Document jBVZERYRdR79qBKN5YN0MbrJQ

FILE NAME: Philip Carey (PC) DATE: 1960-1964 DOC#: PC015 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Worker's Comp Claims O O /?Y\5 v "~ ' s ^a-.m Number: Qp 117279_________ Name: V i l l i am E . L a t t o - C i n c i n n a t i _______ * Cost as of F e b ru a ry 1 , 1961____________________ Reserve: 0 _______________ Compensation: 0 __________ Medical: 0 Date oj Accident or Exposure: 7 /2 9 /6 0 ________ Age: 62______Occupation:A s b e s to s W orker Description of Accident or Exposure: By a p p ly in g a s b e s to s p r o d u c ts c o m m e rc ia lly f o r 5 years. Vature of In ju ry or Disease: A sb e s to sis HISTORY AND STATUS OF CLAIM T h is claim was f i l e d by th e c la im a n t, th ro u g h h is co u n sel,M r. Thomas P. lim an , on January 10, 1961. I t has been pending on in v e s tig a tio n and w ill be nsidered by th e A dm inistrator in the near fu tu re . The B u re a u 1s A c tu a r ia l D epartm ent w ould h av e b e e n j u s t i f i e d i n e s t a b l i s h i n g re s e rv e a g a in s t t h i s claim in th e amount o f $ 5 ,8 0 0 .0 0 . T h is how ever, th e y o v e roked, and we w i l l n o t c a l l t h i s to t h e i r a t t e n t i o n . f Control, an d verify your Workmen's and Unemployment Compensation Insurance costs JOHN^V CANTLON & ASSOCIATES. Inc. T.ONSUITING ACTUARIES Columbut. Ohio --------I-----3- o o Claim Number: OD-117279________Name: W illia m E. L a t t o ________________ Cost as of January 1 . 1962 ________ _ Reserve: 0________________Compensation: 0_________________ Medical: Q________________ Date of Accident or Exposure.Quit Work 7/2 9 /6 0 Age: 62 Occupation: A sbestos Worker Description of Accident or Exposure: Applying a s b e s to s p ro d u c ts com m ercially f o r 35 y ea rs Nature of Injury or Disease: A sb e s to sis. HISTORY AND STATUS OF CLAIM T h is claim was in v e s tig a te d by th e B ureau o f Workmen's Com pensation, and allowed f o r a s b e s to s is and permanent t o t a l d i s a b i l i t y a t a h e a rin g on ^ 2^ 24^ 1962^ Com pensation a t th e r a t e of $49*00 p e r week was o rd e re d p a id from Januar5T E t7"I96T ? On Jan u ary 1 , 1962, th e claim was pending on in v e s tig a tio n The B u re a u 's A c tu a r ia l D epartm ent th e r e f o r e , would have been j u s t i f i e d i n e s ta b l is h in g a r e s e r v e i n th e amount o f $5,800.00. T h is was overlooked by th e B u re a u 's A c tu a r ia l D epartm ent, and we w i l l n o t c a l l i t to t h e i r a t t e n t i o n . Control and verify your Workmen's and Unemployment Compcnsr4ipn Insurance costs il JOHN T. CANTLON & ASSOCIATES, Ine. S f CONSULTING ACTUARIES Colwmbv*, Ohio W tlliam B. l a t t o Cost as of Ja n u a ry ! .. 1961 ....... n Compensation: $ 2 3 .8 6 2 .0 0 Medical: $ 1 .1 3 8 .0 0 ___________ (lut# ,>/ Accident or Exposure: 7 /2 9 /6 0 __________ Age: 62 Occupation: A sb esto s Worker |; /VtfWpd'on of .Accident or Exposure: C laim an t worked a p p ly in g a s b e s to s p ro d u c t-q rntr<mp>rgially t op 35 y ears __________ __________________________________ __ Sature of Injury or Disease: A c W tn c i . HISTORY AND STATUS OF CLAIM 1 T h is c la im was allow ed by th e Bureau of Workmen's C om pensation, and th e c la im a n t vas d e c la re d perm anently and t o ta lly d isa b le d b eg in n in g on Jan u ary 11, 1961, Com pensation w ill be paid to th e claim ant f o r th e rem ainder of -his lif e tim e , and .robably upon h is d eath a death claim w ill be f ile d if th e re a re any su rv iv in g d ep en d en ts T h is y e a r you have b een ch arg ed $23,862*00 f o r c o m p e n s a tio n . We b e l i e v e t h e r e s a q u e s tio n c o n c e rn in g t h i s amount and we w i l l d i s c u s