Document evbxJMewJxKB26jJO0zY3Z0Zm
cc
Choosing the right compound for drywall joints
by Earl Maynard. Manager. U.S.G. Drywall Finishes Research
Since fhe advent of drywall construction in the early
1920's, manufacturers ond drywall contractors hove
wrestled with the problem of how to conceal and
reinforce the joint. Over the years many methods
hove been tried. Some were absolute failures and
others only relatively successful. Some products
olone do an adequate job while others in combination
do a superior job.
Unfortunately no one product solves any one problem
completely. The net result has been the development
of a family of nine dry powder and three reody-mixed
joint compounds. Each is designed
to do a specific job under a speci-
fi edition. Thus, the careful se
lection of the proper joint treatment
materials by the drywall contractor
is important to finished job results.
This report out I ines the basic types
of joint compounds, their composi
tion ond recommended usage. It is
hoped that through better under
standing ol the products, mony of your joint treatment problems will be solved. Bear in mind thot joint
JJEl.UJ,
-Ur-jiLl
ji !=
i itr.
treatment compounds for drywall Tf-jrr construe!ion have two primary func
tions: I) joint reinforcement and
*"i,i
2) joint conceclrnent.
History of Joint treatment
Ecrly joint treatment of SHEETROCK* Gypsum
Panels consisted of plaster of-poris forcoJ into
the joints. Severe creel ing invar- x A. *1
,
icbly occurred in nearly all joints.
This was followed by an ottempt lo ,__
reinforce the joint with a narrow
Cr` A 1----
cloth tape embedded in the plaster.
''V'V.t
The tope helped, but v,-us for from ""y/// liy I
satisfactory. Ir became clear that
a strong tope and o strong adhesive
compound werp needed to replace the brittle plaster.
One answer to the orobb-m was a zinc alloy tape
called Metal "A" introduced by U.S.G. It was
applied with a strong, "high alkaline" joint compound.
' The tape had large perforations and plenty of strength,
hut was expensive, hard to handle ond an outline of
the tnpe "pholoqtophej" thiough finish.-d walls.
Continued research eventual Introduced a higfi-
strength paper tape. It v.os eosy to handle and
inexpensive. Several modifications
have been n>eje Sin:e hut paper
loot.' iv still used universe1 i y for joint
reitd sreernent. from the ISM.O's to
the present, most dryw.ill construc
tion improvements iuvo been made in the t ompPUivis and .!;!. fyrrnotion o! the panels themselves.
Basic Types of Joint Compounds
Functionally there are three basic types of joint compounds in use today: taping (embedding) compounds, topping (finishing) compounds and all purpose (or multi-purpose) compounds. Each is designed for a specific purpose.
/Taping Compounds
_____1
A ^
fj*
IT***
A t\ \
1A 25 9
!
free"**:
Tap ing compounds, sometimes called embedding compounds, ore used to embed the joint tape. They have the greatest adhesive strength of oil the compounds. Since their function is to rein force the joint, they are fhe best products for this use. They ore also best for the first coat on metol corner bead ond trim. The strong bond also gives superior corner reinforce ment. Because of greater adhesive strength they con be thinned slightly for use with mechanical taping tools. Taping compounds are also frequently used for first coat application on fastener heads. They may be used for finishing coats but they're border to sand.
Topping Compounds
r
L_ _.i
Topping or finishing compounds are used for the fill uiid final roots over the embedding compound
to fully concecl the joint area, fas tener heads, corner bead and trim. To finish for decorating, two coats
of conventional topping compound are required. Deep fills ond poor drying conditions sometimes make additional coats necessary.
SZOdO
* ^ .p I u- ! . * V f \ junJ'- i ivivr: u |!
'tit . '.) f il
** orvi ` v : " t'J 'c?nd. ISvy :ro <( ?n*-j K i..tve itirf l.-.'st *.. '-. v I - i 11 ty in louls, 'm.-.'N i:<.".t l.'itur*' rind dir I :!. .--;l*. fhey nri.` I lie Lust products for linisiui'i join;*, since th^y'ir spec i li cal I y du'.igncd for t Iris , Hire: ost.'.
