Document g2b2rKxmk77ZpV8yXkaQjkpmJ
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_O01523_00003568-00001
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00002
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00003
gVsgttnSggSBliiil&j^^
gggggggSiVBXeBVgl^^^
gJgg9t9t99MgggJae9Ig^
ggagisy^^
g\g
BggUBUXSggtigg-jX^
BgtgfigigifgfSafgiiai^ ^fftKggtgXtXsSg'S^ gggSxgggSBByyiaiigyty^
BiggBXgBQgOSgt^ gtilsnil^^
g9ioggg9SgggggsggggS9SS^
g9fggtt99b9gxSxgi99gg9S9^ Byi9iggy9sgggpBex9g6gg9^
9g9&JBgigg9giB33Kgcygg^^^
ggsgSBXttgeSggisggSgeyygit^^^
ity99ggggg9MK&^ gygasgSggggyStggytgS^^
gggyfggg9BBgitS9^
BHBWiiiifBaiaBiiWiii
atieepBsBilsecjf: -
ines-ft^iiSflti-fiBiioif-lis ISailiIiioiigBit^
ggiygyxggygfy
gg
;"JW;|*yQggg|g|;||jggggg|f;g;--|jjgg|;>jg|Jgj..;gg|||g|gp|^ ?:OBlfJB llBIHWtfi^ gsyggtgyggyygguggygigg^
"gAsgitttffSx^sssSS^gygggXlnggggfySg^^gx^tge^ BJSffBftJJ;SltiisBfBiBSfiife;nstcjaif8it6ti5ttgiiisiBiSii|w^
giniiiiifWBhtdsiBifisis?^^ giBfig^tBgsygKggtgyogey^ gBosggSgyKggxglByffggiy^^^^ ggsaggyBexsyyyKtgggtgyi^^^^ jaiiei|alg|BBit3icoeigf|s|fi|a^
B? g|gflitlaiBBgt
y&lagtggBigseygggig^^
^Safgggggggygggggggggggg^^^^^^^^^^
9gg9g^^^^^
'
g J'g
b?b gB-
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00004
BKegBBBiB&BisSSs^^ IffiXBStaf^
BBBBSSgBK-SSSSKgBBSBBX^
.. f<g -< ^.gs-sa
a ''tigfftSaagB^ BBBvgStSBSBfig^^^
-ffSSg^ffl^
- xs si :
.v ;:'^ f
StBX^fliBSfB^
-
.' < ^
^Efj^gg^BBs^^ SBBKstBgS^^
SlfWlfciStS^
'$BgBSiggffgS9gX^
Sis B^^ittof-SS^
;
xSiMggHBiiSgt^esSiiftJa`X8x>ai-iSiem
:^s:"iSg^iiBg^sgS^
; ;f
>f^i!^gilBah-BgSiBBtKtfgfglBjfi
i i
xgigBsgggi;tggBgBBeggggB^fg^
rBaaagsffggiSggiSBx^^
:gBjggfgggeagtgfgi9^^
-
BgSixBgsfB^
BBeBBg&xHiegigesKiBBgi^
sf Wlii|Sisife|icSO
ifSSfialst
gpgai&gsitgt&X^g^
ll|jiSS
ssf;-v-s
s; f
fs -'fs-i -'
xBi.B9^-SgxBlBgfa^Ba^
iji|flefcf-fJifggjiCfsw||fi-ii|lBgSiSS>slSSStiBSiSii'itiiiS friigfgigBS|0tl|^
>XgXXxxBg;^^
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00005
17CV1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523 00003568-00006
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523 00003568-00007
tg^^BgSet^vig^SiS^ llftrOOicW38iEO#SB|i^ aggxubgSxxEiEttSg^gixggflgt^ :'futfoasu3eKgi-S^n^^^^
:Ift -:V A ' ' -
SttKaStElSttE
agStXggBa'fiSSl^^ ^a.ilxit^^ :&BSgttBig^gee^ gxgs^xai&Sltsagf^
BgBxgXgBXStf^ ^QggS&iSg^
SBVXBgXttilttSaSxgrBxSSfKfigXf^
Sugissi^
BBSsXB^^
^SxxSdxglii^
xSsoaioBeSSit^ xaglatBgggigfK^ BgjSlatt&ggeggBi^
ggaxgegggtg^^ g<gtgsSggj&^^ xigggSggigStgggitK^^ SiBtggKggKS^^
Bgxsss^^
vSigBani-SnifiitiioOifilOlltSilifiiftWBS^Stiiss^ SaffsglggggaBB^ ^ffggx^XXXxff^^ ^fiagsgx&9gBfSg^agBtgsgggBg^&^ S*S^!3Btg!xlgBgEggtgggggggggSggBl^^XB
aeiaattilitOBB|t|iefl^o'ili^fi
natS^^
j||iHBi^
g|sB|jtfJtgSiii^
EEsBiSgiSag^^
liEgeg^
EtgfExtx^ASEEgA^^
SExiiffgfiEgEsgEx^^
