29 a
ind H J. Marsteller
hemicai modifies* jaicol Appl
n of rhe mandible
in scroosteoi> s,v
-it'Acmre ot poiy.
jymaud-Syndrom ~-e. Dtsch Med
kraakheit. (Sklerolen Industrie.j lusine. Ludwigs-
VinylcWorid-
Vinyichlond*
catalvse covalent -135 -take of l*C vir.yl vitro Toxicol
Fnvuon Health
--ilts of exposure * u, 219-22'
\rt>eitsplai-'-Konin: Benchte des
.wrtonie ohne J Wochenschr
- -ransioa. Surgery
-i Wcfcenfeldr KH - Mtjnacb chroni-
Veriadeningen i:FO 132:62-68
hunk* E(1978) it dor Arbeitsine'Hyj 24:501-507 nt^nol 21:448-
Tvwitarura in poly* 91:5-17 ironwental boo* toecJ 33:19--50
tveervatioo of the ihloride monomer.
''invl Chloride-Arsociated D>,easc
99
Kuzmack AM. McGaughy RE 119 -5) Quanuuuve risk assessment for community ex
posure to rinyl chionde. U-S- EPA.ORD Report. December 1975
Laib RJ. Bolt HM (1977) Alkylation of RNA by vinyl chloride metabolites in vitro
and in vivo: formation of I-N`f-erheno-adenosine. Toxicology 8:155-195
Laib RJ. Bolt HM l l?"S) Formation of 3.N**etheno-cytidine moieties in RNA by
vmy| chionde metabolites in vitro and m vivo. Arch Toxicol ?U:255
Laib RJ. Siock.8 C>. Boit HM \ 5* Induction ot premalignant hepatic lesions com
parative effects of vin>! chionde and trichloroethylene. Paper presented at the 20th
Congress of European Society of Toxicology. Berlin
June 25--23'. 19"8
Laib RJ. Stoekle C. Bolt HM (1979) Induction of premalignant hepatic lesions' com
parative effects of vinyl chloride and trichloroethylene. Arch Toxicol (Suppl) 2-
463
Laib RJ, Stfickle G, Bolt HM. Kunz W (1979) Vinyl chloride and trichloroethylene-
comparison of alkylating effects of metabolites and induction of preneoplastic en
zyme deficiencies in rat liver. Cancer Res Clin Oncol 94:139-147
Lander JJ. Stanley RJ. Summer HW. Boswell DC. Aaeh RD f 1975) Angiosarcoma of
the liver associated with Fowler's solution. Gastroenterology 68:1582-1586
LariBuer-Lewowiclta H. Dudziak Z. Byczkowaky Z. Marks J (1976) Cryoglobulin*
acraia in Raynaud's phenomenon due to vinyl chionde. Int Arch Occup Environ
Heaitn 36:197-207
Lange Cii, Veltman G (1977) Dermatologbche Aspekte der VinylchloridsehSden. la:
Gutacker HW. Letbach WK (eds) Lebeischdden durch Vinyichlorid. Witastrock.
Baden*Baden Brussel K61n New York, pp 55-68
Lange CE, Juhe S. Stein G, Veltman G {1974a) Die sogenannte Vinylchlorid-Krank-
heit - eine berufsbedingte Systemsklerose? Int Arch Arbeitsmed 32:1-32
Lange CE. Juhe S. Veltman G (1974b) tJber das Auftreten von Angiosarkomen der
Leber bei zwei Arbeitem der PVC-herstellenden Industrie. Dtsch Med Wochenschr
99:1598-1599
*
Lange CE, Juhe S. Stein G. Veltman G (1973) Further results in polyvinyl chloride
production workers. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:18--21
Lange CE, Bloch H. Biersack HJ. Sehrt U. Etzel F, Manteller HJ, Lelbach WK.
Veltm m G (1976a) Chronisch-toxisch* Schiden im Sinnc der Vinylchlond*f(rank*
bett bti Arbeitem in PVC-weiterverarbcitenden Bctricben. Kiinjsche, Uborchemi*
sche und szintignphische (JncemichUngsbefunde. In: Bolt W, Bochter A. Rebcn*
each E. Worth D feds) Jabresbcricbt der Deuachen GeseUschaft fOr Arbeiomedizin.
16. Jahmtaguag. JCdln 5.-8 J -1976. Centner. Stuttprt. pp 195-200
Lange CE. Bloch H. Veltman G, Don M f 1976b) Urinary porphyrine among PVC-
worfcers. In: Dos M fed) Porphyrins in human diseases. Larger. Basel Munchen
Paris London New York Sidney, pp 352-355
Laroche G.Kochfeld M (1948) Un cm d'ecroostfotyse associda an syndrome ostlo*
neuro-endocrinieo coaplexe. Sem H6p Paris 24:984-991
Lasiter DV (1976) Vinyl ehloridc -- best available technology. Ann NY Acad Sci 27]:
176-178
Laws JW. Lillie JG, Scott JT (1963) Arteriographic appearances in rheumatoid arthri
tis and ocher disorders. Br J Radiol 36:477^93
Laws JW, El Sallab RA, Scoct JT (1967) An arteriographic and histological study of
digital arteries. Br J Radiol 40:740-747
Lae FI. Harry DS (1974) Angiosarcoma of the liver in a vinyl chloride worker. Lancet
1:1316-1318
Lee Ft. Harry DS. Adame WGF. UtchQeid M (1977) Screening for liver disease in vinyl
chloride workers. Br J lad Med 34:142-147
Latex R (1966) Chanda und Tokfltotogis derKamatofle. Krauakopf, Mainz
Leldm MJ (1972) AJtfoaeteoiym in Zusammonbang mit der PVC*HciraUuag. In:
lammarionelns Symporion der Weriudrste der Chemischen Industrie. Ludwigshsfen
27.-29.4.1972, pp 69-79
U R L 12250
i } | t "
v-I. I
100 W.K. Lelbach and HJ. Marsrcllor
Lelbj.1i WK. Mars teller HJ < 19^7) Das laparoskopischc Bild der Vinslchlorid-Kranklien. In: Lindner H fed) Fortsehriue dcr gastroenterolugischen Endoskopic. vul S Witzstroek. Baden-Baden BriisscI, pp 37-40
Lesicr D. Greenberg LA. Adams WR <1963) Effects of single and repeated exposure of humans and rats to vinyl chloride. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 24:365-275
Liebegott G 11949) Pathologische Anatoime der chromschen Arsenverginung. Dteu Med Wochenschr 74:855-856
Liebegott G (1952) Ober die Beziehungen zwischen chromscher Arsenvergiitung unJ mahgnen Neubildungen. Zentralbl Arbeitsmed Arbeitsscl.utz Prophy! 2:15-16
van Lierop JBH. Stek W (1976) Analysis of vinyl chloride in food simulant' at low parts per billion levels by mass fragmentography. J Chromatogr 125:183-187
Lrtvre JA. Gama C, (1957) L'icroosteolyse. Bull Mem Soc Med H6p 73.109-120 Lilit R, Anderson H, Nicholson WJ, Daum S, Fishbein AS. Selikoff U (197$) Preval
ence of disease among vinyl chloride and polyvuiyi chloride workers. Ann NY Acad Sei 246:22-41 Lilis R. Anderson H. Miller A. Selikoff IJ f 1976) Pulmonary changes among vinyl chloride polymerization workers. Chest 69:299-303 Lilis R. Anderson H. Miller A. Selikoff IJ < 1977) Modification pulmonaires et exposi tion au chlorate et polychlomre de vinyle. Med Hyg 35:1542-1545 Lloyd JW (] 974) Angiosarcoma of the liver in vinyl chiondeipolyvinyl chlonde workers. J Oceup Med 16:809 Lloyd JW (197$) Angiosarcoma of the liver in vinyl chloride.'polyvinyl chloride workers. J Occup Med 17:333-334 Lopneno N. Birale R. Baroncelli S, Bauer C, Bronzetti G. Cammeliini A. Ccrcignani G. Corsi C. Gervasi G, Leporini C. Nteri R. Rossi AM, Stretti G. Turchi G (1976) Eval uation of the genetic effects induced by vinyl chloride monomer (VCM) under mammalian metabolic activation: studies in vitro and in vivo. Mutat Res 40:85-96 Lopneno N, Baraie R. Baroncelli S. Baruch H. Bronzetti G. Cammeliini A. Corsi C. Freza D, Nieri R. Leporini C. Rosellini D. Rossi AM (1977) Induction of gene mu tations and gene conversions by vinyl chloride metabolites in yeast. Cancer Res 36.253-257 MacSween RNM. Vetters JM. Ross SL. Ferguson J. Johnstone JM. Sandison AT (1973) Haemangio-endothclial sarcoma of the liver. J Pathol 109:39-44 MAK-Werte (1975) Umweltschua in der Sowjetunion. 1U. Maximale ArbeitsplatzKonzentrationen (MAK-Werte) von Schadstoffen und ihre Normierung. In: Berichte des Osteuropednstituts. Heft 108. Fteie Univenitat. Berlin, p 67 Makk L. Creech JL. Whelan JG Jr. Johnson MNU974) Liver damage and angiosarco ma in vinyl chloride workers. JAMA 230:64--68 Makk L. Delorme F, Creech JL f 1975) Angiosarcomes du foie chez des ouvriers ayant 6te en contact prolong^ avec k chlorate de vinyk: epidemiologic et programme de recherches chez les ouvriers. Union Med Can 104:1833-1835 Makk L, Delorme F. Creech JL Jr. Ogden II LL, Fadell EH. Songster CL. Clanton J. Johnson MN.Christoffenon WM (1976) Clinical and morphologic features of hepatic angiosarcoma in vinyl chloride workers. Cancer 37:149-163 MalaveiUeC. Bartsch H, Barbin A, Camus AM. Montesano R. Croisy A, Jacquignon P (1975) Mutagenicity of vinyl chloride, chloroethykncoMde. chloroacctaldehyde and cfcloroeihanol. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 63:363-370 Maiten RE. Ziethuis RL (1964) Industrial toxicology and dermatology in the produc tion and processing of plastics. Elsevier. Amsterdam London New York MaitoniC(]973) Occupational carcinogenesis. Exceipta Medics Int Congr Ser 322: 19-36 Maltoni C(l974) Angiosarcoma epatico in operai esposti a doraro di vinile. Resoconto dei primi due casi riscontrati in Italia. Med Lav 65:445-450 Maltoni C(1975) The value of predictive experimental environmental carcinogenesis. Ambio 4.J8-23
L *".. J'l
URL 12251
II,J Manteiler
i'inO-Kfankvol 8.
