Document dnJNE1OOBb4xJXk3jzgmB1VZ5

PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT BAR-282 ' 9fti at4 rtao^'jrp 1 KJ'll 1*4 'bs 'AC*. Accorjn-|iy -uriu*nt ;o -.ftr Cow 'jn ..*f lAnit:: * ry..*r4 ^.f4:eAl reTAftO .'or 'jryner ctnisf*: :n ol .* t xvii--ocr.`T'CNiL urm riiR4ir(4 for ac ietot .9 ftnu.on 9*r:od for --or.jior--* rr?:*u t" *io -tAW?" oC*o'*i|T*aT.OM 0(* | rAfl *! Cayrc if9rtr<4 turar-.is At ao no* coftci.ori 34ia sn .*,* rt r- \ fACTMt^T 3f usa* tfie *nor. rsesruon ssnsa tut rteord mo lor ;.* r4`oni c.tui .4*t :t:3--oc:-.Mr,CNAL upmr I J f*r rto.T-ar'Tf ri-^ris Af^r rftair AOOi-9 vcai iS ttAf rrcrnc on 9r a4 4 A0 Nt>WTM TAOA*OS * tfi# SrertcArr oai-iausa yfdtr IT* aci 4k.e9or.Ad tr vii * dt*e i.*o rtfi* SU"dO<d '* tl90Asf4 * *Ata*t4d ( rasyirs rtcsTc.en af rscordi nseti* * y mn !9f *. 3**f:com#nt of jc.'orwAUSA t*ry lor vco arocacc-en jf i-jicrfti I; 4 noerd Vi ac .n a nt or*uoiA. sft *i- PbnvAftt uew"* I'ki Aftd '' ` .. mKttrrur.t ire ca^jci of 4l<aa ao4 its kOAu/s ca tjoatsai (9 m c*4i: 0<`49sr .1 titt Ocr.3i-f-*l ue ; 7 nf^nct of iiMiura 4is .ft tuk *(;* it tut .m nit J * c. ' j lUM/if'.111 caujai riAi;oft^ft`f Li* Court t i9TJ aft.eft rtff.'A Vi -*mc ?;rt ie:rfti.*e Aft4 mfOieAl j rn tilt fcrer.ittT < luwri Orttr * f " rtAAA44 -is rteorcistsiri rssuiro- vco .*.<14. a Ad*>iAr *iu*uon sorted or is.ri (> r* i'i" u* it tf* 111 I ll# ISOl'H'l' < ,lrl ;,1t ' T.i It C>f* *t INtml Axjituoni. n ricrtT uunllt in I* ruintr wl for'Jl > f aimcs ia uni S^creurr `far iwcn msaiA* \ * eauoo or ecacu mar os nn* i my ia injurs <jiac ^i ibiuurv >sj*c r . * yts sui os * Ait t 14 ac *lt. do du/Aiion of tsinurmr.i 3iyj '.Arnvr 7ran< for kotft ttsotyro -poiyrt-o-c AftO ffttdiCAJ rr.iru *ii 9*tn jrtretrt for do rtucm isotr ,*c t- M.o in orttr la in u> r.unuon ]N* ^rtuiAi 14 wo Csurtt 4irreuoA. 3,litt :or uittut timurt jitminf.nt i * C4HA r.u eomniitaS rj ro<t* Aft4 has kaiuro rreoroj aro'.uan of v>. u:r.u icAftOArd aui 3o carrie-.io a '*r..rr rtttrdi !rom '.irtt ftwt m r*tIT ''JfJ- J>7 fsacJyeoa uia; iftt oeiftion ctsrmea kf On Stttmetf 1. in J r* :JUti. 1MCourt 4 Aa Aee-x'Aca rtrtaeuoft of ins canuoft of itowuri merti'.er-'c rn:rj for At Uni :9 nan t'Ki.ti S<ir:ft .) CSMA ittutf tn imtrttfleT umacftiT i'fmari aa4 -*1AC tfjo Aatncri iftitui ll'l CSKA kOliff IT AC A it AF ft Tt rjnmrl on uouuot m rttooiuo u 9- k**J44rftmi sirmACj eorrRUao. irtKUFO 4AC4 Of L14 frjytftfttftl J *:t uLon Or wo Infatu-.U mn Stotri- fl. 04XA koiioMs 4\ac itcaruion of Ota %Arrnc#d imet dv r;!i inr rrou..*o min o< n-ao. ?;i rtoomirtoiftc rcouirtmtni for otkoouro dAt AffRiad fir.sia'iri rr.im rresrit .... $uon ||| ol lilt Act 'tt fut lilt. CSC III'- ^cu mo*i*nT uwiry? A4U(jr.*.| from uerso fton ca c*tny %ftie?i dor ftit iirrAar ea.-- s .ri t*i pAft u or:ciftAil7 9rpooo4 voul4 ka tft i dirtfors 4oti not i.tsoio a .*. Oarer: ,f9tiun4f4 *u 4uiCftd pfimonly brairr siub lao cvtacyfoor rsunuoa ; | of acc.on or.d nr.ci tft* nivj -vrrr-rAr Vft.T*diAUlT ?4ut Aftd *"<IJ,` cone*#. fJL i. at nos riouirm for omotorea modi* fftifttion oariod for cuc.n rresrsj -\a% r.sr uoftil iipoiuri.ca uMiva 4',.u ]J?,w mm u cm itio lAotad tftd duo rrraru nit.nt ka trku*fti. Aftd 414 aoi MfilAkfIt */*'"" * AAst do court nocs4 (All f 24 At !>, drtiroTSd Lou of tueft rrcorei routd ka S*`411ZTMSi&rfSiSSti ti9dd prseoturt*. K*wf on Jnw mt iJ nn ;j: r* csha 9auu0r- ^vn4 a oropsoad aomef*fttrti.*o r*A.*.4 trd far otooswrs w*jr- -- viclydt rteordX**i>cftt jrk*uino rtaA im>li of do ?reLl U pco*idad dot i30oufo tnamarirf rrP4l. And raeordo of ^*4iei *' &Auenj. k* Biiru**ftd for a otrad * t.TC\9 frdrt AftJT bA/lftf* d Sfcrnur sromulfAwd a oe* *rmA* -in 04 KA r*ft4fd tt k***4*d* ;uc 1. itn <31 m lXJ " <* 4 7 |v ado* css wcj of rceoras vftoa rto4 c^ isutr sould oroid# a mors umelsu Af in imoiotrt i hucarr of is* a (Aevor .UcsoruftC sun C4 UttU0trU44 4`jcams Tho ;4o4 koriod :or rtcsnccaa. siia rt* dm (Ad AeeymulAUan. ad ka ent* I d rsdicAl at.4 tciaufo n*oiu4A* ra tAitrxe iuaA tuacofu u 4oso* ' IdMM rt'AUOftJftieO 41 4LMAJSI CAUM4 I m ooroAUonsa anoso ca ooamcos. ttM 4auion roui4 a*jo ka rmnansim ca imeMin. Continued tc:tti 14 lucre rscordo ky oil ioneimed 'J n**n;.Ai n do sukiie VMoriit And v Aft ionr39r-44 octdftx of i!TetuACU'i '.ft* roAU of r.?r9fd sorttr ttfrey ir.4 ftrtid -mot.* do Act. Caad etui 4 found, dr**!;-*. purtuAftt 14 te::oft 4'4' 3' of '.ft* A4* aifiuc.ncit* Proeed-jr* ac*. ) CSC III dfJ>). for ^Atlftf V!4 "1-1 tfrt'.ivi. Aeeordiftfi*. oynuont '* d* 4:.*kCon of do Ls:c*d Suiu Z: --*: 3f as* 9*U (` faduiV-Ai Cft-o.n Castrvr.rrc. A/V-CTO Koddien r-srA ' tr4 Tt AT.es dd *U8ft l<k' Of dt ACI lM Sub l$*S. 79 0J.C.m.T*an4rtf* Uu AfiMT i dseursd eonitm iad via past i&MsauacT at bidift aas mauisr* AAkft nfirueit Audsr.cr. ;Aaf.