s i t w ith t h e B u reau an d k eep ou a d v ise d o f a n y d e v e lo p m e n ts. r\ Control and verify your W orkmen's ind U nem ploym ent Compensation Insurance costs JOHN T. CANIIORi' & ASSOCIATES, Inc CON.ITI* 0 ACTIMWM V, OSI fittm . Number: OP 117279_____ Name: W illiam E. L a tto - D ec'd Cost as of Ja n u ary I , 1964 Reserve: $0. Compensation: $17 ,4 0 0 .0 0 Medical: $ 2 ,6 2 6 .0 0 Date of Accident or Exposure: Q uit 7/29/60 Ape: 62_____Occupation: A sbestos Worker Description o fAccident or Exposure: By a p p ly in g a s b e s to s p ro d u c ts com m ercially f o r 35 y e a rs Nature of Injury or Disease: A sbestos i s *I HISTORY AND STATUS OP CLAIM I T h is claim was in v e s tig a te d and allow ed by th e Bureau o Workmen's Compensation, The c la im a n t q u it work on J u ly 29, 1960 and when h is claim was allow ed f o r perm anent t o t a l d i s a b i l i t y , com pensation a t a ra te of $49.00 p e r week was o rd ered paid beginning : on January 11, 1961. The claim ant died on February 22, 1964, A d e a th claim h as been f i l e d by th e widow b u t i s now pending on in v e s tig a tio n and h as n o t y e t been c o n s id e re d . The s t a t u s o f th e claim on Jan u ary 1, 1964, on w hich d a te Che d ec ed e n t was s t i l l liv in g and considered as permanently and to ta lly d isab led the sta tu s of th e claim ju s t if i e s a charge fo r compensation in th e amount of $17,400.00. T his charge i s c o rre c t then in accordance w ith th e ru le s and reg u latio n s o f th e B ureau's A ctu arial S ta ff. - The claim w ill be charged to th e m e rit-r a tin g ex p erien ce and premium r a te o f your company one more y e a r. T h e re a fte r, i t w ill drop o u t o f your m e rit-r a tin g experience and have no f u r t h e r e f f e c t upon th e premium r a t e . * Control and verify your Workmens and Unemployment Compensation Insurance costs JOHN;f. 0ANTLON &ASSOCIATES. Ine. CONSULTINO ACTUATES Cfll.mbw, Okl* * %* . Number: op 117279______Name: W illiam E. L a tt o , D e c 'd .__________ Cost as of Jan u ary 1, 1965______________________ Reserve : $11,000.00 Compensation: $ 8 ,7 4 0 ,0 0 _______Medical: $ 4 ,1 2 1 .0 0 __________ Date of Accident or Exposure: Q u it 7 /2 9 /6 0 Age: 62_____ Occupation: A sbestos Worker_____ Description of Accident or Exposure: A pplying a s b e s to s p ro d u c ts com m ercially f o r 35 y e a r s . 7ature of Injury or Disease: A sb e sto sis . HISTORY AND STATUS OP ClAIM rin g th e d e c e d e n t's lif e tim e he wes c o n sid e re d e s p erm an en tly and t o t a l l y d is a b le d sp inning on Ju ly 30, 1960. Compensation f o r perm anent t o t a l d i s a b i l i t y was p aid a t 49.00 p e r week through February 16, 1964, in th e amount o f $ 9 ,0 7 9 .Q 0 .. d e a th claim was f i l e d by th e d e c e d e n t's widow. T h is was in v e s ti g a te d and allo w ed 31lo v in g a h earin g on February 25, 1965. A d e a th claim in th e amount o f $16,000.00 is ordered paid. i Jan u ary 1, 196>, the d ate th e claim was review ed f o r re s e rv e purposes th e *d e a th .aim was p en d in g . The re s e rv e in th e amount o f $ 1 1 ,0 0 0 .0 0 i s th e r e f o r e c o r r e c t and i accordance w ith the ru les and reg u latio n s of th e B u reau 's A ctu arial D epartm ent. tis i s th e l a s t y e a r th e claim w ill be charged to th e company f o r m e r it - r a t in g rp o ses. In the fu tu re the cost w ill be charged back to th e y ear 1960 and w ill ve no e f f e c t upon the premium r a t e s . * n Control and verify yoxx Workmen's and Unemployment Compensation Insurance costs j JOHN T. CANTLON &ASSOCIATES. Ine. I CONSULTINO ACTUATES CriMbM. OfcW Bureau o f Workmen's Compensation Ohio Departzents Building - - > - -'.A'-i'. A ttention: S r. Paul Drugan . Be* O.D. 11727? ; ..