Document jB9N5mnkBXpYzDXO0bV98nVRQ

DownloadSearchable PDFRandom document
Ross v. Conoco, et al. CMA Privilege Log Revised -- December 22, 1997 Bates Range Date(s) Document Type Author 004307- 04/23/80 CMA Interoffice Memorandum 004310 J.T. Seawell (CMA Project Administrator, Vinyl Chloride) 004412 12/06/79 CMA Interoffice Memorandum J.T. Seawell (CMA Project Administrator, Vinyl Chloride) Addressee David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Edmund Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Description Report prepared in response to counsel's request for information regarding corporate participation in Vinyl Chloride Project Panel Request for legal advice regarding draft summary of research conducted by independent contractor Privilege Copies Attorney Client Privilege ("A/C") (Affirmed by Case Master's 10/18/95 ruling) 010770-010773; 013739-013742; 21355-21358; 100590-100593; 100719-100722; 141596-141599; 148359- 148370 (copies submitted for Case Master's in-camera inspection) A/C (Affirmed by Case Master's 10/18/95 ruling) 004121; 100826; 100833; 148372- 148373 (copies submitted for Case Master's in-camera inspection) Bates Range 004436 Date(s) Document Type 05/31/79 CMA Interoffice Memorandum Author J.T. Seawell (CMA Project Administrator, Vinyl Chloride) 014543- 09/11/86 Letter 014544 Has Shah; Gabrielle Williamson, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Edmund Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Vinyl Chloride Special Programs Panel Description Privilege Copies Request for legal advice regarding funds being held in reserve from independent contractor Legal advice of counsel regarding statutory obligations stemming from research reports prepared by independent contractors A/C (Affirmed by Case Master's 10/18/95 ruling) A/C (Affirmed by Case Master's 10/18/95 ruling) 001291; 101994; 148381- 148382 (copies submitted for Case Master's in-camera inspection) 148397-148398 (copy submitted for Case Master's in camera inspection) 020511- 11/04/94 Memorandum 020515 031666- 11/01/82 Letter 031667 W. Caffey Norman, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Chloride Panel) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 031689- 09/30/82 Letter OS 1690 031691- 09/29/82 CMA Interoffice Memorandum OS 1692 David F, Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 031697 03/03/83 Letter Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Vinyl Chloride Panel Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Legal advice of counsel regarding options available to vinyl chloride manufacturers in addressing Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry test rule Legal advice of counsel regarding proposed answers to interrogatories Mark Travis (Aetna) David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Dick Stoll, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Ron Green, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Letter to CMA insurer regarding pending litigation and insurance coverage issues Legal advice of counsel regarding pending litigation and insurance coverage issues Request for legal advice of counsel regarding discovery responses, litigation strategy, and insurance coverage A1C A/C, Attorney Work Product ("W/P") (joint defense) A/C, W/P (joint defense) A/C, W/P A1C, W/P 115617-115621 2- - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 031eSS- 01/28/83 Letter OS 1699 034095- 06/12/79 Memorandum 034096 Author Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Don Evans, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) cc: Berry St. John, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Dr. Jay Young (CMA staff) cc: E.B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) D.F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) G.V. Cox; J.C. Zercher (CMA staff) Description Legal advice of counsel regarding response to request for production Legal advice of counsel regarding revision of policies dealing with Transportation Incident Cards (CMA 156213-14 and CMA 034095-96 contain different handwritten notes) Privilege A/C, W/P (joint defense) A/C Copies 156211-156212, 156213-156214 034139, 06/12/79 Memorandum 159710 037136 01/11/77 CMA Board of Directors Meeting Minutes Don Evans, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) George E. Best (Secretary-Treasurer, CMA) Dr. Jay Young (CMA staff) CMA Board of Directors Legal advice of counsel regarding revision of policies dealing with Transportation Incident Cards Summary of report by counsel to CMA Board of Directors regarding settlement strategy in lawsuit against CMA A/C A/C, W/P 159709 (copy of the first page of the document) 037579 09/12/78 CMA Board of Directors Meeting Minutes 037590- 09/12/78 Attachment to CMA Board of 037591 Directors Meeting Minutes Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (Acting Secretary-Treasurer, CMA) 038215 06/06/84 General Counsel's Report David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) CMA Board of Directors CMA Board of Directors CMA Board of Directors Summary of report of CMA General Counsel to CMA Board of Directors regarding labeling of chemicals Summary of legal advice of CMA General Counsel to CMA Board of Directors regarding labeling of chemicals Legal advice of CMA General Counsel to CMA Board of Directors regarding CMA's legal strategy in pending litigation and regulatory proceedings (attached to minutes of CMA Board of Directors meeting of 6/6/84) A/C A/C A/C, W/P 071851 071862-071863 074734 3- - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 038896 04/08/74 CMA Executive Committee Meeting Minutes Author George E. Best (Secretary-Treasurer, CMA) 038938 09/12/78 CMA Executive Committee Meeting Minutes 042408 02/11/75 CMA Executive Committee Meeting Minutes Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (Acting Secretary-Treasurer, CMA) George E. Best (Secretary-Treasurer, CMA) 044163 09/08/80 Attachment to CMA Executive Committee Meeting Minutes 044403- 03/06/85 Attachment to CMA Executive 044404 Committee Meeting Minutes 044504 09/08- CMA Board of Directors 09/80 Meeting Minutes 044736 046752 09/0809/80 Undated Attachment to CMA Board of Directors Meeting Minutes Handwritten Notes 046754- 05/04/79 Memorandum 046755 Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA Secretary) Don Evans, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Dr. Jay Young (CMA staff) Addressee CMA Executive Committee CMA Executive Committee CMA Executive Committee CMA Executive Committee CMA Executive Committee CMA Board of Directors CMA Board of Directors Don Evans, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: E.B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) G.V. Cox; J.C. Zercher (CMA staff) Description Privilege Summary of report and advice of CMA's outside counsel (Symington) regarding CMA participation in petition for judicial review of EPA effluent guidelines for inorganic chemicals A/C, W/P Summary of report of CMA General Counsel and staff recommendation to CMA Executive Committee regarding chemical labeling A/C Summary of legal advice of CMA outside counsel (Cutler and Pickering) to CMA Executive Committee regarding possible legal ramifications of claims in lawsuit A/C, W/P Summary of legal advice of CMA's outside counsel regarding CMA publications A/C Legal advice of CMA counsel to CMA Executive Committee regarding liability issues for chemical emergency response program A/C Summary of legal advice of CMA's General Counsel regarding legislation and litigation strategy A/C Summary of legal advice of CMA's outside counsel regarding CMA publications A/C Notes of counsel in connection with request for legal advice regarding CMA safety publications A/C Information provided in connection with request for legal advice of counsel regarding revision of policies dealing with