*i:a ultUoa. vhJea a90*apt4 as If CTH 1910 43ft OfCdf < fSSS4lfl4U8. <Atf\*4 fT4tf4*l ISf fV* tAjntnf <uorui asoivsras mr*. * ] cm moissaMi) it iin IMKinlll. On Jatr V. '.in. surraukt u wcuan ia> < ia aci. < Sue :sit zj CJC OS<. a ssubffs (9t mdieisi rtnrv ( uis uwm itsadirf r% fi.'4 run 1A Cajwn Iui4i Cmr% a/ aanrsis rsr im Dbrvt CMuai% 7?w twctmj ssei wntfi uts ^ivtcwul Oust Ovntrt* nm. A/T^CIOt A9IM44 la M*vr%i nl> iuaa4 ssrusns tn aiAMsrC mcln4* ?4 umm 4mua rnA rsmtscn(fl4. Tbs Csurr iftim im tssmAir N4CTMIU4 U4 UM lUMlNI sd)4lt9 mm tm tn imuhM. sns 4 rnicJi ms ms rstsnusn psrtss fsf ssnssurt wnnnm rmi. "lAtmirti Untsn DfnsMMflL A/t-CTO S. MsdCASA.* iH r. 14* 4t <CA3C. IIT4). Ths Cmrt 4Unis4 uts tssrsisr? (s k^umm Uis 4UM4T4 ha mm* w u%s tfirvfffs/ msnastviAC 9ftrusa am ts rscsa- ossr vatwtsr iuca tuns ssnsa sds snsidf AMursS caioism prstscum Olfl AASniSITVlAUnStMAAm U iiicnswif \n* usus. uta Caurt irec rseorm bavo dadsmd amara bis cao ooossauonsa of Asaaouo rtraurt aa tss sonB)A<o. n 7% Jvaa V ll?l Tbo loaf ^yearn farads mmiai#4 1*41 uQd)4k*rt.Ar#4 tad (At Ml fl> of cm ti'.s Aaadad 14 rs4 as foUovt: lltu.iwi i.kwm '4 icrtrr t mcuasuroA aoad for ruodam la cast <1* ArrsmXrry t-a* fr*uvr 'w* oufiA :otaer psnoas ;ota at;sunL sort Rdo. Dt I ^o*w ~ <A_3 rve* moeiiiM if kata cm OSKA Adnsarr irti of iftf 9sn4ft*i or rt**.*:svsaU ComAiuaa oa Ajasevdo Oust <pme**4* acodiiarvcf rmu*rrd kr tu iRi.on Jd act At at. 161*191 Pttruarr n. iitit ordA iftAJI ka iruinuinod far a oor.od af ana via K104K Cruma Osnaaom for a ot ioaoc M Mtrt Aftd ataU kt niit ai.* Kacommaftoad liandard on iSMiao i AAto uoan rvdunt ca do AuAitcant Sas* 'tonsraur enaaurt I AA4 lie. {a Add)* recary of L^aar for OeeupAdorcAi Ss'rr Oan. taoumofit tt cao vitnaaoi at cat 1 And Kcdltft. do Ocrtecar of dt .vouanoJ OSKA ftoarcnfi usa iwoosrtaa lontr rt* Inttiuita (or Octtoauo'VAJ Softer And caatMa ptriast for staaoum oaoicarcnd BtdlUV Add cs Audaruad rtorvoenu* rsosmo <Tr. ot irr. J3|. Mama ti. ittu. ltd af tIU. a csnotfuua of uia amaonct in do rsearn utdicotao caat iitewi Banitam me* amt Af\aui4 at *at4 for it lasst a mm in oraar is aeu imA a rsmummant manmnffaf m nas of atiot a itaamUf rmnead aa um aoiiaum lawnar oa* 1asm. 1 hi L AC-UO 00 tui 1*J IMS <B 9JC. AA*. uti: l*<riun at Umt omor sn im r% ri. m cm pw itin. noa for aunt u*m%m miaian finun Ufftad it Vutuaftad. DC da Ud 04KA 4 af da *so dot uia iniartots of day of Mms ms. ofiir ftoaitA ssuid 9 kaot aarvod 9f rsdcsma do rttanuan of asaown Ban* tcanna rsesras far a sonod satan rs* dattt M Aeomaauaa of ids rrrorniiat MoiTd* Co. A|rtif<d( JrrtfiM of i^aor |7 Oss.1^mi m#s bio-t* I u urn 1 lAuacr faotsr. 1 9Ms4 tfiat msnr sf )As srsal sms Iaiim t*smart ta darttsaiac aa Asatstsa UA4A/4 ram iiracur AiirawuMa is Um last s# a/Armtua* canasmifif Asaatsi*pt4is4 4i*tm. ia4 asidcn* dr7 ts uia iAt sr mitskis uts aa Mil Sana >rls. Nsua< im dsaa func* Uaasl rdsuansAia katvaoi aisatcal me* /*"N iNCLSraiAl* #*o^ :8C-vg$ yi'td iunne * i.iitr :n a\<*d hc rltf*x 'j) tpotuf 10 asdest iuit m " in ..j contamination a. tamp'ei m.n it rtqxirti darnj :ft< imi: : i' aid 3'ercJC.fti tfcc Hite* 5' F iteri mould it manjed oni* aner a minimum :i' ; *our :f :irt (or expn<wret ensered to 5e : :ir -o 3 i f ren ;: Se^en or egm 1 -*iaur umpics can pf ronered Sjrnjr me da^ d. Eiampiei af`loiancni. , i > * ,'c*c i* emmn* ;* 1v i.-i ,jv c v 0"'.V* iri vd m \* j | .'r .i'. '>. *<S. *' I "g .d :\ : ,hm.\ . J : I jO'l i ^ 1 T < ' i .f 1 <!' ror ar.t a-c jw.Since an '?;<atf fut. ' or a ' *a:i:e :o car-er. ` .-cist m* ie : Chapter W. 5 Elite"'* Oj'r T!:u direc:r i effect:'* .mmeS.a:ei' and * m eiiect jmu r.rtner notice. l>2Mt *.(<* * TMt SUatAU Of NATIONAL AffAtM. INC.. ANINCTON. 9 c. :yO. 2i r 5i , ji jrsenite , j t S*-d'u' -r'C-<<ie. i5j Z.nc jncfliiei$i D.nc iPMnnt. ^ J SI S--.I Jfmren 1*1 <tc'*crunn. cK-r-p'C Or*, r*arsnv acidf Ms-ui'ic-rfftrt of **d :rer*ifi*ej. 50,-e ?v4-*r'ei of *c*e r*mi jcm are as iai!or (I} Animr^iacal :opptr arsensie. t2) CVomared corper ineratc. Oi M*tuPt of c.hiunnated fluoride and pnenoiic uu aouenui solution. -u> rtc crront'um arsenate. (Jj C-icserued amc e.nramiym arsenate. <m * w'jn-'ume irse.nate pnenol. t Manufacturers of teed adduces. Some eiamotes ofihese products are as folio**: 111 Arianmc acid. d) J-Sitro-J'h*croT*pnen*'anoftc acd. <ji a.Sitrnf nv.incfl*c acd (4) J-Lreidn*! -pneny larwmc acd. t Manufacturers of pharmaerjccm for uvc m *eter* man. medicine. Some examples of these products are as folio**: tl) Acrrarsamide. ;2) Caroanone. fJl Oic*iofoonenmtne. *4) Lead arsenate{51 Mrarvsnxl <61 'eoana-ienamme. O T>.ucrarsam*d'Ciparwiatt!. j Manufacturer* of fiats that jse anertic trcride as a refining aytm and a decoicnxer. k. Manutacturen of alloys of nonferraut metals and anemc. Some examples of products manufactured from these ailovt are as toiJoui. 