J exposure of
'unp. Dtsch
'pining und 1 15-to i. ji low :S3-1ST 09-: :o i Preval\nn NV Acid
ong vinyl
res et exposi*
hionde
r.londe
' . Ccrc5?"ini O. i 19^61 Eval*
'll under tl.-s -0: Si -6 A, Coni <~. -r ,'f sene mu jr.ver Res
* n ATilT3i
Heitsplauij. In: Benchte
I anfiowrvo*
ouvriers ayunt I*nip3mnir de
\. Clanton J. itutes of
Jacquignon P -cetaldctiyde
n the produo* rk n*rSer322:
.nite. Reso*
smnogenens.
Vinyl Chloride-Associated Disease
101
Maltoni C i ] 976) Occupations! chemical carcinogenesis: new tacts, priorities. and perspectives. LARC Sei PuM S-: 1-7 --
Maltoni C < 19^7) Recent findinp on the carcinoenicir>- of chlorinated olefins.
Environ Health Perspect 21:1-5 Maltoni C. Lefemine G i 1974a) Carcinogenicity bioassayt ot *myl chlonde. 1. Research
plan ano early results. Environ Res 7 ;3S --405 Maltoni C. Lefemine G < 1974b) La potenaialita deisaggi spcnmcntali nella prediiionc
dei rischi oncogen) ambientali. Un esempio il! cloruro di vimle. Academia Naaionale Jei Lince:. Estratto dai Rendiconti della Gasse di Scienze iche. matematictie e naturaii. $er VIII. vol LVt. fas 3 Maltoni C, Lefemine G (1975) Carcmocenicity bioamys of vinyl chlonde: current results. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:195-218 Maltoni C. Crespt M, Burch PJ feds) f 1973) II. International Symposium on Cancer Detection and Prevention. Excerpta Medica Int CongrSer 275:1-137 Maltoni C. Lefemine G, Chieco P.Carretti D (1974a) La canceroftnes arebientale e professionale: Nuove prospective alia luce della canceregenesi da donsro di vinile. Osp Vita 1:66 Maltoiu C. Lefemine G. Chieco P. Carretti D( 1974b) Vinyl chlonde carcinogenesis: current results and perspectives. Med Lav 65:421-444
Maltoni G.Cilibcrti A. Gianni L. Chieco P(1975) Insorienaa di aagiosarcorai in ratti. in seguito a somministrazione per via oraie di cloruro di vinile. Osp Vita 2:65 --66
Maricq HR. Johnson MN. Whetstone CL.LeRoy EC (1976) Capillary abnormalities in polyvinylchloride production workers. JAMA 236:1368-1371
Maneq HR. Darke CS. Archibald R McL. LeRoy EC f 1978) In vivo observations of skin capillaries in workers exposed to vinyl chloride. An Eaglish*Amencan compari son. BrJ Ind Med 35:1 -7
Marin A. Strauss J. Michels R. Benoit JP. Baitie R. Pierre C (1967) Acro-osteolyse d'originc profesaionneile. Rev Rhum Mai Ostdoartic 34:340--351
Markowiu SS. McDonald CH. Fethicre W, Kernter MS (1972) Occupational aero* osteolysis. Arch Dermatol 106:219--223
Marleau D. ViUeneuv* JP, Huet PM. Coc J. Lafortune M. Ltgarf A. Lavoie P. Visilec A
(1974) Nondrrhobc idiopathic portal hypertension (OPH): RadioloficaJ and hemo
dynamic evaluation of 4 cases by combined hepatic and umbilicoponal catheteriza tion. Gastroenterology 67:813 Maxsteller KJ, Leibach WK (1977) Du ianremedialnische Bild bei Viaylchioridschiden. la: Gumcktr HW. Laibach WK (e^s) Leberechiden dutch Vinykhlorid Vinykhlorid-Kmnkheit. Witzstrodt, BadenBad*n Brtoel K6ln New York, pp 69-
83 Manteiler HJ, Leibach WK. MOUtr R. JQhe S. Lange CE. Rohner HG. VeitreanGU973)
ChronisdMoxtodu Lebencttden bei Acbeiwm in dcr PVC-Produkaon. Dtsch Med
Wochanschr 98:2311 -2314 Manteiler HJ. Leibach WK. Muller R.Gedigk P( 1975a) Unusual sptenoaegalic liver
disease as evidenced by peritoneoscopy and guided liver biopsy among polyvinyl chloride production workers. Ann NY Acad Sd 246:95--134 Manteiler HJ, Leibach WK. MOiler R.Gedigk P, Lange CE (1975) KUniscbe undlaparoekopieche Aspekte dcr Lebetschldea bei Chemiearbeitcrn in dcr Vjnylchiofid4Pol> -
Mikttioo. Leber Magen Darn 5:196--202 Manteiler Hi. Lclbacfa WK. Lange CE. Veltman G f 1976) Chrontsch*toscbc Schiden
in tent dcr Vinykhlorid*Kankheit bei Arbcitern in PVC-wciterrerafbcitcndcn Betrieben. In: Bolt *, Buchter A. Rebendsch, E, Worth D (eds) Vethandlunfin der Deatsehen GeseUachaft (Or ArheitemertlTln. 16. Jahrasragung. Genaer. Stuttgart,
pp 201-207 Martin JF. Wagoner )G. Beck PD (1974) Persistence of vinyl chloride (VO induced
Irver injury after cusadon of expoeuit. Giitroenteroloty 67:814
X> tv? ro cn ro
D
IV
i. By-
% r;
1 i. r
Sfcr t / T'
i-i
f'
a .
I I
102 W.K. Lelbach and H.J. Marstoller
MaStromatteoE. Fisher AM. Christie H. Danziger H (I960) Acute inhalation toNu:t\ of vinyl chloride to laboratory animals. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 5:394-39$
Maugh TH II (1978) Chemical carcinogens: ho* dangerous are low- do*es? Science 202:37-41
McCann J. Simmon V, Sireitwieser 0. Ames BN (1975) Mutagenicity of chluroacev aldehyde, a possible metabolic product of 1.2slidiloro<thane <ei!i> lene Jicliioride i. chloroethanol (ethylene chlorohydnn). vinyl chloride, and cyclophosphamide Pn>c Natl Acad Sci 72:3190-3193
McMichael AJ. Haynes SO. Tyroler HA (1975) Observation on the .. jliuiion of occu pational mortality data. J Occup Med 17:128-131
Mendenhall CL, Sherman J. Chedid A (1974) Intermittent idiopathic portal hyperten sion. Gastroenterology 67:147--148
Meyerson LB. Meier GC( 1972) Cutaneous lesions in acroosteoiysts. Arch Dermatol 106:224-227
Mikkelsen WP. Edmondson HA. Peters RL. Redeker AG, Reynolds TB (1965) Extraand intrahepatic portal hypertension without cirrhosis fhepatoportal sclerosis) Ann Surg 162:602-620
Miller A (1975) Pulmonary function defects in nonsmoking vinyl chloride workers. Environ Health Penpect 11:247--256
Miller A.Teintein AS.Chuang M. Selikoff U.Warshaw R < 1975) Changes in pulmo nary function in workers exposed to vinyl chloride and polyvinvi chloride. Ann NY
Acad Sci 246:42-52 Miller MC. Brandt JL (1962) Portal hypertension in the absence of both liver disease
and vascular obstruction. Am J Dig Dis 7:442-448 Mitchell Johnston EN (1978) Vinyl chloride disease. Br J Dermatol (Suppl 16)99:45-48 Monahan JJ (1926) Raynaud's disease; limitations of classical picture as a guide to
diagnosis; report of a case showing extensive bone involvement. Am J Med Sci 171:346-358 Monson RR. Peters JM. Johnson MN (1974) Proportional mortality among viny(chlo
ride workers. Lancet 11:397-398 Moms JS. Schmid M. Newman S.Scheuer PJ. Sherlock S (1974) Arsenic and non-
cirrhotic portal hypertension. Gastroenterology 66:86-94 Moser KM (1976) Meat wrapper s asthma. JAMA 236:2846-2847
Moulin O. Rety J. Patliard P. Vouiilon G.Guttin G < 1974) Aspects sclerodermiques de I'acro-ostcolyse professionneUc. Ann Dermatol Syphiiigr 101:33-44
Miiller G. Notpoth 1C (1975) Bestimmung zweier Urinmetabolite des Vinylchlonds Naturwissenschaften 62:541
Muller G. Notpoth K. Eckatd R (1976) Identification of two urine metabolites of vinyl chloride by GC-MS-investigations, Int Arch Occup Environ Health 38:69-75
Muller G. Norpoth K.Ktmcn E.Herweg K. Vcrsin EH978) Deiermination of thiodiglycolic add in urine spedmens of vinyl chloride exposed workers. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 41:199-205
Muller R. Gedigk P. Bechtclsheimcr H (1974) Neuere morphoiogische Befunde in der menschlichen Leber nach Vinykhlorid-Exposirion. In: Lehnert G. Szadkowski D, Weber HJ (eds) 14. Jahresbericht der Deutschen Geaellschaft fUr Arbeitsmedizin. 17.-19.10.1974. Hamburg. Centner. Stuttgart. pp 267-269
MBIler R. Bechtclsheimer H. Gedifk P. Mameller HJ, Lclbach WK (1975) Das morphelogische BBd der Leberschldigung nach chroniseher Vinylchlorid-Exposition. Leber
Mafen Darm 5:204-208 MBIler W. Baida BB(1975) Polyvinylchlorid-Kiankheit unterdem Bild einer Akro-
sUerodermic. Hautaixt 26:387 Muenter MD, Perry HO, Ludwig J (1971) Chronic vitamin A intoxication in adults.
Am J Med 50:129-136 Myers SA. Quinn HJ. Zook WC (1975) Determination of vinyl chloride monomer at
the sub ppm level using a personal monitor. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 36:332 -337
c:
3D ro ro vs co
Vm> l C'
Neale hypi
Neumu and bert
Nichob chlv
Niche*!'
