Document gax62M40jY0kvoMLZbeDKBJjq
yb circuit interruption: breaker!
1
Mainstay in most protection plans, loaays drv
breaker keeps pace with growing demands lor trie
reliablo protection, minimum downtime on lauita.'
Industrial-plani breakers, on secondary o(' pr^c
substation IrartBlormer and in secondary substatioS'
use air rather than oil In contact-breaking chamber' In modern switchgear, individual breakers (also m'?
tera and instruments) are removable so malntenan^
can be done with equipment deenergized.
J1
The lew cycles needed lor breakers to trip alio*
protective relay to close contacts, breaker trip coil
move plunger releasing breaker operating mech&
rtism, and opening contacts to interrupt current.
Short-circuit current is maximum during lirst lev
cycles because o( dc component and peak eonWbu#
lion irom motors on line. Thus, there are two base*
lor short-circult-current ratings ol circuit breaks*:
(!) momentary rating--ability to stand mechanical*
stresses which are maximum during early cycles (2flj
interrupting* r--a--t-in- vg -- ability to ubrieauki uciirrccuuiitt ssaotleellyy..^
^aap.between simple air-break switches and breakers, modem load-interrupter switches
BijSfej, whem main need is switching. Where last Setting of breakers isn't required, where possible
^St^phasing car) be tolerated, combination interS@fcstfffeh and fuse serves as economical allernai-'\ot more comp/efe service given by breakers. i^indusinal primary substations, typical units are ifS^efto interrupt 600 amp ol load plus magnetizing
Siring to interrupt station load means switch. r^flSfcon be done without mechanical and electrical I^WiHocking with secondary breakers. Some engi*
specify combination interrupter switches and
Swpeive'r fuses to give short-circuit protection lor pri* P^suxiy feeders and secondary transformers. Fuses are
jjftujually high-voltage boric-acid type. y^-Sirifchlng confers in large industrial plants, where
is distributed over a series of high-voltage
uitffieclers to unit subs, use interrupter switches as an ^ilconomicai means of switching under load.
how circuit breakers are now being applied in primary and*} IfVfsiIcondary unit substations, and on incoming utility-powerfeeders
On the preceding page we strewed the importance ol ade
quate interrupting capacity in today * protective equipment. Now let'* look ot some oi the practices being followed by power engineers in applying this equipment. Primary Substation. II a main transformer broader {in unit's
secondary leads) Is used in the simple-radial system, over current relaying eon be applied to trip thto breaker os backup protection (or plant primary-feeder breakers. Main )ob ol this breaker, from system-protection standpoint, is to detect and isolate faults on primary substation bus. Relaying lor breakors, howover, must bo coordinated with other protective devices in system. Thermal ovorload protection for primary-subslatlon transformer can also control this breaker.
With modern unti-substoiion construction, however, It is now general practice to eliminate tho transformer breaker. This can bo justified by the compactness and extreme reliability ol unit-type equipment, which makes possibility ot a primarysubstation-bus loult remote. In large primary substations, pos sible use ol bus and transformer differential protection should be considered. Additional insurance provided must Justify premium paid. In some special casee, differential schemes combining transformer and bus protection con be devlsod with a saving in cost ol protective lectures.
If the utility sub-transmission system supplying plant pri mary substation consists ol a single radial line, no protection Is ordinarily provided at substation high-voltage terminals, with possible exception ol a high-voltage (use In combination with a switch. In casos where other independent loads are
supplied over the same single radial line, however, tho utility
When a high-voltage breaker Is used In the primary sub- i
station, there Is little Justification for using a breaker in trarw. *]
former secondary leads. Protection normally supplied by -;
secondary breaker can be provided by high-voltage breaker, j
making one less step (n roioy coordination.
;
Beceadery Substations, In simple-radial systems, secondary
sub* are protected in one ol two ways. A main breaker can
be used between stepdown transformer and secondary bus. '
It so, breaker permits not more than 2.5 times normal rats ol .
current to the substation transformer. More usually, trip setting
of this main broaker is closer to rated current of transformer,
common trip setting being I.2S limos rated current.
In the second case, the main breaker is omitted, but sum
ol trip settings of low-voltage feeder breakers is less than IS
times ratod transformer current Transformer thermal over-
current protection can be supplied by some manufacturers.