111 Lead tnot. :Zi Cae*e ineathm.f <'ead and arsenic). (j) Barer** jrcs eac and arsenic). (4) Baren-eieerrodei t-cad and arsenic). <5i Sixrxam metal. <6) Boiler :uo (Copper and arsenic). D Arsenic bronae. (8) Soecui widen such as used on body joints and seams m me automooiie tndusrjr. |9) Anenic brass. < 10) Arvmeal ftaMHii. l. U*<rt <u soidm that contain arvmc as a com* pri*ent in i he alhnr. Eaamnift Automobile and truck bndr manufacturers. m. Manufacturers and/or users of snarnc-oascd ftouimn reagents. n Miscellaneous. Ancmc and/or inenic-crmainmg. inorganic com* pounds an vvnl In each ut the following types of estab* lunmenti. However. every employer does noc nercssanly use them. CfSagscg r-ug (11 Leather jn-er-ei >2) Manufacture** of retime* and rt*j-vj zr enamel. O) Manufacturer*-of anii.re rpiors. 1 a i Manufacturer* of p* rcter*ics (5) Mjiiguctiirers <*ii sunncnndiicti'rt osha procra*-; directive ooo-i* October 11. 19*8 TO REGIONAL ADMINISTRATORS. OSHa Subject- 29 CFR 1910 lQQlfj <21 pf1 J< :r 4, v: - ..... A.rpome Fiber Coneemrsnofl 'or `mra: -j and Continuing Ajeetrot Med.cat Eia.r tion*. 1. ?*rOCit The purpose of :h:s directive i *o : z^tc mspecv.on and comotianct procedures -or :*t -ed evammation repuirtment in the Asbestos s.andarp 29 CFR 19!0.1M1(ja:j. orljloriai. 2. Documentation A/fecred 1^111 directive luppiements and prov'dcs reference *:r the OSHA Industral H'giene F:e)d Cperitions Mart.a. (IKFOM) and 'Jte OSHA Fe:d Gperaticrj Mart.ai (FOMK 2. Sackground In 29 CFR 1910. :00I(jX2l. or tJI or i\ Med .cal ex aminations. me term . . exposed to a;rpcr*e renren* tranons of aaocstot f:bn. . . " 'as been :*t luccrt :f xnsiderapie iiiruiston and debate as ts '.te mein;.-.| :r iter-nranon of "airoorte sccentranoos. * 4, Action a. Definition. In 29 CFR 1910.I00I(jA2K or tjl or *',, Med.;a. ;* ammaunns. the term ". . . exposed to airborne ed-re-i*: noru of aapcsroi fibers, ..." a admi-imtnet' r.terprr-ei to mean exposed to t minimum of 0.1 Uderc* r.ber* crier than S micromerer* per cuetc etnr.rr.rer of air. as ce*.er- mined by the umplusg mr*od pmaerbed n iert:on a : ;( Lha direcpve. The pnnae fiber* orjer man 5 - .-r> merer* per cubic cwtumr.erof air * inaL nereafte: x i::*? viated as "fiber*/ct."* b. Scope and applicabuin*. Medical ruminations as prr 29 Cr? 1910 . or (2) or 14) t|] be required lor any T. ro S*nour : r*e- eeighttd iverift concentration of O.i fiber*/cs. or for a greater ernermration. c. Sampling information. U) Samptmg procedure* mil foltew Chapier X *t the IHFOM.. tih the additional guidanev oi ic.O and 13) ut this Uirectitc. (2) Exposure to atbettot dust %nh lo >cis of cun* taminatmiMe.g.. mixed vith other minerals) (a) Fnr eipmuma to duu that a mrttK asbvtiuv and is expected to be betov the permissible exposure limit, the same filter should be used for the enure tnm, but no longer than 8 hngr*. {bs for cuxAures ripened to be at or abuse the per* missible exposure Umu. several samples may be re* 94mMI< taieiv 4 >miiK imt'm 14 CV*MNT M0T - . :j far :oo estrctivt ind .nvjudjies iarju* e :ji *ica *ou*d be eqyivi.emiy i* si'4*iO Hid eiL/ig MUf Lie O-amjtf II- ...f,, laid ,,iat emr.Uii' aocraiory cpnor.-ona would - .rjw.rra ;o -e*t Lie c* frequency io.e ipecficit.om r;f .*e 5cc,,M *vci csi.eg in .mpracucai and ufl* or jp.e 'fduirtmfu TVre .1 cswuiion n -* iiandsrd of 'Jit Uffll noise ina aoi wild rauies iigiiucint imoiguuy * Tn.n*t preram eoiftm*nis are exetui*e and pro- *tm jir^oni;n <or ursiimerit si employers. * Recoreieeeng requirements are far excessive and caitiy ' particularly for imail and medium-sued * Tie csiibrawon requirements (of donmeiers and ivdiomeieri art ixriausiive and require more lesung tan necessary (d ensure accuracy * Projections o/ Lit number of workers covered by (A* urrencmem Lie overall r*it si compliance. and sa* *t ?* orter far compliance art badly underestimated. ` * TV requirements Liai only audioiogutJ. quahfitd pfivucuns and oiouryngoio|:su eviiuaie audiogram# a*d perform certain du*ei i excessively costly and an mef* fiotnt ue of ufr.ittd professional resources unct trained .eciniciani and qualified nunes eouid acequaieiy perform iwwft rtsocni.dinOM * 7>t acency miicaica.ated `At effect ol impulse noise on measurements Tie Clamper *aa aougnt to tuy -le nut tine* it *u jiutd an ;an .'I Current Report. * 25. 