COtv
230 Nona D
exp<PathNorpott uber latio Arbe Nothnac Hirs. Osier R' AneOsterm. Wach Chlo: Osterm. techr: Ott MC. trial Page M
wo. Pjnh M
b\ > Parmec
lavo:
Pattv ! edu
Patty T new
19b.Penin 1'
troe Bren Deu Sru People* Exp Pessayr and Pha: Peters. sepv. Pilliclv cost. Pimen: Ga>
: -Jv -..t
:d HJ Manteller
Uuon toxicitv 398 ? Science
I ciilorojceifcne dichlondei. -pl;araide Proc
uanon oi -xcu-
*.nal hyperren-
cn Dermatol
11965) Extra ct -sclerous) Ann
iJe workers.
ses in puJmo* : >ride. Ann NY
i liver disease
:.p| 16)90 45-JS .i guids to ' Met Set
ng vinylcti.**-
and non-
demiqut" .1c
-ylcblorids
.tftei of vinyl *9--75 moo of thiOvli :t Afch Occup
funde in der -Jkowski D. usmedinn.
' Dm morpho*aettion. Leber
m*r AAro-
n in adults.
eioiner at
Vinyl Chionde-Auoeiated Disease
103
Neale G. Azsopardi JG (1971) Chrome arsenical poisoning and non-virthouc portal hypertension - a ease for diagnosis. Br Med J 11:725-730
Neumann HG. Osborne JC. Metals M < 1979) Peroxidase activity in fat Zymbal's gland and its possible role for the metabolic activation of carcinogens. Naunyn Schm:cdebergs Arch Pharmacol (Suppl) 307: R l J
Nicholson W J a 977) Cancer following occupational exposure to asbestos and vinyl chlonde Cancer 39 |"92 --1801
Nicholson wj. Hammond EC. Seidman H.Selikoff [j (I97f > Mortality experience o; a cohort of nnvl chloride - polyvinyl chloride workers. Ann NY Acad Sc; 246.225 230
Nona DF. Ritchie S, Silver MD (1977") Angiosarcoma of the liver after vinyl chloride exposure: report of a case and review of the literature. International Academy oi
Pathology ,66th Annual Meeting. Toronto. Abstracts of Papers 36.361 Norpoth K. Muller G, Witting U. Gottschalk D.Gomchaik J (1976) Uncersuchungen
fiber den Stoffwechsei des Vinylchiorids und fiber Wirkuogen der Vinylchloridinhaiation auf Regulationsmechanismen des Lebemoffwcchsels. Verh Dtseh Ges Arbeitsmed 16:187
Nothnagei H. Rossbach Ml (1880) Handbueh der ArzneimitteUehre. 4. Auflagt. Hinchwald. Berlin
Oster RR. Carr CJ.Krantt JC 11947) Anesthesia XXVU. Narcosis with vinyl chloride. Anesthesiology 8:359-361
Ostertnan-Goikar S. Hultmtrk D. Segerback D. Calleman CJ. Cflthe R. Ehrenberg L. Wachtmeistcr CA (1977) Alkylation of DNA and proteins in mice exposed to vinyl chloride. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 76:259-266
Ostcrmaycr H (1967) Vmykhlorid. in: Foent W(ed) UUmanns Eacyklopfidie der technischen Chemie. vol 16. Urban & Schwvzcnberg. MBnchen. pp 87-94
Ott MG. Langner RR. Holder B8( 1975) Vinyl chloride exposure in a controlled indus trial environment. Arch Environ Health 30:333-339
Pag* M. Thiriault L. Delorme F (1976) Elevated CEA levels in polyvinyl chloride worken. Biomedecine 1976:279
Panh Meng H. Faurt H. Pasquier D. Coudere P (1977) Liver angiosarcoma occasioned
by exposition to vinyl chloride. Acta Pharmacol Toxicol OCbhHSuppi) 41:331 Parmeggiani L, Sass C (1955) Rischi e patologia professionale Mila produzione e nella
lavorazione di alcune materie piastiehe. Med Lav 46:14--24 Patty FA fed)(l9S8) Industrial hygiene and toxicology, voi l: General principles. 2nd
edn. lamnctence Publishers. New York Patty FA. Yant Wp, Waite CP (1930) Acute response of fuinee pigs to vapors of some
new commercial organic compounds. V. Vinyl chloride. Public Health Rep 45. 1963-1971
Penin H. Sargar G. Lange CE. Veltmtn G (1973) NeurologBch^sychiatrische und elektraenzephalofraphisehe Befunde bei Fatten ten nit Vmyfchlorid-Krankheit. In: Brenner w. Rohmen W. Rutenfranz J (eds) Bericht fiber die IS. lahrestagung der Deutscben GenlUchaft Hir Arbcitsracdizin. Mfiaehen 24.--26.4.1975. Gentner. Stuttgart, pp 299-304
Peoples AS. Leake CD (1933) The anesthetic action of vinyl chloride. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 48:284
Ptssayre P,WandnrheerJC. Descatorie V. Artigou JY.Bonhamou JP (1979) Formation and inactivation of a chemically reactive metabolite of vinyl chloride. Toxicol Appl
Pharmacol 49:5OS-SIS Peters JM f 1976) PuUk-Health rounds at tha Harvard School of Public Health Per*
epetives. N Engl J Med 294:653-657 PflUchowriti P, Faurc C. Aubert K.Pahn M. Latreflle R. Barrie J 11979) Angioaarcoree
costal Of i nns intoxication au chiorure de polyvinyl. Nouv Presse Med 8:2485 Pimentel Conn J. Menexes Peixoto A f1977) liver disease in vineyard sprayers.
Gastroenterology 72:275 -283
C 20 rNj r-j vn -u
r
104 W.K. Lelbach and HJ. Marstdler
Pivr WT (1976) Diffusion of residual monomer in polymer resins. Environ Health Perspeti 17.2:7-236
Polish E. Christie J. Cohen A, Sullivan B (1962) Idiopathic presmusoidal portal hyper tension f Band's syndrome), Ann Intern Meil 56:624--627
Polyvirn 1 chloride banned in Japan (1974) JAMA 229:855 Pepper H (1975) The heuristic importance ol environmental pathology Lessons irom
the vmyl chloride problem. Arch Pathol 99:69-71 Popper H. Thomas LB (1975) Alterations of liver and spleen among workers exposed
to vinyl chJcnde. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:172-193 Popper H, Udenfncnd S (1970) Hepatic fibrosis- Correlation of biochemii. J and mor
phologic investigations. Am J Med49:707-721 Popper H, Thomas LB. Falk H. Berk PD, Selikoff I (1974) Banti syndrome followed
by hepatic angiosarcoma in vmyl chiondc exposure. Paper presented at the Sixth Meeting of the International Association for the Study of the Liver. Acapulco. Mexico.Oct. 20-22, 1974
Popper H, Thomas LB, Telles NC, Falk H. Selikoff IJ (1978) Development of hepatic angiosarcoma in man induced by vinyl chloride, thorotrasi, and arsenic. Am J Pathol 92.349-370
Preston BJ, Jones KL, Grainger RC (1976) Clinical aspects of vinyl chloride disease Proc R Soc Med 69:284-286
Prodan L.Suciu I. PtsJaru V. Ilea E.Pascu Lf 1975) Experimental acute toxicity of vinyl chloride (monochloroethene). Ann NY Acad Sci 246:154-163
Puech AM. Foumet A, Ltulhere L. Faurv J, Cau G, Maliion JM (1977) Etude des lesions hepatiques observes che2 5 sujets exposes au chlonire de vinyle dont 3 cas d'angiosarcome hepatique Arch Mai Prof 38-787-795
Purchase LFK. Williamson KS (1974) Proportional mortality among vinyl-chloride workers. Lancet 11:591 -592
Purchase LFH. Richardson CR, Anderson D f 1975) Chromosomal and dominant lethal effects of vinyl chloride. Lancet II :410-411
Purchase LFH. Richardson C. Anderson D (1976) Chromosomal effects in peripheral lymphocytes. Proc R Soc Med 69:290-292
Pushin GA 11965) On lesions of the liver and the biliary tract in workers engaged in the production of some types of plastics. Sov Med 28:132-135 (Russian text)
Radwan Z (1977) Uptake and rate of metabolism of vinyl chloride by the isolated per fused rat liver preparation. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 40:101 --110
Radwan Z.HenschkrD (1975) Uptake and metabolism of vinyl chloride in the Isolated perfused rat liver preparation. Naunyn Schratedebergs Arch Pharmacol (Suppi) 287:R]00
Ramaiingaswami V, Wig KL, SamaSK (1962) Cirrhosis of the liver in northern India a dinicopathological study. Arch Intern Med 110:350--358
Rannug U, Jnhanaon A. Ramel C. Wachtmeister CA (1974) The mutagenicity of vinyl chloride after metabolic activation. Arabio 3/5:194--197
Rannug U.GAthe R, Wachtmeister CA (1976) The mutagenicity of chlorocthykne oxide, chlotoacetaldehyde. 2<hloroethano4 and chloroacetic add. conceivable metabolites of vinyl chloride. Chem Biol Interact 12:251 -263
Ravenna P( 1940) Band syndrome (flbroconfestive splenomegaly). Definition, classi fication and pathogenesis. Arch Intern Med 66:879--892
Ravey M. Klopstock 1 (197S) Trace analysis of vinyl chloride hi PVC end in the atmo sphere. J Cbrorastogr Sd 13:552-553
Ravicr E, Diter JM. Pialat J (1975) Un cs d'angjosarcome hlpatiquc cbeg un ouvrier exposl audUonue de vinyle moowire. Arch Mai Prof 36:171-177
Regebon W, Kim U, Oepma J, Holland JF (1968) Hemangieendothclial sarcoma of liver from chronic anenic intoxication by Fowler's solution. Cancer 21:514-522
Reger RB (1977) Vinyl chloride and the polymers. J Occup Med 16:772-773
Vinyl Ch.
Regnauli
olbild^
Rein FR.
KolicV
Reinl W i
des L..
RefnI W.
Gewe:
Reinl W.
nd-Kr.
Reinl W.'
der Gi-
Reinl W. '
der Gt Rein] W. v,
der Ge
Reitr RH ing the
RetyJ.L:.
super
Arch M Rety J. Sj
tique .
Reynolds1
vinyl ci Reynold `
ation <
dase
<= JO
Reynold' : vinvl - t
18.30
ro r\j
Richards i
vi Nature
Roche J . tiens.
Roche J. I
- hepa!i< 2:669
ROSS JM Bacter.