All-cutcc:'.1 Compounds
All-purpose* compounds offer (lie convenience of a reinforcing, fin ishing or a texturing compound in one package. However, all-purpose compounds ere a compromise be tween the Superior bonding quality of a taping compound end the supe rior finishing properties of topping compounds.
What's in a Joint Compound? Casein Compounds
Joint compounds, in essence, are wuter-based adhesives. Until the 1950's all joint compounds were casein-based, dr/ powder products.: Tadcy cc-seirrccmpourds-ore-Mill used-fn mcnyAirecs, ^ ^ including PERF'vA'-TA'Pt'GoVnpO'jnds, but they one rapidly be ivd replaced by either ready-mixed compounds, non-casein compounds or herdeningtype compounds.
Casein is the glue that binds the inert fillers and tape to the gypsum wallboard. Casein is a natural product separated from skim milk; once it is separated and dried for use in joint compounds, it will not dissolve in water. To serve its pur pose, however, it must dissolve when the joint compound is stirred into water. Since casein will dissolve in alkaline solutions, joint compound formulae incorporate alkaline re acting salts in small amounts. When the compound is mixed with water, the salts dissolve and produce the alkalinity to dissolve the casein.
Eorly casein-based joint compounds were commonly called "high-alkaline" compounds. A heavy concentration of alkoli salts in the compound dissolved the casein quickly, even in cold water. However, the alkali reacted with certain types of paints, referred to as "burn-through."
Burn-through, and other problems related to high alkalinity, led to development of "low-alkaline," ca sein-based joint compounds. Most manufacturers simply reduced the amount of alkali. U.S.G. changed the-entire alkaline solvent system to a mild ammonia type which evaporates during drying. There is no alkali left to cause decorating problems.
'n
Lhiir") ng i lv . nV- .. m t ir-n i* I n c _*rn::.jtjnd irvi IV*
f'*rT.iil<i lo 'inn'ti' i oilrn present', new piobien
; t'o
lew -clkol liv
*i :nd*., wlii I tIvy
don't but n t!' cu h. iv o two trill' r -
cut discnjvnntu <5 . Pecowe of iow alkalinity, the comA: n binder tukes
lonmv to dissolve, especially in
cold v/nti'i . That's why most monu-
focturers specify a 3Q-rnin. soaking
period. Another problem: most ca
sein compounds will thin cut Dr water-down when
they stand for Icing periods after mixing.
r
These disadvantages led to development of non--:
casiifn compounds. Adhesive binders in these powder compounds require no alkaline sol
vent. The binders themselves ore
water soluble. Non-casein com pounds are uscble os soon as they
ere adequately mi.\ed--and usually
stable against thinning out. The
non-casein compounds have the ad vantages of both the high- and low-
alkaline casein compounds and none
of their disadvantages. These compounds are rcpidly
replacing the casein types.
Ready-mixed Compounds
J------
The finest ond certainly the fas
test growing joint compound in the
industry is the ready-mixed com
pound. The manufacturer has teken
the responsibi I i ty of mixing the com
pound too smooth, lump-free consis
tency. There are many obvious ad
vantages in ready-mixed--no need to find and carry
water, no mixing, no waiting. Agplication of ready-
mixed, compared to casein powder compounds, is
"slicker." Ready-mixed has superior crack resistance
and ease of handling in tools. It is truly an all
purpose type product, but superior to casein powder
all-purpose compounds. Ready-mix usually has better
adhesion without excessive hardness for sanding.
Vinyl-type binders give ready-mix many of these
properties.
/, _ .... ................. - - .
Drying- and Hardening-type Compounds
There are two basic forms of joint compounds--the drying type ond the hardening type. The dryingtype joint compound must dry by evaporation of water to become hard and develop full adhesion. Drying time depends almost entirely on the temperature and humid ity. Little can be done by manufacturers to speed
8 ZOdD
--orxax.
tr s'yiw down the drying rote. All
pounds will dry
`fast on a warm, dry dav and very sk .y on a cold,
damp day (see"Drying Standards" on page 4).
