Document ddRXwn83J6qgbNLmzxqo0kx0

pmrsnonoii n. pa or o es x> PS* U5 9) * I M E L L O N IN S T IT U T E 4400 F IF T H A V E N U S R ic h a rd W a lm e r, M . D. M anaging D ire c to r I g 4M1 *0 O 2 O^* -9o %6o m*u3o ZUa -25 >* -o -- co c c !-" J o E*o' So ta'S" e J e o e e s - su. g-S 0--.. --0 .2^ 2 s* e--5~e*od 3t SSeE* *c^ISI0h ft. ? X- "O o Z e > XV "' 1 Oh 9*0 *0 E V i ?5 eh E h~ 0 .* *O -? o. ~ 2 i 4o6. ill15 >*5 4 * mZ 2 * oEu 1 fsi 5 s *0^0 0 ! 0 *< s 5 - s-S om 3g 0 o ?S I tgS -- 1x- e *eoZ2 50 1 ^ 55 ** M n 6 : 09 eo : ! AM 2 ----o*4 H . i* rs I; 5 ^ -- o i, J4 ( a o C6 8 < j < u Jo o R o H 5^-0 ' 2 -g X uX a ex 2 x ^ 22 g X --a 0 4 a c 1 > 3,2 k* a * 3k * ft. g g siHsg VX faa 0 m s 14 ir_ faa* 0 m * J; S-S Sjf -5 *g g 2 g f 5-s ii5s.*'' j; A> o JS,, x;:%5 s 1 j ,, * "o 1* J9 2 2 t s fEj -s o k* fa o. sf 3 9 2 O * 6-K 6 23 g a x a. > x0s'*_0 *o za0e fa y W X s: gu(9I z Mc9 --V* - !x * 2h 3 9 ft,X a*T 9 9 m9 2-55 a au eS 1 ~ fa# a O J( # 20 e0*50 r*s to* fib ft u 0 . 2 ad jrsi H s S3 3 sO u S' 3u 2. < us st *s2 :0 3 * s . * M<9 t* 3 1 X s E "S c co --e wX 00 1 9 xx Cd 0 Ij, fa * 0c I 9u oo fit 0 m 1-3 y III O-- -- 0E 0w ^ ^ fa XW 9 0 *- fa 1! tf 20 ~X Po Bw ** ~*o 500 .e* <^X ? 3 > fc X S3 * 6 0 j< 2-. * A a> * ". kev % K ! Se -2 K a- ae --e 3 -a c6o "a Jk3 a 0a g g >-o 0*_ a * oa a C> /:! b ^ a e a% *y aa a cage 3 >3 > * ^ S -- ^a9 2*1 fib 0fa 0. E T9 ee w0 c1 S2 fia O 2 oW u -. a 0o 2X E5 0 fa fa* cV o oa o t 20*5S 03 * & S a 6 .02 ^ s 0 u ** 01 E oe uo Zu 41 0> f0a fa- z 00 00 C Q. G 0* ~ <G vj .0 2 02 0G 60 II fa ^5 Z, 2o s c 2. 2i --aa a .ou ISs |a2us Se :f e 0'a W0 03 g 2|3 03 H a 31 a 2M II 3 2 a fi- ?. 5x ta 11 0 C 0 laX e 2- Sa# 3 00 EXe x 0* e * x0** X 5 fi i; ie s sa Saa >afe *g.' - TE fa xe 0 | ? 2>3* a0t fa>a* --x0 3g x 2 0 W 0 0 T o . . fa 9X e c-2 -5 S 25 0232yla S fa # H iMU0-304 .f^a3A0*** -_< 6 0 e e 0 r a : c 6 fa 0 fa e ? &- k e 0 a 2 0 A0 aftt X 0 9 3 S SX4 -O fH 95 *y* ?! >.J ^ Xa cfc -fa -9 . 24;1.* fJ!*51gi^5.^6c ;J*Offoe2!aa3k0?0*JX0Ccf1a3--x-ag09Jf-a05a 11s ? fi ot a gsQ e j- 2 a a 6 0 h3 c=: <* 2 2 = 4 r aQ3 H os J < U H fa] 2 aa oee 1?a * 0 --*ft* As0 1 < ft ft* 0 ** XX Hi a fa 0* X06 *00 3a0 Sa- eka o5A --Mfa _Xc "00 *- a _ 5x tS *#? ! 2*232 Xft, M03 0fa fNa BS-3S 2S i 2 isl 62 tr * -* 2 X0 E 2 0 X -5f1xa 54 0i J*A "* 2 3A a E a o * Q 3 ( -n e e a * _ m 0 e > X .c e 3; * a* 8* fa ** > S -e 5 5 * T> 0 s? 0 cO ** S t ac ^ si,3 "w 2 m'o m 0 *esS Ec aV *a da is i g-* > +.* ; 5 c &g 4~ hbV o 5 *5*.>*" IS* i 3 - 2 ^- E g uo( &*v *5 V 3 3E i5s S9 IO a. A9 g a . 22 xH^ m *5 o0fa Ob mo 3Sg o 3 u -v* 50 2-S E1 aV 09 J" ^5 J: *T 0 0 * e?|e B 5c -3 O >{' * * 5 * > 5" ea 5 9 'g A f <^ **24 V5 ^-S e 0 Ej e S aE - *59 2? Jut *u| :? 03 s-9 a*0o * h <2 9 ?J * ^ -- foa 2* a 3E 58 BC <"a 6 * 3 W V *A0 S ?3 o .*3h5K . I *>Ho o,20 *s vG jt9H AWo * e e |5 V E -J~eWBT1fMS_i J a > 2 -<-- s. i * U * S -O E - > - 02 B a 0 g g *Z> o3 S* t x1 3B l 2O.* e5 N ?6 32 f*c<-a si<^ts* e !' * 5* * vf J S > lig ,?5 e Es^ S5g S jt - js | S. * .5f 2 S &,*Ss|^JS6j.m:fcn5C'1!a. *_3*:cS#T-Jt*ML-5s--6 i- 0 B,o h U (I c 53 9 . o n u g 5 5J E -O B S I A 5 B>1 s J< - X Sf - ai - t: 53 S g b| - E 5 J? 8a 1e w-- *9*. A** aB ?E A .S2-5 e I 2B u 2a. ||M| 1l n s ! si *" I: X. O B 1* g"3t 32 "taoi- Xw9ao E4* * aCE ?-- a A E _ a a*1 E sc 5 a -o k; ti -12? 