Roth F (I
Berucl
Roth F i 1
468-<>
Roth F ( '
Dtsch `
Roth F (1 Pathoi
Roubal J Eneyci
Roussclot
with iu
euoioy
portal -
- Ibach and H.J. Muntcller
<inv Environ Health Per-
sinusoidal portal hypvr-
,'jrhology Lemons :rom
tmong workers exposed
biochemicii and rr.vr-
nti syndrome followed presented at the Sixth he Liver. Acapulco.
Development of hepatic . and arsenic. Am J
' vinyl chloride disease.
vntal acute toucitv of * 154-163 M (197?) Etude de* :rr de vinyle dont 3 cas
nong vinyl-c.Voride
maland dominant lethal
ul effects ..i peripheral
*n worker* .-nfaged in 133 fRus-^in texo rule by the isolated per40:101-110
.) chloride m the isolated Pharmacol (Suppll
liver in northern India -
Die mutagenicity of vinyl
ity of chlorecthyiene jc acid, conceivable 363 aiyJ. Definition. ciassi-
in PVC aad in the atao-
lutique cbez un ounicr 171-177 ndoffacbtl sarcoma of a. Cancer 21:514--522 4ed 16:772-773
Vmyj Chloride-Associated Disease
* 05
Regnault V i 1835; Cber die Zimmmensvtiung jw-<; Chloikohlenwassersiotfs <Oel des filbildenden Cases) Liebigs Ann Pharm |4:22-Jg
Rein FR. Hurh F (1 97$) Such* sponune primare malignc CefabgeschwuUte in einem Kollektiv von 30.000 Obdukuonen. Int Arch Arbcitmed 34 237-24*)
Re:ni W 119751 Erkrankungert durch Viny^hioruJ. Janresbenchl der Gewerbeauivcnt des Lando Sordrtiein-*Vesttalen. pp 29-5 16
Re:m \V. Weber H I 197*1 Erkrankungen durch X inylchlcrid. Jaitresber..;-.: dsr
Gewerbeaufsicht aes Landes Vordrhem-Wextfalen. ?? - l"--SRe:m W. Weber H i 19"o) Stand der epidemiolagisc^cn F^rclumg iiber die Vmyichlo-
nd-Krankheit. Zentralbl Arbaismed 26:97-104 Reinl W. Weber H. Creiser E (1976; Erkrankungen durch Vinylchlorid. Jahrtsbericht
der Gewerbeaufsicht des Landes Nordrhein-Westfalen, pp 287-295 Reinl W, Weber H. Creiser E f!977) Erkrankungen durch Vinylchlorid. Jahresbericht
der Gewerbeaufsicht des Landes Nortrhein-Wesu'alen. pp 305-324 Reinl W. Weber H.Gmiser E (1978) Eritnnkungen dutch Vinylchlorid. Jahresbencht
der Gewerbeaufsicht des Landes Nordrhem-WestfaJen. pp 347--3^7 Reiu RH. Quast JF. Wjtanabe PG. Gehring P] (1979) Chemical carcinogens: Estimat
ing the risk. Science 205:1206-1208 Rcty J, Lizard P. Berrod J. Schmitt M (1974) Infrared thermography in diagnosis and
supervision of morbidity in workers dealing with vinyl chloride polymerisation. Arch Mai Prof 35:733-738 Rety J.Seuvagc.TuaiUon. Kabrard A (1976) Le 3c cu frangais d'angiosarcome hSpa-
tique chex un ouvrier du chiorure dc vinyl*. Arch Mai Prof 37:551--555 Reynolds ES. Moslen MT. Szabo S. Jaeger RJ. Murphy SD (1975a) Hcpatotoxicity of
vinyl chloride and 1,1-dichlorocthylcne. Am J Pathol 8 1:219-236 Reynolds ES. Moslen MT, Szabo S. Jaeger RJ (1975b) Vinyl chioridennduced deactiv
ation of cytochrome 9*150 and other components of the liver mixed function oxi dase system: an in vivo study. Res. Comm Chcm Pathol Pharmacol 12:685-694 Reynolds ES, Moslen MT, Szabo S. Jaeger RJ (1976) Modulation of halothane and vinyl chloride induced acute injury to liver endoplastic reticulum. Panminerva Med 18:367-374
Richards RJ. Desai R. Hcxt PM. Rose FA (1975) Biological reactivity of PVC dust. Nature 256:664-665
Roche J (1977) Affections hepauques et chiorure dc vinyl*. A propos de 5 observa
tions. Revue general* de littfranite. Thtsc. University of Grenoble
Roche J. Foumet J, Hotteie J. Panh M. Bonnet-Eymard J (1978) Angiosarcome hipitique du es chiorure de vinyl*. Presentation de 4 cat. Gastroenterol Clin Biol 2:669-678
Rom JM (1932) A case illustrating the effect of prolonged action of radium. J Pathol
Becteriol 33:899-912 Roth F (1956) Cber die ehronischc Amnvtrgiftung der Moselwinzer mit besonderer
Berikksichtifuagdcs Anenkrebeea. Z KrebMotsch 61:287-319 Roth F (1957a) Arsen, Leber. Tumotea (KSmangioeitdocheliem). Z JCrebsforsch 61:
468-503 Roth F (1957b) Cber die Spltfolgen des chroobchcn Arsenismus der Moselwinzer.
Dticfa Med Wochcaschr 82:211-217 Roth F (1959) Zur Pathologie der duooischen Atlantargifrang. Zentralbl AUg Pathol
Pathol Arut 100:329-330 Ronbal J( 1972) VinyLpolyvtayi chloride. In: I.L^.dnternation Labor Organization)
Encyclopaedia of occupational health and safety, vol Q. Geneve, pp 1467-1468 Ruumelot LM (1940) The let* plum of congestive splenomegaly (Banti's syndrome)
with hemitemoris bot withont rinhmli of the Uver. Further observations on the etiology of Bend's syndrome and the effect on prognoms of certain variations in the portal venous pattern. Surgery 8:34-42
x z i-w n
cJ>
T i \
**
10b W.K. Lelhjch and H.J Marsteller
Rowe VK ( 1975) Experience in industrial exposure control. Ann NY Acad 5ci 246, 306-310
Rubsamen HU976) VinylchlondkrankhcittVC-Krankheit). Z. Allgeneinmcl 5; 1551-1555
Russell RM. Baghrri SA. Boyer JL {1973) The hepatic lesion of hyrcrvit3niino*ii \ a unique pattern of hepatic fibrosis with portal hypertension and jSwites. Gastro enterology 65:568
Russell RM. Boyer JL. Bagheri SA. Hruban Z (1974) Hepatic injury from chrome hypervitaminosis A resulting in portal hypertension and ascites N Engl J Med 291: 43S-4J0
Sakabe H (197 Si Bone lesions among polyvinyl chloride production workers in Japan. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:78-79
Santa SK. Bhargava S.Gopi Nath N.Talwar JR, Nayak NC. Tandon BN. Wig Kl11971) Noncirrhotic portal fibrosis. Am J Med 51:160-169
Sand M. KulCar Z. Zones M, Gelid I (1976) Malignant tumors of the liver and lungs in an area with a PVC industry. Environ Health Perspect 17:189-192
SchalTner F, Popper H, Selikoff 1J (1976) Initial features of vinyl chloride (VC) hepa tic injury. Gastroenterology 71:928
Schattenberg PJ. Totovic V, Gedigk P. MarsteUer HJ (1977) Die Uitrastruktur der Leberschadigung bet der chronischen Vjnylchlorid-Intoxikation. Virchows Archiv (Pathol Anat) 273:233-247
Schaununn O (1934) Qber die Herzwirkung einiger Inhaiationsnarkotika. Med Client {Leverkusen Ger) 2:139-147
Schaumann O (1938) Monochlorithylen. In: Lehmann KB. Fluty F (eds) Toxikolope
und Hygiene der technischen Ldsungsmittel. Springer. Berlin, pp 130-131 Schlatter C (1976) Geflhrdung von Konsument und PVC-Arbeirem dutch Vinyl-
ehlorid. Schweiz Med Wochenschr 106 647-650 Schmidt H. Schaumann O (1929) Uber kombinierte Gasnarkose. Dtsch l Chir 216:
149- 157
Schmid; K.Batora J (1976) Vorkotnmen des Leberhamangioendothelioms bei Arbeitem. die lang dauemd dem Vinylchlorid ausgesetzt waren. Z aerztl Fortbild 70: 1020-1022
Sehnack H, Stockinger L. Wewalka F<1967) Adventitious connective tissue cells in the space of Disse and their relation to fibre formation. Rev int Hepatol 17:855-860
Schneiderman MA (1979) Chemical carcinogens. Science 203:603 Schneiderman MA. Mantel N. Brown CC (1975) From mouse to man - or how to get
from the Laboratory to Park Avenue and 59th street. Ann NY Acad Set 246:237248
Schottek W (1969) Zur Toxikoiogie des Vinylchlorids. Cham Techn (Leipzig) 21: 708-711
Schiitz A. Wolf D (197T) Gefthrdung dutch Vinylchlorid bei der PVC-Weiterverarbeitung. Benifsgenossenschaften 1:7-13
Schwarzweiler F (1957) Veriaufsuntenuchunfen bei eieem osteoivtischen KrankheiubUd. Z Orthop 88:404-413
Schweitzer GE (1975) Environmental concerns beyond the workplace. Presentation to the Working Group on Toxicity of Vinyl Chloride-Polyvinyl Chloride. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:296-302
Sehn-Bachner U. Etzel F (1977) HKmostaseologische Bcfunde bei Vinylchloridschaden. In: Gutscker HW, Lclbach WK (eds) LcbencMden dutch Vinylchlorid. Witzstrock. Baden-Baden Brteel K61n New York, pp 89-91
Seki K(1965) Histometrical studies of the spleen in Band's syndrome with referen.e to dinko-pathologic correlations. Tohoku J Exp Med 87:222 -243
Selikoff LI (1976) Discusion remark to Barnes: Vinyl chloride and the production of PVC. Proc R Soc Med 69:281
Vin> 1
SelmL 79-
Sever CII. Ai
Shahi thv
She:!. o:
Sid ery sm
Da 5:. eft.
Da Sii Por
Simpv
rer Slater Smim
19: Smim'
Di< r-o Smim
ole' Smith : Smith .
chi Smith - pt.-. Smith 1
ril. Smok
Iff Sm;
17- '
Somit-. Sw.
