Document jyqxmB03YYL6ZzBxGK3V8ZdpN
lUTfire Paychecks An Introduction^ to Occupational I Cancer
Cancer Alert Series U.S. Department of Labor Occupationaljiafety and Health Administration 1978
r
i
i
j
TX GARRETT
RMC0000480
More Than a Paycheck: An Introduction to Occupational Cancer
Cancer Alert Series
U.S. Department of Labor Ray Marshall, Secretary
Occupational Safety and Health Administration Eula Bingham, Assistant Secretary
developed by: John Henry Jones, for The George Washington University School of Medicine and Health Sciences Washington, D.C. 20005
prepared for: U.S. Department of Labor Occupational Safety and Health Administration Washington. D.C. 202t0
Material contained in this publication is in the public domain and may be reproduced, fully or partially, without permission of the Federal Government Source credit is requested but not required. Permission is required only to reproduce any copyrighted material contained herein.
I
^
; !
!
t
TX GARRETT
RMC0000481
TX GARRETT
Working for a Living--Risking Death Joe H. was ready to retire happily after
spending 30 years in the roofing trade, until he developed a persistent, hacking cough .... Minnie J. had come a long way after working on the Liberty Ships in World War II. Her children were grown and she planned an early retirement with her husband. Suddenly the chest pains began___ Marty P. was a plastics man for 21 years. One day his stomach began to ache, and the pain just wouldn't go away.
These workers gave the best years of their lives to supporting themselves and their families. In doing so, however, they brought home more than a weekly paycheck. They brought home cancer.
Millions of Americans risk occupational cancer. Joe, Minnie, and Marty are not alone. The
American Cancer Society reports that one out of every four Americans contracts some form of cancer during his or her lifetime, and one American dies of cancer every 80 seconds.
While we often assume that cancer is a mysterious disease with unpredictable causes, scientists have been discovering that our chances of getting the disease are not based
RMC0000482
entirely on luck. The evidence suggests that exposure to certain substances can lead to cancer The cause of the disease may be found in what we eat, drink, breathe, or smoke. It may be a part of the urban atmosphere.
It may also be found on the job. Cancer may begin with microscopic particles, chemical fumes, or tow levels of radiation. Even if the intake is gradual, and exposure levels low, these substances can build up in the body like deposits in a long-term bank ac count. This "bank-account," however, pays oft in a stow, lingering death.
The spread of occupational cancer in the United States is a problem of critical propor tions. Every American should be concerned-- especially because, with cooperative and con scientious effort, most work-related cancer can be prevented.
Do We Know What Causes Cancer?
Scientists do not completely understand cancer, but they do agree that it is characterized by an uncontrolled growth of ab normal cells. It is thought to begin this way: Sometimes one of the cells in an organism goes haywire, overpowers its control mechanism, and keeps on growing and reproducing. This is the start of cancer, a disease which afflicts people, animals, even plants. In humans, its most deadly characteristic is its ability to migrate throughout the body by way of the blood or lymphatic systems to begin new growths. Cancer can strike people of any age, in any part of the body.
The World Health Organization estimates that from 60 to 90 percent of cancers are trig gered by the body's exposure to something-- for instance, to certain food additives, to some industrial chemicals, or even to excessive sunlight. The risks of such cancers can be reduced. Not smoking cigarettes decreases the possibility of lung cancer. Limiting one's exposure to the sun's direct rays will lessen the chances of skin cancer. And there are many steps that can be taken to prevent ex
posure to cancer-causng substances in the workplace.
Until recently, there were few long-term sur vivors of cancer. Now, because of medical ad vances in detection and treatment of the disease, this rate has improved so that, today, two of every six people who contract cancer will be saved. And our present medical knowledge could save another one of the four remaining, given prompt diagnosis and proper treatment.
A Far-Reaching Problem
Cancer in the workplace is not new. For over two centuries, tests by medical and scientific observers around the world have linked the disease to many different occupa tions. Among workers as varied as painters, chimney sweeps, railroad laborers, and fac tory workers, the stories were distressingly similar.
In the United States today, many Americans have occupations where they come in contact with disagreeable and sometimes toxic fumes, gases, mists, vapors, dusts, and other air borne particulate matter, as well as with potentially dangerous liquids and solids. Several of these substances have been found to be carcinogens (substances
oofing is one of the many trades linked to lung
t
i /
TX GARRETT
RMC0000483
capable of causing cancer). Millions of our nation's workers are thus at a high risk of developing cancer because of the jobs they hold.