9 132) Laal noniA. O.am.Ptr proposed to Rugm i uss fore* 00 reguiaiory reform jiai Lie e'gnt lour umfweifftied noise exposure in nic.i oraeri must at exposed (9 at included .n industrial searing conservation programs under At ** mie at raoed from IS :3 in 1C ad C.Trent Repon. fro if. p. ::u- 0*C ntN A umiiar atuuon rtoutsung lusotnaien ol Lit efftru** suit si tat Oerasauenai Safety and KutU Administriudit I *ww ntir:.n| conntn-atiofl amendment /ulJ review ai fJ# record complied on .re iriMmm. and a rtoptmnd si tnt record auo u ivarrtii'.ed Hareft t n Stcreury * Udor Raymond 1 Oonovut 9j tat Crgiauauon Rtsourw Counselor!, 'nc. OflC criur.zed -se amendmtnt tor rclyiM on iptcirieaUdfi racier cian otrforr^nc* catena and for otmg wo lecamcaK ly comptet for men empioyen. "ta our ntw. OSHA can solve cit 9fotd protiem and many rt iAt vteifte arddiema iconumtd tAt imatfntnt) only 4 ii aiMUtutt* a parfermane* tundard tor t*a scasivt(y iptoficmoo tntBttd amendment.' M argiimf tuced. ORC mini amiur rqfma witM t*c Qumtef ad Commerea aAttt a atmatf a< tssets. tacUdinf sotoificatiMi far tan toaOM. rvoardfcttami rcuir*mtftu. rptci/icauMi rmartd far doaunttan. tntcstr doaamatan on rtiadio idtr * ndairtmama oi uua profram. dafiiuiaoM oi nfitt/icaM imiMd mix intf rtnatd baatfiM m im pfwrm. n4orcemtnt and at*4 far tfta i Mur auadt panatf. rtvwrvmriu far audiomtur eafidratiaa. tratjwjf reduirtmtmj. effect oi impuiat naiad dii measurememj. and UmiuUM atf audiopram ntenew ta eeftdin payvciaar In addiuon. ORC rtquotad Utat stetrai meed, sud u tfra coat dfectjventtt < me amendment, me aumatf ai worsen covered and me rmiLAf everati ran d use amendmem. me . provition fer emptove* momianni oi me profram. poaaaAtd confusion between me requirements of me amendment and Ooee of (A* eld lunoard. (Ac aandimf oi computer profrsms. and (At rtquirtmat tAai me levels ai tow u 40 '12* :3a oe neiused me L.-e ti'iiirt ve*s(e -ece-ve idOiuonai ;?r>sieerii;e me *ewie oeiare me amendment Oecomej e/fec:i*e CSr*A iNSTtuCTiCN SivfS aOCfOuCS ron 30CLiM(sri*G easr (miicmi u*csuai Procedures for iocimemifg past empiovne cioeture '.o airborne asoesios f.Dcrs nen loncrnt.'iLanj ran not oe measured 9* aaing el air uimpics on Lie say of ce rjpecLon or Lierea/icr ere Sttaued .n an Ccr.saLcrai Suiety and Htauft Aominircation uiitAicuon is.ed Fto l Tie .ftitractaon. CPU 2 2 21A. ml r^dti.res 'or jettrmining wneuitr aaaesioe-'Ud seen used or *a.nc.fd -?fj tr-.y ai Lie vertoiact -- or ;f .1 Md seen ntd or rare eo on an irreg-jiar basis, wnetfter employees ere etseied w ngnu'ieant amount! U aides(os<onuin>ng suae - `or Lie purposes of Lie medical txammjuoft requiremenu jf.Lle aadesioi standard 'Re'ermct Pile. 31 123di Compliance officers are uistncted to ooLiin mofiitomg reeults from tne employer or contactor, or from otner sources Iniormjuon nemury w Socumem aipestoi *ae or 9andlmg ts to be ootained Lirsugn employee, employer representative, or union .nter*<fi. a/ic .rrougn mtttd employer rtiormauon J it eiuta. TV instruction cinceu a tumiuir soeumeri trued ji Oc* tober i)?t Put. eieeot for Lie addiuon oi Lie procedures for pocumenting put espesure .'eaves .1 euertiii.y ocrarged <C.r-em Repon. '`ov l. j|Tg Reference P.it 21 f.llv Text of Lie njtTXLon follows Tt ef Of**A iAoun>w Cftv t Lgia 5utijec: Jf CPU :f -Jur-r Airborne T ber Conctnuiuon for Imtauig ar4 Cx.L.iu.rg Asbestos Medical Summations. A. Purpoi# T^u ^Astfnetjoa pf*vi-ff unifprm .-jbwcLpn and rompiiaoc* procedures for Lit medien exarLULon r*> pwirement a Lie uoeitM luncarJ 9. Ccoye TVs JUtriCLon ipoues CSHA-wpe C. Cancellation OSHA inswucuon CPU 2 2 21. Cciober 12. 1 fTf. j canceled. 0. Action. OSHA Regtooal Adminjvitor mo atu >rec- uori maii assure LUt efuorcement of 29 CFR : f i; ;ttl juX). 13i or <4i is coiuiatem wua Lit guidelines n G of tAit instruction. E. ffdf*ol ?*09*om Clafff T^n mitructioa lescrbes a Tederti pntnm Mange wmcb affects Suue pro<rimj. Caca Regional Administrator trull. 1. Zrmm mat tAas eftange a /errareed w tecs State Oesugne*. 2. Explain ifte tdcfvucal comm ai e change to tfie Suit ddnignet u requested. 2 Cajur* (Aat Suit designees are asked u aetnowtedgt receipt od uui Federii program cnaoge m wnung. wiwim 20 dayd of Muficsuon. ta uve Regional Admiatitriiar TTua ockiwwiedgemeai mould include a eetcnpuon euAef of ta* Suit t plan w impfmem tne aange or me rcaaoas wny tat eftang* mould not apply to <Aat Suit 4. Review polices, instructions and guidelines issued Py (At Suu to determine iasi ttus eftangs bas seen com* municaied to Suto program personnel Rooune monitoring cuviue* laceompAAiod inspection* and au file rmewsi mail also be ed (o determine if (Ais caangs baa been im plemented >a acual performance. T Hitckgn**ti. OSHA boa determined List generaUy eiution* mould, u a matter of policy, do asued tot >U4i Caoe fi iHtafTN 0 * umsou anewt ** CS* it;" 4 -fAl* noiatrani of If CFR !91 3 !301 ; ' J. 3 sr - 4 onis **n fr.?l0^j arr iioi4 to minimum af 3 : jtoetxt f.xrs c-fer -..im \ ,r.:CT3fmt'.m ?