Sortn Spir'i-
duo 42U
Spirt.n-i.
Stem ( ph..
Stein nai
Stew.. ndi
Slutu*
aht ' Sueiti I
cl.Suciu I
Ml-'
1 H J. Mcrsieller
-cd Set ;-<>
mmed 51
'.unfits A :tcs. Castro-
i chronic pi J Med *91:
.`keps in Japan
Wig KLH971)
er and lunp in
<ie (VC) hepa-
lalnit der . hows Archie
vj. Med Chsm
i Toxikolote ir -131 --h Vinvl-
L Chir 2! 6 :i* h<i \fSei -ttblld
i<su celts in the 1 J7:S55-S"0
nr how to |et So 246:2.'?
ipZif) 21:
* dtttverarbei-
-lien Kiankheus-
Presentation rid*. Aon NY
nyichlotldschi Ichiorid.
with refcrei<*c
.* production of
Vinyl ClUorid-Associared Dtwasc
107
Schnscf M. Kolf RS < 19"5> Thorotrast and the liver: a reminder. Gastroenterology 6i.
790-803 Sever? LW. Skory LK ( 1975) Monitoring personnel exposure to vinyl chloride, vinylid-
ene chloride and methyl chloride ir. an industrial work environment. Am Ind Hyp Assoc J 36:oo9 -76 Shahm MM i I97j The non-mutagenicity and -recomoinogemcity of vinyl chiorids in
ihe absence of metabolic activation. Mutat Res CO 2p9-2"2
Sherlock S. Feldman CA. Moran 8. Scheuer PJ (] 966) Partial nodular transformation ct the liter with portal hypenension. Am J Med *0 195 -20?
Sidsry * H. Veiiios F i 196*1 Portal hypertension without cirrhosis or extrahepatic ob struction. Am J Surf 108:785-789
Da Silva Horra J < 1967) Late effects of thorotrast on the liver and spleen, and their efferent lymph node?. Ann VS' Aead Sci t*5:67f-f99
Da Silva Horta J. da.Motta LC { 19671 Followup study of thonum dioxide patients ;n Portugal. Ann NY Acad Sci 1*5:830-8*2
Simpson HM. Baggenstom AH. Stauffer MH (1955) Primary tareoma of the liver a report of three cases South Med J *8:1177-1] 82
Slater IF (1972) Free radical mechanisms in tissue injury. Pion. London Smirnova NA( 195*) Paper presented at the conference of young scientists. Gor*ki:.
195*. pp 10-11 (Russian text I Smirnova N A (1959) Climes of chronic intoxication by olefins and vinyl chiondc.
Dissertation GorTcii tRussian text) Snumova NA (1961) On the question of bone lesions due to chronic intoxication by
olefins end vinyl chloride. Vestn Rentgenol Radiol 36:63-66 I Russian text) Smith PM. Williams DMJ 11974) Vinyl chloride and cirrhosis. Digestion 10:321 Smith PM. Williams DMJ.Crossley IR (197$) Portal hypenension induced by vinyl
chloride. Gut 16:402-403 Smith PM. Crossky IR. Williams DMJ (1976*) Portal hypertension in vinyl chloride
production workers. Lancet 11:602--60* Smith PM. Williams DMJ. Evans DMD (1976b) Hepatic angiosarcoma in a vinyl chlo
ride worker. Bull NY Acad Med 52:447^52
SmolCid V11966) Assessment of lead exposure in PVC manufactories and suggestion* for control measures. Arh Hig Rada Toksikol 17:30*' 316 (Serbo-Croatian text i
Smyth HF Jr (1956) Hygienic standards for daily inhalation. Am tnd Hyg Assoc J 17:129-183
Sofamcrschild H. KJupT (1971) Some observations on hepatic sinusoids. Acta Chir
Seand 137:257-263 Sorenson WR (1976) Polyvinyl chloride in fires. JAMA 236:1449 Spirtas R. Kaminski R (1977) Angiosarcoma of the liver in vinyl chloride/polyvinyl
chloride workers. - 1977 Update on tha NTOSH Register. J Occup Med 20:427-
429 Spinas R. McMichael AJ. Gamble J. van Err M (197$) The association of vinyl chlo
ride exposures with morbidity symptoms. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 36:779-789 Stein G, Jiihe S, Lange CE. Veltman G (1973a) Bandfdrmige Osteolysch In den End-
phalangen des Handskdctts. ROEFO 118:60-63 Stsin G. JGhe S. Lange CE. Vaitman G (1973b) Skekttverfnderungen bci der soge-
nannten Vinyicbloridknnkbcit. RoentgenMattter 26:350-355 Stewart 3D. Williams DMJ. McLachian MSF (1975) Acrooueolysis in a polyvinyl chlo
ride woeker with an atypical industrial history, i Soc Occup Mad 25:103-109 Stutte HJ. Heusermann U (1978) DM Milt bet der Vtaylehiorid-Krankheit. Zentralbi
aUg Pathol Pathol Attat 122:284 Sudu 1. Drejman 1. Vaiaskai M (1963) ComributE la scudiut tmboinivirUor predusc de
domra de vinfl. Med loxeraT 15:967-978 Sudu I. Drejmtn I, Vaiaskai M (1967) Etude das maladies dues au chtonire de vinyle.
Med Lav 58:261-271
%
r--> tuo7 GO
I k
{
108 W.K Lelbach and H.J Maniellcr
Suciu i. Prodan L, Ilea E. Padutaru A. Pascu L < 1975) Clinical manifestation1. m vinyl
chloride poisoiung. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:53-69
Szende B, Lapis K. Nemes A. Pinter A (1970) Pneumoconiosis caused by the inhala tion of polyvinylchloride dust. Med Lav 61:433-436
Tabenhaw IR. Gaffey WR (1974) Mortality study of workers in the manulacrure of
vinyl chlonde and its polymen. J Occup Med 16:509-518
Tjkeuchi Y. Mabuchi C (1973) a case of occupational acroosteolysit, presumably
caused by vinyl chloride, Jpn J Ind Health 15:385-394
Tamburro CH (1973) The hepatic role m the carcinogenesis and in early detection -
the vinyl chloride model. Yale J Biot Med 51:67-80
Tamburro CH. Creech JL, Makk L. Whelan JG (1978a) Alcohol vinv] chloride: a causal
relationship in the development of primary hepatocellular carcinoma. Paper pre
sented at the Meeting of the International Association for the Study of the Liver.
Fuengiroia, Spain.October 20-21.1978
Tamburro CH. Creech JL, Davis A. Greenberg RA (1978b) Indocyanine green clearance
as the prospective indicator of hepatocellular chemical toxicity. Paper presented to
the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases a: the 29th Annual Meet
ing. Chicago,-111. Nov 6-8.1978
Tandon BN. Lakshminarayanan R. Bhaigava S. Nayak NC. Sama SK (1970) Ultra
structure of the liver in non-cirrhotic portal fibrosis with portal hypertension. Gut
11:905-910
,
Tassignon JP (1979) Log normal distribution of the ineubation period of liver angio
sarcoma in vinyl chloride polymerization workers. J Occup Med 21:10
Taylor KJW, Barrett JJ, Williams DMJ. Smith PM. Duck BW (1976) Preliminary results
of grey-scale ultrasonography in the detection of vinyl chloride related liver and
spleen disease. Proc R Soc Med 69:292--295
Thiess AM. Versen P (1974) Arbeitsmedizinischc Gedinken zur sogenannren ..Vinyl-
chloridcrkrankung". Arbcitsmed Sozialmcd Praeventivmed 9:146-148
Thomas LB. Popper H (1975) Pathology of angiosarcoma of the liver among vinyl
chloride - polyvinyl chloride workers. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:268-277
Thomas LB. Popper H.Bcrk PD. Selikoff I. Falk H U975> Vmyl-chlonde-tnduced
liver disease. From idiopethic portal hypertension (Banti's syndrome) to angio-
sarcomas. N Engl J Med 292:17-22
Tisdale WA. ICIatskin G, Glenn WWL (1959) Portal hypertension and bleeding eso-
phageal varices. Their occurrence in the absence of both intrahepatic and extrahe-
patic obstruction of the ponaIvein. N Engl J Med 261:209-218
Tola S 41975) Occupational lead exposure in Finland. IV. The polyvinyl chloride
plastic industry. Scand J Work Environ Health 1:173-177
Torkelson TR, Oyea F, Rowe VK (1961) The toxicity of vinyl chloride as determined
by repeated exposure of laboratory animals. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 22:354-361
Trapp JT. Lummui FL, Hilbun BM (1974) Acro-osteolysis: a case report. J Miss State
Med Assoc 15:246-248
Tribukh SL. Tikhomirovs NP, Levina SV. Kozlov LA (1949) Conditions of work and
measures of industrial hygiene in the production of, and manufacture from, vinyl
chloride plastics. Gig Sanit 10:38-44 (Russian text)
Triche T, Nanba K, Ishak JC. WoOcoff A. Berk PD (197$) Hepatic ultrastnictural
changes in rinyl chloride (VC) wotken. Clin Res 23:259A
TrucU JE, Peck SD. Rciquam CW (1973) Hemaagiosarcoau of the liver complicated by disseminated intravascular coagulation. Gastroenterology 65:936-942
Vainio H (1978) Vinyl chloride and vinyl benxcnc (styrene)-owubolism. mutagenicity
and carcinogenicity. Chem BM Interact 22:117-124
Vale FT, Kipling MD, Wafcer AE (1976) Miscellaneous symptoms occurring in worker*
engaged in the manufacture of PVC. J Soc Occup Med 26:95-97
Vazin AN, Plokhova FT (1968) On the pathogenesis of disease due to chronic expo
sure to vinyl chloride. Farmakoi Toksikoi 3:369-372 (Russian text)
^ P--*
cn 40
Vinj
Vazm
to! (RVazir. exVKE
bat' Velirr
Be Veitn.
In chi Veltm COti VeJtm 197
Verck;-
in v 29VUJeru Via. Viola I
Viola 1' Viola r Viola i
to ' Wagon
J`; Walk.-:
t:,< Wa Ikr
34Walki-
2bWalln
Mi Ward .