XSljgBffigBSgggg^
gEBSEggaESEttglgsg^^
B-IO-tlSSSliiOSSl|BEiMt|etBftitiSils|i^
s^ts^^
-^^
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
'-
;
E '
:
ED_001523_00003568-00008
XBBKgiViPKBBgXXXBXXXX^
fSSSBsXSSgtgg^B^^
gKBBBiBgeutsBxBincggBXS^
glfi^BSfSS,3g9ii^sx^^
' ' ;
gAget^sgiK^
ggaiSl^^-gg gB^B8sg^:isg^^
BsfgigigeanB^
J3igg&BsggtigngxagggS-ft9iBgg3ggB
ggtifigfMg&3XB^^
ggigXggSgigisKS^^
B
BsgafiBttB'Gggg^^
BXgBsBgBSBBsBBiBSB^ 3IlifctBBiBiSs3jte|i^
gffBigBBBgKBSBgXBXgBxBBisgsB^^
gxBBgBBSgsgBBXBBfBBBXoXB^
ggsgxgSieBBsXgXsKBXXtBBBB^
gsBBtxgtBBgBBgBgBXSBBsx^ B|a<siqiiftiC|iitit|ifft^^
Riliiilli2iliflHBlSiS3RR^^ gggggBgisgggBg^BxvgeggBsisBXggBgB^^vgs^Beggxs^ Wa^^iaiisiiil^iii'lHlif'IiiiMtiwlWiifctliii
<esesgiORftpffOBRirtfio^^
ggBtBBEXiXXfgB&BXBXSiB^^
<8ritiiiBtWl BigietiiiibititfSts
^f||flg|ggB||gig|IaBg^ <>;;lgioe|g(iftbRl*fiSf#Wft^^ O|tgB|llbasgbB|g|g|jg|Q||||^
0gtRCfalll|iisgl3ai||^
ggBBBxBggibfivgxsBXg^^
lglrt WglStlfcBilttW^ wSesgg |ftigliaiigB|tig||3ba^ grigtt:!|gjtgOtlgli|jg^ Wa|iiiBl|||g||Baagl*gg^
iailysgiigggtSBsjjegg'Cifgfggg^^
g 3'
R '
;3 '
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00009
ggi^SsgSgSg^ xgxgixggsgg&xg^ ftgSxs^BsasU^s-^^ gggxgxSaAsSffg^ xsaiSixtvKxsgxigt:^
gx&S^^
Xti&xggBtgggxxttxgg;^
?<?- IlBitieg^
xssK&S&xtxxgaxg^^^ XfigxxgiiggS^^ gxQffggftx&sux^^ XgtSiexxg'ttSB^X^/iX^ gXgxxssisixSKaSffg^^ xglxgKgBaSgg/xgiSixg^^ JgttSxxBSgi^ x^xxBxsttxgxXSsKxxg^ ^xx^ggsasigSiSifigg^^ XgXXXigBSgggXXfXgSg^
xxBtxBtgggsnxx^^
ggXgtSggXgggggggi^ xgsMXXgggxgxgsffjxfgg^^ gggggggfiottggeegxsgfg^ gX/SxgltfiiXBttggtVxt-gstxttxgttxbxV -'TlxwfS^tSfx^^
xgggxfgBgfegBxigB'iXgXgg^^
ggfigxtgggxBtggnxiXsxx^ gugxgig^X^itggtxgxggxgtxxtxggg^^^ gxaxggxtggiXSBxgffag^^ x^xSSSxxgSAxIgi^ xxgftgxsx^SaiXlxgx^^ ^^leitlis--Kobjik: xl8gi;^iitisStKiit-iisitBst gijgffeSgffSxggasgigls^ ggggxXxgKiBgxggxgsSgieg^^ xgggfSStgRxlgggxt^ ^gax&gs^ggffs^^
BJlislilis Ofci yeifiigttxXgxxi^xefgg^^^^^^ gfiggexxBgg^t^ggnffgS'igx^
^xlfts^^se&tBg^gi^igagg-gggxtijggggg^
^gggfgBBgSgSgxgXlglgx^^ f38fiJt|iftOMfjalliW;WitfliiSgItlilgi|ii|gg^^
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
; ;;. XX ; 8r ; '' :
8
-'
Bj8'8
xx ' ? ' '
b
ED_001523_00003568-00010
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00011
17CV1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523 00003568-00012
^exigX-svv^^ . BBBBfKSSStgBBsBSBB^ gBxgffg^^^ 3tu^&SiXQ9Sj:^ giBBBBsSB9&BS9sisaB^ xggggliffggg03s99g^ ggBggStggstx^SBSfigsxS^ 9i9g^t&S^aig9x^ :I||esaB*iSB3festttlOi^ ggsS^ggegigSxigxS^^ gSBgggnBgl^S^S^ 9Sg9f9[i9gi9ggg9ggg^ BtCstgSlcO^ 9ggl9ttgeggsegaff999^ 9igg9itStg99x^gi9Ki9S^ BgSgBgxtggggfgggsgSBti^ B9S9g9^S9gl9t99tts^ gg99SS99gt^ gigiggttsgBBfgsx^
xBxBBB9x&9sB9BBBaoBS^
f3 iniii#taaeigBjswe-i^^
gtgBBf^BBtgBt9t3ggMt-BBBxgBx9Bs99BBgBBB6^^