*r r.s.c cem.meter if tir as 5* Lie t*mpt.."f method ;rscr-.xd in teet-an C 2 if tin .MLreettoa T>e Jftrase '.Peri on(tr Llan i xr r.s.c :ent..meter af nr mail lerea/ter 5* a::rrvjtfd as f.xri cf i Hcver (or situations .a urj,.*| if exposure ts .aftasiote ctxuona may at itiwrt as proceed .Sgi af Xu tflitrucLosi. C */d'ffmenf Clrff` IMff l Me^ieii examinations as xr 29 CFR 3 919 1901 <i m !j, , jv of , < ui s required !ar any x l-neur Lmm^rtr.xd atpa| concentration of 0 l .'.xri- re. ar tor a (reax* a* cent/mon 1 SaffpMff procedures will follow Cluster X of in# tHFGM iui x aadiLoMt (Videimet of C 1 and 4. af Llia m* st/ycuon : Sa*rvit*0 fir t'.*POu'rf '0 Atorrtnt Oust urn* It,tv lr* *<t 9/ Caniani'idtion it s . *ured wna Otne* Wip *e 11 j a For exposure x Oust sat j mostly etxstos and u es* Xt'.td u x xiow via pormusoif tiposurt limit. tflt umt fiitar snowid x aae (or .fit tnurt Miift. put no XAftr Jub I lours 5 For exposure expected x x ai or so* -X xmunble eiposure limn Severn sampiei may x repuifed durjtf Jlo imft to avoid flvr'udm( iso liiierv J<3"p(id /or >.*yoatrf to AUtttOi QkU witft Htp* Lfvrii if Conrommnnov a Several sample* of exposure may x required durwf 5A0 sAift to avoid svtr'.oadmf Lie fKtf 0 Fiktn mould x c.ur(d oniy after a minimum of l hour of aampunf .n for erasure* expected x X eloao x 0 t .'.xn-re Seven or #i|fu i-nour tampia can x eoiJoctad dunr.f im day 1 r'nsr Exsosnrtt Vhen cmployxs fcjvt Xon trxaod is itMSLS out air samples ejnnoi x jc on Lfit day of iM msxcuon or t^ereaftar eiunons for wnoua violabx of 29 CFR 1919 I00t'ju:i. at x Mi Mitd X iiauod acewdtai is tA (oilowinf proctdu/n a Ctttrrjix tAat emoioyxs won txxaad X airaonx eofKtfurauona of asdwitoa and UMt Muuor Kandiiitf of asxux was xrformod or a rtfaiar xsu or tfut io um or nandimf of asxsuos was xrformod m an uTtfular xnt. Put empioyoti woro rtposod w Sifru/icaot afiXuou of du<t eofiuimni aaxatM. NOTE Cneuanct of(icon *all odtaa moeixna| muita from ux tmpXydr eootracxri or ar aount 1 o | j/Bwranev eompa/iy; eomAMy x pUdi for *dom roo> iraeunf wort ia xi9 fw; Xaldifif owixr/tuiidiAf otftor Foddnl, Suu dal afttcyt. tap mail lAdiejx cQom irx* aiota li fixn/oe of jiatstaa. 0 Oorvmit. 9y owX td. tsnpXyx mprtxnutjn. and umosi Hat t*a wort ni porformod roaumiy. a rrxatod imu: m that Xvsar tiAdlm| of umx tu pwrfdrmod aa tfrvftxr Man. mi tmpXrt *r* (X90d* if x tifmnrtM imavau of dual eosuaidini uAesiaa ta 04* dition. Miid dorvmmuiMM from wntxt omaxyor Afar* maud m Qm nuUAt oparagao. U a emu e. TS# vxUuvt eoddiiiwrtt mun tar* omrrsf at lasat wiuxd ux prrnoiaa I moaUa x mt ua rvquirsnxm of &xud << of ua OcvupdbdAii Saftty aad HulU Act. 4. Tyjxt o/ Violotiont. ___ a. A xrxwT' ndiaudfiof 29CTt 1919 (99ltjHtt. (Six <4i would ottos wnoro an tmpxyrr don ix< pmida Ut n* duirod modicaf tiamuxtiotu. and an ompxyoo ia npimil X 9 l x mort (itervee. 5 Fif :' -:t.:r.s iftd |.-:a*:t :n 'tseaitd *. or a J nrK: -oia;,a tte me fCM r*a5.r v ;ii l.i oet'ow C3U*T *ULf S C*AIN 3g$T aCC-MUwAT.Cs viCuAtis vJhi 0uS4*U9isC srassaos an r"5iovtr -.".at has xft ctttd iwt# fir voxt.on a/ ,,%t Ocr.caticrai Sulti> and Meaitft adm.n;i:ratJon t *o.itctr> m| tuneafd. -'or fakurt id prevtnc acr.mujat.ors 3/ dust m ill (ram t tsaiar >s m rtxa'Od stry 1 <o.*v.3'> ;! ,u< lousecxpmf suneard. tfit l S Court :( A;ota<i :r tfie F:/ut C.rcua. Unit a ru.rd Mart.n S soetsioo in S'i*ur C^^na^angn r 5rr'^'r*v istho**'<n USAURC>0 aff.rmn riurj : .*.t CcrjcauonaJ Safety a/X Honx Review Cammiu.on ' OSHC U2H T>.e cast arose wt of mo maxcron 01 -*it tmpiove# 1 Gwsirtnan La . (Tam tievaiar Gurmf 'JXt .r.jxc-cn .*.e OSHA romplianet officer found <2 ixauoni nert dust are (ram tad areumuUtod T>i station enarftd '.tat .*u ranei- uon vis at vmuuoti of 29 CFR 191922 anu md -Ml .1 crtatfd a fire flatard 7?Us etuuoA u 'Jte -tin sues r.u uon siuod x xo emoioyx for vioiaux 0/ Lie umt louxonomf 1 uncard T.v.e first and `-lird ruum mvoivod dust acrjmusauxx and xo snond .nvoived maxrai and rspti .eft ji waiam^ areu. After a itarjif on Lie menu of caw an CSaK.RC ;ud(f found Lie employer x X m rrxated tertoua "c.a:.3n of Lie leuiecxpirif standard and umiie a lid 3C0 x-Mity Tin aoxaJ foilowod Tie employer did not dispute Lit existence of Lit euft jc- cumulations at tfie (ram eievator Put. ..utead arf.n lik Lie nouMieepmi sxndard Md Xen .rxrmujij.y tt:a.*5- d x include fire and explosion mucm Accoremi 3 Lie empxyx. Suit Utt and explosion uuru can sn.v m aexcued py pramuifun| a ixci/x "j;t cpven.-f -.ioit Mura TNo icxmie court ?;. Liat arf.-t*: sxunf. ";wmiio a specific rwiemu.M may x t CSHa a Py x neanj xi.fitx x cpuntenanct :ai(rroui randiuonj pendi.id Lie promuiiatjon of a refjUi.on .