Document by75VenR65YdnBbL1Odda3kL0
kZtb-f& l'J
PERSONAL AND CONFIDENTIAL
CC: J. H. Todd G. T. Rosen 1und J. M. Cordrey W. T. Darnell J. F. Doughty D. 'A. E rdman T. A. Foster Dr . Y . L. Power T. L. Schrenk R. N. T aylor P. Thi stleton
& J . Zipfel
July 14, 1982
TO: FROM:
R. J. BURGER J. G. L O S C H IAVO
TRENDS IN BLOOD C-8 LEVELS FOR VARIOUS T E FL ON EMPLOYEE GROUPS
SUMMARY Comparison of data for sample results obtained up to
October, 1981 with corresponding data up to June, 1982 shows; For 40 FEP Operators, blood C-8 levels decreased an average 23%. For 85 Fine Powder and Granular Operators, blood C-8 levels
decreased an average 18%. New TEFLON employees are accumulating C-8 at a lower rate than
in previ ous years. Fine Powder Zone 6 Operators still have the highest blood C-8
levels. Blood C-8 levels in females transferred out of T E FL ON are
continuing to decrease.
0835W-1
000199
EID079049
RJZ009070
2
DISCUSSION
The attached Tables contain C-8 in blood data for various employee groups in the TE FL ON Divisions. Blood C-8 data were obtained from the FLAIR program. The FLAIR program has proven itself as a valuable tool in aiding in the analysis of blood C-8 data. All blood samples were analyzed by the C-8 specific method. Data recorded in FLAIR by 6/24/82 are used in this summary. Comparisons are made between the data recorded in FLAIR up to October, 1981 with corresponding data up to June, 1982. The following observations are made:
FP Operators are ex pe ri en ci ng an overall drop in blood C-B levels of 23%. The decrease for those Operators with over 700 days of service is statistically significant at the 0.05 level using the paired t-test.
Fine Powder Operators are ex pe ri en ci ng an overall drop in blood C-8 levels of 12%. Granular Operators are experiencing a drop of 22%. The decreases for Operators with over 700 days of service is not yet statistically significant.
Blood C-8 levels in new T E F L O N employees (those with less than 700 days of service) are increasing. However, their levels are increasing at a slower rate than they were in previous years. The average rate of increase for TEFLON Fine Powder Zone 4 Operators using data collected up to October, 1981 was 0.0019 ppm/day. Using only 1982 data, the average rate of increase has dropped to 0.0004 ppm/day.
Fine Powder Zone 6 Operators continue to have the highest blood C-8 levels. They average 8 ppm and range as high as 26 ppm. TEFLON Zone 6 Operators have higher blood C-8 levels than T E F L O N Zone 4 Operators. This is because C-8 accumulates in the body over time. Zone 6 Operators have worked in TE FLON much longer than Zone 4 Operators. Operators from four other Divisions at Washington Works have very low but measurable quantities of C-8 in their blood.
Blood C-8 levels in females tr ansferred out of TE F L O N dropped an average 19% over an average 161-day period. This includes only females with 0.1 ppm or more C-8 in their blood. The rate of C-8 elimination in females with less than 0.1 ppm is very slow. It is essentially zero for this group.
RJZ009071
0835W-2
000200
EID079050
3
CONCLUSION
The diligent efforts on the part of T E F L O N Production and Technical to reduce C-8 air levels are paying off. Significant decreases in employee blood C-8 levels are now being seen. Efforts must be continued in the TE FL ON Divisions to control C-8. Both air and blood sampling programs should continue at their present rates. It is important to prevent overconfidence which could lead to overlooking items and thus minimizing effectiveness of current programs.
Attachments
JGL/nsw 0835.W- 3
RJZ009072
000201
EID079051
AGE AT LATEST BLOOD Ttsr
33
42
26
27
33
24
35
27
32
28
35
26
30
oo
25 38
o 28
*0
EID079052
27
22 25 ,
24 33
IABLE 1 BLOOD C-8 LEVELS IN FEMALcS TRANSFERRED OUT OF TEFLON
A. FEMALES WITH BLOOD C-8 LEVELS AT OR ABOVE 0.1 ppm
C-8 LEVEL WHEN LEAVING TEFLON (ppm)
C-8 LEVEL AFTER LEAVING TEFLON (ppm)
NO. OF DAYS SINCE LEAVING TEFLON
0.14 1.9
1.0 0.57
1.3 0.11 0.10 2.4
0.83 0.11 0.14 5.1
0.19 0.13 4.5 2.5
0.086 1.2 0.65 0.39 0.98 0.086 0.080 2.0 0.70 0.093 0.12 4.4 0.17 0.12 4.2 2.6
143 288 282 140 114 107 178 126 113 106 303 112 176 161 125 108
AVERAGE = 161
% CHANGE IN CLEVELS
- 38.6 - 36.8 - 35.0 - 31.6 - 24.6 - 21.8 - 20.0 - 16.7 - 15.7 - 15.5 - 14.3 - 13.7 - 10.5 - 7.7 - 6.7 + 4.0*
- 19.1 +
B.
