Document emrqoeaaqZKE8BK3R6rVZQdG9

^Hi^H^HIH^^M^^^^^^^^^^^mMenncilvetlforinorathuona 2. Ilia tibia ofcontent* forPut 101- , rjLnuimurr urotauTtotc Th* fur. CinctQlsnthliacconntibl* ..lteamendttlbyrevtiliijthefollowtea -Gen*r*lBV**Adn>lnltiitkx)h** tmuportitiondocnnmtwilletimlniti antrtu: a" J;/-4MM**.;;Ol(01)tO^U-*-tO:IW m. mum :\ i ' . .v'l ' v. v-` 14119 Rbk "SitBiBcmaP . tbeSopteme w (Indtutria! *CIOw. tUtuteUSVS. iortotmiBceof irdngulatlng :otadc gniflccnTrlik fttasdtidwill rUJt. ti* appropriate diHerrat factor* latteoof lltgtVBMO* haproceutob* fell white tha (finding with ilaorecognteed * tat a particoter * inftrillba JconshSerattea* (.050,0.02). footnote, tba ennination of baud on* ftbriik.Tbe ilbfllly to icawnatft nriUtuSama laadodwratr* xamptetha riapcnoowffl drink oT ,Ji daart7 coaidoot hithaothtrbtadL aandtbat^falar r*thfttr2* ME? tMKesq. : anjuaje leagiven wax# . timt. Itapeak* rhlchtapllci aubstantlal totbeuodda lie"* The Court the significant odbytht (: lematical Wa not required fitfiriRcant approaching revtewtag court eimywMit on tba wiidsrland ,.i fraatocaa a fa tnlaipfatlflj ardnogcu. wmrmomv - I!.WillMliDMx.30MUmTMoto iooSTpropSttybBlTlUi tnUUiuuftdlbrttNtvUhn iMdnfoBains ..S4M9M ^CO(0]X0MrK-M-10!tM3) . ' Jam *. nan ,* . .* ' /i . 1 vi .'V1''-yt-" '' ' */ '".t"''* 1 . . '>' '''* ,.'*-- ? ,V" * -. - ' *14120 .??fiJinl Register / Veil W, Na 70 / Tuesday, April iq IBM / Proposed Rule, &______L! -' >;;-CTerprobtUon niftier Bum anto- " VlndDdaaxceaa mortality from aabealoab - And finally, OSHA believe* that ft ^protection (4BS US. at 655, 656V Vverother cancer*. OSHA did not attempt ' aaed the moat appropriate eardeb to ' OSHA hi. followed there fuldeUne* * * to quantity the risk forcatxxr sites other celcobte die ibk*. OSHA traed a Hnear ';'51n assessing the algnlllcinc* of the rbk then the lung, meaotbaUum end dowtetpoc* model In calculating the f}afmetertal beelth Impairment that >. tutrointeitineltrectiUehouldbe noted tlika for lungcancer. OSHAbelieve* . tS-faMb from aebeato* exposure. OSHA** that at all the reducedtent, forwhkh _ tU* model U appropriate bectu** dote- , .'t'VqtiantluthrailikanetnaentcooceRilng calculetlonsarer* done, the realduel .V rttpona* Information derived bom ;*aabeato* txpoaun 1* baaed on oxtenelv* excess cancerrisks atffl exceed the ' I'aeverel epidemiologic etudlee Indicate* ; r.aiddmce(Gx.M-3SZl.Intaitepart.thl* SupremeCourt* rough guideline oft per : that riek ofelbetloadndoced cencer , rt;etettm*nt ha* taprtaabt evidentiary 7. thousandlihthne rbk cd dying vrhlch \-i Increeaa* linearlywith total doea, weight becauee R rallea upon atodlea of ' wee euggeated aa an example ofa risk i indodlng ttadlee by Hendetatmand .'<s^ ioman worter population, and Include* arhlcfaerttaonabtapetacvt might wall . .! Enterline (1970. Ex. BKltS). UddeU et ai * A- avxrtatyofIndustrialsituations. C.-JecoalderetaniBcant, ii 11B77, Ex. M-058), and Demant et al vk processes. and fiber type*. Further, the OSHA ha* alao estimated th* rbk of 4 (1883b Ex. 64437]. Further. OSHA note* , predicted ttanlb of thb quantitative * the tncldtnce ofaabeatosbet to * that other adentbb and edentUlc f'&aaaeeemmlofilikatlowernqMniea ' 7,errmrtpembtlbl*level of2 f/cc. '{ group* each at Crump (Ex. 8V4122). the , ere couabtentwith etudlee whlch ;>'OSHA'ebnt Mtimate Ubewd on the ,, Envimomantal Protection Agency (EPA) . obMned exceia rhk at eittmated or '^renlteofa hl^i quality atody at en 1? (Ex. M-180) and d Chronic Hazard -,;;weeeiiT*dlowcam^we*poeore* V; adicitoacemeiit tectotyIn Ontarioto J Advbory Pine! en Aabaato*of tb* ;; The eoochulon olel^dBcem rUk U >-datennInetbelncldencaofcosip*nwbl* ConeamerProduct Safety Commbdon . '- fartheregpported by examining OSHA*. (certmed) aibntoeie rFlokeletetn. b. (CHAP] (Ex. M-2S8) and AchcHo and v^walj^ngTOdtoteipntatonoIge ; )). A Unetr model cmnnlatir* 1 Cerdnirofthe BritWi AdvUonr . .