Document dYX28vrKEKop4jQba37v2nYX0

hiss eg BiH iEyi ii i i ib NUR i| bil 1H8l 1 Brzse ek Resi i i lle -- Fe : A | 3 42 i-- 2 HE 3 iiiki '3 felis iiil !2 i4 : 23 3 2 i ! : ial 1 oo : 3 gg 3 a 3 i SiHEi E :$ 1d: lit AiIRdEi.s 3 :i oe i 2 3 3 3 3 {alt ; il i io43 i i oH : Hl : ) BbyHl L1sh . i (REL peli i ; 5 8 3 3 i 3 THiggles : Bl If toy : | gid : I : : | 25 & 5 BoE Ig &53 Of .3 i! ; ad y 985 & . i" RBElE 1 aks !i  Sons : hel Bwl o1odm of hx sois fu `|g Be i Fia Te Hess ie 3 IH FREES w3an358 @ JHAB r i d ubtoae . g ed i . 3 38 i83 i i] |i felis #1 ietel 0i J Ea 125 8 hg. Ei JRE eh ns 2 3 3 >] : . i i . lL k 2 43 ' |& i | 2 : 3 . Ii Fo CH :fl it 13 58010 |i e 8 : gB d B : 13 1 ud , 2Bai8g22 oe i ]5 LA i 1 nr f 8 : 8 : fl i | 23 | i y2 fgli a Hoi F Ji e8 dof 3 8 gl Ebfa 5 [Hd Esl 5 : 3 = 3 2 : | 3 : 2 : - i 5 ; H : I : HE ait Besse ITnE d EB o oes i CRE1 E I 55 i 08 @ TT lo ggeoel 8 f2 3 MTBaiIstslTsi Ea! s fizoze |heg 2o52gdi +fEsyt i WcighEs yLT dd 7 prs ::i |] iE is | 4 | li 8 i7 LEE gy HE i HIE pee J337) H ha IE Lo 13 3858 He iil ii i {uk j2a5g3igl)l f5 iIfEiE p10 3 : 3 3 t , : :. . = v i ; i : i : . | i Iz 5 q ol 3 gh' ve 2 ` 4 ug 4 i 823 288 lt ; i |HE 2 | i i; | gg : ; : 4 : a lit ; i! : 5 . jiTakis ; Bl Ey 2 HIE Ping : A HduEll 2 : g y Bh g rd i: ; | FEE Fass Hg a 14g ee gil bles baa Ne . Ho ooof iy (Eom i g 28 3 33s i iy : el [|H 2 lEs Ea) L 8Eg 3HH Bessa fees s fzizs | afBREeeeels ! Rh de at i 3 | 3 43 i ' Cl fi i 3 3 | t |i hy | | fl : I 333 : =3 | i) 3 2 |B33 23 8 a 3 -------- 2 je IE 7 s888g]| f : i 1 : i ei ESEE * 2 23 i: 4i38 1i ; 3 gs 3 2 i . tlii zull E1gH 1 4 3 of s el ow : ag ld Felsi 3 lHy ahn pid . g: [g1i5i8ly| i& eks ai | 3gaael sds 2 Lo : 2 ' fl : i a* ; g53 fz : 1ii : tals : Bun EiH f33l 7g d3 " I 5 ge35s5 8 foHh 3fa5y : | BE | veifteyhl g iaal i 8 2 4 TR< E | EiEl: i1 fo bos fi | if s < HH i$5 y3i33 i- Ph i i Beas head Busse sgf o J eg Rn 1 E5338 : [fzzes | g| ee#t !:g : CR;ib j1 | 8 ! tkis ii sz: gH LoJE HBER ROE g 7 JEiL iEa p18 ` 3 3 ; s : ;: H s 43 g iHil i Hi fH y fe k: . ile 5 1g |fhe Bloou : jie | 8HH 08 i : $id { g--------1 iB 3 3 EhEyE 2Ldl |: : Jil pd : : 1# :: i28 :i i ls y 3 | gsi :3 3 ite % ile 3 | ur telie -- 3: TREEel 2: uz 8 8i a A Gi : ii [IE 3% i Hl ; [EEE SRE g 2 2 i; 3| LHLE Ei a i J ; Po | ls alm wa | Hi FI i ig I i3E, 138 {i o | as Hig go 1 pi iii FRE Je s 3 : roe 5 ;: IHi s i 3 5 . . ~ cl $li:s | oLos g |: 5 8 8 i: i Ls mhailny : NR ! i 3 3 42 1 i ZF Ea gf 3 . 