:33aeiBJUf;3|BJf3it ^fBiiaf3tftBs3iWPtSWi91i
3|3IIJbOW3SOII
^llagtfOiiwifttialg3t|BjtfBiiigi^|j|j||g||g^^
^s|ft3i^iaiS:ee;gr3Siatfi3il|BiiiiBfi8Sieaiti3ftSBii|
"Swgtec|tjg3s33-fBf3iil^iifiSfaia<Bi|3|33j;Oi^
|aefiitraHi|saii|fetitiaRWi^
b<~; /' C .; ' xgBc
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00013
17CV1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523 00003568-00014
<>99^ yy9Bgy99BtBs999B9S^^
y-^ ''^yy^ 2ys'y;y"Sf^
yyy yyy9yy39igl9yf&B999gBii^
yyyyyyt^yByxS^y^ti^
; yy^y-^
yycyzyix--^y'^^ yy-^^^^
^i^yytS^^
; j :99gygisigBBtg9B999i9S9^ Oiifftalii3Ktsti|s|iSBSHiii^
SSxBfxSsBgygyists^ ygUggiSgsyyssgsgs^
yygtttiyiguggBgjygtBHi^^ ggegey^ficxg^^ ySgeygtatyg^^ uifgySgSgs^i^^^ laSy^g^XlgySt^g^gtSUBfggyy ygsgtggiug^S^yS^
:yy-yyyggy<
'Sis^gsgyXSg^^ :ygy---^Sggglfi:^^ yggy^g^Sgeg-g^tgg^'gf^^
yg
SaS'll:?-S;<B
^Sigif9^Bxfgt99g^
g gggBsygsBxBigBB^
S::;' 'tSSaSflWfoS^
Bfteillt tiitB||SI:|itB^
ggggBBBB^^
9s9B9^B9g99999gBgB9BSi9l9^^
y9g9gSS9BBff9Bts9^^
Qo9BB9BB99igBS9B99fB^^^
9999Bis^^^^
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
y<
9^
'<
a/--a
' 9
'
ED_001523_00003568-00015
17CV1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED 001523 00003568-00016
ligaaiie
lilijli
tfoSlBil
l^vii/g^
.'ZZZ'Z ta&S^s^^
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00017
'fliiltjIstsfiO
aOOl a^BaSaaa
P^
P Ppp
appgggpp
ga- Pggti: pgggg ppP ajaEiBB'^a^^
: : -a
ag PPggFg igapp^
gagp pppgpgggtsggtP&ga^
gaggg ggggaai ggi gpgi ggg aggptopggggg
Pi P
aggpapp ggsgg apg gag apggagp SiiBMBWi^^
; ' Iv
laWaM"^
gag gppg gpgpSg iilii
ggggaa agg gang gagpsg
a>j
agggppa- iilElOW- gg gaSa gganeSP gasitgggggg^^
P
liiBlB agg gang gggSp gpgigpgggSg
P,: g
gsaa agaaappa^^ WjER'-<
PgpSPSft
. . : ,i -:
.
g
gppgpppg 'gggaaa aag Postai ggangp afggggggti--paspKg.<gp3sti
ggggg gag aggg ggggp
^g :
lpwtieaOBi|#WllWi^^
a FPgiFPpPPP--PP -g a SiaB PiifgSBP pppfPgaa: F^apspag^F agpga- PpaggaF
f '- ? '^
gga^ P-FFfSSF pgagpap <?ioaiaa: pppagF' -. tntpP
ppaga> pgsggtflPgpg FF-PF
gggagpagpgaa
pagg g:-gpgspp
F^z
.."PPPP^PFPP^
pggap ggggggpi PPg ggaa pgga gagappF agggaa ggga g FQg P
a^^ap gggggga OiS ggg - -, apagaaap apapgega gigpa gagga
pggpp- gisisasats agi gasaa aaagg gppgaa-F apggaap pppsapFp- aaapggF
ppaigg-P ggggggi gg: agga agga gaaggpp gpgppap ggga apaaggp
gggp ggsggggap ag aaggap aggap paggppF aagaapapp ggaF apg alla ggppp aggggasgaF apg apggpa aagapa aggpppp aaaggaa gpgg aaFPPggp
pggg agpgggpgpaa appg agag agga. ppaagaapp gggapFP appagppa gggpp
\. : : ggggpg^ ag aggpaa aggpp aapgappa gpaggi appggpaaggaga
l<S^^S^
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
U
ED_001523_00003568-00018
6L000-899C0000 29100 03
Vd3 a qn|Q bjj9!S 906Lao|,
nilU.MjovPH 4 U'.3,.,;*.4 'MIHM ; .
m
U'`;p ' !