*jt toonficaiiy taarsuq one of ute uuras mi Lie cxdiLon lefxrttx ' Tliis opinion, wfucfi wa# wrttun Py Cirraa .'ud(t Sam 0 Jonruon. *no was .ouied py C.reuit .'ucfes :L GoioPert and Henry Pouu. wtU appotr xluturv Docit.ons xiud. 9 tax *0*0 MO*|TAr MMALTIIS ACAINJT tVQMEM SUftJlCT 09 OlHA INSTRUCTION TO f'CkO Suttd art sot alwiuttfy profiipiied from leveimf ecxwmie pvTuitiX afpuut worten *no fail x comply im jwd ufety and ixoiui tUMarts xi any tux considertni 9X ifXitatdR af Ml unrtjons x iu tux pun tnoux evafuax Ux action carefully x dourmux emetner it etUAi Xt effxuveneia of UW oypraiJ en/orcemxt prafriffl.' oecor^tAS x as Oceupauanai Safety aM Huix AdmxtftftUda fieX difectivd. The dKviiXftf. OSHA Iratmcuod TTT 2-1 IA. dated Fed 29. aXo xx uxt a rtax wmeft xciudoi men ptnaiux x >u puna `muat oxw Pow xeeo sanruons wouM nnr reouct me ovoraii aff#Rivntsa of tM ixte t anforetfnotu program MM tAai af x fodenf afortvmeai propam. " Midi W*v A "*WV VNlV MaavAi'Wiie C'-*aC*T aCCST -r. :.".fn surcet/yi.v oou.aed rev < of jm :ecj.cfl *e Co^^'iS'O" ?r e* .*:m.m;*j.on r*e --pi3*ef :ated is arf.me-ts 3 `.."e r'fii.oi-i*.*. of SuvCb sOjZIO 'AC:ai 3i S C J f m c sr ao'." n appi ed 3 u nc-stm rorjir-.r.rn IS Sfb'OuS VIOLATES CSAmAC *i*.CS j"3 '.soriii:e afieirr* Csnrei. ;:r:f*se^ mt.aiiv ;rat 4 sia.e--eni contained *a*iri 4 proposed 10 i"e jjoetio* siarcara .nciwd.rg ai moimar-| jnd medical tv a.mi-.ac.on ;P3vi|iom ronr.uy'.ed an admijj.on 3/ `-"e n- 'eauoiiuy of jit juncard 41 applied 10 me coruu-jc'-an .ft- T>r ;r'--4Ae*i juf e^.-emrit :f --r ... as a *eswit 3( xrtipa(.ora< sve'eipci.rr - s *..* * 4 u- voianon 3f Jt vctipat.c^ai Safri' i"C 4r4..v *- -f > r.sansrji Safety and Health 3rvie March U u.oft Sjj:pv TV* naimem puPliifted m 'he Frdr*s.' Jryure'onOc- :a*f f 3*5 ..heicated'.rai ;.*e rev sed iianca-'d ou*d e>- ci.ie he constriction .rc.st.m because he .mc.e^es* of .re construction AOustrv itteif -'*'z he multiplicity 3( ron- fued ori3i4ces artfl he ji.iiution of *<f"iiy `.raruent ovtfsrcei presents 4 cm for separate ireaiment and foe equirff different acminutriiiv e ar>o engineer"! con* irsis hicn may oe more appropriate ano feanpie 'or hjl .ndujiry M4 T'i* jec-i.on n GAP C3*7C,z,,zm No !; avrr-.-rec in jcmimiirati^f 'a ,ctt 1 :ec* :* : *e *r '.m -.".at ie found sniy an other-man-tefou* : Aft :i .*? 7>e case arose out of an :n*pec* 3n of :*e ; m* rJ( , NY pnsix.nenicii manufac jr*f 'ac. .> *vp empiover !! m(i(rd in jie ?rx4C..3n of r.'r- . ;a f 4*; niver :iae rfMtats Aif tampies :aen c-r -j a: mptc- non proved that employees >*r ezxsed to a.rxr-e m-v cmtrji.ons of Mver in rices* of :.nai ;rr--1 . v Cc nsauonal Safetv and Heaun Acmmiijracjon candarcs TV ronmunon '*;cr..rf he *n5io*r t argument .rv At the irtil `-he *ecrtar%- .ntrx-ced rp-;:*. % :e-c* dicned '..141 he itate.--ent juoiiaritd sy he secretary *as m* `.".at *11 sbumed dumj ctmicu Mammat.ara of ;; f'oed :o aopiv jmv to he prsooied *evmon of 'Jit standard employees *no ere etxsed :o *..vr at j.t t--sieve* ? and not '.a he existing standard nicn nad not been formally facility Of :.he 30 rmpioyees lit *e*e 3iaj-ciec ay "av:-t rev-ifd F-ir.'tmort he rom-nsiion noted he tttrrtr* fcnerahted arfyna a per-ranmt and .r-rvmiof m \>* suttmem as simoty h.ffti.ift'urg Xib proetm 3iui*n-oiaci ' 3;scoior*tion of -..he u:n. mucous r*v areas ' is ooxsed to rasing deiermir-itionj or fineing! an sranes and eves T>e Jiu.sh-oiac* um sucoiorition %n he >ni9intv d he nandard mown to ie more marted *n the iijtt^iposed array :/ *r *>e e^aio'er comt*oed aiso hat compliance *itft he face lees arms and hands In :*o other onmt :.icoi:n- -onusrng and medicn examination provisions cog.d ether uon of Jie itin *ai noted only in arm of jc* a^c -pci no iselui purpose and hul X an expensive for Twenty of J.t *orin *ere 3ia|noted a* hav ( a-p -on* a mality or ` .nxJt a lussumial economjc 3urtn uh 3/uun-Oiacs lijcoioraiion of the con;unc::vi -t * e* ne|!.-|jpie x*efu '.a e?noiave ' In lusport s< mu arjv 7>ie irai ;ud|* ronneered yte medicai ev-se*ce ara con rent Hetearrn-CattPtii cliirned 'Jtat io .even of asoostat cluded '.i41 J* sfferi of fixture to *<:er are iu~ 4. v at -jtt onsite as *cil as ooen. ventilated conditions coimetic m naturt Therefore we ;uC|r neid .rat a.ihr.s* prtcladed Jt .need far .redicai esammations It added '.".at Jit Secrtunr mramed his ouraen tf pr:v*( e-p.avee ;t i.touid Uve xen aoie to rtiv on resgiu from monitenjif jytrtrpciurt 10 auver the Secreum Jau .9 prove .