Pr<Ward '
m>i Waian
sir . Waian
nd-
Watan her an-
Waia,. situ-
Watjn nd. 391
Waur btr-
Waxw. nsk
Jf.J Miirm'Kcr
j*ms in vm\ 1
the inhala-
iu}.ii.'.urs ui
resirmably
ii.recnor. -
i L.r.de: a causal I'jper pr?>( the Liver.
preen clearance ;t presented to
Annual Meet-
vtqi Ultra.i.ension. Cut
- freer angio0 iminary results u u*t and
:*irvn ..Vinyl-
np vinyl
nduced ranpio-
. .mp esouJ extra*
*
.letermincii M- 3M - IMi'sSUilc
v.-rfc and *.vm. vtnv f
vucturai
implicated 942 >. mutagenicity
mtg in workers
Irrmuc expo* i
Vinyl Chl>nd--^s*0fc'iat,sd 0i**3S<
110099
Vin AN. Ptokhova ET11969a) Change* ui adrenalin-iike rubsunces ui rabbit blood following chronic exposure to vinyl chloride vapour. Gif Tr Prof Zabol 13 46 -47 (Russian text)
Vatin aN. Plokhova ET < 1969b) Changes of cardiac activity in rats following chronic
exposure to vinyl chlonde vapour. Farmakoi Toksikol 32:220-222 (Russian text) VKE i 1974. 1975J VC'PVC: Bei'hrel <-iner ProblemlOjung- Herauspepeben vom Ver-
band Jer kunstitofferteugendan Industrie a.V i VKE). Frankiurt) Veltman G. Large CE (l9"7-i) A;e;tjmedi2inische Asnekte -Jer Vinjlchlondscltiden.
Beruisdcrmati'sen 25 6" '7
Veltmjn C. Large CE < |9*Tb> A/'cr;incdiz:nitche Aspekts der V:n> !c.`tlor Jschiden In: Gutacker HW. Leibacli WK ledsi Leberschaden durch Vinylchlond - Vinylchlond-Krankheic Witzstrock. Baden-Baden Bnissel Koln New York, pp 95-101
Veltman G. Lange CE. Jfthe S. Stein G, Bachner U f!'5) Clinical manifestations ir.d course of vinyl chloride disease. Ann NY Acad Set 246:6-17
Veltman G. Lange CE. Stein G (1973) Die Vlnylchlorid-Krankheii. Hautarzt 29: 1977-1982
Vertkin Yl. Mamontov YR M970) On the condition of the broncho-pulmonary rystem m workers employed in the manufacture of FVC articles. Gig Tr Prof Zabol 14. 29-32 (Russian text)
VilJcneuve JP.Huet PM. Joly JG. Marleau D.Coce J. Legare A. Lafortune M, Lavoie P. Viailct A (1976) Idiopathic portal hypertension. Am J Med 61:459-464
Viola PL (1970a) Cancerogenie effect of vinyl chloride. Int Cancer Congr. Abttr 29 Viola PL (1970b) Pathology of vinyl chloride. Med Lav 61:174--180 Viola PLl 1974) La malaxtia da cloruro di vinile. Med Lav 65:81-99 Viola PL, Bifotti A.Caputo A U971) Oncogenic response of rat skin, lungs, and bones
to vinyl chloride. Cancer Res 31:516-519 Wagoner IK. Infante PF. Sincci R (1976) Vinyl chloride and mortality? Lancet 11:
194--195
wnker AE (1974) a preliminary report of a vascular abnormality occurring in men engaged in the manufacture of polyvinyl chloride. Br I Dermatol 1974: 22-23
Walker AE (1975) Occupational euro-osteolysis (two cases). Proc R Soc Med 68:343346
Walker A( 1976) Clinical aspects of vinyl chloride disease: Skin. Proc R Soc Med 69: 286-289
Walln&fer H. Zinnagi N (1977) Himugiosartofnatose aach Poly*inylchloridexpositioa.
Med KUn 72:410-413 Ward AM < 1976) Evidence of an immune complex disorder in vinyl chloride workers.
Proc R Soc Med 69:289-290 Ward M, Udnoon S, Watkins J, Walker A. Darke CS (1976) Immunotogicsl mecha
nisms in the pathogenesis of vinyl chloride disease. Br Med 11:936-938 Watanabe PG.GehringPJ(l976) Dosedependent fate of vinyl chloride and its pos-
sibk rvlationriiip to oncogenicity in no. Environ Health Peispect 17:145-152 Watanabe PG. McGowan GR. Madrid EO. Gehring PJ (1976a) Fate of "C-nnykftlo-
ride following inhalation exposure in rats. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 37:49-59
Watanabe PG. Hefner RE Ir. Gehring PJ (1976b) Vinyl chloride-induced deprvsrion of hepatic non-prowin suifhydryl content and effects on brotnosulphaiein (BSP) clear ance in rats. Toxicology 6:1-8
Watanabe PG, McGowan GR, Gehring PJ (1976c) Fact of |4C vinyl chloride after ttfk oral administration in rats. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 36:339-352
Watanabe PG. Zempel JA. Gehring PJ (1978a) Comparison of the fate of vinyl chlo ride fuluwhi riaMe and repeated exposure In rats. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 44: 391-399
Watanabe PG, Zempel JA. Pen DG. Gehring PJ (I97|b) Hepatic macromoleeular Mailing following tapomit to vinyl chloride. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol *4:J7] -$79
WaxweaarRJ.StxbMBrW.WapDncrJK.JomaJ.FaBc H, Carter C( 1976} Neoplastic ririt --nni enrirsis exposed to vinyl chloride. Ana NY Acad 8d 271:40-48
r5 r~
g G
A'- VaT
*: f
Tisiuaj
EI7Ip9t\* I I
rs
rs
'C,UT1M
1M 9> IS S'f a f t* w rt
f'
o rr
a it u-ut|< r c .c .t Cl SC a f'C a f
i rc j re .:.^uv 4'saQ nsiui3
to
r<\Ni S'
<3Ia\;is
j^a
(c utnOJ>ocuSt 1foqtfqox *pey Iih qwv 'apuopp jXuia o) ajnsodxa Iujmoqoj ja.\i| aqj
jo tuioupiOfSue jo SMC9 ox (SI6U 12*-^X *K ?>AOupucjfqo)| `p; ?uts 'IS eauoz
6S-IS:89C 0**V loqie^) qaiy M*qa*?A. JM quM^*puo|qt^<nA *P tuiQ)Cuy uaipsitoioipcj jnz (i61) H Jp3`H uueuuaunuiz
Cl-ree paiuvjtaqjy qwY IU| ysSH pu* sn u#**wq qseojddc tnuojssimtp V ajuiie 3ix< oj ajnsodxa |cuoijedn>ao joj niuii) iqqnsiguaj {fX61) Ty *?nIP*Z
tt9-OI9-U jnj uoisuauadXq icjjod aiiedaqcjiui>9t}nqjJi>uou q]i uuaytd jo uotnajduioaap
irviod jbijc |C.\ujn$ paJuoioij (0661 >'HV tu^H `fty uos*eQ *jy piajsucis ^ us3a?2
e:r- i:p:sz t pov *H Pl uiy Jpuoiip |AWA (t96\i Vf ddr* 61-1 : udf toqiej ejDyA.jjj3UJOutq put Xdowajaiuj uojiaafa Suiuuc.'k
Adoasojatui iqdij iuisn (SKOqup ja.\i| inoqiiM auioapu.^.pucg pa||c>os) uotcuai
jadXq icjji'd .iiqicdotpi ui ua|ds aqi jo saipnji |C9tlo[A|dioK <6i6l) M oioiuruicx 506* !o8:8J udf v^qjcj ciy (fisoqup jsaii (-V'piM aiuojpu.\s
s.uoeg paj|T!x>i) uoyuauadAq feud'd siqiedoipi ui uaajdt qj qjlw 9uucdiuoa sis oqjjia ja.\q 9i|eiauioua|ds ui uaajdf ?tujo sajpnjs |C90o(oqdJOK (t $| > )| oiouieuiex
*,' 68~08:9ft PS PV AS uuy aptjopj? |XutA.{[0d jo ajmacjmieui aqi ui pa>\|<Mui ua^jo.-n jcaiuiaip Juotue sauojsiti
s>3uj|i puc msaj SuiuaajM poH *>( Xpma 3i*o|oiiuapida uy ({^,611 HV ll^G Jf iaii[3neis ->jq [laqduie^ `Jf ,\\f UL-fi-.qAnq -ja iJistJJsqxiH i\f uaqsio^ *HV ut'.w
9681-1681 8C 50JJ p^i iutuinq ut juauttsatn ^su oj qseuiddc
uc rsaipms riio|03(voi jo udisap aqj iqjtuoueiapisuos ortojoriuapidg (66.61 > Sf spo^AV
91 j-- | | z X1 )3adu3j qj|CaH uojL^uj Apmt jciuauiuad
x uc :puoiq.i I^UIA JO naajja ica^opig CPigl) 1
0 8iquj|OH K |l?ui,>\
'V 18S-US:I0C VKVfss icjouodag
sw<(03jsooj3e feuonednaso <i96t )1f
uimcx '3/W^*uuo^a^ '>fa uosp.^
8t-"f 06 3e?'uiaq3 my f sauijaio pajcinfuo.i pur
paicuyoiqa qiiM uozo ;o suou.'roi jo saicg (8961) fy syoueta.x^ *<JG uosutciip \\
9" LS'-LZ PpK dnj9Q roj f ua^io.w apuoiqs [auia
ui Xqdeiiouuaqi pucq jo luauusaict uy
I) X5( sut.\3 3 suaqoy *fK0 tuicifOM
,1
tsi-:>*i:ee
uapjosip iaAq Juuoiiuojv (9^61) HI .<r*soo *A\f2l JOM*X `|\'d qiuis *f|^G suierin.M t9; 1 uotuaSiQ uaqzo iautououi ppuojqr' |Xun ui sjXticqa ia.%q jo uonsaiap
aiicuioiduiXs-aij msx61 > .8 tP"<l `Krl . ' pCVVi mo wea'-p
loiXcx'fKa s>u*m>A\ jn; uaqjOM jawououi
apuojq? i.(uu lurusaj.Aj <e;x6t) IVd ir,fyaj.>jt *
iO|^X TKQ
*
f '/ '
9: pA,v, vlnaso ?oS f
'.i>A|oaiso*oJ.`'c u< sinajap ir^autr^r-l jo
t-- < 11 ')&i**;?iq.'crjr>;^ - fj\a s",n,\k
*-
- *
.iS-6CS'
v>! ''''J'- |'
I uiia cm
\ i : PSl
L| 1 i.vk (i.'-h.. . r ui-j43r . J| 1
/-:'f , > .. -r ->r `-1' " a
ri\ f...