0.078 0.061 0.045 0.092 0.019
FEMALES WITH BLOOD C-8 LEVELS BELOW 0.1 ppm
0.067 0.053 0.041 0.092 0.019
321 107 96
106 296
AVERAGE * 185
- 14.1 - 13.1 - 8.9
0.0 0.0
- 7.2 + 6.1
* This is probably due to analytical error.
JGL/nsw 7/13/82 0835W-4
ao60ozra
TABLE 2 SUMMARY OF WASHINGTON WORKS EMPLOYEES' C-8 IN BLOOD LEVELS
"____________ GROUP_________________
NO. OF SAMPLES
RANGE (ppm)*
AVERAGE (ppm)
Fine Powder/Dispersion Zone 6 Operators FEP Zone 6 Operators Granular Zone 6 Operators Fine Powder/Dispersion Zone 4 Operators TEFLON Polymers Production Foremen TEFLON Monomer Operators Granular Zone 4 Operators Laboratory** TEFLON Copolymers Production Foremen TEFZEL/Telomer "A" Operators FEP Zone 4 Operators Mechani cs Research (Engineers & Chemists) TEFLON Polymers Technical TEFLON Polymers Maintenance Supervision TEFLON Copolymers Maintenance Supervision TEFLON Copolymers Technical LUCITE Zone 4 Operators DELRIN Zone 6 Operators Filaments Zone 4 Operators ZYTEL Zone 6 Operators
21 15 10 37 23 31 17 67 19 26 25 98
8 29 15
2 16
4 2 3 2
1.3 - 26.0 0.3 - 9.6 0.2 - 9.1 0.02 - 6.9 0.1 - 2.8 0.2 - 6.5 0.01 - 4.3 0.01 - 3.2 0.03 - 2.1 0.02 0.01 - 1.6 0.04 - 1.6 0.09 - 0.6 0.03 - 0.6 0.06 - 0.4
N.D.***- 0.5 0.02 - 0.2 0.02 - 0.1 N.D. - 0.09 0.02 - 0.04
0*--0*
8.0 3.0 2.7 1.9 1.2 1.1 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.1 '0.08 0.07 0.05 0.03
RJZ009074
* Only ttie most current blood C-8 sample result for each employee was used to determine ranges and averages.
** The Laboratory group includes Trainees Senior Laboratorians, tab Analysts, Research Analysts, and Lab Supervision
*** N.D. = None Detected (< 0.007 ppm).
JGL/nsw 7/13/82 083SW-S
000203
E1D079053
TABLE 3 TRENDS IN BLOOD C-8 AVERAGES FOR TEFLON ZONE 4 AND ZONE 6 OPERATING GROUPS
\
GROUP
Fine Powder - Zone 6 FEP - Zone 6 Granular - Zone 6 Fine Powder - Zone 4 Granular - Zone 4 FEP - Zone 4
AVG. C-8 LEVEL USING DATA RECORDED IN
FLAIR BY 10/19/81 (ppm)
9.8
4.4
3.3
2.0
0.8
0.6
NO. OF SAMPLES
16 10 9 16 14 10
AVG. C-8 LEVEL USING DATA RECORDED IN FLAIR BY 6/24/82
(ppm)
3.0 2.1 1.9 0.6 0.5
NO. OF SAMPLES
21 15 10 37 17 25
% CHANGE IN C-8 LEVELS
-18 -32 -18 -5 -25 -17
oCO
000204
UGL/nsw 7/13/82 0835W-6 s ao-voV4/JO^l
^ooozry
000205
REFERENCE NUMBER
JGL/n sw 7/13/82 0835W-7
T '.E 4 TEFLON FINE POWDER SERVICE OPERATORS - ZONE 4
DATE OF FIRST SAMPLE
C-8 IN BLOOD
(ppm)
DAYS IN JOB AT SAMPLE DATE
DATE OF SECOND SAMPLE
4/27/81
0.420
0
10/14/81
4/14/81
1.100
317
9/10/81
4/27/81
0.031
2
7/1/81
8/25/81
0.610
121
1/13/82
7/24/81
0.760
73
2/3/82
4/7/81
3.600
462
3/11/82
10/7/81
0.039
3
12/18/81
8/28/81
0.300
124
1/14/82
10/7/81
0.007
3
12/4/81
8/24/81
1.500
601
2/9/82
4/8/81
3.500
738
8/19/81
8/28/81
0.650
124
12/9/81
10/14/81
0.740
531
2/3/82
8/31/81
1.700
1,065
1/19/82 .