2 ! Bh ,i :2 tls a ; 2 #3 & LaifF Ti : | 2omBfou : il : : io L5S34RE ] 2 i2 s2a 31B2 :sha 38 Ei253H5] iioli F 2 5 ; 3 k i | 2} : f y : IEE 83 ge gi li i ft ` ili LE 5.8 | l | i Eds 5 g : : || | 8 poe J|2 & Hi 2 i HEEi onlHBdHi obog giegi h EH sa I|jE 28 88 g 233 W oaielEi eg) Hd F i i sas HEE fagfae B gIg i" 2 Hazzs 3 is.s.s.dl Po +JJee !: dE : : i 428 i i 3 || Ig 3a | 3gli | Ew 3 i ii | dif 1. {1L5E3l3IE1 R lhieesdy {gk iH | Se2%El $5 HT : : ; . T : : 3i .2s !: 3 2 ; 5 i i | 22 lis5 : i \ % gl oat ' 13 3 i I, wg ge 85 g g utI Hh i i lid) [58s | WShE8t8E pd 5 aise . : =k 7 is =| 7 =o Hi ; :nt i 3 Bl Pe f 5wl i pr i ;:: 2i . 5 i 4 | ;i "TR= 3= A = 2C= . 5 7% )a 3i : glis i !3 Holo aIa) Eg 3 | A o8r ge8_ 5 a2. 3 5 1s 7o i : ii ie Hl gr i 15F3i%l i3 g: &Hl e i: y152l fkoa 5 a3 Bh de * i 2 IE | 5 OEE:i ou iql g Mie 8 | wail : 2 IgPgeas lg Ee 7& 8 :0=. Hiss LE Fa Beiz2 Bs ii Clmna.s F3Ss ale = Lj I E ti : ETE 1 pe 3 4Log : kigh, i1si #2 } x Ld }: 5 |TeI | 4 I i fils ] i A 2 i He |Ii 8 = 3 3 . : CE . 5 .- } | 5: di0 sl 1H eel gs I E loa 5 | i g dg ug 3 5 A , ) (Fa 1 4 un 2 1k i . i 3 |i iH5eeddy {BioHssL : : iii iE Pom Foie oe B Hie 3 BE8 i Jat _F.E3 ' fe ] kL 3g EE EF ug i gig 35 HE oF 2LE yTh i555 f in i 2 bs iL : ; | 35885] iis = ; 2 . # fa i Eg : Ei 3 4 3 & | HE - i. : 2 a2 | 1 l- i3s : 2 22 2 a i = FT 155 1 11 ER (152 " { i t2g24s24| | Sea: i5 eloi(BfE s '3 BL vz _ % :a : 35: 2 : : B3YPE i 33) E ie : itl r: sot] : 1B : ER TL 8 --f3 FE[EEEFI : Bil { i g $3i33 g3 vise . Bio:i &I ; . i & -- 223 8 i : i Ho 58 3 $F epETEel 5 i'l12 2B PH3 2 #2 0% liz : 8i 1388, : Pi isl s 4d Ei & zz" : i: i ; fi3!t 1 o [3% . i & t Bom :) : i s & # Cb iH. HEE . 5 5ggf oe IE igse0 HE 3 |; 28 g wf i ii mI ef |z ii IiEE 2: i 3 Hi, ;' ; : open q i h hi i bog ; : if 1 : al 2 fl 3 ii)g 35 . 5 ii i 3 &$ & L: & .E ; Ia ae 453 | 3 i hi g : Is ii . 