3*2* *3S 5 m*\H S*s * E 5: &o < e o2 9"2i ?3 61 6& * s o *2 5 0 3 zlli *>*. fOa > a 2 ^ t*A*9' 3* tS s S s 31 = cgl A5 2 -2 E ^ e 3eo ~-y0fa 0- c fa 0 53o f0ul fa* e b 2 0 r -o #fj eo 0 =S *- SA ,, 3 * |3iE u v9 vc ^f6oa a j* I 9 g 0 2W 5w *o. foa fa e faj 0 X >e* a si _ 5x * *i vB <*o e9 e 5? a0C9rfti 0 9 rJ-100-- ,wO sl2 *| 3 f0al 0fa O ~ %ffci f is: u fa -4 Jj s :s-|i f*a 0- fa acS I - 4P- 5* 1? ^ 5 * tt |3 9^0 6 s g S0 fa ip tc M -o i> 5*2 ill ->0. co 90* ffaa o > >0Gt XfOa E" \l V M < a s WfOa4 *09a ai alt E <r 9 xx g o 0 fi M <o it fa* *3 * 13; JS 2L ng 00U B2s0* ^f9*a r-B 2fa* 4*1 5 S5 1*1 s0 g g| f0aA O0fUa |s IS co 0ao 3 > 4 4 a n Mm v0 c0 ofa "*C0* o -o U 49*1 E si - 9 2a Eu h -0 e9 0 36*90fa i* faa f0a 0G n X es a efa 55 I* E5 0 a *80 50 0a0 -- fea 9 0 ^5 A0*n 9*"m gKoG j fa h 9 0C0 0* g 0f0a* ^&^6*09 0f0a * > a E-- 2_ aoa Eo0a 2 bo a S fiS * : g e *9 sC faa E-g Ti 090 5 > S-9 0* _ V hi * .A 6 a c - a I0 O 0 A t f*a 0a xf0a 32o *9 00 1 fa 0o fa m 0 ts *sfst *9 G9 9 fa -->4 0N *9 0 9A ft *9 00 g5 *9 0 E E| ! fa x ~fa x0 >c ^0 0 C9 f*a i < 0 -" ' < > 5? a>0aC.s*9faOa c : o2 b * x f"c3f Ct ^*> mfli ;Xftac. ex 3 cv> g c ;d - ta4o9*> 3 O fa. oe x*> H Tj b> s f; i*"0". g S -x*o S.x * B ---- c fc. --u *-- -- x fa "a e X o* mm i _X *2 S = * |f 5 h 3 oW 39 > tJ O og> a - -- tr ffaa.. *. 0 o;3i -- o e Is3| _g --3E 3 W 8 :O "O U 3 2 mHm > H <i >! H< < ? o5 a=> b. "i w X fa. s - Q* O W `O * : 55 x 5 2-u * eo *v gmi *v* . XmvZ 6 * TU 3r-o $8 5E o* < g- OA X 2 y fi *m. u 2Li S < e s* ** d SBi tg.,6 -UO . A.. 9_ >-- 1 zu i**nK** 9 * u a*u9fa** 40 *msk t-i- s.t 3 i 5 o s gI 2 = | 2 _2U ux h 0 S ,, l jQj 2 # v. O c -as .ie s ixo > a -- x o E1 ; .-Is* o S 5*S^ fa. X -- fa* 0) ~ O 9 75 * xe J*S u ~ I*>, r4j X- wfia Xo t i w 5 5 -fa. 1X 5Z -hm Q sX o . _OE 5 >.= 2 s x Ztot > A-m. is <2 OU ZX r ui u| si l< Z5 Z <^ ox A. U H <S1 I e9o . In . A Je9 4 ^_ eo o b>- - oNrs e > tc iZ o9 g5 *9 !u M * 5 * " f h *f I? *3 3 1 2 fh* O 2- 2-AX3 ?9* S*S> 2o !s 2^ h _ S' a A X A* i faA *2 >HtX 0 -i j xo ,3*2 o o " 1 U u 5 W JA* fAa ^A a", 04 S SSl t, > 2- a " ? ? X H (0 >* Jht o fa 2 - *o,e<3 pg*i fg*asi X**1 _gfafia*X^ S E -O o JB u" .a5 _Ta# o V) e *- a. > Q << O a 2 . H Co - c E 8u 2x S I S! g a -o. og J < U 2-g a ,, _ 2S x3 au a -o 3 o 53 a"-a 2 2- ^ X o u h 2g.io 2B?J f2iJSS 3s 2 to Ws < p. 2o o n a es ft. Q 2 -w< tt O fa. Q J U X X <z u w> a xu X a3 ok a> ea 3 * S2 - !I o* 5 9 9m 9Z r: is c-- ^9 -E V H 7s c e *.* s t-3 a -2 OO*C9 X x *. xV H c ~o S. E ^ mCfaf*a *Qo. c i< ' J` 2S U<S' 0 64i -3 m ~S* uSe| 4 a j! a . *aclxil*x 51*1 *Sfa fmu4 3* 9 9 5 O3 *e ^a ~ s. g . <$ j je -w j- l s* f ?al$ * C^ 3c *- S2 6 < - j J-- .* EV 2* *a5 tC M3 5V*-l ' sa. i- l*w --> Sr MJt - e> V H1 h V 2 hx | -*4i MM s s i fi 3fia o Ag* pal a Jv 0o> *53 3*$ Q* . a ;< . e* 1S s e!k2 :?St o25 w w2 3 r-Sj 5J50 a * ^ ,L^-- \ af *2 3 V- X J 0 e t* oe . "a ufa ie Eo9 V w U _ -yc 2 fs &0 *c 2 * = i j< -. g . E j < m30 9 *<9*1 -- n* ,2g. g ISail I "Ji A fa a r*s j-J*! rls^s -332,26 Jg 3^o I**i!s * -- 5^ 0 J! f-a - g* S *> *g - 'S <o oo g2 .o -. ac + > <";2 ft a 2 ei " g jj < a <1 . 2 2!5_>*5<. 3 'g 2 , i 2^^ SS3j" 6 S-S352" S IIIs?! 34 " i5 i a a = ~0<X I og > o .2 O' Ob --o <y E` e > c 3J 2U 3 o Ok S *e !* 2 Sa 1SS2a f5a*.22 1 . 'S - - * sEf S s2a 2j> S:*fXi -- -o * TahaB* J a xJguarfihi*u J"r2<6 i""gf -3 u.: J.5 i.> i> e A* U S3 - . B I j (S *V5 < X*a ja* XX3^ -# o e 0. ^ r 9 ^ ^ 5c<2': 8 s i&H - jr 2 * o c g. tt fa Wfi U !^ 0) a*6i) SrB >. . fgt,--'. <x S w -* : av Sf*l iA.JJ{i oi sIj oas- X** 3"aU -<x+ 3ue. fl o c fa 6 A <51 fa O, l ifea oe.* i 2 3 ao Ah ;5 3o ta 1= m 3 9 0 s^ MO e9 52 2 fd fa fibfa> e A. -- -- _ M9 ^a s Ut Oo f,a .*fa aC *u\ *5 - - i - -o >s V ^a V A% 0 fa r. "Sa >fa. 3 o. I a 5 a 2 -< 5 a -J *3-5 " . "3 <a "B 5 W ^ o ;; 2E e ** A -SO isM 6 j 3 32 9 0 f0*a *izU JJ ga fa * f3a amu -ga : .s 3 -2 fa 0. u lz 13 g < 3 3 > m>*% t Is 8S f9a Mp* 3 E2r " *:E< a S. >n. OM 2 aaOa a- So g 5S is 3Sa |J A3 A 1% 1 Jc ASBe3 Sia "Haalth XlalnUi C . Richard Wal Health. A p ril. a fa Ob fa g * Pl4 a * *" s VS s 31 se J : 8 o EOZ 514^o wZ-- 15 i * ^ 6 = 22 3C 2 5 ei . r2o4 2S S *2 ?IO *S I r g 3 gf 2 I v a ( D* .3cSXmr i <" i-s'5 *.."M2fi too --C e -S * fi -eM X-,. 5**a0 x0 8- -.5 <c* ^t. h 9 AO Cw s :2 0 x *5 j*i V# ^to fl>* < A-- 3s 4to# -- _2 131hom^ o o e < *,, u~ < fj> i*f e?" 0 5;x 0 1 fi s e - Jrt to r * fi E e k *-- * sQr js -o xc o aTjQu* * CocA ~ < teVuo s I* 2Eg i2 s< *O2 1 --Wt O XM*0 eW c a S 2" * S eS J^O 22 sHaE, S -2< CO Q *k -&- * s j 5 2 2 ! I2 22 ^B < > s. -o sl-jSg e - 5< o* > 3f, x h5 j-o J4 S g 5 . 