A bewildering aspect of workplace cancer is the long incubation period that often oc curs between exposure to the carcinogen and the first appearance of cancer symp toms. According to Dr. Irving J. Selikoff, Director of the Environmental Sciences Laboratory of Mount Sinai Hospital, once a person is exposed to a carcinogen, 15 to 45 years may go by before any symptoms ap pear. An example: Cancer is now taking its
toll on those who breathed asbestos particles
while working on World War II ships more
than three decades ago. Doctors note several recent deaths due to mesothelioma (cancer of the membranes surrounding the lungs and other organs) among these shipyard workers of the 1940's.
Besides the immediate danger to the workers, evidence is mounting that the oc cupational cancer hazard reaches beyond the workplace to the family and community. Things that cause cancer in the workplace do not necessarily remain in the workplace. Workers who unknowingly take home dust or particles of carcinogenic substances on their bodies, clothes, cigarettes, or any other per sonal belongings may, in turn, expose their families and friends to possible contamina tion. One study of three towns in which vinyl chloride factories are located indicated an abnormal rate of cancer of the nervous system, as well as an abnormal number of birth defects, among the entire population.
If you multiply the number of workers ex posed to carcinogens on the job by the average number of persons In the American family--four--you get an idea of the magnitude of the problem. For example, con sider the over one million brake repair workers in the U.S. exposed to asbestos dust from brake drum linings. Add to them four million construction workers who saw, drill, spray, pack, and otherwise handle asbestos and asbestos products or who work near those who do. Multiply the total by four (in the average family) and you have 20 million
people at risk from asbestos alone. And asbestos is only one of many carcinogens found in the workplace.
The costs as well as the consequences of cancer are alarming. Medical care-- including hospitalization, physicians' ser vices, drugs, home nursing, sickroom equip ment, and necessary treatment--becomes increasingly expensive. To this cost must be added indirect ones, such as the loss of earning power and disability compensation.
Thus, for everyone in the country, the problem of industrial cancer is a critical one. It touches all parts of our world--workplace, home, community.
The increasingly hazardous environment was described by Mt. Sinai's Dr. Selikoff and Dr. E. Cuyler Hammond. Vice President for Epidemiology and Statistics for the American Cancer Society, in a paper delivered before the American Cancer Society Science Writers' Seminar in 1974.
"The air we breathe today contains gases and particles that never before entered human lungs. Our food has chemicals designed to improve its taste, freshness, and appearance--but which are strange to our intestines, livers, kidneys, and blood. We touch, ingest, inhale, absorb an everincreasing number of synthetic materials, and, in other circumstances, agents which have existed on earth but were never before part of the immediate human environment."
In another report. Dr. Selikoff warned: "In the coming decades, we'll have to cope with the consequences of our failure to protect workers in the past and simultaneously have to protect the workers of the future."
A Cooperative Effort
The problem of cancer in the workplace is as old as industry, yet grows more urgent all the time. How can such a widespread and complex problem be solved? It is clear that everyone's cooperation is necessary. Our large institutions, business, industry, and tabor, as welt as individuals, must become in volved in a concentrated effort to rid the workplace of occupational cancer.
1
i i
TX GARRETT
RMC0000484
The following pages will explain some in dividual rights and responsibilities and will reveal ways in which government, manage ment, labor, and the scientific community are attacking the problem of job-related cancer. Examples of how individual workers can par ticipate in this effort will also 6e mentioned.
The Government and the Occupa.tional Safety and Health Act
To protect the worker from the many and ever-present dangers of the workplace, the United States Congress passed the Occupa tional Safety and Health Act (OSHAct) of 1970. Its purpose is "... to assure so far as possible every working man and woman in the Nation safe and healthful working condi tions and to preserve our human resources ..." The law obligates every employer to provide his or her employees with a work place free from safety and health hazards.
The OSHAct established two government agencies--the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the Na tional institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). NIOSH performs research in occupational safety and health, while both agencies provide education and consultation to labor, industry, and Federal and state agencies. In addition, OSHA issues and en forces workplace standards, conducts worksite inspections, and responds to worker complaints.
The OSHA standards are regulations which designate safe and healthful working conditions or practices by which work must be performed to prevent injury or. illness. It is the employer's responsibility to comply with all the standards pertinent to his or her workplace; if the employer does not comply, he or she can be cited, fined, or ordered to abate the hazards. In addition, the employer must ensure that the workers receive train ing in all the standards that apply to their jobs.
