Document bO7JB67Yvyv3DY94NR9k5zGN3

V Executive Offices S3AIHD8V TOHIQISIH Stl Johns-Manville Corporation TWENTY-TWO EAST FORTIETH STREET NEW YORK 16, N.Y. OMMtar 4V 1990 o ftrttt tf Mm1w B>U t fggaaUMtt mJHnton. iW IfitaM to totter to oaf? f tto states of tto --tin toto to flrma <* Iwriir 7, 1990. Tto --tofag u to Hiimi tom*! topaiil to feptoto 21* 2950, to tto toto totort-- Wtolag I--irfitti sto to --to final i--tertostolng o to it to to--to tto f--i tonH to fp--4. ftal to to yi--t to. Mwrte toll ootota toto Smno | \ toirfti toto 0 *. M. 4. * 1. rtotor U 0. toto . I. Footer I. r I r PLAINTIFF'S : i > EXHIBIT .: i MXHHS or 8190888X01 *LD JBT MIUMO LIP 08 1BH 7, 190 Aa 1m LHUW| H 0* I*n iihwrli i< 1m TWVlU| M* Da 1m P. Woodard Propoool of 9optaohor 21, 1990, to tho Qooboo Aobootoo Tht raport to tho Qoofcoo hUitaa Holwf towriitli a Poloooaty (ToMr, dotod 9apt--tor 25 1950, whloh woo ooooptod li prlaalplo tp tho Q A. M, A* at thoir roooot ooptlWi fro1Ty followod, tat to triof, hroii UhnUrj'i Propoool. A oooo&ttoo of tho Q. A. M. A. ugiiii of Muon. Pootor ooA lohoorla priwloi this up art at thio roooot gootlop. Polloolag a aioooooioo with hr. A. K. rite, It woo loft that Nwm. Woodard mk iohoorla, oa Bootoro Torwald aod Lomo woold rorlow tho Proppool at Iomboo to aioar op oop foootloao that aifht ho opoa ood rtro at a ogaoToolna oo to ohat to rooMoaodod fioo horo ao, loololloa oho woold do vhot, hoo loos it woold toko, oad haw wmk tt woold aoot* that woo tho 001111 of thdo aaotlog. X. 1. 00 foil OOPI r 110 AKV.niVtS f^TIONAL MUSEUM OF HEALTH AND MEDIONP ARMED FORCES INSTITUTE OF PATHOLOGY ^ 2 (1) k 1M7 of tki l-rmym of pooplo atplopai i tbo MlMitM ladootry. (2) k otady of tbo h-royo oodo of tbo fonorol popaTotlon by Um aobllo onlta of tbo frorlaalol Dopartaoat of fiooltb (tbooo aot oapooad). (3) A otady of pMioarloi dots 00 tbo proooaoo of ooaaar ot dooth iaaofar 00 ouoh laforaotioo Mgr bo ovolloblo. It mi polaM oat tbot la tbo Fraalaaa It la tbo proatloo aot to Hot ooaaor oa 0 oaaao of doatb 000a whoa it la, 00 that lafocaatloa oa thla may aot bo of aoeb bolp to aa. 2* Or* Laaaa ooaaaatadi a, Tbo 000 laportaat palat la that wa got oa amort l,a,, oao oho 00a taho tbo job oror, do It aowootly tad adoqaataly, md oomo op with tbo oonroot mmnor. k. Br, Loot ogrooa It la laportaat that a Caaadloa bo ohoooa to hoadlo tbo job. Xa ooao a CModlaa oaaaat bo food oho ooa 4e tbo job adoqwtolp, iwioii ftroa tbo V. 3, aaa tbaa bo 3, Mr. a. That prior aoaaaltatloa with apprpprlata Canodloa aatborltloo and a raoaoat far tbolr aaonatloaa os oortala mold got tbolr taolt booking ad that thla will to rovlow tM aattor with Dr. Tidal al alaa to orro*o oe that lfe>. Toroald will bo abla to bo la taaob atoll/ with tbo Boaa of tbo MtfUl Widloal Bohoal (or Or. Torwald will do oa, 00 aogr bo doaldod botmoo tbo too af thaa). By thla arraogoaaBt, Br, Tidal aad tbo Mtffttt of tbo pragrai aad tbolr bolp la obocolog aa abla ooldooloToolol to who alghh bo to for tbo Jab, it b. Xa oddlMoa to tbo opldoalolagiat, a atatlatlaiaa la aaadoi a haaa aaggaatad aa aa asalataat, Ihda aaa ba aot by Dr. Torwald ad IT. Soboruln la llat with tbo ad tbo wlahoo of tbo 4* A, M. K oIm that Toroy that Bootora fhith of X-voyt, vhldi woald laaaa ba Id dr aaly | OTIS HISTORICAL ARCHIVES j NATIONAL MUSEUM OF