P pPip p:
4 I
Hi'piinuq .mphim.
p*'" p ! p M` H h '< ..... , ouph .qd m IPR p: ) H j ; ,Mu,h,|
OHll pl-S II S'il J
< i >' i,> i - ' r ' '
j
, Aa
'!<! /V<
M 4 1 S H?) I JIW 4
num
POOZ pon
oor
tanoa
1 '.di S !H V'/ </. `,,v <, " .r '// Gd
a-gtg^
1 MdH'C l I ! i I t *, i t , I' | H fi H* " I * <'i i i ) ' ' ' ' I M ; ? H i ( ; ' ! " 'd ! '"'t! !'!**" ! f < i m't.f < >p h < ' r >< ( r <ph ir h i < r s* di f' 11-< 's i. < ; 1 : h ' i h i < ?
'-H' h H :rd h !
V|!/\O ifihh;;- O
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00020
LZ000-899C0000 29100 03
'i ur `(i,- .juq p ur,
M q b ; ) j ' "< n<> > ; w * i>1 , * r* bn i ; < f -G q r q
P
! H.oh ,f(h -`i P-'H' :T -: i!
' H
p >I
!
s G ' J 1 " ' H? Mr. I i i ; > jp
Vd3 a qn|Q bjj9!S 906Lao|,
I r -r
r q
toj \ n-puni jHphnj i
5
|r;!p: x-umihi ii<| VIKplllioq
hohpwh rq urpinmq .MphuHM Uiphi s},!s.hh
` 1 u ; H < M UmpHth ibHAqdi .<4 .wnUi
M '/> :>i;
,j i
h*..` k
00
Moss
B
i H
' - c,
v.'r,
' ; . >' ' >>,h
Pc |thc,'ol( .ol OH?,-. > IjjHh;/1
i ' i
! 1 ; ,
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00022
B! S
g.
:
B '
B-' B , ' ' ' Bi, ,
i ; -.-rb;j: : - " - - S j; >r'. \ 'B1-; -a ; -.,,i; jcu'-. *m.< gf .r-H". - rj;.n b- , . '
,,r B B `i'-;!..-. 7. BBB -B--^ - ' - / ,;.(<% ; r-
' / ."..? j , '
;
g3g:gg.;:
'-kg gg`,
.
Agggg AgttA
Agg
ttggg -ACgug- Aglgi gggggg g'tggggigggAiiiitigg ggggggtiA: kgigtgrtggtgtg
gggg gggg-3 ggg B3ggi
ggggggAgg gggAgggAggg
ggg ggggA AAgA k A3-gA:. 1:J gg
17IB7-- ggggA-
IBIS! :-A-\
gggggggg^ AgAg-ggggggggl AggggAggl ggAgS
gggg- g-A^ ggfA gggggi SSrr!i7
gA A
^gggg- g-'g-g AggA gg^gAgA
ggggggggA gAkggggggggl
g Ag gkg k k
A' g^^^
gg^gg^
Wit-< gggg ggg gg-ggAA gggggAAggfSgAggggg^^^^^ ggggggggi !^!!r'7i7iiM7b7 gggA- AkiA- ggkA:/' 3kgg gAAASggg gg-gA-gggAAgAgg g^gAggggAk r!S'!!!-!'!;-7B!!r!|
ggg ^gS3g^A'g
s: ' Vf'g3gg-:^
gggsggg ggggggggAg^
ifill gggg
<
ggA gAAAggAA ggAgAgggggAAgggl ggggkg^gg AAggAgggAAgggl
g-ggg ggggg ggg ggggggg gggggg^
gggggggg gggg^
gigxgggggiggg^ giStSt'g^
ggggfi
- ..< - b' ,: 7..7.-. ,'< : ; - `. ' ,'
- a 7 - /'
7 b'.: .. ,-<
ggggggtu^^
!!lill ggAgA
^g^ -ggg ggggAA: ggggg gggA gggA ggg
gglgggtig^
gAgggg SW^ gAggA
g3ggg- gAgg' gAggA gggg
glggetggA- : gggBgg^^
llllil gAgg AggAg 3ggkgA AAgggg gAgg ggg gggg ggggA -ggg 1011 g^ggA ggkgggA gAggg: ggggA g:g^ gggAg g3ggg AgAg-g gkggg
^gggggggAtggggg ggg 3gkgA Igg^^ Aggkg gggg- ggg-AA A-Agg- ggggg gkggA- Ag-.
gstgggg^^
gligggg gggg gggggg gggg Agggg ggggg ggg- ggA gggk ! gg-A-
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00023
lit 111
tggifgSfB.
llttltftlW
h3UiU}B
h^iH U l<cm.h-, u! Ikh| h;nTd i1 qd pi-npfi n ,.,*; i`- ; o <d M l . J ,< < - * ' >P' 'J'
( 'u
H ,Hd XfiHHsH!
n i;Mb < <;hh
- ` ? a ; V b< n
!"' *<</a.if':' '*<''<<1. H H'
u ''nuir f "' * b b `B
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00024
I <w II < ! Pm .