1
i
i 1t 1
OSHA strictly regulates worker exposure to vinyl chloride.
Various OSHA standards regulating the use of cancer-causing substances require the employer:
to inform workers of the provisions of the standards which apply to them;
to provide regulated work areas restric ted to authorized persons;
to monitor workers' exposure to the substances;
to ensure that workers' exposure does , not exceed specific permissible expo
sure limits (P.E.L);
to provide medical surveillance and pro tective clothing or other protective equipment;
to observe special procedures for emer gencies, maintenance, or decontamina tion;
to keep up-to-date records of workers' medical condition and amount of their exposure to the substance;
j
-I f. .X
TX GARRETT
i
RMC0000485
to allow workers access to their medical records;
to inform workers of the special hazards of the regulated substance; and
to train them in the safe work practices that will keep the workers' exposure within the permissible limits.
To date, OSHA has issued a number of standards regulating such substances as asbestos, vinyl chloride, and benzene. OSHA has also proposed a regulation which would provide a general procedure for identifying, classifying, and regulating carcinogenic substances more quickly and efficiently.
Any worker who feels that he or she is ex posed to a carcinogen on the job, or that there are any other conditions in the workplace which threaten safety or health, should discuss the situation with coworkers or the union representative, and ask the employer to correct the hazard. If more help is necessary, OSHA can make an inspection without giving the worker's name to the employer.
Management's Role: Some Examples
The employer bears a tremendous respon sibility in the fight against occupational cancer. As we have already discussed, management has a legal obligation under the OSHAct to protect the worker's safety and health. In order to carry out these duties, it is important that the employer be thoroughly familiar with whatever OSHA standards apply to his or her establishment. Employers who act responsibly to reduce or eliminate workplace hazards will benefit from a healthier, more productive workforce, sav ings In workers' compensation and medical insurance premiums, fewer workdays lost due to illness, improved morale, and the knowledge that every possible step is being taken to protect workers from occupational cancer.
Some steps management can take to con trol the workers' exposure to carcinogens in clude:
regularly monitoring the workers' ex posure to the carcinogen;
instituting adequate ventilation systems, closed systems, and other engineering controls;
requiring proper housekeeping and maintenance procedures (for example, "wet'' cleanup methods that control the spread of harmful dusts);
* employing trained industrial health and ; hygiene personnel; and
j
instituting educational programs for supervisors and workers.
There are many examples of manage ment's taking the initiative in the fight against occupational cancer. Or. Paul Kotin, Senior Vice President for Health and Safety for Johns-Manville Corporation, outlined in-
W
--'****
TX GARRETT
RMC0000486
dustry's obligations with regard to protecting the worker from cancer. "In reviewing the entire area of risk in the workplace and par ticularly the risk of the development of cancer, management or industry has a special responsibility . . . he explains. "It is management that initiates action. It is in management's laboratories that the new pro ducts are made. It is management that deter mines the scope of the activity. How big the company is going to be. How many people it is going to employ. It requires many things to arrive at these conclusions, but basically the decisions are management's .... This privilege that management has carries with it
some very, very undeniable and emphatic responsibilities. The first is, management must be in the vanguard; it must be in the lead of supporting research, initiating re search. calling attention to areas of ig norance where new information is necessary
The Worker's Part
In recent years, labor unions have worked actively for healthful as well as safe condi tions on the job. Some new benefits won in contract negotiations include: funds for joint labor-management research into health con ditions in rubber products factories; access to company medical records for asbestos workers; and a joint labor-management health and safety committee for oil workers. Certain unions use full-time occupational safety and health specialists who assist with health programs and collective bargaining. They also may recommend to government improved protective legislation or regula tions.
Traditionally, unions have insisted on management's strictly following OSHA stand ards to insure that the rights they provide are enforced or preserved. They have also lob bied for legislation on toxic substances re quiring testing and regulating chemicals prior to their introduction into the industrial en vironment. "It comes down to a question of who shall live and who shall die," declared
. 1--
Compliance with OSHA standards for fabric dyeing operations protects workers from exposure to carcinogens.
Sheldon W. Samuels, Director of Health, Safety, and Environment for the Industrial Union Department of the AFl-CIO. "We simply cannot continue to build industries around unscreened toxic substances."