*! 'VU-'J'i
v~:: 5*h 1 *. u > u3iMuu.\v
N:t*0: :
M r-
lele.I .l fd.J.J3.3I3A.V
'Ulf-'H
" Vr- '
.'T-i9,r6r.P-''|\>X.?du3 S
10 |t>oi[?s I'f ^JCH nit n 1il-lr`*I'-''!WOdV*-. > I ^HG'ucuiSr.v,
!"0 9r !-',S l'~JY K '"
maj mn/nssiQ) 1 s_0(, ucu;3a^
;86l -U6l 9p
'Ptu asoivfjj '
ojoqx Pun IU,,J* 'S ''lf(PMiopuao|n.,-iT.,>,j 1 l to l 1 H uuci'i. Juicaj *h .| ''A.w
^
*ce>ag psirtxiuv-pue((|3|.(U,A ;jsi,9me^ -fu puc iprqiai
Oil
I#*'
r
Environmental Health Perspectives Vol. il, pp. 10I-J06, 1981
Epidemiologic Study of Vinyl Chloride Workers: Mortality through December 31, 1972
by W. Clark Cooper*
A population of 10.173 men. employed in 37 plant*, was identiAed as havint worked for at least one year in jobs involving probable exposure to vinyl chloride monomer (VCM) prior to January
1,1973. Ofthe 9677 men whose vital status was determined, 707 were known to have died. For $99, death certificates were obtained. The standardized mortality ratio (SMR) for all causes was 89, that for all malignancies was 104. The only type of malignancy found in significant excess was in the category of malignant neoplasms of the brain and other parts of the nervous system; 12 deaths occurred where 5.9 were expected, for an adjusted SMR of 203. There were slight but inconclusive upward trends in all malignancies, and for malignancies of the respiratory tract,
digestive tract, and central nervous system associated with reported levels of maximum exposure to VCM. When groups in whom less than 20 years had elapsed from the first exposure were compared with those with 20 or more elapsed years, and 25 or more elapsed yean, no significantly different SMR's were detected for major primary sites of malignancy. Plans for an updated study of mortality, to include deaths in the period 1973-1979 are briefly discussed.
The epidemiologic studies of vinyl chloride work ers summarized in this report were carried out `uringthe period June 15,1973 through December, i976 by Tabershaw-Cooper Associates, Inc., and Equitable Environmental Health, Inc., for the Manufacturing Chemists Association (MCA) (now die Chemical Manufacturers Association).
An initial report, dealing with 8,384 workers from 34 plants, was prepared May 3, 1974 (1). A summarized version (#) was published in 1974. The study population was subsequently increased and hEow-up was improved. After an interim report in 1976 (), a final report based on 10,173 workers was prepared in January, 1978 U). In all ofthese studies the observation period ended December 31, 1972.
Participating Plants
In mid-1973, the MCA identified 43 plants in the United States, belonging to 19 companies, which "filer produced vinyl chloride monomer (VCM) or ed it in the production of poly(vinyl chloride)
Jh
H60 Shattoek Ave., Suite 401, Berkeley, California 94704.
October 1981
(PVC). Of these, 34 were included in the initial
study; four were excluded because they had been in operation less than 5 years, one had stopped production in 1966, and in others information on job histories or exposures was deficient. Three plants were subsequently added to the original 34, so the 1978 report included 37 plants. Of these, 11 pro duced only VCM, 18 produced only PVC, three produced both, and five plants produced homo polymers and copolymers, with or without VCM and PVC.
The geographical distribution of those in- the Btudy, as shown in Table 1, indicates a dispropor tionate number of workers from the South, particu-
Table I. Geographical (Retribution of 10.173 vinyl chloride worker* In 1978 report.
Region
U.S. males (1970), %
Workers in tody, %
Northern! North Central South West
23.8 27.9
80.9 17.4
25.9 16.4 64.8 0.9
101
292?nun
; ;3
I larly from the East South Central and West South Central States. The South, with 30.9% of the total U.S. male population in 1970, supplied 64.8% of the
Table 2. Bases for development of VCM exposure categories.
Criterion
Unit f
( ia ( iS i ,u
K study population. Of the plants participating, the one which had first begun operations with VCM had done so in
Duration of exposed employment
Interval from beginning of exposure to end of observation
Months
Months J
:a
*7
t 1935, the most recent was in 1968. Four plants had begun in 1942 or earlier, 13 in 1952 or earlier, and 27 in 1962 or earlier.
Estimated maximum level to which an individual was exposed for at least 12 months. classified as high, medium, or low.
Integrated or cumulative exposure, crediting
High Medium
Low
1
E >t. st
1 for each month at low, 2 for each
2
I The Study Population month at medium and 3 for each month
3
at high exposure to VCM
;
Exposure index (El) " Cumulative score/average
The objective was to include all male employees
number of months
}
lc T c)
whose work had involved exposure to vinyl chloride
li
P for at least one year prior to December 31, 1972. The designation ofjobs which involved exposure to VCM was made by staff members at individual
analyses. As shown in Table 2, individual exposures in various papers were classified in a number of
li
plants or by a corporate industrial hygienist. In ways, including the maximum level at which an
I approximately two thirds of the study population, individual had been exposed for at least 12 months, TCA staff copied personnel records on individuals an integrated or cumulative exposure, and an
who were identified as having been in exposed jobs. exposure index based on the cumulative score
I In the remaining portion of the population, detailed information on exposed individuals was provided by plant personnel. The methods used in doing this are described in the complete reports cited earlier.
divided by the number of months.
Follow-Up
1
C DO
)
As is customary in historical prospective studies, rvj 1
Study Period
The period of time in which the work-force of a
all who had left employment were traced when possible. Methods included form letters sent by mail and use of retail credit follow-up. For the first
rs> CD e
r
plant was included in the study depended upon the report, there was insufficient time to utilize Social
date it began making or using VCM and also upon Security Administration records, but for subse
the earliest date when personnel records were complete for all employees, if that was later than the foregoing. This was done to eliminate periods when there was differential record retention of workers terminated, deceased, or retired. The end of the study period was December 31, 1972.
Estimates of Exposure
In each plant, every job and location with VCM
quent reports such follow-up was used. In the first, or 1974 report, 85% of the study
population was located; for the final or 1978 report,
the percentage had been increased to 95%.
The mortality calculations were based only on those who were successfully traced, which is equiv
alent to assuming that mortality among those not found was the same as among those who were found. This usually, but not always, results in some overestimation of mortality.
Ti
ucc<
UCCi .eat
scene
ibrc uals expa
5.88
relat
exposure was graded in toms of probable expo
sure. Originally, a job history form was designed in Calculation of Standardized
the l
the expectation that the exposures could be quantified in parts per million. This proved impossible in practice. However, for each plant, jobs and loca
Mortality Ratios
Each worker in the study, i.e., everyone whose
TaM* years.
tions involving the highest exposures could be vital status was ultimately known, was considered
classified as "high", and other jobs classified as to have been under observation from the date on
"medium" or "low" relative to the "high". It is which he attained a year of exposed employment or
-Vo. of
recognized that this subjective classification is of from the date when his plant's records were com- Vo. fo
questionable validity in categorizing the past and plete, whichever came later. Observation periods
*\foui
present exposure of a given worker. From the number of months spent in jobs with classifications of 3 (high), 2 (medium) and 1 (low), a number of exposure categories were developed for use in later
ended December 31.1972, or on the date of death, whichever occurred first.
Observed deaths were classified by cause accord ing to the 7th (1955) revision of the international
i
Vo. de Vo. ce Total i
Death.-
102 _-
Environmental Health Perspectives Octol
I
Classification of Diseases. The expected number of deaths by cause were calculated by using age and cause-specific mortality rates for United States males with the same birth years and age distribu te for the years 1950. 1955, 1959, 1965, 1967 and
jths for which death certificates could not be oDtained were assumed to have the same cause distribution as the death certificates that were obtained. Appropriate increases were made in calculated SMR's.
The statistical significance of the deviation of each SMR in the study population from an expected value of 100 was tested by a method derived from Chin Leong Chiang (5). The formula for determin ing the standard error of the SMR was
V 100 X SMR
SE No. expected deaths
If an observed SMR differed from 100 by more than 1.96 standard errors, it was regarded as significant | at the 5% level; if it differed by more than 2.57 * standard errors, it was regarded as significant at
the Yk level. SMR's based on fewer than five observed deaths were usually not tested for signi} ficance.
Results
f Table 3 summarizes the numbers of individuals, ss of follow-up, person-years and deaths in jssive phases of the study. The number of
I aeaths per 1000 man-years of observation, which in ' general reflects the age distribution of the work
force, suggests that the proportion of older individ. uals increased in the study population as it was ) expanded and follow-up improved. Even so, the
5.88 deaths per 1000 man-years indicates that a relatively young population was being observed; , the U.S. male population 20 and above has about 11
i
TtMe 3. Number* of Individuab, iucku of foUow-up. penonjean, and deaths analysed in successive phases of the study.
Report 1, Report 2, Report 3, 1974 1976 1978
No. of men No. found S found No.dettho No. certificates 7*UI men-yr Dnths/1000 man-yr
8,384
7,128 95%
352
328 77,84$
4.52
9,109 8,714 96%
525
511
94,221 5.67
10.173 9,677 gr
707
669 120,203
5.88
iy October 1981 \
deaths per 1000 man-years. Some published occu pational epidemiologic studies will show 20 or more.
Duration of Exposure to VCM
In the first report, only 15.2% of those studied had begun exposure prior to 1950 (22 years before end of the observation period). In the third report, 33.4% had had 20 or more years for observation since exposure began. This resulted from finding more early employees by improved follow-up, and the inclusion of an older group from one plant in the augmented population.
Standardized Mortality Ratios
Standardized mortality ratios (SMR's) for selected causes of death are shown in Table 4, based on the 352 deaths analyzed in Report 1 and the 707 deaths analyzed in Report 3. Results in the first report led Tabershaw and Gaffey (2) to conclude that vinyl chloride may be associated with cancer of a number of sites, notably digestive cancer, respiratory can cer, cancer of other and unspecified sites (primarily those of the central nervous system) and lympho mas. This was based not on statistically significant excesses in each category, but upon apparent trends when different levels and durations of exposure were compared.