Transportation Incident Cards (CMA 156215-16 contains handwritten notes) (advice provided in document CMA 034095-96, CMA 156211-12 and CMA 156213-14) A/C Copies 061729 062088 061790 072824 065365-065366 072592 062826 156215-156216 4- - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 047060- 10/12/82 Letter and Memorandum 047072 Author Edmund Frost, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) 053803- 05/14/75 Memorandum 053808 061975 01/10/78 CMA Executive Committee Meeting Minutes Wilmer, Cutler & Pickering (Outside Counsel to CMA) and Legal Advisory Committee George E. Best (Secretary-Treasurer, CMA) 062324- 03/13/79 Attachment to CMA Executive 062325 Committee Meeting Minutes Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) 062423062424 063791063792 05/08/79 01/13/92 Memorandum Attachment to CMA Executive Committee Meeting Minutes Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Dell Perelman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 064777 03/08/83 General Counsel's Report David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) 072247 11/19/79 General Counsel's Report Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Addressee R.A. Roland (CMA President) cc: D. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) CMA Board of Directors CMA Executive Committee Description Transmittal note from CMA General Counsel recommending potential use, and forwarding copy, of memorandum prepared by outside counsel regarding compensation legislation Legal advice of counsel regarding advocacy before governmental bodies Privilege A1C A/C CMA Executive Committee CMA Executive Committee CMA Finance Committee CMA Executive Committee CMA Executive Committee CMA Executive Committee CMA Board of Directors Summary of legal advice of Legal Advisory Committee and outside counsel to CMA Executive Committee regarding settlement strategy in lawsuit against CMA A/C, W/P Summary of legal advice of CMA General Counsel regarding litigation strategy (attached to minutes ofjoint meeting of CMA Executive Committee and CMA Finance Committee of 03/13/79) A/C, W/P Legal advice of CMA General Counsel regarding CMA Safety Data Sheets A/C Memorandum prepared by CMA staff counsel regarding subpoenas served on CMA (attached to minutes of CMA Executive Committee meeting of 01/13/92) A/C, W/P Report and analysis of CMA General Counsel to CMA Executive Committee regarding brief filed by opposing party and legal ramifications of pending litigation (attached to minutes of CMA Executive Committee of 03/08/83) A/C, W/P Report of CMA General Counsel to CMA Board of Directors regarding litigation strategy and CMA participation in pending lawsuit challenging sulphur dioxide monitoring requirements (attached to minutes of CMA Board of Directors meeting of 11/19/79) A/C, W/P 5- - Copies 061828061833; 139373-139377; 140347-140352 Bates Range 074283 Date(s) Document Type 09/13/83 General Counsel's Report Author David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) 077047- 01/14/92 Attachment to CMA Board of 077048 Directors Meeting Minutes Dell Perelman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 110322- 02/06/95 Letter 110323 Carol Moors Toth, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Chloride Transportation Committee) 111092- 07/18/95 Letter 111094 111137- 06/06/96 Letter 111138 111204 12/05/95 Letter 111638 03/25/97 Memorandum Carol Moors Toth, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Chloride Transportation Committee) Carol Moors Toth, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Chloride Transportation Committee) Terrence D, Jones, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Chloride Transportation Committee) Carol Moors Toth, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Chloride Transportation Committee) Addressee CMA Board of Directors CMA Board of Directors Hasmukh Shah (Manager, Vinyl Chloride Panel) cc: Peter de la Cruz, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Chloride Transportation Committee) Hasmukh Shah (Manager, Vinyl Chloride Panel) Description Privilege Report of CMA General Counsel to CMA Board of Directors regarding outside counsel's analysis of pending litigation challenging EPA general pretreatment regulations (attached to minutes of CMA Board of Directors meeting of 09/13/83) Memorandum prepared by CMA staff counsel regarding subpoenas served on CMA (attached to minutes of CMA Board of Directors of 01/14/92) Legal advice of and request for information by outside counsel regarding transportation of Vinyl Chloride A1C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C Legal advice and analysis of outside counsel regarding petition to modify transportation regulation A/C, W/P Hasmukh Shah (Manager, Vinyl Chloride Panel) cc: Steven K. Russell, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Hasmukh Shah (Manager, Vinyl Chloride Transportation Committee) Legal advice of outside counsel regarding legal A/C, W/P challenge to administrative rule Legal advice of outside counsel regarding implications of agency response to petition seeking new rule A1C, W/P Wendy Sherman (Manager, Vinyl Chloride Transportation Committee) Legal advice of outside counsel regarding CMA publication (CMA 112493 contains handwritten notes) A/C Copies 112493 6- - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 112028- 09/03/92 Letter 112029 112194- 112199; 112216112239 03/23/97 Letters, memoranda and notes on draft video scripts 115845 02/23/96 Letter Author S, Craig Tautfest, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Chloride Transportation Committee) CMA member companies W. Caffey Norman, III, Esq. (Outside Counsel) 117865 117870 117875 117880117881 117886 117891 117896 117901 117906 117911 117916 117921 117928 117930 117932 117935117936 117941 118931118932 118937 11/14/96 07/24/96 05/16/96 04/23/96 02/05/96 11/22/95 10/06/95 08/04/95 07/06/95 05/12/95 03/03/95 02/07/95 06/30/93 09/21/93 02/23/94 12/15/94 02/07/95 05/07/97 02/06/97 Statements of Services, Memoranda of Services Patton Boggs, L.L.P. (Outside Counsel) Addressee Hasmukh Shah (CMA staff) cc: Robert Ondocsin, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Hasmukh Shah (Manager, Vinyl Chloride Panel) Description Legal advice of outside counsel regarding implications of court ruling Privilege A/C Legal advice and comments of staff counsel of A/C CMA member companies regarding draft video scripts relating to vinyl chloride Hasmukh Shah (Manager, Vinyl Chloride Panel) CMA Legal advice of outside counsel regarding vinyl chloride risk assessment A/C Summaries, prepared by outside counsel, of A/C legal services and advice provided to Chemstar Vinyl Chloride Panel Copies 7- - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 121595- 12/13/96 Letter 121599 156042- 04/20/77 Legal Memorandum and 156086 Attachments 156195- 10/12/82 Memorandum and Lists 156207 159712- 06/04/76 Memorandum 159783 159798 08/04/76 Letter 159799- 07/29/76 Memorandum 159812 159813, 09/03/76 Letter and Cover 159814 Memorandum Author Peter L. de la Cruz, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Institute) James C. Langdon, Jr., Esq. Courtenay Ellis, Esq. (Both Outside Counsel to the American Petroleum Institute ("API")) Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Wilmer, Cutler & Pickering (Outside Counsel to CMA) Daniel Marcus, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Wilmer, Cutler & Pickering (Outside Counsel to CMA) and the CMA Legal Advisory Committee Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee James W. Kachtick (Occidental Chemical Corporation) cc: Greg Rutman, Esq., Larry Thomas, John Maguire, H. Patrick Toner, Lewis R. Freeman, Jr., Robert H. Burnett, Frank E. Borrelli Stark Ritchie, Esq. (API General Counsel) David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) CMA