4/6/81
4.300
461
8/26/81
5/4/81 b/7/81
3.900 4.800
, 1,310 725
9Z0600ZHI
m 3/11/82 o-VoUV/JOi1 12/30/81
C-8 IN BLOOD
(ppm) 1.400 1.500 0.200 0.920 1.100 3.900 0.099 0.350 0.021 1.500 3.500 0.640 0.700 1.600 4.000 2.600 3.600
DAYS IN JOB AT SAMPLE DATE
170 466
67 262 267 800
75 263 ,61 770 871 227 643 , 1,206 603 1,621 962
\
WORKED OTHER TEFLON JOB(S) BEFORE THIS JOB
(YES/NO)
AVG. DAILY RATE OF C-8 DECREASE OR
INCREASE (ppm/Day)
YES + 0.0058
NO + 0.0027
NO + 0.0026
NO + 0.0022
YES + 0.0018
NO + 0.0009
NO + 0.0008
YES + 0.0004
NO + 0.0002
NO 0.0000
NO 0.0000
YES - 0.0001
NO - 0.0004
NO - 0.0007
NO - 0.0021
NO - 0.0042
NO - 0.0051
REFERENCE NUMBER
DATE OF FIRST SAMPLE
8/20/80
4/6/81
8/18/80
7/6/81
ih BLE 5 TEFLON TFE PROCESS OPERATORS - FINE POWDER * ZONE 6
C-8 IN BLOOD
(ppm)
24.000
4.300
29.000
32.000
DAYS IN JOB AT SAMPLE DATE
8,846
857 9,726
2,105
DATE OF SECOND SAMPLE
1/14/82
9/1/81 3/19/82
2/18/82
C-8 IN BLOOD
(ppm)
26.000
4.400
20.000
24.000
DAYS IN JOB AT SAMPLE DATE
9,358
1,005
10,314
2,332
l
WORKED OTHER TEFLON JOB(S) BEFORE THIS JOB
(YES/NO)
AVG. DAILY RATE OF C-8 DECREASE OR
INCREASE (ppm/Day)
NO + 0.0039
NO + 0.0007
NO - 0.0153
NO - 0.0352
00020G
JGL/n sw 7/13/82 835W-8
4/2y/81 9/22/81 10/7/81 10/13/81 10/13/81 4/21/81 4/30/81
4/7/81
0600201
TABLE 6 TEFLON COPOLYMERS FEP SERVICE OPERATORS - ZONE 4
0.009 0.100 0.021 0.013 0.039 1.250 0.760 1.700
1 295
3 2 2 732 115 827
9/10/81 4/7/82 2/5/82
3/25/82 1/14/82 10/9/81 9/28/81 8/18/81
0.150 0.230 0.053 0.052 0.051 1.200 0.660 1.600
135 492 124 165
95 903 266 960
a o-j VO'*OJ \ CTv ....
NO + 0.0011 NO + 0.0007 NO + 0.0003 NO + 0.0002 NO + 0.0001 NO - 0.0003 NO - 0.0007 NO - 0.0008
REFERENCE NUMBER
O O '
\
DATE OF FIRST SAMPLE
8/29/80 8/29/80 8/19/80 8/29/80 4/1/81 8/26/80 8/26/80 8/20/81 8/27/81
TABLE 7 TEFLON COPOLYMERS POLYKETTLE FEP OPERATORS - ZONE 6
C-8 IN BLOOD
(ppm) 4.000
1.900 7.800 1.500
1.300
6.600
5.500
13.000
5.800
DAYS IN JOB AT SAMPLE DATE
6,846 8,733 7,729 7,760 5,449 7,757 9,112 7,940 9,279
DATE OF SECOND SAMPLE
10/14/81 1/27/82 9/25/81 8/13/81 3/31/82 8/7/81 8/5/81 7/17/81 2/2/82
C-8 DAYS IN
IN BLOOD
JOB AT
(PPm) . SAMPLE DATE
4.500
7,257
1.800
9,249
7.500
8,131
1.200
8,109
0.950
5,813
5.300
8,103
4.200
9,456
9.600
8,271
3.100
9,438
WORKED OTHER TEFLON J0B(S) BEFORE THIS JOB
(YES/NO)
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
NO
NO
YES
NO
AVG. DAILY RATE OF C-8 DECREASE OR
INCREASE (ppm/Da.y)
+ 0.0012
- 0.0002
- 0.0007
- 0.0009
- 0.0010
- 0.0038
- 0.0038
- 0.0103
- 0.0170
JGL/n sw 7/13/82 0835W-9
o'O
8Z0600ZTH