Document jVBNb3D4zQ6gaL3D0xMYQXBy
HAR 2 C \
DANIEL S. CREENBAUM
WILLARD R. POPE Cencral Counsel March 16, 1990
0n&
S$*eet, @3a&an/ OS/OS
(^t!cce/ o^^eriexal^ouriAel, el. S9S -5SOS
frank Anthony, Vice President and General Counsel Bird, Incorporated ne Dedham Place PO BOX 1035
Westwood, Ma 02090-0008
Re:
Bird, Incorporated
Docket No. 87-09/
File AP-NE-87-704
Docket No. 87-33/
File AP-NE-87-714
Docket No. 87-16/
File AP-NE-87-705
Penalty worksheets______________________
Dear Mr. Anthony:
Please find enclosed the three penalty worksheets which are background to the Department's assessment of the above referenced penalties. It is my understanding that you did not receive copies of these at or after the informal pre-hearing conference held June 15, 1987.
Yours truly.
Lin Cheney Sasman Deputy General Counsel
cc: J. Belsky, T. Natario, B. Lampkin, J. MacAuley
u
004311
P0& ftp-//?-#?- jvft.
ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTY WORKSHEET AIR QUALITY 7.00
VIOLATOR^ LOCATION
DATE PREPARED BY K//Sa/^
DATE OF NON, IF APPLIC-AaBuLlEl.____________________ _______________________________ /KPS !//sr&dsfo} 310 CMR
VIOLATION CITED
GRAVITY COMPONENT 1. Base Number (range 100-25,000____________
.) 4
2. Actual Impact (+ or -) 3. Potential Impact (+ or -) A. No. and Extent of Violations (+ or -) 5. Total gravity base number (add #'s 1-4) 6. Number of days in Violation 0
A #<77?
3, <Z>6> --7-,-gag-
_Z_______
7. Total (multiply 5 .by 6)
`ADJUSTMENTS TO GRAVITY COMPONENT . 8. Good Faith Effort (+ or -) 0-502 . 9. History of Compliance (+) 0-502
f 7, avn <
* V __
sd z
Kj2SIS
10. Financial Condition (+ or -) 0-502
2
11. Public Interest (+ or -) 0-502
2
-\12. Special Circumstances (+ or -) 0-502 . 13. Total Precentage Adjustments (add #'s 8-12)
2<r 2 / 0/0 2
14. Multiply Line 7 by Line 13
/
_Z 1 2
ECONOMIC BENEEIT 15. Delayed Costs
'
/ 09/)
---------------------------- - 0 0 4 ?> 1, /l
16 Avoided Costs 17. Profits 18. Total Economic Benefit (add #'s 15-17)
t//A
/ /</;
19. TOTAL DOLLAR ADJUSTMENTS (add i 14and 18) ^3. 20. TOTAL PENALTY (add lines 7 and 19)
? D,--
REASON FOR PENALTY ASSESSMENT: Pattern of Noncompliance
------------- -
Continued or repeated Violation After NON
Willful Violation
Significant Impact .. ____ `______________
Failure to report H.W. Release
T.'.ri
r.'Mr ::~j
rrr
. -- *.**!**
0 0 4-313
r-.v '-'i-'sii
-------- Zissr:-..-.1-.-
%;
4)
____^ d.
-U<u4dt<?*--% fist-fcO-ffi-Jl--------------
---.
.. ^77^jrr&d'...
004314
ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTY WORKSHEET AIR QUALITY 7.00
VIOLATOR
Ut
J^<L
LOCCTXOK
DATE OF NON, IF APPLICABLE^
VIOLATION CITED,
IjJL
DATE PREPARED BY
310 cmr ax:T-Q?MJ'h 7./^
GRAVITY COMPONENT 1. Base Number (range 100-25,000
2. Actual Impact (+ or -)
3. Potential Impact (+ or -)
- 4. No. and Extent of Violations (+ or -)
5. Total gravity base number (add
1-4)
6. Number of days in Violation
7. Total (multiply 5 by 6)
> ^j, 5,oirg>_
lLri<r& A)
// MO- -
/
-- -- --
CD / LO^O
.
a
'adjustments to GRAVITY COMPONENT a. Good Faith Effort (+ or -) 0-502 . 9. History of Compliance (+) 0--502 10. Financial Condition (+ or -) 0-502
*>/?>*.; . i
___.
.t-
<7? 2
,/?s'
-- 2
--. ' 2
: --''-i"v ' j Vr*
_ -- >
11. Public Interest (+ or -) 0-502
l"'
t-12. ' Special Circumstances (+ or --) 0-502
'O Z .
2C ~L2) /13. Total Precentage Adjustments (add tf's 8-
"14. Multiply Line 7 by Line 13
njo.rtryt)?
--
> . / Z
, _ - , . * .---
ECONOMIC BENEEIT 15. Delayed Cosin
2. ' J) 0'4
16. Avoided Costs
17. Profits
IB. Total Economic Benefit (add #'s 15-17) 19. TOTAL DOLLAR ADJUSTMENTS (add t 14 and 18) 3-0/0$$
20. TOTAL PENALT! (add lines 7 and 19)
REASON FOR PENALTY ASSESSMENT: 1. Pattern of Noncompliance
1/,OOQ
/,o&<o
. PGrMO
l, MO
26,000
2. Continued or repeated Violation After NON
3.
*
. 4.
Villful Violation ' Significant Impact
5. Failure to report B.V. Release
REASONS FOR ADJUSTMENTS: $22
i
. cr^i- irJ--L-rr-^-
.*
`
'*
*. \
-Jv-4
i-.- --~-r-'.
* ' i."
l
ft
4l`
g
P
f
I
r-v-l
15
is
$
17,
I
g &
t
*' **?. '-
.
T
f
004317
` ----- *- - " ''. r . ................. .vurv:
.--: .i--r _ . --r * - r--
7* - &&
t J.s<&2>. v/^^r^g:=->i___________________
'K^^rA
/^v/~ ^ /?s7VZ-
vfa/Ji -
_____ ___ _____ _xJ. <tj_
-- '.--J --
--------------------------------------------------j-SZ^-ZZ
M 4 3-1-8-
JS 004319