Document emGbG0O0ZqrZ3xwgJBnQv06Yp
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT
UC-P-144
r a ft. k. Huwei i
Date: Sept
Fr am: F
Ber g er
oub j fCt:
NH3 3 till Insulatior i
Uri Sunday morning, Septaiiiber DIO, 1V92 at approximately 8; UU mII, ui 1 1 v Campbell , Wi n-- Wav ins/i-isb Supervi sor > called to i nf or m me that, whi 1 e removi ng insulation from the f-immania Still in the Oxide Derivatives Unit., hi a or ew encounter ud a different tvpe of insulation on cuie area of the column. He stated over the telephone that hie t- e 1 L this i ri5i.il a Li on m a > be asbestos.
I in s t r u c t e d him to not disturb that area u t insulation, but to proceed with insulation removal in the areas that were not in guos L j on. i-ilso an enclosure should be star ted being constructed a.r ound the suspect area. Since another job was goirig to be started at midnight that night, I told hi 1 in I would come out and check hot hi jobs at t hi at 11 ii i -.
Inipt.'Ctioii of the ifunnon i a Still thiat night showed 3 to 7 1 i near' root of l ri sli i at. i on was different from the remui i ider ui the colurrin. 1 Ine contr actor" had wrapped the suspect insulation wi thi plastic, to seal i L for pro tec 1.1 oi'i, and was wel j. Linder wav wi Lli construction u+ t h e on c 1 o s u r" e.
hi samp 1 e of the material was obtained that night and sent to Houston at noon, Monday, September 2!l, 1992, for an analysis, Resul t s were received at o that evening arid shiowed an asbestos content of lu". to 2u"i.
The enclosure was complete and the asbestos insulation was stripped Wednesday, September 23, 1992.
029563
h
,^
b
+\T
5t XL
-j Ai r-- ^*J rF- cQ 1") ^"1 X
i
*a -V
> t
^.
* -c
'A0 V
`V
J
o
w Z
* * * 0 o
Weti/os /' <U>AJ+fli*->*f
V)
. S 15 0#
>
029698
"2
c --N _J o O5
cC w
O
<2 ;
>*., ,
c-.^^ -
t> ^ rA
oan
<50 _
v f?!;'
?")- !? ^20 it J
U)
'J
\r> -J <c f~
fC3
1
029699
LABORATORY & CONSULTING SERVICES
REPORT TO: UNION CARBIDE P.O. BOX 186 PORT LAVACA
ATTENTION: CAL JONES
BULK ASBESTOS SAMPLE ANALYSIS REPORT REPORT DATE: 10/31/90
TEST METHOD: 40 CFR CH. I (1-1-87 EDITION) PT 763,
TX 77979
ANALYST SIGNATURE
KEVCO JOB NUMBER: DATE RECEIVED: DATE ANALYZED:
CLIENT SAMPLE ID: PROJECT ID:
SAMPLE LOCATION:
IS THE SAMPLE HOMOGENEOUS?
DOES IT CONTAIN LAYERS?
IS THE SAMPLE FIBROUS?
SAMPLE COLOR:
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90
K BTGTL
YES NO YES | WHITE
SAMPLE CONTAIN ASBESTOS FIBERS? NO
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90 BUCBJ #1
YES NO YES WHITE
NO
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90 BUCBJ *2
YES | NO
TES WHITE
J NO
-
ASBESTOS TYPE AND PERCENT: TOTAL PERCENT ASBESTOS: FIBROUS MATERIALS AND PERCENT: NONF1BROUS CONSTITUENTS: DEVIATION FROM TEST METHGO:
1
j 0 PERCENT
| 0 PERCENT
I 0 PERCENT
| CELLULOSE
40 - 50 J CELLULOSE
35 - 45 | CELLULOSE
40 - 50
| BINDER-FILLER
| BINDER-FILLER
| BINDER-FILLER
||
|
- THIS TEST REPORT RELATES ONLY TO THE ITEMS TESTED AND MUST NOT BE REPRODUCED EXCEPT WITH THE APPROVAL OF THE LABORATORY.