liO
Ifl
BW
9^ 999-
SB
i nw I. M .,
Hl<|h ", < ,.tit/i;,
HMi< f!,ii iiiw -,
II' Hup,
< >. rit-,
P' ;h . ,n.<i,. !,, > (
W:*BB
,, 1 ; ; I s n It9.
gOPCgO SeSOStlW
n;uMT ", Ps in qi:d < mupmnn buBr . >i J. > t ph\ Popb.p'p -nid bi-phn/h ,! > js nbh >. FmJin ; ut
Hi'Huti'i * h ;>. i ! ni ;> cncf h'h nU
ih u U b ; hpp n.ii -3 ..I J.ohp 4M! pu. I .mM . m .'. H ' \ j
pi;*HM'd * i"'.. <4 irn;il `-.Lsion 4 a pmjv Jpd P
' > ' piJiHcd h
HJ;<i JaiPHi ^t'PHiPp
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00025
non
&g-
100
IfBt
l
llfll liiii
BiO
(jHSMpv <'0
Hwr r0
rip/vv-mii'.h<m m<'Oh i Lh ^H-.Opk'fv. .'h 3. n-up; ,<>< uh priidnH '. .u i HJ< nmd
< hl :i hHp'nr I. bommids i qn'.M-iii -*'<(;<! d H.i ,O'>I
, JH < 3 <p. pt I-h-, u-d ( b: ;> ( -l.id'. ./'V. I
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00026
t
i'* "! '< ;
>| -7 ''-l.nU !
s
Hptnv >, Krhno^hip ht hvi ro mi d H ,ii phmmh m il m^nd r.: mh h d oph v H
m i. IhiiHwl'
>``P'^VHldipm 4';HO|P, MddmM d V,'"'mii-pu em ri mmmimid '> . m M i .`p -.v Ht dmvd .', lmp', 'd.ilion-i
( VHd dp* u r:mpv rnvi r rmMprj. IddirP hnr mm -< nb. p rdimrJ i M ; ; *> P..'^ ; !' ( <(.41.
p -JK) ni npen, en}iofn mu-s.
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00027
(juj/u!; e
IfpHie H.
hnir-Jtp lirUM'Oi imu p-pi'r nji r:( n pj - T, .md -'dh<( >ipb'. H tnhpn) ; !4Ih<'h^
* 'T* (""'!! Pprh < <mpn Mlhoiix ( i In \ `
, ,*<< t ! ,
` Mid
LVHw 'S" ,, v.iiMfjn l'A t
J. SrnH ht. !*,;;-! h! . p > t dp n P * h i ; .
; T P P ` M i'H 4 h iM H CiiPipV i IM t M i S
JHH..U P''
M,
p 0,05) ;H (|H H cihop) pjt
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00028
} J1'
Vbd ''H dd J i dd (.-`ddb- ..dkd 'd i
dj L. dd;! .Vd d'
V, d .dm'-.-: *>' re/k
V\ - K?. V ''/b H*., Budiddddddqid-d: ivddd.-;.
,. ,.;, bd ^'<d:'' *. -..dddd > ?, 7. i. - , ; . n. V- d: - 1 : - d7 ,, T '
-d d " d-dd : . - d : : '<* -b ; ! ' n ; d.;dtd d db
bbifgiOifc ditiifSS^ 9g999
! !;:!d:bd
dSaifBiwfcft 9x/9b9^
dliikbd^
99x999
oflSSt
llltiliO
99^ xS999
Hiieio
ISiilfiK
x99999
dd'd 999999^
99999^ 99999
Mttilf^lCddd
999999^
999999^ 99S^^
lilSici^
iWsiiObdS Ikbdbdli^ 999^99^ 7/ ;
^S^
/99999999/
9999999999 9999999 //9--99999/9X 999:9^ 9//9x99'/^^
/:9s9999999 99/ 9999-x 9/999^
/:Ss|3tOb?>:d? 9t999xa9x
9x/9ig^^
9/999/9/ ^i9999x99f993fi9 XXXy.gf9/99/XX x9/9999999xx/x
9999999^ x9b-~^
999999999/9
99//99999/X 99/999^^
99S9999 ddb:bBBedb
9///9//99999// b^^b;bWidkbd^^^ 999/999 9/ 9/^
999999 9xx999^
99x/9^9^ 9//999999X9 99/9999/9 99/9/99^
g999999 999999^ 9////999/9// 999/999999^ 99/999999 9x999x/9^99/;-:/x/x,
^99999^ 9999999999999, 9999999//// /9/9999/9 - //9/999^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ k^bdldbbifd
99999x x9999/99999^^^^^^^ ///9/-g9//9x^^^^^^ ^d77'db7'lid-;d7^ /xX9/9f^^ 9/X/X/9XxXX//g^^^
99999g -/9999999^ /9X99X:999/99 9999x9999^^^^^^^^^^ X/X///999/XX ///9x9/99^ 999999 9999^9999 99/ /99999 ^Ib-dddOdbdl /X/9/99///^ dd:dbd-b<fiidd .; dj
9/99999 dd-dd';b:Btdid
. d d-^d^^ftd^d^ 999x99^^^^^ 9/////////^
-, U'
9999/99999^^^^^ 99/99999X99 99/////^
9/9XxS999/9 Oliad_d3
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00029
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00030
tll18 m
< 33: ? - ... i 113
f ,11 <' M M > 3 '< T ,11 .. 1 II ,1. :li!iSl:!O
UH .MiM ',,,,nph 1;13m ,
333111,
` mm : 1 ' JM <>'.,<,1
? B1 1 i*3> 3 ill ig:
3333 i
3 31 W-Mt 31 13 3 WS:111O^ 181:1:31331.OII3133:3:13333 OllE
113113:
llSilil^ fH.lgglllg?- Olg
iSHllg SBSS 13,3
Oj-OOmOJ
ttSB
SS33333S3 ^13333333 |||^ tlMglgl:: tB3g3333 g:gl :W133333333333' VluSttS B!l_
Jti33:3::::3MMiJ
OBJu ' 333 3
33^1 33^
O lSBll:
3
m3 1m
fSiS'g
HJtgMgll
-mm" '":
iB33
13gg
lllilSlifll Hlft ggll
lllllllolll
llil 3: i!'311'i?- l
^333:^
:...Il 3S
33331!