NEC sets limits within which individual overcurrent protec
tion on primary side ol secondary-substation transformers can
be omitted (19S3 edition, SoctJon 45J2). Basically, the Code
permits leaving out individual primary overeurrent protection
when Ihere is adequate secondary overload protection (or the .
transformer. Also, when primary-leader relaying can' be said
to detect faults in low-voltage side of the transformer. If you
interpret the Code literally, It permits connecting only 5 Idem
p ossible at various voltages
,,*
RVtlcol transformers to the Sams primary ieodsr without use of schemes havo been worked up to provide selective (ripping
c-Vindividuel overcurrent protection on the primary side of the ^ lifanilointere, when i/ansformer impodanco it 6% or Jess, ft
ot such devlcas. For example: A definite time delay ts olten introduced Into ih* opening of a !ow-volrog breaker at a
;V*;trenformer impedance is between 6*4 and 10%. it is permit- high fault-current level to give branch-ctreuit device enough
Alibis to connect only three transformers of like site to the
limo lo open fl fault Is in branch. It was specifically this problem that resulted in recent
CV'tome primary feeder. tary While the code requirement is generally accepted by power
f $ engineer# today as being approximately correct at 6*4 and
development oi moro accurate adjustable soriss-trip alemenls lor tow-voltage edr breaker*. Since their entry into breaker
,10% iranslormer impodance, the regulation is unnecessarily lield, it i* usually easier lo coordinate characteristics.
^`restrictive lor other valuos of Impedance. In many eases today, j/.-the oversimplilication ol tho Code rule Imposes an economic
Tripping characteristic* ol a breaker necessarily form a band rather than a line, it's defined by a lower ampere-time value below which the breaker will reset end not trip, and an
r,-'* pfiKtfty art the induatria)-p)ani distribution system. krsaksr Coordination. Protection at load points must coordi-
, *,' with breakers at supply ond or law-voltage side ol seei * ondary substation. This coordination between protective elaiv->r-Denti depends mojnfy on the (ow-voltage-foader breaker*
upper value representing maximum time required lor breaker to open circuit (or a given flow of current. Usually, If a ratio ol 2:1 exists between tripping-current value ol larger breaker end smeller, the smaller trip* before largor breaker I* un
J'.. canyIng current to supply several branch leoders. Even though ampere-time characteristics of two dsvices have dissimilar shapes, coordination is generally obtainable because of dif.
latched. Network Protection. In a secondary network system, main
substation breaker i* the network protector. This automati
cally opens only on revorse power How. To get backup protec
Isrenees in normal current ratings. ' Whsn breakers operate up near point oi maximum interrupt ing duty, opening times ol both low-vollage-feoder and branchdrcuh protection may be so nearly instantaneous that coor dination is impossible, it Is lor this reason thal various
tion for network protector In case it falls to open, fuses are usually incorporated as part ol the network protoctor. Throe (uses generally provide overeurrent protection against cur rents greator than 2.S times Iranslormer rated current.
Network relay that trip* protector is an induction-type 3-
phase directional power relay. An overvoltage roclostng fea
ture Is generally incorporated in modern network relays to
This is modem mefalctod switchgear:
initiate automatic recloeing ol proleclor when proper voltage
may call ior an automatic switching devico, a circuit breaker, ot primary-substation high-veltage terminals. This protects incoming line against outage caused by faults in tho indus trial-plan! system. Such a breaker Is generally relayed by overcurrent units, coordinated so that it doesn't trip for faults that should be clearod by primary-leader breakers or other
protective devices in the lf\dulrtal-plont system. The high-voltage breaker can provide backup protection.lor
iaults on the plant system, and where transformer or bus dif ferential protection Is used, the breaker can be controlled by the differential relays.
ftsfl-dreult energy
3-f*8* kvt
disrt-circcil eip pee phase
15,000V
2500 v
480 v
S3 v
25,000
1000
SJOO
31,000
70,000
50,000
2000
11,500
63,000
140,000
100,000
(000
23.000
125,000
280,000
Hoft The stove era attained values diauiSni inpedsic* fiat miy
be met M (he frptaf pint ryitor oa teconfofai of unit ubitilons
i {
.<
i j '!
An assembly of main units and auxiliary compart ments with: (l) all parts enclosed in grounded metal (2) grounded meiai barrier* lo isolate secondary con trols and wiring Irom high-voltage primary device*, and primary units Irom each other 0) removabletypo circuit breaker having sell-coupling primary and secondary disconnecting contacts and a mech anism for moving il physically between connected and disconnected positions (4) interlocks lor sale
operation, proper sequence.
supply is restored to secondary substation. Secondary-Selective Systems. Coordination ol Iripping characleristlcs ol low-vollage feeder breakort and those in tianslormer leads is exactly the same as problem met in simple radials. Exception may came when all load Is carried by one translormer, as would be the case with a singla-endod sec
ondary unit substotion. When substation (s operated with ono translormer. an added
breaker is olten placed between main primary breaker and
fow-yoifage feeder breakers, Then if bus-tie trips automatically on overcurront you avoid difficulty ol getting selective opera
tion of main, bus-tio. and Jow-rofloge-leeder breakers.
TODAYS fliCTBICAl PIACTIC*
sown
tooay's eiecmcAi mactic*