Union or nonunion, all workers have an undeniable right to know if they are being ex posed to a carcinogenic substance on the job. This right, asserts the National Academy of Sciences, "... shapes the boundaries of the employer's duty to reveal information." Workers should feel free to request informa tion--from their employers, safety and health committees, union representatives, company physicians, and OSHA--about any car cinogenic substance used in the workplace, special health hazards involved, or special procedures or equipment necessary for con trolling the hazard.
What responsibility does a worker have to safeguard his or her health against the threat of job-related cancer? Workers should:
read the OSHA poster the employer must display in the workplace;
comply with all applicable OSHA stand ards and the employer's safety and health rules;
TX GARRETT
RMC0000487
report any apparent hazards immedi ately to supervisor;
report to the supervisor any job-related illness;
cooperate fully with the OSHA com pliance officer who inspects the work place;
practice good personal hygiene; and encourge and support the formation of
groups such as effective safety and health committees.
The Scientist's Job
How do scientists determine whether an industrial substance causes cancer? The scientists, working in universities, private and public foundations, government, and other in stitutions, use a number of different methods. One involves exposing laboratory animals, usually rats or mice, to a suspected carcinogen; positive results in these tests can indicate a potential human carcinogen. Another useful method is the study of disease that spreads and Involves large numbers of people. Studies of this kind cur-
Scientists identify and evaluate the cancer threat in the workplace.
r '
rently are being used to examine workers who have contracted cancer. If those workers who handle a certain substance have a higher cancer rate than a sampling of the general population of the same age, sex, race, smoking habits, and exposure time, then that substance may be considered a probable cause of cancer.
Two large-scale efforts by scientists to identify high cancer-risk groups are the American Cancer Society's (ACS) Cancer Research Project and the National Cancer Institute's (NCI) Atlas of Cancer Mortality for
U.S. Counties--1950-69. The ACS study, co directed by Drs. Hammond and Selikoff, has
the cooperation of labor and industry. The
project examines illness and death rates
among various union member groups and the materials these workers commonly handle. Under investigation are: printing press workers exposed to carbon black, various dyes, and asbestos talc and roofers exposed to coal tar derivatives.
The NCI study used computer-generated maps to discover a number of geographical areas around the country where the cancer rate among the population is abnormally high. High death rates from lung cancer were evident in the Gulf Coast and eastern regions where there are heavy concentra tions of chemical and paper products in dustries. Unusual death rates for bladder cancer were found in the eastern and New England regions with a heavy concentration of chemical complexes as well as wood, stone, glass, and clay products facilities. Data indicating high incidence of kidney cancer were revealed in the Midwest and western areas with petroleum refineries, smelters, and lumber products operations. NCI's study has provided important clues about the relation of industrial substances to cancer.
Because of cancer's long latency period, during which the disease is not apparent, there is critical need for methods of detec tion and prediction. To meet this need, new and inexpensive test systems are being developed that may provide quick clues to the possibly dangerous properties of various
1
i
i
TX GARRETT
RMC0000488
against occupational cancer. As you have
substances. Short-term tests, for example,
seen, it is the employer's legal obligation to
may enable scientists to examine com
inform the worker about any toxic substance
pounds for cancer-causing potential, to set
used on the job, the appropriate safe pro
priorities for longer-term tests, and to recom
cedures, and the OSHA standards which ap
mend safe procedures wherever a car
ply. However, the workplace cancer problem
cinogen is in use.
touches all our lives, and every individual
/
Thus, scientists play a crucial role in the
should make a point of finding out more
fight against workplace cancer. Their efforts
about it by requesting information from,
to identify and to evaluate carcinogens pro
employers, union or trade associations,
duce the evidence upon which the govern
OSHA, or other government agencies and
ment, management, and labor must act.
public institutions.
^1
A Final Note
Increasing our knowledge will prepare us to join in the fight against occupational
This booklet has attempted to provide a
brief introduction to the subject of occupa tional cancer. You should now have a better
appreciation of the magnitude and complexi ty of the problem, and of some of the efforts that have been undertaken to deal with it. More important, you should begin to ask questions. Is my own workplace safe from the threat of cancer? Are carcinogenic substances used in my workplace? If so, what must be done to eliminate or reduce exposure? Is my family safe from the oc cupational cancer hazard? My community?
cancer and help us to choose the best
course of preventive action. The decisions are everyone's to make. "These decisions affect us all, " states Dr. Selikoff.