-gwjntitatlvw Hm^en derlered Eromtfw 'axpoamawaeued to general* tharlik Committee on Aeberto* (Ex. Bt-243). :A 5*^ OSHA eirehjiled theee .jihuted. OSHA atUmated an -indata to the It^tt ofconeideratkxia euch .' t.loddecceforaabeatoalaor , >>. hen aleo choeen the linearmodel to prtjdktlmgcancermortelllirdiiato . *atheeMtmandktodcddlMaK! ' ;*pproxtmatahrSOpeeiawocket ; ,**; aebeetoeeroomira.'niut.OSHA'a _ .^prodqcedandtheeppu^ntateneaacddK) axpoaedto21/ccto5ream. -*.**tlmat*eolab*ito*-ieUtedlong J^ectogdwdgnl&k . ~ reetonehb. .. *. determliutioa eoch a. comperijoa of 'the rbk bom aahaatoa expoasra with ^iylyotheroccupational ibka: the regubtory ' >2tia*tment accorded to ridta of aimllir . <-JA magnitude and kind and the extent to ...'v-wtudi Caagreta and th* publichav* ; '. .axpnrtaed their concern with the rltk* .' : eeiulting from eibejtoe expo.tire. . . OSHA** rbk eedmetee predict a rbk .^af01 excete cancerdeethe (Indodlng ,* With regard to meiothelloma rbk, A land and even lowerb pudculaily VOSHA ballevee that an abaohrte ibk atrong. Rret the undeHyiqgdab upon :* ajodel provide, the beat mean* to ariikh die qoentUatlir*rtik aaaetamast ^atlmab tuch tbka. A* explained by tire >for*ab**to#bbaaed*retbereull*of peeemble to the ET8, atwolcb rltk for 'whi^KiLalitjr epidemiologic etodle* :. -meaotheUoma b calculated a* obterved ">]'-i caomoddroacstmedentotao.Tcrhabpagtilvoec*aOl SHA great deatha/paraao-yean at rbk (4g FR 'S (1129). Becaua* of the extreme rarity of : fcooBdence thatfire eaUmateaoIibka derived from theta atodlea are - - dbaait abeerrt ahaeato* expoaato. me ofStendtrdbed Mottahty Ratloa ,.j efkmg.meaotheUoma, andgaatrointtrtnal tepraeanbttva ofactualworkplace 'V..'>*Jj-j Mcp4ae*inyrimecoeatbhrl]enpl,UbeobrwmIejOoaxOrprkOboinewkgtrobrlir*fkpeliermteirm*ditaiecor.tmre2doafa/ecadcIaBftotehe^:.1.a-eptnhoonatnaatdndclttwPblofdyoaic*hbcSbtuefapicMqaoutniidoafo.nliOtrayalS.ciHHbaeArwcHeinmotohapgahaenanrmee*looteaf.*t ? aM*othetkxna.n^*SbUl b ealetdatad ->* the obaemd numberofdeath* In th* ______ Hon divided by the : narnberofdtatha that wouIld bfe .e...-'-nibixkicoebuunddeedr--aslctjheteeeprdrea.raaU-t4-D-2-4OfaO/cxwcco.erluknendrge*actahnscneert.;*ni,;'doa- aoxhaxaaoanotooguahahlyoafcsocbrnaapavanau.ah.o.t.iun.a.ad.t.itl.oe.p.nd.o.oo.p..tfu.tl.Ual.a.n.at.ialofnend*c.b .-.-.napactad In theaxpoaed popubtloaThe ;.*pectad number oldaalhab derived vfromtha mortality rate from a apectfic * *'V.!fU/cOeO.OEwxocerilt*md^WSabeodm*vte!tirior*lntot*2itinal f*teTmhalrtia. tdhbeavbaalitdaiotytmotdfeterarctmoelebdobfyfta ..caoaa in an appropibb comparbon . population.The mortalityrata from . vV; cancer are predicted ae about 4 per UOOO -rrdattvrdyconabtentsttliBateaofdoae* r meaothahomabdoae torero in moat workeT! expoied to 2 f/cc fee 45 year!. repoc!e.The range, olKt (the potency popubttone agefaut which aebeatot animate* auum*drat dte avarag*ag* at fnltbloccrgbdonal ! y;*po*u b 2S. aa dbcutud In j. faaot6*lu--n--g--c--a--n--c-e--r-r-l*a*k-MEx.M^ worker, have been compared.)This fara detailedexplanation) aa areU : modal la also different from that used ?y-adrange* ofK. (Cor meaotheUoma farhmg cancer because both duration of !') Ex. 84^82.1 * Urn* tine* Initial exposure and duration - : OSHA aim. ywer* overlapping. As deacrlbed In the .