**; men it it ot-ftef utes eonsiracted :A Jx umt such yiouuon eas uteiy to cause serous or :eai.". r anner as tA one cued. TVe ;udft then affirmed uht 21 CFR 1113 : :co< a : cvj- i T>:e eomnniion ref ased to accept Lft# offtplovef j defense uan as oUr-<daa*snoua on ute pound Jut it addressed economic feasioituy vnien as not specifically encompassed Oy the terms of the sun* Uwiai 1 1 a<fnrs sard The ijencv n<d jm it could property cwuider a On review the secreta rv arfaed '-".*t severe r^*rc-.e defense of impossibility of complunee >n this case. Put `Jut j.t employer had failed ta uten Jus defense. and iirr-enioie tun dtscpiorsuon s a se'-ous *a:ar; mifun the meaninf of use Act. In addition \* secretam arfjed out iryvrj it a total phvucal atsrupt.on of -"e si.ft t normal state and the psychological and socsai 3'if jftr.is-? In a concvnftf opmaaa Acuif Cuirman rnnft Eamaa* Lbat may result from such a xrmsnent nfl.r.on are did not ;die vui ta merony u naaeniM ^ economic in- Lbemseives itfftciem of find s tenous vtoution 'eiesuiy couid em he sssened u a defense u Jus ease T>ie employer argued that the secreun't contention aid The mc90tauae of Jus defense enforcement praceeainjs not fit enuua the dtfuutioa of serious pnvsiciai him as is neremry ie order to eraurt tAet the burdens placed on that term is defined >a the Field Operation* Manual for compfywf employers are ~ reasoned*. ` accord*n| to Eer- OSHA compliance officers According to that definition IUIOl seemarv has te prove that espoture to saiv er snti rmoer inv feniurmnre. he wed that Use centioerauon of Jus xrt'on tf the body "functaonaliv uneiess. luoyunnauv defeme Pe thr rommiMKW j anor***rute m nru of the rttfucvd m effieitnce. or that it nil shorten life 1fence t mandate to pmeet employees anlv to ihe ffirm TV A mew Commisuon noted that the mal record before feasMe assunpon for the positun that erononucfeasioiiitr it failed 10 fftaolish any systemic implications to silver ex- mar be considered <n enforcement proceedmfy even thouffi poture and that the seervunr s medical etpcm tmnfird mat a sundard does not rtfer to feasibility, he nted the Thiitf " no mared influence on neatth was demonairated 3' hn ("irrju oninmn n a/lnnrrnn ^*//.^/e enore fnr> m study However, the commission rejected 'the nmton that a l OSAMHC m OSHC lOdli and mat of me Sum Circuit m woner 1 ruwanuai aacnfict tf bis or ber appearance is l RMI Co r .^rrv of Ldhne 4 nSAHHr<1 OSNCMIbi anything u than senoo." After revievinf the e^idencv. nrver Sunuao mdicaied According te the commission. 'It Ihe permanent treev eni- that ihe empiover had failed to meet his burden of prueinf Me staining tf [employees I sban caused bv the 4ex*nan of the defense u that the cents of compliance had not am nlvor slid the mcrvsst * melanin production result* n an mown Utinuon tf the tttf s psgmemauon itf ficiem .0 require a TVs rvimf ml appear 10 a future Oeciaena issue finding tf serious nelitiua." 4<l|t Ce<NM-om *ddt m* b<*av m uetwnw sro** me mm sai+t-imm 1432 CC'-*AT:CN sA:*v i Marm.m rm.ti;-i**i **r : < it:s ?*r tear# rfi.mete* f e-d- anc : J ~...ar.s r t;.4.*p cfrti.-rer * ' 'd oi-1 art X7.:a:.ona* star.darj 3l ;j - .ir.i ;tr isuaff cent.meter Z3I units measured > j| 'hii itHrttl ,;:.in a Her--an :f e 2:v jia of eie-rome sntfucvt. Bureau af 3adi0ie|:cai Heal* rd and Oi"jg *iminutf|. t.on reported :n aPoraior'* -sii measured X-rjv raciof.-wuencv .tintownd vis<P'e and nfrired emissions rm>m *.ceo u:ia* *>in ramp.ne ma.adjustment of all rsmrpu .9 product me possible conditions These :eju moed emits.on *a<wes ex.sung suit -`eoerii. anfl .nter*at:anjt Herman u<0 ne ceuid not iw prdn*u:fjtifff jijrcarts 'ar video Jispiav anil radiation emission .n me 'areieeao.e foure. adding mat we try to Lmut urtcj.'-j io --.at need ttaneardi Vfvraft L *oibanm. 3f me Dve university E*e Center. corr?.e<ed m iiuet x .* Uteory a1 <idto supfav unit radiation emissions He said mat in conducting measurements .1* found laeigrovnd radiation >vn often rc greater -jun `.it 'scauon from me idee lima* unit meif He added mat 1 flouretrent :4m emitted more u] ;ra<offt adianon -"an *idec displav unit. The 'tieirenert 2;6 tot inmui atntr potential Mall* futaros from video dijpiav anal ai camoieieiv as radiation hauroi Most agreed *iowevef utot `.lexe uuru were acute 'stner tnan enrame 1.1 ^atur* gward ; SjrtaiCi.cn af Georgia institute of Technology outlined *<swa* proo-ems lucr as fatigue |;art rotor oe/ec* uveness and -* cffecu of adaptation usoctaied ua now display amt use Marvin J Ganioff. af the Motivation and Siresi Sowarcfl Section o( MOSH 'esor.w on oiptr.mcnul and fmid 1tv vesufiuons rcatirtf visual 'aucua and otter vrstat cnan|ti to video Cason* gnu ort He su||rsted '.