303 FERRE { TTT T gd @ Bzilz i 3 3 dg s 8 : ; 7 8 8 58 8 i i1 8 (883 f2z I 3 = 1g fi Wyih I i: i 45 H == 53 si i 17% i { i . Iie fi : : my (ha i 40"% Wi 5 Hi ; 1Pl fii : WFp bBe ; EE HHII E 3 Hd i 3 8 5 Bog t : if : i i P ; R | BE | - 2 Hi z mr BE SP 3 ibe HE PIBEER i Lal ila) i I i | . : HH 8) u : if i i ! ht I 57 i i ! i: $13 LR25 RREE3E tpg ig PbiieoLlEn | Pn Poros it Worl . spy % if E TNE Ly BN I ) | 3% Ty 8 = gz3 | Be | 2 i 13 i ] fe ln { : : 30 IEERg| :: sf . : : CiEL 2 hf i Efe PEE Ei g |(ass2s$=B) : i ; I fk E2E2 E gp i ay of bY Jsl z ENNNR - HA : 53 E--] x il of 5 & a 2 134 3 0 J i ` 3 qi til LIE HH toy Ei . fla i el) : Wok | : di iffm! Me) 2 i[ 5 | p5i | | 3 & & ii of : 3 3 i " B Hin i eagy i iif sf eEzze| i HH Cg ffl GFEoEaElg .iBeased 555 5k aFiedif kiPf E55 Eg] sige ;FLEA E il BmfE |GA | t if H ilis{LJi 5 : ' "1 Big g i i 5 : :E a Pr wgfu Eye il #772 5) H flE f gel --- 5 i sf ] 8 A508 a RES Eo :: "B ts ail 3c [|iiF 4] i $93 i| 13 i3 iy : i) { EE rh 3 i [Th $T3 I HE)| ft i g He i a || i| EilEieSs i ||| x 23 2i PIE E 53 3 8 Fi o|i i%E || i| |: 5% ; &: hl i) i 33 Iid2 | I 2 a Ia : 2: i J HHa ; J IH ih I i { 932 Fl : Pl fi5.3 g i A410 Bil i : Lt iiz ; 8 1 oy :& ial | ' hi i i SorE x $9i2e3 1 jRgEE3E| t he i i 2 gl { dTiEE oidp |HEe 2 Pn 8 be ly HE. - 55.550 2 esse "l 8ihds i ! 33 8 if oHTh. =: . co H d8,i 0 ii i it Eo i [37 i 1i hiss E I : - ERE 3 $91 Pa veoze| : i 8 iy g & i 5 ig92% : fm : ff 8 --43 i : Bs : 5 | if ; i : FH | 5 53 | tik 8g LTT oH ; . i il 7 i z t 552% opRER3E i fir Emi g 8 df 0 i : : Boro i OE (REA s s olggis lge3kb & F 2 [uE ne : mol | [E ER l 8 3 lee a = fl 3 is 3H 13 I. iEIi 5 515k 1 & 3 | z =i] : : i il i 31 : -- ET 3 S983 EP 3EeRel, 3 8g Eg :g & il ; soot] Ty : {[I ill : i i42 g1: i fe : oll#1 of io J i 8 # 8 __fe - fe g i : 3 tl J 3 i i il EE P: ORi 2 84 | - Fizeg iB 2 s533 5 izEERel UE fl Pn i i i le i if ! i : al ze Bs hi3d] Biss :| | Eo al f gt of i: i { z 3 + A EIETT a ! 47 of i SE & ih | g gi Jef553 i 3 iH | : Te i fi i i ! di dq 5 : | y | 21 | e i 223 | dL " 5 i 3 tig! i : ARTS La ii :> H8L zz i :. 2iioe|ee532esE8B 5 fs [HEE]L g if :; ; LiiFEgl sy :c 3 & . fick a di5 223 Co I i i : 3 F{2 g : . * : z = : : ; 5 - $833gi13|gEiEp3eeei. 5 ii pFin HOF le, 2 sei i iE 1isd g i TEPy gf iil i 53 ii . 4 Ho i of } =H5 ' ii 1 } i PO : a i Bi BoA | 7 hy. a Te R:e soo JIE ou] ? graas BooE. E em {HR lo mG fin, cE EEE 3 il 8iol sed | Bs jE PE i I gi gi i gi : sq3 2"zpee) ;2 : I2 8 33 I1 TH g EH i g es z JF2 : Zg iiii il Ti. dF 8 LE& :J5 = Ep ; Bk ! i ps OlEEE 8 [S82 Ps5 u|fE Pyiogif 3 oo i oi 2 fe | 5 i o 2 b 3 i gg : o 3 g |g gl El {3g fg gg i5 l2as|s El Dit ql Bf ih iE :' f = Xt 5} so T8 ost of 35, H { gf $9 i2 3g i z s~ 23 4 53 i |5 il ! 