Legal Advisory Committee Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Edwin J. Putzell, Esq. CMA Executive Committee and CMA Board of Directors CMA Legal Advisory Committee Description Legal analysis of outside counsel regarding petition to change Vinyl Chloride regulation Privilege A/C, W/P (joint defense) Copies Legal advice of API outside counsel regarding potential liability issues raised by API activities A/C, W/P Transmittal memorandum from CMA outside counsel discussing, and forwarding copies of, draft lists prepared by outside counsel of issues raised by proposed compensation legislation A1C Legal advice of CMA outside counsel to CMA Legal Advisory Committee regarding CMA publications (this document is a draft version of document CMA 159940-160010) A/C Transmittal letter from CMA outside counsel discussing and forwarding document CMA 159799-159812 A/C Memorandum prepared by CMA outside counsel and CMA Legal Advisory Committee summarizing legal advice of outside counsel regarding CMA publications (legal advice is contained in document CMA 159712-83) A/C Transmittal letter from Legal Advisory Committee discussing and forwarding document CMA 159815-159828 (same document as CMA 159799-159812) and cover memorandum A/C 159784-159797; 159815-159828; 159845-159858 159844 (same document as 159814) 8- - Bates Range 159869 Date(s) Document Type 10/28/76 MCA Interoffice Memorandum Author Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 159870- 06/22/78 Letter 159871 Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 159872- 09/25/78 Letter and Memorandum 159908 John H. Pickering, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) 159909- 10/20/78 Letter and Memorandum 159913 Conrad S. Kent, Esq. Director, Law Dept. Stauffer Chemical Company 159919- 04/04/79 Letter and Memorandum 159926 159928- 04/13/79 Memorandum 159929 Andrew T.A, Macdonald, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Addressee File cc: George E. Best Albert C. Clark William J. Driver Edward J. Klecka Victor H. Peterson William M. Stover (All CMA staff) Barbara E. Bergman, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Edmund B. Frost, Esq, (CMA General Counsel) Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Description Summary of legal advice of CMA outside counsel regarding revision of CMA Safety Data Sheets Privilege A/C Request for legal advice of CMA outside counsel regarding CMA publications, and information provided in connection with request (advice provided in document CMA 159873-159908) Transmittal letter from CMA outside counsel to CMA General Counsel discussing and forwarding copy of memorandum setting forth legal advice of CMA outside counsel with respect to CMA publications Transmittal letter from inhouse counsel of CMA member company to CMA General Counsel discussing and forwarding memorandum prepared by inhouse counsel regarding labeling of chemicals and CMA Safety Data Sheets Transmittal letter forwarding copy of memorandum prepared by outside counsel setting forth legal advice regarding labeling of chemicals and CMA Safety Data Sheets Summary of legal advice of outside counsel regarding CMA publications and handwritten notes A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C Copies 159930-159931 9- - Bates Range Date<s) Document Type 159932- 06/14/79 CMA Interoffice Memorandum 159933 Author Dr. Jay A. Young (CMA staff) 159934- 10/06/80 CMA Interoffice Memorandum 159935 Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) 159940160010 170645 08/02/76 03/17/92 Memorandum Memorandum Wilmer, Cutler & Pickering (Outside Counsel to CMA) Robert D. Ondocsin, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Donald D. Evans, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: G. V. Cox J. C. Zercher (CMA staff) E. B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) D. F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) CMA staff CMA Legal Advisory Committee Has C. Shah and Elizabeth J. Moran (CMA staff) cc: David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Donald D. Evans, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Kathy D. Bailey, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Langley A. Spurlock (CMA staff) Description Privilege Summary of legal advice of counsel regarding A1C revision of policies dealing with Transportation Incident Cards Legal advice of CMA General Counsel regarding procedures for responding to requests for information received by CMA Legal advice of CMA outside counsel regarding CMA publications Memorandum regarding preparation for depositions A/C A/C A/C, W/P 170646- 07/23/82 Memorandum 648 170649- 11/17/64 Legal Memorandum 667 David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Fowler, Leva, Hawes & Symington (CMA Outside Counsel) CMA Special Programs Project Administrators CMA Memorandum regarding guidelines and procedures for the protection of confidential information Legal memorandum regarding possible legal implications of CMA's Chem-Card program A/C, W/P A/C, W/P Copies 033714 - 10 - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170668- 12/31/79 Letter and attachment 730 Author Gary H. Baise, Esq. (Outside Counsel for The Vinyl Institute) Addressee Roger P. Batchelor, Jr. (Diamond Shamrock Corporation) Description Letter regarding enclosed draft memorandum discussing reference documents cited by EPA to support its airborne carcinogen policy Privilege W/P (joint defense) Copies WORK PRODUCT FILES Vassar v. Air Products Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170476-517 06/27/95 Letter and attachments 170518-520 01/08/95 Letter Author Addressee Description Claudia Wilson Frost, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA and other Co-Defendants) Walter Conrad, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA and other Co-Defendants) Robert Butler, Esq., J. Thomas Deal, Esq., Donald D. Evans, Esq., Carol R. Geiger, Esq., Theodore E. Laslo, Jr., Esq., DeWayne Layfield, Esq., Mary K. McLemore, Esq., Thomas A. Miller, Esq., Robert H. Sand, Esq., Barry J. Shainman, Esq. and A. Richard Winchester, Esq. (In-house Counsel for Joint Defense Group) cc: David J. Hanna, Esq. (Outside Counsel for Co-Defendant) Letter and enclosed legal memoranda prepared to defend a vinyl chloride medical monitoring class action Robert Butler, Esq., J. Thomas Deal, Esq., Donald D. Evans, Esq., Gary A. Garfield, Esq., Carol R. Geiger, Esq., Theodore E. Laslo, Jr., Esq., Mary K. McLemore, Esq., Christi D. Quinn, Esq., Robert H. Sand, Esq., Barry J. Shainman, Esq. and Richard Winchester, Esq. (In-house Counsel for Joint Defense Group) cc: David J. Hanna, Esq. (Outside Counsel for Co-Defendant) Letter of counsel regarding status of lawsuit Privilege A/C, W/P Identical Copies A/C, W/P - 11 - Bates Range 156816 Date(s) Document Type 03/17/87 Letter Author Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) 170521 08/08/85 Letter Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) 170522 07/30/85 Letter Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) 170523-543 08/01/85 Transmittal note and memorandum Arthur F. Sampson, Esq. (Outside Counsel for API) NRDC v. EPA Addressee Kathy Bailey, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Albert J. Beveridge, Esq. (Outside Counsel for the Vinyl Institute) cc: Fredric P. Andes, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Arthur F. Sampson, Esq. (Outside Counsel for API) cc: Fredric P. Andes, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Martha Beaucamp. Esq. (API staff counsel) Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) cc: Fredric P. Andes, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Martha Beaucamp. Esq. (API staff counsel) Description Correspondence from CMA outside counsel to CMA's in-house counsel regarding enclosed brief