5<e 0 8 w "t P ef u 0. I J 3 -2| 01 5 < x x 2 c * 1*' *2 Nj! V<) HaI A U S-- 2X I- <f j XA k. X s u c -0B A Ex S 2 0>f SI 01 b. ss 3 to ^ E e? >E * 5> x0 < 0e 0. 0 13 > 5 x*0 0 -i * S' 5 >6 XC *" Oh X-- Eo fi >k uX ^1v lo us o_ si 6*0 ll Ox b. eif < w In X 0fir 0 -- 9* XA0 O !r E -0 C0U o eo 8= Xto M j: 0 ^e* wO, m * S.2 fi. m to 3 - E fi f2c 9e 0E *o** , S Ee SiS *1. s <c H 2 O 0, cu < i u0 (0 js -H to Q Joe0o --ffiit s* o lo eo * IsO6 51 I u fi fi. U w ; if o * Uo we h * h* X* Jo 5o ^ 0! c A XN X Ns n 8I .. *-- e Of 5 0. w c * c5 B 10 Q ou ah H E ^ S | IS S .n2 . < O U O JO 1] 35 O2 H *u S >0 k^ . .' 2 B-- J tfl o s 50; h!2 ;# I b 5 2f J* `ssf o t S ? J X -01 to a p o d a l publlcallono lo r which ro p rln to I APPO IN TM EN TS TO I- H -F X oo o- wo O* T. S <2 5 a' 52 >5 <m 0 ~2 O3 S 1 ^ I Ba. Eo O k >. : 0 o H X * o g 23 ?X a\ c 9 o X-- H A f 8 o E 2 go b xa U9 Si to x E o Ao 3 & 8* 26 X O *. CS * I?a2 o . D *> tort w *0 e> *x X t* * fi NA* --TJ fi X > O. 3X - 2*0 aHrt S 2 Io8 li fi u . fi 0m fi o * fi Wc to A A uv (U fl XM m c 5 *! 2^ x^ ainn. 2 2 E t fi* =-g<l= n | J b .hfi jX= X,<* ?S x 6*5- 5 *% "* Xb |a " Bo^ Hoort ;2SP ; #5 o . 3 3 25 ?- g 2 $<3 ** k _ O foi Of -- rt6 v I ! to .-5o;-0 S o Ic "*0 tol u f lj B^lo : Oifu s --2M ^^E-XbsS^2 'S t iJ-rl* fk3E0 &2 * xO ks g 2 ** 0 o: - S : w -* 3 B 2 "--so* "o- S2 ^jj: . XXX P 9 1"2 23 --0^3* rtrt < J! S 1 2*8 2|5 --x,, 2-!22 j->bu t g o" f b , 5 0* ?E .| A-- J a O O h 2 ao -3V O. . S,f xW e o z 20 uX m e ok |.=Sb |Ie k ; z < t o o fr2f s ws Urp - -o n -0 ae ii : %tS * 15 5 fi % S fi 30. M xxVsetu*) x-Ac Xv rK. o (fa 6 fa = i <-2 ^ r* S 5 2* -- *'S jt * ,e5.,29>M9efa .* <* = * * * *s c ? * a 2? 2 - >. 2 ~ * _ v -- =5 V ; 3 e * o. s 5f0*gt UO b -9c0 ho. 4n 5c Sue * 9 * 5 S J 5J= | jt * - u, *; ; S,j*s"* *55*:2 19 lc> C c AO *#1 ~* eX -sr> i=M^ u-Ig; O 8 *? Zh t a i'o t 2 t * X*92 --049 . is>-eutaBS>I'~8** !r22-sj"8ji 4.3* v* Ok _ %M jab* ^ u - 2 fa a,4- fa 2- M3 * i 1 ,I--6 e 9 * x: a m |o.=5.* 5fa 5'e0*,-s* ^|f .c-`JSJit-0e ** 8al4 s -Xft*iBXS j*fe2jt je* 0 X * ft ** e 2 Q 4 3ei5iS . S' V S 5 *** -Jt Mw e j a . e ,c * * ? !\a: s7*-5**a-#o32s * j Sff `Jje g,,2Z Je"; 4.. * o s. .g s|2 ** c 5^ e *4 40 2 * J M*2 fct =i f y !c 3J--".Uffai>Xj-".w0as**d(. b<acaa5f5Si5g>If2HiJvB.gVga!i*Je*"jdS#*s*gB|***S"8M8m*lifc0e2l*ai*a*wSNs'S(*--t;afh*ai';SJSj9*fet*,s'i-i%*cC<jXoiSVVtsJt*i"tui--;a8**1 = s,; a ^ i sa *s ft a i fvt 3K fBt, w Bft * os o So524g g ? : e S^ "s ** > 35 * ft i * e n 5 .1 or !i fa> ,,r O g j * B , aa fa O *u J.l fua .la* saa:t ?al:Sa?| 3i|Ijg:55*. 0. A o fet < i;A i0f, g. f0t *Xf0ct ft X 3 Xfftt Xfa a0 Jo em co* I51* ^*<>.5-w o Jt -9 -- to< e i gi xV <8*9 g g 9*2 J5(5" iw "f#ca O ft 5 ^ ^ is * HV Bft fc So 2 B' --*B* 9ffmtt -8 * I g a!! B x*" 90 # o' ? B2 21 B 2 a >. 9 u ^ o-c * c s* fa : i?t^ e oje zit I t"* s -o s ho 8&" e5 :o o 8> o ft ftl lJmi5 os S,<3(5 o A SS2 |!l3|2ft * JK ^fet J8sb I < : If 5 >SIt8 ft CM U * Sz J P U fa a m o IP --oaJs I e5 *O-- j^S-sft Sj!i * " a l Xft ft 8at _>. 'S mtt .=2*.299* > >: a _r e 2 >QfBftt h ;o H 5S|S 5 g4 *o* Om X C 22 B >^ 55 s ga m h0 e 8l3|> 2;*e5 3*!rf|- b m 2 ft JS 2 i * "till ss1| X ft 6 S E ^u0 <C Bo 0O0B 2 CP fgOt f0t - *g*-2ft fc f RM ft ft x aw X JcML E0 U *3 2& -I Q SA tfa & S I *2 3?