- ALL SAMPLES WILL BE DISPOSED OF 90 DAYS FOLLOWING SAMPLE RECEIPT UNLESS OTHERWISE INSTRUCTED BY THE CLIENT.
- UNDER CURRENT EPA REGULATIONS, AN "ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL" CONTAINS MORE THAN ONE PERCENT ASBESTOS.
Kevco SERVICES INC. 890 PITTSBURGH ROAD BUTLER, PA 16001
TEL 412-586-6343 FAX 412-58S-2172
029700
LABORATORY & CONSULTING SERVICES
BULK ASBESTOS SAMPLE ANALYSIS REPORT
REPORT DATE: 10/31/90
REPORT TO: UNION CARBIDE P.O. BOX 186 PORT LAVACA
ATTENTION: CAL JONES
TX 77979
ANALYST SIGNATURE:
KEVCO JOB HUMBER: DATE RECEIVED: DATE ANALYZED:
CLIENT SAMPLE ID: PROJECT ID:
SAMPLE LOCATION:
1156* 10/31/90 10/31/90
BUCS #1
IS THE SAMPLE HOMOGENEOUS? DOES IT CONTAIN LAYERS? IS THE SAMPLE FIBROUS? SAMPLE COLOR:
YES NO YES TAN
SAMPLE CONTAIN ASBESTOS FIBERS? NO
1156*
O'
10/31/90 V 10/31/90
-
sues *2 ..." ;
1156*-;/-
10/31/90
10/31/90
...
I-#1 STGTL
ir:.
ASBESTOS IN GRAY CAP ONLY**--..'
YES
NO YES
| TAN-GRAY
- -
"1 yes
'
NO
1 YES
WHITE
YES '
' - -0 '
no ;
ASBESTOS TYPE AND PERCENT: TOTAL PERCENT ASBESTOS: FIBROUS MATERIALS AND PERCENT:
NONFIBROUS CONSTITUENTS: DEVIATION FROM TEST METHOD:
|
j CHRYSOTILE
< IX
`
0 PERCENT
LESS THAN 1 PERCENT |
0 PERCENT ; ;
FIBROUS GLASS 20 - 30
CELLULOSE
01 - 02
FIBROUS GLASS 25 - 35 1 CELLULOSE
CELLULOSE SYNTHETIC
< ix 01 - 05 I
35 - *5
BINDER-PERLITE
1 BINDER-PERLITE MATRIX
1 BINOER-FILLER
_l 1
______ 1
- THIS TEST REPORT RELATES ONLY TO THE ITEMS TESTED AND MUST NOT BE REPRODUCED EXCEPT WITH THE
APPROVAL OF THE LABORATORY.
'
- ALL SAMPLES WILL 8E DISPOSED OF 90 DAYS FOLLOWING SAMPLE RECEIPT UNLESS OTHERWISE INSTRUCTED BY THE CLIENT.
- UNDER CURRENT EPA REGULATIONS, AN "ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL" CONTAINS MORE THAN ONE PERCENT .
ASBESTOS.
. :
*1 MATRIX OF SAMPLE DISSOLVED IN TETRAHYDROFURAN, HEATED, EVAPORATED, THEN ANALYSIS CONTINUES ACCORDING ; c TO TEST METHOO
KCVCO SERVICES INC. 890 PITTSBURGH ROAD BUTLER, PA 16001
TEL 412-586-6343 FAX 412-586-2172
029701
Kevco
LABORATORY & CONSULTWG SERVICES
REPORT TO: UNION CARBIDE P.O. BOX 186 PORT LAVACA
ATTENTION: CAL JONES
BULK ASBESTOS SAMPLE ANALYSIS REPORT
REPORT DATE: 10/31/90
TX 77979
TEST METHOD: 40 CFR CM. I (1-1-87 EDITION) PT 763, SLEPT. F APP. A. PAGES 293-299.