Correspondence between counsel for aligned parties regarding enclosed draft brief Reason for With holding A/C, W/P Identical Copies W/P (joint defense) Correspondence between counsel for aligned parties regarding enclosed draft brief W/P (joint defense) Legal memorandum regarding jurisdictional arguments of respondents in NRDC v. EPA W/P (joint defense) - 12 - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170544-545 06/28/85 Letter Author Peter L. de la Cruz, Esq. (Outside Counsel for The Vinyl Insitiute) 170546-547 07/17/85 Letter Arthur F. Sampson, Esq. (Outside Counsel for API) 170548-549 Notes 170550-557 11/06/87 Memorandum 170558 03/19/87 Letter Robert M. Sussman, Esq. William K, Rawson, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA Panel) Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) 170559 04/01/87 Letter Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) Addressee Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) cc: Arthur F. Sampson, Esq. (Outside Counsel for API) Fredric P. Andes, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Stark Ritchie, Esq. Martha Beaucamp, Esq. (API staff counsel) Robert Brager, Esq. (Outside Counsel for The Vinyl Institute) Charles E. O'Connell Thomas J. McGrath Roy T. Gottesman, Ph.D. Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) cc: Martha Beaucamp, Esq. (API staff counsel) Fred P. Andes, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) CMA Butadiene Program Panel Description Correspondence between counsel for aligned parties regarding status of NRDC v. EPA litigation Reason for With holding W/P (joint defense) Identical Copies Correspondence between counsel for aligned parties regarding legal memorandum on legislative history of relevant statutory provision W/P (joint defense) Handwritten notes of CMA staff counsel Draft memorandum regarding decision in NRDC v. EPA W/P A/C, W/P Arthur F. Sampson, Esq. (Outside Counsel for API) Kathy Bailey, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Kathy Bailey, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Letter enclosing draft outline for amicus brief in vinyl chloride litigation A/C, W/P (joint defense) Letter enclosing drafts of brief for vinyl chloride litigation A/C, W/P - 13 - Bates Range 170560-561 Date(s) Document Type Notes Author Addressee Description Handwritten notes of CMA staff counsel Reason for With holding W/P Identical Copies 170563-574 12/02/86 Memorandum 170587-595 11/09/87 Memorandum 170596-604 07/31/87 Memorandum 170626 11/04/86 Letter 170627 06/26/85 Letter 170628 03/11 Notes 170629 03/25 Notes 170642-644 06/25/85 Memorandum Neil J. King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) Robert M. Sussman, Esq. William K. Rawson, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA Panel) Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) Neil Jay King, Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) Neil Jay King. Esq. (Outside Counsel for CMA) William P. Gulledge Alice R. Mayer (CMA staff) Fredric P. Andes, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Donald D. Evans, Esq. and Fredric P. Andes, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) CMA Butadiene Program Panel Legal memorandum analyzing vinyl chloride decision A/C, W/P Legal memorandum analyzing legal implications of decision in vinyl chloride litigation A/C, W/P 170575-586, 170614-625, 170630-641 CMA Donald D. Evans, Esq. Fredric P. Andes, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Peter L. de la Cruz, Esq. (Outside Counsel for The Vinyl Institute) cc: Fredric P. Andes, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Environmental Management Committee Legal memorandum analyzing legal implications of decision in vinyl chloride litigation Letter analyzing decision in vinyl chloride litigation A/C, W/P A/C, W/P 170605-613 Letter between counsel for aligned parties W/P analvzine leeal issue in NRDC v. EPA (joint defense) Handwritten notes of CMA staff counsel reflecting legal analysis regarding brief in vinyl chloride litigation Handwritten notes of CMA staff counsel reflecting proposed legal strategy of aligned party Memorandum setting forth suggested legal strategy regarding vinyl chloride litigation W/P W/P A/C, W/P 007543-007545; 101737-101739 - 14 - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170913-914 09/04/87 Letter Author Gary H. Baise (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Institute) Addressee Description Peter de la Cruz, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Vinyl Institute) Letter between counsel for aligned parties analyzing EPA reaction to decision in vinyl chloride litigation Reason for With holding A/C, W/P (joint defense) Identical Copies Arnstein v. MCA Bates Range 156622-623 Date(s) Document Type 08/26/76 Letter 170776-777 12/16/76 Letter 170778 03/16/76 Letter 170779 02/25/76 Letter 170780 03/03/76 Letter Author Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Addressee Daniel Mayers, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) cc: Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Daniel Mayers, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) cc: Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Daniel Mayers, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) cc: Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Daniel Mayers, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) cc: Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Description Letter enclosing copies of court order and filed pleading and analyzing same Letter enclosing invoices for legal services rendered and discussing settlement issues Letter enclosing copies of court order and filed pleading and analyzing same Letter enclosing copies of filed pleadings and analyzing same Letter enclosing copies of filed pleading and analyzing same Privilege A/C, W/P A1C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P Identical Copies - 15 - Bates Range 170781-782 Date(s) 02/16/76 Document Type Letter 170783 Note 170784-786 02/04/76 Note and attachment 170787-788 01/22/78 Note and attachment Author Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Description Privilege Daniel Mayers, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel cc: Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) W. Driver (CMA President) G. Best (CMA staff) W, Driver (CMA President) G. Best (CMA staff) W. Driver (CMA President) G. Best (CMA staff) Letter enclosing copies of filed pleadings and analyzing same Handwritten note regarding answer filed in case Handwritten attorney notes regarding attached letter from outside counsel enclosing copy of order entered in case and analyzing same Handwritten attorney note regarding attached letter from outside counsel enclosing copies of filed pleading and analyzing same A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P 170789-790 01/14/76 Note and attachment Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) W. Driver (CMA President) G. Best (CMA staff) Handwritten attorney notes enclosing letter from outside counsel analyzing settlement issues A/C, W/P 170791 01/02/76 Letter Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Daniel Mayers, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) cc: Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Letter analyzing enclosed copy of a filed pleading A/C, W/P 170792-799 07/22/76 Memorandum 170800-896 04/18/75 Memorandum and attachments Kenneth D. Johnson (CMA staff) A.C. Clark (CMA staff) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Memorandum analyzing opinions of opposing expert witness Memorandum and attachments regarding information requested by counsel relating to Amstein litigation A/C, W/P A/C, W/P Identical Copies - 16 - Bates Range 170897-899 Date(s) 02/06/75 Document Type Memorandum and attachments 170900-907 02/05/75 