33333B33S 333mM
1 IUI ggiQ
SB 333'3 3 .: 3 ilijif
Slliiia Mglog IO 13331113311:130 3111glllllli
3:|31.T 111 113:333::
tus
3333
3lii
jSIB
St
lit 333313333^333, iisi
13:333:33333333331
itS
hsiI
g
llfl
11313 :1133333ig
|131331313133311f
I31 131333
gg 13331133313:31 333 113:33133131!
|j3:31'331333311
331g il : 3 lu:
3 il
tu
"S333333^^
3mt > 1 Hn
MJ
.' S,
tKsSSBBUBU9t-..3:3:3 :33333:m3
itigilo
0333313311:1
^
Mis.
13::3:::13m
3:333 ~33333i;l i3 3:1311333:80
;:O3:i.Mli
3^ 3:::33::31...
3...3:
3BOsM1333333 ::33j3
St^StBB^
ifiill^
uMM'ij.hi,: iiidiM
i , M.m r Mty,.,- mvi
111133 33 :33 33:133
31?: 3 11 11 :33 3:^^ 11,, 311:33111
33-m3:m:33:3: 133333313131ilt3I m?m1|;mm33?m:S 333111111:111111 lliOilllilll
tHtlSl:3'!31 3111331:3ill!li| 1331111:113:1111?1S
3:1133 ll-3313;ltiil33113, 3333igl 3333^
3^
BIIImmII
3MOlgil21B
bbbbbbb^^ B333SU 333^
OilBolilf !813g3M:m:33 333131133331 31.88
:13133131i1:1 ijf
BBB^
33333^ 33333^^
OllOlll 1 : 1::1- '1' B
:. l. -. lBl
33:3::::3333: 3 1:m
,,.MM'I.lUM M.h 1 , i'jfibl, ImIjhi hisiiM 1OM31
lEi^iiiii 1;111m11m1:3I 3131131,.,11S
: :3133i3rt33. 33, 33333s
W--.?
loOilt U:BB9uB ; 13111333113111111133,11 3333S
1 < I" 1 .n.llqllMJ biM, -i>- ,)M II '! , K > 0 M '< ' ."V ,3 II "1 ,1-1.,
1 ,
,
.
' - .h KM! . fiil.H Mi> I < U il |- u"!........ >1 3
llllllBI
3333S^
^3-'^
Il I, :l..iwi^ :. B333S33 lilllllBlg
33:S3it3,3^ Iglllgjlllll 33O
3133333:3:^^^^
3-H / < - ' ; i
lllll^
-
13331 1:113:|||3g 3333gf33:9 S3B3S
3 '' i 3 3
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_O01523_00003568-00031
^ViUlUiQ^^
SsS^-^
BgBB:t^^B
Stlli "SssbS.bbQ.bBbSbbBB
si1! OiO Bggl'ggg
llOllfife>
SSII
BgiBB
11B- BlWfli
BBB^
BUBB
gg^BB BBBg^
SiBBiBS^
BBB--B BABBgg^
|J1|
SBbBb SSgB^BSSB:
BBtarsgB^
SSiS^
ItgSS^ gSBBS
^bsbbbgagMBBg^
^ISbbSsb^ 9SSbb BBSSb^^
IS11W
IBBB&BBiBsBg^^
^BBbbB
ijiilll
isRO^ilif
bSSSb-
-, % i lliai
^SSSbilills^ OiiB<SS
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00032
ilOO
9SS---^ gt^ t9saSgg^
;||||||^|b11|||||^^ liwg^
ig|gi||g||gg-|||--|lgl|i|fi|ill|g|gi^^
?lgllgggl^ JSSS'^SX^^
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00033
f'
`Z:-,
' s /
:?/ d -,
Bf;b^^
ftBBB: BB9gB
BBBBr B^
BiiBBB'BBBBStBBBB^
BBBB^B-s
BSBBB^
IBBBBeB'S
BBBBBb
lBBBBB^
BBBBBB^ BSBii^B^e^g^BBB^^
BBBBBB
SSBB;^ b^bs^bbbb^bbbabbb^
BBBiBS:9BBBBBBBBBi^^
c ..' " Z
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00034
/ nz, 'rjphic aa iVexf,, SC Am A ACOVA
l'AA
Mu..