< , -r.-yRoosi lilO-A . -.V '" - ' William Latto \ Gentleman: The above nnnbered claim has been re fo rre d t o th is D ivision f o r a statem ent re la tiv e to th e claim ant's exposure to asbestos and s ilic a dust u b ilo employed as an asboatos w orker. The ecployzeat record of , the claim ant as taken from the Xilo i s as follow s: . ' y i$2$ 1 1931 1933 - 19li2 191*2-1952 . 1952 - 1957 ? r :* Saith Paris C o., Youngstown ( Hot in Directory) Asbestos Service Co., Woodland, roun3stown . . RI. U-21U5 .dohns-Mansville Philips Carey Co. 4 - ~ ' ; :: r, _.* In h ia l a t t e r of October U, 1961, L. A. P ech stein , A ssista n t S ecre- ta r y , The P h ilip Carey Manufacturing Co., C in c in n a ti, Ohio, stakes the ` ` following atatenanti ,?i t ^ v , : .. ~ "During the period fo r which we s t i l l have records o f h is employ- nent with u s, the claimant was an applicator o f thermal in su la tio n . The m aterial was composed o f 355 magnesia and asbestos, f ib e r s , in the process of application, i t was neoesaary th a t the material be ' out or sawed, thus freeing an undeterwinate amount o f asb estos f ib e r and s i l i c a dust?. 'll,'- The amount of asbestos fibers in the thermal insulation is 155 :4 i' :4; p.* . A v i s i t was sade to the Asbestos Service Co., 120 S. Veodland, ' : Youngstown. This I s the f ira fo r which the e la isa n t in term itten tly worked from 1933 to 1X97Uu<2. Tmhaeyy stuatuead tuhnaset tmhe clxaaiumiaannut workxoeda wn iwth rFa<oggniwoa*ia coonntaining 155 aasbeastos one-half of hia time, md he wwoorked wwith calPLned. * V- W' ,/<.\f V . - . . ; ? :* . i * V * '* * *,*f . V c u-/.'/.* 'ty r *>V. >>'? * `` A > * O ____. .. u WVM^IBUaUbJkUn -2 - Jan u ary 22, 1962 diatonateoua e a rth , approxim ately 1 0 i o f h ia ti n e . Dlatomateoua e a rth ia a fo ra o f f r e e s i l i c a , which when c a lc in e d i a v e ry a c tiv e i n producing s i l l coal a. The m a te ria l which he handled cane in th e fo ra o f ahapea th a t could be f i t t e d around p ip e a . He would c u t th e ahapea w ith an unvented saw and be exposed to d u at in v is i b le q u a n itle a . ,.f >Yc The fo llo w in g i a quoted from a l e t t e r d ated November 6 , 1956, r e l a tiv e to C.D. 977U2, P aul U iegand, which c l a i a was allowed* The conpany was th e A sbestos S erv ice Cospanyt . v'- ; ; : '."The claim an t worked m ostly on b o i l e r in s t a U a t is n a and I t . ^ ^ _ is estim ated th a t he spent over 50 p er cent of h ia tin e in s ta ll- * --- ` ing in s u la tio n c o n ta in in g d ia te c a te o u s e a rth * T his m a te ria l . . .. 100 p e rc e n t s i l i c a end according to . the'company^ acst-' of:./'; ** v ' !' i t has been c a lc in e d . T his makes i t an a c tiv e fo rn o f a i l i c a . Axons o th e r th in g s , ho would aav th e blocks of in s u la tio n w ith <- / a hand-sav. I t i s co n d u ced th a t th e claim an t was exposed . r`.`t o s i l i c a du at in s i g n i f i c a n t q u a n t itie s w hile doing t h i s work. ' : ` ^ The rem ainder o f h ia tin e ho in s ta lle d in su la tio n ccspcsed :' o f ae b ea to s o r co n ta in in g a s b e s t o s * . . . . . . " - / * * v : -V4 rt v I f fu rth e r inform ation is needed in connection with th is claim , a p la n t in Ohio can be found where in s u la tio n i s being in s ta lle d and duat counts made. ^ i t i s believed th a t th e claim ant had .three years exposure to asb esto s an d /o r a i l i c a d u s t i n Chio, p a r t o f which was w ith in th e p a s t e ig h t y e a r s . . y o r/tru ly yours, * > De-Vitt Huffman I n d u s tr ia l Hygiene Snginser ' ffiinh - i i -ir . i ! !' ( .* j V*;: t i f *0 \ /*7t `a t- I -V*>.