^ptbum^mo^d.bndn.Hvao, ' frerulong cancer. meeotheUoaa < yEI& OSHA'*bnt eadmab ofdw ;j^,lj.**atrolnt**tlnalcancer at various -potney factorKtbOOL but en y- fn aum. and aa OSHA pointad out In - A- potentblPEla.IntummiryforTn.fot* -' y appropriate estimate o!Kicould Ue dwEIS.OSHAhaaaatimatadthatat i:; working lilttime ofexpoeure. the . between0003end &01 OSHAbelieve, : th*present 2f/ccIavaLafflployaea : *. eatimatea oflifetime riik ere: 17ertceaa " 'vthtt the agreement bgood among tha Ki axpoaed over a vrotkteg Ulettma ofS `V;' deethe perUOOO avorker* et a IkS f/cc t valuta considering the dUltrtnl yaera an predlctad to have an axcaa* '' PEL,7*xceaadeathaperlDavnrkara u, statisticalpowara of the atndles and tha , rbk ofdying bom cancer of04 in tOOO jji.-at 03f/ec PEL and3 excea* death, per dlHersnt type, of wotkplacaa atudlad. , and olcontracting dlMbling end often v; AUOOO worker, at a Oil f/cc PEL. Tbtaa ' Similarly, a reUttvalynarrow rtnge (a ; fatal asbeatosbofSO in 1000. OSHA ..-`ji-aatlmatea indud* only cxcaaa mortality '-factor ofto) repreatabth* ; baliavaa that each of dim tiaka are . lung cancer, meiothelloma. and ' ^meaotheliaairbkpredlctadbytbtfour significant and tmaccapbble. Rlaka at -ratftatrotobaUnileanear.anddonot :-% *tndb* aaed...t.s...c..a...l.c..u...h..b--K* 'the 2f/cc leva! hava been acknowledged .'r#;KU99 ]'004t00X0^Am-(4-ttMia0 '.4<*aae .aw. aoe <1 / Fedarxl R*td*be / Vol 40, No. 70 / Toeadey, April la IBM / Propoied Rales *,. Xb*toladeofinformation on these - ., abeatnabraktsanddutdtfadngafat -'laxposurs willhavsoccurred, workers.OSHA has not included them ~ ttanearfatur*. . -:.y RwtheTrnot*.b*catjatoIthalooiUttnci -X-rt'iadwacoooadcanalyab.Mialaaqt ; Fiberglasshasbaan seed s*a -, ssaodabd avlthaabestoeetbud v bformetloaforthbfrtwp of ~.- aubadtabgbartofaihaataalnmany dbeaaet.thaUnkbataretnoccupaSan f'} mefnlentnc*atariten b erelbhbin th* feoducta.Rooflngfalb,plpdlnaftlta. ..'oddlaaaaabcooaldBrablyUaiclaar. /is JSBetady(Ex. 44-3B3).Tb# effected and a^ibaltcoattiphave allbean . . PorthamaJoeUyofworitatawhobava ; actta caaatmctlon avoold tndodrSIC produced using gher^aaafnplace of '-CM atit.the basisfortha lags! action / ' IKUCaearalBuOdlngContmctora, tt&pri-nrbriitb ^ SsSs:l5KASSSyto SkigbFamily Houats; SIC 1S22, General - c^BalkBnt Contractors, Other Than 8ingla -~i: family HonaecSlClKtUOptratiira .1. ri'f Budders; SIC 1S4U GanwilBuUdlng fs 'v, ConttracUoRtlndnatrialBulldlngsand > C SSSS5 -War*ooset:SIClS12,G*n*Tal0ullding ? Gnatructloa OtherthanInduatrUl 'ffaMlnga andWarehotaeetSIG1823. >1 Water,Sawer,Plprilna.Cocmailcatloq '. tnanyotherauUblulamateibb ndPowtrlln*Cctiuctlon:81ClS28; - havebeen achieved, ^** Heavy Cooetraction; SIC 171U Ptxmhlr* Haatieg(Except EbctrlmlkandAtr .' C Ncttttf] JninyEiirltaumd , aetimated thetfor the 1800-2015period Mthegtoftfafal eSxpaec4te4d dir^e5ctwOnwtnMcbtl KabdityfarthtaecompanltaarlUb* may , /. K>t3&A22 bbiUllioknm[rE8xx. B.u4--m12A).aAala . , y eonaaquanc*. tb* debt ratiega ofmany '-.V'JrfthaixwnenbabvoJvadtwv* fallen E4J4999 OOUCOIXOt-Arft-M-tftIM*) fm ivk non - S434999 *P M. WO