Document bapKpLmaQ0pj6qK3xeEGxK5Jo
Hidden dangers in the air we breathe
Particles of certain widely used mineral substances are so small that they can't be stopped by the excellent filter system in our. noses, or by any ordinary means. If allowed to be present in your home or place of work or business, minute particles of some materials may lodge in your lungs and eventually cause cancer.
The first report of lung cancer believed to have been
caused indirectly by asbestos fibers was recorded in
1935. Many studies have since been reported in which
examinations have been made of or autopsies per
formed on persons who have been in direct contact
with asbestos, either in the mining and manufacturing
phase or in connection with its many uses as an insulat
ing material.
Thorrt Sc nnu/ pntCi!C?-UV HO dOl'bt thlt 2 JJffJOR
greatly increases his chances of developing a really dan
gerous disease called asbestosis if he is subjected for a
time to the fine asbestos dust that is possibly present
within one-half mile of an asbestos manufacturing
plant in the country' or anywhere within a considerable
distance from the^framewoik of a new building that is
being fireproofed by spraying it with an asbestos-based
product. (A single major tall building in New York City
will receive nearly 5000 tons of asbestos spray, of which
a great part floats off into the air of the city. It has
been suggested that, for city dwellers, the hazard of
lung cancer may be as great from inhalation of asbestos
as from the smoking of cfcavettes.l
And while Lie symptoms of asbestosis, a non-malig-
nant lung disease, take years to develop, it would seem
at this time that there is a good likelihood that after 20
to 30 years have elapsed, lung cancer will develop in a
surprisingly High percentage of the cases. And the as
bestos worker who smokes cigarettes regularly in
creases his cancer risk enormously. 50 percent of 3000
autopsies in one study showed asbestos particles in the
lungs.
Unfortunately, experts have now about concluded
that a practical hazard and a definite long-term danger
exists, not only for dirccliy exposed persons, but for
practically everyone who is forced to exist on the
highly contaminated air found in most urban and some
rural areas. Once in the lungs, the asbestos particles,
remain there throughout life. Even kindergarten chil
dren have boon exposed, in using asbestos powder with
water as a form of modeling clay. '
The root of the problem
.
Why this comparatively sudden awareness of a danger
that must have existed for two thousand years or
more? Actually, modern medical researchers had to re
sort to the electron microscope in order to identify
positively the minute pieces of "encapsulated" mineral
fiber. Many are so fine that they cannot be seer, when
floating in the air around us. And there are literally
thousands of sources for the material in man-made
products in our environment.
The long fibers of asbestos, like those of cotton and
wool, for example, have- those qualities required for
spinning the material Into a thread and thence into
fireproof garments, curtains, shields, ironing board
covers, house insulation, insulation for electric wires,
and the like. The short fibers arc mixed with-various
binders, such as cements and plastics, and the mixture
compressed into pipe coverings, brake linings, clutch
faces, roofing and siding shingles, filter cloth, yarns
and ropes, plaster, rubber goods, some paints, siding,
paper, and many molded products. Actually, the num
ber of products on the market which contain asbestos
is believed to exceed 3000. However, there is a favor
able trend; some manufacturers arc novv offering min
eral fiber material for certain uses that does not con
tain asbestos. '
.-
Fortunately, the great majority of these products
utilize the asbestos as a mixer or extender and bind it
into some other material where it is not available in the
free state, except when the material disintegrates with
lime and weather. When used in firm mixtures, as in
asphalt root coalings and in plastics. Hie likelihood that
the fibers will separate and become airborne is greatly
reduced, as is the danger of their being inhaled in harm
ful amounts.
'
Protective actions taken
Serious research has been in progress for some years to Investigate the possible dangers to health that may be
SEPTEMBER 1971 / 29
CAPCO KIN 0000668
.J
involved. Many companies have taken certain action
dangers involved, the number of uses for asbestos con- j
needed to reduce the-hazard. As, an example, special
tinucs to increase. Even in the home, there arc many ' I
plastic bags havoUfen developed as containers so that
areas, from roof--asbestos shingles--to cellar--asbestos
:
water and dry' asbestos can be mixed safely to be used . insulation and cement on boiler and .pipes--and on
j
as heat insulation on the exterior of heating boilers and
ironing boards, where asbestos is lo be found in one
;
pipes.
.
form or another. Asbestos board is much used, and
i
New York City, Philadelphia, and the State of Cali sawing it in the hobby shop puts countless fibers into
fornia have taken action to control the manner in
the air of a home.