"There is for the first time an oppor tunity," he continues, "for us all to make our voices known in the decision-making pro cess. All of us have the right to put our two cents in and voice our opinions about what should be done, and the decisions have to be made by all of us. We have the chance to prevent cancer in the workplace. If we miss this opportunity, it will be our own fault."
Knowledge--of the risks, of control
methods, and of mutual rights and respon sibilities--is the key to a united defense
****
rir-
There is a Cancer Information Service (CIS) affiliated with the National Cancer Institute and the American Cancer Society. Callers can receive answers to their questions about cancer by using CIS's toll-free National Line: 800-638-6694.
Training sessions given by the employer are one way to keep workers informer! about cancer hazards.
I
TX GARRETT
RMC0000489
Some High-Risk Operations, Carcinogens, and Related Cancers
Trade/Operation
Roofing trades
Woodworking
Automobile clutch and brake maintenance
Mining Milling Insulation construction Asbestos fabrication Uranium processing Milling Rubber manufacture Dye industry Metal working
Oil refining
Coke oven work
Plastics production
Carcinogens
coal-tar-pitch volatiles
asphalt
Affected Organ
lungs, mouth, larynx, esophagus
solvents chlorinated hydro
carbons organic dusts
nasal membranes
abestos
lungs, mesothelium
radiation
benzene
benzedine
chromium, arsenic
polycyclic hydro carbons
coke oven emissions vinyl chloride
lungs, lymphatic system
bladder bladder respiratory system
white blood cells
kidneys, lungs liver
TX GARRETT
RMC0000490
U.S. Department of Labor OSHA Regional Offices
Region I (CT, ME. MA. NH, Rl, VT) JFK Federal Building, Room 1804 Government Center Boston. MA 02203 Telephone: (617) 223-5539
Region II (NY, NJ, PR. VI, CZ) 1515 Broadway, Room 3445 New York, NY 10036 Telephone: (212) 399-5941
Region III (DE, OC. MO. PA. VA. WV) 2100 Gateway Center 3535 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19104 Telephone. (215)596-1206
Region IV (AL, FL, GA. KY, MS. NC. SC. TN) 1375 Peachtree Street, N W, Suite 587 Atlanta, GA 39209 - Telephone: (404) 881 -3573
Region V (IL, IN. MN. Ml. OH. Wl) 230 Dearborn Street 32nd Floor Chicago. IL 60604 Telephone: (312) 353-2220
Region VI (AR. LA. NM. OK. TX) 555 Griffin Square, Room 602 Dallas. TX 75202 Telephone: (214) 749-2477
Region VII (IA. KS. MO. NE) 911 Walnut Street Room 3000 Kansas City, MO 64106 Telephone: (816) 374-5861
Region VIII (CO. MT, ND. SD. UT. WY) Federal Bldg., Room 1554 1961 Stout Street Denver, CO 80294 Telephone: (303) 837-3883
Region IX (CA, AZ, NV, HI) Box 36017 450 Golden Gate Avenue San Francisco. CA 94102 Telephone: (415) 556-0586
Region X (AK, ID, OR. WA) Federal Office Bldg., Room 6010 909 First Avenue Seattle. WA 98174 Telephone: (206) 442-5930
. L .. '. -Y
More Than a Paycheck" is also the title of a documentary half-hour film in color narrated by John Wayne and presented by the George Washington University School of Medicine and Health Sciences.
If members of your union, trade association, civic organization, school, or other group would like to obtain a copy of the film, contact your nearest OSHA Regional Office or the National Audiovisual Center, General Services Administration, Washington. D.C. 20409 (301-763-1891).
'
T
; i
The Cancer Alert Series consists of the follow ing titles:
More Than a Paycheck: An Introduction to Occupational Cancer
Health Hazards of...
Chromate Pigments and Paints: Hexavalent Chromium
Roofing Materials: Coal-Tar-Pitch and Asphalt
Asbestos
Benzene and Aromatic Amines
Inorganic Arsenic
To order copies, address your request to the OSHA Publications Office. U.S. Department of Labor, Room N3423, Washington, D.C. 20210, telephone 202-523-8677. FTS 8-523-8677.
:
-i
1 j
ft
TX GARRETT
RMC0000491
CB 2 as
I I
t TX GARRETT
.(9*9-110}) 8>60-Zi--008--T SOAiZ 'D "N 'UicqjnQ
jaaa^S * trV 002 93puag uoRtjuuojuj aa*uj asjnQ
:a ,
s
0 c 5
0 a'Ca>. ffl -u9 =* = O O a.
L
/
RMC0000492