Memorandum and attachments 170908-909 02/03/75 Memorandum 170910 01/28/77 Letter 170911-912 02/18/77 Letter Author A.C. Clark (CMA staff) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Best, Clark, Klecka, Peterson, Stover and Campbell (CMA staff) cc: W. Driver (CMA President) J.G. Tritech (CMA staff) cc: A.C. Clark (CMA staff) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) W. Driver (CMA President) G. Best (CMA staff) Description Memorandum and attachments regarding information requested by counsel relating to Amstein litigation Memorandum and attachments regarding information requested by counsel relating to Amstein litigation Memorandum analyzing issues relating to insurance coverage Letter enclosing copies of court order and filed pleadings and analyzing same Handwritten attorney notes regarding attached letter from outside counsel analyzing issues relating to settlement Privilege A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P 170915-921 02/09/76 Letter and attachment 170731-739 04/04/75 Memorandum and attachments 170740-743 04/04/75 Memorandum and attachments Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Daniel Mayers, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) cc: Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Best, Clark, Klecka, Peterson, Stover and Campbell (CMA staff) cc: W, Driver (CMA President) Best, Clark, Klecka, Peterson, Stover and Campbell (CMA staff) cc: W. Driver (CMA President) Draff answer and accompanying transmittal A/C, W/P letter Memorandum from counsel requesting information relating to Amstein v. MCA litigation and responses to same A/C, W/P Memorandum from counsel requesting information relating to Amstein v. MCA litigation and responses to same A/C, W/P Identical Copies - 17 - Bates Range 170744-758 Date(s) Document Type 02/14/75 Letter and attachments Author Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 170759 02/05/75 Letter Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Alan J. Davis, Esq, (CMA Outside Counsel) cc: Daniel K. Mayers (CMA Outside Counsel) Alan J. Davis, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) cc: Daniel K. Mayers (CMA Outside Counsel) Description Letter and attachments providing information requested by outside counsel regarding defense of Amstein litigation Privilege A/C, W/P Letter providing information requested by outside counsel regarding defense of Amstein litigation A/C, W/P 170760-761 02/05/75 Memorandum 170762 02/07/75 Memorandum 170763-765 02/06/75 Memorandum and attachments 170766-772 02/06/75 Memorandum and attachments 170773 02/11/75 Memorandum 170774-775 02/10/75 Memorandum Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) William M. Stover (CMA staff) A.C. Clark (CMA staff) Robert . Vamerin (CMA staff) E.J. Kiecka (CMA staff) M.V. Campbell (CMA staff) Best, Clark, Kiecka, Peterson, Stover and Campbell (CMA staff) cc: W. Driver (CMA President) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Bruce M, Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Victor H. Peterson (CMA staff) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Memorandum from counsel analyzing A/C, W/P alienations in Amstein litigation requesting information regarding same Memorandum responding to request from counsel for information regarding defense of Amstein litigation Memorandum responding to request from counsel for information regarding defense of Amstein litigation Memorandum responding to request from counsel for information regarding defense of Amstein litigation Memorandum responding to request from counsel for information regarding defense of Amstein litigation Memorandum responding to request from counsel for information regarding defense of Amstein litigation A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P Identical Copies - 18 - Bates Range 158546-548 Date(s) Document Type 07/12/76 Letter 158549-552 List 158649 07/08/76 Letter Arcell v. Ashland Author Shanley & Fisher (Outside Counsel to CMA) K.D. Johnson (CMA staff) Bruce M. Barackman, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Dr. Kenneth Johnson ~ Robert A. Boutillier, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Description Handwritten note attaching letter regarding information provided to outside counsel in Arcell v. Ashland litigation List of exhibits assembled for possible submission in response to request to produce documents Letter regarding publications for the Arcell case Reason for Withholding A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A1C, W/P Identical Copies Waldrop v. Vistron Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170000-015 08/20/80 Letter and attachment 170016 08/08/80 Letter Author Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Draft response to interrogatories and A/C, W/P document production request; report of counsel regarding same Peter R. Agnew, Bruce M. Barackman, John S. Beale, Albert C. Clark, Geraldine V. Cox, Wayne H. Harrington, Gary C. Herrman, George W. Ingle, Victor H. Peterson, Hugh M. Robinson, Hasmukh C. Shah, James N. Sites, Gordon D. Strickland, William M. Stover, John C. Zercher (All CMA staff) Request of counsel for information responsive to interrogatories A/C, W/P - 19 - Bates Range 170017 Date(s) Document Type 08/11/80 Memorandum 070018 08/11/80 Memorandum 170019 08/12/80 Memorandum 170020-034 08/06/80 Letter 170035 170036 07/14/80 Letter 07/14/80 Letter 170037-042 07/09/80 Letter Author Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) 170043-044 06/27/80 Letter 170045-047 06/27/80 Letter 170048-065 06/18/80 Letter Memorandum Charles S. McCowan, Esq. (Outside Counsel of Co-Defendant) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Addressee Geraldine Cox (CMA staff) Vic Peterson (CMA staff) Bill Stover (CMA staff) Patrick C. Joyce (CMA staff counsel) David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St, John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) cc: Marshall Pearlman Benton Leach Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) cc: David Zoll, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Request of counsel for information responsive to interrogatories Request of counsel for information responsive to interrogatories Request of counsel for information responsive to interrogatories Legal advice of counsel regarding proper scope of discovery and responses to interrogatories Legal advice of counsel regarding response to interrogatories Discussion regarding potential expert witness in related litigation A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P Letter setting forth legal advice of outside counsel regarding plaintiffs counsel's solicitation of clients and enclosing legal memorandum regarding attorney-client joint defense privilege Request of counsel for legal advice and assistance in related litigation A/C, W/P W/P (joint defense) Response to counsel's request for information in support of legal argument Report and analysis of counsel regarding jurisdictional defense A/C, W/P A/C, W/P - 20 - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170066-068 06/11/80 Letter 170069-071 06/03/80 Letter Author Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) 170072-073 05/05/80 Letter 170074-088 11/18/80 Letter and attachment 170089 11/14/80 Memorandum 170090-093 11/10/80 Letter and attachment 170094-095 11/07/80 Letter Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressees cc: J. Berry St. John, Esq., Member representatives of the CMA Vinyl Chloride Special Projects Panel, Member representatives of the CMA Acrylonitrile Special Projects Panel, Dr. Geraldine V. Cox, CMA Vice President - Technical, Dr, Hasmukh C. Shah, Director, CMA Special Projects David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Peter Agnew (CMA staff) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) bcc: Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Report