*Sj3! c! : zl Ut (fa < ff*ti* *1 *- *fMl B 3||& o< so2 u ft ^ 9 4 --ft -mMa| ft *Xf*t* X** H p*` 2e 3- <->. x Bo o H >* 1xis 5 D -B 5* < the U n lv e re ity o f P itte b u rg h G reduete S chool o f P u b lic H ealth. M r. S ch re tb e la 'a p n v to u i experience Included in d u a trta l h ea lth engineering drtth the D epartm ent o f H ealth o f the C ity o f P itte b u rg h fo r one y e a r and e e rvlca aa a s a n ita ry anglneer w ith the U ntied S tate* P u b lic H ealth S ervtca fo r fo u r year#. a Xm gv w <o" x0, "eo xE Uo oJozz< o Sn'a: 28 *Xv O ; >> ft 52 5n 5 >u ft Q X * s2 H tm o 2 ft J t. 25 Q Ift Q? U 2 $2 W0 *1 d- 2 (0 X o h<: S -> 3< ! ft 2 y* <^0 0h* u2 <0* w 3(Q 0c S*tfxuo3t x5g*B* ' S os; "X fxt BHS J0** zQ0 2 Ss 3t fmtE9 oS z2 28 d3 s* Q2 |! M SSS 3 u - *59 It J5 ff<tt ?X 35 u o z => o u >< ft wo > O < g 2 <e h X X e 5 |x -I3 mae o k. C & Eo e2 (0 J-0 O5 Sit ft s * <OM Q9, f0i o 00 O 0 0_ 2 u 0 *5 0 .M2 * -- S>* --y D* * w 98- ^fa* -S js c 2 e U xuhg X 09o. (0g 22 5g ?M 0> fOt* X0 j" x9 S TS :s ft BK a, UEo v mge aa. < <fUto -*f<t ft X "X5 o ft <w w ft (g0 Oft 2 2 to X uft s2 Q s2 2 O H f<3t o a 2 ft aft 2 u w 0 b? uIn o a 2 < 2M 3 Ooc3 k to ft Uve >2< < ft 2* ft ft ft * . ' u H fnt s ft ft fot Q ft <o ft 3 6g J?"U -8 S - < ;3| X ft t 2 ^ o Uin --s -c s O>3 Cam. 1315 3>r. t. J. leConnell, JL.isH. Xedicai Director. Insustrial Health Section, Metropolitan. LiXe Insurance Co., Ee Icrd City,.. . - - **'* Xy dear Brr``HcContiuIl: V h ."--v^iSiTSJirr: Xsbeatos IXist nt Sorth Charleston Pleat. *a*c*, our plant at Sorth Charleston, as *eil as tb* other.* Divisions, iiT* been cording vitfa your Ccrpany Xor a long xlae:.ia the cX iaXcmsticn, necical and otter- vise, regarding i^tutxoo Hut to.t; and Asbertoais. -7r*V-*.. . ':>Jfe hare Los a sssbcr aX suite, es you ere mre, Xor vhiea 70a hs7o axulsttd uu tt prepare, rad at the last trial, your dr. ?ahnel tec.iliix. It hart dopeauad on your Corpary to present certain ir*oru*uian that our attorney, Hr. Julian liltohtl oX Charleston, S. C., desired. and ot vere at 0 stfcndotili to buna irftat to do and c-r:y un vita thuae cults, Xor X again say re had depend*!'.on your Coapacy's assistance. Ha rurally, re were very rush upset last wisk then X.% Jul'icrda rrpcrtcc that re could not expect any court assistance Xran your dcp.'rtaent, due to orders you had received Xros your superiors. e lfiaeii-iely vested to have you talic o7er the situation vith Hr. liltahell, te sc that he could as, and then taey got In touch vitii uc and auuec rhat X thought cX Subpoena ing Hr. Fehntl, X told than Xraicly that it locura to ne ts IX that was the only thin* couud do, IX vte vert coin: to have the help oX Hr. Pehnel in these particularly Important, eases. Xt say laox occ' to you that this subpoena vas aerred, but really there vas nothing else Xor us to do, usd X could not set iy other vxy out under the circanstances, after Hr* Hitaha11 had pointed^out that it vas going to aeas to his to hare Hr. Pehnel there. X do hose you vlll h&ite this into considsratisn and that the assist ance oX Hr* aehaal will be given ns very cheerfully. X can recognise the position aX the insurance ccopsry in testifying in ordinary cases oX this Jdna, hut as X see it, these particular cases of ours at Charleston really cose lr.ts a dliXurent category. e carried Conoensatlun and Health Insurance vith ysur Ccnsarr vhen these suits were Xlrst brought uo at Charles- tsa and oX course, uaaer the policies, % rere rwt covered tgsin cezege suits Xor Asbvstosis. 004 C ---r insarsne i t \ jCo-:iisaiy-ii r ir.su a?- Jotaat-JinnviilM startsd *ith z Du* s^rv-v 0f ------------ T.>.en y.-or appropriation"for t:xil\h*r ,..i :*;r -l-t V fcs thst it b c-.rri?? on l I;1:-*;*- 4"a > r.,:U* btoy^X-I;'rTeC?o1=6*?" ^y5i5S*^C0*r*tr3n-*a so. ' the expense or Johs-aln?<" i**: cr. 2^ia ell led us to believe that uacer the conditions, * would hsro 7Ti? 0S3lotAr.cn in trying tie**; unfair suits( hich wou eventually b. a benefit to you, ore Also hare eonsicertble bearing on the Dost rzatet, about which so aucb nso been pubiistod lately. I ft-ei na ir 7our Cocoany has not taken into consideration all the: various factors whan taming down our request for Mr. fennel's prt: cnee ct tat trials ir Cttri^rttr 1ir. ?ehnei being the only aun ehc haa beta following tne details of tra Asbestos Iniat through all its various raclficr.sirrs laterally, if r? etulc have xos*-s*.vr* tt*e attitude the Metropolitan Insurance Co.'s tfeciaax Seporsnsnt wo.