-- * |f *"V *'rv.-yV.f-i N,*.* . .. v*V, >f <:; I . mtnt and report jjme to the Bureau of Workmen's Compensation. This form O ll-i is to be used only in cases where the occupational disease causes a disability of MORE THAN ONE WEEK. It should be completed and signed by the disabled employee and his employer and mailed to the nearest office of the Bureau of Workmen's Compensation. Office addresses on reverse side of this application. Ago (r I ' PART X. STATE OF OHIO B u r e a u o f W o r k m e n 's C o m p e n s a t i o n Claimant's Report of Occupational D isease Claim No. O . D ..li7 _ 2 7 9 / D pR dM II <>t Location |C k L CLAIMANT'S n a m b! V fT T I lTJl llln t) 2. Homo Address- J. 2 2 (Numberl Ha.on S t . (S tree t) 3. Ato__ 62- -iecurity ,298-10-2163 E. (M iddle la lttsl) 'warren. (CUr) .Employer:___ P h l l l n J atto_ (Last) .T rum bull. (County) (Sute) C rY 1-1>V. C o. Dsto Report ri // o Dato of Discs 7 -- Rtpoif Log OeenysK. Asbestos Worker (Welder, etn) _No. and relationship of dependents:---- A sh e sto sis, Pulm onary, w ith sev ere f ib r o s is , / (r. L H oofing Lag. 4. From what dlststa art you nff.rinf > / c y s t i c f o m a t i o n s and c h r o n i c i n f l o w s t l n n ____ 5. What parts of tha body art *( l 'iny.3 Give datt your symptoms first appeared :zL/5 2 -- Name of employer when symptoms a p p ea r td j? h illp --C a n sy Peysnoru Lac J4fg* Cn. -- long in employ of this employtr before symptoms Erst appeared: c ' 1n t i n u o u s l ' f . Location of plant where you worked, when disability began: *0utL'3 to w n . H a h o n in g Cou n t y ....... / (County and CUy) 7 When were symptoms first reported to p i 0 " o r a b o u t A n r i l 1 . l-iS.t? ------- 2. Describe exactly how you were exposed to the substance, which, in your opinion caused your disease:--bjf-- npp lsH tvr nVyt.ns p r o d u c t s c o m e r c i a l l v f o r 1 5 y e a r s . Occupano in Exportaeo 9. Give name and address of physician who f6ir}sf/ddUiagnosed your disease as being occupational..and date diagnosis VfavnW B a r d i n - -21 il,. '. i c k l i f f C i r c l e , f o u n d s tow n, O hio , j j ______ 10. Have yon previously suffered from the disease for which this application is made, or any other occupational Ko rr go, give details (dates of attacks, name and address o f physiciaa). 1L Date quit work:__JnT v 2 0 r 1 C 6 0 .F or what b egan m ed ical checkings.. 12. Oats returned' to work:. -Type of >> - 1 1 Occupation wtraji disability g,? A s b e s t o s W orker Whan A p p lica tio n A sb esto s m aterials^ _ work (a) immediately prior to onset of ymptmnt_ c o n t i n u o u s l y <M During n r .n m .. IS years - __Type of work yon were doing Length'of time la this type of .1 14k W ere yon exposed to dost in your work}__ _ -T ype o f dnstl ,l `KgLAHS.yia t,&l?&. T T S S t ? ,! . Describe briefly how yon were exposed: \ff, .S h a p in g & a P P lY ta f. FflgnLPSfrfflLJ&pdnete- glaee r~r\, wnnl - rilatomaccous e a rth , e tc . Over oliai periods were yon exposed la your employment?. c S i l t ! PU.QU.8jjt. Agency (Dlsoos / c '/ / Agency Port Typo ol Duooj M olato o l Dito. ,) Part at Seer ',7ia <AS y- Putt WOfO Data o f lest exposure to dnstt July 39.. I 960 Avorogo We** IS, I f you were esposed to the snbstance which allegedly caused this disease in other employments, give the names sad addresses o f tha other employers, and dates of employments:-- $r*pT.9V.?Cg - - jsn l.t& JjlaiA S - n* t iM n . i q ? 1-1011: A sbestos S e r v ic e C o ... Youngstown. Ohio ly sT r-iy h O . S a m H l I . Cn. and P h i l i p C a re v C o . 1QI.2-1C60._____________ 16 H m yipa filed * pfi t i oM application conccnuof this or an? other occupational d istu t? . U to l i f t claim number: - ..... -- ------- g ^ ?