Document k49aXJRQ6ZxnL1mXxp7NJMYB
FILE NAME Newspaper & Magazine Articles NMA
DATE 1956 Mar 16 DOC NMA111
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Journal Article - News of Science -
Smoking Air Pollution and Lung Cancer
unity or multiplicity of causative agents
of respiratory cancer among the general
population as well as regarding the role
of cigarette smoking in this disease cer-
tain common factors are apparent The
identification of more proved car-
News of Science
cinogens in air pollutants and in cig-
arette smoke is becoming increasingly
correlated with the incidence of lung
cancer The qualitative relationship ap-
pears convincing the quantitative rela-
tionship to the estimation of concentra-
tions of these compounds is of impor-
Smoking Air Pollution and Lung Cancer
report is presented as an interim com-
munication and that its indicated conclu-
.
sions are far from final
tance if the quantification of lung cancer incidence can be accurately established from reliable pathological observations
a e e P. C. Stocks and J. M. Campbell sum-
marize the results of the first 2 years of
a year study in England of environ-
mental histories of persons with and
without pulmonary cancer in the British Medical Journal 1955 II 923 15 Oct. 1955 The death rates from cancer of the lung bronchus and pleura were
calculated in men between 45 and 74
years of age of different smoking habits living in rural mixed and urban areas The death rates were then related to
measurements of benzpyrene and other carcinogens present in the air in
the areas studied Concentrations of
smoke and sulfur dioxide were deter-
W. C. Hueper notes that the total evidence from epidemiological clinical and pathological studies indicates that lung cancer is caused by several atmospheric pollutants rather than a single factor in Public Health Reports 71 94 Jan. 1956 He states that the avail-
able data do not allow determination of
the relative importance of the various recognized respiratory carcinogens in the general population although single carcinogens in the air have been implicated in lung cancer in restricted occupational groups exposed to defined potent
carcinogens He feels that the recent alarming in-
At present the latter does appear to correlate with this incidence and does sup-
port the qualitative relationship thereto An interesting and important consid-
eration is raised by Hueper that the in-
dications that tobacco tar contains car-
cinogenic agents have been derived from observations of the skin of selectively inbred strain of reactive mice and have no equivalent in man However the finding of Stocks and Campbell that exposure to benzpyrene whether from tobacco smoke or from air pollution is consistently and quantitatively related to human lung cancer incidence constitutes a strongly suggestive piece of evi-
e ervRegeE E.M.L mined according to standard methods
crease in frequency of lung cancer may
dence
and anthracene
fluoroanthrene
be causally related in part to atmos-
It would appear at present that at least
pyrene
benzpyrene and benzperylene
pheric pollutants that are carcino-
one if not several carcinogenic compounds are of etiological significance in
were quantitatively determined by spec-
genic as a product of modern indus-
this disease and that increasing indus-
trophotometric techniques
trial development A number of general
trialization with its product of air pol-
It was found that the concentration of
environmental and specific occupational
smoke benzpyrene other polycyclic
air pollutants have been implicated in
lution is a significant factor in the in-
hydrocarbons and sulfur dioxide in the
the causation of lung cancer such as
creasing evidence of lung cancer Al-
air rises with increasing urbanization
dusts and fumes of nickel chromium
though the more quantitative aspects
The air concentration of benzpyrene in
compounds arsenicals asbestos coal tar
have yet to be firmly established the
8 11 times that in rural
soot vapors or mists of isopropyl oil cer-
present reports represent somewhat of an
Liverpool was to
with the
tain producing petroleum deriva-
advance in the direction of clarifying a
that has too fre-
areas This ratio corresponded
ern
estimated mortality ratio among non-
tives radioactive ores and gases and
field of investigation
smokers in those areas The rural death
carcinogens present in gasoline or diesel
quently been the subject of extremely
Peo e
rate from lung cancer increased propor-
engine exhaust dust of asphalted roads
equivocal or sensational reports
onyRP
tionately to the number of cigarettes
and carbon black in automobile tires
tn
smoked per week and pipe smokers as a
Numerous epidemiological observations
tene group ranked with cigarette smokers of strongly suggest that industry Cosmic Spherules in Deep
OAN, approximately 25 per week The city
factors have played an important causal
Sea Sediments
renameOh
death rates exceeded the rural rates but
role in the increase of lung cancers ob-
ese
Re
the urban ratio fell from approxi-
served in industrialized countries during
The small magnetic spherules con-
SEITE
Oe, RR
AE
mately 9/1 in nonsmokers to nearly 1
the last 50 years
tained in deep deposits Science 123
in
smokers The authors estimate
According to Hueper there does not
1081 2 Dec. 1955 continue to interest
STEsc
heavy
between the
scientists in various parts of the world
that approximately half of Liver-
seem to exist any parallelism
considers various
emia pool deaths of men from lung cancer
lung cancer death rate and the per capita
E. J. Opik Ireland
arise from cigarette smoking and about
consumption of cigarettes for different
kinds of evidence for the cosmic source
fourths of the remaining half are
countries the lung cancer death rate
of these deep deposits stressing par-
due to a factor only slightly present in
parallels as closely or even more closely
ticularly that the frequency of spherule
diameter distributio1 extracted from
>
rural areas
the rise in production and consump-
tion rates of motor fuel coal tar and
samples of deposits obtained by the
All death rates from lung cancer were
proportional to the estimated
several other carcinogenic substances or
Swedish deep expedition shows ex-
with theoretical fre-
directly amount of exposure to benzpyrene
the production of asphalted roads than
cellent agreement
either from cigarette smoke air pollu-
that of cigarettes He feels that the medi-
quency of micro meteors Nature 176
tion or both Stocks and Campbell sug-
cal evidence supporting a major role
926 1955 The lairt ai^-ounton 080053
gest an urban factor in the etiology of
of cigarette smoking in the causation of
nich nich
Poreaagiict
g
lung cancer and feel that benzpyrene plays a dual part through cigarettes and air pollution The authors note that their
cancer is inadequate Although the reperts of thegu v akers
are essentially upposed Begarding the
450