V ' ;'> , ; .
StiiAAl Us^zgSB -g-gg> :iuiAMAiWj^
/ L
ggygigy
zgSgg^
r- : 1
zy^
gg^
soIaava gggggg^ ggggy 29^
gySSt
*lu su
AA A
OVA1 gggSgg gggg
pBSAA gggogg
AOddACtii
ggtggy gggsg ggsgg ggggg^ ^gggg gg^gg gggyg ggiggg^
ggggyg gggggg gsggg ggggggy^
g gggSggz g^gg 2Sgyggggg^
gSgzgy ggggzg ciiCA 1111.^
-,r> d-AprAA"' S rzzy
ii.-
'- . u:. IA. -iM'-T-'
" "^r -yz-'.z '
... ' r- * i: > CfeSiiA gSSgz X "-..
O
gzg&g:
tggggzz gzggy ^yya 9gggz gz
^ y: y y > g2yy2yyyyzzy->
z -' '
y-
gggigy gggg liaolc
Z /< A
ggggg ggig Afifisc
9gggy gggg ggSg: gggl ggg
y>>
wgggg- gggsg Z 22 g^ggyt gggsg zg^Seeg-y
'AM
Wii^
gggsg
ggagg
ggggg
ggSgg-
g&agyg
gggBg
! c'a iAXS'Su:
:'A
ggggz^ gggg gSSg gSBgg xaiiiB 2SSZ OaiftA
/ ' ' <A
.A
J s -AAA -- ';i' ' ' . .. ""
9Sggg gg&g gggg ggsg$ ggsgg gSys gggg BSiBA liiBA
gtSggg ggssg ggSg ggsgg ggggy ;.Z2i ygaag ggSgg gggSgz ggZQggg^.du
Igggg Z Z A gggg c ? A 2SSgy gSng 9 G A Aiilii^ lAlliilfli
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00035
O.' 74 44 al 77 77;-. ZZZZtt 3Z CVaOO-t 1 "77 aOO-O r 1'0/7!
M. :'.'!j t - ''<?. g.7
StalO<"< M'r i,
7 7
ZZiZzZ^ y
PBftlt zzzz^ zzzz^
ZZZZZ-Ziz
7 ...
Z^ zzZZzzz^ zZzatzzaZs zzzz^
fOl
zZZzzs^ ZzZzZZZZSs ZZ^&
777/. zzzzz^g zzzzzzzz;^
zzzzz^
00777 zzztZt& ZZZZZzZZtZ^
zz-S
IIB11 ZZZZzZ^ zzZzZzzztZZZ^ ZZZZ^
^Q^ZZZZ ZZZZZZZZ^ ZZZZZZZZzfzZ ZZzzZZ^ zzzzzsez
z ZZZZ3& zzzzzZzzzs^^^
zzzzzgza
^StZZ^ ZZZZZZZ^ ZZZZZZzZ&izZZZZZZZZZSz zZZZas z^ ZZZZ^^ Zzzzz^
sOoisOlOi-loaiSO
ZZZZZSBZX^
ZZzZZ ZZz
tlistaTsaiiu^^^
BtitiSii: ;BI177^fZSzzzzz lU^ZzZz ^ZSSzZZ: 9SSzZZ
iiSB: IlSii iiSi
c,,v- 17BIO
z z zzzz z z z z
Zzz -ZzaZ z la/
1 .7
^szzzzz 7|77iafe ZZZZZiitZZZ
azaaa
AZAZ. ;
07:^
WIO IOI7 zzzSztXizz zzszziSfzSZZ Z- ZZ- ZZZ
WO77 ... xc ZA&SZZa zzzzSzZz lO
W-7; ' 171S 71S7 Zz^SZ OSO ^zzizz
77<V^:-;O
Z-Z-ZA zsszz 7 ZZ 7.. 7/: 7 ..',4 Z 7.7' aS^
VZ TZ ZzzSSzz Zz^zSZ -77I7 717 ZZil^zZ 77
^^ZZZZ AZi&ZS^
osso zSZSsZ Z-QBZz ZgSSzzzZ: fils
AA AT-
fiisio ZzzQZZ9gZZ- Oifio zslzz- zzSsZ ZZSzSKZZ zzgSz Sili Olia liait
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00036
n, <4 ;/, >'i, s'' 4 A^C'/a
1014 ?/x^3n;rxcn p,r7hyXCr ijr, "/
StafpBZ
O
"-4-
>11*11 ||
OEszziizzi:^
110
1I1A4
^>BK ^M ^gS3^
.'