- I f gNnlag this application I w pw l f o i ift. on boholl ol arN lI 4 ol tar pono who shall baso oar taierest ta this tota, i IDhgroo ol DUa i l ptortiloai ol law fwMddhf any phyiktaa or othos poroon who has heretofore attended of examined mo. or who htaaitov attend or oicomlao na from dlsctosmy oar* knowledge or latormattoa which Ih*f thereby teotufU. t haoo m d oil tho iuio* Mats ofUaiiMd hoooia and know tho mow to ho tra on* correct. I hereby authoriso tho Borooa ol Workmen's Compensa* tto* to pay tar amounts wh*h msy ho awarded ditto la tho possono rettoria a u s im pnfsuat la ttua appttcatloa lot pay* 7 aaoat il ol tho Stato Oompaiaeaoft Disosso JToad. Doys Isoot (U applicant sisas hr mark two witnesses.mint S is hart.) (Signature ol ip p u ^ a a c u unabletourn. markmust bon u d e.) r Street aAir-- O > " City or Town-. -i_________ f ^ V 1 part o . Employer's Report of Occupational D isease received L Name of ~"T1**y**~~ (Nana as ibsum on rerW Seete) 2. Office sddrtss:- (N um bert (SCra.il (CUM tftu t Nature o f b c sln m :. (fannliif. coot mlalnC. oto) -T yp e o f organisation:- ( W ... (C<>yajarynyu. Ii^.icu li 4* Tha ttin in p of tha iojurtd employee lor senrieta rendered at time o f occupat"ion w i i * b* | r ^ / Ca*M k r / MSAIMt h o /s s i/ r  d idiicm i oi claimant/.. ,.I not, indicato the points o{ disagreement:. g. The following is a statement of wages earned each week by the injured employeeduring the period of one year immdiate! to date of disability .. J_U.XX_2.6.f-- , 1953. *" --- -- JUilY 31 , l: Show total earnings--Make no deductions (or For week ending Amount oi_ ^serntftgs -'-'during week _ 7 /2b/8q 16.00 6 /2/89 186,00 : 8 /o /sq liOo 5 /i6 A q . 1F O 0 . ^ 23/89 186.00 . 6/30/39-- 186.00 3 h a ________ l i S O o 9 /1 3 / 3 9 liOS - 0/20/39_______ lob.00 9 /9 7 /5 0 .- 1 8 6 . 0 0 iQ/sb... 186.00 10/11750 186.00 m/iP/j Q 186.00 1 0 /9 5 / 5 0 ______ 1 8 6 .0 0 11/l'Aq- V 72.00 n /fi/co 381 .30 T1 /1 5 ^ 5 0 1/48.80 - n / 99/t;a 186.00 p /?o/n 186.00 1 oV/cQ _ 80 1 9/90 /cq 37 .8o .8 n Social Security, Mo. days employed during week 6 8 _. .. 6 8 8 8 8 A 8 8 8 8 8 8 7 7 A 8 8 7 . 7 7 Old Age Pensions, Insurance or Unemployment Compensation. =3H*s= s= s = = s= = For week Amount oi earnings---- No. d employ ending jjuMfrR-veek during> 8 /8/60 '^126.70 --- ___ 8/22/60 136.80 A . 3/29/60 171.00 8 6 A / 6O . liob A - 6 / V 60 171.00 8 fi/l.o/fio____ 102.6b 3 6/20/60______ 7/3/60. - 136.80 . it 179-.00 * 5 .7/10/60 V 7/17/60 18?.60 ii 191.00 / 7/ 91/60 7/11/60 191.00 191.00 _. ,- r 8 These wares wf re~earned 1n West1 Virr.inla until 8/116/60 from which ' rnt:f t'ho wtifwq t.f/no poiviM -in Ssnnr vsnia. . ~ *i ,, . . f\St r, n - nn. .... ___pr.1 . n 7 '-6 / A L - f. a- 1 DIA M-I+. v*ov*lr r sr> floravr 4*1 above__ pov4rut.4; vrwwV ending 9./8/60-______ i . 1 9l I f m eals, lodging, tips, e tc , were received in addition to w ages, describe and atate weekly value ,4-Q f.9 .9 . 10, W m employee receive wages o f meals and lodging daring period o f d.ahn;ty? Indicate what part, it any; 11. I f employee did not work on any days during the period ihow n on W age Report (Item 6 ). stato reasons: (Personal, plant i t down, ocher injuries, illness, tie .)--------- -----------------... .....-- --------- - .............. ......... .. . B y signing below, I do hereby certify that Xhave authority to exacuU this Employer's Report end that the answers to the que Mona given in said report are correct to the bast of my information and belief. B y signing ride report the employer certifies tk this is a valid -isip ,, requests that compensation be paid claimant forthwith and w aives notice o f receipt o f claim aa w ell as notice order o f compensation from the Bataan o f Workmen's Compensation Adm inistrator aa provided in & C. 4 U U U -U 3 . This claimant was not included in our Ohio Reports but was included in our reports to West Virginia and Pennsyl vania . , -- (N ta t oi jMnoa tienine npoett (Official till o t person tie n in e anti Ids departm ent) The Philip Carey Manufacturing Co.yor_ Oame at employer aa hewn, on Imurature CertMeate) !1. 