With the enlarged study group, the SMR for malignancies in the entire population dropped slight ly, as did the SMR's for malignancies of the buccal cavity and pharynx, digestive tract and respiratory tract. However, tumors of the brain and central nervous system, when examined separately, still appeared to be in excess.
A number of analyses were done in the third report in an attempt to sharpen the focus on work exposures.
There appeared to be a slight but definite trend in the SMR's for all malignancies, malignancies of the digestive tract, the respiratory tract, and for other and unspecified sites with increasing levels of estimated maximum exposure (Table 6). HoweverT the numbers ofexpected deaths woe relatively few in some categories and the groups differed widely in age distribution as manifested by deaths per 1000 1 person-years.
To reduce dilution ofthe study population by men whose exposures had begun only recently, a sepa rate analysis was carried out on those whose expo sures to VCM had begun 20 years or more prior to 1972, and on those whose exposures had begun 25 years or more prior to 1972 (Table 6).
Another analysis was made of a population of men who had worked in plants producing only PVC
103
(where VCM exposures were presumably high), whose exposures had begun 20 years or more be fore the end of the study period and who had been
reported as having medium or high VCM exposures for a year or more (Table 7). This group experi
enced 210 deaths where 249.7 had been expected* The pattern of mortality from malignancies was not j appreciably different from that of the total study group.
In summary, increasing the study population and
Table I. Observed and expected deaths (O/E) and standardized mortality ratios for selected causes (SMB's adjusted for missing
death certificates).
*
Cause (ICD Mo, 7th Rev)
1974 Report O/E SMR
1978 Report_____ O/E SMR
All causes All malignancies (140-205)
Buccal and pharynx (140-148) Digestive (150-159(
Respiratory (160-164)
Other and unspecified (190-199) Brain and CNS (193) Leukemia and aleukemia (204) Lymphomas (200-203, 205)
Major cardiovasc. renal (330-334. 400-468. 592-594)
Cirrhosis liver (581) No. of workers Person-vr
352/467 79/77 5/2.84
19/21.7 45/44.3 17/11.75
3/3.77 6/6.06
155/207 9/15.6 7,128 77,846
75* 110 189 94 112
1_55
85 106
80* 21
707/795 139/141 r 5/5.19 29/40.8 25/23.9 28/20.2
12/5.9 9/6.65 11/10.36
347,385 14/26.5
9,677 120,203
89* 104 102 75 107 147 203b 143 112
95 56b
.4
URL 1226S
Significant at 1% level. `'Significant at 5% level.
Table 5. Observed and expected deaths (O/E) and standardized mortality ratios for selected causes as related to maximum level of reported exposure to vinyl chloride monomer (SMR's adjusted for missing death certificates).
Cause (ICD Mo, 7th Rev)
Reported maximum exposure VCM
Low-
Medium
High
O/E SMR O/E SMR O/E SMR
AH malignancies (140-205)
Digestive (150-159) Respiratory (16IM64) Other and unspecified (19CM99) No. of workers Person-yr Deaths/1000 person-yr
65/71
14/20.9 19/22.2 11/9.9
_ 4,925 58.741 6.16
. 98
72
92 119
66/53.5
1016.6 19/17.1 1S/7.5
3,021 39.927
6.6
109 18/16.5
67 5/4.4 116 7/5.1 180 4/2.7
1.731 21.535
3.9
112 117 141 150
Table 6. Analysis of deaths based on time from beginning of exposure to end of study period (SMR's adjusted for missing death certificates).
Cause of death (ICD No. 7th revision)
< 20 yr No. SMR
> 20 yr No. SMR
> 26 yr No. SMR
All causes All malignancies (140-205)
Digestive (150-159) Respiratory (160-164) Other and unspecified (190-199) Leukemia (204) Cardiovascular-renal
168 77* 549 93 393 96
31 95 108 107 73 104
8 96 21 70 16 74
8 80 87 116 22 100
6 108
22 162
13 146
3 155
6 137
4 137
68
84 279
97 211
105
Significant at 1% level.
T04
A- <
e j 4-
C- "
Environmental Health Perspectives
*
l l
t
(
;, improving follow-up did<npg strengthen the sug'* gested associations between VCM exposure and
malignancies other than those caused by hepatic angiosarcoma, as will be pointed out later, and a suggested association with tumors of the brain and
ntral nervo&s system.
Table 7. Deaths in plants producing only PVC, based on workers whose first exposures began before 1952, and w ho
had medium or high VCM exposures (SMR's corrected for missing death certificates!.
Cause of death (ICD No. 7th revision)
O/E SMR
All causes All malignancies (140-205)
Digestive (150-159)
Respiratory (160-164) Other and unspecified (190-199) Cirrhosis of liver (581)
210/249-7
4646.01 9/13.63 17/14.75
10/ 6.33 6/7.95
84*
106 70
122 167 80
Significant at level. t
Angiosarcomas
Nine angiosarcomas are known to have occurred in the U.S. during the study period, i.e., prior to 12/31/72. As shown in Table 8, eight of these were found in the study, but only three were coded as angiosarcoma on the death certificate. However, four others were coded as tumors of the digestive tract. Unfortunately, two were coded 230x so as to fall out of the category for malignant tumors of the GI tract, and one was coded as cirrhosis of the liver.
As shown in Table 8, the angiosarcoma which was not found was in a man who had died in 1961. We have not determined how he failed to be in the study population. The years of exposure for the eight cases ranged from 4 to 23 years, while elapsed time from beginning of exposure to death ranged from 16 to 24 years.
Tumors of the Central Nervous System
The 12 tumors otthe brain had been diagnosed on death certificates as follows: glioblastoma multiforme, 4 (1 confirmed by autopsy); astrocytoma, 2 (2 au-
Table 8. Angiosarcoma deaths and data on VCM exposures.
ICI No.1
First exposed
Year of death
Time from first exposure to death, yr
Total yr exposure
Est. max. exposure
Age at death
USA-02
1955
1971
16
14 High 38
-04 1949
1968
19
18 High 43
-05 1944
1964
20
20 High 52
-07 1944
1968
24
14
Med
45
10 1946
1970
24
23 Low 70
-11 1951
1968
17
17 Med 60
-12 1949
1969
20
20 High 50
-16 1950
1969
19
4 High 41
LI -08 --
1961
Not in study group
Number used in registry periodically prepared by J. Stafford. Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd., Plastics Division.
[]
O' Case no. 1 2 3
IF 4 5 6 7 8
it 9 10
a 11 12
October 1981
Table 9. Summary of brain tumor deaths (ICD No. 205) and data on VCM exposures.
First exposed
Yr of death
Time from 1st exposure to death, yr
Total yr exposure
Max. exposure
1958 1967 1957 1941 1960 1966 1947 1945 1949 1947 1935 . 1935
1972
1972 1968 1958 1970 1971 1971 1963 1971 1971 1966 1967
14 5 11 17 20 15 24 18 22 24 21 32
5 Low 5 Low
7 Med 6 Med 8 High
3 Med 23 Low 18 High 21 Low 23 High 18 Low 22 Low
Age at death
67 43 54 61 43 54 57 44 58 49 59 57
105
tu \
2 J'
Im *.
topsies); ependymoma of the 4th ventricle (autop sy); "malignant brain tumor" or "carcinoma of the brain," 5 (with no autospies). This group is cur rently being made the subject of more rigorous review. The information obtainable from our re cords, summarized in Table 9, is insufficient to prove or disprove a cause-and-effect relationship between occupational exposure and these tumors.
Conclusions
A study of 707 deaths in a population of 9677 men who had worked for one year or more in jobs involving exposure to vinyl chloride and whose vital status had been determined as of December 31, 1972, did not show a significant excess of deaths due to malignancies. There did appear, however, to be a significant excess of tumors of the brain and central nervous system, based on 12 such deaths. There also continued to be slight but inconclusive trends toward higher SMR's for deaths from digestive tract and respiratory tract tumors associated with maximum levels ofpast exposure. No striking changes in malignancy patterns were apparent when analy ses were directed toward individuals in whom 20 to 25 years had elapsed since first exposure. The results suggest that, except for a proven associa tion with hepatic angiosarcoma and a strongly sug gestive association with central nervous system tumors, vinyl chloride probably is not associated with significant excess cancers of other sites.
It should be emphasized that the epidemiologic study summarized in this report was planned, the populations defined, and analysis under way before cases of hepatic angiosarcoma had been diagnosed
in workers exposed to vinyl chloride (6). An update is scheduled with inclusion of additional deaths in the cohort during the years 1973 through 1979. The study can be improved by a separate analysis of data from the plants which began operations before 1960, and by separating, insofar as possible, expo sures to vinyl chloride monomer, polyvinyl chlo ride, and various copolymers. It is also hoped that criteria for defining exposure and for rating levels of exposure can be improved to permit better indi ces of integrated exposure.
This study was begun June 15,1973 under a contract between the Manufacturing Chemists Association, 1825 Connecticut Av enue. N.W., Washington, D.C. (now the Chemical Manufactur ers Association) and Tabershaw/Cooper Associates. Inc. It was continued under later contracts with TCA and with Equitable Environmental Health. Inc.
REFERENCES
1. Tabershaw/Cooper Associates. Inc. Epidemiological study of vinyl chloride workers, final report. Submitted to the Manufac turing Chemists Association, May 3, 1974.
2. Tabershaw, I.R., and Gaffey. W, R. Mortality study of workers in the manufacture of vinyl chloride and its poly mers. J. Occup. Med. 16: 509-518 (1974).
3. Equitable Environmental Health, Inc. Supplementary epi demiological study of vinyl chloride workers. Report pre pared for the Manufacturing Chemists Association. Septem ber 1976.
4. Equitable Environmental Health, Inc. Epidemiological study of vinyl chloride workers, final report. Prepared for the Manufacturing Chemists Association. January 1978.
5. Chiang, C. L. Standard error of the age-adjusted death rate. Vital Statistics Special Reports 47: 275-285 (1961).
6. Creech, J. L., and Johnson, M. N. Angiosarcoma of liver in the manufacture of polyvinyl chloride. J. Occup. Med. 16:150 (1974).
X1 r" r> r 'j co
--j
106 Environmental Health Perspective?