'
which buildings are sprayed with asbestos. Rules gov
erning adequate enclosure of the area in which the
spraying takes place and cleanup and disposal proce
dures have been outlined. Indeed, following the initial
action in April of 1970 in New York City, the hazard
was considered sufficiently great that the mayor or
dered the spraying of asbestos halted wherever possible
in all construction projects under supervision of the
city government; the decision, at least in part, was
based upon testimony presented by Dr. Irving J. Sell-
koff, of Mount Sinai Hospital School of Medicine, who
is one of the modern pioneers in asbestos epidemiol
ogy. Based upon work done by his group, Dr. Selikoff
stated that lung cancer was the cause of death of al
most 1 out of every 5 asbestos workers in the city in
the past 27 years.
The report,, which summarized findings of examina
tions of 632 asbestos insulation workers, covered a pe
riod of 25 yean. During that period, 358 persons in the
group died. Of that number, 72 deaths were due to
cancer of the lung or pleura. Statistically, in considera
tion of normal mortality rates, only about 9 deaths
would have been expected. The danger of mcsolhelial
tumors exists not only among asbestos workers but
also with othen after only "apparently minimal and
jiOii-otx-upaiionai" exposure to asbestos dust, but
usually after a .long delay or latent period of forty
years or more.
-
In California a bill has been introduced to prohibit
the use of asbestos or fiber glass as linings in air duct
systems of new buildings.
'
Lately, talcum powder for babies has been found to
contain substantial amounts of asbestos particles, and these are of course readily inhaled by infants and those
who care for them. Talc dust alone presents problems similar to asbestos but the risks arc not so great.
In late 1970, over 100,000 women's coats were
manufactured and sold from a blend of melton-type
doth imported from Italy which contained wool, ny-
Ion, and asbestos. While it is almost a practical impos-
sibility to recall the coats, according to Mr. H. Mendel-
sund, an officer of the International Ladies Garment
Workers Union, union members have been ordered not to cut or sew cloth containing asbestos.
The main reason why this cloth was made and im
ported was because of the cost advantage it might offer
due to the possibility of a lower import duty on as
bestos material as against other fibers.
If you have such a coat-lhe label will tell--it should
be "taken out of circulation." Family Health reports
that Dr. Selikoffs advice was that one should bury a
' coal that contains asbestos fibers.
Fiber glass has -Io been under suspicion tor some - time as a cause of respiratory injury, Tuorc have been
suggestions that it might be harmful in view of its use in home furnishings and in the ducts of heating and
'
j j 1
'* ; ; : : i
;
: ; I ' .' .
cooling systems. Information available up to this time
'
Opinions differ ^
does not indicate any substantial danger from this cause, (hough it is established that "man-made vitreous
-
As is so often the ease, there are some who feel that the reasons for concern regarding asbestos fiber inhala tion arc not as well based as they might be. Dr. George Wright, a pulmonary disease specialist in Cleveland, who has served industry as consulting expert on asbestos, has commented to the effect that some of (he concern may be ill founded regarding the large quantities of asbestos supposedly put into the air from automobile brake lin ings. He stated that "the amount of asbestos fiber used in friction material in the United States was estimated
fibers" have become lodged in human lungs. Pending - availability of further information concerning the pos
sibility of harm from glass fibers, we suggest that city and stale governments and individuals should not allow use of glass fiber in any part of a heating, cooling, or ventilating duct system of a home, office, or factory. Glass fibers are regularly used in the form of a mat as a filter in warm air healing systems, but it is believed that in this use the danger of putting glass fibers of inhalable size into the air stream is not great.
;
. ; ' "
.
at less than five percent of the total in 1965. And the
Everyone should be alert to the potential danger that
.'
high heat of friction destroys the asbestos, converting
exists in the handling or use of any articles made of or
It to material no longer having the characteristics of - containing asbestos fibers or glass fibers. We do not
asbestos.... . . .
know at this time how convincing the evidence by Dr.
.
"Serious exposures to asbestos fiber can occur in cer
Wright tending to minimize the hazaid from asbestos
tain occupational and immediately adjacent environ
may be. Our advice would be, in any event, to avoid
j
ments but there is evidence that a low concentration of asbestos in the air breathed by the general public is not likely to be harmful."
Even with the increased awareness of the potential
contact with asbestos in every practicable way, espe-
cially in connection with building, heating, and plumb
ing operations. On glass fibers as a source of skin irrita
tion, see Consumer Bulletin, November 1969.
'
: .
30 / CONSUMER BULLETIN
*
CAPCO KIN 0000669