1 Bureau Offices ! lkron__ ________ 807 United Bldg. i-og" ______ K E. Main St I j 2anton__ ____SOI Market Avenue S. Mansfield____ .405 Farmers Bank Bldg. !.. Cincinnati 4t Duttenhoier Bldg. Martins Ferry. --Cor. 4th St Walnut Sts. Cleveland. _L4K Superior Avenue, W. Portsmouth--. ____ 102 Masonic Temple Columbus. Dayton Su m Office Bldr. _____ 3rd A Jefferson Sta. Springfield. Toledo-- ---- i l E. High Street . SOB Richardson Bldg - Hamilton. ess Rentschler Bldg, Youngstown--, ot Realty Bldg. 11-- ano Colonial Bldg. ZsaesviUe-- . - ras Masonic Bldg. O ; . -- *> * r> , BoTMbtr H, I960 R r. T htM i P, Wellaan A ttorney ate Law 103 3 . Park At* , V u m , Ohio VOHXJd'S C0RPR3SATI03 OCCUPATI03AL DI33A3B (A0BS3703Z3) CLAIM - WILLIAM 3 , U ? ? 0 , 1073 1*303 0 ?. 13333, OHIO Bear Hr, W allsast Hr. R isto baa forwarded your l a t t a r of Cotobor 27, Rr. Lattoa l a t t a r o f October 27, to g eth e r a i t i two ooplas o f Qla la a n t 1a Raport o f Osenpatlonal Disease req u irin g oar ecsplotlen and os*a t ion o f P art I I , fo r f i l i n g w ith th e Cbio Bureau o f Wo r i so n 's Compensation. I t la the polloy of oar oospany to os s lo t caployoe* la obtain in s 07917 W ortoaa'a Compensation b e n e fit to rhioh they aro e n title d * Th* pollo y a p p lie s p a r tic u la r ly t o H r. L atto dio h u baan a lia s te and lo y a l employs f o r ran y years* Th*r e f e r , wo a ro oonoernsd o ra r tb a fo o t t h a t tb* arcings o f Hr* L atto t a r a n o t boon r a p o rtad on o a r pay r o l l re p o rts ' t o Ohio* I f th* o la la la flla d la Ohio, o ar anawar to question It, Part XI, would b ara to bo n asatiro * u nless th ere la sea* re c ip ro c ity between Ohio and West V irg in ia o r Ohio and PanaaylTaala, wonder whether th e Ohio Barsau weald deny J u ris d ic tio n and lia b ility * Whilo Hr* L atto re s id e s la Ohio, be was h ire d and c o n tro lle d by oar P ittsb u rg h O ffloo, end has worked la ro eeat years only In Vaste V irg in ia o r Pennsylvania* Follow leg Bale XZIIZ o f th e Ohio S ta te Workmen's Compensation Ins tra n c e Fasd Mancai, we hare reported and paid aa followst 1957 through 1959 West V irginia Week ondlng 5/3 /6 0 * 5/16/60 threogh 7/29/60. Pennsylvania Hr. Them P. tfollaaa IJow*bcr l;, I960 Pa 1. Ueat V irg in ia , o f c o u rse , is a oapkl-ra e ta t* and v* paid in to i t s S ta te Insurance P n td , m Pennsylvania, wo o rs priTvfcdlj insured w ith Psm aylvsnia ihnafaatnrers* Aaaoeiatico Casualty Ssstrsi&xs' Ccapany (P o lic y no FC 09523) to tsaca wo rep o rt o u r Fam sylvania. pay w l l aod P*7 proud,cam ao o crd icg ly . Up, I a t t o nvA o u r Company had no a u tc a l ag rseaen t to bo botaad by th e tfcris*en*s Compensation Last o f a ry p a r tic u la r a ta t Hr L a tto 'a l a t t e r in d ic a te s th a t bo f i r s t n o tlf lo d th e Ccarazy o f h la c o n d itio n l a A pril 1959 w hile worsting l a West V irg in ia . Bo became dlaablod l a J o l7 , 196a u h ils working la Pw oasylvsnla. Z b e lie v e wo h a t had no aaboatools o la la a l a Boot V irg in ia , and I do n o t know tbo p rovisions o f I t s laws* However, wo know th a t endor th o Pennsylvania Ooenpatlccal D isease Act offe e t Its January 30, I960, compensation fo r o llla e a la , onthraeo*. s i l i c o s i s o r a s b e e to s is la payable c a ly when I t la chem t h a t th o employee bee aggregated a t l e a s t tQtro years employment l a P w a sylvania daring a