Drying compounds shrink when they dry. Some
formulations shrink more than others--but they a]_|
shrink. The shrinkage problem led
to development of hardening-type
compounds . . . minimal shrinkage
compounds. After compounds chem
ically harden they do not shrink --
thus are extremely valuable in deep
fills such as on metal corner bead
and in openings around pipes, etc.
The primary value of hardening-type compounds.
35 )
such os DURABOND* Joint Compound--Taping, and
DURABOND 90 Joint Compound, is the shorter time
required to finish joints. As soon os the DURABOND
Taping lies hardened--usually less than 4 hours--topping coat moy be
applied (DURABOND90 hardens in
approximctely 90 min.). This brief
time period is especially valuable
in cold, damp weather when it is often necessary to wait several days before drying-type compounds are
ready for another coot. With proper
job sciiedul ing ond adequate man
power, the three-coat joint treatment on SHEETROCK
SW Panels can be completed in a single day. This is sometimes considered impractical or unnecessary. But
frequently, pre-filling, taping end fill coats may be
applied the first day and final topping coat the second.
USG " Joint Compound--All Purpose, U5G Joint Compound--Topping, USG Ready-Mixed Joint Com pound-All Purpose or USG Ready- ^7,,^ .
Mixed Joint Compound--Topping are recommended for the final coat over DURABOND. These products are
'''5
easier to sand ond touch up forfinul decoration. They clso give a more even suction across the joint. Thus,
V t-
I
hardenir.g-lype compounds vri11 not reduce the number of coats, but they give considerably more assurance that no more than three coats are
-i L.
requiied, evert in slow-drying weother.
DUivABOND XL Joint Compound is cn exterior joint
treatment formulation in powder form far pre-filling,
embedding tope and linishirn joints of USG Exterior Gy O',urn Ceilir.n Coard--clsj far tilling holes in board '.urinous, t I induing ond filling metal accessories and fusti usi heads. Unlit.other DURABOND compounds,
DURABOND XL is formu
lated for all three joint-
treatment coot* --embed
ding, filling and finishing, if necessary. However, each coat
must be applied witliK 'fcssional smoothness in order to ovoid sanding ana\..iishing. DURABOND XL Joint Compound hardens in from 30 to 60 min.
The advantages of a hardening-type product are most obvious in slow-drying weather. But what happens when DURABOND Joint Compound is used on a hot, dry doy, and dries before it hardens? In such cases a normal amount of shrinkage occurs--about equal to that of ready-mix or casein powder compounds. In other words, DURABOND will perform about the same as a conventional drying-type joint compound. DURABOND Joint Compound--Taping, DURABOND 90 and DURABOND XL Compounds are U.S.G.'s hardening-type prod ucts that a skilled drywall mechanic can use effectively. They provide the opportunity to gain speed and quality where his job calls for it. At the same time, he can accommodate a wider range of job conditions.
Compatibility of Joint Compounds
As described cbove, each joint compound i. de
signed to provide a distinct job result. Each product within each line is designed to ac
complish a specific job result. The chemistry of each line frequently
|f
differs and is often incompatible if*
with cnother line. The incompati-
bil ity arises when products from dis-
'
similar lines become intermixed--
either in the mixing container or
j\
on the wall. Complete loss of bond
/ \\
or impossible application properties can be evidence
of contcmination.
Cosein compounds generally are incompatible with
non-casc-in compounds and with hardening-type joint compounds. While cosein formulas
are fairly tolerant of ready-mixed
formulations, the two lints were
never intended to, nor should they
be mixed together.
The aryv-oll contractor should be
aware of the need for job cleanliness .. .cleanliness of mixing con-
1111
LI 1 \
tamers, tools water, et cetera. With
the introduction and use of new product lines, job
cleanliness becomes increasingly important to the
Joint Treatments for the Future
Every manufacturer is looking hard for new answers to gypsum drywnll joint tieatmenf problems. This is true at U.S.G.'s Research Center where the most recent developments--SHEETROCK SW and its companion, DURABOND 90, were developed and released for manufacture. New joint compounds and techniques are now being developed for the manufactured liomc industry w-here panel joints must be firmhed in a matter of hours instead of days.
Perhaps the future will see a practical and effective one-coat joint treatment system.
o X o ra
00