*id take at this late data/ae wauls h*vc rirer c specialist and be would have had all the n-to vnish yrsr Company stjw n;*s. om* -s you jcbov, %v have spent largj suss fcr ss:i tar Carries ton Hlcnc on iveul one, with ( you; asaistu&ce. ( I tla r.st btlirrs that by ah*. fanna! tesiiiyinz at Char leston, it will witablish c precedent, *t- it. is forcl7 liiely you r >111 tars this type or east- ccrae up a*Lin for s-any year-', end I an also certain At Is rtry questionable if you will get the sane aaaur.t of assistance fsoa any tve cocranics that you hare been get- tlaj fron Johns-lirxrillc arc ourselves, and coreorer, It was oar intention to dr.\r it: otnor esbes to?; conpacics In tnis survey cs soon -T tho tine tv: right to fcrir.r tnss is., cnc. this would nan a tranuranus anaart of infrraetior. An Aabesto-s lust i*nd Asbw.stosis in the pcsotssicr. cf the Satrcpolitaa Insurance Co., wna would be the nrjLy cats in the baited states, so fx ns t.w uuw, having this in- 1 arm. *lw?i. - x hi.-* >.%n trying to got In touch with cy friend, Mr. Jenea 1. Savins"h. Vico frealwont of the Metropolitan IcsurAcce Co*, to endeavor to hare hin naXw on oppointawnt with Mr. luber, y-.ji p-- ` i c na. so I can go over this natter with hin very care fully and^tVioraughlr. ant I hope to b* scie to co so nest Tuesday. Ozfortunntsl.T, I be i\r^y the letter port of this reek. Very truly yours. f ?r*iridcnt / t 0040-: / V.* t Cc". 3, 1315 Br. l. J. McConnell, Aas't. Medical Director, Incustrial Eealah Section, Metropolitan. Life Insurencc Co., 5e 2crx City, v My dear ZCy'ilcCpntu:!!: j j ( . V / -L-.^iSUSJZrr: Asbestos JXist at Barth Charleston Pleat. >:A3 y*j \-rcv, our plant *t Borth Charleston, as veil as the other.'Divisions, Lit* been working xith your Corpany for a lens tian.ia the. acquiring of Lnfomaticu, nccical cal other wise, re garlias Asfcaito:; lost Lnnnrns cal Asbertoais. jryy.-'i. - Loro Las s gnnbcr nf salts, as you *r* imt, Tor xfcica yea Lavo i_s^ixt*S as as prepare, sal st the last trial, - 7our dr. Pahacl teo-.ifiix. tc hart dcpauaed oc jour Cocpany to present certain lai'am^aloc that our attorney, iir. Julian bitohtil, of Charleston, C., desired. ~t at* xcr* it c rthnittill to kuov xhat to do cal carry ua Tits tacte salts, for I again say re Lai depended'.on. 7 a-ar Convey** as sir tana c. Maturtliy, xe xere ery rush upset lust wuk then r. Jui'lcrls rrpsrtca that xe could not expect an~ court assistance Iran your depprtnest, due to orders you Lad received frox year superiors. e lcaeai-tely wanted to have you talk o7er the situation xith Mr. Mitchell, te st that hs sauld as, end when tsej got in touch %itu ur uni Aakac rhut I theught of "subpoena ing Mr. Teasel, 1 told than frankly that It locked to ne as if that was the only thing x* eouud id. If xe xcr& going to here the help of Mr, Pehnel lu ths* particularly iaportant. eases. It say loos oca' to you that this subpoena xas carrel, tut really there was nothing else for us to do, sal Z could not aei any other way out unaor the cireuastances, after Mr. Mitchell Lad pointed^out xhat it was going to aem to Lis to Lavs Hr, Pehnel there. I da hope 70U will tak* this Into consideration anti that the as sis t- iisc. of Mr. Jehal will be given ns very cheerfully. I can recognise the position cf the insurance ecrp.ry in testifying in ordinary cases of this kina, but es I see it, these particulat cases of ours at Charleston really cote into a different category. Be carried Coaaensatian and Health Insurance xith your Ccnptxr xhen these suits xcre first brought uo at Charleston and of course, uaaer the policies, we were not covered agsirs. cenege suits for JLsbosvosis. 