. 4:x .
Battei
r.-'\ laiizzlii-zzzOlii81iBziiiiRwisz iiSSiOilz|
Bill liziil
Sit iSiii fizaaB
sSia* zfBiil fiaz
: I ; 'Z^-: S
4 SAV ^SSi liiiiazOSiSzfzzl^
SiOi zlilii Rial
11
Z.'Z'Z OiftlSiSl lliS S11B1S
i Zsz, z.^
lilzz
Ollzzz SS^ ^iiIif3 Zilz s^i &S-M RZZ;Z OiSVS lallte z0zJ38Z|ZiiiilZ oaawz ^lilBz -z zs : Zilfli-
Zlli|ZZB4,p|
Well
fzloR BilzIlfitill siili Oiiiii SS Sili zzizoili
S-llzi :SS^ lilli aiilz'ziiiii Sili -SSS gi& Sili SigaB tS
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00037
\ o:. ; ? i p':c..'Jj-7 f--f iiMfphk. Ph'-MrihydG-j. mJ Zs,'iV'l. g :u.k
9 - <j.
.i ;k-' PrL !
,". et Pkt. " i k ' :7 rk;.';.
'g--: j.i1' i, : *
y
PttiftiBSM
S9Kgl9i&:9 py g||ll|i^; ^iiiiiiySHpy 1ifgiPp_7P9i99S^ py-; llplpitli
9 9k9 <! 'j
'
P-7PP-C
rag^kk9k--99 % .......... ^999^^
^999k9<
............................
ayypyyyyyypyyi^^ ikS^
k^li&9g9K: llflilp ISSS^ , : -i.
O |W '
laea apyp 9kk9
7
;
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00038
. ju. '; . - 3 -'">' > : ' ,.1. ; .,;ri
G"; oB-RuO RrKGR
'.'^,5 ;,.r
OR - 3 Rh/Rr.1
g
9^
tlait Qnl
303009^^^^^^ istssiis^^
IggK^eta^^
llaitlili^
tler
facit
99999>
BtRlBlBB
99^
9g^^
98S-8gg^eBgSB 99Bgg^^
loea|3o3S^98B^^
99-gggSgligSg
99BB9^
g9B^9K9SiS99 999g9g8^
9&S^^
99BS8f^^ 999S93gB8g3g
99B8^sgiB
BSbiS^ 9^
89^98^^
Wiiiii
9999SSttSBBag
BB9^
99899999999999^ yBQQBi^
999g^
9Btg^^ ~ BgigB^^
99gff^
\;?l0331SSlfi3
99^999,g399S9SXt :9;3lB38Sffili g9gi9vS^ g^99OsS^
gBB9fi9gg^ 999iBSat989
B8Q9saB--^
xBlR'-R-c
>Wx333
Rsip^
99Bgg^^ B9Bg^^
:3iOs^ 999gB8^^
99g[ggg^
99gBBieBggg899 99^99^
9Bb3B^^
99B^SS99^
^iaetPSOSfiBffii^ ^fitatijsOHO"
.: ^S9TK99BBg9gBB
?3iO;99S<:^
^pg;a;3--<3
B998^^^
^S'3'39-^-;-:
XBS999Sg^^^^
;,' '
9B^
999B89B^
99a^BtBBS:
99BaS33ggggt999 99B9BfiSgBtB
9999B9g^S8SB99^999B9B93^^
99S98BSg3B8^^^^ 99g^^
99BXtQB9SlB9:
999B99Sg8^^ ?3BOi
9B9B^
99&9SS99SS9
99B9t^^
99i9gt&9gB
99BSfS&i8999B9g90S99S6B
99SSS8gSB99BBlSfc
33
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00039
pbiadh ?. Bara,,;- B- eue: Mviiid'i i ..rrvlilioB aurra far ManU.g vrcp >,Bavai /ana a- as'U n^-c- va.e -ea,.aavii :ai . hahjeta: avu'enai.-'1 Bn:B:ira !z n^-iair
(3^ ' '.a' .a aa
::
e: a^
B a a a
a -a
v>a. ;r aa' a, ' a a ` ,a a< ' av; >:. a.B ; ,p
; ; a a aw ' ' -a a ;
a - laa < -
". !
aCiSa
lwa<ep-
S-MPa ;;:a<'::
P-isstl^
::tiniii#ipa a : ' -P a^jtstgpco^
:th.:-rt .V .itf
:BBp
'ySti*9x-
lpl angriaiia aSffSMnjf: aisBiaa aBWaa B^dsiirs^B 99ia^
bBqSb
a -a? a
9 . ... .. . a ,. .. . . , a. a .
B93&^
Bqsqb
is bSB9
a aa a a
a aa
a a
a ;: a : a a a a
BSB&b
B9SBB-
l Btif iBWaa
> aaa:
bboBB
bB aaaaa
ailla Bail
BB:SBB9-:
BBBSBi
lai- lia Bill-: BBQs^ - . :a '
- -B 1 >
aa
1 .
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA
ED_001523_00003568-00040