3 m3 enn) 3 m$i2 Th82 fn :{ i LR H d ] Ph : gfig 5 a 1 : Sy: iE lH iil ig idf | = : & 5 . :i z | = e = i i AL 3BE REY A HEE IS ro i 8 0% i fa so Hg lH 6 8 LR : cecll o :i Pl, [I a + : Pn HE 3 [J 555 fe 8 i oR gz :$ $a5d9 3 33 5 les +]: % 8 3 gHHg :2 iil Ih tb : BE | dee g5 , { i ; 93 1 IE 3! J a1FH is Wi : olis { ol : fo8p liISS t dPrim i i;st I2 lsit : i1 i | & == 23 : i v ii ; . i. ae :i: ": i igi 83 oHle isg) 3 of HE 7 |ioissg . 2 sed || i1 z 123 i io| 5 [| : fPotEE : hit | EH : Hs 383%2 y 8 & . ix : ! il +ni3 1 "fheene | BL 3 s ii s90' I tf Hi 5 HE Bf : iol .3 8 (338 z E E28 f@ [iBEF 3 Pos i | m1 l : gi 8 5% z Bi 8 oy sal } ie it 4 3 & Ho: Hiss |: bg ol : ete ! nE i oT s& Pii. | hid bdoa sd om dd Ease I,EH 3 SHEE 44 p-- wi f-iqia--g ai. TR : [faaes JTiolg,) Si a fle La i p.6t Attachment B p.65 NORTHERNBISFICT OF ORDA EMERALD COASTDTLITIES AUTHORITY, . wind, oASENOsL___ IMCOMPANY, etal, Defends DECEAOFRGAA RYHTOHIENSOTRNIN Gary Hohwnsimdotcpopuet ndossnlty Bios 1 MyawGa oHohserni(Ansand aioverthea oflhosn se. Tamsompelpit and authorsiomzaekdethiyDeshartahesaoltonts.conataninded thelrwibinmyposton eowiedge antiuesndost, 2. TamamanagerBovitgnaionHteasllt,handSullyQberafionsef 3M Campany; 1 have bothabachofegollonooeernd mas ofst pieecer dagrsee tn chil engineefng.Syasin hsscongmed somo of contomrpuboli dfidking wader systems. 3. Asparfofmyresponsibilitiesat3M Cothpatiy, | havebeh wslvedTn 1hconrdintaheisoalnatoiefnofstern defied Toeriowe puaroctae `sulfSnatePROS), perfluoroocta(nPcFOaAt)e,and homlogous peifiuctiristed ompoandsfromdrinkingwatersystom. Insodoing;1 hvebscotiie famillewith. ' . p.66 UNNOIRTTEHDESRTNADTIESSTDRIISCTTORIFCTFLCOORUIRDTA EAUMTEHROARLIDTCYO,AST UTLITIES . "Pialati, CASENO4 IMCOMPANY,etal, Difondants `DECEOFAGAR RYHAORINSOTEINN GaryHohensio ndscoafpeernu daeslte yws Blin: 1 MyaeisOunyHohensginatd aioverhoagsoFliejenst. Tamcompetontandathorzed 0mskstivDedhwation.andthehillsssntained Shel aewihinmyparsonsKngwledgroacnandd oqreest. 