00*3CCl ----------. h:.-* cny da ., ro: ro ot.v,:-r ir.surzr.c w& .ht W?(S fcOTih Vf~7 k>>3 * * k> v -- _ y--~ Cocpsrr, fcr- * did sc. Later" on/w* hired a nan, -'<. vorr uad'jr yrur control, tut t the expense of Johss-lUnyi; it"'. y^is ia us to believe that unctr the conditions, w would iavr yy;; cssirtAr.cn In trying these unfair suits, which vou eTenr-Cill7 t a benefit to you, arc Also have consioerabl* bearing on the JDetat rautet, atout which ay such nao been published lately. I feel ns Id your Cocoany has not taker Into consideration all the: various factors when turning down our recue.it for Mr. Jehnei** prt: cnee ct tat trial* tr Cnvi^-Ton iir. ?ehnei being the only sun niu tea been following tne entc-iis nt the Asbestos Imot through ail its various raalfleaders. Saturoliy, if r? could have ior-s-.vn the attitude the Metropolitjs lr.rtrcr.ee Co.1 s Medcai Zepsrsnent ao^ld take at this late datr/vst wruls hitvs nro c tpeclaiira arc be would have had all the n-tc wnich your Company so* n..s. ntk -s yuu jov, %v have spent largj cues tr rrhr cne Chrraeston'Wient an iveui one, with your assistance. I Cz not bt-lirvs tnct ky su* i'chriti tesi-iiyinz at Char leston, it will aatntlish c precedent, it it. is h*.iel7 likely you will t'iVr this type cl case cove up t*uin far cany years, and Z as also certain it is very questionable if you will get the ssae hhoar.t of resistance face any tve companies that you have been gettins frou Jahns-lirxriUc tnc ourselves, and r.oreover, it was oar Intention to CLr.\r it: ot n*r esbesto?; conpacics in tnis survey as toon sr tho tine rvt ri^ht to trlr.r thoa in, tno this wuic aean a trasuThrua cnaurt of inrrnatitr. dn Acbt?:.to.s lest i.ne Asbw.stoiis in the posotrsicn cf ih; ZtrreBolitaa Insurance Co., ana would be the only ones in the Unites StAtca, so Iat ns we crow, having this in- i orn*ciwh. I have be*n trying to gut in touch with cy friend, Ur. Janes 1. 5ivana.*{h. Vicu ?rerioent of the Metropolitan Insurance Co., ysur to endeavor to hae Prvcidcnt. no I con hia hake nn oppointaent with go over this natter with hia Mr. boker, very cure- fDunlflayrtuenndr.tTahivo,roIughly*-- anbe f hope to be able to iypwy the letter part oo of so nest Tuescoy. this week. Very truly yours. fc--* Preridcnt 0040-1 -/ Cera n 3, 1315 l?r. l J. ZcConneli, X.ns't. Kedical Clxectar. Industrial Health Section, Metropolitan, Life Insurance Co., lew Icrn City, ^ ...^ Hy dear Drr'IlcrCrntu:!!: -.l-.v.-iSUSJT--: Asbestos Hist et Hcrth Charleston Plant. .^Aa 7Ta t our plant et Borth Charier ton, as veil is the otherr Divisions, hT* been forking vith frour Company for a lone xlae:.in the-aiuji ring of lafamaticu, nccieal ad otter- vise, regarlins Asfcuaau:; Bust hat* res and Aster tools. btTo hud t stnbcr ~ suits, cs you ere mre, for vtiea yea ha7o esuistad an tt prepare, and ot the last trial, 70ur Hr. Pshnol "testif let. Is hare depauad sc ytur Cccpany to present certain infomohioc that our attorney, Jir. Julian Mitchell, of Charleston, . C.. desire!. ad tt* vers at c standstill to doe what to do end cariy un ritu thuse cults, for I acolt say re hr! depended. on. 7 our Goosey's assistants. Ha rurally, re were very rush upset Inst wax* shea r. Julicrda rrpurtes that ve could not expect any court cssistcrso Iron your dcprrtnent, due to orders you had received frou jour superiors. e lEaesi-tely vested to hare you talc 07sr the situation vith Hr. Hitahell, to sc that he could as, end then taej cot In touch %itii us ad sauce that Z therght of "subpoena ing Hr. Jean*!, 1 told than franxly that it loohe! to se is if that was the only thlai ua could as, if sre vers going po hare the help of Hr. Jehad iu these particularly inportant- eases. Zt nay loos occ' to you that this subpoena vus serve!, hut really there was nothing else for us to do, usd Z could not see any other vay out under the circueutsnccs, after Hr. Hitahell had pointed^out vhat it vss going to aean to hia to hsva Ur. ?