period of tan years cozt preceding d is a b ility l a oa occupation hawing a a l l l e a o r aeboatoa fcaaard Ocr raoords a t C ln sln a a tl do n o t go back ton y e a rs , b a t Sir Bioko oaa h e lp you w ith records ca f il e a t Pittsburgh Please do n o t h e s i t a t e to ask f o r fu rth e r I n f c r s s tic n . By ee ry h e re o f, we a r e asking o ar a o tc a rla a a t Coluabus to f a m is h any advise they have Ve w i l l h o ld b o th eoplea o f th e Claimant? a Report u n t i l th e b e s t procedure h a s been d e to m 1 .. % / Sincerely, \ . v 'V L A P echstein A sslsteat Secretary '> \ eat John T . O estlm A. P . Slake - Pittsburgh w riH J --*ir-KrMENT OF INVESTIGATION Colum bus REPORT OP INVESTIGATION i No. * ZTSL__________________ if Vfill i a n E. l a t t o . 170 L au rie Drive , _____ Ormond Bea c h . F lo rid a ______ S. S. N o .______22&nl23&3-------------------------- Employer The r h l l i o Care? Hanufacturln g Co. . Lockland t A d d re s s _____C in c in n a ti 15. Ohio_________ ; Industrial Commission of Ohio, *suant to instructions, the above numbered claim has been made the subject of an investigation and swing report relative to same is herewith submitted: Date Dictated...f?.r? .7.dlL . o this report,4~ ? ., ,,Dates of iv*ngatinn V arious.... .......... - Date Transcribed._4r..2.Ir^ - ition covered following mattara? General Investigation -- ...... .... -- ----- ----- . ( K m ((* M a i m M a m u u M l t a n * m n 4 k , U nM iiM U a.)*1 I I Fora OD-L has been file d by the claimant on which he s ta te s be is ; from a lung condition which is the re s u lt of an occupational disease d in the course of his employment with the named employer. That his f worked was July 29, i 960. 1 The employer has submitted a l e t t e r in which they state th a t a fte r I :laimant did not work fo r then in Ohio. That hs worked e ith er in. Hest | here we reported and paid, or Pennsylvania where they were privately d paid premiums accordingly. They fu rth e r sta te s th a t from 1957 to I > the claimant worked in Vfest Virginia and from May 16, i 960 through \ 560 ha worked in Pennsylvania. They further sta te they had no mutual ; with the claimant to be bound by the 'dbrkmen's Compensation Law of any 1 s ta te . The employer has submitted wages from January 1 1953 to July Tbs claimant in his a ffid a v it sta te s th at he has been a resident e < Ohio continuously from 1915 to date. That from 1915 to 19&3 he snt of Youngstown, Ohio, and from 19U3 to date he has been e resident j WLo . The claimant fu rth e r sta te s th at he f i r s t started working in the da in 1925 when he sta rte d working fo r the Smith P aris Company, Ohio and remained in th e ir employ u n til 1931. That he then became the Asbestos Service Company, Youngstown, Ohio in 1933 and remained Lay u n til 19h2. That the work pefformed fo r these two employers 1 exclusively in Ohio. The claimant further states th a t in 19U2 u n til 1952 he was employed ansvilla Company and since 1952 lias been employed by the Philip Carey Company. The claimant furth e r states th a t in 1950 to 1952 the vast majority is performed in Ohio. That i n '1953 approximately JOwaaks were spent 1 195b approximately UO weeks were spent in Ohio* Hs fu rth e r states^ a spent'the en tire year in Ohio. ' Ha"further sta te s th a t from late'* Spring of 1956 he worked exclusively in*Ohio. However, there uere not working due to lack of work. ?he claimant further sta te s th at his la s t exposure in Ohio occurred - Steel Corporation, Youngstown, Ohio in 1957. ora C-19 has been completed by Dr. Hardin and i s attached. Dr. Hardin copy of the Pathology Report which i s attachad giving the diagnosis pulmonary, with severe fib ro s is , cystic formations and chronic inilarnof the x-ray interpretations have been obtained and are attached along ha hospital records. 