-it poof contnat. (:arv and ms^ficient vort-rm oreits rrjy cofltrfeit* to nntr romoiainti. Sul .ie eoncuded Jut cauMl laneJ|ts suit -ecuI re suosiantiauon Cuier repored ccrr>4ims jnc-jded povuanJ lacamJon and mujcuiar usoroen Sooert Amdl 4 \M I'njvemty o< Wisconsin, annotated Jiese arootems to iviward or im proper poiturtt static aaomf d poitum muscled for lonf penadJ. and repetitive motions ludanf to muscle fatafta# and disorders .nvoivmf tenoons. muscles, joints, and nemos. fteseareaen ecviated an several causes for tnese proMems Most acreed t&at tM vortouce ai paruiily to ptame for pmjiia compUimj. Micftsel J. Smua cftief 9t ute Mouvauon tad Slrw Xessairt Section * NIOSH. uad j trt art pad now Olsou* suu os \M nurtet. ud sound er|onemic pnnacia for tfteir use. t&si tamgiy are nos pel into effect '*Vf rsa t uvavs go Met and try u Mat v$ m me manufactamt." M added. SmaiH ano omen ifircd. Mweeer. ifut jno content may tfurt UM aume for causand onrter fteaua compfainu `niere art 4 neil of a lot of comauinu out meet uui e rt not Marine' from trouts, microficftt nieen. and outer dcncal sorters. Smua said He Mamed Use repetiuv# nature 0( \M oort and Ute influence of me total comouter system and us reduirememi for fti|a ievi of joi nma and cerum types rf Mafia cempiamu. Smua announced mat MOSH Mans to aa me National Academe of Sciences to revir*rqutnn| vitaon acaminataona for all joot requinnf eiooe acuity vert. MOSH tooommoneeoono Smitn also outlined (tnerai recommendationa tAai NIOSH gave to use San rranciace NevsMder A|eocy. MaM on a eaim 'aiard e*aiua:'pn CfCactrt :*e*e -- --.e-cai :-s nl p# ;u5i.ined <n :o .ma w >ev .nev.-e 5rri;rt ti- * Mai.rtj orip:acet as as xu i r >:* 4- ;ji:a5ir c'ta.'l ce^poara e-|*t: screen 'rfn *:** ir 4*:reu are rpm-jti Set,.i<f "e luiartcf v*ef- :* - i tp:av ..-1: 4-9 me operator set^ren 50 ire iJO mi;,.m*:r*s sr sf '.rte acccmmocaiion ran|e * Settic.f ;. 4f)(:t :n ne ;3 ta !? ?*?! rti.i tie top 3/ me icrwn so vp*- .-i- :-e'i.:r e *> r and :ne pouom 9/ me screen no .3*tr .an 0 :*|rees 9* 5* ev evei. * 5it:rt4 me levboard Jie-fM :tirt *<o 4,'d *33 ,Tiiilime*ers it fiome row * Ma,i| le^poards if xn : e * Setting me ulum:nat.on ie*ei 3eteen JC3 ana *:o .1 * Coniroiiirtg 41 are * P'anmnf ort-rtst refim.ts a ;$ -- .-!? p-ei after ;wo nnurs of continuous *'fl cuoiav :er*ru*a. -o-x for soenton under moderate visual Jemarci ars a bmirtui* sreac after an# lour of cant.n.ous vors 'zr 3oeratom uJ) Pi(n vijyaj oemancs zr repeuuve *on uses and * Performirtf mpren#Miv# jrrp ace-eni v.yat aminaoons. nui vtewiflj reduirtmentj af me aperitar t ,od in mind Smun concluded mat ;oo cement factors id *- 5io.a\ urut u.<# contnout# 10 me srooiems aeservw .n * iceo ciipii' unit aoentors .n an mteracuve av Comm*tsOA CSAWOC AIjICTS (C3N0MIC ;**ifaJ.Hu^v as off(ns( in Aiscsros vioutrioN :aji An empiover may not Jefend ifamst c:u;.orts 'zr ^oiauons of 4jPostal monitoring arc medical esarv.-at.sn fjnoaros on mo |?eund mat ccmpi.ance 1 economics..^ Purcerjome. me Occupational Safety and Heann Pe*ie Cammauion naied Marco :i TTusdecmod m Rtit*rc*-Cat:'*il !nr H: -- on CV. mg Tou-e* Oti*uton < No lirsii. affirmed in adTjnifuiuvf lac ;udfe s decision finomf mat me employer noaated me standards p> failing to monuar a wortsr.e 11*0 provide medical examinations far employees exposed 10 airpome conctntrationa of uoestos fiOen Thai esse arose after an inspection of me empiowr 1 create ,n Kuiaoilvtlie. Art-. nere tne firm a engaed io conatAicung cooltng towers for a nuctear po er j-ant 7*i# Mn mnsinfd of concnte columns w>ucfi were fmed k<i tftoeiias meets Aj pan of uteir duties emoiosees drilled and -t use sneeu prior to insulting -tem a me edtumns a< mmtitonng me employer 1 onjue for preience of 1 tome iimum fibers, an mduflnat fivgiemst (or :ne *ecmary iaooe found Uiai tmpinvee etnmure to aioe^tns waa 9 33 to | H isdestoo fihen mejsunng ireater utan five microni ie lavigts. per cutic ctnumeter of nr on an eicm Mur um*eigflted averted Mitt. AiUtougn exposure levels dad not exceed utooe lanuu set oy une asoestos sundard ai 21 CT% 1119 INlili, me evidence snowed uui Je emptdver had failed to conduct iu own moniionng of Uio wdruao to dotemme wnotnor emptovees er exposed to asdesuo fibers or to pvt nodical tumanation* to itt employees. On use Msu * Uttx evidence, an administrative law judge affirmed a citauoo issued agamsi tna empiover for ^ofatidRf of asbestos monitonng and medacai etamjnauon rundardj 29 CFR 1919.1Mtif>UiaM<jiili Rmearcn-Cat- a>id-dt ti**, a Brown w'Root. Inc. Post Office 3oi Three. Houston Tens :*X1 ic; 35.501? TCt Cerl Plcherison PSOt CMrlei Tester SU3JECT: Semale oF 'esket ."eterii! hr, F, X, Pin-ely* Assistant wir*eer* o*<r 'Mv'jlsn Se'ety, uked me to sen? t*o simsles aF 'esket H*teri|l uses an Project 35-501?, "r, Prre1 ske3 IF eauld eessltly tell 1F- iny ij canteined within these 4terf*1s, men ishestsj, <//i-yr Chrlj 'ecier SFety Suoenvijar cc: File