<LANALYST SIGNATURE IS_____
kL
PAUL BURN -
>
r-
KEVCO J08 NUMBER: DATE RECEIVED: DATE ANALYZED:
CLIENT SAMPLE ID: PROJECT 10:
SAMPLE LOCATION:
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90
BTG #3
IS THE SAMPLE HOMOGENEOUS? DOES IT CONTAIN LAYERS? IS THE SAMPLE FIBROUS? SAMPLE COLOR:
YES NO | YES | PINK
SAMPLE CONTAIN ASBESTOS FIBERS?
NO
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90
BTG #4
"ASBESTOS IN GRAY CAP AND SAMPLE**
YES NO ;
YES GRAY
..YES '
. .. ...
....
|
i i
--
'(
ASBESTOS TYPE AND PERCENT: TOTAL PERCENT ASBESTOS: FIBROUS MATERIALS AND PERCENT: NONFIBROUS CONSTITUENTS: DEVIATION FROM TEST METHOD:
0 PERCENT
SYNTHETIC
10 - 20
CHRYSOTILE AMOSITE
TOTAL:
SYNTHETIC
01 - 05 40 - 50 | 41 - 55 | 01 - "1
BINDER-PERLITE
BINDER-MATRIX
J______________ :_____________
*1 - ,
|
i fl j 1
- THIS TEST REPORT RELATES ONLY TO THE ITEMS TESTED AND MUST NOT BE REPRODUCED EXCEPT UITH THE
APPROVAL OF THE LABORATORY.
- ALL SAMPLES WILL BE DISPOSED OF 90 DAYS FOLLOWING SAMPLE RECEIPT UNLESS OTHERWISE INSTRUCTED BY
THE CLIENT.
- UNDER CURRENT EPA REGULATIONS, AN "ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL"-CONTAINS MORE THAN ONE PERCENT
ASBESTOS.
' - .. .
" '<s ..
*1 MATRIX OF SAMPLE DISSOLVED IN TETRAHYDROFURAN, HEATED, EVAPORATED, THEN ANALYSIS CONTINUES ACCORDING
TO TEST NETHOO
f?
i "
Kevco SERVICES INC. 890 PITTSBURGH ROAD BUTLER, PA 16001
TEL 412-586-6343 FAX 412-586-2172
029702
LABORATORY & CONSULTING SERVICES
REPORT TO: UNION CARBIDE P.0. BOX 186 PORT LAVACA
ATTENTION: CAL JONES
BULK ASBESTOS SAMPLE ANALYSIS REPORT
REPORT DATE: 10/31/90
TEST KETHOO: 40 CFR CK. I (1-1-87 EDITION) PT 763, SU8PT. F APP. A. PAGES 293-299.
TX 77979
PAUL nurn :
.=;iv
KEVCO JOB NUMBER: DATE RECEIVED: DATE ANALYZED:
CLIENT SAMPLE ID:
PROJECT ID:
;
SAMPLE LOCATION:
IS THE SAMPLE HOMOGENEOUS? DOES IT CONTAIN LAYERS? IS THE SAMPLE FIBROUS? SAMPLE COLOR:
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90
SUC8 #7
ASBESTOS IN GRAY CAP ONLY**
YES
NO
YES GRAY
.
SAMPLE CONTAIN ASBESTOS FIBERS? YES -
/
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90
BTG #1
11564
..
10/31/90
'
10/31/90 >^ r
--
YES NO YES PINK
. 1
-
YES .
j NO
J
YES I PINK: .
' .. rV-
NO
ASBESTOS TYPE AND PERCENT: TOTAL PERCENT ASBESTOS: FIBROUS MATERIALS AND PERCENT:
NONFIBROUS CONSTITUENTS:
DEVIATION FROM TEST METHGO:
| CHRYSOTILE
< IX
| LESS THAN 1 PERCENT
j
0 PERCENT
1
| 0 PERCENT .
j CELLULOSE
75 - 85 j SYNTHETIC
10 - 20 j CELLULOSE SYNTHETIC
< IX 15 - 25
| BINDER-MATRIX PERLITE
1 BINDER-PERLITE
j BINDER-PERLITE
| *1
__1
'
' ' -
`'
- THIS TEST REPORT RELATES ONLY TO THE ITEMS TESTED AND MUST NOT BE REPRODUCED EXCEPT WITH THE
APPROVAL OF THE LABORATORY.