2> Iavmnigatot or D*pviy. ffttCIOSOKESt Original File , ....... C-19 - Dr. Hardin C-16 - North Side Hospital Copy o f h o s p ita l records. C-17 - Dr. Ben.S. Brown J- C -l? - Dr. D.W. M etcalf *.. . C-105 - VaHiaai E. L atto ' ...................\ Pathology Report L e tte r from Hardin L e tte r from Qaployer's A ctuaries L e tte r from the esployer to Attorney nellaan Copy o f claim an t's ages f r m 1-1-53 t o 7t31-^. l e t t e r from th e Employer, L e tte r from th e Claimant ' ; ~ ^ ` T * i* :i *$, _ i j STATE OF OHIO B u r e a u o f W o r k m e n 's C o m p e n s a t io n CLAIMS SECTION No> U7279J3D Name ______________________ __ I78 Laurie Drive Onaond Beach, Florida The P h i U p Care/ lfg. Co. Lockland Cincinnati 15, Ohio NOTICE OF HEARING Sieraan, Sicman t Sieaum, Att73. 705 Union Savings & Trust Bldg. Warren, Ohio John T. Cantlon & Assoc.,Inc. 40 W.Third Ave. Columbus 1, Ohio You are hereby notified that the above numbered claim will be for hearing at the office of The Bureau of Workmen's Compen* 1102 R ealty Building sation R e a rin g Root City of Youngstown, Ohio, on t h e ^ ^ M " S i ^ ,, d a y of .. . ...jg.______ l _ t 1 9 J ? . a t .. .2:Q0.........nVW k , . P-____ M. This notice is sent you for your information in case you desire to be present. You will not be reimbursed for expense incurred in coming to this hearing, unless a subpoena has been, issued for your attendance. However, if it is possible for you to appear, you may be able to furnish information which would be of assistance in deciding the questions involved, Question: ALLOWANCE OF CLAIM - OCCUPATIONAL DISEASE. PJDlAMC Kay 3,1962 \< k Your8#truly, BUREAU OF WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION ~ nnsirT riitmi iminlitnrnr R efera ..jx ila a E. L atto SbM tud ^ 178 la u rl D rlva ^aaaQ gai,, fiorida. ' BUcal and No___Lfiddg& d .- Cilt---- Cincinnati 15r PMa is) X' .Claim NowOJ)___ 2i 7?j[2L3 - - D a l . oI Disability 7-&9-4Q--- ---- l a s t lnj.axposura 9-23~5 * -- Manual 1 8 1*? ------- 16& ^ FtHDINGS o r FACTS AND MBTOTES ' O s this day lhia claim waa b t t m tha Buraau aad fiadiags a s d oxdwa w a r. mad* a* follow That th cbava namad em ploy.. I C in b M bacwtca o t tba contraction, la th a cnuro o< hta B ptorm m t, t W oepaoul O teasa aa OaaerttMfi la R. C. 123.. a t tha Uma aa d ia th a m anner aU oftd in th a appUcattoa. ntfi^O ltaaaa *mp<aarw * " " tha tlm a a t th a cantractton o t said acoupatlonal Oiaaaaa. a subscriber to tha s tate Occupa- That ata sm plorcc a t tb a Uma o t M ating into th a amploymant (com which s a i d -------- ___ ><____ n a u tte d did not wtUUUy and t ^ l g raprcaant blmaaU aa not having pcavtoualy suSacad tram such diseases 1- 11- 61- J cS w \y Matala AodUac--In nhisna egaaathae naaaswClilmtal 1Varan. Bs TdblsO fCT : for ClaimantPaul Burns.AttT. ' ' ~ Ptataat for Employ John T . CantIo n & Assoclataa Zt is the flading of tha Administrator that statutory requiresmuta ars satisfied herein risdioticn of this elala involving ashestosis, a disease of th* respiratory tractcontracted * of occupational injurious exposure to dust containing asbestos, and that because o f said claimant is totally disabled. It Is therefore ordered that the claim be allowed aad . atloa be granted for permanent total disability from 7-30-60 to date - aad continue suspension until future facte warrant the stopping of payment! that neeeasaxy medical pital care* because of the aebesteelsgbe authorised and bills for same be paid per fee ~ ` " That the sot of $35#00 heretofore paid out of the Surplus Fund to Dr.F.G.Kravic, for ':* at review and report, be now credited to said fund and charged as a coat of tha claim.