of counsel of legal strategy and request for information in support of legal argument Report of counsel regarding plaintiffs legal claims against defendants and funding of litigation Request of counsel for technical assistance in support of defense of lawsuit Draft opposition to plaintiffs' motion for order compelling discovery, and legal advice of counsel regarding response to opposing counsel's motion Legal advice of counsel and request for assistance regarding ascertaining limits of insurance coverages Draft affidavit of insurance claim representative and legal advice of counsel regarding same Report and analysis of counsel regarding appellate court's ruling in related proceeding A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C,W/P A/C, W/P A/C,W/P A/C, W/P (joint defense) A/C, W/P - 21 - Bates Range Date($) Document Type 170096*097 10/31/80 Letter 170098-109 10/31/80 Letter and attachment Author Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) 170110 10/30/80 Letter 170111 10/21/80 Letter Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) James W. Greer (Claims Representative of CMA's Insurer) 170112-122 10/16/80 Memorandum 170123 10/13/80 Letter 170124-135 10/17/80 Letter and attachment 170136-137 10/15/80 Memorandum Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Daniel Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) cc: Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Legal advice of counsel regarding filing of answers and objections to interrogatories and request for production Draft objections to interrogatories and request for production; consultation between joint defense counsel 'regarding same A/C, W/P A/C, W/P (joint defense) Waldron v. Vistron Mailing List Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Berry St, John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Dan Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) BerTy St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) cc: Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Report and analysis of counsel regarding unauthorized pleading filed with court A/C, W/P Communication with counsel regarding A/C, W/P insurance coverage for lawsuit Legal analysis of counsel regarding unauthorized answer filed by attorney as "General Appearance" A/C, W/P Communication between joint defense A/C, W/P counsel regarding filing of pleading (joint defense) Draft motion to withdraw appearance and memorandum in support thereof; legal advice of counsel regarding same A/C, W/P Report and analysis of counsel regarding unauthorized appearance and pleading A/C, W/P - 22 - Bates Range 170138 Date(s) Document Type 09/26/80 Phone Message 170140 09/26/80 Letter 170141 09/05/80 Letter 170142-144 08/04/81 Letter and attachment 170145 170146 08/04/81 Memorandum 07/31/81 Memorandum 170147 07/31/81 Letter Author Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) James W. Greer (Claims Representative of CMA's Insurer) cc: Peter Agnew (Controller, CMA) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) James W. Greer (Claims Representative of CMA's Insurer) cc: Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Report of communication from claims representative of CMA's insurer regarding insurance coverage for lawsuit Communication by counsel regarding information in support of claim for insurance coverage for lawsuit Legal advice of counsel regarding depositions and implications of related litigation Letter forwarding legal bills regarding defense of lawsuit A/C, W/P (joint defense) A1C, W/P (joint defense) A/C, W/P A/C, W/P WaldroD v. Vistron Mailing List R. Roland, B. Barackman, G. Cox, D. Carroll, J. Sites, H. Shah, C. Stack (All CMA staff) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Report of counsel regarding status of litigation Report and analysis of counsel regarding status of litigation Report of counsel regarding future joint defense planning A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P - 23 - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170148-150 07/29/81 Letter and attachment Author Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) 170151 07/28/81 Letter Joe B. Norman, Esq, (CMA's Outside Counsel) 170152 06/30/81 Letter and attachment Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) 170153-154 06/22/81 Memorandum 170155-156 06/10/81 Letter Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) 170157 06/08/81 Letter 170158 06/02/81 Letter 170159-161 05/29/81 Letter 170162 06/04/81 Letter Patrick C, Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Joe B. Norman (CMA's Outside Counsel) Bruce Barackman, Esq. (CMA V.P. and Secretary) James W. Greer (Claims Representative of CMA's Insurer) cc: Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Berry St, John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Draft pleading and report by counsel of communications with insurance claims representative regarding potential legal defenses Analysis of counsel regarding reply memorandum filed by opposing party Communication by counsel regarding enclosed draft reply memorandum and revision of same Report and analysis of counsel regarding facts of case and legal strategy in same Report of counsel regarding firm billing practices Report of counsel's research regarding answers to plaintiffs interrogatories Legal advice of counsel regarding recent court decision Report of counsel's research regarding evidentiary issue Legal advice of counsel regarding objections to plaintiffs interrogatories A/C, W/P (joint defense) A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C,W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P - 24 - Bates Range 170163 Date(s) Document Type 06/01/81 Letter Author Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 170164-167 05/15/81 Letter and attachment 170168-169 03/10/81 Letter 170170-177 03/18/81 Letter 170178 01/06/81 Letter 170179-185 12/30/80 Letter and attachment 170186-191 12/19/80 Letter 170192 12/29/80 Letter 170193 12/02/80 Letter John L. Oberdorfer, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) cc: Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Bruce Barackman, Esq. (CMA V.P. and Secretary) Gloria Sodaro, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Ed Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Berry St. John (CMA's Outside Counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) James W. Greer (Claims Representative, Aetna) cc: Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Waldron v. Vistron Mailing List Carol Stack (CMA Vinyl Chloride Program Administrator) Communication with counsel regarding A/C, W/P designated witness at hearing on motion Legal advice of counsel regarding court litigation of market dominance regulations and memorandum summarizing legal research regarding appeal from ICC decision Legal advice of counsel regarding response to plaintiffs interrogatories A/C, W/P A/C, W/P Draff supplemental response to plaintiffs interrogatories and letter regarding same Analysis of counsel regarding codefendant's motion for summary judgement Letter forwarding legal bills regarding defense of lawsuit A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A1C, W/P Legal advice of counsel regarding service of process Report of counsel regarding status of litigation Analysis and report of counsel regarding status and funding of litigation A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P - 25 - Bates Range 170194-195 Date(s) Document Type 11/24/80 Letter Author Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) 170196 11/21/80 Letter 170197-198 11/20/80 Letter Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) James W. Greer (Claims Representative, Aetna) 170199 11/17/80 Letter 170200-275 Memorandum James W. Greer (Claims Representative, Aetna) J.T. Seawell (CMA Vinyl Chloride Project Administrator) 170276-86 Report 170299-315 08/25/80 Letter and attachment J.T. Seawell (CMA Vinyl Chloride Project Administrator) J. Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Huntington T. Block (CMA's insurance broker) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Dan Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Analysis and report of counsel regarding disposition of motion to withdraw and motion to compel discovery Analysis of counsel regarding appellate brief filed by co-defendant .Report to counsel setting forth insurer's willingness to defend CMA's interests, but reserving right to decline coverage and withdraw from defense A/C, W/P A/C, W/P A/C, W/P Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Report to counsel regarding defense of A/C, W/P suit and insurance policy limits Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Report prepared at request of counsel regarding technical support for litigation strategy W/P, A/C Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Report prepared at request of counsel regarding technical support for litigation strategy Draft discovery response and analysis of counsel regarding same W/P, A/C A/C, W/P 170238-275 (without handwritten notation); 170437-474 (signed copy) 170287-298 - 26 - Bates Range 170316 Date($) Document Type Author 08/16/80 Letter Charles S. McCowan, Jr., Esq. (Outside Counsel to Co-Defendant) 170317 170318 05/23/80 Letter 09/20/83 Letter 170324 08/06/81 Letter 170325-336 09/26/80 Letter with attachment Edmund B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) J.N. Chett (Claims Manager of CMA's Insurer) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 170337-338 11/30/83 Letter 170339 11/28/83 Letter 170340 11/08/83 Letter James E. Coleman, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Robert W. Frantz, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies J. Berry St. John, Jr., Esq. Allen R. Fontenot, Esq. Roger Frttchie, Esq. David Robinson, Esq. Harry McCall, Jr., Esq. (Counsel to Co-Defendants) J, Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) James Greer (Claims Representative for CMA's Insurer) cc: Patrick Agnew (Controller, CMA) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Robert W. Frantz, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Robert W. Frantz, Esq, (CMA staff counsel) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Correspondence between counsel with aligned interests regarding related litigation matter A/C, W/P (joint defense) Letter enclosing requested information ^relating to litigation Letter to counsel regarding legal strategy in response to discovery requests Legal advice of counsel regarding strategy of opposing counsel A/C, W/P W/P, A/C (joint defense) A/C, W/P Follow up correspondence regarding CMA's insurance coverage A/C, W/P (joint defense) Legal advice of counsel regarding response to subpoena Legal advice of counsel regarding scope of discovery Letter to counsel regarding legal strategy in response to plaintiff's deposition notice and document request A/C, W/P A/C, W/P (joint defense) A/C, W/P (joint defense) - 27 - Bates Range 170341 Date(s) Document Type Author 10/14/83 Letter Richard P. Oatmanm, Esq. (Assistant Claim Counsel for CMA's Insurer) 170342 10/14/83 Letter 170343-344 10/12/83 Memorandum 170345-347 08/26/83 Letter 170348-350 07/18/83 Letter and attachment Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq, (CMA staff counsel) Jacqueline A, Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 170351 06/30/83 Letter 170352-353 05/25/83 Letter 170354-356 02/21/83 Letter 170357 01/24/83 Letter Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Daniel R, Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: J. N. Chett (Claims Manager of CMA's Insurer) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Robert W. Frantz, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Richard P. Oatman, Esq. (Assistant Claim Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) bcc: Aetna Life & Casualty (CMA's Insurer) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Response to counsel's letter regarding insurance coverage and attaching document A/C, W/P (joint defense) Legal advice of counsel regarding possible notice of deposition including 'handwritten notes A/C, W/P (joint defense) Report and analysis of counsel regarding legal work undertaken in connection with lawsuit A/C, W/P Legal opinion of counsel regarding client's participation in joint defense of lawsuit A/C, W/P (joint defense) Draft discovery responses and legal opinion of counsel regarding discovery responses and proposed legal strategy in defense of lawsuit A/C, W/P (joint defense) Request from counsel for information responsive to interrogatories and regarding trial witnesses A/C, W/P (joint defense) Report of counsel regarding discovery A/C, W/P and identification of defense witnesses (joint defense) Legal advice of counsel and request for comments regarding discovery strategy A/C, W/P (joint defense) Legal advice of counsel regarding response to discovery request A/C, W/P J 031663031665 - 28 - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170358-359 10/21/82 Letter Author Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) 170360 10/08/82 Letter 170361-362 09/21/82 Letter Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) C. William Bradley, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Co-Defendant) 170363 06/22/82 Letter Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Charles S. McCowan, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Co- Defendant) cc: Paul H. Spaht Roger M. Fritchie David W. Robinson Harry McCall, Jr., Esq. John E. Cox, Esq. (Counsel to Co-Defendants) J. Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Request of counsel for advice regarding response to interrogatories and technical information in support of defense A/C, W/P (joint defense) Request of counsel for information in A1C, W/P support of defense (joint defense) . Legal advice from counsel regarding expert witnesses A/C, W/P (joint defense) Report of counsel regarding case status A/C, W/P and request for information to support (joint defense) defense - 29 - Bates Range 170365 Date(s) Document Type Author 06/28/82 Letter Charles S. McCowan, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Co-Defendant) 170367-368 01/22/82 Letter and attachment 170368.1368.2 11/12/81 Letter 170369-370 10/28/81 Letter 170371-373 09/22/81 Letter and attachment Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Paul H. Spaht, Esq. Harry McCall, Esq. Roger M. Fritchie, Esq. John E. Cox, Esq, William S. Penick David W. Robinson, Esq. (Counsel to Co-Defendants) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA's Insurer) cc: Gayle Sanders Fred Dovell Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) James W. Greer (Claims Representative for CMA's Insurer) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Joe B. Norman (CMA's Outside Counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) James W. Greer (Claims Representative for CMA's Insurer) Legal advice of counsel regarding deposition strategy W/P (joint defense) Letter forwarding legal bill regarding defense of lawsuit A/C, W/P (joint defense) Legal advice from counsel regarding order ofjudgment and legal strategy regarding appeal of same Legal advice from counsel regarding standards governing appeal from judgment A/C, W/P A/C, W/P Letter forwarding legal bill regarding defense of lawsuit A/C, W/P (joint defense) Bates Range 170374 Date(s) Document Type 08/10/81 Letter Author Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) 170375 08/06/81 Letter 170376-379 170380 Handwritten notes on pleading 11/03/83 Letter 170381-383 07/18/83 Letter and attachment 170384 01/16/84 Letter 