*bncl there. Z do hose you vlll tsuce this Into considsratisn and that the assist ance of Ur. Jebawl will be given ns very cheerfully. Z can rscogaiss the position of the insurance ecnpsry in testifying in ordinary cases of this Xlno, but as Z see it, these particular cases of ours at Charleston really cose into a different category. Pe carried Cor.oensatiuc ad Health Insurance vith your Conpany vhen these suits vert first brought uo at Charles ton und of course, unaer the pollcie:., %e rere not covered tgsi--. ceueze suits for Xsbos'-osis. 004 C^J ,,,, .,j: ro Q. r insurznc h./e'ny data that ws *arth very trh.n0i lust- :or sb*stoxis, * cr. t-.,\-cx mr.js.^p-jSrirjf t***--*. v~r V Co: .IS 2'^ifsl-v;y of * .* ** fl ,F*vn ifii^??ro7rAatl:Ja *r t:ii- w-x'r* t*,,* 'St j ycj f, u* ee ^T-^p Cospsry, and *e did *0. aterPi/** ^ by to y2ar cor*trai> ^ <** tie expense or Jobra-^?^*1 cu tTbis ell Ivd ns to believe that uncer the conditions, w would haw. 77;.* assistance In trying the** unfair suits, which vou. evenrutll7 tx a benefit to you, era i*l*o have consicersbl* bearing on the Cost rasuet, soout which cu such has been publlshoa lately. I feel an id 7our Cocoany tea not taken into consideration all the: various rectors when taming aom our reeuest for Hr. rhnel`s prt: once ct tat trisis in Cntri^-vm iir. ?ehnel being the only nun whe hts been follcrrins tne estniis of tne Asbeatos lust through all its various ranificatiers. Ssturaliy, if r 1 eruld have ior-s-rr. toe attitude the Metropolitan Insurance Co*s Henicax vepartsmt *oad take at this late date,'us -rouln h*vo streo c specialist aaf be would have had all the fi-ta valor y-r:r Co-ipuay stjw n..*, mi _s you icnae, *v have spent lcrgj cuss tr onho tr.r Chcraestun blent an iveai one, with your assistance. 2 Cz r.zz believe that t>y sir. x\:hx:ti testiiyin? at Char leston, it fill ssintlish c preueisnt, xs it. is h.rciv likely you >111 have this type cr ease ccr?e up a*uin for cany years, and I an also certain it is very questionable if you will gee. the sane auaant of r.ssistmcc Iron iny twe companies that you have been gettins fron Jchns-llrxrillc sne ourselves, and remover, it ws our intention to drnr in otnt-r esbestON companies in tnia survey as loan sr the tine tvs right to trlrr then is, tnc this wuic nean a tresornsrss anuurt of ini rmetiur. dn Asbestos lo.l .nc Asbw.stosis in the pcsofcssicn cf bhi: larrcsolitcn Insurance Co., aro would be the only css; in the O'aitwd States, so X*x an t.e snow, having this in- 1 om. .im. I^htve bets trying to got in touch with cy friend, lir. Jsses 1. Savins:^. Vice President of the Hetropalitun Insurance Co., to endeavor to have hla naice nn appointaent with Hr. Lobes, ysur President, so 2 can 0 over this natter with his very care fully snd thoroughly 1 sh- 2 hope to w-. able to co so neat Tuesday. Onfortunr.tsly, 2 be the letter part of this week. , Very truly yours. Preridcnt 0040-1 Ur. t. J. Incustria Me trope11 Hew Zcru Hr ttis h -.L-.ypiSULTZrT: asbestos IXist et Horth Charleston Plant. y*a :rcv, cur plant at Berth Charleston, as en as tb o therr Pivia Ians, LtT* bvu vorcir.g vlth your Conpaay for a long xlaei.ln the aay.'f.ri a; of Aafamaticn, nccicai and othervise, regarding Asfcostui; Luat haasraa and. Astertools. ~.'