HEALTH AND MEDK3NE. i ARMED FORCES INSTITUTE OF PATHOLOGY * 3 tba Job of atndying thooa vhlafc vcnld bo oooi to Saraaao. It w polntad oat thit tbo too aanpany doatora ahoald not bo mood la oqr fhahlan ttet al|M load wy-- to gaostlan tbo objoottrlty of tho study and this brau can dotarmlna. B. OaBlmsle&oi 1. Dootoro Snlth and Cartlor vftll aorooa X-rays, than Saranao will oka tbo final study on tbo X-rays that hair* boon seroonod oat 2. in apldaaloloffiat will bo cheats, aa ovtllnad abort. Saronoo will sdco tbo approach with o wiow total wiring final arrtagtooto with tbo mb who boo boon toatatlwoly ahaoea. 3. Tba oylionlologloal ropart aa flrnt noda will go to Ion, Or. lam will oralnoto tho roport In this font and ooggoot boot nao of tho iopart, rarlaieno that night bo noo, and otbar oooh nattoro* Thom ohoold bo dlaooaoion botwoon Swnoo, tho nadarwriting argoolsailant, nod othoro intorootod on to tho ttnolinom and proprlnty of tho woo of tbo notorial Aomiopod by tldo rapart. It la taportant that tbs roport bo arallahio only to tbo oriir nrlting imp galao and not nado gonorolly available not11 It baa boon rrrloood with and by tho aanpoaloo. 4. Saronoo Laboratory la raopmolblo for tbo progran. a. 8mm in to idn tbo final awuganaat with tbo apldaolologlot and otbaro to nako tho atady, and ia aloo raopnooiblo to hood vp and saporvioo tbo atady. b. Tho progrm ahoald bo otartod aa ooon to it io paooibla to do ao. e. It won ontlnotnd that tbo Job amid ba darn ia ala nnotbn if a goallflni opldantalagiot non ba ottalaad nbo am donate a raainnahla langth at tlao to tho otndy. It in danimhln that tba Jab ba dona In ala noatha and tborofaro tba paraoa htmd fan tba Jab Would bo fapmawd w&tb tbo fhat that tba atady obwill bn paaha i and asotInaltat matted prooptly. d. While tba arlgiaal pragma ototad o poaaiblo oaot at $4,000, it won ntntod ia tba diaoooolon that tba oaot night m batman 14,000 mi H,000, it bolag tbaaght, tenner, that $5,000 wanld ba adagnoto. di (1) Tbo trmaplontlog of oabootoa sad (originally ouggootod to bo andor bis group). ti into anloala at Sr. i ' uoivy*;v_l MKUniVtS ; l^TiONAl MUSEUM OF HEALTH AND MPDIOmc MED FORCES INSTITUTE Of PAWaoSy^ 4 (2) Utilising tb* faeilltloa at the fratoa Labcrttorj, u la tha past, and aubjsatlng aalnala to high asbsstos dost oonditlsns* 4. 31souaslant 1. Sr* Uw add that ha la net praparad to earry oat a faraal projast aa aaatlanad la (X) abort| that Or. vlllloa Smith, along with ST* Swtharland aaooalatad with hia, la doiag soao of thla vlth flaoly ground asbestos, aa vail as with aana othar aatoriala. 2* Or* Varvald gave tha following information about part (2) of tha program, uhleh, of osoras, la girna la nora detail la tbs Saraaao Laboratory's Proposal of Soptonbar 21, 1950* a. 8ot op a program aanafatlng of 300 aalnala to bo aubjoetsd to aaboatoa and 300 b. Tbs la llkoly to laat for two years. a* Zt vaald probably taka too right kind of aalnala and got to gat wy. of tha 4* panting Hr. Vonraldi *Us hapa to ahov or pram that imm laaftdanea la net Inaraaaad aaong thaao aalnala ma If dvatad." Zt woo aalloasJ that aaafa roaulta as an tha basis of anlnal axparlnaatstlsn, tha roaalta aro, atriotly qpaklagi trna only of anlnal a, and It should bo roallaad that tha aaaa raanlta night or night not half tri In tha 