170385 11/22/83 Letter 170386-387 10/28/81 Letter 170388 08/14/80 Memorandum Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Jacqueline A. Simmons, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq, (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Robert W. Frantz, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) A.C. Clark (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) cc: Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) James Greer (Claims Representative of CMA's Insurer) Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Legal advice of counsel regarding draft pleading and coordination of joint defense A/C, W/P (joint defense) Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Request of counsel for information regarding allegations of case A/C, W/P (joint defense) Handwritten attorney marginalia reflecting potential responses to motion to compel W/P (joint defense) Robert W. Frantz, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Legal advice of counsel regarding deposition strategy A/C, W/P (joint defense) Daniel R. Atkinson, Esq. (Counsel for CMA's Insurer) Draft discovery responses and opinion of counsel regarding proposed legal strategy in defense of lawsuit A/C, W/P (joint defense) Robert W. Frantz, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Report by counsel regarding status of A/C, W/P case and settlement negotiations (joint defense) Jim Coleman, Esq. (Outside Counsel to CMA) Summary of legal strategy taken in defense of lawsuit A/C, W/P (joint defense) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Joe B. Norman, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) Legal advice of counsel regarding standards governing appeal from judgment A/C, W/P Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Results of research in regard to request A/C, W/P by counsel for information responsive to discovery requests 031694031696 - 31 - Bates Range 170389 Date(s) Document Type 08/12/80 Memorandum 170390-391 08/14/80 Memorandum 170392-393 08/08/80 Memorandum 170394 08/08/80 Memorandum 170395 06/26/80 Letter Author Hugh M. Robinson (CMA staff) Kurt Sanford (CMA staff) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) David W. Robinson, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Co-Defendant) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Results of research in regard to request A/C, W/P by counsel for information responsive to discovery requests Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Results of research in regard to request A/C, W/P by counsel for information responsive to discovery requests Peter R. Agnew, Bruce M. Barackman, John S. Beale, Albert C. Clark, Geraldine V. Cox, Wayne H. Harrington, Gary C. Herman, George W. Ingle, Victor H. Peterson, Hugh M. Robinson, Hasmukh C. Shah, James N. Sites, Gordon D. Strickland, William M. Stover, John C. Zercher (All CMA staff) -Request by counsel for information responsive to discovery requests and handwritten notes in response to same A/C, W/P Peter R. Agnew, Bruce M. Barackman, John S. Beale, Albert C. Clark, Geraldine v. Cox, Wayne H. Harrington, Gary C. Henman, George W. Ingle, Victor H. Peterson, Hugh M. Robinson, Hasmukh C. Shah, James N. Sites, Gordon D. Strickland, William M. Stover, John C. Zercher (All CMA staff) Request from counsel for information responsive to discovery requests and typewritten note in response to same A/C, W/P Berry St. John, Esq. (CMA's Outside Counsel) cc: Paul S. McAuliffe Charles S. McCowan, Jr., Esq. (Outside Counsel to CoDefendant) Legal advice from counsel regarding upcoming trial and trial strategy in related litigation W/P (joint defense) Identical Copies - 32 - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170396-397 06/21/80 Letter 170398 06/20/80 Memorandum 170399-401 06/20/80 Note and attachment 170402 06/24/80 Memorandum 170406-407 08/11/80 Memorandum 170408-413 06/19/80 Memorandum Author Charles S. McCowan, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Co-Defendant) W. Harrington (CMA staff) John Beale (CMA staff) John C. Zercher (CMA staff) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Addressee Description Reason for Withholding David W. Robinson, Esq. (Outside Counsel to Co- Defendant) Request from counsel for technical assistance in support of defense in related litigation W/P (joint defense) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: G. V. Cox (CMA staff) E. B. Frost, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Results of research in regard to request A/C, W/P by counsel for information responsive to discovery requests Request from counsel for information responsive to discovery requests and handwritten note in response to same A1C, W/P Results of research in regard to request A/C,W/P by counsel for information responsive to discovery requests Geraldine Cox (CMA staff) Bruce M. Barackman, John S. Beale, Albert C. Clark, Geraldine V. Cox, Wayne H. Harrington, Gary C. Henman, George W. Ingle, Victor H. Peterson, Hugh M. Robinson, Hasmukh C. Shah, James N. Sites, Gordon D. Strickland, William M. Stover, John C. Zercher (All CMA staff) Results of research in regard to request by counsel for information responsive to discovery requests and handwritten notes in response to same A/C, W/P Request from counsel for information responsive to discovery requests and handwritten notes in response to same A/C, W/P Identical Copies - 33 - Bates Range 170414 Date(s) Document Type 06/24/80 Memorandum 170415-420 06/09/83 Memorandum 170421-436 05/23/83 Memorandum Author V.H. Peterson (CMA staff) Jeff Turner, Esq. (Outside CMA Counsel) Jeff Turner, Esq. (Outside CMA Counsel) Bates Range 170922 Date(s) Document Type 10/05/94 Letter Author Robert Ondocsin, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) 170923 09/28/93 Letter 170924-929 09/20/93 Letter Mary Ann Fisher, Esq. (General Counsel to CMA Member Company) Edmund Frost, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) 170930-932 10/04/93 Memorandum Brian W. Hayle (CMA legal staff) Addressee Patrick C. Joyce, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) John L. Oberdorfer, Esq. (Outside CMA Counsel) CMA File Description Reason for Withholding Identical Copies Results of research in regard to request by counsel for information responsive to discovery requests A/C, W/P Legal advice from counsel regarding discovery against trade association Draft memorandum regarding legal advice concerning discovery against trade association A/C, W/P A/C, W/P Miscellaneous Addressee Alison Berkes, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) David F. Zoll. Esq. (CMA General Counsel) David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Don D. Evans, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) cc: Bob Ondocsin, Esq. (CMA staff Counsel) Description Reason for Withholding Letter to outside counsel re: A/C, W/P documents pertaining to vinyl chloride Letter regarding status of and analyzing issues in pending and potential vinyl chloride litigation A/C, W/P Memorandum and draff letter analyzing issues regarding document retention AC, W/P Memorandum analyzing vinyl chloride A/C, W/P litigation Identical Copies - 34 - Bates Range Date(s) Document Type 170933-941 07/10/92 Memorandum and attachments Undated Annotated Document Index Author Edmund Frost, Esq. Judith Altenberg, Esq. (CMA Outside Counsel) Davis, Graham & Stubbs (CMA Outside Counsel) Addressee David F. Zoll, Esq. (CMA General Counsel) Don Evans, Esq. Bob Ondocsin, Esq. (CMA staff counsel) Description Analysis by counsel of legal issues identified in review of documents pertaining to acrylonitrile, butadiene, and vinyl chloride Reason for Withholding A/C, W/P Annotated index of CMA documents prepared by CMA's outside counsel containing attorney mental impressions A/C, W/P Identical Copies