2. Tans menggorinBovina]Health andSafetyQperafions oN `Campany, Thaveboth bachelorofgelsosadraneofslop dogree bn ol . ginseng, Mymasta'tdi consemedtbromoval ofota onspublic cing Salo spss. 3. Aspirofmy respansbolt3MlEColtmeporsy, Lavebon waivedtn hecoordinaotfitohn nlalioafytstoemnsdesig to weve phuoroocians aufinate (PFO),peefuorsostPFhOAo)e, andhomatogous eifveirmied Compound fom dkialcnsystgems.Inso doHnavegbss,eceArle with ' p67 hoSots associated with fo desig, instalation, ienane,an aperatfsohn syn. 4. ThavesetvheicocmpwlaeindtfledbytheEmerald Coast Utilities Author (BOUA fheshove efionsed mater To pose, averviomed EQUSs demandfor"alineaessary fontoddessig"n, conslruct, install, operate,and maott hetareaitmenntfacilitiesond equipment nece tosremsovaePrFOyA and FFOS fromthedfiwrateirii tsupnpliges to'the public. 5. osroxpernce, GACa theshnologyofshui nthdnite `fective to-addrassthepresoef nPFCcKien latgsstale, miusfolpil drinking water supplysvoisdries. 6. Thagranularactivated carbon (OAC)treatmentsyste fnstalled to teal PFCs in the:Ci-of Oakdele, Mintsesotacostmorethin $2.5 nillionFor 4dusign Tove ie02,500 ellispor slo, 8 Indiis&cprests: edfr shoClty of Oldie,pti alba Wide GoutHICARGAY aRSUS TBANZABESE: AIRBBSE0ASCANPOAOF.This igure dosnotinclude operating gosts, whiinc200h8 exneded $150000. & Yhayeseviowedtho2008 finencial ropforaEOsUAt, publicly avaliable `ats nial whichindicateson page 78 UratBGUAs2008supply tateway 12,159enflionBallons, whicThs Ini excofe23s,0s00gallonsper minute, mea4l0timesthesafeofthe Oakdale,Minnesotasystem.`Thereaplsoo indr icat tes tha BOUA srvedmorethan89,000customers. 8. Although amsareofhoevidanoeto supporttheallsgafionthat REanO2FSOA rs present inhe ECA ersupply, vespfrdhe purose Fis doclaration Cd scefor tt purpose a, aallegehde . , . p68 Compllo, hese substancesbebeen detcted "at varying amounts and atvarying A ------ times." Complaint; paragriph 4). 1 alsonote thar, inadditionto the costs of fostaling sysiom capableofrepoving (hase PFOAand PROS, Plaiatilscelks andlogPOS."Caplin paragraph 83, Baseduponmytrang,eluant, md experience withtreatmentsystemsofthe Kind sought by BCUA rere, it is my opluion d10e8stre,assonabq le dengorseteosfspcieiorntsif,riapncetrhtmaainll,tytahat3"ealslntececrssasrytfeamndcsa"pnaeteidceofdto. removingPFOA and PFOSforansothority witha flow valethesize ofBCUA'S on BOApom vx TSO wouldexosed$75,000, Asyslforetreiatinng even afewwellsof theaveragesizeof Date: August 14,2009 ltt 3 .