Document gaax0ywXDe9L7G1ZLgBL5aJre

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT ST.CLAIR COUNTY, ILLINOIS PRANCES E. KEMNER, atal., Plaintiffs, vs. MONSANTO COMPANY, Defendant. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ORDER Defendant Monsanto, pursuant to ordsr, has submitted numerous documents to this court for camtra inspection assarting attornsy-clisnt and work product privilagss. Aftsr review of all submitted documents the argument and authorities in defendants' memoranda and its own research, this court rules as follows: Number C22830-34 C22835-6 C22837-8 C22839-80 C2&881 C22882-91 C22892-4 GROUP I Produce C22836 C22846-80 X C22893-4 exhtbtt g Not Produce X C22835 X C22839-45 X C22892 Number C22895- 928 C22938- 41 C22942- 46 C22947* 56 C22957 C 2 2 9 5 8 ' 59 C22960- 62 C22963 71 C22972* 23062 C23063C23066- 79 C23080- 87 C23088 97 C23098 112 C23113 14 C23115 140 C23141 44 C23145 51 C23152 59 C23160 62 C23163 4 C23165 6 C23167 79 Produce X C22961-2 C22964-71 X C23064-5 X C23089-97 C23114 C23170-79 Not Produce X X X X X C22960 C22963 C23063 X C23088 X C23113 X X X X X X X C23167-69 Number C23180-85 C23186-87 C23188-9 C23190-204 C23205-23224 C23225 C23479 C23480-84 C23485 C23486-90 C23710-78 C23779-81 Number C23682 C23783-86 C23787 C23789-91 C23792-94 C23795 C23799 C23800-12 Produce C23181-85 X C23200-204 % . X Not Produce C23180 X C23190-199 X X X X X X X GROUP II Produce X X X X X (except first p<;k Not Produce X X iph ) X Number C23813-15 C23816-17 C23818-23 C23824-26 C23827-34 C23835 C23836-49 C23850-51 C23852-3 C23854-5 C23856-7 C23858 C23859-60 C23861-2 C23863-4 C23226-23478 C l 3714-13897 f *>3865-68 C L 869-933 C 1-3934 C 93f - 37 13938 - ^ V C23497-6^7 ro UQn-ino Produce X Not Produce X X C23824-5 X X C23826 X X produce/ first paragraphs X X X X X X X X X C23866-8 X C2386T firs' ^ X X X Y Number C23952-58 C09617-27 C23959-71 C23972-81 Number C23982-7 C23988-46 C22929-37 C24047-55 C24056 C24057-63 C24064-66 C24067-72 C24 073-76 C24077-83 C24084-85 C24086-88 C24089-90 C24091-94 C24095-101 GROUP III Produce Not Produce (except C09624 and first 8 lines of CC353) X (except C23968 from V to end of V on C23969) X (except IY on C23980-1) GROUP IV Produce Not Pro X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X Number C24102-107 C24108 C24109-23 C24124-32 C24133 C24134-61 C24162-68 C23491-93 C24172-83 C24184-89 C24190-91 C24200-202 Number C24280-338 C24339-43 C24344-89 C24490-585 C24586-98 G24599-623 C24624-28 GROUP IV Produce Not Produce X X X X X X X X X X X X GROUP V Produce X X X X (except C24554-76) X Not Produce X X Number C24643-44 C24645-50 C24651-76 C24677-98 C24699-703 C24704-8 Number C24709-16 C24717-68 C24769-71 C24772-75 C24776-83 C24784-7 C24788-90 C24791 C24792-25020 C25021-23 C25024-25 C25026-30 GROUP V Produce Not Produce X X X X X X (except C24706 last half-6 lines of C24707) GROUP VI Produce C24720-68 C2470-71 X X X X X X C25027-30 Not Produce X C24717-19 C24769 X X X C25023 Number C25031 C25032 C25033-36 C25037-38 C25039-55 C25056-58 C25059-67 C25068-74 C25075-7 C25078-89 C25089-90 C25091 C24169-71 C25417-22 Number C25092-4 C25095-97 C25098 C25099 C25100 GROUP VI Produce C25058 C25061-67 X GROUP VII Produce Not Produce X X X X X C25056-7 C25059-60 X X X X X X Not Produce X X X X X Number C25101_ C25102-116 C25117-25 C25126-32 C25133-49 C25150-51 C25152 C25160-65 C25166-69 * C25170-3 C25174-5 C25176 C25177-78 C25179-82 C25183-90 C25191-208 C25209-21 Number C25222-32 C25233-38 C25239-44 GROUP VII Produce 025*11-16 X GROUP VIII Produce C25241-4 Not Produce X C25102-10 X X X X X X X X X X X X X X Not Produce X X C25239-40 Number C25245-77 C25278 C25279-82 C25283-85 C25286-71 C25372-4 Number C25375 m C25376-7 C25378-9 C25380-5 C25386-94 C25395 C25396-99 C25400-02 C25403-5 C25406-11 C25412-13 C25414-16 C16651-62 GROUP VIII Produce X GROUP IX Produce X X X X Not Produce X X X X X Not Produce X X X X X X X X X Number C25423 C16666-78 C16663-65 GROUP IX Produce X X Not Produce X C21360-C22231 X Number Produce Not Produce C24203-04 X C24205-09 X C24210-32 X C24233-48 X C24249 X C24250-58 X C24259-69 X C24270-79 X The documents ruled discoverable shall be produced instanter.