3. Xtvaa that, vbllo tha provide aaah prcgraa la going ea, a nrograaa raport on tha Thara vaa aona qaaatian aa ta bar sanplata a progress raport should ba and It vaa agreed that a prograaa raport night vail bo of no non than bn typaarlttan pagaa ta ahav In waalaa farm a* Tha work that boa baon iBptom np ta that Una. b. lav tha voth la pragraaalng at tha aonant. a* Uhat tha fbtara vad laoha Uba, l*a., aa to vhaa aapplatlna nay bo tapeatad md vbathar or aot tha prograa la ahaai of sohadala or bablad sdhsAaln, and by boo maah* d* Uhat gaaaral qowolnaloaa thara aro, if any, at tha nansat, without giving datallad data an tha vork. 4* Tha prssant Idas is that tha tva-yuar progrm aaa ha undartateam at an aatlaatad seat, aa ahavn In Saranaa's Proposal of Taptanhai 21, 19f0, of $16,000 for tha first year, ond 610,000 for tha aaasod yaar. OTIS HISTORICAL ARCHIVES NATIONAL MUSEUM OF HEALTH AND MEDONE. ARMED FORCES INSTITUTE OF PATHOLOGY * -5 National museum of health and medonp ARMED FORCES INSTITUTE Of PATHOLOGY ^ B. 1. Sufficiently olear data haa been shown andmr A, "Discussion,* chare, to shew the way la which tha progrmi weald progress, and tha consensus waa that tha progrmt should ha uodartakaa aa promptly aa paaaibla in lina with tha points brought oat in tha discussion. III. Othar Phaaaa of tha LoogHUnga Program. A. Discussions 1* In tha Proposal to tha Q. A. M. A., four auggaationa vara nadai a. That tha Tarioua ooaq>aaiaa making op tha Association aaa that there la more publicity than in tha paat about the knowledge of thia problem and about aono of tha many favor able aspects that do exist, but whioh are unknown to aost people. Tha purposa of this is to oombat tha adverse and often uararrsated paaudo facts that are put oat by others. Or. Snith and Or. Cartier should be kept advised by others in tha Q. A. M. A. and tha asbestos industry of any develop ments that nay become known to than. b. That oar doctors occasionally make talks or lecturea at nedleal schools in tha general area. c. That we aao that oar doctors get adequate affiliation with research eastara such as Barsaaa and othar organisations so that they will get all available Information on thia and othar anah subjects. d. That tha oempanias in tha aabestoa industry aansidor tha formatloa af an Institute for Industrial Chart Dias aaaa with othar mining associations. In doing this, it waa mantlonod that tha halp of Or. dragolre of Boaamoant Sansterlmn, Or. Burke of the Laureatian, and othars ha aoogkt. B. ConsTnetones 1. It was agreal that tha flrat throe (a, b, and a, above) should bo dene, it being understood, of aeursa, that judgment mast ba usad la tba dagreo ef partialpatlon af our dootaro under bail. However, it waa the eemaanaua af tha group that tha aabaataa industry would da wall ta avoid ldontifying ltaalf at thia time with othar mining aaaaalatioma (d, above) so for as cheat diaaaaaa are eamoamad. It waa pointed out that tha problems af tha aabaataa indus try ora minor ss tempered with those ef many othar miming industries, and that anah affiliation might tand to identify tha aabaataa mining Industry with tha problems ef othar miming Industriea. It was felt that this should ba bald in abeyance. at andlver Brown A. R. Plohar L. C. Hart C. K. Poster, Msntreal j. p. r. .. Movenbar 24, 1990