.
' --
.. .:v.
-
- ALL SAMPLES WILL BE DISPOSED OF 90 DAYS FOLLOWING SAMPLE RECEIPT UNLESS OTHERWISE INSTRUCTED 8Y^ ; i.
THE CLIENT.
'*
> ..
- UNDER CURRENT EPA REGULATIONS. AN "ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL" CONTAINS MORE THAN (WE PERCENT/;'
ASBESTOS.
;
*1 MATRIX OF SAMPLE DISSOLVED IN TETRAHYDROFURAN, HEATED, EVAPORATED, THEN ANALYSIS i^TINUES~ACCORDING
TO TEST METHOO
' `
' y.-Y- -
- > TK*IrTv.
-' *
^
Ksvco SERVICES INC. 890 PITTSBURGH ROAD BUTLER, PA 16001
TEL 412-S88-6343 FAX 412-S86-2172
029703
evco
LABORATORY & CONSULTING SERVICES
REPORT TO: UNION CARBIDE P.O. BOX 186 PORT LAVACA
ATTENTION: CAL JONES
BULK ASBESTOS SAMPLE ANALYSIS REPORT
REPORT DATE: 10/31/90
TEST METHOO: 40 CFR CM. I (1-1-87 EDITION) PT 763, SU8PT. F APP. A. PAGES 293-299.
TX 77979
ANALYST SIGNATURE: PAUL BURN
KEVCO JOB NUMBER: DATE RECEIVB): DATE ANALYZED:
CLIENT SAMPLE ID: PROJECT ID:
SAMPLE LOCATION:
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90
BUCB84
IS THE SAMPLE HOMOGENEOUS? DOES IT CONTAIN LAYERS?
| YES NO
IS THE SAMPLE FIBROUS?
YES
SAMPLE COLOR:
BROUN
SAMPLE CONTAIN ASBESTOS FIBERS?
NO
-
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90
BUC8 85 7
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90
BUC8 86
1 ASBESTOS IN GRAY..;, CAP ONLY**
YES ; no . ;
J YES . - 1W
YES YES':
BROWN-GRAY.
BROWN -
-| YES ,
NO ^
'
*
ASBESTOS TYPE AND PERCENT:
1 CHRYSOTILE
<1X j
TOTAL PERCENT ASBESTOS:
. | 0 PERCENT
j LESS THAN 1 PERCENT j
0 PERCENT
FIBROUS MATERIALS AND PERCENT: NONFIBROUS CONSTITUENTS:
CELLULOSE SYNTHETIC
< IX 1 FIBROUS GLASS 20 - 30 | FIBROUS GLASS 20 - 30
OS - IS j SYNTHETIC
01 - 02 SYNTHETIC
05 - 10
j BINDER-PERLITE
| BINDER-PERLITE V MATRIX
1 BINDER-MATRIX GLASS BEADS-PERLITE
DEVIATION FROM TEST METHOO:
j ^_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 1 *1
*1 .
THIS TEST REPORT RELATES ONLY TO THE ITEMS TESTED AND MUST NOT BE REPRODUCED EXCEPT WITH THE
APPROVAL OF THE LABORATORY. . "
- ALL SAMPLES WILL BE DISPOSED OF 90 DAYS FOLLOWING SAMPLE RECEIPT UNLESS OTHERWISE INSTRUCTED BY
THE CLIENT. ..." > .
. - r.
- UNDER CURRENT EPA REGULATIONS, AN "ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL" CONTAINS MORE THAN ONE PERCENT
ASBESTOS.' i : >
. ` - .
*1 MATRIX OF SAMPLE OISSOLVEO IN TETRAHYDROFURAN, HEATED, EVAPORATED, THEN ANALYSIS CONTINUES ACCORDING *-
TO TEST METHOO
r . ; . . .
029704
KeVCO SERVICES INC. 890 PITTSBURGH ROAD BUTLER, PA 16001
TEL 412-588-6343 FAX 412-586-2172
Kevco
LABORATORY & CONSULTING SERVICES
REPORT TO: UNION CARBIDE P.O. BOX 186 PORT LAVACA
ATTENTION: CAL JONES
BULK ASBESTOS SAMPLE ANALYSIS REPORT
REPORT DATE: 10/31/90
TEST METHOD: 40 CFR CH. I (1-1-87 EDITION) PT 763. SUSPT. F APP. A. PAGES 293-299.
TX 77979
ANALYST SIGNATURE: PAUL URH
KEVCO JOB NUMBER: DATE RECEIVED: DATE ANALYZED:
CLIENT SAMPLE ID: PROJECT ID:
SAMPLE LOCATION:
IS THE SAMPLE HOMOGENEOUS?
DOES IT CONTAIN LAYERS?
IS THE SAMPLE FIBROUS?
SAMPLE COLOR:
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90 BUCB 81
| YES NO YES TAN
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90 BUCB 82 -
| YES' ... NO YES TAN -
---
-
'
11564 10/31/90 10/31/90 BUCB 83
| YES NO YES
J TAN
SAMPLE CONTAIN ASBESTOS FIBERS? YES
YES '
-/
NO
ASBESTOS TYPE AND PERCENT: TOTAL PERCENT ASBESTOS: FIBROUS MATERIALS ANO PERCENT:
NONFIBROUS CONSTITUENTS: DEVIATION FROM TEST METHOO:
CHRYSOTILE
05 - 10 CHRYSOTILE
< IX
TOTAL:
5 - 10
LESS THAN 1 PERCENT J
0 PERCENT
FIBROUS GLASS 20 - 30 j SYNTHETIC
10 - 20
FIBROUS GLASS CELLULOSE SYNTHETIC
< IX < IX
10 - 15
BINDER-PERLITE
1 BINDER-PERLITE
BINDER-PERLITE
| ||
THIS TEST REPORT RELATES ONLY TO THE ITEMS TESTED ANO MUST NOT BE REPRODUCED EXCEPT WITH THE APPROVAL OF THE LABORATORY.
- ALL SAMPLES WILL BE DISPOSED OF 90 DAYS FOLLOWING SAMPLE RECEIPT UNLESS OTHERWISE INSTRUCTED BY THE CLIENT.
- UNDER CURRENT EPA REGULATIONS. AN "ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL" CONTAINS MORE THAN ONE PERCENT ASBESTOS.
029705
Kevco SERVICES INC. 890 PITTSBURGH ROAD BUTLER, PA 15001
TEL 412-586-6343 FAX 412-586-2172
wioesPie Tfikvifye. P
PARTIAL COPTBpSEROW.
$) E? IOW PE
/ftpPRL CoPb/J$eA
029711
.-- nuv c\ 'yw k34;we>m klvu*
Kevco
LABORATORY * CONSULTING SERVICES
r.r>/ o
UPORT TO: UNION CARI10I P.O. BON 106 PORT LAVACA
ATTENTION: CAL JONES
SULK ASBESTOS SAMPLE ANALYSIS IEP0RT
UPON! DATE: 11/21/90
TEST NETHOO: 40 CER CN. 1 0-1-87 EDITION) PT 763. SURPT. F APP, A. PAGES 293-199.
TX 77*79
ANALYST SIGNATURE PAUL MURM
aVCO JOB NUMBER: DATE RECEIVSD: DATE ANALYZED:
CLIENT SAMPLE ID: PfiOJCCT ID:
SAMPLE LOCATION:
IS THE SAMPLE HOMOGENEOUS?
DOES IT CONTAIN LATENS?
IS TNE SAMPLE FIBROUS?
SAMPLE COLOR:
11706 11/20/90 11/21/90
*1 OXIPC
|
YES
NO
TES
WHITE
11706 11/20/90 11/21/90
2 ODUPC
|
| TES
NO
TES
TAN
11706 11/20/90 11/21/90
93 ODUPC
|
TES
| NO
TES
TAN
SAMPLE CONTAIN ASRESTOS FIBERS? TES YES NO
ASRESTOS TYPE AND PERCENT: TOTAL PERCENT ASBESTOS: FIBROUS MATERIALS AND PERCENT:
NONFIBNOUS CONSTITUENTS:
OBVIATION FROM TEST METNOOi
| CHRTSQTILE
05 - 10 | CHRYSOTILE
20 - 30 |
j TOTAL:
5 10 | 10TAL:
20 - 30 |
0 PERCENT
FIBROUS GLASS 13 - 25
FIBROUS GLASS 10 - 20 1 CELLULOSE SYNTHETIC
01 02 13 - 23
1 BINDER PERLITE |
BIWER PERLITE |
BINDER PERLITE METAL
....
|
- THIS TEST REPORT RELATES ONLY TO THE ITEMS TESTED AND MUST NOT BE REPRODUCED EXCEPT VITN THE APPROVAL OP THE LABORATORY.
ALL SAMPLES WILL BE DISPOSED OP 90 DAYS FOLLOWING SAMPLE RECEIPT UNLESS OTHERWISE INSTRUCTED BT THE CLIENT.
UNDER CURRENT EPA REGULATIONS, AN "ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL" CONTAINS MORE THAN ONE PERCENT ASBESTOS.
Kevco SERVICES INC. R90 PITTSBURGH ROAD . BUTLER. PA 16001 TEL 412-SB6-634S FAX 4T2-5B6-Z172
029712
NOV 21
Kt-VOU 5U<V1UL
Kevco
LABORATORY 4 CONSULTMG SERVICES
r. O'
REPORT TOl UNION CARSIDE P.O. BOX 186 PORT LAVACA
ATTENTION: CAL JONES
BULK ASBESTOS SAMPLE ANALYSIS REPORT
TX 77979
REPORT DATE: 11/21/90
TEST METH00: AO CFR CH. I (1-1-87 EDITION) PT 763, SUBPT. E APP. A. PAGES 293-299.
ANALYST SICIUTUMi
0. A
PAUL HURM
KEVCO JOS NLMSEIi DATE RECEIVED: DATE AMLTEED:
CLIENT SAMPLE ID: PROJECT ID:
SAMPLE LOCATION:
11706 11/20/90 11/21/90
B4 OOUPC
IS TNE SAMPLE NGHOGENEOUS7 DOES IT CONTAIN LAYERS1 IS TNE SAMPLE FISRCUS? SAMPLE COLOR:
| TES NO
| YES | GRAY
SAMPLE CONTAIN ASIESTOS FIBERS? YES
11706 11/20/90 11/21/90
* OOUPC
1 (CHRYSOTILE IN CAP AND SAMPLE)
1 *
1 0
11
GRAY
|
YES |
ASIESTOS TYPE AND PERCENT: TOTAL PERCENT ASIESTOS: PIIROUS MATERIALS AND PERCENT: NONFIRROUS CONSTITUENTS: DEVIATION FROM TEST METNflO:
CHRYSOTILE AMOSITE
01 OS CHRYSOTILE 40 50 AMOSITE
01 * 05 1 30 - 40 |
TOTAL:
41 55 TOTAL:
31 - 45 |
CELLULOSE SYNTHETIC
< IX
SYNTHETIC
01 * 05
01 - 05 j
UNDER MATRIX
metal
1 IINDEI MATRIX METAL
1 |
*1 1 J!__________________________ l
- THIS TEST REPORT RELATES ONLY TO THE ITEMS TESTED AND MUST NOT EE REPRODUCED EXCEPT WITH THE APPROVAL OF TNE LABORATORY.
ALL SAMPLES UILL IE DISPOSED OF 90 DATS FOLLOWING SAMPLE RECEIPT UNLESS OTHERWISE INSTRUCTED IT THE CLIENT.
- UNDER CURRENT SPA REGULATIONS, AM "ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL" CONTAINS MORE THAN ONE PERCENT ASEESTOS.
*1 MATRIX OF EAMPLE DISSOLVED IN TETRAHTDROFURAN , HEATED, EVAPORATED. THEN ANALYSIS CONTINUES ACCORDING TO TEST HETHOO
029713
Kevco SERVICES INC. 890 PITTSBURGH ROAD . BUTLER. PA 16001