**>JJe~bavij huh a snsber nf suits, as you ire avare, Tor tl Vcu 'hu*7o i s jIsted uu to prepare, and at the Iasi trial, your Hr, Pahnol testif iix. t c hart dcpanaca on year Company to present contain incarnation that our attorney, iir. Julian Mitchtil, cl Charleston, . C., desired. imd ui? vere at a standstill to knee what to da and c-r:*y cm vita thute cults, Tor I again say re had depend el .on y cur Coa^mcy's assistance. Haturally, re eere very rush upset last vac* then Xr Juiicrdn repartee that ve could not expaet any court csslstcrso Iron your dcp?rinert, due to orders you had r*ceived iron your superiors. * e IsaeaJLitely vented to hare-you t&lic 07er the situation vlth Ms, Mitchell, to st that he could as, end then taej got in touch vlth +i and eased that Z thought si Subpoena ing Mr. Fenntl, 1 told then frsr.'il? that it locked to ne as If that was the only thing uo eouid do, if ue vert- going go have the help of Mr. ?ehnel in these particularly important. eases. Zt say lose cc` to you that this subpoena vss served, hut really there vas nothing else Tor us to do, and Z could not ae* any other vxy out under the circans tone cs, alter hr. Mitahcll had pointed^^out vhat it vss going to aeon to him to hers lr* Pehnel there. Z do hose you vill tarn* this into consideration and that the assist ance of Ur. Jabnel sill be given us very cheerfully, 0 Z con recognise the position oT the insurance ecnpssy in testify!** in ordinary eases of this kino, but as Z see it, these partieulst cases of ours et Charleston really cose ir.ta a dirforent category. tie carried Cocvsensatiun and Health Znsurar.ee vlth yzzr Ccncanr when these suits were first brought ut ai Charleston, ur.d of course, uaaer the pollcieo, %e rare not covered agsins. cenege suits for Asbi/s.osis. 004 Cl) --.^.j or. te-"T' .'c-_cl? tlueri..2ASt- ____ . . w C WW . > no.- ro ozi.ir Imsmtzic- 't'j has eny data .hat *-:t; fcorth iril"* aA*-dbitr-frotor~.r"i:"i,'tiotrnu: rn::?a"t.urcriarlly AysobuerstCooss?bvus-t wc--?--v wry t*rsl ril^iir^ to+t coo*>r..tw -i*. ysu, i--t ' frith Dust Survcv of : Co=bs=y sJc`n*J.-j- appropriation for init '' t:1* Jr^roostot y~J r'--u* it~t cnrrir.^n^.tsl^. e^f^^ed^ ***??& toToS uSyry^ wstroi, tut at ta ex?e of Jahns-hanville : curatives. ell led us to Veiit;T# that uncr the conditions, w would her* your csslhtAnc* la trying the**- unfair suits, which vou evenrutll7 tn a benefit to you, ora also hat* eonsioerabl* bearing on the Dost raoxet, snout which tv such nao been published lately. I f**e1 aa id your Cocoary hr.s not taken into consideration all the: various factors when turning down our request for Ur. Tehnel*? pre: cace ct tat trials in iir. ?ehnel being the only nan hc kaa been following tne details nr tre Asbestos Isict through ail its various raulficr.ilrrr naturally, if r: could have lor^s-.vr* to* attitude the Uctropolltos Insurance wo.*s tfesicsx vepartsent >o.J.d take at this late dots,'*/.* would h*vs cured c specialist site be would have had all the fi-ti which your Company nv> n;s. ow uS you isaov, . have Spent lergj cuss tr a-sht tar Cs.-rc^ston an i.*ul one, with your scsistwnce. 2 da r.ot btliavs that ly xr. funnel testiiyin? at Char leston, it will tctnhlish c yrcuehont, si it. Is haiei7 likely you >111 hare this type of esse ccwe up a*uin for xany yeara, end I an also certain it is very questionable if you >111 gee the ssne nrount of assistance fion any tve ctw^anies that you hare been get- tins fron Johns-lirxrillc arc oxarsclres, and coreorer, it us our intention to dr.*;r in cn*r sbesto* companies in tnis survey cs soon or tho tine tv: right to bring thtsa in, trx this wold nsn a trosurnrus tnuurt of inrornatior. Un Asbeata* Dust ;.nd Asb>to5ia in the pcsotaslsn cf the Ztrrepoiltan Insurance Co., ano would be the only onus in the l/nittc states, so as t.e una, having this In- forai.tiari. 2 hare be>n trying to gut in touch with cy friund, Ur. Janes 1. Sivans!{h. Vice Jracitent of the liet*-opolltn Insurance Co., to endeavor to hare hla nfJce nn oppointaent with Ur. icker, your President, so 2 con go over this matter with hie very care fully end t'torousiily, tna f hope to t*. able to go so neat Tuescoy. Onfortunctaiy, 2 be ns'*'y the letter part of this week. , Very truly yours. Preridcnt 0040-: