Document dnjmNvKbpxKGenexo3k9ByNeq
FILE NAME: Norton (NORT) DATE: 1932
DOC#: NORT008
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Conference Presentation by Dr. Albert E. Russell, Surgeon, US Bureau of Mines
y
i
* - - -fl - -
*
INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION
O K*
W ISC O N SIN
Kkw M. Witjt.t C m m m i**i~t> rr%C h '\ir m n n
R. IL Ks~r^*ff C um m i**n> rrr
Viitta Tfuarrz C om m ittiontr
A. J. AUTMICYCT, Srrrrtar;t
Haut A. S ki^ N, tlin r tu r n f M'nrktirtt'd Cumpr'ISuduA
Proceedings of Conference Concerning
EFFECTS OF DUSTS UPON
(
THE RESPIRATORY ' SYSTEM
Held a t .Mednah A thletic Club, Chicago November 16-17. 193-
CONTENTS
. W ednesday, November 13, 1932--Morning Session
P jt
F red M. Wlleux, Chairman. Industrial Commission of Wisconsin Prelim inary rem arks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ____________________ 5
A ddress-of Or. Leruy U. Gardner. Director of Saranac Labo ratory for study of t u b e r c u l o s i s . . __________ 3
W ednesday, November IS, 19:12-- Ajtoinoon Session
Address of Dr. W. Irving Clsrk. Medical Director of Norton Company, Worcester, Massachusetts ______. . . . . ___ ___ 50
Discussion__________ ________________________________ SO Continuation of address, of Dr. G a r d n e r . . . . . . . . . -- . . . . . . . 70 Address of Donald E. Cummings, A ssistant Director of Sar
anac Laboratory for Study of "Tuberculosis.-- . . . . 31 D iscu ssio n __ , _____________. . . _________________--___ _ 103
T hursday, Novembo 17, 1932--Morning Session
Discussion of addresses of Dr. Gardner and M r..Cutnm ings_ 112
Address of Dr. H. S. Willis, Pathologist of Wm. H. Maybury Sanatorium, Detroit, M ich ig an ______________________ 124
Address of J. J . Bloomfield. S anitary Engineer, U. S. Public
Health Service
133
T hursday. November 17, 1932-- Afternoon Session Address of Dr. A lbert E. Russell, Surgeon, U. S. Bureau of
D iscu ssio n ___ __________________________________________ 188
AmNDicjai A PPEN D IX A.-- Biographical s k e tc h e s -------------------------------- 238 A PPE N D IX B-- List of persons who attended conference-------- 213
0 /1
h -**
I S
^
^
180
\,
This man was a slate worker. Hi history is th a t he lived
and :i * ...
in the area of this slate unci th a t for most of his lift*, aside
th e e **.:;! ; ....
from farm ing. that had been lus sole occupation. Thu slate
that
w orkers in one plant which we- observed wens not extmaed
r h r s l ! h . ..
to any quartz.. The plant adjacen t to this mill had about
ami the:.-
3 # quartz In the slate it used. You will note a considering
the ai'-ra^-. :
slate that the silica content of shite varies in different ureas
placed ill :ii-t
so we can't sny that slate has a definite am ount of silica
ca.su ss ha vis.
without determining it first. The same holds tru e for gran
cools, th rir urr
ite. There are certain granites which have much less than
. pensation an-:
3 5 # . 1 think most of the Vermont granite contains about
This is the
3 5 # quartz. You can see the futility of try in g to compare X-rays of the lungs from w orkers in one industry to those
In Austral:;. They catted ::
of another.
,
Dr. roorc's r
c This is an X-ray of a slate miller. You- will notice he has a few pulmonary m arkings, w ith quite a b it of fine linear fibrosis. We found in- the group of slate miller
more fibrosis l culosis, o r h. dtlst. The st;
w orkers one case who lmd an active -tuberculosis. He had
advanced cas*
been in this slate mill about six years and apparently the
phases. At :
tuberculosis was just incidental ami not a result of his
classification i
occupation.
mended. The
Other slate workers showed hilus thickenings with a few
w ritten into th
calcifications. Still other slate workers showed a different
they said a
picture but not extensive pathology.
should be adc
This is an X-ray of another slate worker showing quite
stages design;
ra bit of shadows in the lower portion of the rig h t lung with a few calcifications. This is the X-ray <f a m an who had. or has. asbestosis. Ills nccuiuuion was that of cleaning and restoring the' as bestos on pipes in one of o u r government hospitals. He
brosis than u: ommended. stages would first stage of : em sid ered ac
had been working at the trade aland six years, t think.-and
This slide r
you will see. he has fibrosis of both lungs. T he character
come under ti
of the ribrosis is quite a bit different from th a t of th e gran
ever, the deli,
ite workers. He hud disability ami the government com
stage, bur you
pensated him for it.
dicating that
Thus is a graph showing classification of silicosis. The
tho lung. He
first classification was made in South Africa.' They started
S tates Govern
out classifying their cases ;u< prim ary and secondary stages,
eight year.,
and as they learned more about the disease they had to
m asks. He i:
add to this classification. They learned th a t they had a
which were g
Utfo e-.iriiep than prim ary and it was called ante-prim ary.
ing in the
\
I
f 'VV . ' ..
.
..W1 ".J
II' 1%
U,..:
V.
'.if
^ > t'-- M*T^,
r>
at
*2
which position he held until 1U10. Ho then entered the
ployment of this United S tates Public. H ealth S -rv ic ^ a<
a memlier of the Stair of Service. Hospital No.
al
Greenville, South Carolina, w here lie rem ained in service,
specializing in. the treatm ent of tuberculosis during
am i 1921. From 1922-22, inclusive. Dr. Russell acted as
Assistant Chief of the Tiiltem ilosis Hospital Seriiuu ,, (
th e U. S. V eterans' Bureau. From tU2t-2U he w as in
char?* of field studies as to the health of workers in,dusty
trades for the United S tales Public Health Service, in
1930 he w as appointed as official* representative of the
United States at the International Silicosis Conference at
the Lea?ue of Nations a t Johannesburg. South Africa, of
which he acted us Vice-Chairm an. In 1930 he became
Chief Surgeon of the UT. S,, B ureau of Mines.
Dr. Russell has made numerous contributions to medical
magazines, and has w ritten many reports for the U. S.
Public Health Service, covering particularly the Held of
pulmonary diseases and more specifically those diseases
resulting from the inhalation of dust.
X '7 7
L<v* tov /'y
/ f T ~ <.
.)
y .>
, r _A_
^
1~"l" '*t-<'- ttl
<~r% t - t?
I.IST OK !,Kl:.'ON> c kx tni; k>*hkr: systhj: !i>:i-i SION OV WtSOtN: HKi; m IT. i:*=a r
Ai.lr--i. Asa A. 1.liir
Atkinson. F... Mii
Autst. R. A.... ilnn Han>-31. Or. A. 1- Mil
ftrlknap, .<>. .\l.PW:UM' DrUU. Or. ti. L. . Was
BrfIJn, Dr. D.H. Cbic Birv*r. E.J--. .. Xoh; BloomnrlU.-J.. . 'Was.
Uniton. Ur.J. A. t'liir
Uruwn. Wm. K. UiU
Clone. Dr. *>V. Irvins Won
CoUinghom. M. I>., SC.dli
Cummings. 1. K.
.sjrx X.
IX-BlousIjri XMf
Dickson. L- ll. . . . cu
Dobbins. Dr. T>.isv CVfi* Do*.ArthurU... . >-`5x
>4t Eariynrrtt*.J. U.. . .Chic French, 0. E-. .Ciiic ford. IV W. U. M.!.
\
r '-
.'V
e emvice iii 25, at ervice.
r 1320
:ted aa
ton o f v ia in . * i dusty e. In of the nee i t ' lea, o f ecame
ledical U. S.
of
:ir
A p p e n d ix Hr
l i s t OK PERMnN'.S WHO ATTENDED CONKERKNCK CON*. CERNING EKKKCTS OK DUSTS UPON THK RESPIRATORY
- SYSTEM - IIEI.D RKKOllK THE iN D U STU IA I. COMM IS. SION OK WISCONSIN AT CHICAGO. ILLIN OIS. ON NOVKM HKli Hi -1?. IPiUt
.Vume Andrew, Ara A.
AA/ren Chicago. UL. .
P l.'l,vi.l
1 **<1/5Km /!* iaiinliernienH Mu
tual Casualty ('ll.
*
t* t
f
Atkinson. K,, . Augas. R. A .... Banyai, Dr. A. L .. Belknap, . L.
Milwaukee, W i * ............................... Lilierty Mutual Casualty
Montreal, Wia.--. .................. .
.Montreal Mining Co.
Milwaukee, Wia. Physician___
Clinic Director. -Mumlalr San.-
W. Wia. Ave. Medical Director Glulat L'niun Mtg.
MUaaukee, Wia.
Co.
-
Belli. Dr. G .L ... Wauwatuaa, W ia^......................... . SupL MuinJul-
San.
Berlin, Dr. D. S. . . . Chicago. III. . . ..................................Augustine Hwp.
Stever, E . J . . . . . . . . KohUr. Wia.. . Mt-rh. Eugintrer ..KohlerCompany
Bloomfield, J .J .. .Washington, D. C . . . ........... . ....... .IT. S. Public
/
Health Servinr
BriUon, Dr. J. A. Chicago, I I I . . Mediral D irector international Harvester Cow
Brawn, Wm. E .----- Milwaukee, W is.. Lawyer.
. Allis-ChuJmeni Mfg. Co.
Clare,Dr. W. Iron* Worcester, M aaa..P h y sician ...... . .NortonCompany Harvard School
Cottingham, M. D. Kohler, IV ia..... .Medical Director Kohler Company
Cummings, D. E-.. Saranac Lake, N. Y .... . . . . . . Aia`t D irector... Raranat: Lab.
DeBloia, Lewis........New York, N. Y. . . ..................... ................................
D lc k o a ,L .E ..--.-C h ic n g o ,IlL .... . . . . . . . . . . __ _.Standard Equip merit Co.
Dobbins, D r.Tbos. Kenoeha, W ia ^ ............... ............... .N ush Motors Co.
Doe, A rthur B .... ..823 N. Broadway, Lawyer____ . . . Employers Group Milwaukee, Wia.
* ;-Earlywine, J. L . . . . -Chicago, I1L. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
\ French, G. E .... ...Chicago, B L ..-- . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . L i b e r t y MutrCo*.
Pan). Dr.AY. B .... .Milwaokee, Wia. .Physician.... ......... Aae't Chi/T. B.
.
Div. Health
..
Dept.
. fr f
v < e . . ^ e , **%
* '*** **** '
.-\J J / r x t
/Vi'/Vuio
G oadrey,A lim i K. Milvauk, W u. l.awy*..
fu u n tu
C o n fiti <*.1
Ass't City Atty.
M*wak,C.A-.
O iin j|< i,llI,
(/M a ile r, Or. T..S. r \ \ \ Wi*. A iv , S u n t* * Uilwaukt*, WU.
oku !. u r. c : n . . .a u V a g u jiL . . .
Otjen,C. J.
Milwaukee. Wau Atturtiey *
. 111. Ind*. Cren.
\
f
. llt.SUei Cu. .. Liberty Mutuai
in*. Co.
4 f
i
l
Parrhth, L .J. . . Milwaukee. Wi*.
A. 0 . Smith Curp.
V t
Plerpon. Or. O. C. Inmwnod. Mieli.
. . Ptvkumia, Maihve
Cu.
t
Reid. M. A . ; . . . . . . . Huriey, Wi*..
......... Montreal Mining
<
Co. d; Odanah
Iron Co.
\
Reynolda, Paul F. Cleveland. Ohio . .
. Montreal Mining
#
Co. t
Rinto, Or. H. F.. ...M ontreal. Wi*..
Montreal Mining
<
i
RuaulL Dr. A. E. ..Washington, D.C. Surgeon
.. U.S.Publie
Health Service
S an d er.O .A ..... . 800 Empir*B!dg......................... Employer* Mut.
fr
Milwaukee, Wi*. .
Sappington,
.
Or. C. 0. . . Chlcugu, Ili. . Consultane Ind.Med.
4 . . . . f
SchBleonmj.oHvia.t.,.W. . .. . . 210 Empire Bitlg., Intom bi . . ............. . l '
Milwaukee, WU.
Sexton, JamesM....Milwaukee, W is..
Employer* Mut.
ic
Story, H. W............ Mlwauk**, Wis. '
. . . . .Allb-Chalmer
f
MIg. Co.
TThaamriinlg, aLr.,AE....L......... .MMiillwwaauukkeeee,, WWit*s.,..APattlolimuleoyy.bl ....................... 1
Warfleid, Or.
Louxi M ... . . . Milwaukee, Wi*. Intom bi
White, Wm. W ... ..Cleveland, O h io ............................... Montreal Mining Co.
WUeo*, F. M.. . 1 . . . Madison, W ii^ ...C h airm an .;........ Wis. Ind*. Corri.
WiUIa, H. 3._______Detroit, MIeh ; ______ ______ Detroit Public
_
Health Dept.
Gotdxehmldt, W. J. Milwaukee, Wl*. .A tto rn e y .......... .
Grave*, Dr.S. S.___ Chiogo, Ili.____ Medicai Director [IL Ind*. Corri.
Cray, A. W . . . . . . . .'J24 E.W1*. Ave.. Medicai. . . . . . . Private Practic* hliiwaukee, Wi*.
-,
. 'iuillerr. y..
r
Guir*. Pter, Jr. tr
liahhe. Dr.A M. M
Heneel.H. (J.
ri
Huth, Gnerim C. .. . a
!rerand. Walter...,. fCi Janier. X . W......... Mi Knut<on,R.C....... . i l Kuecnle. 5 . E . .. . ..R
Kuhn, Dr. Leroy P.. . a
Lavieh. J . I . . . . . . .C i
Lotz. Oscar ........ .\Z i Mrintyre. i l . D. C .t
McLaren. D r . J . 3 . ..Ap;
Meilum. H .J.
Milolarieh. DrEdw. I . . . . . .
,\tu
Nelson, Harry A .. r.fa
Wnbetz, Vnyta Ma Wright. C. B.. . - Mie
i.
,
U'
V
'
v
.
7.
-
r
t
t
.
*
It
t
.
-
:tr,
.Y.mv Guillert, f \.
Chirac*. 111.
IIluiitrw 1\ m n r \ fu%
O*.
Cuir. peter, Jr. Chirac1', ill.
Commiii*rter . .' III. Indu, ("um.
Habbe, Dr. J. B .... Milwaukee, Wia. ilnrntgennloctst
Hennei, H. G .. . . Chinalo, HI........ .dainty Director . Youmwfim-n Sht. &TutmC.
Huth, Gordon t \ '.'.,Oii*-aco. 111.
t'o irrrsal Allan Cement ('<.
Inland, W aiter.. . . .Kohler. Win.
Employment Mcr.Knhlrr Go.
Janxnr, V . \V, . . . . Milwaukee. Win.
.Seaman Body Corp.
Knutson. R. G ..... .Madison, W .. ...M rm lier...
Win. Innu. Cum. .
Kueehle.B. . . . . . .Box 32. Wausau,
M is...
In*uranec . . .
Employer Mut. '
Kuhn, Dr. Leroy P. .Cln'mcn. Ill..............
. . . Lumbermens Mut. Can. Co.
U vieh, J . L - ......... .Chiracn,Ill.......... ...
. . . . . Lumbermenn Mut. Can. Co.
Lotz,Oacar . . . . . .324 E. Mis. Ave,, Medical. Milwaukee, Wi*.
Private Practice
McIntyre, M. D. . Cleveland, O hio..
. . . . Ptrkantle, Mather Co.
McLaren. D r .,J . B. .Appleton. Win... Physician.. . ..
.Cliief Surcmn. Kimlierly-Clark Cnrp.
Milium. H. J. . . Kenosha, Wia.
. .
Nash Mollir t.'o.
Milostavirh, Dr. Edw. u ........ : .Milwaukee, Win. . Pathologist . .
Nelson. Harry A .. .Madison, Wia___ Director, Work* m m 's Comps^ Win. Indu. Com.
W nbvtx, VoytA.. . Madison, \VU___ Mcmocr__ . . . .Win. Indus. Com.
VTrichLC. B . . . . . .Minneapolis,
Minn.. .
Internist...
...
Zinn. R. r .................IronwoonJ, Mich. .................. ............. Pirfcandn, Mather Co.
) T t t \ V f
t*^s
'"la*
*Xh
* s
#
\ -